Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
STEPPER MOTOR Je4M ~ETECTIOPV CIRCUIT
Field of the Invention
[00001] The present invention relates to electrical motors and is particularly
applicable but not limited to methods and devices for detecting malfunctions
in an
electrical stepper motor.
Background to the Invention
[00002] The ubiquity and popularity of lottery games is undisputed. Everyday
numerous people in different countries buy lottery tickets in the hope of
striking it rich.
Arguably, the most popular form of such lotteries, and certainly the one with
the largest
payoffs, is the game of Lotto, typically sold through an electronic online
lottery system.
For this type of a lottery, for each wager, a player selects a predetermined
number of
numerals from a finite pool of choices. A draw is then performed during which
the
same predetermined number of numerals are randomly selected from the pool of
choices. ~epending on the number of matches between a player's selected
numerals
and the randomly selected numerals, the player wins prizes.
[00003] For a game as outlined above, a database of numbers selected by
players
is created and, for each wager, a player is provided with a ticket. The ticket
has printed
on it not only the amount of the wager but also the sets of numerals selected
by the
player. The ticket then becomes the player's proof that he made a wager and
what
numerals he wagered on. Another important part of the ticket, aside from the
numerals
selected by the player, is the ticket's identifying number. This identifying
number
correlates to a record at the lottery central system that contains the details
about that
particular ticket.
[00004] Clearly, the printing of the lottery ticket, usually done at the point
of sale
terminal, is important. It is for this reason that the ticket printers need to
have some
way of determining whether a print job has been completed or not. Since each
ticket
1
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
constitutes a print job, a successful print job means that a particular ticket
has validly
been printed and, as such, the record for that printed ticket is valid. The
valid record
can then be added to the records which will be checked against the winning
numbers.
[00005] Unfortunately, malfunctions in the printer, and specifically printer
jams,
can cause trouble. A printer jam does not necessarily stop the printer from
printing.
Instead, in one type of printer jam, the printer head may continue to print
with the paper
not being fed properly. This leads to the data destined for a whole ticket or
tickets to be
printed on a single line on the paper. Such a condition is usually not
automatically
reported to the lottery central system so that when a printer paper feed jams,
the print
head continues to print and the lottery ticket terminal, and hence the lottery
central
system, is under the impression that tickets are being printed. lNhile this
does not affect
the entry and storage of valid records, there is no corresponding evidence of
a valid
ticket being printed. The player does not have any proof of his or her wager
as the
ticket has been misprinted due to the printer jam. While the above scenario
describes
a paper feed problem, other printer jam scenarios which lead to the
misprinting of
tickets are possible. ,
[00006, One attempt to solve the above problem of tracking the paper feed in
the
printer and reporting any errors when they occur involved the use of special
paper.
This approach used specially printed paper with regularly spaced dots or other
marks
printed on the back of the paper. An optical scanner capable of detecting fibs
marks
determined the speed of the paper feed by counting the number of marks
detected for
every given period of time. When the speed fell below a certain threshold,
there was, in
ail probability, a paper jam. 1/llhiie this approach works, it cannot be
easily adapted to
different types of printers as it requires not only specialized paper but also
specialized
hardware including at least one optical sensor to detect the marks on the
paper.
[00007] Based on the above, there is a need for a solution that can easily be
built
into printers and which does not require special paper.
[00008] It is therefore an object of the present invention to at least
mitigate if not
overcome the shortcomings of the prior art.
2
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
Summary of the Invention
[00009] The present invention relates to methods, devices and circuits for
detecting malfunctions in stepper motors. A driver circuit driving a stepper
motor
produces a signal proportional to the current in the windings of the stepper
motor. This
signal is then amplified and integrafied for ease of comparison. The resulting
signal is
then compared to a specific entry in a table of values with each entry in the
table
corresponding to an operating profile of the stepper motor. If the resulting
signal does
not correspond to the operating profile for which the motor is configured, the
stepper
motor is jammed or stalled. A suitable alarm and a corresponding sequence of
actions
may then be triggered.
[00010] In a first aspect the present invention provides a method for
detecting a
specific condition in a device having an electric motor, the method
comprising:
a) determining a signal level for at least one winding of said motor;
b) comparing said signal level to a predetermined expected signal level range;
and
c) generating an alarm relating to said specific condition in said device in
the
event said signal level is not within said predetermined expected signal level
range.
[00011] In a second aspect the present invention provides a circuit for
detecting
malfunctions in a device having an electric motor, the circuit comprising:
- feedback circuit means for retrieving a feedback signal related to a signal
in at
least one winding in said motor;
comparing circuit means for comparing said feedback signal with an expected
signal level range,
wherein a malfunction is detected when said feedback signal is not within said
expected
signal level range.
[00012] In a third aspect the present invention provides a system for
detecting
malfunctions in a motor, the system comprising:
- processing means for comparing a feedback signal with an expected signal
level range;
- motor driver means for driving said motor and for producing said feedback
3
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
signal, said feedback signal being related to a current level in at least one
winding of
said motor,
wherein said feedback signal is received by said processing means from said
motor
driver means and a malfunction is detected when said feedback signal level is
not
within said expected signal level range.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[00013] A better understanding of the invention will be obtained by
considering the
detailed description below, with reference to the following drawings in which:
Figure 1 is a block diagram of a system for detecting malfunctions in an
electric motor
according to one embodiment of the invention;
Fig 2 is a circuit diagram of a signal conditioning circuit for use with the
system
illustrated in Figure 1;
Fig 3 is a waveform illustrating the range of feedback signal levels for a
completed task;
Fig 4 is a waveform illustrating the differing feedback signal levels
encountered when a
malfunction occurs in an electric motor; and
Fig 5 is a flowchart illustrating the steps executed in a process for
detecting
malfunctions in an electric motor according to one aspect of the invention.
Detailed Descr_Iption
[00014, Referring to Figure 19 a block diagram of a stepper motor jam
detection
system is illustrated. A stepper motor 10 is controlled by a driver circuit
20. The driver
circuit 20, in turn, receives input from a microprocessor subsystem 30 that
controls the
output of the driver circuit 20. A feedback connection 40 from the driver
circuit 20 feeds
into a signal conditioning circuit 50. The output of the signal conditioning
circuit 50 then
feeds an analogldigital (AID) converter 60. The output of the AID converter 60
then
feeds the microprocessor subsystem 30.
[00015] In operation, the microprocessor subsystem 30 sends digital control
signals to the driver circuit 20. Based on these digital control signals, the
driver circuit
20 controls the currents in the windings of the stepper motor 10. A feedback
signal
4
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
from the driver circuit 20 to the signal conditions circuit 50 sent via
feedback connection
40, provides an indication of the current in the windings of the stepper motor
10. ~nce
this feedback signal is properly conditioned for ease of use by the signal
conditioning
circuit 50, the A/~ converter 60 converts the analog signal ~a conditioned
feedback
signal) into a digital signal. This resulting digital signal is then sent to
the
microprocessor subsystem 30. The digital signal is then compared to an
expected
signal level and, based on the results of the comparison, an alarm may be
generated by
the microprocessor subsystem 30 if the digital signal from the Af~ converter
60
indicates a motor jam.
[00016] To determine if there is a motor jam, the microprocessor subsystem 30
is
equipped with a memory 30A which contains a preprogrammed lookup table. The
preprogrammed lookup table has entries which correspond to specific tasks
which the
stepper motor may be executing. In one embodiment, the table entries
correspond to
speeds at which the stepper motor is to be operating. Each entry consists of a
signal
value range corresponding to an acceptable digital signal value for a specific
motor task
or setting. Thus, if the stepper motor is to execute a task requiring a
certain speed
setting, the table entry for that tasklspeed will consist of the acceptable
digital signal
value range for that tasklspeed. Since the feedback signal from the driver
circuit is
usually a voltage reading, the entries in the table may therefore be voltage
ranges. If
the digital signal received by the microprocessor subsystem 30 is
substantially different
from the expected range, then a malfunction may have occurred with the
stepping
motor. Alarms may then be generated or exception handling procedures may then
be
initiated once this condition is detected. Experiments for a specific
implementation
have shown that a substantially lower digital signal value from the expected
signal value
indicates a stepper motor jam. It should be noted that determining which
profilelsignal
value range is to be used for comparison purposes is straightforward. The
microprocessor subsystem 30 determines what is to be the tasklspeed of the
stepper
motor 10 and, as such, can use this predetermined setting to retrieve the
expected
value from the look up table when sending the control signals to the driver
circuit 20.
[00017] It should be noted that white this document refers to a signal value
range
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
corresponding to an acceptable digital signal value for a motor's task or
speed, this
signal value range may be implemented by using a reference point value. The
reference point value can constitute a minimum or a maximum acceptable value
for the
digital signal. If the reference point value is used as a minimum value, any
digital signal
reading that is less than the reference point value indicates a malfunction or
an alarm
condition. Conversely, if the reference point value is used as a maximum
value, any
digital signal reading that is greater than the reference point value
indicates the
presence of the malfunction or alarm condition.
[00018] In one embodiment, the microprocessor subsystem 30 is comprised of a
microcontroller, a number of memory chips, including flash memory for storing
a
program and the lookup table, and assorted support chips and circuitry. It has
been
found that a microprocessor compatible with the Intel 8051 series of
microcontrollers
(such as the DS80C390 manufactured by Dallas Semiconductor) provided
acceptable
results. However, any suitable processing device such a microcontroller, a
microprocessor, or dedicated processing control circuitry may be used.
[00019] The driver circuit 20 may consist of a chip set specifically designed
as a
driver for a stepper motor 10. The chip set may consist of single or multiple
integrated
circuits (iCs) which collectively performs the driver function. The driver
circuit 20
receives digital input from the micropracessar subsystem 30 (perhaps through a
latch)
to determine which winding of the stepper motor receives current and when The
feedback signal, sent to the signal conditioning circuit 50 via the feedback
connection
40, is proportional to the current being sent by the driver circuit 20 to the
windings of the
stepper motor 10. Such a feedback signal is ideally a voltage proportional to
the
current in the stepper motor windings. For ease of implementation, a stepper
motor
driver integrated circuit (IC) which specifically implements a sense lead
carrying this
feedback signal may be used. In one embodiment, favourable results have been
obtained using the TEA 3718 family of stepper motor driver ICs manufactured by
SGS-
Thomson Microelectronics. However, other stepper motor driver ICs with a sense
head,
such as the M54646AP and M54676P from Mitsubishi and the NJM3717 from New
Japan Radio Co., Ltd., may be used. Clearly, depending on the number of
windings a
6
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
stepper motor may have, a corresponding number of driver ICs are to be used.
In one
embodiment, a 2 coil stepper motor will need two parallel driver ICs, with
each driver IC
driving one coil. Any stepper motor driver circuit, such as the examples
listed above,
which implements the chopper current control method of controlling the current
in the
stepper motor may be used.
[00020] The signal conditioning circuit 50 is used to amplify the feedback
signal
and integrate the signal, resulting in a conditioned feedback signal. The
feedback
signal may be too weak to be of proper use (in the order of hundreds of mV)
and the
feedback signal may be difficult to directly convert from an analog to a
digital signal. To
rectify this, cascaded amplifier and integration circuits may be used in the
signal
conditioning circuit 50.
[00021] Referring to Figure 2, an example of a conditioning circuit 50 is
illustrated.
As can be seen from Figure 2, in one embodiment the integrating circuit 50A is
an RC
low pass filter which effectively integrates the output of an amplifier
circuit 50B. The
input to amplifier circuit 50B is the feedback signal and the amplifier
circuit 50B itself is
composed of an operational amplifier (OA) 70 and a resistance 80 coupled
between the
negative input of the OA 70 and its output. A second resistance 90 is coupled
between
ground and the negative input of OA 70. The feedback signal is fed into the
positive
input of OA 70. Integrating circuit 50A consists of a resistance 100 receiving
the output
of circuit 50B and a capacitor 110 coupled between ground and the other end of
the
resistance 100. The amplifier circuit 50B receives the feedback signal,
amplifies it, and
passes it on to integrating circuit 50A. Integrating circuit 50A then
integrates the
amplified feedback signal, thereby "cleaning up" the signal and making it
suitable for
conversion from analog to digital.
[00022] The AID converter 60 may be, for ease of implementation, an off the
shelf
component. Favourable results have been achieved using an AD7829 8 channel
sampling analogldigital converter IC manufactured by Analog Devices.
[00023] Referring to Figure 3, a waveform derived from the current of the
windings
of the stepper motor is illustrated. The waveform is that of the conditioned
feedback
signal during operation of the stepper motor. The waveform illustrates the
conditioned
7
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
feedback signal after it has passed through the signal conditioning circuit
and prior to its
entering the Ai~ converter 60. As can be seen, the conditioned feedback signal
level
stays within a very narrow range when the motor is in operation. Once the
motor is
turned off, the conditioned feedback signal returns to zero. hiowever, during
a
malfunction or an alarm condition, this conditioned feedback signal level is
much
greater or much lesser than the regular narrow range. Figure 4 illustrates a
waveform
of a conditioned feedback signal during a motor stall. As can be seen, the
conditioned
feedback signal is within a narrow range until the motor stalls at point A. At
this instant,
a noticeable spike in the conditioned feedback signal level occurs and the
conditioned
feedback signal level than rapidly plateaus to a level (point ~) significantly
lower that its
previous range ( point C). It is this change in the conditioned feedback
signal level that
the microprocessor subsystem 30 detects when performing an effectively real-
time
comparison of the conditioned feedback signal level with an expected signal
level
range. The look up table approach is therefore advantageous since different
tasks and
different speeds for the stepper motor may require different current levels in
the stepper
motor windings and, hence, different conditioned feedback signal levels.
[00024) It should be noted that the change in the conditioned feedback signal
levels during the jam or motor stall condition is due to a change in the
impedance of the
electric motor. Experiments for one implementation have shown that when the
motor
stalls, the impedance of the motor changes and that this causes a drop in the
conditioned feedback signal. The conditioned feedback signal, derived from the
feedback signal (a voltage proportional to the current in the motor windings),
drops due
to this change in the impedance. The changed impedance of the stalled motor
causes
the driver circuit to change the switching pattern that it uses to drive the
different
windings in the motor. It is this change in the switching pattern that causes
the drop in
the conditioned feedback signal.
[000253 It should further be noted that if a jam, stall, or malfunction of the
stepper
motor is detected by the microprocessor subsystem as noted above, the
microprocessor subsystem may implement a number of options. Microprocessor
subsystem may
8
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
a) halt the job being executed;
b) send an alarm alerting an operator to the malfunction;
c) postpone the current job until the malfunction is rectified; or
d) any combination of the above options.
[00026] The alarm may easily be generated by the microprocessor subsystem by
setting a specific bit in a message sent to a networked central system. The
central
system can then record that the specific job the microprocessor subsystem was
working
on (such as a print job of printing a lottery ticket) was not completed and
that it will
therefore need to be restarted.
[00027] The steps in the above process are summarized in the flowchart of
Figure
5. The process begins with retrieving the appropriate expected signal levels
for a
specific task to be undertaken by the stepper motor (step 120). Once this is
done, the
stepper motor can then begin to execute its task as determined by the
microprocessor
subsystem. Once the coils in the stepper motor are energized by the driver
circuit, the
feedback signal travels back to the microprocessor subsystem and its digitized
and
conditioned version is received (step 130). The received digitized and
conditioned
feedback signal is then compared to the expected range of feedback signal
levels (step
140). After the comparison, a decision is made as to whether the received
digitized and
conditioned feedback signal was withing the expected signal levels (step 150).
If the
received signal is within the expected range, then another decision (step 160)
concerning whether the job is finished is made. If the task is not yet done,
then the
logic returns to step 130 - that of receiving more digitized feedback signals.
On the
other hand, if the task is done, a confirmation message confirming the
completion of the
task is sent to the central system (step 170). The central system can then
note that that
particular task was completed by the stepper motor. The logic then returns to
step 120
by way of connector A.
[0002] If the decision 150 is answered in the positive and that the received
feedback signal is not within the expected levels, a malfunction of the motor
or an alarm
condition must therefore have occurred. A message is thus sent to the central
system
9
CA 02435754 2003-07-22
noting the malfunction and the non-completion of the task (step 180). This
step may
also involve the activation of an alarm through the use of the microprocessor
subsystem.
[00029] It must be noted that the steps in the flowchart of Figure 5 are those
executed by the microprocessor subsystem. The amplification and integration of
the
feedback signal (executed by the conditioning circuit), is optional but
convenient. Also,
while the above invention may be implemented in lottery terminal printers, it
may also
be implemented in other types of printers andlor any other devices (such as
scanners)
which use electrical motors. Furthermore, while the above description refers
to stepper
motors, other types of electrical motors may be used with the selection of
appropriate
driver circuitry/ICs.
[00030] A person understanding this invention may row conceive of alternative
structures and embodiments or variations of the above all of which are
intended to fall
within the scope of the invention as defined in the claims that follow.
