Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
NON-HAZING UV CURABLE POWDER COATINGS
CONTAINING CRYSTALLINE RESINS
Field of the Invention
This invention relates to ultraviolet (UV) radiation curable powder coating
compositions. More particularly, this invention. relates to UV curable powder
coating
compositions containing cyrstalline resins adapted to prevent hazing in the
coating formed
therefrom when cured at low temperatures.
B_~~ck~,ound of the Invention
Powder coatings have gained considerable popularity in recent years over
liquid
coatings for a number of reasons. Powder coatings are virtually free of
harmful fugitive
organic solvents and, therefore, give off little, if any, volatiles during
curing. This eliminates
solvent emission problems and creates a healthier environment for workers
employed in the
coating operations. Powder coatings also improve working hygiene, as they are
in dry solid
form and have no messy liquids associated with them which adhere to workers'
clothes and
coating equipment. They are relatively non-toxic as well and can easily be
swept up in the
event of a spill without requiring special cleaning and spill containment
supplies. Another
benefit is that they are virtually 100% recyclable. The oversprayed powders
are normally
reclaimed and fed back into the original powder feed during the coating
operation, leading
to high coating efficiencies and minimal waste. Yet, despite such advantages,
traditional
thermosetting powder coatings have not been suited for coating heat sensitive
substrates,
since the temperatures at which these powders.must be cured are usually higher
than the
heat sensitive substrate can withstand.
W ith the increased desire to coat heat sensitive parts with powder coatings
and
realize the foregoing benefits, recent emphasis has been placed on developing
powders that
permit polymerization or curing at lower temperatures. One class of low
temperature-cure
powder coatings recently developed for heat sensitive substrates are UV
curable powder
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
coatings. Such UV curable powders can be formulated to melt-flow and cure and
produce
desired smooth glossy coatings at much lower temperatures than had ever been
possible
with traditional thermosetting chemistry, which is primarily due to the curing
reaction being
initiated solely by ultraviolet radiation rather than heat. The UV curing
mechanism also
enables production of the powders in traditional melt-blending equipment and
storage at
room temperature without triggering unwanted prereaction.
UV curable powders are typically prepared from solid unsaturated non-
crystalline
base resins, solid unsaturated non-crystalline crosslinker resins, solid
photoinitiators, flow
additives, other performance-enhancing additives, and optional pigments and
inert fillers.
It is also common to replace some or all of either the base or crosslinker
resin with a
crystalline material, as taught, for example, in EP 0 636 669 to DSM. One UV
powder
coating promoted by DSM that is presently preferred employs a blend of a non-
crystalline
base resin and a co-reactive crystalline crosslinker resin. Specifically, it
comprises a
stoichiometric blend of a solid, relatively polar, unsaturated amorphous (non-
crystalline)
polyester base resin with fumarate or maleate unsaturations and a glass
transition
temperature (Tg) of about 125°F (the Tg of the base resin being
sufficiently high for desired
blocking resistance but still low enough for desired low temperature melt-flow
behavior),
and a solid, somewhat incompatible, relatively non-polar, crystalline divinyl
ether urethane
crosslinker resin with a melting point (Tm) of about 195-230°F (the Tm
of the crystalline
resin being above the Tg of the base resin and also above traditional melt-
processing
temperatures to avoid destruction of intact crystal structures during
processing and
attendant loss in melt-processing efficiency and blocking resistancel,
together with a solid
photoinitiator, flow control agent, and optional pigments. The presence of
crystalline
ingredients, in particular, has been found highly desired because the powders
will exhibit
low melt viscosity and excellent flow out behavior during the initial melting
stage of the
coating process, allowing the powders to readily coalesce into smooth molten
coating films
which upon subsequent UV curing and develop into exceptionally smooth coatings
with
desired glossy appearance.
However, one drawback with the use of crystalline materials, particularly
crystalline
crosslinker resins, having such high melting points (Tm) is that in order to
obtain cured
coatings with desired smooth glossy appearances, the coating must be UV cured
at
temperatures above the melting point of the crystalline component. If the
temperature of
the molten coating after flow out is allowed to drop below the melting point
to the point at
which the crystalline component visually appears to recrystallize in the
coating prior to UV
-2-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
curing, which can happen during transfer of the coated part from the melting
to UV curing
operation and/or es a result of the coated part having a variable mass, the
cured coating will
have an undesirable haze or blush on the surface with attendant loss in gloss
and
smoothness. The haze is believed to result as the crystalline resin component
separates out
and migrates to the surface of the coating whereupon it is believed to
recrystallize back into
intact crystal structures. This imparts to the coating a cloudy, rough, matte
appearance
characteristic of crystalline resins. While this is desirable when making low
gloss coatings,
it becomes troublesome when trying to control hazing and obtain higher gloss
films at low
temperatures. Moreover, with increased demand to coat heat sensitive parts
that can only
withstand temperatures near the melting point of the crystalline ingredient,
there is a need
to provide a non-hazing UV curable powder coating that can be cured at such
low
temperatures and still produce a uniform haze-free smooth glossy finish over
the part.
The limitations of traditional UV curable powders containing a crystalline
resin can
be best seen when trying to coat assembled electric motor casings which house
a number
of heat sensitive components, including working parts and electric circuitry
associated
therewith. To avoid damaging such components, the melt-flow and curing
temperatures
must be kept at levels that are only slightly above the recrystallization
point. To further
complicate the matter, these.motor.casings tend to have a variable mass.
During coating,
as the powder is melted at the desired conditions for curing, the heavier mass
sections
create heat sinks and cause the temperature of the molten coating in these
sections to drop
below the point at which the crystalline ingredient recrystallizes, while in
other sections the
coating temperature is kept above the recrystallization point. As a result,
the cured coatings
produced therefrom have an unacceptable mottled appearance due to the haze
appearing
around the heavier mass sections, rather than having a consistent smooth
glossy coating
across the part.
To overcome the hazing and mottling problem, it is possible to use non-
crystalline
resins alone which do not recrystallize. However, in order to achieve adequate
flow out at
the low temperatures suited for heat sensitive substrates, the Tg of the non-
crystalline
resins must be lowered considerably, which would render the powders physically
unstable
and susceptible to blocking or sintering during storage at room temperature.
Powders that
block are extremely difficult to meter and spray during the coating operations
and lead to
inconsistent spray patterns and defects in the coatings. Reducing the amount
of crystalline
resin, particularly the crystalline crosslinker resin, to levels at which
recrystallization does
not occur (i.e., below 10 wt. % of the resin system) has also been tried, but
at such low
-3-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
levels the powders exhibit poor flow out at low temperatures and produce
incompletely
cured coatings with severely textured appearances.
It would be desirable to provide an improved UV curable powder coating
composition
containing crystalline resins adapted to prevent hazing in the coating formed
therefrom
when cured at low temperatures.
It is, therefore, a primary object of this invention to provide a UV curable
powder
coating composition containing crystalline resins that do not suffer from the
forgoing
drawbacks.
It is another object of this invention to provide a UV curable powder coating
composition containing crystalline resins adapted to prevent hazing in the
coating formed
therefrom when cured at low temperatures.
It is related object of this invention to provide a UV curable powder coating
composition containing crystalline resins adapted to prevent mottling and
impart visually
consistent gloss and smoothness in the coating formed therefrom when cured
over a broad
range of high and low temperatures.
It is a further object of this invention to provide a UV curable powder
coating
composition of the aforesaid character that is melt-processable, storage
stable chemically
as well as physically, exhibits a low flow viscosity when melted for curing,
and possess the
ability to be melt-flowed and cured at low temperatures suited for heat
sensitive substrates,
all without detracting from the smoothness, gloss, and overall quality of the
coating film
produced therewith.
In accordance with a broad aspect of this invention, there is provided a melt-
processable, storage-stable, low temperature flowable, UV curable powder
coating
composition containing crystalline resins that exhibits reduced or no hazing
in the coating
formed therefrom when cured at low temperatures, which comprises a film-
forming
particulate blend of: A) an unsaturated base resin; B) an unsaturated
crosslinker resin co-
polymerizable with the base resin; and, C) a photoinitiator, wherein the
combination of
components A) plus B) comprises a blend of at least one crystalline resin and
at least one
non-crystalline resin, and the improvement wherein the powder coating
composition
comprises D) a recrystallization or haze inhibitor for the crystalline
component that visually
appears to inhibits its recrystallization in the coating after the powder
composition is melted
-4-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
, . ~-
PATENT
3612-05-24
for curing and foremost reduces or eliminates hazing in the coating formed
therefrom when
cured at low temperatures that normally give rise to such hazing.
In accordance with a preferred aspect of this invention, there is provided a
melt-
processable, storage stable, UV curable powder coating composition containing
crystalline
resins that is melt-flowable at. low temperatures suited for preservation of
heat sensitive
substrates, e.g., 170'F-300'F, and exhibits reduced or no hazing in the
coating formed
therefrom when cured at low temperatures, e.g., about 170°F or lower,
which comprises
a film-forming particulate blend of: A) a non-crystalline unsaturated
polyester base resin
having a Tg above 90°F, preferably a non-crystalline unsaturated
polyester having maleate
or fumarate unsaturations; B) a crystalline vinyl ether functionalized
crosslinker resin co-
polymerizable with the base resin having a Tm above 180°F, preferably a
crystalline vinyl
ether terminated urethane oligomer; C) a photoinitiator; and the improvement
wherein the
composition contains D) a crystalline epoxy resin which serves as a
recrystallization or haze
inhibitor having a Tm above 180°F, preferably a crystalline epoxy
oligomer compatible with
1 5 both A) and B1, wherein incorporation of component D) reduces or
eliminates hazing in the
cured coating formed therefrom.
Throughout this specification, all parts and percentages specified herein are
by
weight unless otherwise stated. Herein, the base resin A) plus crosslinker
resin 8) plus
recrystallization or haze inhibitor D) are considered to be the "resin system"
and equal to
100 parts. Levels of other components are calculated as parts relative to 100
parts of the
resin system ("phr"1. Also herein, "glossy" or "high gloss" means gloss levels
of 50 or
above on a 60° Gardner Gloss scale. Further herein, "non-crystalline"
(otherwise referred
to as "amorphous") broadly defines resins which show no or trace
crystallization or melting
point as determined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). While the term
"crystalline"
includes crystalline as well as semi-crystalline materials and broadly defines
resins with a
discernable crystallization or melting point by DSC. Lastly,
"recrystallization temperature"
or "recrystallization point" refers to the temperature at which the
crystalline resin
component visually appears to separate and recrystallize out of the powder
composition
after being melted for curing, as evidenced by the visual development of a
haze in the
coating.
The base resin A) is preferably comprised of at least one unsaturated
polyester resin
having at least one ethylenic unsaturation site per molecule. The unsaturated
polyester
-5-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
resins can be prenarec~ conventionally by condensation of one or more
ethylenically
unsaturated polyfunct~onal carboxylic acids (or their anhydrides) having
carboxyl
functionalities of 2 or greater with one or more polyhydric alcohols having
hydroxyl
functionalities of 2 or greater. While the unsaturation is typically supplied
by :he carboxylic
acid, it is also possible to supply it through the alcohol. Moreover, the
ethylenic
unsaturation may be provided in the polymer backbone or at the end of the
chain. If it is
supplied at the chain end, ethylenically unsaturated monocarboxylic acids (or
their esters)
are employed in the condensation reaction. Also, whether the unsaturated
polyester is
carboxyl- or hydroxy-terminated will depend upon the -OH/-COOH ratio employed
the
monomer mixture. While these saturated reactivities generally do not
participate in the
curing reaction which proceeds through the unsaturated groups, they are often
used to
achieve desired chemical and mechanical properties.
Examples of suitable ethylenically unsaturated polyfunctional carboxylic acids
(or
their anhydrides) include malefic anhydride, fumaric acid, itaconic anhydride,
citraconic
anhydride, mesaconic anhydride, aconitic acid, tetrahydrophthalic anhydride,
nadic
anhydride, dimeric rriethacrylic acid, etc. Malefic anhydride, fumaric acid,
or their mixtures
are generally preferred because of economic considerations. Examples of
suitable
monofunctional acids employed for chain end unsaturation include acrylic acid,
methacrylic
acid, etc.
Often, polyfunctional saturated and aromatic acids are employed in conjunction
with
the polyfunctional unsaturated acids to reduce the density of the ethylenic
unsaturation and
provide the desired chemical and mechanical properties to the coating.
Examples of suitable
saturated and aromatic polycarboxylic acids (or their anhydrides) include
adipic acid,
succinic acid, sebacic acid, malonic acid, glutaric acid, cyclohexane
dicarboxylic acid,
dodecane dicarboxylic acid, phthalic anhydride, isophthalic acid, terephthalic
acid,
tetrahydrophthalic acid, hexahydrophthalic acid, trimellitic acid,
pyromellitic anhydride, etc.
Examples of suitable polyhydric alcohols include ethylene glycol, diethylene
glycol,
triethylene glycol, propanediol, butanediol, neopentyl glycol,
cyclohexanedimethanol,
hexanediol, 2-n-butyl-2-ethyl-1,3-propanediol, MP Diol, dodecanediol,
bisphenol A,
hydrogenated bisphenol A, trimethylol propane, pentaerythritol, etc.
The unsaturated polyester resins can be formulated to have either a
crystalline or
amorphous microstructure. According to this invention, it is preferable that
the resin system
of the UV curable powders contain at least about 10 wt.% reactive crystalline
material to
impart desired low flow viscosity when melted for curing. It is well known in
the art that
-6-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
certain alcohol and acid monomers can impart crystallinity to the unsaturated
polyesters.
For example, symmetrically substituted linear monomers or cyclic monomers or
their
mixtures are generally used to form crystalline polyesters. Examples of
typical dihydric
alcohols that are known to promote crystallinity include ethylene glycol,
butanediol,
hexanediol, and cyclohexane dimethanol. Examples of typical dicarboxylic acids
that are
known to do the same include terephthalic acid, adipic acid, dodecane
dicarboxylic acid, and
cyclohexane dicarboxylic acid.
Typically, only solid unsaturated base resins A) are of interest in powder
coatings.
Solid unsaturated polyester resins typically have a weight average (Mw)
molecular weight
ranging between about 400 and 10,000, and preferably between about 1,000 and
4,500.
The unsaturated polyesters typically have a degree of unsaturation, preferably
fumarate or maleate unsaturation, between about 2 and 20 wt.%, and preferably
between
about 4 and 10 wt.%.
If the unsaturated polyesters are hydroxyl-functionalized, then the hydroxyl
number
is usually from about 5 to 100 mg of KOH/gram of resin. If the unsaturated
polyester is
acid-functionalized, then the acid number is usually from about 1 to 80 mg of
KOH/gram of
resin.
In a preferred embodiment, the base resin A) comprises a solid, relatively
polar, non-
crystalline unsaturated polyester resin with maleate or fumarate
unsaturations. Accordingly,
the reactive crystalline material is preferably supplied by the crosslinker
resin B).
Generally, all of the non-crystalline resins useful herein should have a glass
transition
temperature (Tg) higher than 90°F, preferably in the range of about 110
to 150~F, which
is sufficiently high for conventional melt-processing and for the powders to
remain solid and
not block or sinter during storage at room temperature. Yet, the Tg is still
low enough so
that the powders pass their softening point and flow freely at temperatures
needed to
preserve heat sensitive substrates, usually between about 170°F and
300°F, and preferably
between about 170°F and 250°F.
The unsaturated base resins A) work best in combination with co-polymerizable
crosslinker resins B) (otherwise known as curing agents) having ethylenic
unsaturation, and
preferably having two sites of unsaturation per molecule. Examples of such
crosslinker
resins include oligomers having ethylenically unsaturated vinyl ether, vinyl
ester, allyl ether,
allyl ester, acrylate or methacrylate groups, although the vinyl ether groups
are generally
preferred. These materials are usually available as crystalline resins.
-7-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
Examples of suitable vinyl ether crosslinker resins include crystalline
divinyi ether
terminated urethane oligomers. This crystalline oligomer can be prepared by
well known
techniques, such as by reacting hydroxyl-functional vinyl ethers, such as
hydroxybutyl vinyl
ether, with crystalline diisocyanates, such as hexamethylene diisocyanate,
hydrogenated
methylene bis (cyclohexyl) diisocyanate, or biurets or uretdiones thereof.
Another suitable
vinyl ether crosslinker is a crystalline vinyl ether terminated ester
oligomer. This crystalline
material can be prepared by conventional methods as well, such as by the
condensation of
hydroxyl-functional vinyl ethers, such as hydroxybutyl vinyl ether, with
crystalline carboxylic
acids (or their anhydridesl, such as phthalic anhydride.
Other suitable crosslinkers include resins having acrylate or methacrylate
groups,
such as dimethacrylate terminated urethanes. Again, these materials are
usually crystalline
resins which can be formed conventionally by reacting hydroxyl-functional
(meth)acrylates,
such as hydroxyethyl methacrylate and hydroxypropyl methacrylate, with
crystalline
isocyanates. Allyl ester crosslinkers are also commonly employed, such as the
reaction
product of allyl alcohol and crystalline carboxylic acids (or their
anhydrides), typically
phthalic anhydride. Standard crystalline allyl ether crosslinkers include the
reaction product
of an allyl ether, such as allyl propoxylate, and a crystallizing hydrogenated
methylene
diisocyanate.
The crosslinker resins B) of particular interest herein are solid materials as
well
because good powder stability and melt-processability is more easily achieved.
The solid
crosslinker resins typically have a weight average (Mw) molecular weight
ranging between
about 200 and 1,000, and preferably between about 300 and 800.
Of course, if these resins are liquids, as with any of the other materials
employed in
the UV curable powder other than the base resin, they can be converted to
solid by
absorption onto inert silica-type filler, such as fumed silica, before use, as
is well known in
the art.
In a preferred embodiment, the crosslinker resin B) comprises a solid,
relatively non-
polar, crystalline vinyl ether terminated urethane resin. As described above,
the reactive
crystalline ingredient is preferably supplied by the crosslinker resin B),
with the base resin
A) preferably supplying the reactive non-crystalline material.
Generally, all of the crystalline resins useful herein should have a melting
point ITm)
higher than the Tg of the non-crystalline resins, and preferably higher than
180°F up to
about 300°F. This allows for efficient melt-processing of the powders
using conventional
equipment and at the same time ensures that the crystalline structures remain
intact after
_g_
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
melt-processing, which gives the powders the desired powder stability and
blocking
resistance. Moreover, the Tm is still below the flow temperature required for
preservation
of heat sensitive substrates.
It will be appreciated by a person of ordinary skill in the art that the
relative amounts
of unsaturated base resin to unsaturated co-polymerizable crosslinker resin in
the UV curable
powder coatings will depend on the choice of materials employed. Usually, such
materials
are employed in stoichiometric equivalent amounts to allow crosslinking to
proceed to
substantial completion, although excess of either can be used if desired. In
general, if the
crosslinker is a vinyl ether terminated urethane oligomer and the base resin
is an unsaturated
polyester with maleate or fumarate unsaturations, as preferred, the
crosslinker is used in an
amount ranging from 0.5-1.5 equivalents of the vinyl ether unsaturation to 1.0
equivalent
of polyester unsaturation, preferably 1 .0 to 1 .0 equivalents.
To obtain the desired low viscosity melt-flow behavior at temperatures between
170'F and 300°F, preferably between 170°F and 250°F, the
amount of crystalline resin,
whether supplied by the base resin A) or crosslinker resin B), present in the
UV curable
powders generally ranges between about 10 and 50 wt.% of the total amount of
A) plus
B), and preferably between about 15 and 25 wt.%, with the balance being non-
crystalline
resin. Below about 10 wt.%, desired flow behavior at the lower melt
temperatures
generally cannot be attained. Above about 50 wt.%, recrystallization rates
generally cannot
be controlled effectively.
Standard free-radical photoinitiators C) are also incorporated in the UV
curable
powders to initiate photopolymerization of the ethylenically unsaturated
compounds.
Examples of suitable alpha cleavage photoinitiators include benzoin, benzoin
ethers, benzyl
ketals, such as benzyl dimethyl ketal, acyl phosphines, such as Biphenyl
(2,4,6-trimethyl
benzoyl) phosphine oxide, aryl ketones, such as 1-hydroxy cyclohexyl phenyl
ketone, etc.
Examples of suitable hydrogen abstraction photoinitiators include Michler's
ketone, etc.
Examples of suitable cationic photoinitiators include diaryliodonium salts and
copper
synergists, etc. Usually the amount of photoinitiator present ranges between
about 0.1 and
10 phr, and preferably between about 1 and 5 phr.
In accordance with this invention, in order to reduce or eliminate hazing and
maintain
a consistent smooth glossy appearance when the powder coating, after having
been melted
and flowed out for curing, is cured in the molten state at temperatures below
the normal
recrystallization point of the crystalline resin component supplied by A) or
B), preferably
supplied by B1, a recrystallization or haze inhibitor D) is employed in the
resin system of the
_g_
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
powder composition. In general, the recrystallization inhibitor D) comprises
another
crystalline resin that is mutually compatible with the co-reactive generally
incompatible
crystalline and non-crystalline resins supplied by A) and B). When
incorporated in the
powder composition, the recrystallization inhibitor visually appears to
disrupt recrystallization
of the crystalline resin species supplied by A) or B) in the coating and
foremost prevents a
haze from visibly developing in the coating formed therefrom when cured at
temperatures
that normally gives rise to such hazing.
The recrystallization inhibitors D) of particular interest herein are solid
materials as
well. More particularly, this material is a solid crystalline oligomer having
moieties that are
compatible with both the co-reactive non-crystalline and crystalline materials
supplied by A)
and B). The crystalline oligomer typically has a weight average (Mw) molecular
weight
ranging between about 200 and 1,000, and preferably between about 300 and 800.
The
melting point (Tm) should also fall within the range described above for
crystalline materials,
i.e., a Tm higher than the Tg of the non-crystalline resins, and preferably
higher than 180°F
up to about 300°F. It may also contain unsaturated groups which
participate in UV curing,
although it typically does not. This component can further be characterized by
not being
able to recrystallize from a neat melt as shown by DSC in contrast to the
crystalline
component supplied by A) or B) that is susceptible to hazing.
In a preferred embodiment, where the non-crystalline resin is an unsaturated
polyester base resin A1 and the crystalline resin is a vinyl ether terminated
urethane
crosslinker resin B), the recrystallization inhibitor D) is preferably a
crystalline oligomer that
contains one or more moieties compatible with the relatively polar non-
crystalline
unsaturated polyester, such as an aryl, e.g., benzyl, substituted aryl,
sulfone, ether, glycidyl
ether, hydroxyl, ester, and the like which render component D) compatible with
the base
resin A1, and an aliphatic crystalline backbone and a molecular weight (Mw)
close to that
of the crystalline crosslinker resin B) which render component D) compatible
with the
crystalline crosslinker resin B1.
Most preferably, the recrystallization inhibitor D) is comprised of a
crystalline epoxy
oligomer that has by definition a glycidyl ether moiety and may contain other
moieties listed
above as well. It may further contain unsaturated functionalities, although
typically only
saturated functionalities are present. Preferably, the molecular weight (Mw)
of these
crystalline epoxy oligomers is less than 800. Crystalline epoxy resins of the
aforesaid
character can be prepared by well known techniques, such as by the
glycidylation of an
alcohol containing the aforesaid functional groups and known to have limited
rotation with
- 10-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
epichlorohydrin. Examples of suitable crystalline epoxy resins useful in the
practice of this
invention include, but are not limited to, tetramethylbisphenol diglycidyl
ether, triglycidyl
isocyanurate, dihydroxydiphenyl sulfone diglycidyl ether (bisphenol S
diglycidyl ether), 2,5-
di-t-butylbenzene-1,4-diglycidyl ether, diglycidyl isophthalate,
epoxypropoxydimethyl
benzylacrylamide, hydroquinone digylcidyl ether, 2,5-di-t-butylhydroquinone
diglycidyl
ether, and terephthalic acid diglycidyl ester, etc.
As discussed above, it is also possible to supply the recrystallization
inhibitor D) with
unsaturated groups which will participate in the UV curing reaction which
proceeds primarily
through the unsaturated groups. An example of a suitable co-reactive
recrystallization
inhibitor includes a crystalline vinyl ether containing one or more of the
aforesaid moieties
such as butanol-4-ethylenyl-oxy-benzoate.
While not wishing to be bound by any particular theory, it is believed that
the
recrystallization inhibitor inhibits the recrystallization of the other
crystalline component by
making the other crystalline component more compatible with the non-
crystalline resin. In
this more compatible blend, the other crystalline resin component visually
appears to
separate and recrystallize out of the molten coating powder less completely
than it does in
the absence of the re crystallizatioh inhibitor.
The amount of recrystallizatio.n inhibitor D) employed will, of course, depend
on the
amount of reactive crystalline resin contained in the UV curable powder
composition. The
amount generally ranges between about 0.1 and 100 wt.% of the total amount of
crystalline resin supplied from A) or B), and preferably between about 1 and
50 wt.%.
Other ingredients such as standard catalysts may also be employed to increase
the
crosslinking rate, such as transition metal compounds based on a fatty acid or
oil, or tertiary
amines. Cobalt soaps, such as cobalt octoate, cobalt neodecanoate, cobalt
naphthenate,
and cobalt octadecanoate, are especially preferred. If employed, the amount of
catalyst
present is typically less than about 1.0 phr, and preferably ranges between
about 0.1 and
0.5 phr.
In addition, thermal free-radical initiators, such as organic peroxide and azo
compounds, in conjunction with the photoinitiators can also be employed. The
presence of
thermal initiators alongside photoinitiators has been found to assist in
curing down near the
substrate, particularly when pigmented, opaque, or thicker film coatings are
desired.
Examples of suitable peroxide and azo initiators include diacyl peroxides,
such as benzoyl
peroxide, azobis (alkyl nitrite) peroxy compounds, peroxy ketals, such as 1,1-
bis(t-butyl
peroxy)-3,3,5-trimethylcyclohexane, peroxy esters, dialkylperoxides,
hydroperoxides, ketone
-11-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
peroxides, etc. If employed, the amount of thermal initiator present usually
ranges between
about 0.1 and about 10 phr, and preferably between about 1 and 5 phr.
Common additives such as pigments and fillers, flow control agents, dry flow
additives, anticratering agents, surfactants, texturing agents, light
stabilizers, etc., can be
used as well. For instance, the UV curable powders made in accordance with
this invention
can be clear coats (i.e., unpigmented and unfilled) or contain up to about 200
phr, usually
up to about 120 phr, of traditional fillers and/or pigments for desired
opacity andlor
coloration. Examples of suitable fillers include calcium carbonate, barium
sulfate,
wollastonite, mica, china clay, diatomaceous earth, benzoic acid, low
molecular weight
nylon, etc. Examples of suitable pigments include inorganic pigments, such as
titanium
dioxide, and organic pigments, such as carbon black, etc. The other common
additives
mentioned above are typically present in a total amount up to about 1 5 phr.
Examples of
typical flow control agents include acrylic resins, silicone resins, etc.
Examples of typical
dry flow additives include fumed silica, alumina oxide, etc. Examples of
typical anticratering
agents include benzoin, benzoin derivatives, low molecular weight phenoxy and
phthalate
plasticizers, etc. Examples of typical surfactants include acetylenic diol,
etc. Examples of
. typical texturing agents include organophilic clays, crosslinked rubber
particles, multiple
crosslinkers, etc. Examples of typical light stabilizers include hindered
amines, hindered
phenols, etc.
The UV curable coating powders employed in this invention are produced by
conventional melt-blending techniques. The components are dry blended
together, and then
melt blended in a single screw or twin screw extruder with heating above the
melting of the
resin system. The extruded composition is rapidly cooled and broken into
chips, ground in
a mill with cooling, and, as necessary, the particulates are sorted according
to size. Average
particle size is typically between about 20-60 microns. Gaseous or
supercritical carbon
dioxide may be charged to the extruder to lower extrusion temperatures. This
is particularly
desirable with powders containing crystalline resins. These powders tend to
experience
drastic reductions in viscosity above the melting point (Tm) of the
crystalline materials,
which, in turn, undesirably reduces the amount of shearing and mixing action
occurring in
the extruder, leads to longer processing time while waiting for the
crystalline materials to
recrystallize and the powder to harden, and also reduces the shelf stability
of the powder
produced due to destruction of crystal. Thus, extrusion is preferably carried
out at
temperatures above the Tg of the non-crystalline resins but below the Tm of
the crystalline
components for efficient melt-processing and desired storage stability.
-12-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
Once the dry, free-flowing, UV curable powders containing the crystalline
resins are
produced, they are ready for application onto a substrate to be coated.
The UV curable powders are applied in the usual fashion, e.g.,
electrostatically, to
the substrate. Usually electrostatic spray booths are employed which house
banks of
corona discharge or triboelectric spray guns and a reclaim system for
recycling the overspray
powders into the powder feed. The applied powders are next exposed to
sufficient amount
of heat to melt and flow out into a continuous, smooth, molten film over the
substrate. The
substrate may be heated at the time of application (pre-heated) and/or
subsequently (post
heated) to effect melting and flow out. Heating can be performed in infrared,
convection
ovens, or a combination of both, although infrared ovens are preferred.
In the initial melting stage, the UV curable powders employed in this
invention have
the ability to melt and flow out into exceptionally smooth films very rapidly
(e.g., in about
5-190 secondsl at very low melting temperatures (e.g., between 170-300'F),
making these
powders suited for coating a plurality of heat sensitive substrates. Usually,
the flow
1 5 viscosity is also very low (e.g., around 100-4,000 cone and plate) which
helps to produce
extraordinarily smooth coatings at the desired flow temperatures.
Immediately following melting and flow out of the powders, the molten powder
coating is exposed to UV light, which, in an almost instant, cures and hardens
the film into
an attractive, durable, haze-free, uniformly smooth and glossy coating across
the entire
substrate. Standard UV light sources are suitable for curing the coating, such
as standard
medium pressure mercury-, iron doped mercury-, and/or gallium doped mercury-
vapor lamps,
e.g., 600-watt Fusion H-, D- and/or V-lamps. Electron beam radiation may be
used instead
of UV radiation, if desired. Hardening of the coating takes between about 1
millisecond and
10 seconds, and typically less than about 3 seconds. The coating thickness
that can be
obtained is typically between about 0.5 and 25 mils, and more commonly between
about
1 and 10 mils.
The glossiness of the cured coating (measured on a 60° Gardner Gloss
scale) is
desirably about 50 or above, preferably about 70 or above, with no visually
significant drop
off in the level of gloss and smoothness across the film when cured at
temperatures which
the crystalline ingredient supplied by A) or B) would normally separate and
recrystallize out
in the absence of the recrystallization inhibitor D).
The UV curable powder coatings employed in this invention are particularly
suited
for heat sensitive substrates. They are also suited for traditional heat
resistant substrates.
Examples of typical heat sensitive substrates include wood, such as hardwood,
hard board,
-13-
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
laminated bamboo, wood composites, such as particle board, electrically
conductive particle
board, high, medium or low density fiber board, masonite board, laminated
bamboo, and
other substrates that contain a significant amount of wood. These substrates
may be filled
or primed with UV liquids, powder primers, or solvent- or waterborne coatings
to improve
smoothness and reduce the required film builds. Other heat sensitive
substrates include
plastics, such as ABS, PPO, SMC, polyolefins, polycarbonates, acrylics, nylons
and other
copolymers which usually will warp or outgas when coated and heated with
traditional heat
curable powders, along with paper, cardboard, and heat resistant composites
and
components having a heat sensitive aspect, and especially those which have a
variable
mass, etc. Examples of typical heat resistant substrates, include metal,
steel, other alloys,
glass, ceramic, carbon and graphite.
This invention will now be described in greater detail by way of specific
examples.
Examples 1-2
Curing of UV Curable Unsaturated Polyester Powder Coatings
The following ingredients were blended and extruded together in the manner
given
to produce UV curable powder coatings according to this invention that are
capable of
forming a consistent haze-free smooth glossy finish when UV cured at variable
high and low
temperatures, along with a traditional UV curable powder coating that is not
capable of such
results which serves as the control.
- 14-
CA 02279164 2002-06-26
i I
PATENT
3612-05-24
INGREDIENTS PHR
CONTROL EXAMPLE XAMPL
1 2
DRY BLEND UNTIL HOMOGENEOUS
Uralac XP-3125' (Non-Crystalline)8C 80 80
Uralac ZW-3307P2 (Crystallin~)20 20 20
Epon~RSS-1407' (Crystalline)--. 5 ---
Ciba RD 97-275' fCrystallinel.-- -..- 5
Lucerin TPOS 2 2 2
Resiflovv P-87 2 2 2
Shepard-Black' 6 6 6 -
CHARGE TO EXTRUDER
AND EXTRUDE A1 MELT
TEMPERATURE OF 180F
AIR COOL EXTRUOATE
AND BREAK INTO CHIPS
AND THEN ADD
Aluminum Oxide C 0.2,6 0.2~ 0.2~
CHARGE TO MILL AND
GRIND TO POWDER
1 5 SCREEN TO -140 MESH
Table Footnotes
Uralec XP 3125 is a solid, amorphous, unsaturated polyester resin that is
believed to be based on fumaric or malefic acid, terephthalic acid, and 1 ,6
hexanediol, sold by DSM Resins. The resin individuolly has a Tg of about
~ 125°F.
iUrelac 2W-3307P is a solid, crystalline, divinyl ether urethane crosslinker
resin that is believed to be based on hexamethylene diisocyanate and 4-
hydroxybutyl vinyl ether, sold by DSM Resins. The resin individually has a Tm
of about 223°F and a recrystallization point of about 178°F-
. ~Epon RSS-1407 is a crystalline epoxy resin composed of tetramethyl
bisphenol digiycidyl ether, sold by Shell Chemical. The resin individually has
a Tm of about 221 °F.
'Cibe RO 97-275 is a crystalline epoxy resin composed of bisphenol S
diglycidyl ether, sold by Ciba Polymers. Tha resin individually has a Tm of
about 257°F.
sl.ucerin TPO is a solid photoinitiator composed of Biphenyl (2,4,8-trimethyl-
benzoyl) phosphine oxide, sold by BASF.
°Resiflow P-67 is a solid acrylic flow control agent, sold by Estron
Chemical.
'Shepard Black is a black spinet copper chromite pigment, sold by Shepard
Color.
°Aluminum Oxide C is a dry flaw additive composed of aluminum oxide,
sold
by Deguasa.
Each powder formulation above was electrostatically applied by a corona
discharge
spray gun onto two separate steel panels that had been pre-heated to different
temperatures, i.e., 170°F and 250°F. The panels were coated at
these two temperatures
-15-
~ Trademark
CA 02279164 1999-07-30
PATENT
3612-05-24
to simulate what happens on a heat sensitive part which has both thin and
thick sections
which heat up to different temperatures depending on the mass of the part. The
applied
powders were then allowed to fuse as a result of the residual heat given off
by the pre-
heated until a smooth continuous molten coating film had been formed.
Immediately after
fusion, while the film was still molten, the panels were cured by exposure to
UV radiation.
The cured coatings all had a film thickness of between 2.2-3.0 mils. The
coating conditions
and performance results are given in the Table below.
CONTROL EXAMPLE EXAMPLE
1 2
Pre-heat 115 175F 250F 175F 250F 175F 250F
minutes)
Powder Application100 100 100
kV kV kV
Corona Corona Corona
Gun Gun Gun
UV Cure 11 600 800 600
second) Watt Watt Watt
D-Lamp D-Lamp D-Lamp
Substrate 0-Panel Q-Panel Q-Panel
Coating Temperature170F 242'F 168F 241'F 168F 242F
at UV Cure
Haziness Hazy No No No No No
MottledHaze Haze Haze Haze Haze
Smoothness TexturedNo Heavy No Heavy Slight
Orange Orange Orange Orange Orange
Peel Peel Peel Peel Peel
60 Gloss 72 90 82 94 77 94
MEK ResistanceSlight No No No No No
(50 Double Rub Rub Rub Rub Rub Rub
Rubs) Off Off Off Off Off Off
The above results confirm that incorporation of a more compatible crystalline
resin
into the powder composition alongside the crystalline crosslinker resin
prevents a haze from
visibly developing on the surface of the coating upon being cured at
temperatures at which
the crystalline crosslinker resin would normally recrystallize out in absence
of the other
crystalline ingredient. This enables production of cured coatings with a more
consistent
smooth glossy appearance especially over a variable mass, heat sensitive part
despite having
sections of the part cured at different temperatures above and below the usual
recrystallization temperature.
Example 3
The following ingredients were blended and extruded together in same manner as
provided in Examples 1-2 to produce another UV curable powder coatings
according to this
invention that is capable of forming a consistent haze-free smooth glossy
finish when UV
cured at both high and low temperatures, along with a traditional UV curable
powder
coating that is not capable of such results which serves as the control.
- 16-
CA 02279164 2002-06-26
PATENT
3612-05-24
INGREDIENTS PH R
CONTROL EXAMPLE
3
Crylcoat E5252' )Non-Crystalline)80 80
Uralac Z4V-3307P (Crystalline)20 20
Epori RSS-1407 ICrysta~line)-- 5
Lucerin TPO 2 2
Resiflow P-87 2 2
Shepard Black ' 8 6
Aluminum Oxide C 0.296 0.296
1 0 Table Footnote
'Crylc:oat4E5252 is a solid, amorphous, unsaturated acrylated polyester resin.
The resin individually has a Tg of about 140'F.
Each powder formulation was tested in the same manner as provided in Examples
1-2. The coating conditions and performance results are given in the Table
below.
1 5 CONTROL EXAMPLE
3
Pre-heat 115 175"F 250F 17!5F 250F
minutes)
Powdqr Application1 OO 100
kV kV
Corona Corona
Gun Gun
UV Cure 11 600 800
second) Watt Watt
D-Lamp D-Lamp
Substrate Q-Panel Q-Panel
I
20 Coating TemperatureGenerally Generally
at UV Cure Same Same
As As
In In
Examples Examples
1-2 1-2
Haziness Very Slight No No
Hazy Haze Hraze Maze
Very
Mottled
Smoothness Slight No ModerateNo
Orange Orange Orange Orange
Peel Peel Peel Peel
80 Gloss 24 $8 _ 138 88
25 MEK ResistanceSlight No Slight No
(50 Double Rub Rub Rub Rub Off
Rubs) Off Off Off i
From the foregoing it will be seen that this invention is one well adapted to
attain
all ends and objects hereinabove set forth together with the other advantages
which are
apparent and inherent. Since many possible variations may be made of the
invention
30 without departing from the scope thereof, the invention is not intended to
be limited to the
embodiments and examples disclosed, which are considered to be purely
exemplary.
Accordingly, reference should be made to the appended claims to assess the
true spirit and
scope of the invention, in which exclusive rights are claimed.
-17-
'" Trademark
