Language selection

Search

Patent 2516057 Summary

Third-party information liability

Some of the information on this Web page has been provided by external sources. The Government of Canada is not responsible for the accuracy, reliability or currency of the information supplied by external sources. Users wishing to rely upon this information should consult directly with the source of the information. Content provided by external sources is not subject to official languages, privacy and accessibility requirements.

Claims and Abstract availability

Any discrepancies in the text and image of the Claims and Abstract are due to differing posting times. Text of the Claims and Abstract are posted:

  • At the time the application is open to public inspection;
  • At the time of issue of the patent (grant).
(12) Patent Application: (11) CA 2516057
(54) English Title: STOPPER OF VESSEL
(54) French Title: FERMETURE A OUVERTURE PAR POUSSEE
Status: Dead
Bibliographic Data
(51) International Patent Classification (IPC):
  • B65D 51/18 (2006.01)
  • B65D 51/22 (2006.01)
  • B65D 51/24 (2006.01)
(72) Inventors :
  • RHO, HEE KWON (Republic of Korea)
(73) Owners :
  • RHO, HEE KWON (Republic of Korea)
(71) Applicants :
  • RHO, HEE KWON (Republic of Korea)
(74) Agent: GOUDREAU GAGE DUBUC
(74) Associate agent:
(45) Issued:
(86) PCT Filing Date: 2004-02-14
(87) Open to Public Inspection: 2004-10-07
Examination requested: 2005-08-12
Availability of licence: N/A
(25) Language of filing: English

Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT): Yes
(86) PCT Filing Number: PCT/KR2004/000303
(87) International Publication Number: WO2004/085278
(85) National Entry: 2005-08-12

(30) Application Priority Data:
Application No. Country/Territory Date
10-2003-0009544 Republic of Korea 2003-02-14
10-2003-0017929 Republic of Korea 2003-03-21
10-2004-0005212 Republic of Korea 2004-01-27

Abstracts

English Abstract




A closure with a push type opener and a device for automatically keeping slit
sealing member inside the cloture. The closure includes a closure body
detachably coupled at an inlet of a container, a cutting region provided at
the closure body and sealing the inlet of the container or the closure body as
a hemispherical region descends by a pressing method, and a device having a
function of keeping the slit sealing member therein. The sealing member can be
easily by using the cutting region without touching it by hand, and thus, a
content of a container can be hygienically taken. In addition, content
separately stored in the container and in the closure can be simply mixed for
use.


French Abstract

Cette invention concerne une fermeture comportant une ouverture par poussée et un dispositif servant à maintenir automatiquement l'élément d'étanchéité fendu à l'intérieur de la fermeture. Cette fermeture comprend un corps de fermeture couplé détachable au niveau d'une ouverture d'admission d'un contenant, une zone de coupe située au niveau du corps de fermeture et servant à sceller l'ouverture d'admission du contenant ou du corps de fermeture lorsqu'une zone hémisphérique descend sous l'effet d'une pression et un dispositif servant à maintenir l'élément d'étanchéité fendu à l'intérieur de la fermeture. L'élément d'étanchéité peut être facilement retiré à l'aide de la zone de coupe sans être touché, ce qui permet d'accéder au contenu d'un contenant de façon hygiénique. En outre, des contenus stockés séparément dans le contenant et dans la fermeture peuvent être mélangés simplement en vue de leur utilisation.

Claims

Note: Claims are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.



CLAIMS


1. One piece or two or more pieces of closures of a container
comprising:
a closure body detachably coupled at an inlet of a container; and
a sealing member provided at the closure body and sealing the inlet
of the container or the closure body as a hemispherical region descends by
a pressing method,
wherein a cutting support 41 is installed inside a thin connection film
33 of the closure (Refer to a principle presented in a 'Waveform annular
body and Cap(B) described with reference to Figure 1 of Japanese
Application No. Sho 57-126367 entitled 'Cap' filed on February 3, 1981 by
the applicant of DAINIPPON INK AND CHEMICALS, INC., a former patent
application), a structure having a new function such as a sealing member
keeping recess 43 and a cutting blade 44 are installed at the cutting
support 41, and such a principle that a sealing member 2 sealed at the
inlet of the container is penetrated by a cutting blade 42 of the closure,
slit
by the cutting support blade 44 and then inserted in the sealing member
keeping recess 43 for storage is applied.
2. The closure of claim 1, wherein a wrapper installation jaw 16
for mounting a wrapper 15 is installed at an inner or outer surface of an
outer wall (protecting wall) 11 of an upper portion of the closure, and a
spoon mounting jaw 14 for mounting a spoon 13 is installed at an inner



13




surface of the outer wall 11.

3. One piece or two or more pieces of closures, wherein a
cutting support 41, a cutting blade 42, a cutting support blade 44 and a
sealing member keeping recess 43 are installed at an inner surface of the
side of a body of the closure.

4. The closure of claim 1 or 2, wherein a thin connection film
has at least one crease so that a hemispherical (dome) region can be
easily folded.

5. The closure of claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein a sealing member
keeping recess of the closure for keeping sealing member is provided to
keep a sealing member which has been penetrated, slit and separated.

6. The closure of claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein a sealing portion, a
connected portion, a perforated portion or one or more undercuts are
installed at a lower portion of an outer wall region of the closure coupled to
a container.

7. The closure of claim 1 or 2, wherein a pressing plate 32 in
various forms at the center of an upper end of a dome region is provided
so as to easily press the dome region.

14


8. The closure of claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein the cutting support
blade 44 is installed at the cutting support which has the sealing member
keeping recess for keeping the sealing member slit after being penetrated
by the cutting blade and a penetrating bar 45.

9. The closure of claim 1 or 2, wherein a penetrating bar 45 is
installed vertically and downwardly at the center of the pressing plate 32 of
the hemispherical region 30 of the closure, and has a cylindrical shape, a
jaw at its lower portion, and a sharp end portion to facilitate penetrating
the
sealing member.

10. The closure of claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein an open bar 45 in
various forms is installed vertically and downwardly at the center of an
inner surface of the pressing plate 32 of the hemispherical region 30 of the
closure.

11. The closure of claim 1 or 2, wherein a suitable open bar 46
(e.g., a cross type or a 'T'-shape one, etc.) is installed at the position of
the
penetrating bar 45 to substitute the penetrating bar 45 in order to easily
open the sealing member 2, and an upper space 35 is formed at a certain
portion inside the hemispherical region 30 to keep a content 3 such as a
solution or powder.

12. The closure of claim 3, wherein a wrapper installation jaw 16
for mounting a wrapper 15 is formed at an inner or outer surface of an

15




outer wall (protecting wall) 11 of an upper portion of the closure, and a
spoon mounting jaw 14 for mounting a spoon 13 is formed at an inner
surface of the outer wall 11.
16

Description

Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.




CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
CLOSURE WITH PUSH TYPE OPENER
TECHNICAL FIELD
The present invention relates to a closure with a push type opener
and, more particularly, to one piece or two or more pieces of closures
capable of opening a sealing member which blocks an inlet of a container
or an inner side of a closure by pressing it, and capable of automatically
inserting a slit sealing member inside the closure for storage.
BACKGROUND ART
Figure 1 is a sectional view showing a closure of a container of a
beverage container (bottle) having an opening structure in accordance with
a conventional art.
The closure of a beverage container includes a closure body 5
detachably coupled at an inlet of a container 1 sealed by a sealing member
2; an ascending/descending member 6 installed to be moved linearly up
and down at an upper outer side of the closure body 5; and an auxiliary
closure 7 capped at an upper portion of the closure body 5.
When a user wants to drink a beverage in a closure-capped
2 o container, the user may separate the closure body 5 from the beverage
container 1 and remove the sealing member 2 blocking the inlet of the
container 1. And then, the user may couple the closure body 5 to the inlet
of the beverage container 1, open the auxiliary closure 7 and grasp the
ascending/descending member 5 by hand and pull it upwardly. Then, an
1



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
upper side surface 6' of the ascending/descending member 6 is isolated
from a head part 5' of the closure body to open the closure of the beverage
container 1, so that the user can drink the beverage by inclining the
beverage container 1.
If the user does not want to drink the beverage any further, he/she
can press the ascending/descending member 6 by hand to return it to its
original position, thereby closing the inlet of the beverage container 1.
However, the conventional closure of the beverage container having
such an opening structure has the following problems.
That is, in order to open the container, the closure body 5 is
separated from the container 1, the sealing member 2 is removed, and
then, the closure body 5 is coupled again to the beverage container 1,
causing inconvenience to open the closure.
Especially, since the sealing member 2 is firmly attached for sealing
at the inlet of the container 1, it is not easy for the user to open it, and
thus,
in most cases, the user must open it by hand, causing a problem that the
inlet of the container 1 is contaminated in the process of removing the
sealing member 2, which is not hygienic.
In addition, the conventional closure makes it difficult to keep a
different content from a current content put in the container 1, so a
container is additionally required or the structure of the closure is to be
formed more complicate.
Moreover, when the user wants to drink a beverage contained in the
beverage container, he/she must open the closure by putting up the
2



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
ascendingldescending member 6 by hand, and after finishing drinking the
beverage, he/she must push the ascending/descending member to its
original position by hand, contaminating the portion where the beverage is
discharged, which is thus insanitary.
TECHNICAL GIST OF THE PRESENT INVENTION
Therefore, it is one object of the present invention to provide a
closure with a push type opener capable of opening a container
hygienically, removing a sealing member simply and keeping a slit sealing
member inside a closure for storage by constructing such that the sealing
member for sealing an inlet of the container is opened by pressing without
separating the closure from a container, and mounting a spoon for a user
to have a content in the closure to thereby avoid users' inconvenience of
preparing a spoon personally.
Another object of the present invention is to provide a closure with a
push type opener capable of improving users' convenience with a
construction that a mixed beverage or a food stuff can be kept in one
container and closure without a necessity of keeping them in individual
containers, and contents contained in each container and closure can be
2 o mixed by opening a sealing member by pressing, to thereby simplify
keeping and mixing individual contents.
Referring back to a problem of the conventional art, when the
sealing member mounted at the inlet of the container is to be removed, the
closure is first released from the container, the sealing member is torn off
3



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
directly by hand or by using a tool (knife or a gimlet), and then, the content
in the container can be used. In such a case; it is quite inconvenient for a
user to use the closure, the sealing member is quite roughly torn off, and it
is not easy to handle and keep the removed sealing member in storage.
In order to accomplish the above objects, there is provided a closure
having an inlet in the container processed by a sealing member or having a
sealing member mounted in the closure, including a device for cutting the
sealing member and keeping slit sealing member in the closure for storage,
whereby in a state that the closure is coupled at the inlet of the container,
a
1o spoon 13 mounted at an upper portion of the closure is released without
isolating the closure and the container, and a pressing plate 32 of an upper
end portion of a hemispherical (dome) region 30 of an upper portion of the
closure by the thumb is vertically pressed to make the sealing member
sealed at the inlet of the container be penetrated by several cutting blades
42 installed at a lower portion of a cutting region 40 of the closure (Refer
to
a principle presented in a 'Waveform Annular Body and other Cap(B)
described with reference to Figure 1 of Japanese Application No. Sho
57-126367 entitled 'Cap' filed on February 3, 1981 by the applicant of
DAINIPPON INK AND CHEMICALS, INC., a former patent application),
2 0 and then, when the closure is rotated in an opening direction, the sealing
member is completely cut by cutting blades 44 of a cutting support 41 and
smoothly inserted into a sealing member keeping recess 43 in the closure.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
4



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
Figure 1 is a sectional view showing a closure of a beverage
container having an opening structure in accordance with a conventional
art;
Figure 2 is a bird's-eye-view projected over an external structure of
the closure;
Figure 3 is a sectional view showing 'before operation' with respect
to an internal structure of the closure;
Figure 4 is a sectional view showing 'after operation' with respect to
an internal structure of the closure;
1o Figure 5 is a drawing illustrating a cutting blade installed at a lower
portion of a cutting support, of which
Figure 5A is an unfolded sectional view; and
Figure 5B is a bottom view;
Figure 6 is an enlarged sectional view of a sealing member keeping
recess 43 installed at a middle portion of the cutting support;
Figure 7 is a drawing illustrating a cutting support blade installed at
the side of the sealing member keeping recess of the cutting support, of
which
Figure 7A is a sectional view; and
Figure 7B is a bottom view;
Figure 8 is a sectional view showing a spoon installed at a spoon
mounting jaw installed at an upper portion of an outer wall (protecting wall)
of the closure and a wrapper installed at a wrapper installation jaw;
Figure 9 is a projected plan view showing the spoon installed at the
5



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
spoon mounting jaw installed at the upper portion of the outer wall
(protecting wall) of the closure and the wrapper installed at the wrapper
installation jaw;
Figure 9 is a drawing illustrating a penetrating bar, of which
Figure 9A is a sectional view; and
Figure 9B is a bottom view;
Figure 10 is a drawing illustrating 'before operation' of the closure
having only a cutting region without a hemispherical region;
Figure 11 is a drawing illustrating 'before operation' of the closure
1o having only the cutting region without the hemispherical region;
Figure 12 is a drawing illustrating 'before operation' of the closure
having only the cutting region without the hemispherical region;
Figure 13 is a sectional view showing addition of the penetrating bar
or an open bar in Figure 3; and
Figure 14 is a sectional view showing addition of the penetrating bar
or an open bar in Figure 4.
MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Preferred embodiments of the present invention will now be
2 o described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
The structure of a closure in accordance with the present invention
will be described as follows.
The closure is divided into an outer wall region 10, a hemispherical
(dome) region 30 and a cutting region 40.
6



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
The outer wall region 10 is coupled at its lower portion to an inlet of
a container 1, and its upper portion is more protruded than the inlet of the
container. A spoon mounting jaw 14 and a wrapper installation jaw 16 are
installed at an outer wall 11 of the outer wall region 10. A knurl 12 is
installed at an outer surface of the outer wall region. At a lower side of the
outer wall region 10 coupled to the inlet of the container 1, there are
formed a sealing portion 17, a connected potion 18, a perforated portion 19
or an under cut 20, and the knurl 12A.
The dome region 30 is surrounded by an upper portion-opened
cylindrical outer wall 11, and includes a pressing plate 32 installed at an
upper end of a hemisphere (dome) 31, a thin connection film 33 connecting
the outer wall region and the hemispherical (dome) region. The thin
connection film has at least one crease 34.
The cutting region 40 is installed at a lower inner portion of the
dome region. The cutting region 40 has a cylindrical shape with a lower
portion opened, and is installed in a vertical direction. The cutting region
40
includes a cutting support 41 required for penetrating and cutting a sealing
member, a cutting blade 42, a cutting support blade 44 for slitting the
sealing member, and a sealing member keeping recess 43 for keeping the
2 o slit sealing member.
A first embodiment of the present invention will now be described
with reference to Figures 3 and 4.
A closure includes a wrapper installation jaw 16 installed at the inner
surface or the outer surface of the outer wall (protecting wall) 11, a
7



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
wrapper 15 mounted at the wrapper installation jaw 16, the spoon
mounting jaw 14 installed at the inner surface of the outer wall 11, a spoon
for scooping a content, a pressing plate 32 formed thicker than the
connection film 33 of the dome region 30, a crease 34 allowing the
connection film to be easily folded, a cutting blade 42 of the cutting region
40 penetrating the sealing member, a sealing member keeping recess 43
keeping the slit sealing member, and a cutting support blade 44 of the
cutting support 41 for completely slitting the penetrated sealing member.
The closure according to the first embodiment of the present
1o invention is applied to a container in which content 3 is put in a paste
state,
or content such as a thick solution or a powder product, which a user can
have with a spoon.
A second embodiment of the present invention will now be
described, in which the closure does not have such a spoon mounting jaw
and a spoon as in the first embodiment of Figures 3 and 4.
Its operational order is as follows.
1 ) The wrapper 15 mounted at the wrapper installation jaw 16
installed at an inner or outer surface of the outer wall (protection wall) 11,
namely, a portion of the outer wall region 10 of the closure is removed by
using fingers or other tools.
2) The pressing plate 32 of the dome region is softly pressed by the
thumb in a vertical direction downwardly.
3) The thin connection film 33 is folded by virtue of the pressing
force and the cutting region 40 also descends.
8



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
4) The cutting blade 42 of the cutting region 40 installed at the lower
side of the dome region 30 mounted at the inlet of the container descends
to penetrate the sealing member 2, and at this time, the folded thin
connection film 33 remains folded, not being recovered to its original state.
5) The sealing member which has been penetrated by the cutting
blade 42 is inserted in the sealing member keeping recess 43 (Refer to
Figure 4).
6) In order to release the closure from the container, the closure is
rotated in an opening direction.
7) A portion of the sealing member 2 inserted in the sealing member
keeping recess 43, which has survived the cutting and thus remained intact,
if any, is cut by the sharp cutting support blade 44 installed perpendicular
in the opening direction to the side of the cutting support 41 and inserted
into the sealing member keeping recess 43 completely, and the slit sealing
member 2A is kept in the sealing member keeping recess 43 of the
closure.
The closure in accordance with the second embodiment of the
present invention is applied to a container which holds a watery solution
that users may have by applying their mouths to the container, or to a
container having a content can be poured into a different container for a
user to have, e.g., milk, watery yogurt, cafe latte, or the like.
A third embodiment of the present invention will now be described.
In such a structure of the closure as in first embodiment, an open
bar 46 for penetrating the sealing member to open it is installed at a lower
9



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
portion of the pressing plate of the hemispherical region, and an upper
space for storing content inside the hemispherical region is formed.
A fourth embodiment of the present invention will now be described.
Figures 11 and 12 illustrate installation of the cutting region 40 at an
inner wall surface of the outer wall region, without having the hemispherical
region 30. A closure in accordance with the fourth embodiment of the
present invention operates as follows.
1 ) A closure 4 coupled spaced with a certain interval 50 from the
inlet of the container 1 with the sealing member 2 mounted therein is
rotated (in case of a screw) in a closing direction and descends vertically
by a pressing force (in case of an undercut) to be closed completely.
2) The perforated portion 19 of the sealing portion 17 is torn off by
virtue of the rotational force or the vertical descending force and the
closure is tightly attached to the inlet of the container.
3) The sealing member 2 is penetrated by the cutting blade 42
installed at the inner surface of the closure 4, cut by the cutting support
blade 44 and completely separated from the inlet of the container 1.
4) The completely slit sealing member 2A is released from the inlet
of the container and inserted into the sealing member keeping recess 43.
5) When the closure 4 is rotated in an opening direction, the
connected portion 18 is torn and the perforated portion 17 is caught by a
protrusion of the lower portion of a screw installed at an outer surface of
the inlet of the container to remain there while the sealing member 2A is
kept in the sealing member keeping recess 43. In this state, the closure 4



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
is released from the inlet of the container.
The closure is applied to a container which holds a content 3 in a
paste state, or content such as a thick solution or a powder product which
a user can have with a spoon.
As stated above, when the closure coupled at the inlet of the
container 1 with the sealing member 2 mounted therein is opened, the
sealing member 2 is automatically penetrated, slit and inserted for storage
in the sealing member keeping recess 43 inside the closure.
In addition, the closure mounted at the inlet of the
sealing-processed container which automatically keeps the sealing
member 2A when it is opened .can be applicable to any containers so long
as they are sealing-processed regardless of a content, rather than being
limited to the beverage container, and a design (or pattern) of the closure
is to be interpreted to come within the coverage of the present invention.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
As so far described, the closure with the push type opener in
accordance with the present invention has the following advantages.
That is, for example, first, since the sealing member capping the
2 o container can be opened by the pressing method, a user cannot be
bothered to separate the closure in order to remove the sealing member to
take the content of the container.
Second, because the user can easily open the inlet of the container
without applying hands to the inlet of the container in order to remove the
11



CA 02516057 2005-08-12
WO 2004/085278 PCT/KR2004/000303
sealing member to have a beverage or a content of the container, he/she
can take the content hygienically.
Third, with a content stored inside the closure, the sealing member
can be opened by the pressing method, and the content stored inside the
closure and a content stored in the container can be mixed. Accordingly,
the user can simply mix the different contents to have it.
Fourth, since the sealing member mounted at the inlet of the
container is removed and automatically stored inside the closure, the slit
sealing member does not remain as waste.
1o Finally, since a spoon or a straw can be kept in a space of an upper
portion of the closure, a user can easily use them for having a content of
the container, and in addition, by providing a closure cover, it accomplishes
effectiveness of advertising as well as preventing introduction of foreign
materials to thereby improve hygiene of the spoon or the straw.
12

Representative Drawing
A single figure which represents the drawing illustrating the invention.
Administrative Status

For a clearer understanding of the status of the application/patent presented on this page, the site Disclaimer , as well as the definitions for Patent , Administrative Status , Maintenance Fee  and Payment History  should be consulted.

Administrative Status

Title Date
Forecasted Issue Date Unavailable
(86) PCT Filing Date 2004-02-14
(87) PCT Publication Date 2004-10-07
(85) National Entry 2005-08-12
Examination Requested 2005-08-12
Dead Application 2012-02-14

Abandonment History

Abandonment Date Reason Reinstatement Date
2011-02-14 FAILURE TO PAY APPLICATION MAINTENANCE FEE
2011-06-15 R30(2) - Failure to Respond

Payment History

Fee Type Anniversary Year Due Date Amount Paid Paid Date
Request for Examination $800.00 2005-08-12
Application Fee $400.00 2005-08-12
Maintenance Fee - Application - New Act 2 2006-02-14 $100.00 2006-01-18
Maintenance Fee - Application - New Act 3 2007-02-14 $100.00 2006-12-28
Maintenance Fee - Application - New Act 4 2008-02-14 $100.00 2008-01-31
Maintenance Fee - Application - New Act 5 2009-02-16 $200.00 2009-02-09
Maintenance Fee - Application - New Act 6 2010-02-15 $200.00 2010-02-10
Owners on Record

Note: Records showing the ownership history in alphabetical order.

Current Owners on Record
RHO, HEE KWON
Past Owners on Record
None
Past Owners that do not appear in the "Owners on Record" listing will appear in other documentation within the application.
Documents

To view selected files, please enter reCAPTCHA code :



To view images, click a link in the Document Description column. To download the documents, select one or more checkboxes in the first column and then click the "Download Selected in PDF format (Zip Archive)" or the "Download Selected as Single PDF" button.

List of published and non-published patent-specific documents on the CPD .

If you have any difficulty accessing content, you can call the Client Service Centre at 1-866-997-1936 or send them an e-mail at CIPO Client Service Centre.


Document
Description 
Date
(yyyy-mm-dd) 
Number of pages   Size of Image (KB) 
Representative Drawing 2005-10-18 1 20
Cover Page 2005-10-18 2 54
Drawings 2005-08-12 12 271
Claims 2005-08-12 4 101
Abstract 2005-08-12 2 80
Description 2005-08-12 12 433
Claims 2010-07-19 6 203
Drawings 2010-07-19 20 387
Abstract 2005-08-13 1 14
Description 2005-08-13 27 932
Claims 2005-08-13 10 259
Drawings 2005-08-13 20 389
Prosecution-Amendment 2007-07-17 3 59
PCT 2005-08-13 65 1,865
Assignment 2005-08-12 5 130
PCT 2005-08-12 2 80
Fees 2006-12-28 1 42
Fees 2006-01-18 1 50
Prosecution-Amendment 2007-01-09 3 143
Correspondence 2007-07-30 1 12
Fees 2008-01-31 1 43
Fees 2009-02-09 1 44
Prosecution-Amendment 2010-01-22 2 89
Prosecution-Amendment 2010-07-19 10 292
Prosecution-Amendment 2010-12-15 9 514