Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
EXTERNAL THICKNESS CONTROL AND METHOD
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to improving the quality of products
produced by plastic resin extrusion lines and to the production of blown film.
When blown film is extruded, it typically is in the form of a continuous,
vertically oriented tube. The tube, which is in a molten state as it exits a
die,
expands in diameter as it is pulled continuously upward. The diameter
stabilizes
to a more or less constant value when the tube cools sufficiently to solidify.
This
solidification occurs a short distance from the die at what is called the
frost line.
Air cooling systems such as air rings outside of the tube and internal bubble
cooling (IBC) systems within the tube are provided close to the exit of the
die to
ensure that the tube cools quickly enough to remain stable.
After solidifying, the tube passes through stabilizers of various designs
and into a flattening device, known as a collapsing frame, to convert the
inflated
tube into a flattened out film with no air inside. This film is pressed
together by
motorized nip rolls that continually draw the film upward and away from the
extrusion process to form what is call "layflat." The die and nip roll act as
seals,
which in steady state, form a trapped, column of air with constant volume
inside
the tube.
As the film is extruded, thickness variations occur around the
circumference of the bubble. It is recognized that these variations are caused
by
such factors as circumferential nonuniformity in flow distribution channels
(ports
and spirals) within the die, melt viscosity nonuniformity, and inconsistent
annular
die gaps through which the polymer exits the die. Additionally, variability of
the
cooling air and non-uniformity of air aspirated into the cooling air stream
fxom
the atmosphere surrounding the extrusion line are major contributors to film
thickness variation.
Many film processors rely on conventional blown film equipment to
determine the film thickness. This approach typically yields an average
variation
of +/- 10%-20% in film thickness, overall. The presence of such thickness
variations creates problems that limit the throughput of downstream conversion
equipment, such as printing presses, laminators, or bag machines. In processes
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
where the film is not converted in-line, but is wound onto a roll prior to
converting, the thicker and thinner areas of many layers on the roll create
hills and
valleys on the roll surface, thus deforming the film and magnifying the
subsequent converting problem.
A widely practiced method for controlling blown film thickness variation
is the use of fans and barriers placed strategically around the process to
correct for
ambient air variability. This is usually done in combination with manual
operator
adjustment of the annular die gap through which the liquid polymer melt exits
to
help minimize the die gap and the effects of variation in the melt viscosity.
The
main problem with this approach is that the ambient conditions surrounding the
process constantly change and require continuous monitoring and barrier and/or
fan repositioning. This approach also does not take care of the relatively
narrow
thickness bands associated with the die ports and spirals, but does allow the
processor to use the highest performance equipment available on the market to
maximize throughtput on the line.
Thickness improvement over such manual adjustments is found in current
systems that actively measure the thickness of the film on-line. Employing
closed
loop control, these systems use computers to track thickness variations as
they
occur in the still-inflated bubble and to calculate corrections to individual
control
zones within the die or cooling systems. These zones impart localized
thickness
variations which are opposite to those measured and thus to some extent
correct
for thickness deviations circumferentially around the bubble, including to
differing degrees those variations caused by the ports and spirals within the
die.
Many such systems presently in use require the use of control equipment which
improves thickness control but at the expense of throughput rate. A problem
associated with all automatic systems is the necessary complexity which
creates
high cost and requires the use of skilled operators and maintenance personnel.
One approach seeks to control blown film thickness variation by direct
mechanical adjustment and deformation of the die lip. In these systems,
localized, circumferentially variable, mechanical adjustments to the die lip
cause
detrimentally large hoop stress and elastic forces to develop in the die lip,
thereby
resisting deformation and spreading the effect of the adjustment over a larger
area
than that intended. These problems limit the effective resolution. These
systems
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
have correspondingly poor control over thickness variation but do not preclude
the use of high performance cooling systems which maximize throughput rate.
Another approach utilizes direct, circumferentially variable, heating of the
exit lip from the die. In these systems, individual heaters embedded in the
die lip
locally heat the lips. Since heat spreads outward in all directions through
the
steel, the effect is not as locally concentrated as desired and resolution is
reduced.
Also, heat that is added to the die lip transfers this heat to the molten
polymer,
thereby raising its local temperature. This extra heat must be removed by the
cooling systems, forcing the throughput rate of film production to be lowered.
Yet another approach employs circumferentially variable heating of the
cooling air which flows from the primary cooling ring surrounding the blown
film
bubble. Individual actuators control the local temperature of the cooling air
and
affect the thickness of the film. Due to the large volumes of air and
associated
turbulence involved, mixing occurs and significantly degrades the performance
of
this type of system. Also, heat that is added to the cooling air have the
drawback
of losing cooling capacity since overall temperature is raised, thus forcing
the
throughput rate of film production to be lowered.
A more commonly used approach alters in a circumferentially variable
way, the flow of air exiting the primary cooling ring° surrounding the
exterior of
the blown film bubble. Individual low pressure actuators mechanically alter
the
flow of cooling air through associated control zones by using an air blade to
section off and bleed air out and away from the air ring which starve feeds
the
local air flow without causing appreciable pressure drop across the actuator
as is
described in US Patent No. 5,281,375. The thickness of the film is affected
because more or less heat is removed due to the presence of more or Iess
cooling
air. Typically, single flow designs of air rings that use this approach
produce
acceptable thickness control capability, but have a drawback in that the
reduced
cooling capability lowers processing throughput rate.
Air blades more recently have been fitted to high performance dual lip air
rings, such as those manufactured by Addex, Inc. Multiple radially oriented
channels located within the plenum are used to evenly distribute and direct
the air
flow to the air blades where the low pressure drop air blades section off some
of
the air that is delivered to the lips the same as with a single flow air ring.
This
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
approach has a significant limitation in that there is limited control range
capability and can only partially compensate for variations present on a
typical
blown film process. These systems suffer from the additional disadvantage of
added complexity which adds significantly to cost and reduced resolution due
to
the size of the air blade actuators which limits the ability to control narrow
thickness variations commonly present. These systems retain their high
throughput capabilities.
A further approach controls in a circumferentially variable way the flow of
air exiting the internal bubble cooling (IBC) ring contained within the blown
film
bubble. This approach does not affect bubble stability since the tube does not
lock on the internal cooler and has excellent control of thickness variation.
Further, it allows the use of any high performance cooling system exterior to
the
bubble that is desired and therefore allows for maximum throughput rate. One
drawback, however, is that the system cannot be fitted to smaller die
diameters,
i.e., less than about 10 inches (2,50mrn), due to space constraints.
Additionally,
not all processors of film want to employ IBC systems within their process.
It is highly desirable to produce higher quality film during the extrusion
process so that the downstream equipment can be run faster and produce better
end use products with more consistent thickness while at the same time
maximizing the throughput rate of the extrusion line through the use of high
performance dual flow air rings and without size restrictions or the
requirement to
use IBC. It is further desirable to accomplish this using a simpler design to
minimize cost and labor.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention includes an external air ring thickness profile
contxol system on a blown film extrusion line. The external thickness profiler
of
the present invention includes a simple to use and inexpensive manual
actuation
system as well as an automatic actuation system. Rather than trying to
minimize
pressure drop with an actuating zone, the system of the present invention
employs
a high pressure drop actuator which acts locally to alter air flow without
affecting
critical relative flows to lips where the air is provided to the blown film.
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
According to one embodiment of the present invention, air is provided
through radial channels and then to the lips, in which case cross-sections at
actuation points are varied in one or more channels to locally alter air flow
such
that there is a high pressure drop before reaching the lips. This drop allows
the air
flow to normalize within the channel after actuation and thus to develop into
uniform pipe flow. Upon exiting the radialLy inward end of the multiple
channels,
the air flows are under semi-laminar flow conditions inwardly through the lip
section, thus preventing appreciable mixing with air from other channels.
After
the actuator, the length of the radial channel should be of sufficient length,
e.g.,
about 8 times the effective channel diameter or greater, to fully generate
pipe flow
and create the desired pressure drop. Shorter lengths channels would reduce
the
effect on local thickness. Further, it is preferred to deliver the air to the
lips as
soon as possible after it clears the radial channels so that the pressure drop
in the
lips does not become large compared to the pressure drop through the radial
channels, a situation that would also serve to dilute the local effect on
thickness.
Manually controllable barriers can be used as actuators to provide a low
cost alternative to automatic control. These barriers can be provided as
screws
that are handled in a similar fashion to die adjustment bolts commonly used by
operators when adjusting die lips for thickness optimization, or as blocks to
block
portions of an annular region between air inlet and lips. The thickness
adjustment.
can be well pronounced and fine-tunable using procedures that are generally
understood by operating personnel in other contexts. A further advantage is
that
the resolution attainable is high because there can be over 120 control zones
even
on very small processes and hoop stresses are not an issue.
Other embodiments add automatically controllable barriers, such as
pistons, to allow for automatic closed loop control of thickness variation.
In a dual external ring, it is desirable to locate the actuator before the air
flows separates to the two lips. About 10% of air flows to a lower lip,
typically
located outwardly concentric with an exit point of the molten tube from the
die.
The remaining 90% passes to a main lip located concentrically above and
generally outward from the lower lip, as is readily know in present dual lip
air
rings. By actuating well before this lip section, semi-laminar flow air acts
Locally
to divert at the same relative proportions to the lower and main lip and thus
not
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
affect bubble stability as long as a certain minimum air flow is present to
develop
Bernoulli forces strong enough to just "lock" the tube into the lips.
Other features and advantages will become apparent from the following
detailed description, drawings, and claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic side view showing a blown film extrusion apparatus
including an external thickness profiler according to the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a schematic cross sectional view of the external thickness
profiler of FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 is a perspective cross sectional view of the external thickness
profiler without the outer plenum portion.
FIG. 4 is a partially cut away perspective view of the radial channels and
actuator section of the manual thickness profiler of FTG. 3.
FIG. 5a is a graphical representation of the thickness profile resulting on a
blown film extrusion line taken with the manual thickness profiler in the
neutral
position.
FIG. 5b is a graphical representation of the thickness profile resulting on a
blown film extrusion line taken with the manual thickness profiler inducing
thickness bands at four equally spaced positions.
FIG. 6 is a cross sectional perspective view on an enlarged scale of the
thickness profiler of the present invention incorporating automatic
positioning of
actuators.
FIG. 7 is a partially cut away perspective view of an actuator section of
the manual thickness profiler according to another embodiment of the present
invention.
DETAIL DESCRIPTION
FIG. 1 illustrates a known system for extrusion of molten plastic resin to
form blown film. Plastic pellets are fed into a feed hopper 2 and transferred
into
an extruder 4 where the pellets are melted, mixed, and pressurized by the
action of
an extruder screw. The melt exits extruder 4 and is conveyed through a die
block
6 where it is directed upwardly through a vertical neck 8 into the bottom of a
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
blown film die 10. The plastic melt flow is designed to form an annular,
cylindrical plastic melt flow 12 which is extruded from an annular orifice at
the
top of die 10. This annular melt flow is continually drawn away from die 10 in
a
manner generally concentric with a process centerline 14. The annular diameter
of the cylindrical plastic melt flow 12 enlarges as it progresses from the die
until
it reaches a frost line I6 (indicated diagrammatically by a saw-tooth Line) to
form
a cooled, solidified plastic tubular film bubble 18.
Primary cooling air for the process is supplied to an external thickness
profiler 20 from an air source (not shown). External thickness profiler 20
functions as the primary cooling air ring for the process. The air is applied
to
contact the extruding plastic melt adjacent a base portion of the bubble by
air ring
lips 22. The air flows in circumferentially controlled annular air streams 24
along
an outside expanding surface of the bubble.
Inside the bubble and concentric with centerline 14 is an internal bubble
cooling (IBC) system 26. System 26 provides internal cooling air to contact an
inside surface of the extruding plastic melt adjacent the base portion of the
bubble
and flows in annular air streams 28 along the inside expanding surface of the
bubble. The plastic melt is cooled sufficiently to solidify into tubular
bubble 18 at
frost line 16.
Internal cooling air is provided through air passages 30 located in die 10 to
IBC system 26. Bubble 18 is sealed at the top by nip rolls 32, 32a and at the
bottom by die 10, and thus has a closed volume. To maintain a constant bubble
volume, air is exhausted out of bubble 18 at the same rate that it is pumped
in
through air passages 34 located in die 10 according to known techniques,
enabling
the annular dimension of bubble 18 to remain constant.
Also, according to known techniques, tubular bubble 18 is continually
drawn upward through stabilizer 35 and collapsing frames 36 and 36a where it
is
compressed into a flat sheet of film 38, also known as "layflat," as it passes
through a nipping point between nip rolls 32 and 32a. These nip rolls are
driven
to continually pull the film through the extrusion process. Layflat film 38 is
then
converted andlor wound into finished product by downstream processing
equipment.
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
Non-uniformities in the extrusion system, for instance non-uniformities in
resin flow produced by the discrete flow passages commonly used in die 10,
cause
circumferential thickness variations in bubble 18. Thickness variations are
measured by sensor 40, e.g., of the known capacitive or nuclear back-scatter
types, which is scanned around the circumference of bubble 18 by circularly
rotatable track 42. Thickness information and respective position information
of
the thickness sensor are continually provided to thickness monitoring console
44
which provides operator 46 with feedback of the magnitude and location of
cicumferential thickness variations in bubble 18. Tn response to feedback from
thickness monitoring console 44, operator 46 changes circumferentially
controlled
annular air streams 24 to achieve the desired thickness profile around the
circumference of bubble 18.
FIGS. 2 and 3 are schematic and perspective cross sectional views of the
external thickness profiler 20 (FIG. 1) and the sets of air ring lips. Primary
cooling air enters the external thickness profiler through multiple air inlets
48
formed integrally with an outer plenum 50. Air passes more or less
tangentially
from inlets 48 into annular plenum chamber 56 formed by outer plenum 50, top
plenum wall 52 and bottom plenum wall 54. This structure is generally known.
Multiple air inlets 48 extend partially along the circumference, and connect
through large open passages (not shown) as part of plenum 56.
Referring also to FIG. 4, tangential air flow patterns are converted to
radial air flow patterns by passing air into multiple radial channels 58
formed
monolithically in bottom plenum wall 54 and enclosed by top plenum wall 52.
Multiple radial channels 58 are arranged outwardly and circumferentially
equally
spaced around the air ring lips to provide air flow to the air ring lips. FIG.
2
shows a series of the inner radial ends of channels 58.
Local air flow through each radial channel 58 can be independently
modified and controlled by using manually actuated barriers, shown here as
screws 60, with one actuating screw 60 associated with each radial channel 58,
thereby allowing for circumferentially variable air flow to be delivered to
the air
ring lips. Barriers could potentially be provided for only some of the
channels.
Circumferentially variable air flow enters lip plenum 62. An air dam 64
(FIG. 3) deflects a portion of this air (about 10%) through a back-pressure
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
generated by the air ring lips 22, through multiple lower lip feed holes 66
and
directs this air to Lower lip 68. Referring also to FIG. 1, Lip 68 is
coaxially spaced
just outwardly of a base of cylindrical plastic melt flow 12 and typically
just
above die 10. This air begins to flow upwardly as part of circumferentially
controlled annular air stream 24 along the outside of the expanding
cylindrical
plastic melt flow 12. Referring mainly to FIG. 3, a majority of the
circumferentially variable air, typically about 90%, passes under air dam 64
and
exits through main Lip 70 where it rejoins air from lower lip 68. The balance
of
air flow exiting lower lip 68 and main lip 70 is critical to maintaining
bubble
stability.
Air exiting from main lip 70 forcefully acts due to Bernoulli forces on
cylindrical plastic melt flow 12 to hold it closely spaced, about r/4 inch
(6mm)
concentrically inward from main lip 70. The local flow volume of controlled
annular air stream 24 must remain above a certain minimum, such as an
equivalent to a flow that creates about two inches of water pressure drop
through
lips 22 under normal operating conditions; otherwise, insufficient holding
force
will be present and bubble 18 will become unstable.
Manual actuating screws 60 should be located in an air flow region of
pressure drop large enough to be significant compared to the pressure drop of
lips
22 and be constrained sufficiently to flow laminarly to minimize mixing
effects
which would act to erase the effects of circumferentially variable air flow.
It has
been found through experimentation that radial channels 58 account for
slightly
more pressure drop than the pressure drop from lips 22, making radial channels
58
a good location for manual actuating screws 60. Further, it is desirable that
radial
channels 58 are made to be at least 8 times longer than their effective
diameter to
generate semi-laminar pipe flow as is commonly understood within industry for
air flow in a pipe. Manual actuating screws 60 are preferably placed at or
near the
inlet to radial channels 58 to allow radial channels 58 to be long after such
flow
regulation by manual actuating screws 60 to generate semi-laminar pipe flow
and
thus help prevent appreciable mixing effects when the air exits the radial
channels. Unlike some devices in which a diverting blade is used to slice and
divert a significant portion of air flow out and away from the air ring Lips,
in this
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
embodiment, the air that is provided to the radial channels all goes to the
lips
without being diverted through exit slots or other intentional means.
The barriers can actually be placed anywhere along the radial channels
provided that the pressure drop across these barriers is significant compared
to the
pressure drop across the lips such that back pressure and air mixing at the
inner
end of the radial channels are not significant. The desired relationship is
for the
pressure drop across the barriers to be 50% or more of the pressure drop
across
the lips and preferably at Ieast equal to that pressure drop.
To allow desired control of the thickness at desired locations, a change in
the barrier in one or more nearby radial channels should have a predictable
effect
at that same circumferential position in the bubble. It would be most
desirable,
for example, if control could be achieved such that a change over a 10% range
of
the radial channels would yield a change in just 10% of the resulting bubble,
thus
allowing fine control. There generally will be at least some side-to-side
mixing of
air as it exits the radial channels and some mixing due to back pressure from
the
lips. As long as the pressure drop is substantial compared to the lips,
however,
the attempt to localize the change will be reasonably effective; if the
pressure
drop is insignificant, however, back pressure will create significant mixing
and
churning and effectively wash out the effect of the change in the barriers in
the
radial channels.
FIGS. 5a and 5b together show the ability of external thickness profiler to
affect the thickness profile around the circumference of bubble 18. FIG. 5a
depicts an actual process producing 2 mil (50 micron) thick film with the
resulting
profile indicating a total thickness variation of about 8 to 10 percent for
0° to 360°
around a circumference of bubble 18 with all manual actuating screws 60 being
in
a neutral 100% fully open position. The same process without changing any
operating conditions is shown in FIG. 5b, this time with manual actuating
screws
60 being repositioned to 20% open over a width of 25° at four equally
space
locations of 0°, 90°, 180°, and 360°. Thickness
bands 72A, 72B, 72C, and 72D
are clearly evident with a width commensurate to the 25° spread of
actuation and
with total magnitude of about 25% of nominal thickness, which is 2 1h to 3
times
more than is required to offset the natural variation present in FIG. 5a. As
overall
film thickness varies, typical process variations as a percentage are
magnified
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
11
roughly inversely proportionally to the overall thickness; similarly, the
response
magnitude of thickness control varies as well. For example, a 1 mil (25
micron)
film might exhibit 16% to 20% variation and the actuation response under
similar
conditions described above would be a magnitude of about 50% again, which is
more than large enough to compensate.
FIG. 6 is a cross sectional perspective view of external thickness profiler
20 of the present invention incorporating automatic positioning of actuators.
All
components function the same as before except that manual actuating screws 60
are replaced by automatic actuator pistons. Automatic actuator pistons 74 are
frictionally held in place by o-rings (not shown) in top plenum wall 52.
Piston
adjusting grooves 76 are cut into automatic actuator pistons 74 and aligned to
allow a servo wedge 78, to fully engage. A servo positioner 80 vertically
adjusts
the position of servo wedge 78 which in turn locally adjusts one of the
multiple
automatic actuator pistons 74. Rotatable annular ring 82 is driven and
positioned
by motor 84 and is sandwiched using ball bearings between top plenum wall 52
and a top plenum clamping plate 52a to allow for rotation. Servo positioner 80
together with integral servo wedge 78 are attached to a rotatable annular ring
82
to allow for the positioning of servo wedge 78 to align with any one of the
multiple automatic actuator pistons 74 located circumferentially within
external
thickness profiler 20, thereby allowing for individual adjustment of each
automatic actuator piston 74 one at a time. Servo control cable 86 is
connected on
one end to the fixed top plenum clamping plate 52a at position 86a and is
connected at the other end to rotatable annular ring 82 at position 86b such
that
signals and power can be brought to and from servo positioner 80.
FIG. 7 is a view similar to FIG. 4 but showing an alternative embodiment.
Unlike FIG. 4 which shows radial channels with sidewalk that prevent side-to-
side mixing from one channel to the next, FIG. 7 is for an embodiment in which
there are no such radial channels but rather a continuous annular region. In
this
embodiment, bolts 60A extend through nuts and through a top wall and are
rigidly
connected to elongated and radially oriented blocks 61. Block 61 effectively
controls the top wall of the annular region and thus can be used to allow or
restrict
air flow in a controllable manner. If the pressure drop is sufficiently large
across
the blocks even when fully open, the side-to-side mixing and churning effects
at
CA 02440638 2003-09-11
WO 02/075248 PCT/US02/07775
12
the inner end of the annular region will be sufficiently small such that the
operator
can achieve the desired control over the cooling air on the bubble. The system
of
FIG. 7 can be made automatic in a manner similar to that shown in FIG. 6.
The present invention has been described in connection with certain
structural embodiments and it will be understood that various modifications
(such
as individual automatic actuators) can be made to the above-described
embodiments without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as
defined in the appended claims. While a dual lip air ring has been shown, the
system and method could be used with a single lip arrangement.
What is claimed is:
