Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
DESCRIPTION
Ceramic Honeycomb Structure
Technical Field
The present invention relates to a ceramic honeycomb
structure. More particularly, the present invention relates
to a ceramic honeycomb structure capable of balancing the
disadvantages incurred by the increased pressure loss and
the decreased thermal shock resistance against the
advantages brought about by the increased isostatic strength
and the cell wall shape and honeycomb external shape of
higher accuracy, and which is suitably used, for example, as
a carrier for catalyst for automobile exhaust gas
purification. The ceramic honeycomb structure of the
present invention is also used suitably as a filter for
diesel particulates or the like, as a chemical reactor (e. g.
a catalyst carrier for fuel cell reformer), or as a heat
exchanger.
Background Art
As catalysts for purification of automobile exhaust
gas, there are used so-called honeycomb catalysts wherein a
catalyst component is loaded on the surfaces of the cell
walls of a ceramic honeycomb carrier (honeycomb structure).
In these catalysts, since the axial direction strength of
the honeycomb carrier is higher than its strength in the
1
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
sectional (diameter) direction, the honeycomb carrier was
held in the axial direction. In this holding manner, in
order to prevent the breakage of the honeycomb carrier
occurring at around the periphery of its ends in axial
direction holding, the thickness of the cell walls (ribs)
near the circumference of the honeycomb carrier was made
larger than the thickness of the cell walls in the inner
portion of the honeycomb carrier to increase the anti-
pressure strength of the honeycomb carrier in the axial
direction.
Recently, however, the higher output adopted in
engines has required a lower pressure loss of honeycomb
catalyst and the stricter regulation employed for exhaust
gas has needed the effective utilization of whole catalyst
carrier; therefore, it has been started to hold the
honeycomb carrier mainly at its outer surface, in place of
holding in the axial direction. Another reason for this is
that the stricter regulation for exhaust gas has invited a
larger catalyst volume and an increased catalyst mass and,
as a result, the holding in the axial direction has become
unable to give a sufficient holding area and promise
sufficient holding relative to engine vibration.
Meanwhile, in order to enhance the purification
ability of catalyst, it has been started to make thinner the
thickness of the cell walls of a honeycomb carrier and
decrease the weight of the honeycomb carrier and thereby
reduce the heat capacity of a catalyst and enhance its
2
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
purification ability (warm-up property).
The above use of cell walls of thinner thickness tends
to result in a lower fracture strength against the external
pressure which the honeycomb carrier receives at the outer
surf ace .
In order to meet the recent even stricter regulation
for exhaust gas, it has been aimed to improve the conditions
of engine combustion and the purification ability of
catalyst. As a result, the temperature of exhaust gas has
become higher year by year and the thermal shock resistance
required for a honeycomb carrier has become stricter.
Thus, due to the thinning of the cell walls, the
employment of holding honeycomb carrier at the outer surface,
the increase in temperature of exhaust gas and the like, the
setting of cell wall thickness and honeycomb outer wall
thickness, the increase in the isostatic strength of
honeycomb structure, and the higher accuracies of honeycomb
external shape and cell wall shape have become important
tasks to be achieved.
In connection with the above, there was proposed, in
JP-A-54-110189, a honeycomb carrier structure whose cell
walls are made thinner at a given ratio from the outermost
peripheral cell wall towards the center of the cross-section.
In this structure, since use of a thin wall in the entire
honeycomb carrier is impossible, the total mass of the
honeycomb carrier is inevitably large, posing a problem in
the warm-up property of the honeycomb carrier. This
3
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
structure is undesirable also in pressure loss.
There was also proposed, in JP-A-54-150406 and JP-A-
55-147154, a structure wherein the walls of the cells near
the circumference of the structure are made thicker than
those of the inner cells. However, no mention is made on
the thickness of the outer wall or on the specific relation
between different cell wall thickness therein.
In these honeycomb structures of the prior art, since
the thickness of inner cell walls is as large as 0.15 mm or
more and the holding is made in the axial direction, the
thickness of the honeycomb outer wall was not a problem.
One may merely point out that too large an outer wall
thickness gives a low thermal shock resistance, if forced to
do so.
Further in WO 98/05602 was proposed a ceramic
honeycomb structure wherein the average cell wall thickness
T is 0.05 to 0.13 mm, the average outer wall thickness is
larger than T, W>T (W is an average width of contact between
cell wall and outer wall), and 0.7 ~ -(T/4) + 0.18.
This ceramic honeycomb structure exhibits some effect
in prevention of peripheral chipping during handling;
however, it was not fully satisfactory in increased pressure
loss, reduced thermal shock resistance, increase in
isostatic strength, and the improvements in the accuracies
of cell wall shape and honeycomb structure external shape.
No in-depth investigation has hitherto been made
particularly on the improvements in the accuracies of cell
4
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
wall shape and honeycomb structure external shape. That is,
a ceramic honeycomb structure is generally molded by
extruding, for example, a cordierite raw material for
ceramic through a die having lattice-shaped slits; then
dried; and fired to become a product. When a smaller cell
wall thickness is employed, the cell walls tend to deform
during molding, owing to the cause mentioned later and
resultantly the fired material obtained showed no
satisfactory isostatic strength while this did not happen
when the cell wall thickness was as large as 0.15 mm or more.
Nevertheless, no sufficient investigation has been made.
The deformed cell walls axe destroyed at the deformed sites
by a small force. That is, when cell walls do not deform
and are molded at a high accuracy, they theoretically become
sites of compression stress when a pressure is applied to
the outer surface of honeycomb structure, and the
destruction of honeycomb structure takes place owing to the
buckling of cell wall or outer wall. Meanwhile, when cell
walls have deformed, a bending stress (a stress in tensile
direction) is generated at the deformed sites, resulting in
easy destruction. In general, materials are less resistant
to tensile strength than to compression stress and, in
ceramic materials, in particular, the ratio (about 1/10) of
tensile strength to compression strength is very small as
compared with that (about 1/3) of metal materials.
Therefore, when there is deformation of cell walls,
destruction takes place at a strength considerabllr lower
5
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
than a strength at which destruction takes place ordinarily.
The present invention has bee made in view of the
above problems, and aims at providing a ceramic honeycomb
structure capable of balancing the disadvantages incurred by
the increased pressure loss and the decreased thermal shock
resistance against the advantages brought about by the
increased isostatic strength and the cell wall shape and
honeycomb external shape of higher accuracy, and which is
suitable particularly as, for example, a carrier for
catalyst for automobile exhaust gas purification.
Disclosure of the Invention
In order to achieve the above object, the present
inventor made a study including various tests mentioned
later, with considering the thinner cell walls recently
employed in honeycomb carriers. As a result, the following
was found out. That is, the adoption of a thick wall only
in the cells near the circumference of honeycomb structure
as seen in the prior art is insufficient and attention must
be paid also to the extrudability of honeycomb structure;
therefore, the designing of a honeycomb structure need be
made while paying attention not only to the relation between
the wall thickness of each outermost peripheral cell and the
wall thickness of inner cells (basic cells), i.e. the basic
cell wall thickness, but also, while considering the basic
cell wall thickness and the thickness of honeycomb outer
wall, to the relation between the basic cell wall thickness
6
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
and the wall thickness of the cells existing between the
outermost peripheral cell taken as starting cell and any
cell taken as end cell of a certain number of cells
extending inwardly from the starting cell and located near
the circumference of honeycomb structure: by making the
designing of a honeycomb structure as above, the above-
mentioned aim of the present invention can be achieved. The
present invention has been completed based on the above
finding .
It has heretofore been believed that a honeycomb
structure having a high strength against a pressure applied
to the outer surface can be obtained by allowing the
honeycomb structure to have an increased outer wall
thickness. There were produced cordierite-made thin wall
honeycomb structure samples having an outer diameter of 90
mm, a length of 110 mm, a square cell shape, a cell wall
thickness of 0.11 mm and a cell density of 9.3x105 cells/m2
(wall-to-wall distance: 1.04 mm), with varying the outer
wall thickness between 0.1 and 0.9 mm; and they were
measured for isostatic strength and the results are shown in
Fig. 5. As shown in Fig. 5, the isostatic strength showed
no increase and reversely decreased, even if the outer wall
thickness was made thicker than 0.4 mm.
The reason for the fact that mere increase in outer
wall thickness gives no increase in isostatic strength, is
considered to be that as the outer wall thickness is
increased, the amount of shape deformation of the wall (rib)
7
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
of the cells near the circumference of honeycomb structure
increases and moreover the number of the deformed walls
increases. This is considered to be because as the outer
wall thickness is increased, the amount of the raw material
passing, during extrusion molding, through the die slit for
outer wall formation increases and, as a result, the ribs of
the cells near the circumference of honeycomb structure are
dragged toward the outer wall and the raw material flow in
outer wall and the raw material flow in ribs become
unbalanced. The main reasons therefor are considered to be
that the change of ribs to smaller thickness incurs easy
buckling deformation and that, when the honeycomb structure
after extrusion molding is fixed by a jig at the outer
surface, the honeycomb structure per se deforms owing to the
own weight and, as a result, deformation of the outer wall
and the inside ribs, particularly the ribs near the
circumference of honeycomb structure takes place. This
tendency is considered to be higher as the ribs are thinner
and the structure is bigger.
According to strength of materials, buckling strength
is basically proportional to the square of cell wall (rib)
thickness, as shown by the following formula. It is
appreciated from the formula that the thickness of cell wall
has a great influence on the strength of honeycomb carrier.
Buckling strength = (k nZE) x (t/L)2
wherein k is a coefficient, E is a Young s modulus, L is a
cell wall length, and t is a cell wall thickness.
8
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
Also, there was conducted a test for thermal shock
resistance in supercooling, wherein a honeycomb carrier
having a cell wall thickness of 0.11 mm was heated in an
electric furnace for a given length of time to make the
temperature uniform and then taken out from the furnace.
The results are shown in Fig. 6. As the outer wall
thickness of the honeycomb carrier was increased, the
thermal shock resistance decreased and the decrease was
larger when the outer wall thickness was 0.7 mm or more.
This is considered to be that as the outer wall is thicker,
the outer wall per se has a larger heat capacity and the
temperature difference between inside and outside the outer
wall is bigger.
For lowering the heat capacity of outer wall, there is
an idea of forming notches in the outer wall, as seen in the
above-mentioned JP-A-54-150406. This idea has a meaning if
the outer wall is sufficiently thick; however, when the cell
wall thickness is very thin (1.12 mm or less), the outer
wall cannot be freely made thicker as mentioned previously
and resultantly the effect of notches is small. Conversely,
there is a risk of decreasing the rigidity of the outer wall.
Also, strength was measured in honeycomb carriers
wherein the wall thickness in the cells near the
circumference of the carriers were made larger than the
inner cell (basic cell) wall thickness as in the prior art.
As a result, there was certainly an increase in strength;
however, as the wall thickness in the cells near the
9
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
circumference of the carriers was too large, the strength
tended to decrease. Inspection of a carrier having a
considerably large wall thickness in the outermost
peripheral cell indicated that the cell wall of the
outermost peripheral cell had deformation. The reason is
considered to be the same as the reason for the above-
mentioned fact that mere increase in outer wall thickness
gives no increase in isostatic strength. As in the case of
mere increase in outer wall thickness, mere increase in the
wall thickness in the cells near the circumference of
carrier does not necessarily contribute to the increase in
isostatic strength.
Fig. 7 shows the results obtained when each cell wall
thickness of the cells existing between each outermost
peripheral cell taken as a starting cell and any cell of the
2nd to 20th cells extending inwardly from the starting cell
was increased from the basic cell wall thickness (75 Eun) to
100 dun, 150 Eun or 200 dun and each of the resulting honeycomb
structures was measured for isostatic strength (~). As can
be taken from Fig. 7, the degree of increase in isostatic
strength was low when the wall thickness of the first to 4th
cells was made larger; a striking increase in isostatic
strength was seen when the wall thickness of each cell from
any of the 5th to 15th cells was made larger; and there was
observed the settlement in the degree of increase in
isostatic strength even if the wall thickness of the 5th to
20th cells was made larger. No increase in isostatic
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
strength was seen when the wall thickness of the 1st to 2nd
cells was made larger; however, a sign of increase was seen
when the wall thickness of the 1st to 3rd or 4th cells was
made larger; and a clear increase was seen when the wall
thickness of 5th or later cells was made larger.
Strength measurement was~also made by changing the
dimension of external shape of honeycomb structure. In a
honeycomb structure having a circular section of 144 mm or
more in diameter or having an elliptical section having the
same sectional area as the circular section, an increase in
strength was seen when the wall thickness of each cell of
the 10th to 30th cells was made larger; and there was
observed in a similar tendency to that mentioned above in
the degree of increase in strength when the wall thickness
of the 10th to 40th cells was made larger. (This was the
same tendency as seen above.)
Fig. 8 shows the results obtained when each cell wall
thickness (Trl~Trl3) of the outermost peripheral cell, taken
as a staring cell to the 13th cell was made larger one by
one than the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a
ratio of 1. 00 to 3 . 00 in terms of [ ( Trl-Trl3 ) / ( Tc ) ] and
measurement of isostatic strength (%) was made. As seen
from Fig. 8, a sharp increase in isostatic strength was seen
from when the ratio of said each cell wall thickness to
basic cell wall thickness, i.e. [(Trl-Trl3)/(Tc)] was 1.10;
and the degree of the increase settled when the
[ ( Trl-Trl3 ) / ( Tc ) ] was 2 . 5 .
11
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
Fig. 9 is a partly enlarged view of Fig. 8. As seen
from Fig. 9, since the sharp increase in isostatic strength
lasts to [(Trl~Trl3)/(Tc)] - 1.20, it is preferred to adopt a
[ ( Trl-Trl3 ) / ( Tc ) ] of 1. 2 0 or more .
Fig. 10 shows the results obtained when each cell wall
thickness ( Trl-Trl3 ) of the 1st ce~.l ( taken as staring cell )
to the 13th cell was made larger one by one than the basic
cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a ratio of 1.00 to
3.00 in terms of [(Trl-Trl3)/(Tc)] and measurement of
pressure loss (%) was made. As seen from Fig. 10, a sharp
increase was seen from when the [(Trl-Trl3)/(Tc)] was 3.00;
therefore, it is preferred to adopt ordinarily a
[(Trl-Trl3)/(Tc)] of 3.00 or less and, from practical
viewpoints, a [(Trl~Trl3)/(Tc)] of 2.50 or less, preferably
1.60 or less.
Fig. 11 shows the results obtained when each cell wall
thickness (Trl--TrlS) of the outermost peripheral cell taken
as a staring cell to the 15th cell was made thicker than the
basic cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a ratio of 2.0
in terms of [(Trl-Trls)/(Tc)] and measurement of pressure
loss (%) was made (case 1); when, in addition to the
conditions of the case 1, each cell wall of the 16th to 20th
cells was allowed to have a sectional shape of an inverse
trapezoid (the minor base was present inwardly), the
thickness of said each cell wall was made thinner as said
each cell wall was located more inwardly, and the thinnest
wall thickness was made identical to the basic cell wall
12
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
thickness (Tc) (case 2): when, in addition to the conditions
of the case 1, each cell wall of the 16th to 20th cells was
allowed to have a sectional shape of a spool, the thickness
of said each cell wall was made thinner as said each cell
wall was located more inwardly, and the thinnest wall
thickness was made identical to the basic cell wall
thickness (Tc) (case 3); when the ratio of the outermost
peripheral cell wall thickness (Trl) to the basic cell wall
thickness (Tc) was set at 2.0, each cell wall of the 2nd and
later cells was allowed to have a sectional shape of an
inverse trapezoid (the minor base was present inwardly), the
thickness of said each cell wall was made thinner as said
each cell wall was located more inwardly, the smallest wall
thickness was made identical to the basic cell wall
thickness, and measurement of pressure loss (%) was made
(case 4): and when the ratio of the outermost peripheral
cell wall thickness (Trl) to the basic cell wall thickness
(Tc) was set at 2.0, each cell wall of the 2nd and later
cells was allowed to have a sectional shape of a spool, the
thickness of said each cell wall was made smaller as said
each cell wall was located more inwardly, the thinnest wall
thickness was made identical to the basic cell wall
thickness, and measurement of pressure loss (%) was made
(case 5). As seen from Fig. 11, pressure loss is large in
the cases 1 to 3; therefore, when increase in pressure loss
is a disadvantage, it is preferred to make gradually smaller
the cell wall thickness from the outermost peripheral cell
13
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
toward inner cells as in the cases 4 and 5.
Fig. 12 shows the results obtained when, in the cases
of Fig. 11, thermal shock resistance (%) was measured in
place of pressure loss. As seen from Fig. 12, when the cell
wall thickness was made gradually smaller from the
predetermined cell to a particular inner cell as in the
cases 2 to 5, an increase in thermal shock resistance can be
obtained as compared with the case 1.
Fig. 13 shows the results obtained when pressure loss
(%) was measured by setting, at 2.0, the ratio of each cell
wall thickness (Trl-Trio) of the cells existing between the
outermost peripheral cell taken as a starting cell and any
cell extending therefrom to the 30th cell, to the basic cell
wall thickness (Tc), i.e. [(Trl~Tr3a)/(Tc)]. As seen from
Fig. 13, pressure loss increases from when the number of
cells of thickened wall exceeds 20.
Fig. 14 shows the results obtained when external shape
accuracy (mm) was measured by setting one by one, at 1.6,
the ratio of each cell wall thickness (Trl-Tr2o) of the cells
existing between the outermost peripheral cell taken as a
starting cell and any cell extending therefrom to the 20th
cell, to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), i.e.
[(Trl-Tr2o)/(Tc)]. As seen from Fig. 14, external shape
accuracy (dimensional accuracy) increases from when the
number of cells of thickened wall exceeds 5 and, when the
cell walls of up to the 15th cells are made thicker, the
dimensional accuracy is half of when the cell wall thickness
14
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
is constant and the same as the basic cell wall thickness.
The reason is considered to be that the thicker wall
thickness adopted in the cells near the circumference of
honeycomb structure increased the rigidity of the structure
and the deformation occurring from structure molding to its
firing was suppressed. It is considered that this also
contributes to the improvement in the uniform molding.
Based on the results of the above study, there is
provided the following ceramic honeycomb structure according
to the present invention.
[1] A ceramic honeycomb structure (1) constituted by cell
walls (ribs) (2) forming a composite structure from a
plurality of cells (3) being adjacent each other and a
honeycomb outer wall (4) surrounding and holding the
outermost peripheral cells located at the circumference of
the composite structure;
characterized in that a basic thickness of cell walls
(2) (the basic cell wall thickness) (Tc) is Tc S 0.12 mm,
an outer wall thickness (Ts) of the honeycomb structure is
Ts Z 0.05 mm, and an open frontal area (P) is P ~ 80%, and
there is a relation shown by a formula:
1. 10 ~ ( Trl~Tr3_ZO ) ~Tc 5 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness ( Trl~Tr3_zo ) of cells existing between an
outermost peripheral cell and any cell within a first end
cell from a fifth cell to a twentieth cell extending
inwardly, taking the outermost peripheral cell as a first
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
staring cell.
[2] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to the above
[1], wherein there is a relation shown by a formula:
1. ZO s (Trl~Tr3_ls ) /Tc S 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness (Trl-Tr3_15) of cells existing between an
outermost peripheral cell and any cell within a first end
cell from a third cell to a fifteenth cell extending
inwardly, taking the outermost peripheral cell as a first
staring cell.
t3] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to the above
[1] or [2], wherein any cell within a second end cell from a
third cell to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking a cell
adjacent to the first end cell but located inward therefrom
as a second starting cell, has such a cell wall thickness
that a section of said each cell wall has a rectangular
shape whose minor side of rectangle is a cell wall thickness
thereof when the honeycomb structure is cut by a plane
perpendicular to the direction of the cells (passages), and
a cell wall thickness having a shortest minor side is
identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening a minor side thereof one by one as a cell is
located more inwardly.
j4] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to the above
[1] or [2], wherein any cell within a second end cell from a
third cell to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking a cell
adjacent to the first end cell but located inward therefrom
16
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
as a second starting cell, has such a cell wall thickness
that a section of said each cell wall has such an inverse
trapezoidal shape as a minor base of inverse trapezoid is a
thickness of said each cell wall when the honeycomb
structure is cut by a plane perpendicular to the direction
of the cells (passages), and
a thickness of a cell wall having a shortest minor
base is identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening a minor base of inverse trapezoid thereof one by
one as said each cell wall is located more inwardly.
[5] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to the above
[1] or [2], wherein any cell within a second end cell from a
third cell to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking a cell
adjacent to the first end cell but located inward therefrom
as a second starting cell, has such a cell wall thickness
that a section of said each cell wall has such a spool shape
as an inner side of spool is shorter than an outer side when
the honeycomb structure is cut by a plane perpendicular to
the direction of the cells (passages), and
a thickness of a cell wall having an shortest inner
side is identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening inner side of spool thereof one by one as said
each cell wall is located more inwardly.
[6] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to the above
[1], wherein there is a relation shown by a formula
1.10 S Trl/Tc S 3.00
between the cell wall thickness (Trl) of each outermost
17
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
peripheral cell and the basic cell wall thickness (Tc),
there is a relation shown by a formula
1.10 S ( Trl~Tr3_zo ) /Tc S 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness ( Trl~Tr3_zo ) within a third end cell from a
third cell to a twentieth cell extending inwardly, taking
the outermost peripheral cell as a third starting cell,
a section of said each cell wall has such a
rectangular shape as a minor side thereof is thickness of
said each cell wall, or such an inverse trapezoidal shape as
a minor base of inverse trapezoid is present inwardly and is
thickness of said each cell wall, or such a spool shape as
inner side of spool is shorter than outer side when the
honeycomb structure is cut by a plane perpendicular to the
direction of the cells (passages); and
a thickness of the cell wall having a shortest minor
side, or a shortest minor base or a shortest inner side is
identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening the minor side of rectangle, or the inward minor
base of inverse trapezoid or the inner side of spool one by
one as said each cell wall is located more inwardly.
[7] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [6], wherein there is the following relation
1.10 S ( Trl--Tr3_zo ) /Tc 5 2 . 50
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and said each
cell wall thickness ( Trl-Tr3_zo )
[8] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
18
CA 02386107 2004-07-15
above [1] to [6], wherein there is the following relation
1 . 20 ~ ( Trl~T~3_2o } /Tc c 1 . 60
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and said each
cell wall thickness (Tr,--Tr3-zo} .
[9] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [8], wherei:n the cells have a sectional.shape
of a triangle or a higher polygon.
[IO) A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [9], wherein the honeycomb outer wall has a
sectional shape of a circle, an ellipse, a trapezoid, a
triangle, a tetragon, a hexagon or a special shape whose
left and right are asymmetrical to each other.
[11] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1) to [10], wherein the honeycomb outer wall has a
diameter of 144 mm or more when it has a circular sectional
shape and, when it has a sectional shape other than a
circular sectional shape, it has a sectional area equal to
when it has a circular sectional shape, and,
there is the following relation
1 . 10 ~ ( Trz--Tr,o_4o ) /Tc C 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness (Trl-Trlo-4o) of cells existing within a first
end cell from a third cell to a fortieth cell extending
inwardly, taking the outermost peripheral cell as a first
starting cell.
[12] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1) to [10], wherein the honeycomb outer wall has a
19
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
diameter of 144 mm or more when it has a circular sectional
shape and, when it has other than a circular sectional shape,
it has a sectional area equal to when it has a circular
sectional shape, and there is a following relation shown by
a formula:
1.10 S ( Trl~Trlo-3o ) /Tc S 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness (Trl~Trlo-3o) of cells within a first starting
end cell from a tenth cell to a thirtieth cells extending
inwardly, taking the outermost peripheral cell as a first
starting cell.
[13] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [12], wherein the cell walls and the honeycomb
outer wall are made of at least one kind of materials
selected from the group consisting of cordierite, alumina,
mullite, silicon nitride, aluminum titanate (AT), zirconia
and silicon carbide.
[14] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to (13], which is used as a carrier for catalyst
for automobile exhaust gas purification.
[15] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [14], which is assembled into a catalytic
converter by loading a catalyst component on the cell walls
and holding the honeycomb outer wall at the outer surface.
[16] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [1] to [15], wherein the corners of each cell are
formed so as to have a radius of curvature of 1.2 mm or less.
' CA 02386107 2004-07-15
[17j A ceramic honeycomb.structure according to any of the
above [1] to [16J, wherein each intersection between each
outermost peripheral cell wall and the honeycomb outer wall
is formed so as to have a radius of curvature of 1_2 mm or
less.
[18J A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above [lJ to [17J, wherein there is cell deformation and,
when a diameter of the honeycomb structure is 120 mm or less,
a first or third end cell is any o~ a third cell to a fifth
IO ceil and, when a diameter is more than I20 mm, a first or a
third end cell is any of a sixth cell to a twentieth cell.
[19] A ceramic honeycomb structure according to any of the
above (IJ to [18J, wherein there is provided with a
corrugated cell wall having a corrugation in the direction
of the cells (passages) between at least one pair of cells
adjacent to each other, of the cells from the first starting
cell to the first end cell or from the second starting cell
to the second end cell or from the third starting cell to
the third end cell.
As described above, the present invention can provide
a ceramic honeycomb structure wherein the disadvantages
incurred by the increased pressure loss and the decreased
thermal shock resistance and the advantages brought about by
the increased isostatic strength and the cell wall shape and
honeycomb external shape of higher accuracy are balanced
appropriately and which is suitably used, for example, as a
carrier for catalyst for automobile exhaust gas purification.
21
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
Brief Description of the Drawings
Fig. 1(a) is a perspective view schematically showing
an example of the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention. Fig. 1(b) is a plan view schematically showing
an example of the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention.
Fig. 2(a) is a partly enlarged view of the portion A
of Fig. 1(b). Fig. 2(b) is a further enlarged view of Fig.
2(a).
Fig. 3(a) is a sectional view schematically showing an
example according to the ceramic honeycomb structure of the
present invention, wherein any cell within a second end cell
from a third cell to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking
a cell adjacent to the first end cell but located inward
therefrom as a second starting cell, has such a cell wall
thickness that a section of said each cell wall has such an
inverse trapezoidal shape as a minor base of inverse
trapezoid is a thickness of said each cell wall when the
honeycomb structure is cut by a plane perpendicular to the
direction of the cells (passages), and
a thickness of a cell wall having a shortest minor
base is identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening a minor base of inverse trapezoid thereof one by
one as said each cell wall is located more inwardly. Fig.
3(b) is a sectional view schematically showing an example
according to the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention, wherein any cell within a second end cell from a
22
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
third cell to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking a cell
adjacent to the first end cell but located inward therefrom
as a second starting cell, has such a cell wall thickness
that a section of said each cell wall has such a spool shape
as an inner side of spool is shorter than an outer side when
the honeycomb structure is cut by a plane perpendicular to
the direction of the cells (passages), and
a thickness of a cell wall having an shortest inner
side is identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening inner side of spool thereof one by one as said
each cell wall is located more inwardly. Fig. 3(c) is a
sectional view schematically showing an example according to
the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present invention,
wherein any cell within a second end cell from a third cell
to a fifth cell extending inwardly, taking a cell adjacent
to the first end cell but located inward therefrom as a
second starting cell, has such a cell wall thickness that a
section of said each cell wall has a rectangular shape whose
minor side of rectangle is a cell wall thickness thereof
when the honeycomb structure is cut by a plane perpendicular
to the direction of the cells (passages), and
a cell wall thickness having a shortest minor side is
identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc), by
shortening a minor side thereof one by one as a cell is
located more inwardly.
Fig. 4 is a drawing schematically showing a case where
the ceramic honeycomb structure (honeycomb carrier) of the
23
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
present invention has been accommodated in a catalytic
converter container.
Fig. 5 is a graph showing the results obtained when
there were produced cordierite-made thin wall honeycomb
structure samples having an outer diameter of 90 mm, a
length of 110 mm, a square cell shape, a cell wall thickness
of 0.11 mm and a cell density of 600 cpsi (wall-to-wall
distance: 1.04 mm) wherein the outer wall thickness was
varied between 0.1 and 0.9 mm to measure isostatic strength
thereof.
Fig. 6 is a graph showing the results obtained when
there was conducted a test for thermal shock resistance in
supercooling, wherein a honeycomb carrier having a cell wall
thickness of 0.11 mm was heated in an electric furnace for a
given length of time to make the temperature uniform and
then taken out from the furnace.
Fig. 7 is a graph showing the results obtained when
each cell wall thickness of the cells existing between each
outermost peripheral cell taken as a starting cell and any
cell of the 2nd to 20th cells extending inwardly from the
starting cell was increased from the basic cell wall
thickness ( 75 hum) to 100 ~.im, 150 Eun or 200 Eun and each of
the resulting honeycomb structures was measured for
isostatic strength (%).
Fig. 8 is a graph showing the results obtained when
each cell wall thickness ( Trl--Trl3 ) of the 1st cell ( taken as
staring cell) to the 13th cell was made thicker one by one
24
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
than the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a
ratio of 1. 00 to 3 . 00 in terms of [ ( Trl~Trl3 ) / ( Tc ) ] and
measurement of isostatic strength (%) was made.
Fig. 9 is a partly enlarged view of Fig. 8.
Fig. 10 is a graph showing the results obtained when
each cell wall thickness (Trl-Trl3) of the 1st cell (taken as
staring cell) to the 13th cell was made thicker one by one
than the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a
ratio of 1.00 to 3.00 in terms of [(Trl-Trl3)/(Tc)] and
measurement of pressure loss (%) was made.
Fig. 11 is a graph showing the results obtained when
each cell wall thickness (Trl~TrlS) of the 1st cell (taken as
staring cell) to the 15th cell was made larger than the
basic cell wall thickness (Tc) so as to give a ratio of 2.0
in terms of [ ( Trl--Trls ) / ( Tc ) ] and measurement of pres sure
loss (%) was made (case 1}; when, in addition to the
conditions of the case 1, the section of each cell wall of
the 16th to 20th cells when cut by a plane perpendicular to
the cell (passage) direction was allowed to have such an
inverse trapezoidal shape as the minor base of inverse
trapezoid was present inwardly and was the thickness of said
each cell wall, the minor base of inverse trapezoid was made
shorter as said each cell wall was more inward, and the
thickness of the cell wall having the shortest minor base
was made identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc)
(case 2); when, in addition to the case 1, the section of
each cell wall of the 16th to 20th cells when cut by a plane
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
perpendicular to the direction of the cell (passage)
direction was allowed to have such a spool shape as the
inner side of spool was shorter than the outer side and was
the thickness of said each cell wall, the inner side of
spool was made shorter as said each cell wall was more
inward, and the thickness of the cell wall having the
shortest inner side was made identical to the basic cell
wall thickness (Tc) (case 3); when the ratio [Trl/(Tc)] of
the outermost peripheral cell wall thickness (Trl) to the
basic cell wall thickness (Tc) was set at 2.0, the section
of each cell wall of 2nd and later cells when cut by a plane
perpendicular to the cell (passage) direction was allowed to
have such an inverse trapezoidal shape as the minor base of
inverse trapezoid was present inwardly and was the thickness
of said each cell wall, the minor base of inverse trapezoid
was made shorter as said each cell wall was more inward, the
thickness of the cell wall having the shortest minor base
was made identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Te),
and pressure loss (~) was measured (case 4); and when the
ratio [Trl/(Tc)] of the outermost peripheral cell wall
thickness (Trl) to the basic cell wall thickness (Te) was
set at 2.0, the section of each cell wall of 2nd and later
cells when cut by a plane perpendicular to the cell
(passage) direction was allowed to have such a spool shape
as the inner side of spool was shorter than the outer side
and was the thickness of said each cell wall, the inner side
of spool was made shorter as said each cell wall was more
26
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
inward, the thickness of the cell wall having the shortest
inner side was made identical to the basic cell wall
thickness (Tc), and pressure loss (%) was measured.
Fig. 12 is a graph showing the results obtained when,
in the cases of Fig. 11, thermal shock resistance (%) was
measured in place of pressure loss.
Fig. 13 is a graph showing the results obtained when
pressure loss (%) was measured by setting, at 2.0, the ratio
of each cell wall thickness (Trl--Trio) of the cells existing
between the outermost peripheral cell taken as a starting
cell and any cell extending therefrom to the 30th cell, to
the basic cell wall thickness, i.e. [(Tr,-Tr3o)/(Tc)].
Fig. 14 is a graph showing the results obtained when
external shape accuracy (mm) was measured by setting, at 1.6,
the ratio of each cell wall thickness ( Trl~-Trzo ) of the cells
existing between the outermost peripheral cell taken as a
starting cell and any cell extending therefrom to the 20th
cell, to the basic cell wall thickness, i.e.
[ ( Trl,..TrZO ) / ( TC ) ] ~
Fig. 15 is a drawing schematically showing an idea of
cell deformation.
Fig. 16 is a drawing showing a relation between the
diameter of ceramic honeycomb structure and strength
increase.
Fig. 17 is a perspective view schematically showing a
corrugated cell wall having a corrugation in the cell
(passage) direction.
27
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
Fig. 18 is a drawing schematically showing the tester
used in measurement of isostatic strength.
Fig. 19 is a graph showing the cold-hot cycle of
1,200°C x cycles used in the test method for measurement of
isostatic strength.
Best Mode for Carrying Out the Invention
Specific description is made below on the best mode
for carrying out the present invention.
As described previously, the ceramic honeycomb
structure of the present invention is constituted by cell
walls (ribs) forming a composite structure from a plurality
of cells being adjacent each other and a honeycomb outer
wall surrounding and holding the outermost peripheral cells
located at the circumference of the composite structure;
characterized in that a basic thickness of cell walls
(the basic cell wall thickness) (Tc) is Tc S 0.12 mm, an
outer wall thickness (Ts) of the honeycomb structure is Ts
0.05 mm, and an open frontal area (P) is P ~ 80~, and
there is a relation shown by a formula:
1.10 S ( Trl~Tr3_2o ) /Tc ~ 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness ( Trl~Tr3_ZO ) of cells existing between an
outermost peripheral cell and any cell within a first end
cell from a fifth cell to a twentieth cell extending
inwardly, taking the outermost peripheral cell as a first
staring cell.
28
CA 02386107 2004-07-15
As described above, in the ceramic honeycomb structure
of the present invention, the basic cell wall thickness (Tc)
of the cell walls constituting the honeycomb structure is
0.12 mm or Less, preferably 0.07 mm or less; the honeycomb
outer wall thickness (Ts} is 0.05 mm or more, preferably O.I
mm or more; the open frontal area (P) of_the basic cell
portion is 80% or more; and a relation of I.10 ~ (Trl-Tr3_
) /Tc ~ 3 . 00 , preferably 1 . 10 ~ ( Trl-Tr3_,s ) /Tc ~ 2 . 50 , more
preferably 1 . 20 ~ ( Tr,--Tr3_~5 ) /Tc ~ I . 60 is allowed to hold
10 between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness {Tr,-Tr3_~5) of the cells existing between each
outermost peripheral cell (first starting cell) and any cell
(first end cell} of the 3rd to 15th cells extending inwardly
from the first starting cell. Thereby, a thin wall
15 honeycomb structure can be obtained wherein the disadvantage
incurred by the increased pressure loss is balanced against
the advantage brought about by the increased isostatic
strength are appropriately balanced, and which has an
increased isostatic strength and a cell wall shape and
honeycomb external shape of higher accuracy.
The embodiment of the ceramic honeycomb structure of
the present invention is described below more specifically
with referring to the accompanying drawings.
Fig. 1(a) is a perspective view schematically showing
an example of the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention, and Fig. I(b) is a plan view thereof. A ceramic
honeycomb structure I comprises a plurality of parallel
29
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
passages (cells) 3 separated by cell walls 2. Each
outermost peripheral cell of the plurality of cells 3 is
surrounded and held by a honeycomb outer wall 4.
Fig. 2(a) is a partly enlarged view of the portion A
of Fig. 1(b), and Fig. 2(b) is a further enlarged view of
Fig. 2(a). As shown in Figs. 2(a) and 2(b), there is each
outermost peripheral cell (first starting cell) 8 in the
nearest vicinity of the outer wall 4; and a second cell 9
extends inwardly from the outermost peripheral cell (first
starting cell) 8. The wall thickness of the outermost
peripheral cell (first starting cell) 8 is shown by Trl, and
the wall thickness of the second cell 9 is shown by Trz.
Similarly, the wall thickness of any cell of the cells
existing between 3rd to 15th cells is shown by Tr3_~s
Incidentally, the cell walls 2 are largely divided into
walls 2a of cells near the circumference of honeycomb and
walls 2b of basic cells.
In the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention, the following relation is specified
1. 10 S ( Trl--Tr3_~5 ) /Tc ~ 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness (Trl-Tr3_ls) of the cells existing between each
outermost peripheral cell taken as starting cell and any
cell taken as end cell of the 3rd to 15th cells extending
inwardly from the starting cell.
When the value [ ( Trl~Tr3_~s ) /Tc ] is less than 1. 10 ,. no
improvement in isostatic strength is seen. When the value
, CA 02386107 2002-04-02
is more than 3.00, pressure loss increases.
Thus, in the honeycomb structure 1 of the present
invention, each cell wall thickness (Trl~Tr3_ls) of the cells
existing between each outermost peripheral cell (1st cell)
and any cell of the 3rd to 15th cells extending inwardly
from the 1st cell is made larger than the basic cell wall
thickness (Tc) by a given proportion. However, when only
the wall thickness (Trl -- Trz) of the 1st to 2nd cells is
made larger by a given proportion, there is no improvement
in isostatic strength or external form accuracy (cell wall
shape accuracy); and when the wall thickness of the cells
existing between the lst cell and any cell located inward
from the 15th cell is made larger by a given proportion,
pressure loss increases; moreover, carrier mass increases to
a level higher than specified, resulting in increased heat
capacity, which may adversely affect the warm-up property of
catalyst during cold start.
In the ceramic honeycomb structure of the present
invention, it is preferred that, as shown in Fig. 3(a) to
Fig. 3(c), the section of each cell wall, within the 2nd end
cell of from the 3rd to 5th cells extending inwardly, taking
the cell adjacent to the 1st end cell but located inward
therefrom as the 2nd starting cell is cut by a plane
perpendicular to the cell (passage) direction, is such a
rectangular shape as the minor side is the thickness of said
each cell wall [Fig. 3(c)], or such an inverse trapezoidal
shape as the minor base of inverse trapezoid is present
31
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
inwardly and is the thickness of said each cell wall [Fig.
3(a)], or such a spool shape as the inner side of spool is
shorter than the outer side and is the thickness of said
each cell wall [Fig. 3(b)]; the minor side of rectangle, or
the inward minor base of inverse trapezoid or the inner side
of spool is made shorter as said each cell wall is more
inward (the degree of shortening may be 1.10 to 3.00); and
the thickness of the cell wall having the shortest minor
side, or the shortest minor base or the shortest inner side
is made identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc). By
constituting the present honeycomb structure as above,
improvements in pressure loss and thermal shock resistance
may be obtained.
In order to prevent the increase in the weight of
honeycomb carrier, caused by the thickening of the cell
walls near the circumference of honeycomb structure, it is
possible to apply padding to the internal portion of the
outer wall on at least the areas where outermost peripheral
cell walls located adjacent each other come into contact
with the outer wall of honeycomb structure, with making the
space therebetween narrower (this padding is contact
padding) or to the V-shaped areas formed by contact between
each intersection of two cell walls and the outer wall (this
padding is V-shaped padding) and thereby achieve a rib shape
of higher accuracy, an improved isostatic strength, etc. and
make the cell wall thickness relatively thin.
Specifically, the corners of each cell are formed so
32
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
as to have a radius of curvature of preferably 1.2 mm or
less and the intersection between cell wall and honeycomb
outer wall is formed so as to have a radius of curvature of
preferably 1.2 mm or less.
In the present invention, it is also preferred that
the following relation is allowed to hold
1.10 S Trl/Tc S 3.00
between the cell wall thickness (Trl) of each outermost
peripheral cell and the basic cell wall thickness (Tc),
when the outermost peripheral cell is referred to as
third starting cell and any of the 3rd to 20th cells
extending inwardly from the third starting cell is referred
to as third end cell, the following relation is allowed to
hold
1.10 S ( Trl-Tr3_ZO ) /Tc S 3 . 00
between the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) and each cell
wall thickness (Trl~Tr3_ZO) of the cells existing between the
third starting cell and the third end cell, and
when the honeycomb structure is cut by a plane
perpendicular to the direction of the cells (passages) and
the resulting section of each cell wall of the cells
existing from the third staring cell to the third end cell
is seen, the section of said each cell wall is allowed to
have such a rectangular shape as the minor side is the
thickness of said each cell wall, or such an inverse
trapezoidal shape as the minor base of inverse trapezoid is
present inwardly and is the thickness of said each cell wall,
33
CA 02386107 2004-07-15
or such a spool shape as the inner side of spool is shorter
than the outer side and is the thickness of said each cell
wall; the minor side of rectangle, or the inward minor base
of inverse trapezoid or the inner side of spool is made
shorter as said each cell wall is more inward; and the
thickness of the cell wall having the shortest minor side.
or the shortest minor base or the shortest inner side is
made identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc). By
constituting the present honeycomb structure as above,
improvements in pressure loss and thermal shock resistance
can be obtained.
In the present invention, it is also preferred in view
of the pressure loss in practical application that the basic
cell wall thickness and each cell wall thickness ( Trl--Tr3_ZO )
have, as mentioned previously, a more restricted relation of
1.I0 ~ (Trl-Tr3_ZO)/Tc "C 2.50, or an even more restricted
relation of 1.20 C (Tr1--Tr3_zo)/Tc ~ 1.60.
As to the sectional shape of cell, used in the present
invention, there is no particular restriction. However, a
sectional shape of, for example, a triangle or a higher
polygon can be mentioned. In particular, any of a square,
rectangle and a hexagon is preferred.
As the sectional shape of honeycomb outer wall, used
in the present invention, there can be mentioned, for
example, a circle, an ellipse, a trapezoid, a triangle, a
square, a hexagon or a special shape whose left and right
are asymmetrical to each other. Of these, a circle or an
34
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
ellipse is preferred.
In recent years, honeycomb carriers have come to be
mounted in large vehicles (e. g. trucks) as well and large-
sized honeycomb carriers have become necessary. In the case
of such a large-sized honeycomb carrier as having a diameter
of 144 mm or more when the sectional shape of honeycomb
outer wall is a circle, or, when the sectional shape is
other shape, having a sectional area equal to when the
sectional shape is a circle, it is preferred that the first
end cell counted from the outermost peripheral cell (1st
starting cell) is stretched to any of the 10th to 40th cells,
preferably the 10th to 30th cells, all extending inwardly
from the outermost peripheral cell, that is, the cells of
thickened wall are increased and that the ratio of the cell
wall thickness ( Trl--Trlo_4o ) , Preferably ( Trl-Trlo-3o ) to the
basic cell wall thicknes s ( Tc ) , i . a . ( Trl~Trlo-4o ) /Tc ,
preferably (Trl-Trlo-ao) /Tc is set ordinarily at 1. 10 to 3.00
and, in practical application, at 1.10 to 2.50, preferably
1.20 to 1.60.
As the material for cell wall and honeycomb outer wall,
used in the present invention, there can be mentioned, for
example, at least one kind of material selected from the
group consisting of cordierite, alumina, mullite, silicon
nitride, aluminum titanate (AT), zirconia and silicon
carbide.
Fig. 4 is a drawing schematically showing a case in
which the honeycomb carrier of the present invention has
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
been accommodated in a catalytic converter container. A
honeycomb carrier 13 is held by a ring 12 at the outer
surface and accommodated in a converter container 11. There
is no particular restriction as to the ring 12, but a metal
mesh-made ring is ordinarily used. Between the converter
container 11 and the outer surface of the honeycomb carrier
13, a buffer member 14 (e. g. a mat or a cloth) is preferably
interposed.
Next, the present invention is more specifically
described by way of Examples. However, the present
invention is in no way restricted by these Examples.
Incidentally, the honeycomb structures obtained in the
Examples were evaluated for performance by the following
methods.
Isostatic strength test
The test and evaluation were made according to the
JASO standard M 505-87 issued by Society of Automotive
Engineer of Japan, Inc. In Table 1, evaluation was made by
three grades of no increase (increase was not seen as a
significance difference as compared with standard), small
increase, and increase.
Thermal shock resistance test
This is a test in which a honeycomb carrier of room
temperature is placed in an electric furnace kept at a
temperature higher than room temperature by a given
temperature, is kept for 20 minutes, is taken out onto a
refractory brick, is observed for appearance, and is lightly
36
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
tapped by a metal bar at the outer surface. An evaluation
of "pass" is given when the carrier appearance shows no
crack and a metallic sound (not a thick sound) is heard when
tapped. The test is repeated until a "fail" evaluation is
reached when the temperature inside the electric furnace is
gradually increased by each 50°C. When "fail" is reached at
a temperature of 950°C higher than room temperature, the
thermal shock resistance of the honeycomb carrier is taken
as 900° C difference.
External shape accuracy test
Accuracy of honeycomb structure circumference was
measured using a three-dimension tester.
Pressure loss test
A converter accommodating a catalyst-loaded honeycomb
structure was fitted to a 2-liter 4-cylinder engine. A
difference between the pressure at the converter inlet and
the pressure at the converter outlet was measured and taken
as the pressure difference of the honeycomb structure.
Examples 1 to 53 and Comparative Examples 1 to 25
A kneaded raw material consisting of talc, kaolin,
alumina, water and a binder was subjected to extrusion
molding and then fired to produce various cordierite-based
honeycomb structure samples each having a square cell shape,
a diameter of 106 mm, a length of 155 mm, an outer wall
thickness of 0.2 mm and an open frontal area (P) of 80% or
more. In these samples, the cell structure, basic cell wall
thickness, No. of cells of thickened wall near the
37
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
circumference of honeycomb structure, thickness of thickened
cell walls near the circumference of honeycomb structure,
and ratio of thickness of thickened cell walls to basic cell
wall thickness were varied as shown in Table 1. Each
honeycomb structure (carrier) produced was subjected to
isostatic strength test, thermal shock resistance test,
pressure loss test and external shape accuracy test. The
results are shown in Tables 1 to 4.
Incidentally, Example 18 is a case where the wall
thickness of the outermost peripheral cell (starting cell)
to the 15th cell was set at 0.150 mm and each wall of the
16th to 20th cells was formed as follows:
the section of said each wall had such an inverse
trapezoidal shape as the minor base of inverse trapezoid was
present inwardly, the minor base of inverse trapezoid was
shorter as said each wall was more inward, and the
thickness of the cell wall having the shortest minor base
was identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) (0.075
mm). Example 19 is a case where the wall thickness of the
outermost peripheral cell (starting cell) to the 15th cell
was set at 0.150 mm and each wall of the 16th to 20th cells
was formed as follows
the section of said each wall had such a spool shape
as the inner side of spool was shorter than the outer side,
the inner side of spool was shorter as said each wall was
more inward, and the thickness of the cell wall having the
shortest inner side was identical to the basic cell wall
38
CA 02386107 2004-07-15
thickness (Tc) (0.075 mm). Examples 20 and 21 are cases
where each wall of the outermost peripheral cell (staring
cell) to the 20th cell was formed as follows:
the section of said each wall had an inverse
5. trapezoidal or spool shape, the thickness of said each wall
was shorter as said each wall was more inward, and the
thickness of the cell wall having the smallest thickness was
identical to the basic cell wall thickness (Tc) (0.075 mm)..
The same thing is also applicable to Examples 50, 5I, 52 and
53.
39
CA 02386107 2004-07-15
x o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
U a~ .y~~ m +~ a a~.N
O
m m a~ Y ~ Y Y Y +~+~
U C C C C C C C C
G romromromrooa mromromromro
-i H .-i.-t.-i.-i.-i.-i~ .-i
m N H H H N N H N
~n rom m rtm ro m toro
+~ rd to rom m ro m ro
E m ef> > > > > > > >
a 21 roZ7 ro 27 ~Oro
N -.i C --Iri -ri.-f~-9~.-i-.~1,-I
C C C C C C p C
m m roo p o o o ~ c a
ro ro m ro ca ro m ro
.c v al tr trtr tr tr trtr
m +~ Y Y a +~ -v .v~
H N tnW W W w W w W R7 I I I III I III Ir
m m m m m m m N
e~ a m m m m m m m m m m m mm m ma
N N m m m m m ~o m m w m m mm m mm
c ro~a m rom ro ro roro la m m mro m rom
m p, ro.i .-rm m m m m m .-~m m mm m ma~
m m m
m N C -i .-iH N H H N N ~ H N NN H HN
~ N H N
O m c6c6 b U U U U U U b U U UU U Utr>
.,r U U U U
H O +~E E C C C C C C E C C CC C C.i
C C C C
Pa ~f]fn ~ H H H H H H V7 H H HHI 1 I1H Hm
r-~ rl -r-~ ,1 -.-t
>. roro ro >.-o >. >~ a a a >.ro~oro~o >. ~oaro
~o ~o ro ~s ro
o H m m a m .-t.1 m m m .1m mmo~ .1 mmm
a~ m m m m
~s m > > +~> Y Y > > > Y > >>> Y >>>
> > > > >
m 1-I TSO O .CO .C .C O O O .CO OOO .C OOO
O D O O O
C1 C N H tnN tn Cn H H N CnN HNN m HNH
G N H H H H
b U 161~ a.l,-tC1 ,-1-.iC4t1 Y rlC1R~P..i-ImriC1L1GL
O. p, C1 f1 C1 CL R. P C1
.C v O O -tE .1 ~-tE E O --iE EEO -i EEE
U E E E E E E E E E
v~ cnz z ~nH VJ V1 H H ,'ZInH HHz In HHH II
m -a ~ -ri rl ,1 ri rl 'rirl
m m m m
m m m m
U ro ro m ro
-~ rom m m m m m m m m m m mmm m mmm mm
.c
+~.+I N H m m m H m m m H m m mmN m NNm mm
41 b U rtfb 10 U b b b U b rtb16U b rorob tt1R7
tT
Y C b C ri N m C .-i.1mi C mfm mNC ri Nmm mm
m m m m m m
m m C W .-iH N ~.i~-i.-f.1 -ri.1N HN~.-t.i NNN HH
N N H N H H
O N b b U U t0 b b b U UU rt1UUU UU
U U U U U U
m -t~ a-~O E c G O E E E O E C cCO E CCC CC
C C C C C C
H m UlZ V7 H H z m cnm z w H HN,'L[/JNHH HH
r1 ..i,--.i m'I r~
O O
C
~x
.-i
U
.-I
- .--i
'ri
ri
O m H f7 t~ f7f7 .-ir7 riM t~1f')
.C
IO
2 U O N m .-iri .-i.-i.-1N N W .-i.-aN 1f~t9ririn-i.-i
Y
$
w r-~r~ r~r-~r M o r~ 0 0 0 0or r rr o0
O f'If'1M r7 p .1 N f O O O OO~D v0 vDvo ON
J
m . . . _r
H .-IH H '-1~-VH rir/ N N N NNN N NNvDf'7f~
I ~
x~_
U
m
U
-.
-1
N
C
x y 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 00 o
m
U 'C r o 0 0 0 0o ro a,o u~ 0 0 0o Nv
.-i
-ri O r1 n-!.-i.~ O O O r-Iri H r-V'-1rHN N NNO NN
G7
H
.c -
~u -o
c
ro
N o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0. 0 0 0 000 0 0oN o0
~
3
m
m m
U U
C
U x In In In In m c0Inu~ In wn
'a
-.t r r r r r r r r r r r r rrr r rrr rr
.1
U
"
m .-i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 000 00
-~
N tp .
.C
m 3+' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 000 00
H m
O (y O O O O O O O O O O O O OOO O OOO OO
~ U o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 000 00
U ' ~D~o ~D ~O~o ~D ~D O t0 ~D ~D~D~o~O~o ~D ~o~oO ~DO
.1 w w w w . w w w w w . w www . ww. ww
G
ri
.-i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 000 00
H
-.~
m y,
E
U t/~ r~r->rh r~r'~r'7ro r~r7 n r~r>r7r~r~ r~ir7r~r7t7r~
-r
N
> > > > > O.-iN Mv~ ~D>
.-I (
ri mi-I-i.-iN r~ .riV' W D wi r fDO~r1:~ .-i.Hri.i.-ir1
N f'1 v~ f1 ~
i-~ .VJ.n Y -1~ i~
a~ m ro m m m ro m m m ro m m mmm m mmm mm
m m m m m m
m
r--j.-i H N .i r-iri H .-i.-i.-IH .-t.1.-1.1-~ -I .-i.-i.-I.iH
N ri.-i .-1 .-i m .-I
.-1
,pc~, roro a n.a rt c~,a a ~a a a.u,cLc~.a n,o.a a.~c
ro c~,a, ss. a. ; a
c~,
E n. L1L1 E E E c1 E E E ri E E EEE E EEE EO.
E E E E E E
ro E E ro 10N E ~ roro E b b NN~ t0 ~ro16roE
H E ~ N x x ~ x ~ I x N
b x w x
x o o o x o x x o x x xxl' xxx xo
x U x W W W x W W W V W W WW.W :ilWWW Wx
W U m U U mn ; U
W m m W
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
0 0
U a-' ~.'
O
+~ +I
'H
rl N N N r1 H
ro
ro+~ ro +~ v ro ro
ro ro ro ro
E d .O ~ 9 >
N N G1 'C 'O
H H C) OI rl rl
rl H H C p
d U r1 rl a a
N U U ro ro
a1 ri r-I lT t71
O N +I +~
H I . A ~n ~n w W I I. I
H b ro N N
p C
n n
N O O d m O rl Yi O OO O
H H
H N N N N N H H N NN N
a ro ro ro ro ro a~ a~ rororo ro
r. .
N d d m 01 O ri ri O md O
a N N
O~ Ov
N H H H H H .-i .-1 H HH H
N G C
O E E
~ ~
, trlOI U U U ro b U U0~ 01U
N U U ro ro U
N ro ro
~
H ri ri C 4' f.' E E G Crl ri
0 C G," .C G C C.
'.~ LC
O 0
W Ix1GG H H H U7 U7 H HG1 G.1
~ rl ri ~ i~ rl ri
W W
+~ I-I
ro b
a a
ro
v
W I I I 1 I H H I II I
ro
i'. N d N O m 41 m G7
y.l N N N N N N N N
y.l
ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro
~
N C C C C C O G C
~i.~
H H H H H H H H H II 1
N
O
O
ro
I
3
Nx o 0
H N N
Uro
,~ I I
rl
m
O M M tA If7 If7 O O O OIA O
m v0 ~O
.O
CJ
7., H e1 H H ri N N .1NN M
U H H
+~
Q1
I O I O
o x b x
a~~ ~ .~
m a~ a~
~i ~ ~
N ro
ro
roro
H O
H H
0 0 0 0 o a o 00 0
~ O 7
pl N p.
a7 d
H
In o o O o > O O oo O
> O ro U
ro U x
x U
U
p p, C p,
H y H O
.,.I .,-I
0 m
M V' N N N H IJ~ N NN N
H tA i~ 'd
k~ 'd rl
rl 'C
'O
N
N
'O
~
N
a~
ro
~
3
x o 0 0 o o o o o 00 0
x In In u~ In
U ~o o mo In ~n n v~u~u~ u~
U n n w n
H
ri N M H H n-1 H H rimiH H
rl O O O O
rl
~
,p
w
,~
p~
~p
N O O O O O O O O Oo O
O O O O O
+~
U
~-
ri
m
U
I
U y vn u~ u~ m n m vnIwn In
x
,
rl U n n n n n n n n nn n
'.1N
N v O O O O O O O O OO O
rl rl
N
ro x
ro a~
pp o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0
g
~
p
~
rl
p
H
N
a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0
w
i O O O O O O O O OO O
Y
U
U ~D ~D ~D t0 ~G ~O ~D ~D~0~D ~o
~
i ~ ~ ~
rl
a
rl
I O O O O O O O O OO O
~-I
H
ri
I
d
N
E
I M M M M M M M M MM M
V
(n
1
1 O O
H
d
O ,a y n a0 O~ O H N Ma If1
,~
r1 ri ri H H H N N N NN N
vD n
I +~ i~
+~
a~ ro ro o a~ a~ a~ m a~a~a~ a~
ro a~ a~
a~
1 H H .-I r1 .1 r1 r1 H r-Irl r-I
r-I ri r-I
H
r-I
aroa rowroa a w a. a w a wa a
I ro E ro ro b ~ ~ rob~ ro
ro
E E 0
E
c
x W W W W W W WW W
I U 7
W ~ U
U 4
W
41
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ' O O 8 '
O ' ' ' O
O
C C C C C C ~ ~ N O C C C N N
C t
A
O ~ i~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ i~ N ~ ~
O -p . ~ y O ~ . . U N
d ~ N N N N
s U L N N N N N N L y_ N O y. y
N L L
O O N U ~ ~ ~ ~
~ N
a0,, ~ ~ .~ .r.~.~.,N .~ N
+ + L L
'
.v.~ y +~+.~r.i+~~ ~ U ~ .N +~
U r.~
~
m O C C C C C r~ +r C C C C .V +~
y C O m +~ +~
L ~ . c~ o~a~a~a~s s p ~ a~ a~a~ s
a~ ~ ~ p s a~ s
s
.~ L > > > > > '~ '~ _ > > > '~ ._
'~ m W
>
I- > . . . . . c~ V) . . . . V) v)
. c~ V)
m m m m m w w w
a~ a~
O N O N O O O U O ~ N d N N
d N N N
N N N N N N N N N O N N N N O
N N -_ - N
N
O f0 cCl9~0t4l0 W f0 L O f0c0 a.
10 f0 lC c0 N l0
l0 c0
N ~ O O O O N O 07 O C7 ~ O L L L
N O N ~ ~ L
L
C L L 1 L L L 1. L L L
L 1.
O N O U U U U U U U U U (n U U U U -
U U (~ U
U
C ~ _ C r
~ C r
r
. _ . . . _
. .
.
>~ 'O 'O'O'G'fl'~ 'C 'fl 'O 'a'O
'O 'O 'fl 'O 'O
'O 'O
O U L >~ d7 O O N N d O d O O O 47
O N O ~ d
N
O ' O O O O O O O O O O O O O
L O O O O
' ~ t ~
O
t U R ~ a n a a a a a a N a a a
a a a c Z -
a
N~ E E E E E . E .~~EE E E
E E E E
E E
,
a~ a~ a~ o~ a~
N N N N N N
U s 'p !0 O O d O d N N O N ~ N N N
A d G7 N O
;N ~- L L N N N N N N N L ~ N N N
~ L N N ~ N
f0 ~ U U U W N N (d l9 (C U U c0 l9
~C N L cC
c0 cC
C ~ C L L L L L L L C = L L L
Y L V L
N i C . . . ~ .
to _ - U U U U U U U -_ -_U U U
- U U . U
N N l0 lC tCr = S ~ ~ C C N ~ S ,~ C
N C. O .~
~
... , . .. Z
. .
.
(~ N f~ (/7 (~
~ N
O O
C O O O O O O O O O O ~ r O T N
O O N N
3 O T T T T r
p
U
Z
r~
p T N c'~~ ~C1t01~ 00 lC7 t0 CDcC cD
O ~ O tD t0
c0
/\1 TT T T T T T T MT T T T
TTNNM T
V
~
N
N ~ C ~n O InO ~7O ~n O O ~ O O O O O
ip ~n O O O
a~ ~ mn cc ccr~r~0000 0~ r~ ao 0000 ao
3 ~ o N m oo 0o
ao
C ~C O O O O O O O O O T T O D O O O
m T T O O
V V C C C O C O C O O O O C C O O O
~ v O O CO O
t ~
U
N
V _ O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
~ O O O O
00 0 0 0
Q o0 0 0 0 0 0 00000 0 0 0
00 0 o c o 0 00000 00 0 0 0 00 0
00 0 0 0 0 0 00000 00 0 0 0 00 0
00 0 0 0 0 0 00000 00 0 0 0 00 0
O O 07 O)O C7O C7 O O O) O 0707 O)
O 07 ~ 07
O
w w w w w W ww w w w w w w
0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
o 0 o 0
N N N N N N N N N N CV N N N N N
N N N N
L
> > ~G 1~ 00O O N M ~ > 00 ~ O N >
O 1f~ c0 I~ O
'y O ~ 00 N N N M M M M M :N M M W t
N M M O
M
I a~ ~ ~ a~ a~a~a~a~a~ a~ ~ a~ a~a~ ~
~ a a~ a~ a~ a~ a~ a~
a~ a~ a~
~ a a a a a a a a a ~ a a a n ~-
a a o a a
a
o o o . ~ o g
x E ~ m c m c c ~ ~ R m ~ c m ~ ~ ~
a ~ o o ~ m c o m e
a o
~
O O o x x x x O x x x x O
x x x x x
x
~ U x x x x x x u m~ um U uu u u tL U
U mut~ uu to ttm l u~ u~
t
u~ u , . ,
u.m
42
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
~ ~ I o ~ ~ o ~
o N 'p -U 'a 'a 'C , 'a 'U 'a . U 'O .
~ ~ 'C .id +~ 'C 'a
'N ~ i.~
S U L .i L L L L L L L L L L L
L C C C C C C
C
t!J C tQ (p fp ca c0 N ~ (C fC c4 U ~ fC
'U ~ 'D ~ '~ ~ 'U ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~
'a 'U 'a 'U 'C ~ Z3
C cC C c0 C ~ C N w ~0 'p C U
C C C G C C C
c~ > c~ > c0 > lC > > > N 7
n fC c0 ' c0 ' l0 t0 N ID
' ' ' ' '
( +~ ~ +~ +r + +.i + .~-~+~ .N
+~ V~ N (n fn (n ~ ~ ~
N N N uJ
~ D. Q.
fJJ W UJ W L1J UJ UJ
~
N
O -p U -a U "O U 'n ~ U U N ~ U
~
L N L ~ L N L ~ N ~ L N
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
U ~ cp !4 R U N t0 l0
~ 7
~ t C i C L C ~ C .C i ~ ~ i.
'9 U ~ U U U U - U U - U U
(n C (n ~ (n C (/~ . C (n C
C ~
f ~
N. (n
U ~
'U ~ 'C 'G 'U 'U 'U j 'U 'U 'G 'O 'U
L ~ L ~ L ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ 1.
f
U f~ ~ f0 ~ l0 > 0 L > > >
'
U -a o ~ o a o ~ a o 0 0 ~ o
(O C L C L C L C ~ L L L C L
a cv a c~ a m ._ a a a cv a
E ~ E ~ o E E E ~ E
s z
v~
-v ~ -o ~ ~ ~ -a N ~ a~ a~ 'o a~
'~ ~ N ~ o ~ ~ N m N ~ m
' C c c c . c c
o O o O O
'i' C i C ~ C i C U L i i C i
i ~
p ~ U ~ U ~ U ~ .~ U U U ~ U
.~ N N C N ~ fly .~ N z = ~ ~ (A
O ii
N
~+-
U
~ cC O O O O O O O N O tf~~7 O O
i N
r r r r T T
U +r
~
O CO O ~ O Lf7 O ~ ~ ~ ~
~
I t M
/~ T r T T r T L T
r T r T T
~/ T
N ~ ~ tI)O ~ ~ O O O tt7 tt~ tn O ~
~
U U 3 N O T 1~ O ~ C7 M M M O N
~ M
~ T N T T T T O T T r O T
C ~ T
- O O O O O O O O O O O O
O
U _- W m t_t~_I,c'~O O O O O O O O
~ _ ~ ~ I
O
U ~ ~ T r r r O O O
Q ~
_ 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~
m
N
L N O O O O O O O O O OHO
O O
~
_ ~ Q O O O O O O O O O OIO
O O '
' I
N N M ~Y ~ W ~ ~ d CG
U U ~ \ \ Wit \ \ t \ ~ \ ;
\ \ \ CO
\ ~\ \
\
_ i
. ~ M
+' 1n LC) it~~ ~ ~ M c ~ M ,
E M MOM
I i
I
L U U I U U U i ' U
U ; I i
I U
41
I 7M;M 7~t,~h 7t0 M c0 >r~.700 t~
~N !Jtn
~ T ~J ~ ~ .
,f,/T ,+d r ~ '
i T ~.J
~ ~ r
~ ./J
~,~,~ T
r
M a~cLaa c c c ~~I~ cLa~
a~ o~ O~j~ ~~
~ L L L a a a a ai a
a~' a
~ a a
j
a n . a a a ~ ~ a m
a a -! a ~ a
~ I
~
m
l Ec c c ~
o a a '~
l I
i
0 o o o x , x x o x
I-~ U x x x~ o o W m x Iw
U U x x x a o
u~ m U o ~U x
t,u~m x u ~U
U m:U
w,tu w
'U
u~
43
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
-n 'o -o -n 'O 'D o 'o 'v 'o 'O
U V 'G Id 'N 'N
+~ 1J
+~
.~ L L L L L
tn C L L L L L L
C C L C O C
L
C
C
C
lp N l0 c0 t0
c0 l0 O lC O "O ~
'C N .D l0 'O ~ 'O 'O
'O N f0 U
'O .a 07 'O ~ 'a ~
'O N
C c0 C c0 C t0 C O C N C -p C cC C C c0
C C C
lp 7 l0 O J l9 ~ t9 J N
N J
t0
N N II! V!
~ H (/~ ~
N
/
V~ ~ ~ ~
~ a,
~
f
~
~
W W W ~ W ~ W
N O
p N
O '~ ~ N ~ d ~ ~
0
N ~
f M N
J1 (0 t0
L O
~ C
t~ ' ~ U U V V C p V ~ U
-' O
y (/~ ~ N N c N C
~ ~
~ c
N
~
d.
'D 'O 'O 'G 'a ~ 'O 'O 'O 'C 'O 'O
'D
L N L O L N N O d L d L O
N ~ ~ ~ ~ > > > > p ~
O
O O ~ C O C O
O
O
O
L C L O L L
C L L
C Z
L
o ~a a ca co a a a a m a ca a
a '
v~~ v~~ ~ E~ ~ NE ~E
c~
n
,
a~
N ~ N ~ ~ N N N ~ N O
~
f
IJ
.p N .D ~ L (0 !0 O .~ l0 .~ N
p
td p C ~ C i C V i L L C i C L
pL c~OV (0V c0 .C VU C7 OC1 00
.~ N t~ ~ fn f~ O C ~ .r fn .r tn .~
~
Z
N
N N N
O r O ~ O N ~ r O ~ T O ~
~ M T
T T T
p
N N N N N N N t/J
~ ~ ~ ~
~
a a a
a
0 ~ ~ 0 O cG ~0 O c0
~ ~ V p U V
O
0
~
~ 0 T D, 0 T N ~ C~ T N
0. C
T 0, 0
0,
~ ~ ~ G'
T
T T T T T
N ~ M ~ N U N
~G ,C 7C
~C
p O O ,.
N
7 > > J
C C C C
O .~
N
H Z N
C ~p Lt7 O O Lf~ 1f~ tl~ lf~ L1~
~ Lf~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M N
d N M cC vt7 M cD t0 t0 O ~ M M c0 O M co
?~ 00 O
C ~ O O O O O O O O ~j co O O O p O O ~
- m
V V C C C C C C C C t O C C C t C C
~
t .t
V
H
N
_ LC7 O O lf~ In t!7 Lf) t1~ 1f~ Lf~ tn In
V R tI~ 1t~ M M M M M N N N N
~ M M ~
~
~
3
C O O O O O O O O O O O O O
vJ
tQ =
~C
Q
d .V O O C O O O O O O O O C O
U .C
r~
'v O O o O O O O O O O O O O
~ O O O O O O O O O O O
_ ~
a
V U ~ ~
N N N N N N N N N 00 00
U ~ inn
~ ~ i
, 0o mm~n ~n o0 00
T T N N
T T T T T T T T T
L > > > > >
>
C7 00 O 07 > T ~' N 7 ~7
' N M
M O T
'
yr T :Er W N ~ N ltd Ln ~ N Lc7 :N N
~ N y N tn
~
L a i C7 i G) L d L d L ~ d N ~ L O7 i O G7
O d C7
~ a ~ a ~ a ~ a ~ a a a ~ a a ~ a a
a a
~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~
X ~LU ~ICIO ~1 0~~~~1 ~AC ~1
0c ~c O 9 W
0 9 W
0 o x o x o x o x o x x x o x x o x x
x x
I-~U Ut,um Uuiw UtoUmUtoto ~u Umu,i Ut,ut,u
44
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
As appreciated from Tables 1 to 4, good results are
obtained when the requirements for the present invention are
satisfied. Similar results were obtained also with other
cell structures of triangle, hexagon, etc.
The above performance evaluation of honeycomb
structures was made on a case of no cell deformation in
honeycomb structure. It was confirmed that similar
performances are obtained also on a case of cell deformation
in honeycomb structure, as long as there is a relation of
1. 10 S ( Trl-Tr3_ZO ) /Tc ~ 3 . 00 between the basic cell wall
thickness ( Tc ) and each cell wall thickness ( Trl--Tr3_ZO )
Herein, "cell deformation" refers to a state in which
cell wall (rib) is deformed relative to the central axis of
honeycomb carrier. The amount of deformation indicates a
case in which deformation is 1.1 to 5.0 times the thickness
of cell wall (rib).
It was confirmed that in a ceramic honeycomb structure
having "cell deformation", a sufficient strength can be
obtained when the 1st or 3rd end cell is any of the 3rd to
5th cells (when the honeycomb structure has a diameter of
120 mm or less) or the 1st or 3rd end cell is any of the 6th
to 20th cells (when the honeycomb structure has a diameter
of more than 120 mm). That is, as shown in Fig. 16, when
the honeycomb structure had a diameter of 120 mm or less and
the 1st or 3rd end cell was any of the 3rd to 5th cells,
there was obtained a sufficient strength which was 2 times
as compared with a honeycomb structure using no reinforced
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
cell and having an ordinary cell wall thickness; when the
honeycomb structure had a diameter of more than 120 mm and
the 1st or 3rd end cell was any of the 6th to 20th cells,
there was obtained a sufficient strength which was 2 times
as compared with a honeycomb structure using no reinforced
cell and having an ordinary cell wall thickness. Even when
the honeycomb structure had a diameter of more than 120 mm
and the 1st or 3rd end cell was any of the 3rd to 5th cells,
there was obtained a sufficient strength which was 1.2 times
as compared with a honeycomb structure using no reinforced
cell and having an ordinary cell wall thickness.
It was also confirmed that a honeycomb structure
having, in the cells from the starting cell to the end cell,
a corrugated cell wall (such as shown in Fig. 17) having a
corrugation at the intersection of at least one pair of two
adjacent walls (for example, a pair of Rx and Ry in Fig. 17)
was superior, in thermal shock resistance, to a honeycomb
structure having an ordinary cell wall having no corrugation,
in addition to the above-mentioned evaluated performance.
That is, it is confirmed that a honeycomb structure having a
corrugated cell wall showed a superior thermal shock
resistance (a higher resistance to cracking) than a
honeycomb structure having an ordinary cell wall having no
corrugation by subjecting the place including the boundary
portion possessing at least corrugated shape to a cycle of
heating at 1,200°C for 5 minutes and then cooling for 5
minutes was conducted 10 times (10 cycles) according to a
46
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
burner test (a test for examining the tendency of crack
formation) described later. The honeycomb structures used
in this test had the same material and shape as in Example 1.
Burner test
A tester shown in Fig. 18 was used. This tester is
Maremont Exhaust Gas Simulator Model No. 3 or an equivalent
thereto, or a hydraulic isostatic tester (a product of NGK
INSULATORS, LTD.) or an equivalent thereto. As shown in Fig.
18, this tester has a main burner 101, a pilot burner 102, a
combustion chamber 103, a bypass 104 and a holder 105. Into
the combustion chamber 103 are fed an LPG 106 and heating
air 107, and ignition is made using a spark plug 108 to give
rise to combustion. In the holder 105 are set a sample 110
and, in the vicinity thereof, a thermocouple 109. The
bypass 104 switches the heating air 107 and cooling air 111
to each other, whereby a cold-hot cycle is applied to the
sample 110.
The test method was as follows. First, a holding
material (not shown in Fig. 18) was wound round the sample
110, and the sample was set in the holder 105 so that no gas
passed outside the sample 110. Then, the thermocouple 109
was set 5 mm upstream of the gas inlet end of the sample 110.
Then, a cold-hot cycle of 1,200°C x 10 cycles, shown in Fig.
19 was applied to the sample 110. Lastly, formation of
cracks in the sample 110 was examined by observation.
Incidentally, the gas flow rate during heating was 1.0
Nm' / min .
47
CA 02386107 2002-04-02
Industrial Applicability
The honeycomb structure of the present invention can
be suitably used as a carrier for catalyst, etc.,
particularly as a carrier for catalyst for automobile
exhaust gas purification, etc. The honeycomb structure of
the present invention is also used suitably as a filter for
diesel particulate or the like, as a chemical reactor (e. g.
a catalyst carrier for fuel cell reformer), or as a heat
exchanger.
48
