Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCTIUS98/06736
TITLE
FLAME RETARDANT RESIN COMPOSITIONS
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to resin compositions which have a combination of
good physical properties and good flame retardance.
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND
Synthetic resins, including polyesters and aliphatic and aromatic
polyamides, such as nylon-6,6 and nylon-6, and copolymers thereof, are often
used for molded articles and fibers. In many uses, particularly for molded
articles,
it is preferred if the resin has improved resistance to fire, compared to the
resin
alone. This is often attained by the addition of various agents which improve
the
basic fire resistance (i.e., flame retardance) of the resin, but sometimes
these
agents degrade or diminish other physical properties of the resin. Since
resins are
widely used, compositions which have improved fire resistance but yet retain
the
desirable physical properties of the resin are constantly being sought.
German Patents 2,150,484 and 2,130,793, and A. E. Lipska, Comb. Inst.
Arizona State Univ., West. State Sect. Combust, Inst. WSCI, 1973, report that
certain tungsten compounds can be used in various ways to improve the fire
resistance of polyamides. The combinations of agents described hereinafter are
not disclosed in these references.
U.S. Patent 4,298,518 discloses compositions containing polyamides and
melamine cyanurate, which are said to have good fire resistance.
U.S. Patent 3,458,470 discloses compositions containing polyamides and a
variety of tungsten or molybdenum compounds, including silico- and phospho-
tungstic acids. These compositions are said to have good resistance to
discoloration and be stable to light.
Melamine phosphate may be added to synthetic resins to improve the
flame retardancy of the resins, but when heated to normal engineering polymer
processing temperatures the melamine phosphate gives off so much water that
the
resultant mixture of the resin and the melamine phosphate has very poor
physical
properties.
What are needed, therefore, are flame retardant resin compositions which
do not have the problems and deficiencies of the prior art.
1
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to flame retardants for polyester and polyamide
compositions wherein the polyamides are synthetic aliphatic polyamides, and
synthetic aliphatic aromatic polyamide copolymers, and mixtures thereof, and
specifically relates to compositions containing (1) 30 to 70 weight percent of
a
polyester or a synthetic, aliphatic polyamide or a mixture thereof; (2) 15 to
40
weight percent of glass or mineral reinforcing agent; and (3) a flame
retardant of
(a) 20 to 45 weight percent of melamine polyphosphate; (b) 15 to 30 weight
percent of melamine polyphosphate and up to 10 weight percent of a charring
catalyst; (c) 15 to 30 weight percent of melamine polyphosphate, up to 10
weight
percent of a charring catalyst and up to 10 weight percent of a char former,
wherein all percents by weight are based on the total weight of (1)+(2)+(3)
only.
These compositions exhibit good fire resistance and are useful as molding
resins. These compositions may also include other additional fillers and
additives
as are commonly known in the art.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
The composition described herein is a resin composition having both good
physical properties and good flame retardancy. The composition has three
components (1) a polyester or certain polyamides or a mixture thereof; (2) a
glass
or mineral reinforcing agent; and (3) a flame retardant which includes a
melamine
polyphosphate compound and optionally a charring catalyst, or a charring
catalyst
and a char former.
The first component is a polyester or certain polyamides or a mixture
thereof, which is present in an amount of 30 to 70 weight percent of the
composition.
"Polyester" as used herein includes polymers having an inherent viscosity
of 0.3 or greater and which are, in general, linear saturated condensation
products
of glycols and dicarboxylic acids, or reactive derivatives thereof.
Preferably, they
will comprise condensation products of aromatic dicarboxylic acids having 8 to
14 carbon atoms and at least one glycol selected from the group consisting of
neopentyl glycol, cyclohexane dimethanol and aliphatic glycols of the formula
HO(CH2)nOH where n is an integer of 2 to 10. Up to 50 mole percent of the
aromatic dicarboxylic acids may be replaced by at least one different aromatic
dicarboxylic acid having from 8 to 14 carbon atoms, and/or up to 20 mole
percent
2
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
may be replaced by an aliphatic dicarboxylic acid having from 2 to 12 carbon -
atoms.
The most common polyester compositions are based on polyethylene
terephthalate homopolymers, polybutylene terephthalate homopolymers,
polyethylene terephthalate /polybutylene terephthalate copolymers,
polyethylene
terephthalate/polybutylene terephthalate mixtures and mixtures thereof,
although
= other polyester may be used as well, alone, in combination with each other,
or in
combination with those polyesters listed above.
"Synthetic polyamide", as used herein, includes a polymer which is made
by man, and does not include natural fibers such as wools or silks. By an
"aliphatic polyamide" is meant a polymer which has repeat units which include
amide groups in the main chain, and in which at least some, preferably at
least
50 mole percent, of these amide groups (through the nitrogen atoms and/or
carbonyl carbon atoms of the amide groups) are connected to aliphatic carbon
atoms. Preferred polyamides include nylon-6,6, nylon-6, nylon 6,12, and
copolymers of nylon-6,6 and nylon 6. Nylon-6,6 and nylon-6, and copolymers
thereof, are especially preferred and nylon-6,6 is more preferred.
By "aliphatic aromatic polyamide copolymers" is meant a polymer which
has repeat units which include amide groups in the main chain, and in which at
least some of these amide groups (through the nitrogen atoms and/or the
carbonyl
carbon atoms of the amide groups) are connected to aromatic carbon atoms.
Preferred "aliphatic aromatic polyamides copolymers" include nylon 6T/61
(polyhexamethylene terephthalamide/polyhexamethylene isophthalamide
copolymer), 6T/6,6 (polyhexamethylene terephthalamide/polyhexamethylene
adipamide copolymer), 6T/6, l 0 (polyhexamethylene
terephthalamide/polyhexamethylene decanediamide copolymer), 6T/6,12
(polyhexamethylene terephthalamide/polyhexamethylene dodecanediamide
copolymer), etc.
The second component in the invention is a reinforcing agent, such as a
glass or mineral reinforcing agent, and which may include glass, carbon, mica
and/or aramid fibers. The reinforcing agent, which is present in an amount of
15
to 40 weight percent, is important in obtaining the desired combination of
both
good physical properties and improved fire resistance in the inventive
composition.
The third component of the invention is a flanie retardant that includes a
melamine polyphosphate compound and optionally either a charring catalyst or a
charring catalyst and a char former. In one embodiment, the melamine
3
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
polyphosphate compound is doped with a charring catalyst or with a charring
catalyst and a char former.
The melamine polyphosphate compound is the melamine salt of of
polyphosphoric acid. The polymeric chain of polyphosphoric acid is ideally
(HMPO3)n, where n is greater than 2 and M stands for melamine. Melamine
pyrophosphate is defined as H4M2P07, where M stands for melamine. The
polymeric sodium salt is (NaPO3)n. It is only required that the average chain
length be greater than 2, some pyro and mono phases will ordinarily result
during
synthesis of inelamine polyphosphate.
The flame retardant component typically contains 20 to 45 weight percent
of the melamine polyphosphate compound, based on the total weight of the
composition. When less than 20 weight percent of the melamine polyphosphate
compound is present, the composition is not effective as a flame retardant
under
UL94. However, lower amounts of the flame retardant may be effective under a
flame retardant test less stringent that UL94, such as the glow wire test of
International Standard IEC 695-2-1/0 1994. For synthetic polyamides, in
practice
the upper amount of the melamine polyphosphate component is 35 weight
percent, because while it may be possible to use greater that 30 weight
percent of
a melamine polyphosphate compound, such amounts are not deemed to be
practical because of the high costs of using such an amount of the melamine
polyphosphate compound. However, even greater amounts of the melamine
polyphosphate may be used, especially when a polyester is used.
The preferred amount of flame retardant used with aliphatic polyamides is
25-30%.
An optional ingredient of the inventive composition that is part of the
flame retardant is a charring catalyst. When melamine polyphosphate is used as
the melamine compound, the presence of the charring catalyst is not essential
to
the invention, but its use in conjunction with melamine polyphosphate greatly
reduces the amount of melamine polyphosphate needed, as discussed below.
As used herein, the term "charring catalyst" includes metal salt of a
tungstic acid or a complex oxide acid of tungsten and a metalloid, a tin oxide
salt
such as sodium tin oxide, and/or ammonium sulfamate. Preferred metal salts
include alkali metal salts of a tungstic acid, with sodium tungstate being
especially preferred. By a complex oxide acid of tungsten and a metalloid is
meant a complex oxide acid formed by a metalloid such as phosphorous or
silicon
and tungsten. Preferred complex oxide acids include silicotungstic acid and
phosphotungstic acid, with silicotungstic acid being especially preferred. If
the
charring catalyst is present as part of the flame retardant component of the
4
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
inventive composition it is present in an amount up to 10 weight percent based
on
the total weight of the inventive composition. A preferred range is from 0.1
to
weight percent, with a more preferred range being from 0.1 to 2 weight
percent.
5 Another optional ingredient of the inventive composition that is part of the
flame retardant is a char former such as a polyhydric alcohol. Other examples
= include novolac, vinyl alcohols and starches. In the present invention, it
is
preferred that the polyhydric alcohol be penterythritol or dipenterythritol.
If it is
present in the composition, the char former is present in amounts of up to 10
10 weight percent based on the total weight of the inventive composition. A
preferred range is from 0.1 to 10 weight percent, with a more preferred range
being from 0.1 to 2 weight percent.
Still other optional ingredients of the inventive composition that are part
of the flame retardant are melamine cyanurate, melamine, and zinc borate.
By "melamine compound doped with a charring catalyst" is meant a
melamine phosphate compound such as melamine pyrophospate that is made such
that the charring catalyst is bound to the melamine polyphosphate. The
melamine
compound doped with a charring catalyst may be made by preparing an aqueous
solution of melamine, preparing an aqueous solution of silicotungstic acid or
phosphotungstic acid, and preparing an aqueous solution of a phosphorous acid,
such as polyphosphoric acid. The tungstic acid solution is added to the
phosphorous solution, and then that mixture is added to the melamine solution,
wherein melamine pyrophosphate is formed. The resulting solution is vacuum
dried to produce the doped melamine polyphosphate compound. The mole ratio
of the melamine to phosphorous in the solution should be from 2:1 to 1:2. The
number of moles of the charring catalyst should be from 0.01 to 0.5 moles per
mole of melamine polyphosphate compound, and preferably 0.1 moles per mole
of inelamine compound. There may not be a 100% formation of melamine
polyphosphate when the doped melamine compound is made, so that while the
doped melamine compound is primarily melamine polyphosphate, it may also
include melamine phosphate and/or melamine pyrophosphate.
The melamine compound that is doped with a charring catalyst may also
be made by contacting, in an aqueous medium, melamine and silicotungstic acid
or phosphotungstic acid in a molar ratio of from I to 24 moles of melamine per
mole of the tungsten compound to prepare "melamine salts" of the tungstic
acids.
It is preferred that the contacting be carried out at 50 C to 100 C. It is
believed
that the melamine not only forms salts with the tungsten compound used, but
also
solvates the resulting salt much like water forms hydrates. Cyanuric acid may
5
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
also be present so that the melamine forms a "mixed salt" with cyanuric acid
and
the silico- or phosphotungstic acid.
It has also been discovered that for compositions that include a synthetic,
aliphatic polyamide and a glass or mineral reinforcing agent, melamine
polyphosphate alone is effective as a flame retardant to obtain UL-94 VO if
used
in a proportion of 25 to 30 weight percent. As discussed above, an amount of
melamine polyphosphate of 5 weight percent or above may be effective to pass a
less stringent flame retardant test such as the glow wire test.
The compositions described herein have improved fire resistance
compared to the resin alone, and are particularly useful as molding resins for
making parts such as electrical and electronic parts such as bobbins, coil
forms,
connectors, fasteners, and for parts in equipment such as circuit breakers.
These
compositions also retain the good physical properties of the resins, that is
desirable mechanical properties particularly toughness. Toughness may be
roughly estimated as being proportional to the product of the tensile strength
and
elongation, so the higher either or both of these are, the tougher the
polymer. It is
preferred that the composition be fire resistant enough so that it has a
rating of VO
in the Underwriters Laboratory test UL-94, at a thickness of 0.16 cm (1/16
inch).
It is well known that lower levels of the flame retardants disclosed herein
may be successfully used to prepare compositions which meet flame retardant
tests less demanding than Underwriters Laboratory test UL-94. For example,
lower amounts of the inventive flame retardants may be used in combination
with
a resin and a reinforcing agent and still pass the glow wire test under less
demanding conditions, specifically at temperatures lower than 960 C and/or at
higher thicknesses than 1.5 mm.
It is also preferred that the melamine phosphate compound, reinforcing
agent and flame retardant, such as the charring catalyst, be relatively well
dispersed in the resin. A preferred degree of dispersion can be attained by
producing the composition in any of a number of different types of equipment
which are commonly used to disperse materials in polymers. For instance, a
twin
screw extruder with appropriate mixing screw sections can be used to
satisfactorily melt mix the ingredients. It is also believed that the
dispersion of
the charring catalyst in the polymer is aided by starting with tungsten
compound
having relatively small particle sizes.
It has also been discovered that the elongation of molded bars made from
the inventive composition may be unexpectedly increased by adding to the
composition a compatabilizer such as a silane compound. An example of an
acceptable silane compound is triethoxy(3-aminoproply) silane sold under the
6
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
trade name A1100 by Aldrich Chemical Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The
silane compound may be added to the composition by any conventional method.
A preferred method is that the silane is first coated onto the melamine
polyphosphate compound before the melamine polyphosphate compound is added
to the other components of the inventive composition. Alternatively, the
silane
may be added to the resin and/or reinforcing agent, which is then mixed with
the
melamine polyphosphate compound.
The silane compound may be present in any amount up to 0.4 weight
percent, based on the total weight of the resin, reinforcing agent, flame
retardant
and silane compound only. A preferred range is from 0.01 to 0.4 weight
percent,
and a more preferred range is from 0.1 to 0.3 weight percent.
In a preferred embodiment, a flow enhancer may be added to the
composition to improve the flow. An example of an acceptable flow enhancer is
dodecanedioic acid (DDDA), available from E.I. du Pont de Nemours and
Company of Wilmington, Delaware. When a flow enhancer is used with the
compositions of the invention, it is preferred that the flow enhancer be used
in an
amount of from 0.25 to 0.5 weight percent, based only on the total weight
percent
of the resin, reinforcing agent, flame retardant and, if present, silane
compound.
EXAMPLES
The following abbreviations are used in the Examples and the Tables set
out below:
STA - silicotungstic acid
NYADG - wollastonite
PBT - polybutylene terephthalate
PET - polyethylene terephthalate
MPOP - melamine polyphosphate,
VALOX 307 - PBT made by GE, (Schenectady, NY)
HTN - High Temperature Nylon 501 by DUPONT, (Wilmington, DE)
Unless otherwise indicated, the following procedure was used in the
examples. The resin used in the Example was both resin pellets and ground
resin,
and then the resin, a reinforcing material, a melamine polyphosphate compound,
a
charring catalyst, a charring catalyst and a char former, were thoroughly
mixed,
which usually took 30 minutes. In.the examples where a doped melamine
compound was used, the doped melamine compound was prepared as set forth in
the Example, and then was thoroughly mixed with the resin and reinforcing
material.
7
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
The resin mixture was then dried under standard conditions, and then
extruded on either a 28 mm or a 30 mm Werner & Pfleiderer twin screw extruder,
using a screw design having a mid range screw severity, at a melt temperature
of
270-300 C, and at rates of 11.3-15.9 kg per hour. Bars of 1/16" were molded on
a
0.043 kg (1.5 oz) molding machine. Standard molding conditions for the resin
mixtures were used.
These resin mixtures were then molded into bars using typical injection
molding machines, ranging from laboratory sized machines to commercial sized
machines. Melt temperatures were typically 280-300 C, and mold temperatures
were typically 45-100 C. The molded bars were then tested for a flammability
rating in the UL-94 test at 0.16 cm thickness, unless otherwise indicated.
Examples: Nylon6,6 Resin
In the following examples, Zytel 1018 nylon 6,6 resin sold by DuPont
was used. The data are summarized in Table 1. The reenforcement is either
glass
(PPG 3540) or NYADG.
Table 1 sets forth the compositions of the following Examples 1-4 using
aliphatic polyamide.
Example 1: MPOP/char catalyst
A molded bar was made with melamine polyphosphate doped with a
charring catalyst. 385 g of melamine and 423 g polyphosphoric acid was
dissolved in 2500 g of methanol. 15 g STA was added and the mixture was
stirred overnight. It was filtered and dried in a vac oven 90 C. The
composition
was found to perform at a rating of UL94VO.
Example 2: MPOP
A molded bar was made with melamine polyphosphate doped with a
charring catalyst. The preparation of melamine polyphosphate was done by first
adding 65 gallons hot water to a large tank. Next, 4,600 g HCl (37%
concentration) was added, then 12.95 lbs of melamine and 11.75 lbs of sodium
polyphosphate (Hexaphos from FMC, Philadelphia, PA). Stir and heat for 3
hours. Then the NaCI was filtered out via washing. The product was dried in a
vac oven. The composition had a rating of UL94VO.
8
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
Example 3: MPOP
A molded bar was made with melamine polyphosphate (from example 2).
The melamine polyphosphate was heated at 270 C for 30 minutes. The
composition was rated "VO".
Example 4: MPOP
= A molded bar was made with melamine polyphosphate (from example 2).
The melamine polyphosphate was heated at 270 C for 30 minutes. The
composition was rated "VO".
Table 1- Examples 1-4
Composition (Wt. %)
xam. Nylon 6,6 Nylon 6,6 Flame Flame Filler Filler
No. Pellet Powder Retardant Retardant Type Amount
Type Amount
1 20 30 MPOP/STA 25 glass 25
2 20 30 MPOP 25 glass 25
3 20 30 MPOP 25 glass 25
4 20 30 MPOP 25 NYADG 25
Example 5: Polyester
A molded bar was made using Rynite 3934 polyester resin and the
melamine polyphosphate from Example 2. Proportions were PET pellets, 20%;
PET powder, 30%; MPOP, 25%; and glass, 25%. The composition had a rating
of UL94VO.
Example 6: Polybutylene terephthalate (PBT).
A molded bar was made with MPOP (from Example 2). The composition
was 20% PBT pellets (GE VALOX); 25% PBT powder (GE VALOX), 30%
MPOP, and 25% glass (PPG 3563). It had a rating of UL94VO.
Example 7: PBT
A molded bar was made with MPOP (from Example 2). The composition
the same as Example 6 except that the MPOP was heated at 270 C for 30
minutes. It had a rating of UL94VO.
Example 8: high temperature nylon (HTN)
A molded bar was made with melamine polyphosphate (from Example 2).
The composition was 25% HTN 501 pellets, 25% HTN 501 powder, 25% MPOP
and 25% glass (PPG 3540). It had a rating of UL94VO.
9
CA 02285044 1999-09-22
WO 98/45364 PCT/US98/06736
Although particular embodiments of the present invention have been
described in the foregoing description, it will be understood by those skilled
in the
art that the invention is capable of numerous modifications, substitutions and
rearrangements without departing from the spirit or essential attributes of
the
invention. Reference should be made to the appended claims, rather than to the
foregoing specification, as indicating the scope of the invention.
In addition to the components discussed above, the compositions of this
invention may contain additives commonly employed with synthetic resins, such
as colorants, mold release agents, antioxidants, tougheners, nucleating
agents,
ultraviolet light and heat stabilizers and the like. An example of a common
filler
is magnesium hydroxide.
