Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Weather Resistant Fanels
The present invention relates to weather resistant panels. In particular, the
present
invention relates to weather resistant doors and most particularly temperature
resistant
doors. For ease of reference the teim "panel" when used herein shall include
"door".
Whilst the invention will be described with particular reference to the panel
being a
door, it is also applicable to other panels such as, for example, false walls,
wall
facias, office dividers and the like.
By "weather resistant" we mean that the panel is resistant to damage caused by
climatic features such as temperature and humidity. In particular we mean
damagt
that is caused by changes in climatic features and in particular changes in
temperature. In addition, we mean damage that is caused when opposed faces of
the
panel are exposed to different climatic features in particular different
temperatures.
Where the panel is, for example, an exterior door, the external face of the
door may
be exposed to high temperatures during the summer months whilst the internal
face
of the door is exposed to cool temperatures caused by, for example, air
conditioning.
In contrast, in the winter months the outer face of the door is exposed to
cold
temperatures whilst the inner face is exposed to warmer temperatures due to
heating
inside the building. The door will also be exposed to different temperatures
during
a 24-hour period as the ambient temperatures change or as a result of being
exposed
to direct sunlight and then in shade. Even where the panel is for use
internally, the
panel may be exposed to different temperatures during a period as heating is
switched
on and off, is altered over time or differs between rooms.
Damage to the panel caused by these differences in temperature and/or humidity
includes crack failure on the surface of the panel, the development of
curvature,
lcnown as "bowing" or other distortion of the entire surface of the panel.
Distortion
of a panel, such as a door, may have several severe consequences. First the
appearance of the door may be marred. Secondly, the ease of the operation of
the
door may be affected, in particular it may become difficult to open or shut
the door.
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Most seriously, the air-tightness, water-tightness and sound insulation of the
door may
be reduced.
It is therefore desirable to provide "weather resistant" panels which are able
to
withstand these changes in temperature and/or humidity and which therefore
have a
longer useful life. Further it is advantageous if the panel exhibits an
ability to
insulate the face of the panel remote from a heat source from the heat. That
is to say
the panel reduces the transmission of heat through the panel.
Panels which are resistant to the transmission of heat have various
applications. Heat
resistant panels are desirable for use in domestic, industrial and commercial
buildings
and are required in buildings that have multiple occupancy such as hospitals,
residential homes, offices and the like. These panels may be for internal or
external
use. Many countries set minimum safety requirements which building materials
must
meet before they can be used in the aforementioned situations. The ability of
the
panels to not only retard heat transmission but also to withstand changes in
ambient
temperature is particularly advantageous as the frequency at which panels have
to be
replaced is reduced.
Panels may be made from a variety of materials. Historically, wood has been
the
material of choice, either used alone or glazed to allow visibility through
the panel.
However, wooden panels can suffer from warping and splitting when subjected to
changes in temperature. In recent years it has been desirable to replace wood
as the
preferred material with plastics materials which are generally cheaper and
easier to
handle than wood.
Panels formed from plastics material often comprise a pair of vacuum formed
thermoplastics skins, attached to opposed faces of a frame, eg of wood and
having
a core of a filler material which may be, for example, glass fibre, foamed
plastics or
the like. Panels of this type are difficult to manufacture and do not overcome
the
disadvantages of wooden panels with regard to temperature resistance. Indeed
for
some plastics materials the damage caused by changes in ambient temperature
can be
-2-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
greater than for panels made from wood. In particular, panels formed from
plastic
materials tend to suffer from bowing when exposed to increased temperature on
one
side of the panel. This is believed to be due to the different levels of
expansion of
the plastics skins on the "hot" and "cold" sides of the panel. Since the skins
are
bonded at their edges to the frame, the only way in which the different levels
of
thermal expansion of the skins can be absorbed is by bowing.
Further, it has been difficult to obtain panels formed from plastics material
which
meet the heat resistant criteria set down by the legislative bodies.
We have now discovered that the above-mentioned disadvantages can be overcome
and that a panel having a vacuum formed thermoplastics skin can be formed
which
exhibits improved resistance to bowing and which exhibits substantial heat
resistance.
Thus, according to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a
panel
comprising a substantially open-cell, rigid foam core and at least one vacuum
formed
thermoplastic skin adhesively bonded to said foam core. The at least one skin
preferably comprises vinyl chloride polymer such as PVC or, more preferably
uPVC.
The panel preferably comprises two skins adhesively bonded to opposing faces
of the
panel. More preferably the panel also includes a frame or frame members which
are
suitably of wood.
Without wishing to be bound by any theory, it is believed that when the
opposed
faces of a panel according to the invention are exposed to different
temperatures, the
rigidity of the core, to which the heated skin is adhesively bonded, provides
a counter
force to the thermal effect on the skin and inhibits the skin from expanding.
It is
further believed that the substantial stress which would be created in the
skin due to
the inability to expand fully is possibly absorbed, at least to some extent,
by material
flow within the skin. In any event, whether or not this theory is correct, it
has been
found that when the skin of the panel is exposed to changes in temperature
and/or
humidity, cracking, bowing and other damage caused by exposure to heat are
substantially reduced over what has been achieved heretofore. Further the
-3-
CA 02318510 2006-12-07
transmission of heat through the panel is also reduced.
The foam core preferably has at least one face containing pores which when
the, or
each, skin is in place are open to the rear face of the skin. In this
arrangement, the
adhesive can percolate into and key to the surface of the foam, thereby
forming a
stronger bond. This serves to lock the skin to the foam.
Where a panel is faced with vacuum formed plastics skins, it is difficult to
provide
them with the depressed zones of moulding detail which are found in
traditional
panelled wooden panels. This is because in order to achieve the depressed
zones it
would be necessary either to use preformed foamed core parts of complicated
shape or
to leave space behind the depressed zones empty. Both methods are
disadvantageous.
The first is costly and the second results in a panel having zones of weakness
and an
unacceptable lack of rigidity. One method of overcoming this problem is to
provide the
moulding detail as raised portions in the skin. However, these are not as
aesthetically
pleasing as the preferred depressions and further, if these are hollow, the
air inside the
raised portions expands when the panel is exposed to increased temperatures
and the
mouldings may burst.
Therefore, according to an embodiment of the present invention there is
provided a
panel comprising at least one vacuum formed thermoplastic skin having
depressed
zones adhesively bonded to a foamed plastics core wherein the core comprises a
substantially rigid plastics foam having frangible cell walls and portions of
the core
behind the depressed zones have been compressed with fracture of the cell
walls of the
foam to accommodate said zones.
By a foam having frangible cell walls we mean that under compression the foam
crumbles by brittle fracture of the cell walls e.g. involving a clean fracture
of the cell
walls. In one aspect of the invention, such foams retain a clear and
substantially
dimensionally accurate imprint in the crushed zone of the object through which
the
compressive force is applied. In general, it is preferred that the yield
strength of the
foam, which in this case means the minimum force required to cause the
fracture of the
-4-
CA 02318510 2006-12-07
cell walls and for the foam to crumble, is in the range of about 100 to 140
KPa (15 to
20 lbs/sq.in) more preferably at least 200 KPa (30 lbs/sq.in), since this
provides the
panel with useful impact resistance. In general, for a given foam composition,
the
greater the density, the greater the yield strength.
By using a substantially rigid plastics foam with frangible cell walls,
mouldings with
depressed zones of moulding detail can be readily formed by applying the
vacuum
formed skin to the foam core with sufficient pressure to cause the cell walls
of the foam
in the areas behind the depressed zones of the skin to be fractured whereby
the foam is
caused to conform to the contours of the skin in those zones by controlled
localised
crushing. Thus, air gaps between the skins can be avoided and it is not
necessary to
perform the core pieces in the form of complicated shapes. This is
particularly
advantageous since the presence of such air gaps in prior art panels has
contributed to
their inability to resist changes in temperature.
It is advantageous to use an open cell foam having frangible walls as pressing
a skin
having depressed regions into a conventional foamed core such as of
polystyrene
cannot be successfully achieved because the resilience of the foam will cause
distortion
of the skins when the pressure is released.
The open-cell, rigid foam core is a filled phenolic foam. However, the foam is
advantageously selected to be of a high density relative to the foamed
polystyrene
conventionally used, e.g. a density of 75 kg/m3 or above, since this gives a
better feel to
the panel and makes it sound and handle more like a conventional wooden panel.
However, foams having lower densities may also be selected. The filler is
preferably a
finely divided inert and preferably inorganic solid. The filler may be
selected such that
it contributes to the panels ability to resist changes in temperature. In a
particularly
preferred embodiment, the filler is capable of absorbing moisture, e.g. as
water of
crystallisation.
It is believed that in prior arrangements where a closed cell foam is
employed, such as a
polystyrene foam, any solvent employed or moisture present during the bonding
of the
-5-
CA 02318510 2006-12-07
foam core to the skin tends to be trapped between the core and the skin. Any
volatilisation and subsequent condensation of the solvent or moisture due to
localised
changes in temperature, for example as a result of exposure to strong sunlight
and then
darkness, cause high localised pressure variations which tend to lead to
localised
bubbling, or failure of the bond. The effect is even more marked where high
temperatures are encountered. A closed cell foam may even contribute to the
"bowing"
because any air or solvent trapped in the core itself will expand when the
core is heated
causing the panel to bow.
Without wishing to be bound by any theory, it is believed that the reduction
of bowing
is assisted by use of an open cell foam in the core since gas flow is possible
which
reduces the localised increases in pressure. As the foam is of an open cell
configuration, as the gases in cells closest to the heat source expand they
flow through
open pathways to adjacent cells and by this means pressure is dissipated
through the
panel. Further, the open cell configuration reduces the rate at which heat is
passed
through the panel. ,
Thus according to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided
the use of
an open cell foam as a rigid core in a panel according to claim 1 having at
least one
thermoplastics skin to improve the weather resistance of the panel.
One particularly suitable foam is that produced by effecting a curing reaction
between:
./~
-6-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
(a) a liquid phenolic resole having a reactivity number (as defined below)
of at least I and
(b) a strong acid hardener for the resole,
in the presence of:
(c) a fmely divided inert and insoluble particulate solid which is present
in an amount of at least 5% by weight of the liquid resole and is
substantially
uniformly dispersed through the mixture containing resole and hardener;
the temperature of the mixture containing resole and hardener due to applied
heat not
exceeding 85 C and the said temperature and the concentration of the acid
hardener
being such that compounds generated as by-products of the -curing reaction are
volatilised within the mixture before the mixture sets whereby a foamed
phenolic
resin product is produced.
By a phenolic resole is meant a solution in a suitable solvent of the acid-
curable
prepolymer composition obtained by condensing, usually in the presence of an
alkaline catalyst such as sodium hydroxide, at least one phenolic compound
with at
least one aldehyde, in well-known manner. Examples of phenols that may be
employed are phenol itself and substituted, usually alkyl substituted,
derivatives
thereof provided that the three positions on the phenolic benzene ring o- and
p- to the
phenolic hydroxyl group are unsubstituted. Mixtures of such phenols may also
be
used. Mixtures of one or more than one of such phenols with substituted
phenols in
which one of the ortho or para positions has been substituted may also be
employed
where an improvement in the flow characteristics of the resole is required but
the
cured products will be less highly cross-linked. However, in general, the
phenol will
be comprised mainly or entirely of phenol itself, for economic reasons.
The aldehyde will generally be formaldehyde although the use of higher
molecular
weight aldehydes is not excluded.
The phenol/aldehyde condensation product component of the resole is suitably
formed
by reaction of the phenol with at least 1 mole of formaldehyde per mole of the
phenol, the formaldehyde being generally provided as a solution in water, e.g.
as
-7-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
formalin. It is preferred to use a molar ratio of formaldehyde to phenol of at
least
1.25 to 1 but ratios above 2.5 to 1 are preferably avoided. The most preferred
range
is 1.4-2.0 to 1.
The mixture may also contain a compound having two active H atoms (dihydric
compound) which will react with the phenol/aldehyde reaction product of the
resole
during the curing step to reduce the density of cross-linking. Preferred
dihydric
compounds are diols, especially alkylene diols or diols in which the chain of
atoms
between the OH groups contains not only methylene and/or alkyl-substituted
methylene groups but also one or more hetero atoms, especially oxygen atoms,
e.g.
ethylene glycol, propylene glycol, propane-l,3-diol, butane-1,4-diol and
neopentyl
glycol. Particularly preferred diols are poly-, especially di-, (alkylene
ether) diols
e.g. diethylene glycol and, especially, dipropylene glycol. Preferably the
dihydric
compound is present in an amount of from 0 to 35 % by weight, more preferably
0
to 25% by weight, based on the weight of phenol/aldehyde condensation product.
Most preferably, the dihydric compound, when used, is present in an amount of
from
5 to 15% by weight based on the weight of phenol/aldehyde condensation
product.
When such resoles containing dihydric compounds are employed in the present
process, products having a particularly good combination of physical
properties,
especially strength, can be obtained.
Suitably, the dihydric compound is added to the formed resole and preferably
has 2-6
atoms between OH groups.
The resole may comprise a solution of the phenol/aldehyde reaction product in
water
or in any other suitable solvent or in a solvent mixture which may or may not
include
water. Where water is used as the sole solvent, it is preferred to be present
in an
amount of from 15 to 35 b by weight of the resole, preferably 20 to 30 b .
Of course
the water content may be substantially less if it is used in conjunction with
a co-
solvent. e.g. an alcohol or one of the above-mentioned dihydric compounds
where
one is used.
-8-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
As indicated above, the liquid resole (i.e. the solution of phenol/aldehyde
product
optionally containing dihydric compound) must have a reactivity number of at
least
1. The reactivity number is 10/x where x is the time in minutes required to
harden
the resole using 10% by weight of the resole of a 66-67% aqueous solution of p-
toluene sulfonic acid at 60 C. The test involves mixing about 5m1 of the
resole with
the stated amount of the p-toluene sulfonic acid solution in a test tube,
immersing the
test tube in a water bath heated to 60 C and measuring the time required for
the
mixture to become hard to the touch. The resole should have a reactivity
number of
at least 1 for useful foamed products to be produced and preferably the resole
has a
reactivity number of at least 5, most preferably at least 10.
The pH of the resole, which is generally alkaline, is preferably adjusted to
about 7,
if necessary, for use in the process, suitably by the addition of a weak
organic acid
such as lactic acid. -
Examples of strong acid hardeners are inorganic acids such as hydrochloric
acid,
sulphuric acid and phosphoric acid, and strong organic acids such as aromatic
sulphonic acids, e.g. toluene sulphonic acids, and trichloroacetic acid. Weak
acids
such as acetic acid and propionic acid are generally not suitable. The
preferred
hardeners for the process of the invention are the aromatic sulfonic acids,
especially
toluene sulfonic acids.
The acid may be used as a solution in a suitable solvent such as water.
When the mixture of resole, hardener and solid is to be poured, e.g. into a
mould and
in slush moulding applications, the amount of inert solid that can be added to
the
resole and hardener is determined by the viscosity of the mixture of resole
and
hardener in the absence of the solid. For these applications, it is preferred
that the
hardener is provided in a form, e.g. solution, such that when mixed with the
resole
in the required amount yields a liquid having an apparent viscosity not
exceeding
about 50 poises at the temperature at which the mixture is to be used, and the
preferred range is 5-20 poises. Below 5 Poises, the amount of solvent present
tends
-9-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
to present difficulties during the curing reaction.
The curing reaction is exothermic and will therefore of itself cause the
temperature
of the mixture containing resole and acid hardener to be raised. The
temperature of
the mixture may also be raised by applied heat but the temperature to which
said
mixture may then be raised (that is, excluding the effect of any exotherm)
must not
exceed 85 C.
If the temperature of the mixture exceeds 85 C before addition of the
hardener, it is
difficult or impossible thereafter to properly disperse the hardener through
the mixture
because of incipient curing. On the other hand, it is difficult, if not
impossible, to
uniformly heat the mixture above 85 C after addition of the hardener.
Increasing the temperature towards 85 C tends to lead to coarseness and non-
uniformity of the texture of the foam but this can be offset at least to some
extent at
moderate temperatures by reducing the concentration of hardener. However at
temperatures much above 75 C even the minimum amount of hardener required to
cause the composition to set is generally too much to avoid these
disadvantages.
Thus, temperatures above 75 C are preferably avoided and preferred
temperatures
for most applications are from ambient temperature to about 75' C. The
preferred
temperature range appears to depend to some extent on the nature of the solid
(c).
For most solids it is from 25 to 65 C but for some solids, in particular wood
flour
and grain flour, the preferred range is 25 to 75 C. The most preferred
temperature
range is 30 to 50 C. Temperatures below ambient, e.g. down to 10 C can be
used,
if desired, but no advantage is gained thereby. In general, at temperatures up
to
75 C, increase in temperature leads to decrease in the density of the foam
and vice
versa.
The amount of hardener present also affects the nature of the product as well
as the
rate of hardening. Thus, increasing the amount of hardener not only has the
effect
of reducing the time required to harden the composition but above a certain
level
dependant on the temperature and nature of the resole it also tends to produce
a less
-10-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
uniform cell structure. It also tends to increase the density of the foam
because of
the increase in the rate of hardening. In fact, if too high a concentration of
hardener
is used, the rate of hardening may be so rapid that no foaming occurs at all
and under
some conditions the reaction can become explosive because of the build up of
gas
inside a hardened shell of resin. The appropriate amount of hardener will
depend
primarily on the temperature of the mixture of resole and hardener prior to
the
commencement of the exothermic curing reaction and the reactivity number of
the
resole and will vary inversely with the chosen temperature and the reactivity
number.
The preferred range of hardener concentration is the equivalent of 2 to 20
parts by
weight of p-toluene sulfonic acid per 100 parts by weight of phenol/aldehyde
reaction
product in the resole assuming that the resole has a substantially neutral
reaction, i.e.
a pH of about 7. By equivalent to p-toluene sulfonic acid, we mean the amount
of
chosen hardener required to give substantially the same setting time as the
stated
amount of p-toluene sulfonic acid. The most suitable amount for any given
temperature and combination of resole and finely divided solid is readily
determinable
by simple experiment. Where the preferred temperature range is 25-75 C and the
resole has a reactivity number of at least 10, the best results are generally
obtained
with the use of hardener in amounts equivalent to 3 to 10 parts of p-toluene
sulfonic
acid per 100 parts by weight of the phenol/aldehyde reaction product. For use
with
temperatures below 25 C or resoles having a reactivity number below 10, it
may be
necessary to use more hardener.
It may be necessary to make some adjustment of the hardener composition in
accordance with the nature, especially shape and size, of the mould and this
can be
established by experiment.
By suitable control of the temperature and of the hardener concentration, the
time
lapse between adding the hardener to the resole and the composition becoming
hard
(referred to herein as the setting time) can be varied at will from a few
seconds to up
to an hour or even more, without substantially affecting the density and cell
structure
of the product.
-11-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Another factor which controls the amount of hardener required can be the
nature of
the inert solid. Very few are exactly neutral and if the solid has an alkaline
reaction,
even if only very slight, more hardener may be required because of the
tendency of
the filler to neutralize it. It is therefore to be understood that the
preferred values for
hardener concentration given above do not take into account any such effect of
the
solid. Any adjustment required because of the nature of the solid will depend
on the
amount of solid used and can be determined by simple experiment.
The exothermic curing reaction of the resole and acid hardener leads to the
formation
of by-products, particularly aldehyde and water which are at least partially
volatilised.
The curing reaction is effected in the presence of a finely divided inert and
insoluble
particulate solid which is substantially uniformly dispersed throughout the
mixture of
resole and hardener. By an inert solid we mean that in the quantity it is used
it does
not prevent the curing reaction.
It is believed that the finely divided particulate solid provides nuclei for
the gas
bubbles formed by the volatilisation of the small molecules, primarily CH2O
and/or
H20, present in the resole and/or generated by the curing action, and provides
sites
at which bubble formation is promoted, thereby assisting uniformity of pore
size.
The presence of the finely divided solid may also promote stabilization of the
individual bubbles and reduce the tendency of bubbles to agglomerate and
eventually
cause likelihood of bubble collapse prior to cure. The phenomenon may be
similar
to that of froth flotation employed in the concentration of low grade ores in
metallurgy. In any event, the presence of the solid is essential to the
formation of the
product. To achieve the desired effect, the solid should be present in an
amount of
not less than 5% by weight based on the weight of the resole.
Any fmely divided particulate solid which is insoluble in the reaction mixture
is
suitable, provided it is inert. The fillers may be organic or inorganic
(including
metallic), and crystalline or amorphous. Even fibrous solids have been found
to be
effective, although not preferred. Examples include clays, clay minerals,
talc,
-12-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
vermiculite, metal oxides, refractories, solid or hollow glass microspheres,
fly ash,
coal dust, wood flour, grain flour, nut shell flour, silica, mineral fibres
such as finely
chopped glass fibre and finely divided asbestos, chopped fibres, finely
chopped
natural or synthetic fibres, ground plastics and resins whether in the form of
powder
or fibres, e.g. reclaimed waste plastics and resins, pigments such as powdered
paint
and carbon black, and starches.
Solids having more than a slightly alkaline reaction, e.g. silicates and
carbonates of
alkali metals, are preferably avoided because of their tendency to react with
the acid
hardener. Solids such as talc, however, which have a very mild alkaline
reaction, in
some cases because of contamination with more strongly alkaline materials such
as
magnesite, are acceptable.
Some materials, especially fibrous materials such as wood flour, can be
absorbent and
it may therefore be necessary to use generally larger amounts of these
materials than
non-fibrous materials, to achieve valuable foamed products.
The solids preferably have a particle size in the range 0.5 to 800 microns. If
the
particle size is too great, the cell structure of the foam tends to become
undesirably
coarse. On the other hand, at very small particle sizes, the foams obtained
tend to
be rather dense. The preferred range is 1 to 100 microns, most preferably 2 to
40
microns. Uniformity of cell structure appears to be encouraged by uniformity
of
particle size. Mixtures of solids may be used if desired.
If desired, solids such as finely divided metal powders may be included which
contribute to the volume of gas or vapour generated during the process. If
used
alone, however, it be understood that the residues they leave after the gas by
decomposition or chemical reaction satisfy the requirements of the inert and
insoluble
finely divided particulate solid required by the process of the invention.
Preferably, the finely divided solid has a density which is not greatly
different from
that of the resole, so as to reduce the possibility of the finely divided
solid tending
- 13-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
to accumulate towards the bottom of the mixture after mixing.
One preferred class of solids is the hydraulic cements, e.g. gypsum and
plaster, but
not Portland cement because of its alkalinity. These solids will tend to react
with
water present in the reaction mixture to produce a hardened skeletal structure
within
the cured resin product. Moreover, the reaction with the water is also
exothermic
and assists in the foaming and curing reaction. Foamed products obtained using
these
materials have particularly valuable physical properties. Moreover, when
exposed
to flame even for long periods of time they tend to char to a brick-like
consistency
which is still strong and capable of supporting loads. The products also have
excellent thermal insulation and energy absorption properties. The preferred
amount
of inert particulate solid is from 20 to 200 parts by weight per 100 parts by
weight
of resole.
Another class of solids which is preferred because its use yields products
having
properties similar to those obtained using hydraulic cements comprises talc
and fly
ash. The preferred amounts of these solids are also 20 to 200 parts by weight
per
100 parts by weight of resole.
For the above classes of solid, the most preferred range is 50 to 150 parts
per 100
parts of resole.
Thixotropic foam-forming mixtures can be obtained if a very finely divided
solid such
as Aerosil (fmely divided silica) is included.
If a fmely divided metal powder is included, electrically conducting
properties can
be obtained. The metal powder is preferably used in amounts of from 50 to 250
parts
per 100 parts by weight of resole.
In general, the maximum amount of solid that can be employed is controlled
only by
the physical problem of incorporating it into the mixture and handling the
mixture.
In general it is desired that the mixture is pourable but even at quite high
solids
-14-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
concentrations, when the mixture is like a dough or paste and cannot be
poured,
foamed products with valuable properties can be obtained.
In general, it is preferred to use the fibrous solids only in conjunction with
a non-
fibrous solid since otherwise the foam texture tends to be poorer.
Other additives may be included in the foam-forming mixture; e.g. surfactants,
such
as anionic materials e.g. sodium salts of long chain alkyl benzene sulfonic
acids, non-
ionic materials such as those based on poly(ethylene oxide) or copolymers
thereof,
and cationic materials such as long chain quaternary ammonium compounds or
those
based on polyacrylamides; viscosity modifiers such as alkyl cellulose
especially
methyl cellulose, and colorants such as dyes or pigments. Plasticisers for
phenolic
resins may also be included provided the curing and foaming reactions are not
suppressed thereby, and polyfunctional compounds other than the dihydric
compounds
referred to above may be included which take part in the cross-linking
reaction which
occurs in curing; e.g. di- or poly-amines, di- or poly-isocyanates, di- or
poly-
carboxylic acids and aminoalcohols.
Polymerisable unsaturated compounds may also be included possibly together
with
free-radical polymerisation initiators that are activated during the curing
action e.g.
acrylic monomers, so-called urethane acrylates, styrene, maleic acid and
derivatives
thereof, and mixtures thereof.
Other resins may be included e.g. as prepolymers which are cured during the
foaming
and curing reaction or as powders, emulsions or dispersions. Examples are
polyacetals such as polyvinyl acetals, vinyl polymers, olefin polymers,
polyesters,
acrylic polymers and styrene polymers, polyurethanes and prepolymers thereof
and
polyester prepolymers, as well as melamine resins, phenolic novolaks, etc.
Conventional blowing agents may also be included to enhance the foaming
reaction,
e.g. low boiling organic compounds or compounds which decompose or react to
produce gases.
-15-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
The foam-forming compositions may also contain dehydrators, if desired.
A preferred method of forming the foam-forming composition comprises first
mixing
the resole and inert filler to obtain a substantially uniform dispersion of
the filler in
the resole, and thereafter adding the hardener. Uniform distribution of both
the filler
and the hardener throughout the composition is essential for the production of
uniformly textured foam products and therefore thorough mixing is required.
If it is desired that the composition is at elevated temperature prior to
commencement
of the exothermic reaction, this can be achieved by heating the resole or
first mixing
the resole and the solid and then heating the mixture. Preferably the solid is
added
to the resole just before the addition of the hardener. Alternatively, the
mixture of
resole, solid and hardener may be prepared and the whole mixture then heated,
e.g.
by short wave irradiation, preferably after it has been charged to a mould. A
conventional radiant heat oven may also be used, if desired, but it is
difficult to
achieve uniform heating of the mixture by this means.
Preferably, the foam has a density in the range 75 to 500 kg/m3, more
preferably 100
to 400 kg/m3 and most preferably 100 to 250 kg/m3. Foam cell size is-also
important
because up to a limit the larger the size of the cell for a given density, the
thicker
will be the walls and hence the greater the physical strength of the foam.
However
if the cell size is too large, the strength begins to suffer. Preferably, the
cell size is
in the range of 1 to 3mm.
Any suitable thermoplastic material may be employed to form the skins of the
panels
provided it is capable of being produced as a sheet which is vacuum formable.
For
reasons of cost, the skins are preferably formed of a vinyl chloride polymer
such as
PVC, more preferably u-PVC, since this is the material conventionally used;
however
other plastics materials such as acrylics, ABS and polymer blends may also be
used.
Any suitable adhesive may be used for bonding the skins to the foam core,
including
moisture-curing polyurethanes, two-pack polyurethanes, solvent based adhesives
and,
-16-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
preferably, unsaturated polyester-based adhesives. Provided an open-cell foam
is
employed, excess solvent or moisture is not a problem as it can be absorbed
into the
foam.
To give improved rigidity, in general the panel skins will be spaced not only
by a
foam core but also by a frame or frame members such as stiles, rails, and/or
mullions. The frame members may be of wood, metal or plastics or a combination
of these, e.g. metal-reinforced plastics. The plastics material may contain
filler, if
desired, to improve hardness and/or rigidity.
In a preferred embodiment, the foam core occupies substantially the entire
volume or
volumes within the frame; i.e. substantially the whole space within the panel
defmed
by the skins and the components of the frame. It is also preferred that the
foam is
bonded to each skin over substantially the entire area of the foam core which
is in
contact with that skin, even when the skin includes one or more depressed
zones,
since this enhances the overall strength of the panel and the resistance to
bowing.
In one preferred embodiment, the core of rigid plastics foam is in the form of
one or
more rectangular blocks of said foam, at least one of the skins includes one
or more
depressed zones and the portion of the block or blocks behind each said zone
conforms to the contours of said zone as a result of selective controlled
crushing of
the foam in the area behind said zone.
The panel skins are made from vacuum-formable sheets. Each skin may be formed
by drawing the sheet down on to a suitable mould by vacuum forming.
The doors of the preferred embodiments of the present invention, when produced
using a filled phenolic foam in the core exhibit resistance to bowing or
warping on
heating up to about 50 C and even above. Without wishing to be bound by any
theory it is believed that the rigidity of the foam core to which the vacuum
formed
skin is bonded prevents the bowing of the skin and that the normal expansion
of the
skin due to heat is absorbed in some other manner such as an adjustment of the
- 17-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
thickness of the skin. In any event, bowing can be substantially eliminated in
the
panels of the invention. In the case of a conventional foam core, such as of
foamed
polystyrene, on the other hand, it is believed that the core is insufficiently
strong to
resist the force on the skin which causes the bowing and either the foam is
torn or
else it is distorted, e.g. stretched, by the bowing. It is further considered
that this
inherent weakness of the core is further exacerbated by heat. Thus, as the
temperature to which the skin is exposed is increased, so the ability of the
foam to
resist the bowing force is reduced.
If it is desirable that the doors be resistant to internal movement at higher
temperatures, the foam core can be treated such that it has cured fully prior
to the
formation of the door.
The edges of the door may be left uncovered e.g. to-expose the side faces of
the stiles
and rails where the door contains such frame members, or the edges may be
capped,
e.g. with uPVC cappings which may be bonded to the skins by adhesive or by
heat
sealing, or with extruded metal, e.g. aluminium, sections which may be
attached by
any suitable means such as screws. Alternatively one or both of the skins may
be
formed during the vacuum forming process with lips which cover the edges of
the
door and hence the side faces of any stiles and rails.
The panel is preferably constructed so that it does not require the skills of
a craftsman
to hang in place. Thus, there is provided a weather resistant panel comprising
front
and back faces, top and bottom faces and two side faces wherein each side face
has
a channel extending therealong, each of said channels being sized to receive a
longitudinal cap member.
The channel extending along each side face is preferably of the same width and
depth
and is preferably located centrally in the width of the side of the panel.
Thus, the
two sides of the panel will be the same such that, subject to any design, such
as
panelling, on the faces of the panel, it can be left hand or right hand hung.
-18-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Each channel is preferably of generally rectangular cross-section and the
depth of the
channel may be greater than the depth of a portion of the cap member which
will
extend into the channel. The additional depth is preferably from 2mm to 8mm,
most
preferably 5mm.
One benefit of having this additional depth to the channel is that if when the
panel is
to be hung in place, it is found to be larger than the space available, the
panel can
readily be reduced in size by removing wood from the side faces of the panel
without
affecting the ability of the channel to receive the cap member.
The width of the channel is preferably from 10mm to 40mm, more preferably
30mm.
As has been stated, whatever the width of the channel, the channel is
preferably
located concentric to the side face of the door.
The door may also include channels in at least one of the top and bottom
faces.
These channels are also shaped to receive cap members and are preferably
located
concentric to the face of the door. The top and bottom channels are preferably
of the
same size and configuration.
A longitudinal cap member suitable for insertion in one side channel of the
panel
preferably comprises a pair of upper flanges in a common plane which are
spaced
apart and conjoined by a lower flange located beneath the pair of flanges and
parallel
therewith.
The combined widths of the two upper flanges and the gap between them is
preferably equal to the width of the panel. The widths of the two upper
flanges are
preferably different. The flanges are preferably arranged such that when the
cap is
placed in one side channel of the panel, the lower flange is located in the
channel and
an upper surface thereof is collinear with the upper surface of the walls of
the channel
and the upper flanges extend over the upper edges of the walls of the channel.
This
arrangement means that a leaf of a hinge may be readily recessed in the
finished panel
such that it can be correctly hung in place. In order to locate the hinge, a
section of
-19-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
one of the upper flanges may be removed such that the leaf of the hinge can
lie across
the upper edge of the wall of the channel and across the upper surface of the
lower
flange. The length of the section of the flange removed will depend on the
length of
the hinge.
The two upper flanges may be of different widths. This will enable the same
cap
member to be suitable for use with one of two different sizes of hinge. In the
UK
two standard sizes of hinge are commonly used with household doors, these are
30mm and 35mm. Thus, in a particularly preferred embod'unent of the present
invention the widths of the upper flanges and the spacing between them are
such that
the distance from the outside edge of one flange to the opposed edge of the
gap
between the upper flanges is 30mm and the distance from the outside edge of
the
other flange to the opposed edge of the gap between the upper flanges is 35mm.
Two legs preferably extend downwardly from the flanges and are preferably
located
such that in use they are a sliding fit with the inner walls of the channel in
the door.
They preferably extend downwardly from the flanges for a length that is less
than the
depth of the channel. A foot member may extend inwardly from each leg to form
a
ledge extending along the cap member below the plane of the lower flange. This
ledge enables a plate to be located below the lower flange and spaced
therefrom.
When a hinge has been located on the upper face of the lower flange, it will
be fixed
to the lower flange, preferably by means of at least one screw. If a metal
plate is
located below the lower flange the, or each, screw will extend through the
plate
thereby strengthening the fixing of the hinge to the cap metnber.
As the cap member is separate from the panel, the panel fitter, can place the
cap
member against the panel frame to accurately note the position of the hinge
before
it is fitted to the door. The appropriate portion of one flange can then be
removed
from one of the pair of upper flanges and the hinges connected to the cap
member
before the cap member is inserted into one side channel in the panel. The door
may
then be hung in place in the conventional manner. In one alternative
arrangement,
the cap member having had the hinge members located on its surface may be
-20-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
connected to the door panel via the hinges before it is placed in the channel
of the
panel.
The cap member may be held in place in the channel by any suitable means. In a
preferred embodiment, the cap member will be attached to the panel by means of
screws.
The configuration of the cap member selected for use in the opposing side face
to that
carrying the hinges will depend on the type of locking mechanism to be used.
Suitable locking mechanisms include conventional mortice locks and multi-point
locks
fitted to a groove known as a Eurogroove or any other suitable groove.
A longitudinal cap member suitable for insertion in one side channel of the
panel
preferably comprises a flange, preferably having a width corresponding to the
width
of the panel. This cap member is also suitable for use in the top or bottom
channel
of the panel, where present and is particularly suitable for the top channel.
Two legs preferably extend downwardly from the flange and are preferably
located
such that in use they are a sliding fit with the inner walls of the channel in
the door.
They preferably extend downwardly from the flange for a length that is less
than the
depth of the channel. A foot member may extend inwardly from each leg to form
a
ledge extending along the cap member below the plane of the flange. This ledge
enables a plate to be located below the flange and spaced therefrom. This
plate can
be used to strengthen the attachment of the lock to the cap member.
The cap member may be provided with a plate located on the ledge.
When the panel is to be hung in place, the cap member may be held against the
panel
frame and the position of the lock accurately noted before an appropriate
section is
cut from the cap member. The cap member may then have the lock fitted before
being located in the channel. The cap member will then be placed in the
channel and
may be fastened in place by means of screws, glue or both screws and glue.
-21-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/cB99/00067
The ledges of the above second and third aspects may be located from 0.5mm to
2mm
below the lowest surface of the flanges, preferably 1mm.
A longitudinal cap member suitable for insertion in one side channel of the
panel
preferably comprises a pair of coplanar spaced apart flanges and a trough
member.
This cap member is also suitable for use in the top or bottom channel of the
panel,
where present, and is particularly suitable for the bottom channel. When the
cap
member is used in a side channel of the panel it is suitable for use with a
multi-point
lock. If the cap member is used in the bottom channel of the panel, the trough
member may include a draft excluder, such as a brush or flipper seal.
Where a panel comprises the channel and cap members described above, there is
open
space located around the periphery of the panel. Without wishing to be bound
by any
theory it is believed that the expanding gases which travel through the foam
in the
manner described when the panel is exposed to increased temperature vent into
this
void space and thus pressure at the surface of the door is reduced. Further,
where
the panel is a door, the cap members will include apertures for the hinges and
locks
allowing venting of the gases to air.
In a particularly preferred embodiment of the present invention the panel
comprises
a frame, having channels as described above, a foam core comprising an open
cell
foam of the kind described above and cap members of the kind described above.
Most preferably the panel is a door.
The production of a panel in accordance with the particularly preferred
embodiment
of the present invention will now be described in greater detail with
reference to one
embodiment and with the aid of the accompanying drawings in which:-
Figure 1 is an exploded perspective view of the manufacture of a panel;
Figure 2 is an exploded view of a door and two side cap members and
two portions of a door frame for illustrative purposes;
-22-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Figure 3 is a cross-section of a hinge side cap member located in a
channel;
Figure 4 is a perspective view from above of a hinge side cap member;
Figure 5 is a perspective view from below of a hinge side cap member;
Figure 6 is a cross-section of a lock side (for use with a mortice type
lock) located in a channel - also suitable for use as a top cap
member;
Figure 7 is a perspective view from above of the cap member of Figure
6;
Figure 8 is a perspective view from below of the cap member of Figure
6;
Figure 9 is a cross-section of a lock side (for use with a three-point
lock) located in a channel - also suitable for use as a base cap
member;
Figure 10 is a perspective view from above of the cap member of Figure
9;
Figure 11 is a perspective view from below of the cap member of Figure
9.
Figure 12 is a graph illustrating bow under hygrothermal test on Door 1
for lock and hinge side;
Figure 13 is a graph illustrating bow under hygrothermal test on Door 1
for top and bottom;
-23-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Figure 14 is a graph illustrating bow under hygrothermal test on Door 2
for lock and hinge side;
Figure 15 is a graph illustrating bow under hygrothermal test on Door 2
for top and bottom;
Figure 16 depicts the actual bow measured during phases 1 and 2 test
conditions;
Figure 17 depicts absolute bow measured during phase 2 test conditions;
Figure 18 is a graph of bow of door 1 subjected to 60' C for hinge and
lock side;
Figure 19 is a graph of bow of door 1 subjected to 60' C for top and
bottom;
Figure 20 is a graph of bow of door 2 subjected to 60' C for hinge and
lock side; and
Figure 21 is a graph of bow of door 2 subjected to 60' C for top and
bottom.
A door in accordance with the present invention is formed by first forming the
skins.
Using a suitable mould panel skins 8, 10 are vacuum formed in known manner
from
uPVC sheets to resemble the faces of a conventional six panel door with a wood
grain
effect moulded into the face which is to provide the outer surface of the
skin. The
sheets may be self-coloured in a yellowy brown hue siunilar to oak.
Referring now to Figure 1, one of the skins 8 is placed face down on the
platen 12
of a press, the platen having located thereon a mould jig 14 which matches the
contours of the moulding, and a suitable adhesive, preferably an unsaturated
-24-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
polyester-based adhesive, is applied to the upturned face, which is the rear
face, of
the sheet.
In a separate operation, not illustrated, the components of a softwood frame
16
comprising a pair of vertical stiles 18 and two or three horizontal rails 20
are located
on a support surface and rectangular blocks 22 cut from a pre-formed slab of
open
cell foam, such as filled phenolic foam sold under the trade name ACELL by
Acell
Holdings Limited of appropriate dimensions are fitted to substantially fill
the spaces
between the stiles and rails, the thicknesses of the blocks being
substantially the same
as that of the stiles and rails, and the lengths and widths of the blocks
being such that
they just fill the spaces between the stiles and rails. The whole is then
bonded
together using a suitable adhesive.
This preformed assembly is positioned on the adhesive-coated upturned face of
the
vacuum-formed skin 8.
With the other vacuum formed skin 10 placed face down, its upper, or rear
face, is
coated with the adhesive and the skin is then turned over and located, with
the
adhesive-coated rear face facing downwards, on top of the assembly of stiles,
rails
(which together form the frame) and blocks of the open cell foam. The top
platen 24
of the press, which carries a mould jig 26 which matches the contours of the
moulding on the skin 10, is then lowered on to the assembly and pressure is
applied.
The pressure is such as to cause the foam blocks to be crushed locally between
the
depressed zones of the vacuum formed sheets as these areas are forced into the
foam,
whereby the assembly of blocks 22 and frame members 18,20 is firmly held
between
and in contact with the two skins. At the same time, some of the adhesive
coated on
the face of each of the vacuum formed skins is forced into the surface layers
of the
blocks. The pressure is maintained until the adhesive has cured and set and
the
skins, blocks and frame members are securely bonded together. Suitable
pressures
are of the order of 0.5 to 30 kg/cm2 but it will be understood that as the
depressed
zones of the skins are the first to come into contact with the foam blocks,
the
-25-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
pressures applied locally in the depressed zones and which cause localised
crushing
of the foam are much higher, perhaps of the order of 5 to 100 kg/cm~ or more.
Therefore foams may be used which are crush resistant up to this level of
pressure,
thereby considerably enhancing the impact resistance of the panels.
If desired, several panels may be laminated at the same time by placing the
assemblies one above the other in the press.
Preferably, the assemblies are located within frames during pressing to
prevent any
distortion in a plane perpendicular to the direction of pressure.
After removal of the panel from the press, its surface finish may be improved
by
applying a stain of different colour to the sheet and then removing the stain
from the
high points, e.g. by wiping, so that it is left substantially only in
ingrained areas.
The resultant panel bears an excellent resemblance to a conventional wooden
panel
with close reproduction of the contours of the panelling and a realistic grain
effect.
Despite the open-cell nature of the foam, its insulation properties are about
the same
as those of a conventional PVC panel with a polystyrene foam core. Because a
rigid
foam is used and the foam can substantially completely fill all the voids
between the
frame members, the panel is strong and resistant to warping and its impact
strength
is greater than that of conventional PVC panels with a polystyrene foam core.
The
percolation of the adhesive into the surface layers of the foam ensures an
improved
bond between the core and the skins, thereby reducing risk of delamination.
Absorption of any trapped moisture or solvent into the open-cell foam reduces
the risk
of localised build-up of pressure and concomitant bubbling or failure of the
adhesive
bond.
The use of a filled phenolic foam such as the foam available from Acell
Holdings
Limited in the core endows the panel not only with a substantial resistance to
distortion, especially bowing, when exposed to temperature changes but also
with a
very desirable combination of flame resistance, heat and sound insulation,
impact
-26-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
strength, rigidity and resistance to flexure.
Preferably the door includes the above-described system to facilitate sizing
and fitting
of the panel. If this system is to be utilised, as illustrated in Figure 2,
the finished
door comprises a door 1 having side channels, not shown, and side cap members
2
and 3 . When hanging the door the cap members are placed against the door
frame
4a and 4b. The position of the hinges 5 is noted and the cap member 2 is cut
to
allow the leaf of the hinges to be recessed in the cap member. The cap member
2
may be fastened to the door frame 4a before the cap member is placed in the
channel
in the door 1. The position of the lock is noted and the cap member 3 is cut
to allow
the locks to be placed therethrough. Figure 2 illustrates a cap member for use
with
a multi-point lock and thus three sections are preferably removed.
The configuration of a suitable cap member for use with hinges is illustrated
in
Figures 3, 4 and 5. The cap member comprises a pair of upper flanges 21 and 22
in a common plane which are spaced apart and conjoined by a lower flange
231ocated
beneath the pair of flanges 21 and 22 and parallel therewith.
The combined widths of the two upper flanges 21 and 22 and the gap 24 between
them is equal to the width of the door. The widths of the two upper flanges
are
different. The flanges are arranged such that when the cap is placed in one
side
channel of the door, the lower flange is located in the channel and an upper
surface
thereof is co-linear with the upper surface of the walls 11 and 12 of the
channel 13
and the upper flanges 21 and 22 extend over the upper edges of the walls of
the
channel. This arrangement means that a leaf of a hinge may be readily recessed
in
the finished door such that it can be correctly hung in place. In order to
locate the
hinge, a section of one of the upper flanges may be removed such that the leaf
of the
hinge can lie across the upper edge of the wall of the channel and across the
upper
surface of the lower flange.
The two upper flanges 21 and 22 are of different widths. Thus the same cap
member
is suitable for use with both 30mm and 35mm hinges.
-27-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Two legs 25 and 26 extend downwardly from the flanges and are located such
that
in'use they are a sliding fit with the inner walls of the channel in the door.
They
extend downwardly from the flanges for a length that is less than the depth of
the
channel. A foot member may extend inwardly from each leg to form a ledge 27
extending along the cap member below the plane of the lower flange 23. This
ledge
27 enables a plate to be located below the lower flange and spaced therefrom
and may
be used for fixing the hinge plate prior to fitting the cap member in the
groove.
The configuration of a suitable cap member for use with a mortice is
illustrated in
Figures 6, 7 and 8. The cap member comprises a flange 31 having a width
corresponding to the width of the door.
Two legs 32 and 33 extend downwardly from the flange 31 and are preferably
located
such that in use they are a sliding fit with the inner walls of the channel 13
in the
door 1. They preferably extend downwardly from the flange for a length that is
less
than the depth of the channel. A foot member extends inwardly from each leg to
form a ledge 27 extending along the cap member below the plane of the flange
31.
This ledge enables a plate to be located below the flange and spaced
therefrom. This
plate can be used to strengthen the attachment of the lock to the cap member
and may
be used for fixing the lock prior to fitting the cap member in the groove.
A cap member for insertion in one side channel of the door for use with a
Eurolock
is illustrated in Figures 9, 10 and 11. The cap member comprises a pair of
coplanar
spaced apart flanges 34 and 35 and a trough member 36.
The channel in the external perimeter of the frame may be formed before or
after the
final panel has been constructed. The panel may also be produced at one size
and
then cut after being formed to the particular requirements. Thus where the
panel is
a door, the panels may be formed of a standard size and then machined to fit
particular door frame apertures.
While the invention has been described with reference to the production of a
solid
-28-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
panelled panel, it will be understood that apertures may be provided if
desired, e.g.
for glazing.
When a panel of this kind is exposed to changes in temperature and in
particular to
the application of heat on one side, it would be expected that the skin would
exhibit
bowing. In prior art arrangements, for example, one would expect bowing in the
region of 12nun or the like. In contrast, with a panel of the present
invention,
bowing is not detected at all or only a bow of 1-2 mm at temperatures in the
order
of 50 C.
Tests have been carried out to consider the effect on the door of higher
temperatures.
In these tests, the samples are placed in an oven for one hour at 80 C and
then for
two hours at 70-73 C. The results obtained are set out in Table 1.
-29-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
bR
4 0 0
bR
~3 4 c o
~ bR 00
ri
a: 4 c o
=~ .~
a 4 ~c r
....
00 o =~
=d ~ .=.
3 eq v V
M
00
E"
V
~ .=,
E ~ ~.. af ~ 1 v1 N
=y p~q : 1=~, ,~
V
c
0
~
~ o
w
v ~+
i-.
=3 ... .o ~n ~n .r
>, = -~ X3 ..
40.
v .O V=f ~f1 yyN ~
~ Il II
_ ~=+
y ta0 .+ 00 ~ .~
a ~ .G O =-= w
O
+
a a =~
-30-
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
A six-panel door according to the invention and made from vacuum-formed uPVC
skins, a softwood frame and blocks of ACELL foam in the manner described above
with reference to Figure 1, was tested in accordance with test BS476 Part
22;1987
The specimen tested was a fully insulated single acting single leaf doorset.
The
subject was mounted into a masonry wall and oriented such that it opens
towards heat
provided by a furnace. The dimension of the doorset under test was 2072 mm
high
by 893 mm wide. At its thinnest point (centre of the panels) the door was 13mm
thick. After 40 minutes the mean temperature of the door surface away from the
heat
source was 90 C while that of the door surface exposed to the heat source was
900 C.
After 15 mins exposure the maximum deflection was only 5mm towards the
furnace.
Further tests were conducted on two door sets formed as described above. The
test
procedures used are set out as Test 10 and Test 11 in BS DD 171:1987. A new
European standard was being drafted at the time of the tests (prEN1121). -
Whilst test
procedures and limiting value of bow had not been finalised, reference is made
to the
new standard and the doors were classified according to the proposed limiting
values
for bow.
The dimensions of the door leaves were 800mm x 1970mm and they were mounted
in frames. The doors were of similar construction and were fully furnished.
The experimental equipment comprised two climatic chambers separated by an
insulated partition. Each chamber incorporated air conditioning equipment
which
allowed the simulation of internal and external climates. One chamber was as
the
"external chamber" (where Ea = initial equilibrium conditions, Eb = test
conditions
and Ec = higher thermal temperature) and the other as the "internal chamber"
(where
Ia = initial equilibrium conditions, lb = test conditions and Ic = higher
thermal
temperature). Both chambers have dual controls for humidity and temperature.
The
pre-set values were as set out in Table 2 below.
-31-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Table 2
Hygrothermal test
External chamber Ea : 25'C/609b rh (relative humidity)
Eb : 5' C/85 k rh
Internal chamber Ia : 25' C/60 % rh
lb : 28' C/40 % rh
Thermal test
External chamber Ea : 28' C
Eb : 40' C (hot) -10' C (cold)
Ec : 50' C and 60' C
Internal chamber Ia : 28' C
lb : 28'C
Ic : 28' C
The doors sets were mounted in the dividing partition between the two chambers
with
the external face of each door facing into the external chamber. A mounting
system
securely fixed each door frame into the partition.
Distortion of the door styles, the opening lock side and the hinge side, was
measured
with a movement bridge. This consisted of a aluminium beam 1950mm long with a
dial gauge mounted at its centre. The beam had a blunt knife edge bearing foot
at
one end and spherical bearing foot at the other. The bridge was attached to
and held
against each door style by springs. This ensured that the same pressure was
always
exerted through the bearing feet on the door styles, thus ensuring consistent
measurement of distortion. Bow at lateral positions on each door leaf (top and
bottom) was measured in a similar way with a 685 mm bridge and this, due to
its
shorter length was held by hand against the door, but always supported in the
same
position on long screws.
-32-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
The test was carried out in accordance with Test 1 0 and Test 1 1 of DD171
1987
which were designed for door leaves. However, it is now recognised that it is
more
meaningful to test door sets fully furnished and finished to simulate the in-
use of the
doors more accurately. A new European test procedure recognises this, but it
is still
only in draft. In the absence of a complete documented European test the DD171
test
procedure was used on the door sets rather than just on door leaves.
Hygrothermal test
The experimental procedure was carried out in 3 phases as follows:
Phase 1 - Equilibrium conditions
The test procedure commenced by opening the chambers to each other with the
air
conditions held at 25'C/60% rh (Ea and Ia) as set out above. These conditions
were
maintained until both door leaves reached equilibrium and showed no movement
of
greater that 0.05mm per day.
After the door sets reached equilibrium and immediately before the external
and
internal climates were applied, the bow of the lock side, hinge side, top and
bottom
of each door was determined with the measuring bridges. The measurements were
taken on the internal side with the door leaves slightly open.
Phase 2 - Dual test conditions
The chambers were then isolated from each other and the differential climates
(Eb
and Ib) set out above were applied. The bow of each style caused by the
differential
conditions was measured at daily intervals. The differential climate was
maintained
and measurements continued until the movement was less than 0.05 mm increase
in
bow per day.
As in phase 1 the distortion (bow) measurements were taken on the internal
side with
doors slightly open.
-33-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Phase 3 - Equilibrium conditions
After the completion of the test in the dual conditions (phase 2) the chambers
were
once again opened to each other with the air conditions held at 25' C/60% rh
(Ea and
Ia) as in phase 1. Bow was once again measured.
Thermal test
The experimental procedure, as specified by DD171, was carried out in 3
phases.
Extra test phases were included, in addition to those set out in DD171, in
order to
carry out an assessment on the doors at higher temperatures than directed by
the
standard. The procedure was as follows :
Phase 1 Equilibrium conditions
Both chambers were held at 28' C for 20 hours.
Phase 2 Test conditions
Stage 1 The internal chamber was held at 28' C while the temperature
of the external chamber was increased to 40' C and held at this
increased temperature for 5 hours.
Stage 2 The internal chamber was held at 28' C while the temperature
of the external chamber was decreased to -10' C and held at
this lower temperature for 20 hours.
Phase 3 Test conditions
The internal chamber was held at 28' C while the temperature of the
external chamber was increased to 50' C and held at this increased
temperature for 7 hours. Then the doors were once again equilibrated
before the external sides were heated to 60' C and held at this
temperature for 7 hours.
Phase 4 Test conditions
In separate tests, the temperature of the external chamber was
-34-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
increased to 70 C and 80 C, respectively.
Distortion (bow) of each door was measured at the end of each phase. The
measurements were taken on the internal side with the door slightly open. From
these readings the average bow for the style and rail positions were
calculated. In
addition to this, the overall bow (the difference between the hot and cold
external
face), the bow due to heating (the difference between equilibrium and hot
external
face), and the bow due to cooling the external face (the difference between
equilibrium and cold external face) were also calculated.
RESULTS
Hygrothermal test
The alteration of bow values for each test phase is presented in Figures 12 -
15. Bow
values for the vertical sides (lock and hinge sides), are shown in Figures 12
and 14,
and for the top and bottom of each door, Figures 13 and 15. A summary of bow
values is shown in Table 3.
Thermal test
The results are presented in Figures 16 - 21, they indicate changes of bow for
each
test phase. Figures 16 and 17 concern the DD171 test and Figures 18 - 21 plot
the
bow movement of the doors when they were subjected to a higher temperature
(60' C)
than that required by DD171.
The maximum bow values are summarised in Tables 4 and 5.
Figures 22 to 25 record changes of bow when the doors were exposed to the
still
higher temperatures of 70 C and 80 C respectively.
DISCUSSION
Hygrothermal test:
Phase 1
Both doors exhibited some bow at the start of the equilibrium test phase 1,
but there
-35-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
was little change during the short duration of the phase. This was probably
due to
the doors being stored in similar conditions before testing. Door 1 bowed very
little
whereas the hinge side of door 2 exhibited nearly 2 mm of bow.
Phase 2
When the dual conditions were set the lock and hinge vertical sides of each
door
initially bowed towards the positive (convexed) direction when viewed from the
internal side of the doors. After this initial deviation the lock side of each
door
straightened and then exhibiting bow in the negative (concave) direction. In
the case
of the hinge side of both doors the bow deviation continued in the same
direction as
the initial bow. Door 1 remained convexed, bow in the positive direction, and
Door
2 exhibited bow in the same direction, but because the bow at the start of
phase 2 was
-2mm the effect of the continuing bow deviation was to straighten the door.
Although
starting from a slightly different initial bow the movement of the doors was
almost
identical for both the two lock side and the two hinged sides. The bow at the
top and
bottom of each door followed a similar pattern to the lock vertical sides, but
was very
small.
At the end of the dual condition phase of the hygrothermal test the lock side
of both
doors exhibited very little bow. In the case of the two doors under test the
bow at
the hinged side was higher than that exhibited on the lock side. However, in
both
cases the bow was visibly insignificant.
Phase 3
At the end of the dual conditions phase of the test, equilibrium conditions
were once
again set. This caused an immediate bow in the concave (negative) direction
for both
doors. In both cases the hinge sides ahnost returned to their previous
equilibrium
bow of phase 1. However, in phase 3, the lock sides exhibited the greatest bow
deviation of the complete test, about 2 mm, but this decreased in a few hours
to a
maximum of about 1.5 mm.
-36-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Phase 4 (Tests at 70 and 80 C)
Bow after 5 hours in less than 1.5mm in all cases.
Conformance to DD171
For both doors the bow movement was well below the maximum allowable value of
10mm.
Conformance with draft European standard (prEN 11 21)
This draft new standard has 4 classifications from Class 0 through to Class 3.
The
maximum bow allowed in the classes is: no requirement, 8 mm, 4 mm and 2 mm
respectively. The maximum bow is specified as the difference between the
initial and
final value or the actual final bow which ever is the greatest. This
effectively means
that the initial bow before the differential climates are set, is included in
the
maximum bow criteria. The test procedure is still in draft, but it is likely
to suggest
similar dual conditions for external doors as in DD171. However, in the draft
prEN
standard a phase 3 stage is not specified. On this basis we can consider the
bow
deviation at the end of phase 2 in the procedure used and comfortably assign
the
classifications of prENI121. These are based
on bow occurring on the lock side, according to the requirements set out in
the
European draft, and are as follows
Door 1 is Class 3 (highest level of performance)
Door 2 is Class 3
Thermal DD171 test
Phase 1
When the doors were at equilibrium at 28' C(end of phase 1) they all exhibited
some
bow along the two longitudinal edges (lock side and hinge side) and on the two
transverse edges (top and bottom). The results, Figures 12 and 13, indicate
the
direction and value of the bow distortion for each edge of each door and in
general
the values were small. The lock side bow of both doors was similar in the
concave
-37-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
(negative) direction when viewed from the internal side of the doors. As in
the
hygrothermal test the bow for the hinge side of door 2 was about -2 mm.
Phase 2 / Stage 1
After the differential conditions of Phase 2 / Stage 1 were applied (28' C/
40' C) the
distortion of each door decreased or remained at very low levels of bow in the
concave (negative) direction. This was a similar trend as observed for
composite
GRP faced doors.
Phase 2 / Stage 2
The differential conditions of Phase 2/ Stage 2(2$' C/-10' C) caused, in
general,
bow distortion in the opposite direction, convexed (positive), to that of
stage 1. This
for all the measurement positions of both door leaves was greater than
measured at
stage 1, considerably so for the two longitudinal edges and the greatest bow
was
exhibited along the lock sides. Again, this is typical for a composite door
and in the
past has been observed for GRP skinned doors.
Conformance to DD171
For both doors the bow movement was visually insignificant and well below the
maximum allowable value of 10 mm.
Conformance with draft European standard (prEN 1121)
Classifications can be assigned, based on bow occurring on the lock side,
according
to the requirements set out in the European draft prEN 1121 as follows :
Considering bow caused by heating and cooling -
Door 1 is Class 2
Door 2 is Class 2
Considering bow caused only by heating -
Door 1 is Class 3 (the best classification)
Door 2 is Class 3
-38-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Extra thermal test (Phase 3) 50' C and 60' C
Both doors were tested at higher temperature on the external side than
specified in
DD 171 and extra bow from the equilibrium conditions was small and visually
insignificant for both doors. The fmal values are shown in Table 3. The value
for
the hinged side of door 2 is higher than other values due to the relatively
high initial
bow which could have occurred during manufacture. Even for this side of door
2,
the actual bow deviation after equilibrium condition and during dual
conditions was
very small. However, it should be noted that there is a sharp increm in bow
movement between the external temperatures of 50' C and 60' C.
The extra test was nearer to the conditions specified in the new European
standard,
prEN1121, than thermal test of DD171. Therefore, considering conformance with
the new standard based on bow occurring on the lock side, the following
classifications can be assigned:
Door 1 is Class 3 (the best classification)
Door 2 is Class 3
CONCLUSIONS
The performance of both the doors fully satisfied the limiting values for test
DD 171:1987 Test 10 (Hygrothermal distortion) and Test 11 (Thermal
distortion).
The new European standard (prEN1121) is only in draft form, but it is likely
that the
classification assigned to the doors, considering only the hot external
temperature,
would be Class 3 (Class 3 being the highest level of performance). If the
cooling
phase of the current test procedure is considered, the classification of the
doors would
be Class 2.
-39-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Table 3 Snmmary of bow measurements
Door Side Initial Bow at Max Bow at Initial Bow at
bow end of bow in end of bow in end of
(mm) phase 1 phase 2 phase 2 phase 3 phase 3
(mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (MM)
1 Hinge 0.04 -0.13 1.18 1.16 0.19 0.52
Lock -.059 -0.65 0.43 -0.6 -2.01 -1.45
Top 0.35 0.32 0.42 0.26 0.03 0.12
Bottom 0.33 0.31 0.64 0.34 0.01 0.1
2 Hinge -1.92 -1.93 -1.16 -1.16 -1.6 -1.62
Lock -0.55 -0.59 0.39 -0.28 -1.56 -0.95
Top -0.02 -0.08 0.1 -0.1 -0.32 -0.26
Bottom 0.14 -0.11 0.38 0.16 -0.08 -0.07
Looking from the internal side +ve (positive) = Convexed
-ve (negative) = Concave
-40-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Table 4 Change in average bow during test (mm)
Type of Bow Door 1- Door 1- Door 2- Door 2-
Longitudinal Transverse Longitudinal Transverse
Initial bow -0.310 0.240 -1.455 -0.090
Bow after 2.295 0.445 1.725 0.475
treatment
Overall Bow 2.605 0.205 3.180 0.565
Bow due to 0.010 -0.365 0.945. 0.010
heating
Bow due to 2.595 0.570 1.875 0.555
cooling
-41-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
N S o O O
~
g ~ O O ~
m O O 9
o
8 p" O O
A E-~G O GO Q
b
.-. N =y p p O
~. ,y4 M
g N M
A O O Oi
pp p~ N
'O
8 Q 00 M
M M
9 9 9
0 0 0
~o ~
1-i V1 tn M
Av E-+ 9 9
W Q O M M =-+
~
~ =y
A ~ o 0 0
rl y
0 0
G. =~ cq
~
U-
F h
-42-
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (RULE 26)
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
Further tests were carried out on doors made in accordance with the invention
and
comprising:
Two vacuum formed PVC sheets of 1.5nun thiclmess at 20 C
A foam core supplied by Acell Doors
A Foaming PU adhesive
A laminated timber frame
The dimensions of the door at 20' C were 2m high x lm wide.
In repeated tests, bowing of the order of less than 3mm at 60 C was noted.
However, PVC door sheets are known to expand 1 mm over a 1 m length for each
10' C increase in temperature. If it is assumed that "triangular" expansion
occurs
rather than parabolic, a PVC sheet 3 metres in length constrained at top and
bottom
would be expected to bow by approximately 89.5 mm, In a panel such as a door,
the
sheet is constrained at all four sides and a bow of the order of 90 mm would
be
expected.
Without wishing to be bound by any theory, it is known that PVC creeps as
temperature increases. It is believed that in the arrangement of the present
invention,
where the skins are adhered to the foam core by a glue, preferably a
polyurethane
glue, creep occurs towards the centre of the door and thus a 40' C rise in
temperature
would only increase the thickness by about 1 q6 averaged over the whole cell.
For comparison, doors containing other foams (ie not open cell rigid foams)
were
subjected to the test and bowing of the order of 10mm was noted. Thus the
general
structure offers an improvement over prior art doors but a particularly
preferred door
can be obtained by using filled phenolic foam and most particularly that
produced by
effecting a curing reaction between:
(a) a liquid phenolic resole having a reactivity number (as herein defined)
of at least 1 and
(b) a strong acid hardener for the resole,
-43-
CA 02318510 2000-07-07
WO 99/35364 PCT/GB99/00067
in the presence of:
(c) a fmely divided inert and insoluble particulate solid which is present
in an amount of at least 5;6 by weight of the liquid resole and is
substantially uniformly dispersed through the mixture containing resole
and hardener;
the temperature of the mixture containing resole and hardener due to applied
heat not
-exceeding 85 C and the said temperature and the concentration of the acid
hardener
being such that compounds generated as by-products of the curing reaction are
volatilised within the mixture before the mixture sets whereby a foamed
phenolic
resin product is produced.
Again without wishing to be bound by any theory, the composite nature of the
door,
in particular its frangible open cell foam core, enables creep and recovery
without
destroying the bond between the skin and the foam core. Further, free venting
through the open cells and orifices cut in the wood frame prevent a build up
in
pressure. This has been demonstrated by repeated cyclical test. In particular
it is
noted that bowing peaks at a temperature below 60' C and then recovers as
temperature-induced creep increases.
-44-
