Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02414234 2006-11-01
AGGREGATE DILATOMETER DEVICE
AND METHODS OF TESTING
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1 Field of the Invention
2 [0002] The invention relates generally to devices and methods that are
useful for
3 measuring the thermal expansion and/or chemical reactivity of aggregates
used in
4 concrete and like substances.
Descrintion of the Related Art
6 [0003] Techniques for determining the coefficient of thermal expansion, and
7 related expansion information, for a particular aggregate type are
important, as such
8 properties determine the thermal expansion of concrete using that aggregate
type to a
9 considerable degree. Techniques for determining the chemical reactivity of
aggregate
types are important for similar reasons. Chemically reactive aggregates can
expand
11 greatly over time inside a concrete mixture, which may lead to cracking
thereby
12 weakening the structure of the concrete.
13 [0004] To date, techniques for determining information concerning the
expansion
14 of aggregates and substances containing aggregates have generally involved
the use of
flasks to contain crushed pieces of aggregate mixed with water. To measure
aggregate
16 expansion, these arrangements also relied upon a readings of the levels of
a delicate
17 balance of water and mercury contained in a complex arrangements of tubes
and
18 stopcocks. These prior art techniques were also relatively limited, of
questionable
19 accuracy and incapable of measurements over wide temperatures.
1
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 [0005] Further, such techniques (which were limited to thermal expansion
testing)
2 provided no reliable means of determining the actual temperature of the
aggregate being
3 tested. Instead, it was assumed that the aggregate samples were at the same
temperature
4 as the water bath surrounding the flask.
[0006] Other methods of determining information relating to the expansion of
6 aggregate utilized direct measurement of individual aggregates by placing
chunk
7 aggregate members inside a clamp or similar retainer and gauging llow much
the
8 individual member expands as temperature is changed. Unfortunately,
information
9 obtained from this type of measurement is not accurately generalized to
larger amounts
of aggregates.
11 [0007] Existing alkali silica reaction (ASR) techniques for testing the
chemical
12 reactivity of aggregates also have significant limitations. These tests do
not always
13 provide reliable results or results that may be applicable to the
prediction of performance
14 under similar conditions in the field.
[0008] The invention addresses the problems of the prior art.
16 SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
17 [0009] The invention provides metliods and devices for improved measurement
of the
18 thermal expansion and/or chemical reactivity of aggregates used in concrete
and for
19 similar substaiices. In a preferred embodiment, aggregate is placed into
the chamber of
a metallic container having an enlarged opening. The aggregate is placed in a
water bath,
21 and a tightly sealable lid is placed onto the container. The lid carries a
linear variable
22 differential transducer (LVDT). A thermocouple for sensing temperature is
also retained
23 within the lid so that a sensor on the thermocouple contacts the water bath
when the lid
24 is secured onto the container. The LVDT is operationally interconnected
witll a storage
or recording device. In a preferred construction the lid retains a tower
member having
26 a float that is freely moveably mounted upon a guide rod. Movement of the
float is
27 indicative of a volumetric change in the aggregate and water.
28 [0010] In operation, the dilatometer device is used to determine the
information relating
29 to the amount of expansion or contraction of the aggregate in response to
thermal
changes. In addition, the devices and methods of the present invention are
useful for
31 determining the degree of reactivity of the aggregate. Preferably, he
dilatometer is
32 calibrated before use with aggregate by filling the container with water
alone and then
-2-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 determining the thermal expansion associated with the water in the
particular container
2 being used. The degree of volumetric change for the aggregate alone may be
deterinined
3 using equations that isolate and remove the expansion quotient of the water.
4 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0011] Figure 1 is a side-cutaway view of an exemplary aggregate dilatometer
device
6 constructed in accordance with the present invention.
7 [0012] Figure 2 is a side view of an arrangement for de-airing the
dilatometer device
8 illustrated in Figure 1.
9 [0013] Figure 3 is a regression table illustrating the volumetric thermal
expansion of
water.
11 [0014] Figure 4 is a table illustrating the volumetric change of a
dilatometer container
12 with temperature.
13 DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
14 [0015] Referririg to Figure 1, there is shown an exemplary dilatometer
device 10 that
includes a cylindrical container 12 that is formed of a strong and durable
material. It is
16 presently preferred that the container 12 be fashioned of stainless steel
or brass. The
17 container 12 defines an interior chamber 14 with a large opening 16 at its
upper end. It
18 is preferred that the container 12 and its opening 16 have a diameter of
approximately six
19 (6) inches so that larger samples of aggregate or hardened concrete may be
accommodated within its chamber 14 and permitted to expand and contract
therein. A lid
21 18 is removably affixed to the container 12 by means of a threaded
coiuiection 20. The
22 lid 18 contains a central aperture 22 and is preferably formed of stainless
steel or brass.
23 [0016] A generally cylindrical tower member 24 is secured to the lid 18 by
means of
24 fasteners 26 which pass through a radially projecting flange 28 at the
lower end of the
tower section 24. The tower member 24 has a central section 3 0 that defines a
cylindrical
26 passage 32 therewithin. A reduced diameter portion 34 is located at the
upper end of the
27 tower member 24. Secured within the reduced diameter portion 34 is an
apparatus 36 for
28 determining an ainount of expansion for a material within the chamber 14 of
the
29 container 12. A currently preferred apparatus 36 is a linear variable
differential
transducer (LVDT) of a type known in the art for sensing mechanical movement
and
31 generating an electrical signal indicative of such movement. The currently
preferred
32 LVDT is a UCAS/sCHAEVITZ Model MHR.050, which provides a voltage of 10.00
-3-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 volts for a displacement of 1.27 mm. The apparatus 36 is electrically
interconnected via
2 lead 37 with a data storage or recording device of a type known in the art,
such as a
3 suitably programmed computer data acquisition device. Placement of the
apparatus 36
4 within the tower member 24 is advantageous since the apparatus may be kept
primarily
above the level of the materials contained therein and, at the same time, be
kept in contact
6 with those materials for sensing of expansion.
7 [0018] The passage 32 of the tower member 24 retains a float 38 that is
mounted upon
8 guide rod 40 so that the float 38 is able to be moved freely upwardly and
downwardly
9 along the guide rod 40. In currently preferred embodiments, the float 38 is
preferably
made of glass, but may be constructed of another material suitable for thermal
or
11 clzemical expansion testing. It is further noted that the central section
30 of the tower
12 member 24 has one or more fluid communication apertures 42 disposed
therethrough.
13 Plugs or screws 44 are removably disposed within the apertures 42 to close
off fluid flow
14 through the apertures 42.
[0019] A tliermocouple 46 is disposed within the lid 18. The thermocouple 46
has a
16 sensing element 48 that extends into the chainber 14 of the container 12
when the lid 18
17 is secured thereupon. Although not shown, it will be understood that the
thermocouple
18 46 may be electronically interconnected to a monitor device (not shown),
such as a
19 computer having suitable monitoring software, such as Labtech Notebook. The
thermocouple 46 is used to determine when the contents of the container 12
have been
21 brought to specific, predetermined temperatures.
22 [0020] Prior to the testing of samples of aggregate, the device 10 must be
calibrated.
23 Calibration involves filling the container 12 with water 50 but no
aggregate. The
24 container 12 is then brought to the same first and second temperatures as
will be used for
the mixture of water 50 and aggregate 52. Readings indicative of the position
of the float
26 38 are obtained by the LVDT 36 at both temperatures. An expansion curve may
be
27 developed that is representative of expansion for the dilatometer device 10
with water 50
28 alone.
29 [0021] Figure 1 shows the chamber 14 of the container 12 being filled with
water 50
and pieces of aggregate 52. It should be understood that, if it is desired to
test concrete
31 rather than aggregate, pieces (or a piece) of concrete will be substituted
for the aggregate
32 52. A column of water 54 extends upwardly within the passage 32 of the
tower member
-4-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 24, ending at a water level 56. The column of water 54 floats the float 38,
and the
2 location of water level 56 is set by overfilling the column of water 54 and
then removing
3 a plug or screw 44 from one aperture 42 and allowing water to drain down
until the water
4 level 56 become even with the lower end of the aperture 42. If this is done
with every
test, a substantially constant water level 56 will be provided for each.
6 [0022] In operation for testing of aggregate samples, the container 12 of
the dilatometer
7 is filled with a mixture of water 50 and aggregate 52 and then the lid 18 is
affixed to the
8 container 12 allowing the sensing element to be disposed within the water
50. Prior to
9 filling the container 12, it is desired to presoak the aggregate pieces 50
in water for at
least 24 hours.
11 [0023] A de-airing operation is then performed (See Figure 2) to help
remove air from
12 pores in the surface of the aggregate 52 and, thus, allow the aggregate 52
to be saturated
13 more coinpletely. A de-airing device 60 is interconnected to the
dilatometer device 10.
14 The exemplary de-airing device 60 is a flask 62 that is partially filled
witli water 64. The
neck of the flask 62 contains a stopper 66. A first tube 68 is disposed
through the stopper
16 66 and into the water 64. The first tube 68 extends into the tower member
24 of the
17 dilatometer device 10 within which it is secured in an airtight manner. A
second tube 70
18 extends through the upper portion of the flask 62. The second tube 70 is
interconnected
19 to vacuum source (not shown). De-airing of the chamber of the dilatoineter
device 10
occurs when the vacuum source draws air from the flask 62. The reduced partial
21 pressures between the flask 62 and the dilatometer 10 causes entrapped air
within the
22 aggregate 52 of the dilatometer 10 to be released and drawn into the flask
62 through the
23 first tube 68. Such captured air will bubble up through the water 64 and be
drawn by the
24 vacuum source through the second tube 70.
[0024] Following de-airing, the water 50 and aggregate 52 are then brought to
a first
26 temperature and allowed to equilibrate. This is typically done by placing
the container
27 12 in a water bath (not shown) that is maintained at the desired
temperature. The
28 thermocouple 46 is monitored to ensure that the temperature of water 50 and
aggregate
29 52 is accurately maintained. The thermocouple 46 is used as it is preferred
to obtain a
direct reading of the temperature within the container 12 than to assume that
the
31 temperature within the container 12 is the same as that of the water bath
outside the
32 container 12.
-5-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 100251 Once the water 50 and aggregate 52 have equilibrated, the float 38
will be
2 buoyant upon the water level 56 which will be at a first position within the
tower member
3 24. As a result, the LVDT 36 will provide a first reading indicative of the
position of the
4 water level 56 within the tower member 24.
[00261 The container 12 is brought to a second temperature. Again, this is
preferably
6 done by the use of a water bath (not shown) that is being maintained at a
second
7 temperature. The water 50 and aggregate 52 are allowed to equilibrate at
this second
8 temperature. Again, the thermocouple 46 is used to monitor the temperature
of the water
9 50 and aggregate 52. Once the water 50 and aggregate 52 have equilibrated at
this second
temperature, the water level 56 and float 38 are brought to a second position
within the
11 tower member 24. The LVDT 36 provides a second reading indicative of this
second
12 position. The second temperature is higher than the first temperature, and
both the water
13 50 and the aggregate 52 expand as they are brought from the first
temperature to the
14 second temperature. An expansion curve is developed to provide the
coefficient of
thermal expansion for the dilatometer 10 and water 50. That coefficient is
then compared
16 to an expansion curve developed during calibration where the container 12
is filled only
17 with water. The coefficient of thermal expansion for in each instance can
then be
18 calculated using volumetric equations that relate the rise of the water
level 56 within the
19 tower member 24 to the volumetric increases of water 50 a.nd aggregate 52
due to the
changes in temperature. For example, when the temperature is raised from Tl to
T2, the
21 aggregate 52, the water 50, and the container 12 all expand. Therefore, the
apparent
22 volume change that the LVDT 36 detects consists of three parts:
23 AV, = Ah = AVa + AV, - AVf
24 where aVl = observed total volumetric increase due to temperature
change AT,
26 A = inner sectional area of tower,
27 Ah = rise of the water surface inside the tower,
28 dVN, = volumetric increase of water due to change in temperature
29 AT,
AVf = volumetric increase of inside volume of the dilatometer
31 due to AT,
-6-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 AVa = volumetric increase of aggregate V. due to AT, and
2 AT = temperature increase from Tl to T2.
3 Since Vf=Va+Vw=V,
0
4 AVa = Va ya /,T
OVf = Vyf OT and
6 AVW = Vw,y,,, AT =(V - Va) y AT
7 where V = total inner volume of the container 12,
8 VW = volume of water in the container 12,
9 Vf = volume of the container 12,
Va = volume of aggregate in the container 12,
11 ya = coefficient of volunletric thermal expansion of aggregate,
12 yW = coefficient of volumetric thermal expansion of water, and
13 yf = coefficient of volumetric thermal expansion of container,
14 we have
Va'Ya AT+(V - Va) YW AT = OV1 + VYfT
16 or
17 ya = AVi - V- 1 (YW - Yf) + Yf
18 VaOT Va
19 [0027] It can be seen from the latter equation that, in addition to the
records of OV,, Tj
and T2, one needs to know the coefficients yW and yf due to the temperature
increase from
21 Tl to T2 in order to determine the coefficient of thermal expansion of the
aggregate 52.
22 Those of skill in the art will recognize that the parameter yw for any
temperature range
23 within 0-60 C can be obtained as:
24 yW = V2 - vi
T2-TI
26 where v, and v2 are the specific volumes of water at temperatures Tl and
T2, respectively.
27 [0028] A regression from these data, illustrated in Figure 3, shows how the
specific
28 volume (the reciprocal of the density) changes with temperature. The
coefficient of
29 expansion for the container 12 may be determined by performing a
calibration of the
-7-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 dilatometer device 10. Calibration is performed by filling the chamber 14 of
the
2 container 12 with distilled water and heating the container 12 in a water
bath over a
3 continuous temperature range from 4 C to 34 C. A temperature increment of
about
4 6 C has been used in testing. After each teinperature increment in the water
bath, a
minimum of one hour was allowed for the container 12, and the water in it to
reach
6 equilibrium in temperature. The teinperature, as measured by the
thermocouple 46 and
7 the ainount of expansion of the distilled water, as measured by the LVDT
apparatus 36,
8 were recorded by a conlputer data acquisition system which was also used to
perform the
9 calculations for determining the coefficient of expansion yW.
[0029] The coefficient of expansion yf for the container 12 may be taken as a
constant
11 equal to the slope of the straight line 4.90 x 10-5/ C, as depicted in
Figure 4. This value
12 has been obtained empirically, and it is suggested that, if required to
achieve the desired
13 degree of precision, einpirical testing of the actual container to be used
be conducted to
14 obtain more accurate data.
[0030] The dilatometer device 10, or a variant thereof, may also be used for
methods
16 of testing aggregate expansion that involves chemical treatment of the
aggregates instead
17 of variations in temperature. When chemical treatment is used, the float 3
8 should not be
18 made of glass, but rather, of a material, such as a plastic, that will not
react with the
19 particular chemicals that are being applied to the aggregate 52.
[0031] For a chemical reactivity test, the water 50 is replaced by an
alkali/water
21 solution 50. A currently preferred solution is a one molar sodium oxide
solution. Pores
22 within the aggregate 52 contain silica (not shown). Alkali within the
solution 50' reacts
23 with the silica and is absorbed into it causing the aggregate 52 to swell.
The swelling of
-8-
CA 02414234 2002-12-18
WO 01/98763 PCT/US01/19686
1 the aggregate 52 results in a movement of the water/solution level 56 within
the tower
2 member 24.
3 [0032] The dilatometer 10 and associated components will measure the
expansion
4 associated with these reactions by detecting the amount of expansion of the
mixture of
the solution 50' and aggregate 52 caused by reaction of the alkali solution
with the silica
6 in the aggregate 52. The degree or percent of volumetric expansion for the
aggregate 52
7 may be derived using equations similar to those useful for determining
coefficients
8 relating to thermal expansion.
9 [0033] The devices and methods of the present invention provide a number of
advantages. First, they permit continuous monitoring of both temperature and
expansion
11 information for a given aggregate in testing for susceptibility to ASR. The
method also
12 allows for a variety of treatments to be applied to the solution 50'
relative to their
13 effectiveness to mitigate expansion to ASR. Also, they provide resilient
and reusable
14 testing equipment that is capable of testing large, uncrushed portions of
aggregates or
concrete portions.
16 [0034] While described in terms of a preferred embodiment, those of skill
in the art will
17 understand that many modifications and changes may be made while remaining
within
18 the scope of the invention.
-9-
