Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
FINISH TOPPING MACHINE FOR BULB CROPS
Description
The present invention relates to methods and apparatus for
removing a portion of the tops, or stems and roots, from bulb crops such
as onions, shallots, beets, garlic, radishes, and turnips, and more
particularly to apparatus for finish topping of such bulbs. For ease of
discussion herein, all such bulb crops are referred to as "onions." By
"finish topping" is meant the removal of an additional portion of the
plant top to leave a desirably short length of top attached to the bulb.
The roots may also be removed by finish topping.
It may be desirable to remove most of the top growth and roots
from each bulb before sale. Typically, stems are preliminarily cut by a
harvesting machine in the field to a length of between about 2 and 4
inches, and may also be finish topped by a second apparatus in a factory
packing operation to the USDA No. 1 Pack standard of 1.5 inches. Even
shorter stems of 1 inch or less are highly desirable for many consumers,
particularly of onions for direct retail sale. Although bulbs may be of
varying size within a given harvest, it is further desirable that the stems
of all bulbs be cut to a uniform length from the shoulder of the bulbs.
In many geographical regions, for example, in the southern United
States, onions typically are harvested for human consumption when the
above-ground portion of the plants are still succulent. This presents a
particular problem in that topping apparatus can rapidly become fouled
with sticky onion juice which can cause the machine to jam and also can
leave an undesirable stain or residue on succeeding bulbs.
Numerous schemes have been proposed in the onion harvesting
and processing art for trimming stems and/or roots.
US Patent No. 2,414,922 issued January 28, 1947 to Barrett et al.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 2 -
discloses an onion topping device, known as a roller topper, with a
topping bed having a plurality of longitudinal spiral-wound rolls, each of
which rotates against a parallel stationary cutter blade. When onions
are fed onto the bed, the stems and roots are entrained between the
spirals and the cutters and are sheared off, much in the fashion of a reel
lawnmower. A disadvantage of a roller topper is that onions differing in
size and shape will have cut stems of differing lengths. An additional
disadvantage we have found is that although the spiral rolls and the
cutters may trim dried onions cleanly, when presented with succulent
onion stems the rolls and cutters can rapidly become wet with juice and
pulp and can leave unacceptable stains and residues on the bulbs.
US Patent No. 2,978,333 issued April 4, 1961 to Teigen discloses
an apparatus having a vacuum box above a conveyor, the vacuum box
being open towards the conveyor and having a rotary knife therein. As
upright conveyed onions pass the vacuum box, the stems are drawn into
the box and are severed by the knife. Since the spacing between the
conveyor and the box is invariant, the spacing of the knife is referenced
only to the bottom of the bulb, not to its shoulder, and hence onions of
different heights will be cut undesirably to different lengths of residual
stem.
US Patent No. 5,431,000 issued July 11, 1995 to Shuknecht at al.
discloses a sickle-bar topper disposed within a forced-air onion
harvesting machine wherein whole onions being conveyed horizontally on
a chain-link belt are exposed to a forced air draft from below which lifts
the stems upwards into engagement with a horizontal sickle-bar cutter.
As in the Teigen apparatus, the spacing of the cutter is referenced to the
bottom of the bulb (the conveyor), and thus stems of varying lengths from
the shoulder are left on the bulbs. Further, if the spacing is set to
provide short residual stems on smaller bulbs, the cutter may be low
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 3 -
enough to cut into and ruin larger bulbs.
It is a principal object of the invention to provide an improved
apparatus for finish topping of bulb crops wherein the plane of a topping
cutter, and hence the length of each residual stem, is referenced from the
shoulder of each individual bulb.
It is a further object of the invention to provide an improved
apparatus for finish topping of bulb crops wherein the length of each
residual stem as measured from the shoulder of the bulb is substantially
identical.
It is a still further object of the invention to provide an improved
apparatus for finish topping of bulb crops wherein bulbs are not bruised,
punctured, or stained by passage through the apparatus.
Briefly described, a finish topper machine embodying the
invention comprises a plurality of longitudinal, parallel, generally
horizontal, endless moving belts having spaces therebetween, referred to
herein as a 'belt section," the belts being disposed between upwardly
extending side walls which form thereby a conveyance channel for onions
on the belts. Adjacent of the belts are driven at different linear speeds.
In a preferred embodiment, alternate belts are either reduced to zero
speed or are replaced by stationary rails to maximize the speed
differential. Below and adjustably close to the belts is a cutting means,
preferably a driven rotating blade similar to a rotary lawnmower blade,
rotatable about a generally vertical axis and in a direction to exert a
downwards draft of air through the belts. Onions introduced onto the
belts are conveyed through the apparatus by the belts, and the
differential speed of adjacent belts causes the bulbs to rotate and gyrate
randomly as they are being conveyed. The spacing of the belts is set to
permit the attached stems of bulbs to extend downwardiy between
adjacent belts. The bulb itself is retained on its shoulders, on the upper
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 4 -
surface of the belts, in inverted posture. During passage through the
machine, each bulb in its random rotational movements assumes this
attitude at least once, at which time the stem is immediately sheared by
the cutting means to the proper residual length. The cut waste falls to a
conveyor below the cutting means and is removed from the apparatus.
Since each onion is restrained by its shoulders against the belts, the
residual stem of every onion is equal in length as measured from the
onion shoulder.
To accommodate a desired throughput load and velocity, an
apparatus in accordance with the invention may comprise a plurality of
belt sections similar to that just described, each section depositing onions
onto a succeeding belt section and ultimately into a receptacle for further
processing. A typical machine may include, preferably, four such
sections. It may additionally comprise a first pre-sizing section, without
cutting means, wherein the belts may be spaced apart preferably slightly
farther than the belts in the topping sections to permit undersize onions
to fall between the belts to be otherwise used or discarded.
In a further embodiment, one or more of the belt sections may be
covered by a flexible blanket extending substantially full-width of the
section between the side walls, the onions passing between the blanket
and the belts. The down-pumping of the cutting blade below the belts
creates a partial vacuum in the onion region which draws the blanket
against the onions to increase the random gyrations of the onions.
In a still further embodiment, the apparatus may be variably
elevatable at its downstream end to cause the onions to "run uphill."
This feature is useful in establishing experimentally, and then setting,
the optimum residence time for any particular batch of onions in the
apparatus, balancing completeness of topping with throughput speed and
productivity.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 5 -
The foregoing and other objects, features, and advantages of
the invention, as well as presently preferred embodiments thereof, will
become more apparent from a reading of the following description in
connection with the accompanying drawings in which:
FIG. 1 is a side elevational view of a finish topping apparatus in
accordance with the invention, taken along line 1-1 in FIG. 2;
FIG. 2 is a plan view of the apparatus shown in FIG. 1, taken
along line 2-2 therein;
FIG. 3 is a detailed elevational view, partially in cross-section, of
an individual belt and associated conveyance structure;
FIG. 4 is a plan view of a portion of the conveyance structure
shown in FIG. 3;
FIG. 5 is an elevational cross-sectional view of the portion of the
conveyance structure shown in FIG. 4, taken along line 5-5 therein;
FIG. 6 is an elevational cross-sectional view of a portion of the belt
and conveyance structure shown in FIG. 3, taken along line 6-6 in FIG. 3
and enlarged from circle 6-6 in FIG. 7;
FIG. 7 is an elevational view of a stationary inter-belt rail;
FIG. 8 is a cross-sectional view of a belt pulley mounted on a
pulley drive shaft;
FIG. 9 is an elevational view, partially in cross-section, taken
along line 9-9 in FIG. 3;
FIG. 10 is an elevational view near the downstream end of the
apparatus, taken along line 10-10 in FIG. 2;
FIG. 11 is an elevational view of the upstream end of the
apparatus, taken along line 11-11 in FIG. 2;
FIG. 12 is a cross-sectional view of the apparatus, taken along line
12-12 in FIG. 2;
FIG. 13 is an isometric view from above, showing placement of a
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 6 -
tipper bar in the onion path between the belts; and
FIG. 14 is an elevational view, partially in cross-section, showing
an onion being tipped over by the tipper bar shown in FIG. 13.
Referring to FIGS. 1 through 14, there is shown a bulb topping
apparatus 10 in accordance with the invention. A generally trough-
shaped longitudinal frame 12 having an upstream, or feed, end 14 and a
downstream, or discharge, end 16 supports a plurality of pairs of
transverse drive shafts 18 and idler shafts 20 which are mounted
through appropriate holes in opposed sidewalls 22 and 23 of frame 12.
Drive shafts 18 are rotatably supported by bearings 24 mounted on
sidewall 22 and are driven by electric motors 26 mounted on opposing
sidewall 23. Preferably, the rotational drive speed of the motors, and
hence of the drive shafts, may be controllably varied by any conventional
motor drive control scheme (not shown). Shafts 18 may be individually
driven as shown in FIGS. 2 and 11, or they may be driven, for example,
from a single larger motor by a conventional arrangement of pulleys and
belts, sprockets and chains, gears, or other suitable drive means (not
shown). Idler shafts 20 are non-rotatably supported and fixed as by
threaded fasteners to frame 12.
Supported on drive shafts 18 are a plurality of drive pulleys 28
axially spaced apart along drive shafts i8. Each one of pulleys 28 may
be fixed to rotate with drive shaft 18 at any desired axial location by
means of set screw 30 threadedly disposed in well 32. Alternatively,
pulleys 28 may be otherwise fixed to rotate with shaft 18, for example, by
making the shaft and the pulley bore polygonal in cross section, or by
threading the shaft and providing locking nuts on either side of each
pulley (not shown).
Supported in bearings 34 on idler shafts 20 are a plurality of idler
pulleys 36 axially spaced apart along idler shafts 20. The bearings of
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98107812
each idler pulley 36 may be fixed at any desired axial location by means
similar to those just described for the drive pulleys.
The planes of rotation of all the driven pulleys and all the idler pulleys
are parallel. For each driven pulley there is a coplanar idler pulley, each
pair
of such pulleys defining a conveyance path for an endless belt 38. Between the
pulleys, each belt 38 is supported and guided by a guide frame 40 having
struts 42 and belt guides 44, and including a plane which is coplanar with the
plane of the pulleys. Each guide frame 40 is supported through bores therein
on mounting rods 46 attached to sidewalls 22,23, and may be fixed on rods 46
to be coplanar with the pulleys by set screws 48. Preferably, belt 38 is
provided on its inner surface with a groove 50 which is receivable of guide
pins
52 in belt guides 44 and a radial flange 54 in each of pulleys 28,36. The
guide
pins and pulley flanges serve to retain the belts in place and to keep the
belt
groove free of debris during topping operation of the apparatus. In the latter
respect, this arrangement is superior to other, more conventional
configurations which might be selected, such as V-belts in V-pulleys. Belts 38
may be molded or otherwise formed fram any suitable durable, flexible
material such as a polymer, and in a currently preferred embodiment are
formed by heat welding of appropriate lengths of linear stock cut from
continuous polyurethane belting. The combination of belts 38, pulleys 28,36,
and guide frames 40 defines a first conveyance assembly of the apparatus,
belts 38 being drivable at a first linear velocity.
In a preferred embodiment, between adjacent belts 38 is a stationary
rail 56, the outer surface 58 of which is substantially coplanar with the
outer
surface 60 of belts 38 over approximately half the length of belt 38, as shown
in FIG. 7. In assembly, rails 56 are alternated with guide frames 40 on
mounting rods 46. Each rail 56 may be fixed on rods 46 by set screw 62,
preferably to be equidistant from the adjacent guide frames and belts. Rails
56 may be smooth on their upper surfaces as shown in FIG. 7, or one or more
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
_ g _
rails may be provided with a central, longitudinal ridge formable as by
welding
of rod stock onto the upper surface thereof. The ridge may be coated or
covered with a polymeric sleeve if desired. Rail 56 defines an embodiment o~a
second conveyance assembly of the apparatus.
Preferably, the transverse spacing between each belt and its adjacent
rails is the same for all belts and rails and is less than the diameter of the
onions being topped, so that each onion rests partly on a belt and partly on a
rail, bridging the gap therebetween. The spacing between belts and rails may
be easily varied by varying the positions of the pulleys 28,36 on the shafts
18,20 and the guide frames 40 and rails 56 on rods 46. For example, we have
found that to obtain a 1 inch residual stem on an average onion from the
northeast US may require a belt-to-rail spacing of about 1.5 inches, whereas
northwest US and California onions, being somewhat larger on average, may
require a spacing approaching 2 inches. These spacings may be varied for any
particular crop of onions as desired by varying the pulley, guide, and rail
positions as described hereinabove.
In an alternative embodiment, rails 56 may be replaced with a second
set of belts, being interleaved with belts 38, and a second set of guide
frames
40 to define another embodiment of a second conveyance assembly of the
apparatus. Idler shafts 20 are replaced by driven shafts, bearings, and
motors,
like shaft 18, bearings 24, and motors 26. In addition, on each shaft, idler
pulleys are alternated with drive pulleys. Preferably, the second set of
shafts
and belts may be driven at a second linear belt velocity substantially
different
from the linear velocity of the first set of belts, or even in the opposite
direction, to impart rotation and gyration to bulbs being conveyed.
Each assembly of driven and idler pulleys and belts supported by a pair
of shafts defines a belt section. Bulb topper 10 comprises five such belt
sections, 64, 66, 68, 70, and 72, sequentially and respectively.
In first belt section 64, the pulleys, guide frames, and rails are spaced
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/13598/0?812
_ g _
along the driven and idler shafts to provide desired gaps between adjacent
belts and rails. Section 64 functions as a pre-sorter, and the width of these
gaps is set to permit all unacceptably small bulbs introduced into the
apparatus to fall through and be collected for other processing or discard.
All
bulbs larger in diameter than this width are passed on to the remainder of the
machine. Section 64 has no topping capability.
All subsequent belt sections are substantially identical and have topping
capability. As shown in FIGS. 1 and 12, each section is provided with a cutter
motor 74 mounted on a bracket 76 extending between sidewalls 22 and 23.
Bracket 76 preferably is bolted to the sidewalls through slotted holes to
permit
adjustment of the vertical position of bracket 74. Extending upwards from
motor 74 orthogonal to upper rail surface 58 is motor shaft extension 78 which
is constrained on bracket 76 by bearings 79 and which is provided at its upper
end with a rotary blade 80 similar to the blade of a rotary lawnmower. For
example, blade 80 may be a 27 inches long and motor 74 may be a 3 HP direct
drive motor operative at 1760 rpm. Preferably, the width of the belt section
between sidewalls 22 and 23, the length of the section between the pulleys,
and the placement of struts 42 in frames 40, and the length of blade 80 are
all
selected so that the rotational path of blade 80 extends the full width of its
belt
section. Preferably, blade 80 is sharpened along the entire length of its
leading rotational edge, to maximize the area of cutting opportunity, and is
twisted downwards at its trailing edge so that blade 80 is both a cutter and a
down-pumping fan blade.
Any desired length of residual stem on a finish-topped onion may be
obtained by setting the vertical position of bracket 76 in the slotted holes
in
the sidewalls such that the cutting edge of blade 80 is the desired distance
below the upper surface 60 of belts 38.
Disposed below, the cutter drive motors 74 within trough frame 12 is a
conventional conveyor 75 for receiving the cut stems and transporting them
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 10 -
out of the apparatus.
The upper surfaces of the belts and rails in each belt section define a
conveyance plane for that section. Preferably, the conveyance plane for each .
succeeding section is lower than that of the preceding section, as shown
clearly
in FIG. 1, preferably by about one-third the diameter of the pulleys. Also,
the
drive pulleys 28 of each section are staggered from, and interleaved with, the
idler pulleys 36 of the preceding section. This configuration allows smooth
flow of onions from one section to the next and prevents onions from becoming
dynamically trapped in a nip between sections. Also the drop tends to rotate
the onions forwardly so as to assist the belts to orient the onions in an
inverted
position for topping.
Apparatus in accordance with the invention may be provided with an
onion tipper bar 81 to assist in rotating the onions, as shown in FIGS. 13 and
14. Tipper bar 81 preferably is disposed below and transverse of belts 38 and
is formed in a series of square bights 83 extending upwards between the belts
and rails. Bar 81 is supported by sidewalls 22,23, and preferably is rotatable
to vary the attitude of the bights to onions being conveyed by the belts. In
operation, an onion encountering a bight 83 may be tipped from upright to
inverted position for topping as shown in FIG. 14.
The gyrating action of onions moving through topping apparatus 10 also
can be enhanced by addition of a flexible blanket 82 to one or more of the
topping sections. As shown in FIG. 1, for example, blanket 82 is suspended at
its forward edge on a rigid mounting bar. extending between the sidewalls
above the entrance to section 70. Blanket 82 may be formed of any convenient
flexible material, preferably of rubber sheeting about 100 mils in thickness,
and extends substantially the full width and length of the belt section
between
the sidewalk. Because of the partial vacuum produced by the down-pumping
action of blade 80, blanket 82 is drawn downwards against the onions passing
between blanket 82 and belts 38, increasing the force of the onions against
the
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02295911 2000-O1-04
WO 99/02050 PCT/US98/07812
- 11 -
belts and preventing the onions from bouncing and becoming bruised. Since
the blanket is stationary and the belts are moving, the onions are caused to
rotate about a horizontal axis transverse of the direction of onion travel.
Simultaneously, of course, the speed differential between the belts and rails,
or
between two sets of interleaved belts, causes the onions to rotate about a
vertical axis transverse of the direction of onion travel. The combination of
these two simultaneous rotary motions of results in a very vigorous, random
gyration of each bulb in which each bulb can assume for a moment the desired
inverted posture for topping at least several times during a single passage
through the topping apparatus.
Preferably, bulb topping apparatus 10 is vertically pivotable on foot 84
and is variably tiltable by lift 86, which may include a hydraulic or
pneumatic
cylinder or other jacking arrangement. Via lift 86, the angle of the
conveyance
planes may be varied to vary the speed with which onions pass through the
apparatus. Raising lift 86 to force the onions to travel up a gradient extends
the residence time and hence increases the opportunity for topping, but also
reduces the throughput volume of the machine. Optimum conditions may be
easily achieved experimentally for each batch of onions by varying the speed
of
the controllably-variable belt drive motors 26 and the elevation of lift 86.
From the foregoing description it will be apparent that there has been
provided an improved apparatus for finish topping of bulb crops, wherein the
length of residual top is controlled by reference to the shoulder of each
bulb,
and wherein the length of residual top is the same for each bulb, and wherein
tops may be trimmed to a desirably short length without damaging or staining
of the bulbs. Variations and modifications of the herein described finish
topper, in accordance with the invention, will undoubtedly suggest themselves
to those skilled in this art. Accordingly, the foregoing description should be
taken as illustrative and not in a limiting sense.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
