Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
CERAMIFYING COMPOSITION FOR FIRE PROTECTION
Field
The present invention relates to fire barrier compositions which function by
forming a ceramic at the elevated temperatures encountered in fire conditions.
The invention also relates to the preparation of such compositions and their
use, for example in shaping them to form articles that require fire barrier
properties. The invention will be described with reference to cable
applications,
which are a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention, however it
will
be understood that the composition may also be used in providing fire barrier
properties to a range of articles.
Background
The fire barrier properties of building materials and the maintenance of power
and communication in fire situations are critical to the safety of inhabitants
and
effective fire fighting. As a result many countries set standards for the
performance of buildings under fire conditions. For example cables for
critical
applications are required to continue to operate under fire conditions to
ensure
the maintenance of power and communications. To meet some of the
Standards cables must maintain circuit integrity when heated to a specified
temperature (e.g. 650, 750, 950 or 1000 C) for a specified period of time. It
is
also necessary to take into account that in order to be effective, fire
insulation
may need to provide protection from the effects of water jet sprays and
turbulent
gas flows encountered under fire conditions.
It is also desirable that a material used to impart fire resistance has
acceptable
mechanical strength for the intended application, following exposure to the
elevated temperatures likely to be encountered in a fire situation, so that it
can
remain in place when subjected to the mechanical shocks and/or forces (eg
from strong gas currents) associated with fire scenarios.
One method of improving the high temperature performance of an insulated
cable has been to wrap the conductor of the cable with tape made with glass
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
2
fibres and coated with mica. Such tapes are wrapped around the conductor
during production and then at least one insulating layer is applied. Upon
being
exposed to increasing temperatures, the outer layer(s) are degraded and fall
away, but the glass fibres hold the mica in place. These tapes have been found
to be effective for maintaining circuit integrity in fires, but are quite
expensive.
Further, the process of wrapping the tape around the conductor is relatively
slow compared with other cable production steps. Wrapping tape around the
conductor slows overall production of the cable, again adding to the cost. A
fire
resistant coating that can be applied during the production of the cable (for
example by extrusion) thereby avoiding the use of tapes, is desirable.
A variety of materials have been used to impart fire resistance to structures
and
components, including electric cables. The use of compositions based on
silicone elastomers has been reported. However, silicone elastomers can be
expensive, have relatively poor mechanical properties and can be difficult to
process, for example by extrusion techniques. Furthermore, these compositions
tend to have the associated disadvantage that they are converted to powdery
substances when exposed to fire as a result of the organic components of the
silicone elastomers being pyrolised or combusted. The pyrolysis or combustion
products are volatilised and leave an inorganic residue or ash (silicon
dioxide)
that has little inherent strength. This residue is generally not coherent or
self-
supporting and indeed is often easily broken, dislodged or collapsed. This
behaviour mitigates against using silicone elastomers in passive fire
protection.
This means, for instance, that silicone polymers used as insulation on
electric
cables must be protected and held in place with physical supports such as
inorganic tapes and braids or metal jackets.
We have found that some materials, based on silicone polymers or other
polymers in combination with various inorganic additives, retain their
integrity
and form self-supporting ceramics on exposure to fire, and some of these have
been proposed for use as insulation layers on electric cables that do not
contain
physical supports.
CA 02561824 2012-06-18
3
Ihternational Application PCT/AU03100968 describes a fire resistant
composition, which comprises 'a silicone polymer along with mica, and ~ glass
additive in respective amounts from 5% to. 30% and 0.3 to 8% by weight based
on the total weight of the composition:
International Application PCT/AU03/01383 describes a composition which
contains an organic polymer, a silicate mineral filler and a fluxing agent (or
precursor resulting in a fluxing agent) to result in from 1 to 15% of fluxing
agent by weight of the residue resulting from fire conditions
Other fire barrier compositions attempt to meet fire rating requirements by
using
inorganic materials which foam under the influence of a chemical intumescing
.agent during a fire. For example Horacek (US Pub 2003/0031818 and
2003/0035912) describes an intumescent strip and sheath for wires and cables
which forms fire resistant glass foam under fire conditions. The intumescent
component. is a mixture such as dipentaerythritol, melamine and ammonium
polyphosphate in specific proportions which constitutes from 20 to 35% by
weight of the total composition. Keogh (US, Pub 2002/0098357) describes an
intumescent wrap for cables and the like in which the intumescence is provided
by a 50:50 blend of ammonium phosphate and melamine. Thewes (US Pub No
2004/0051087) and Rodenberg at al (DE-103 02 198) disclose a fire protection
material which likewise rely on the presence of a melamine as a blowing agent
to provide foam in fire conditions. The intumescing agents such as melamine
251. and pentaerythritol 'react with the polyphosphoric acid to form transient
phosphate ester species which dehydrate to provide an organic foam.
Commercially available flame retardants may contain a mixture of a phosphoric
acid generating agent, a charring agent such as pentaerythritol or
carbohydrates and agents such as melamine which accelerate .foaming. When
mixed in specific proportions the composition provides intumescence. While the
formation of foam provides improved' insulation and a heat barrier we have
found that the expansion generally results in a very mechanically weakened
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
residue which is not self-supporting. As a result of the residue not being
self-
supporting the insulation is prone to fall or fracture thereby exposing the
insulated material. Also the composition is more susceptible to compromising
insulation in the presence of water and/or severe air currents which are
frequently encountered during fires.
Summary
We have now found that integrity of a ceramic forming composition may be
retained by using a composition comprising certain combinations of inorganic
phosphate and silicate mineral filler.
We provide in accordance with a first aspect of the invention a ceramifying
composition for forming a fire resistant ceramic under fire conditions the
composition comprising:
(i) at least 10% (preferably at least 15%) by weight of mineral silicate;
(ii) from 8 % to 40 % by weight of at least one inorganic phosphate that
forms a liquid phase at a temperature of no more than 800 C; and
(iii) at least 15% by weight based on the total weight of the composition of a
polymer base composition comprising at least 50% by weight of an
organic polymer.
The composition of the invention is preferably formulated to provide a self-
supporting ceramic on exposure to an elevated temperature experienced under
fire conditions.
When used herein the phrase "exposure to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions" is used to refer to severe fire conditions
as
simulated by heating at a temperature of 1000 C for a period of 30 minutes.
By using the inorganic phosphate, silicate mineral filler and preferably other
inorganic fillers we have found that it is possible to retain the shape and
dimensions of the material as a result of trapping combustion gases during
transformation of the composition to a ceramic on exposure to an elevated
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
temperature experienced under fire conditions. Typically rectangular test
specimens of the composition of the invention will undergo changes in linear
dimension along the length of the specimen of less than 20%, preferably less
than 10%, more preferably less than 5%, still more preferably less than 3% and
5 most preferably less than 1%. In some cases net shape retention is the most
preferred property. The retention of shape does not require the blowing agents
used in intumescent compositions of the prior art. Indeed the compositions of
the invention are preferably essentially free of additional intumescing agents
such as melamine and pentaerythritol which we have found make it difficult to
control the expansion of foams under the variety of conditions encountered in
fires. We have found that controlled expansion can be achieved by using
ammonium polyphosphate which, together with the other gases generated
during combustion, enables the shape and dimensions of the product to be
maintained under fire conditions.
The ceramic formed from the composition of the invention on exposure to an
elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions preferably has a
flexural
strength of at least 0.3 MPa, more preferably at least 1 MPa and most
preferably at least 2 MPa.
The composition may and preferably will comprise up to 30% (preferably up to
20%) by weight of at least one of hydroxides, oxides and carbonates selected
from at least one of aluminium, barium, calcium and magnesium. More
preferably the composition comprises 10 to 20% by weight of a component
consisting of at least one compound selected from the group consisting of
aluminium hydroxide (alumina trihydrate), magnesium carbonate and calcium
carbonate.
In a further aspect the invention provides a cable comprising at least one
elongated functional element such as a conductor and at least one coating
layer
comprising the hereinbefore described ceramifying composition. Preferably the
cable comprises a single insulation coating and the single insulation coating
is
formed of the hereinbefore described ceramifiable composition. The inner
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
6
surface of the ceramifiable layer may abut the functional element (such as one
or more copper wires) and preferably the outer surface of the layer is free of
further coatings or layers. The ceramifiable layer is preferably applied to
the at
least one functional element by extrusion. One of the significant advantages
of
the composition of the invention is that it provides a combination of fire
protection and sufficient strength, on exposure to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions, to allow cables to be prepared using a
single
insulating layer of the composition of the invention. This has not generally
been
possible for compositions of the prior art as insulating compositions have
generally been of insufficient strength to be self-supporting, to support the
weight of the conductor and to withstand the conditions of water spray and gas
turbulence encountered under fire conditions. As a consequence, the
commercially available cables with high fire rating generally require a
physical
supporting and sealing layer to maintain the integrity of the insulating
layer.
Although such layers may be used with the composition of the invention, they
are generally not required to provide a high fire rating.
The inorganic residue formed from the composition of the invention has also
been found to have high electrical resistance on exposure to an elevated
temperature experienced under fire conditions. This is particularly important
to
maintaining electrical integrity of a functional element.
The composition generally forms a self-supporting and porous ceramic when
exposed to an elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions and
typically at least 40% of its total composition will be inorganic compounds.
Detailed Description
The ceramifying composition of the invention provides fire barrier properties
on
exposure to an elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions. The
ceramifying composition includes mineral silicate (optionally together with
other
inorganic fillers) and inorganic phosphate which together with the mineral
silicate forms a coherent ceramic on exposure to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions. On exposure to an elevated temperature
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
7
experienced under fire conditions the phosphate component initially forms a
liquid phase, preferably at a temperature lower than the decomposition
temperature of at least one of the other gas generating components. A
dispersed gas phase is formed as a result of the decomposition of the organic
polymer and other components such as ammonium polyphosphate. As the
temperature of the composition increases to above about 800 C the
composition forms a ceramic comprising the inorganic phosphate component
and mineral silicate. The inorganic phosphate and silicate components
(particularly magnesium silicate if present in the silicate component) react
at the
high temperatures to solidify and strengthen the walls around the pores formed
by the entrapment of gaseous phase.
The shrinkage associated with the decomposition of the organic materials, and
optionally also some of the inorganic components, is compensated by the
formation of uniformly dispersed fine pores in the transient liquid phase.
The dispersed fine pores entrapped in the transient liquid phase formed by the
decomposition of the inorganic phosphate component, enable the composition
to approximately retain the original size and shape on conversion to a
ceramic.
The evolved gases provide a controlled expansion of the viscous liquid phase
(formed on decomposition of the inorganic phosphate) which is reinforced by
the combustion residue and inorganic filler particles at all stages of
conversion
into a ceramic under fire conditions. The controlled expansion matches the
volume lost through combustion, to form a relatively strong ceramic of at
least
0.3 MPa, preferably at least 1 MPa and more preferably at least 2 MPa in
strength and of similar size and shape to the original article.
The controlled dispersion of fine pores, formed by the decomposition of the
inorganic phosphate component (in the absence of other intumescing agents)
and the interaction of the inorganic phosphate and mineral silicate filler
enable
the composition to form a ceramic which is self-supporting even when heated at
a temperature of 1 000 C for 30 minutes.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
8
Compositions containing significant amounts of additional intumescing agents
such as melamine and/or pentaerythritol generally do not form a self-
supporting
ceramic under fire conditions as we have found that significant intumescence
interferes with strengthening interaction of the components of the present
invention.
The composition provides a ceramic on exposure to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions which is preferably self-supporting. A range
of
different conditions can be encountered in a fire. Experimentally we have
examined two extreme conditions involving exposure at 1000 C for 30 minutes.
These simulated conditions, which are examples of tests examining an
exposure to a temperature experienced under fire conditions are described as
fast firing conditions and slow firing conditions in the examples.
In order to examine whether or not a composition is self-supporting we use the
following test as our standard. The test involves specimens of nominal
dimensions 30 mm x 13 mm x 2 mm (approximately) made from the
composition which are placed on a rectangular piece of refractory so that
their
long axis is perpendicular to one edge of the supporting refractory block and
a
13 mm long portion of each specimen is projecting from the edge of the
supporting refractory block. The specimens are then heated at 12 C per minute
to 1000 C and maintained at this temperature for 30 minutes in air. At all
temperatures, the specimens of composition remain rigid and coherent without
bending over the edge of the supporting block to a significant degree (i.e
providing a bending angle to the original position of less than 15 degrees).
The
resulting ceramic will preferably retain the shape the specimen had prior to
exposure to elevated temperatures.
The composition of the invention comprises at least one inorganic phosphate
compound that forms a liquid phase at a temperature at no more than 800 C
(preferably no more than 500 C). The amount of inorganic phosphate is in the
range of from 8% to 40% by weight based on the total weight of the ceramifying
composition although the appropriate amount to provide self-supporting
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
9
properties, shape retention and strength will depend on the nature and
proportion of other components including the optional fillers. Where there is
more than one phosphate then the total amount of phosphates that form a liquid
phase at a temperature of less than 800 C (preferably less than 500 C) is in
the
specified range (e.g. 8% to 40%). Specific examples of inorganic phosphates of
this type include ammonium phosphate, ammonium polyphosphate and
ammonium pyrophosphate. These inorganic phosphates decompose and form
a liquid phase (containing phosphorous pentoxide) at temperatures in the range
of approximately 200 to 800 C.
Phosphates such as boron phosphate (MPt >1200 C) which have a relatively
high melting point and hence do not form a liquid phase at a temperature of no
more than 800 C (preferably no more than 500 C) do not form part of the
inorganic phosphate component required by the invention and, while they may
be present as additional fillers, they generally do not contribute to the
transient
liquid phase which is reactive with the mineral silicate. Ammonium
polyphosphate offers significant advantages in the compositions of the
invention
and is the most preferred inorganic phosphate. Accordingly in a particularly
preferred embodiment the composition of the invention comprises from 8% to
40% by weight ammonium polyphosphate based on the total weight of the
ceramifying composition.
Significant advantages are provided by inorganic phosphates that form a liquid
phase at relatively low temperatures under fire conditions. We have found that
the liquid phase formed from the inorganic phosphate component in the
composition of this invention is only a transient liquid phase. Its
interaction with
other components of the composition results in formation of crystalline phases
and transformation of the composition into a solid ceramic at high
temperature.
Inorganic phosphates and in particular systems based on ammonium
polyphosphate have the significant advantage of maintaining the integrity of
the
composition in combination with the other components of the composition of the
invention. In a particularly preferred embodiment of the invention the
inorganic
phosphate liquid forming component is chosen to provide, in combination with
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 1 O PCT/AU2005/000465
other components, properties (particularly relatively high viscosity) which
will
entrap an adequate amount of gas pores and maintain the shape and
dimensions of the product. If the viscosity of the transient liquid phase
formed
under these conditions is relatively low, all the gas produced may be lost,
resulting in an increased likelihood of failure through shrinkage and possibly
also loss of the liquid component.
It is believed that on exposure to an elevated temperature experienced under
fire conditions the inorganic phosphate in the composition of the invention
decomposes at a temperature at or below the decomposition temperature of at
least a portion of the other components. In the case of ammonium
polyphosphate the decomposition products include ammonia and phosphoric
acid. The ammonia may contribute to the porosity of the ceramic formed on
solidification of the transient liquid phase. The phosphoric acid reacts with
any
organic material in its proximity initially forming a carbonaceous char which
is
oxidatively depleted as the composition is further heated and forms a ceramic.
The viscosity of the transient liquid phase which is optimal to entrap gas
will of
course depend on the types and volumes of gases generated and the
proportions of organic components and any optional components such as
processing aids and the like.
The inorganic phosphate is most preferably ammonium polyphosphate and is
present in an amount of from 8 to 40% by weight of the total composition.
In one embodiment of the invention the inorganic phosphate is preferably
present in an amount of from 15 to 40% and still more preferably from 20 to
40% by weight of the total composition. Such compositions may be preferred
where high strength of the resulting ceramic is a priority.
In another, more preferred embodiment the inorganic phosphate is present in
an amount in the range of from 8 to 20 % by weight of the total composition,
more preferably from 10 to 20% and still more preferably from 10 to 15% by
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 11 PCT/AU2005/000465
weight of the total composition. Compositions of this embodiment are
particularly suited to applications where good electrical insulation is
required
under fire conditions (at elevated temperatures). This embodiment is, for
example, particularly preferred in cables used to maintain essential services
under fire conditions and indeed may even allow a single insulating layer to
be
used.
Generally the inorganic phosphate component will form a liquid at temperatures
below 450 C. Gases are produced by thermal decomposition of components in
the composition including the organic components. Examples of inorganic gas
producing materials include hydrated materials such as magnesium hydroxide
and aluminium hydroxide, carbonates such as magnesium carbonate and
calcium carbonate and ammonium polyphosphate. Examples of organic gas
producing materials include organic polymers and any organic processing
additives. It is particularly preferred that the gas generating component is
finely
divided and distributed throughout the ceramic forming component.
The gas-generating component may comprise a mixture of compounds that
generate gas at elevated temperatures. Preferably the gas-generating
component will generate at least a portion of gas above the temperature at
which the inorganic liquid forming component forms a liquid. The gas phase is
trapped by the liquid phase which is transiently formed under fire conditions
during transformation of the composition to a ceramic. The gas phase appears
in the ceramic as fine pores. Further we have found that the silicate
component
interacts with the liquid phase to provide part of the structure of the walls
defining the pores in the resulting ceramic.
The composition of the invention will typically form a'self-supporting ceramic
at
temperatures encountered under fire conditions. The porosity of the resulting
ceramic is preferably in the range of from 20 vol% to 80 vol%. Preferably at
least 40% of its total composition will be inorganic fillers.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 12 PCT/AU2005/000465
The compositions in accordance with the present invention also include
silicate
mineral filler. Such fillers typically include alumina-silicates (e.g.
kaolinite,
montmorillonite, pyrophillite - commonly known as clays), alkali alumino-
silicates (e.g. mica, feldspar, spodumene, petalite), magnesium silicates
(e.g.
talc) and calcium silicates (e.g. wollastonite). Mixtures of two or more
different
silicate mineral fillers may be used. Such fillers are commercially available.
Silicon dioxide (silica) is not a silicate mineral filler in the context of
the present
invention.
The composition typically comprises at least 10% by weight, preferably at
least
15% and most preferably at least 25% by weight of silicate mineral filler. The
maximum amount of this component tends to be dictated by the nature of the
product and the level of the silicate which will not unduly impair processing
of
the composition.
Inorganic fibres which do not melt at 1000 C can be incorporated, including
aluminium oxide fibres, may be incorporated in composition of the invention.
In addition to mineral silicate fillers, a wide range of other inorganic
fillers may
be added. The composition may and preferably will comprise an additional
inorganic filler comprising an amount of up to 30% (preferably up to 20%) by
weight of the total composition of at least one of metal hydroxides, metal
oxides
and metal carbonates. Examples of metal ions in such inorganic fillers include
calcium, aluminium, magnesium, barium, caesium, cobalt, iron, lead,
manganese, nickel, rubidium, strontium and zinc. The preferred additional
inorganic fillers are selected from at least one of hydroxides, oxides and
carbonates of at least one of aluminium, barium, calcium and magnesium. The
oxides, hydroxides and carbonates of aluminium, calcium and magnesium are
more preferred. and still more preferred are alumina trihydrate, magnesium
carbonate and calcium carbonate. Preferably the amount of the additional
inorganic filler is in the range of from 5% to 20% by weight of the total
composition.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
13
The composition of the invention is preferably essentially free of intumescing
agents such as melamine, melamine phosphate, melamine pyrophosphate,
pentaerythritol and the like.
The composition of the invention forms a ceramic on exposure to temperatures
experienced under fire conditions. We have found that the composition passes
through a transitional phase on heating. The ceramic comprises a phase formed
from the inorganic phosphate and dispersed mineral silicate and, optionally,
other filler particles and a gas phase formed from decomposition products,
which maintain the shape and dimensions of the material.
The self-supporting properties, dimensional stability and strength of the
composition may be compromised in the presence of significant amounts of
such intumescing agents. The optimum proportion of components within the
ranges described above (in particular the inorganic phosphate and mineral
silicate) may be determined by a person skilled in the art having regard to
the
herein described contribution of those components to the performance
characteristics of the composition. Typically the composition will contain
less
than 1 % by weight of the composition of melamine and pentaerythritol although
the tolerable amounts may be determined having regard to the hereinbefore
described tests for examining self-supporting properties under fire conditions
and the strength and change in dimensions under fire conditions.
In one embodiment of the invention the ceramic forming composition consists
essentially of:
i). at least 15% by weight based on the total weight of the
composition of a polymer base composition comprising at least
50% by weight of an organic polymer;
ii). 8-40% by weight of at least one inorganic phosphate that forms a
liquid phase at a temperature of no more than 800 C (preferably
no more than 500 C) based on the total weight of the composition,
iii). at least 10% by weight based on the total weight of the
composition of silicate mineral filler;
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
14
iv). optionally an additional inorganic filler in an amount of up to 30%;
and
wherein the composition forms a self-supporting ceramic on exposure to an
elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions.
The composition of the invention comprises an organic polymer. An organic
polymer is one that has an organic polymer as the main chain of the polymer.
Silicone polymers are not considered to be organic polymers, however, they
may be usefully blended with the organic polymer(s), as the minor component,
and beneficially provide a source of silicon dioxide (which assists in
formation of
the ceramic) with a fine particle size when they are thermally decomposed. The
organic polymer can be of any type, for example a thermoplastic polymer, a
thermoplastic elastomer, a cross-linked elastomer or rubber, a thermoset
polymer. The organic polymer may be present in the form of a precursor
composition including reagents, prepolymers and/or oligomers which can be
reacted together to form at least one organic polymer of the types mentioned
above.
Preferably, the organic polymer can accommodate high levels of the inorganic
components required to form the ceramic, whilst retaining good processing and
mechanical properties. It is desirable in accordance with the present
invention
to include in the fire resistant compositions high levels of the inorganic
components as such compositions tend to suffer reduced weight loss on
exposure to fire when compared with compositions having lower levels of the
inorganic components. Compositions loaded with relatively high concentrations
of inorganic components are therefore less likely to shrink and crack when
ceramified by the action of heat.
It is also advantageous for the chosen organic polymer not to flow or melt
prior
to its decomposition when exposed to the elevated temperatures encountered
in a fire situation. The most preferred polymers include ones that are cross-
linked after the fire resistant composition has been formed, or ones that are
thermoplastic but have high melting points and/or decompose to form a char
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
near their melting points; however, polymers that do not have these properties
may also be used. Suitable organic polymers are commercially available or may
be made by the application or adaptation of known techniques. Examples of
suitable organic polymers that may be used are given below but it will be
5 appreciated that the selection of a particular organic polymer will also be
impacted by such things as the additional components to be included in the
fire
resistant composition, the way in which the composition is to be prepared and
applied, and the intended use of the composition.
10 Organic polymers suitable for use with this invention include thermoplastic
polymers, thermoset polymers, and (thermoplastic) elastomers. Such polymers
may comprise at least one polymer selected from the group consisting of
homopolymers and copolymers of polyolefins, vinyl polymers including poly
vinyl chloride, acrylic and methacrylic polymers, styrene polymers,
polyamides,
15 polyimides, epoxies, polycarbonates, polyurethanes, polyesters, phenolic
resins
and melamine-formaldehyde resins.
The organic polymers that are particularly well suited for use in making
coatings
for cables are:
commercially available thermoplastic and crosslinked polyethylenes with
densities from 890 to 960 g/litre, copolymers of ethylenes of this class with
acrylic and vinyl other olefin monomers, terpolymers of ethylene, propylene
and
diene monomers, so-called thermoplastic vulcanisates where one component is
crosslinked while the continuous phase is thermoplastic and variants of this
where all of the polymers are either thermoplastic or crosslinked by either
peroxide, radiation or so-called silane processes.
Compositions of the invention may be formed about a conducting element or
plurality of elements by extrusion (including co-extrusion with other
components) or by application of one or more coatings.
As noted, the organic polymer chosen will in part depend upon the intended use
of the composition. For instance, in certain applications a degree of
flexibility is
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
16
required of the composition (such as in electrical cable coatings) and the
organic polymer will need to be chosen accordingly based on its properties
when loaded with additives. Polyethylenes and ethylene propylene elastomers
have been found to be particularly useful for compositions for cable coatings.
Also in selecting the organic polymer account should be taken of any noxious
or
toxic gases which may be produced on decomposition of the polymer. The
generation of such gases may be more tolerable in certain applications than
others. Preferably, the organic polymer used is halogen-free.
As noted the polymer base composition may include a silicone polymer.
However, in this case the organic polymer would usually be present in the
polymer base composition in a significant excess when compared with the
silicone polymer. Thus, in the polymer base composition the weight ratio of
organic polymer to silicone polymer may be from 5:1 to 2:1, for instance from
4:1 to 3:1. In terms of weight percentage, if present, the silicone polymer
might
generally be present in an amount of from 2 to 15% by weight based on the
total weight of the formulated fire resistant composition. When a combination
of
organic and silicone polymers are used, high concentrations of silicone
polymer
can present processing problems and this should be taken into account when
formulating compositions in accordance with the present invention.
The composition of the invention typically comprises at least 15% by weight
based on the total weight of the composition of a polymer base composition
comprising at least 50% by weight of an organic polymer.
The upper limit for the amount of polymeric components in the fire resistant
composition tends to be influenced by the desired properties of the formulated
composition. If the amount of the polymeric components exceeds about 60% by
weight of the overall composition, it is unlikely that a cohesive, strong
residue
will be formed during a fire situation. Thus, the base composition generally
forms from 15 to 60%, preferably from 20 to 50%, by weight of the formulated
fire resistant composition.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
17
The organic polymer is present in the polymer base composition in an amount
of at least 50% by weight. This facilitates loading of the polymeric base
composition with the additional components without detriment to the
processability of the overall composition. As noted the polymer base
composition may include a silicone polymer. However, in this case the organic
polymer would usually be present in the base composition in a significant
excess when compared with the silicone polymer.
On exposure of the composition of the invention to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions (to 1000 C) the residue remaining will
generally constitute at least 40%, preferably at least 55% and more preferably
at least 70% by weight of the composition before pyrolysing. Higher amounts of
residue are preferred as this may improve the ceramic strength at all
temperatures.
The compositions of the present invention may be provided in a variety of
different forms, including:
1. As a sheet, profile or complex shape. The composition may be fabricated
into these products using standard polymer processing operations, eg
extrusion, moulding (including hot pressing and injection moulding). The
products formed can be used in passive fire protection systems. The
composition can be used in its own right, or as a laminate or composite
with another material (for example, plywood, vermiculite board or other).
In one application the composition may be extruded into shapes to make
seals for fire doors. In the event of a fire, the composition is converted
into a ceramic thus forming an effective mechanical seal against the
spread of fire and smoke.
2. As a pre-expanded sheet or profile. This form has additional benefits
compared with the above, including reduced weight and the capacity for
greater noise attenuation and insulation during normal operating
conditions.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
18
3. As a mastic material which can be applied (for example from a tube as
per a conventional silicone sealant) as a seal for windows and other
articles.
4. As paint, or an aerosol-based material, that could be sprayed or applied
by with a brush.
Specific examples of passive fire protection applications where this invention
may be applied include but are not limited to firewall linings for ferries,
trains
and other vehicles, fire partitions, screens, ceilings and linings coatings
for
building ducts, gap fillers (i.e. mastic applications for penetration),
structural fire
protection (to insulate the structural metal frame of a building to allow it
to
maintain its required load bearing strength (or limit the core temperature)
for a
fixed period of time), fire door inserts, window and door seals, intumescent
seals, and compounds for use in electrical boxes, in fittings, straps, trays
etc
that are attached to or used to house cables or similar applications.
Another area of application is in general engineering. Specific areas of
general
engineering, where passive fire protection properties are required, include
transportation (automotive, aerospace, shipping), defence and machinery.
Components in these applications may be totally or partially subject to fire.
When totally subject to fire, the material will transform to a ceramic,
thereby
protecting enclosed or separated areas. When partially subjected to fire, it
may
be desirable for a portion of the material to transform to ceramic, being held
in
place by the surrounding material that has not transformed to a ceramic.
Applications in the transport area may include panelling (e.g. in glass fibre
reinforced thermoplastic or thermoset composites), exhaust, engine, braking,
steering, safety devices, air conditioning, fuel storage, housings and many
others. Applications in defence would include both mobile and non-mobile
weapons, vehicles, equipment, structures and other areas. Applications in the
machinery area may include bearings, housing barriers and many others.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
19
The compositions of the present invention are especially useful as coatings
for
the production of cables for example they can be used for insulation or
sheathing layers. The compositions are therefore suitable for the manufacture
of electrical cables that can provide circuit integrity in the case of fire.
Description of the Drawings
Figure 1 is a perspective view of a cable having a ceramic forming insulation
layer in accordance with the invention.
Figure 2 is a perspective view of a multiconductor cable in which compositions
of the invention are used as a sheath.
Figure 3 is a perspective view of a particularly preferred embodiment of the
cable of the invention in which the composition of the invention forms a
single
insulating layer about a conductive element.
Figure 4 is a perspective view of a fire performance article.
Figure 5 is a cross section at position II shown in Figure 4.
Figures 1 and 2 show single and multiconductor cables 1, 10 respectively,
which have an insulation layer 2, or layers 12 and having additional
ceramifying
layers 4, 14 of a composition in accordance with the invention. In both of
these
cable designs, the position of the insulation layer and the ceramifying layer
in
accordance with the invention can be interchanged depending on the role of the
additional layer.
In the design of such cables the ceramic forming insulation layers can be
extruded directly over conductors and the ceramifying layers extruded over an
insulation layer or layers. Alternatively, they can be used as an interstice
filler in
multi-core cables, as individual extruded fillers added to an assembly to
round
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
off the assembly, as an inner layer prior to the application of wire or tape
armour.
Figure 3 shows the simple cable design which may be used with the
5 composition of the invention particularly the embodiment comprising ammonium
polyphosphate in an amount of from 8 to 20% by weight. The composition in
the invention forms an extruded insulation layer 2 about the conductor (1).
The
inner surface 2A of the insulation layer abuts the conductor and the outer
surface 2B is free of further coatings.
Figure 4 shows a possible design for a fire performance article 1 and Figure 5
shows a cross section at the position II in Figure 4. The metal substrate 12
has
a protective coating 16 which comprises at least one ceramifying layer (17-20)
and may comprise one or more other layers such as glazing layer 18 or other
ceramic forming layer.(19).
In the first embodiment of the cable of the invention as shown for example in
Figure 1 a functional element such as copper conductor is surrounded by a
ceramifying insulation composition which forms a relatively weak ceramic which
in turn is surrounded by a ceramifying composition in accordance with the
invention for forming a fire resistant ceramic under fire conditions the
composition comprising:
(i) at least 10% by weight of mineral silicate;
(ii) from 8 % to 40 % by weight of at least one inorganic phosphate
that forms a liquid phase at a temperature of no more than 800 C;
and
(iii) at least 15% by weight based on the total weight of the
composition of a polymer base composition comprising at least
50% by weight of an organic polymer;
wherein under fire conditions a rectangular test specimen of the ceramifying
composition undergoes less than a 10% change in linear dimension along its
length.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
21
Compositions in accordance with the current invention are well suited for use
imparting fire resistance to structures and components. We have discovered
through extensive evaluation that components that melt at temperatures below
1,000 C and hence form liquid phases can be beneficial in forming strong and
stable ceramics, but their electrical conductivity is invariably high. This
causes
test cables, particularly multi-core cables, to fail due to the leakage of
current
through the insulation exceeding the capacity of the fuse or other circuit
protection. There are many prior art examples where the strength of the
ceramic was given higher importance and the resistivity was neglected. We
have solved this problem by having a fusible component that provides only a
transitory liquid phase, and which is converted (in the presence of a mineral
silicate) to a crystalline solid at higher temperatures, providing a material
which
consequently has a much lower electrical conductivity at high temperature than
compositions that still have a liquid phase present under these conditions.
Compositions may be suitable for use as the sole insulation layer on electric
cables particularly where they exhibit suitable high electrical resistance at
elevated temperature. In this aspect we have found composition comprising
from 8 to 20% by weight of APP to be particularly advantageous. For those
compositions that do not meet this requirement, it may be desirable to
incorporate an additional layer that is electrically insulative at high
temperature
to ensure circuit integrity.
For instance, a composition which imparts thermal resistance and/or provides a
physical barrier at elevated temperature but which becomes electrically
conducting may be provided about a layer adapted to provide electrical
insulation.
In a particularly preferred embodiment of a cable in accordance with the
invention there is another layer of a ceramifying material, axially inward
from a
strong ceramifying material described in accordance with the composition of
the
invention. The axially inward layer may be of a range of types and may be a
second layer in accordance with the composition of the present invention. It
is
CA 02561824 2012-06-18
22 --
particularly preferred, however, that in the cable in accordance with this
embodiment that the layer axially inwards of a layer in accordance with a
composition of the present invention is of the type described in our co
pending
International Patent Application PCT/AU03101383
The use of an insulation layer of this type, that forms-a self-supporting
ceramic
on exposure to fire, in combination with a layer (preferably an outer layer)
made
from compositions in accordance with the current invention typically has the
advantage of providing a mechanically'stronger coating over the conductor
after
exposure to fire.
The resulting cable is more likely to remain functional in a fire and when
subjected to the mechanical shocks andlor forces (e.g. from strong gas
currents
and/or water spray) associated with fire scenarios.
However, the composition of the invention may also be used in combination
with ceramiifying compositions which provide inferior mechanical strength at
temperatures encountered under fire conditions. Thus on exposure to elevated
temperatures, compositions in. accordance with the present invention may form
a physically strong coherent layer over an insulating layer, which is degraded
to
inorganic residues that are not coherent, around an electrical conductor and
therefore do away with the need to use physical supports..
The ceramifying insulating layer and layer in accordance with the composition
of
the invention may be applied by conventional means such as extrusion. This
extrusion of the composition , of the invention may be carried out in a
conventional manner using conventional equipment. The thicknesses of the
layers of insulation will depend upon the requirements of the particular
standard
'for the size of conductor and operating voltage. `typically the insulation
will
have a total thickness from 0.6 to 3 mm. For example, for a 35 mm2 conductor
rated at 0.6/1 kV to Australian Standards would require an insulation
thickness
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
23
of approximately 1.2 mm. The cable may include other layers such as a cut-
resistant layer and/or sheathing layer.
In a further embodiment of the cable of the invention a copper conductor is
surrounded by a filled organic polymer layer which decomposes to deposit a
loosely packed electrically insulating inorganic powder (e.g. silicon dioxide,
aluminium oxide, magnesium oxide) in the resulting gap between the conductor
and the ceramifying layer of the composition of the present invention on
exposure to temperatures encountered under fire conditions.
The inorganic phosphate component provides a transitional liquid phase under
fire conditions and entraps pores of a gas phase formed as a result of
decomposition of the ceramifying composition on exposure to elevated
temperature experienced under fire conditions. At temperatures over 800 C the
inorganic phosphate forms part of the ceramic material.
Furthermore, on exposure to elevated temperature experienced under fire
conditions the compositions may also yield residue which is coherent and has
good mechanical strength, even after cooling. The residue is self-supporting
and will be retained in its intended position rather than fracturing and being
displaced, for example, by mechanical shock. In this context the term
"residue"
is hereinafter intended to describe the product formed when the composition is
exposed to an elevated temperature, experienced under fire conditions.
Generally an elevated temperature of 1000 C for 30 minutes is sufficient to
covert fire resistant compositions of the invention to residue. Desirably, as
well
as providing thermal insulation and/or a coherent physical barrier or coating,
compositions in accordance with the present invention may also exhibit the
required electrical insulating properties at elevated temperatures.
The present invention describes materials that typically meet the requirements
of providing no substantial change in shape on exposure to an elevated
temperature experienced under fire conditions, producing ceramics that are
self-supporting and have acceptable mechanical strength.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
24
It has been found that compositions in accordance with the present invention
may form a coherent ceramic product when exposed to elevated temperatures
and that this product exhibits desirable physical and mechanical properties.
The
ceramic formed on exposure of compositions of the present invention to an
elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions has a flexural strength
of at least 0.3 MPa, preferably at least 1 MPa and more preferably at least 2
MPa. It is a distinct advantage that the compositions are self-supporting,
i.e.
they remain rigid and do not undergo heat induced deformation or flow. They
also undergo little, if any, shrinkage on exposure to an elevated temperature
experienced under fire conditions, whether the heating rate experienced is
relatively fast or slow. Typically rectangular test specimens will undergo
changes in linear dimension along the length of the specimen of less than 20%
and preferably less than 10%. Generally speaking the limit on contraction is
more important, preferably this is less than 5% and more preferably less than
1% and most preferably essentially none. In the case of expansions, any
expansion is less than 20%, preferably less than 10% and more preferably less
than 5% and most preferably less than 3%. Changes in dimensions are also
influenced by additional factors including the thermal degradation behaviour
of
the components, particularly the different behaviour of organic components and
can vary from shrinkage to expansion, (caused by gases escaping from
decomposing components of the composition) with expansion having the most
pronounced effect (in a percentage change basis) in the least constrained
dimension such as the thickness (height) of the specimen. Thus one skilled in
the art can select the components of the composition to achieve a range of
outcomes under the expected heating conditions, for example: no significant
change in linear dimensions, no substantial change in all three dimensions
(net
shape retention), an increase in linear dimensions of under 5%, etc.
It is a further advantage, of the compositions of the present invention, that
this
type of coherent product with desirable physical and mechanical properties can
be formed at temperatures well below 1000 C. The compositions of the
invention may be used in a variety of applications where it is desired to
impart
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
fire resistance to a structure or component. The compositions are therefore
useful in passive fire protection systems.
As explained, preferably the compositions exhibit minimal linear dimensional
5 change after exposure to the kind of temperatures likely to be encountered
in a
fire. By this is meant that the maximum linear dimensional change in a product
formed from a composition in accordance with the present invention is less
than
20%, preferably less than 10%, more preferably less than 5% and most
preferably less than 1%. In some cases net shape retention is the most
10 preferred.
The invention will now be described with reference to the following non-
limiting
examples.
Examples
15 The specification and claims refer to terms which are defined below along
with
test methods for their determination. The tests to determine these properties
should ideally be conducted on specimens 30 mm x 13 mm x 2 mm
(approximately), although in some examples specimens with somewhat
different dimensions have been used. The properties and conditions are:
- Slow firing conditions. Heating test specimens from room temperature to
1000 C at a temperature increase rate of 12 C/min followed by holding at
1000 C for 30 minutes. These conditions are representative of 'exposure to an
elevated temperature experienced under fire conditions'.
- Fast firing conditions. Placing test specimens in a pre-heated furnace at
1000 C and maintaining the furnace at that temperature for 30 minutes. In the
examples, some of the compositions have been exposed to these firing
conditions to illustrate the effect of different firing conditions on some of
the
measured properties. These conditions are representative of exposure that may
be achieved under a scenario of very rapid heating.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 26 PCT/AU2005/000465
- Change in linear dimensions. The change in linear dimensions along the
length of the specimen. The method for determining the change in linear
dimensions is by measuring the length of the specimen before firing and upon
cooling after being subjected to either fast firing conditions or slow firing
conditions. An expansion of the specimen caused by firing is reported as a
positive change in linear dimension and a contraction (shrinkage) as a
negative
change in linear dimension. It is quoted as a percent change.
- Flexural strength. The flexural strength of the ceramic is determined by
heating the test specimen under slow firing conditions and, upon cooling,
carrying out the determination by three-point bending of the span length of 18
mm using a loading cross head speed of 0.2 mm/minute.
- Residue. The material remaining after a compositions has been subjected to
elevated temperatures experienced in a fire. In the context of this invention,
those conditions are simulated heating the composition from room temperature
to 1000 C followed by holding at 1000 C for 30 minutes.
- Self-supporting. Compositions that remain rigid and do not undergo
significant
heat induced deformation or flow. Determined by placing a specimen on a
rectangular piece of refractory so that the long axis is perpendicular to the
edge
of the refractory block and a 13 mm portion is projecting out over the edge
from
the block, then heating under slow firing conditions and examining the cooled
specimen. A self-supporting specimen remains rigid, and is able to support its
own weight without significantly bending over the edge of the support.
Typically
any bending over the edge of the block will provide an angle to the original
position of less than 15 degrees.
- Net shape retention. Compositions that undergo no substantial change in
shape when heated. This will depend in part on the shape and dimensions of
the specimen being tested and the firing conditions used.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 27 PCT/AU2005/000465
Examples in accordance with the invention were also found to be self-
supporting and to retain the shape the specimen had prior to its exposure to
elevated temperatures.
Example I
A two-roll mill was used to prepare the compositions denoted A, B, C and D in
Table 1. In each case, the ethylene-propylene (EP) polymer was banded on the
mill (10-20 C) and other components were added and allowed to disperse by
separating and recombining the band of material just before it passed through
the nip of the two rolls. When these were uniformly dispersed, the peroxide
was
added and dispersed in a similar manner.
Flat rectangular sheets of about 1.7 mm thickness were fabricated from the
milled compositions by curing and moulding at 170 C for 30 minutes under a
pressure of approximately 7 MPa.
Rectangular sheet specimens with dimensions 30 mm x 13 mm x 1.7 mm
(approx) were cut from the moulded sheets and fired under slow firing
conditions (heating from room temperature to 1000 C at a temperature increase
rate of 12 C/min followed by holding at 1000 C for 30 minutes) or fast firing
conditions (putting sheets into a pre-heated furnace at 1000 C and maintaining
at that temperature for 30 minutes). After firing, each sample took the form
of a
ceramic. The change in linear dimensions caused by firing was determined by
measuring the length of the specimen before and after firing. An expansion of
the specimen caused by firing is reported as a positive change in linear
dimensions and a contraction (shrinkage) as a negative change in linear
dimensions.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
28
Table 1: Compositions A, B, C and D
Composition (weight %)
A B C D
EP Polymer 18 18 18 18
EVA Polymer 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5
Ammonium Polyphosphate 27 27 27 27
Talc 25 40 25 -
Mica - - - 25
Alumina Trihydrate 15 - - 15
Magnesium Hydroxide - - 15 -
Other Additives (Stabilisers, 8 8 8 8
Coagent, Paraffinic Oil)
Peroxide 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
TOTAL 100 100 100 100
Firing Condition Slow Fast Slow Slow Slow
Change in linear dimensions -2.9 2.0 0.2 6.7 -2.1
when ceramified -
On firing at 1000 C, the compositions A, B, C and D transform into hard and
strong ceramics that retain the initial shape with minimum dimensional
changes.
Example 2
Specimens made from compositions A, B, C and D were tested and found to be
self-supporting. They did not fuse and produced coherent self-supporting
porous ceramics that retained the shape of the specimen prior to exposure to
elevated temperatures. Visual inspection revealed that the unsupported span of
each specimen remained in place without bending over the edge of the
refractory support due to its own weight.
Example 3
A copper conductor of 1.5 mm2 cross section was insulated with a layer of 0.5
mm wall thickness of a ceramifiable composition E (Table 2). A second layer of
the composition A (Table 1) was extruded directly over the layer of
composition
E to provide a composite insulation wall thickness of 1.0 mm. This insulated
conductor was twisted together with three other insulated conductors made in
the same way to form an assembly of four insulated conductors.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
29
The assembly of twisted, insulated conductors was then sheathed with a
commercially available halogen-free, low-smoke, low-toxicity thermoplastic
compound, forming a finished cable. Three segments of this cable were then
subjected to the circuit integrity test of AS/NZS3013:1995.
The test requires the cable segments to be energised at 240 Volts and then
subjected to a furnace test of 2 hours duration to reach a final temperature
of
1,0500C, and then subjected to a water jet spray for 3 minutes.
Three segments of cable made and tested as described were able to maintain
circuit integrity and thus meet the requirements of the circuit integrity test
of
ASJNZS3013:1995. A comparative cable was produced and subjected to the
same test using only insulating material of composition E and was found to
perform unsatisfactorily.
Table 2: Composition E
wt.%
EP Polymer 19
EVA Polymer 5
Clay 10
Talc 10
Mica 20
Alumina trihydrate 10
Calcium Carbonate 10
Silicone Polymer 5
Other Additives, 8.4
Peroxide 2.6
TOTAL 100
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
Example 4
Compositions given in Table 3 were prepared by mixing the polymers with the
respective filler and additive combination using a two roll mill as described
earlier in Example 1. Compositions F to N are practical embodiments of the
5 present invention. Compositions 0 and P are comparative examples.
Specimens of nominal dimensions 30 mm x 13 mm x 1.7 mm were made from
these compositions by curing and moulding at 170 C for 30 minutes under a
pressure of approximately 7 MPa. One set of specimens was fired under the
slow firing conditions described in Example 1. For each composition, the
10 change in linear dimension along the length of the specimen caused by
firing
was determined by measuring the length before and after firing and the
flexural
strength of the resultant ceramic was determined by three-point bending of a
span length of 18 mm using a loading cross head speed of 0.2 mm/min.
Another set of specimens was fired placing them along the edge of a refractory
15 block in the manner described in Example 2 and inspected after firing to
determine whether they were able to self support during firing by remaining
without bending over the edge of the supporting refractory block. The results
of
all the tests are given in Table 3.
Table 3: Test results for compositions F to P
F G H I J K L M N 0 P
EP Polymer 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18
EVA Polymer 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5
Ammonium polyphosphate 35 10 27 27 27 27 27 27 27 - 27
Zinc Borate - - - - - - - - - 27 -
Talc 25 40 - - 25 25 25 10 15 25 -
Calcined clay - - 25 - - - - 11 - - - -
Wollastonite - - - 25 - - - - - - -
Alumina trihydrate 7 17 15 15 30 25 15
CaCO3 - - - - - - 15 - - - 40
MgCO3 - - - - - 15 - - - - -
BaCO3 - - - - 15 - - - - - -
Process oil 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.6
Additives 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4
Peroxide 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
TOTAL 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100
Firing Condition Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow Slow
Change in linear -3.1 -1.8 6 -2.5 5.5 6.7 6.3 2.3 1.6 - 6.4
dimensions 27.2
Strength of ceramic 6.20 3.82 2.9 2.3 2.65 3.43 4.20 2.64 3.86 - 0.76
residue (MPa)
Able to self support Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No
20 Note: A negative value for change in linear dimensions indicates a
shrinkage
and a positive value indicates an expansion
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
31
The results for compositions F to N show that, when heated up to 1000 C, the
compositions of the present invention undergo less than 10% change in linear
dimensions and the ceramic residue formed has a flexural strength in excess of
2 MPa. The comparison of the comparative example 0 with composition A
(Table 1) shows that, replacing the low melting inorganic phosphate component
(ammonium polyphosphate) in composition A with zinc borate, which also
produces a liquid phase at a similarly low temperature, results in a shrinkage
well in excess of 10% and the ceramic residue formed looses its ability to be
self-supporting. The comparative example P, which does not contain any
mineral silicate, results in a ceramic residue that is not self-supporting and
has
a flexural strength much less than the preferred value of at least 1 Mpa.
Example 5
This example compares the performance of the compositions of the invention
with a composition of US Patent US2003/0031818 (Horacek).
A two-roll mill was used to prepare the first composition from US Patent
US2003/0031818 denoted "Q" in Table 4, and also a composition of this
application, denoted "R" in Table 4. In each case, the EP polymer was banded
on the mill (40-50 C) and other components were added and allowed to
disperse by separating and recombining the band of material just before it
passed through the nip of the two rolls. When these were uniformly dispersed,
the peroxide was added and dispersed in a similar manner.
Flat rectangular sheets of about 1.7 mm thickness were fabricated from the
milled compositions by curing and moulding at 170 C for 30 minutes under a
pressure of approximately 7 MPa.
Rectangular sheet specimens with dimensions 30 mm x 13 mm x 1.7 mm
(approx) were cut from the moulded sheets and fired under fast firing
conditions
(insertion into a furnace maintained at 1000 C followed by holding at 1000 C
for
30 minutes). After firing, each sample took the form of a ceramic. Visual
examination confirmed that while composition "R" had formed a ceramic residue
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
32
that had maintained its original dimensions, composition "Q" had not
maintained
its shape and underwent a significant change in excess of +20%. A test formed
under slow firing conditions showed that composition "R" was self supporting
and composition "Q" was not. The performance of composition "Q" was
considered to be inadequate for use as a cable insulating material as it was
not
self-supporting and did not maintain shape and dimensions, and was therefore
likely to fail in any fire test. In contrast composition "R" showed net shape
retention (excellent dimensional stability).
Table 4: Compositions Q and R
Composition Q Composition R
PHR % %
EP Polymer 100 26.95 EP Polymer 18.50
LDPE 10 2.70 EVA Polymer 4.70
Ammonium
Clay 100 26.95 Polyphosphate 13.50
Pentaeryithritol 11.11 2.99 Talc 20.00
Melamine 22.22 5.99 Clay 7.50
Ammonium
Polyphosphate 66.67 17.97 Alumina Trihydrate 15.00
Paraffin wax 3.00 0.81 Calcium Carbonate 7.50
Paraffin oil 50.00 13.48 Process oil 5.80
Stearic acid 2.00 0.54 Coupling agent 1.00
Zinc oxide 2.00 0.54 Process aid 2.50
Stabiliser 1.00 0.27 Stabiliser 1.40
Coupling agent 1.00 0.27 Peroxide 2.60
Peroxide 2.00 0.54
Total 371 100.00 100.00
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
33
Example 6
This example relates to preparation of thermoplastic compositions in
accordance with the invention. Compositions shown in Table 5 were prepared.
[Tables
Thermoplastics L_ "- ] L_ "W
fl, polychlor EPDM
PVC PS TPV oprene
PVC Polymer 25
DOP plasticizer L 2.4
17-71
Ips
TPV 29.8
Polychloroprene 29.8
IEPDM 30
[Process Aids 1.4 0.7 0.4
Additives 1.2
APP 28.2 28.2 28.0 28.1 28.2
talc 26.1 26.1 25.9 26.0 26.1
ATH 15.7 15.7 15.6 15.7 15.7 E-71
Total 100 100 100 100 100
Firing conditions Slow Slow ISlow Slow Slow
Change in linear
dimensions -5.9 3.0 -5.3 3.0 5.6
Strength of ceramic
residue (MPa) 0.8 0.9 2.3 2.5 0.3
[Able to self support M7 yes yes yes yes
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
34
Compositions S to W in Table 5 were prepared by mixing the polymers with the
respective filler and additive combination using a Haake Reocord Batch Mixer.
Composition S was based on PVC powder (Australian Vinyls K62R2) mixed at a
temperature of 170 C, at 30 rpm for approximately 10 minutes. Composition T
was based on a powdered polystyrene (PS, Austrex 103) and was mixed at
180 C, at 40 rpm for 1 to 2 minutes until the torque stabilized, and then for
a
further 5 minutes. Composition U was based on a thermoplastic vulcanizate
(TPV, Santoprene 591-73), with calcium stearate and paraffin used as
processing aids premixed with the TPV pellets and fillers respectively, and
then
mixed in the same way as for the polystyrene composition. Example V was
based on a polychloroprene (Neoprene TRT). This composition was not
crosslinked. It was mixed at a temperature of 180 C, but otherwise per
Composition U. Example W was based on an ethylene propylene diene polymer
(Nordel 3745). This composition was not crosslinked. It was mixed at a
temperature of 170 C but other wise per Composition U.
3 mm thick plaques were compression moulded from these compositions at 155
to 180 C for approximately 10 minutes under a pressure of approximately 10
MPa. Specimens were then cut from the plaques. One set of specimens was
fired under the slow firing conditions and tested as described above. All
these
compositions based on thermoplastics produced self-supporting ceramics after
slow firing with less than 10% change in linear dimensions and flexural
strength
greater than 0.3 MPa.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
Example 7
This example relates to preparation of crosslinked rubbers in accordance with
the invention. Compositions shown in Table 6 were prepared.
Table 6
Rubbers X Y
r._._._
...................................................._....,.....................
.......__..........___....._.....`_.._.._...._.......__......................._
........"........__........._............ ........ _..................
__.._.._...... ....................
SBS NBR
SBS 35
NBR -_-j 35
,Process oil ~~-6 6
Additives T T^'--~- 3 3
Peroxide 4 4
APP 17 17
to I c 22~~22
BATH 13 13
.......... .... _...._.._..._.................. ........... ......
.........._.......... _.... ........
;Total 1 100 100
Firing conditions Slow ( Slow
Change in linear dimensions -6.4 -5.8
Strength of ceramic residue (MPa) ~- 2.8 4.8
.....................
self support
.............._.................._......_.....__...............___........~....
.... _. .i
Able to .... ...
pport ye.s f yes
s
5
The rubber compositions in Table 6 were prepared as follows.
Composition X is based on an SBS rubber (Kraton D1102CS), which is a clear
linear block copolymer based on styrene and butadiene with bound styrene of
10 29.5% mass and density of 0.94 g/cm3, The SBS was softened on a two-roll
mill
heated to about 50 C and all additives were added gradually until a
homogenous mixture was obtained. Dicumyl peroxide (DCP) was then added to
this mixture on the two roll mill.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
36
Composition Y is based on an NBR rubber from Nippon Zeon which is a block
copolymer with 41% acrylonitrile. The composition was prepared by mixing the
polymer with the respective filler and additive combination in an internal
mixer at
40 C.
Plaques were compression moulded from these compositions at 175 C for
approximately 25 minutes under a pressure of approximately 7 MPa.
Specimens were then cut from the plaque, fired under the slow firing
conditions
and tested as above.
These compositions based on crosslinked rubbers produced self-supporting
ceramics after slow firing with less than 10% change in linear dimensions and
greater than 2 MPa flexural strength.
Example 8
This example relates to preparation of polymer emulsion/dispersion
compositions in accordance with the invention. Compositions shown in Table 7
were prepared.
Table 7
Emulsion/dispersion AA AB AC
PVAc EAA SBA
Vinyl acetate homopolymer 34
_._ ............................
....... ... ..... .................................. ..............:
Ethyl Acrylate/Acrylonitrile 30
-------- -----------
!Styrene butyl acrylate 30
Process oil 6
LAPP 20 21 28.2
...... ............... ...... ..................... ........... -.....
..._.... _...... _................. _.._._..._._......................... -----
- ........... .... _..__._..._..._........._................. ........
_.......... ...._........_..._.............. ..._..........
talc 24 r 26 26.1
ATH
16 r 1715.7
[Tota i 100 100 1 100
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
37
Firing conditions slow slow slow
lChange in linear dimensions -4.6 -1.5 -1.3
Strength of ceramic residue
(MPa) 6.3 5.3 3.3
'Able to self support yes yes yes
The aqueous dispersion formulations in Table 7 were prepared as follows.
Composition AA was based on Acropol 63-075 (from Nuplex Resins) which is a
vinyl acetate homopolymer emulsion with 55% solid content and viscosity of
2500 cP. Composition AB was based on Primal NWB-56 (from Rohm and
Haas) which consists of ethyl acrylate and acrylonitrile monomers. Composition
AC was based on Texicryl 13-092 (from Nuplex Resins) which is a styrene butyl
acrylate (copolymer) dispersion with 50% solid content and viscosity of 500
cP.
In all cases the polymer content in the formulations is based on the solid
content of the respective emulsions/dispersions.
The inorganic components (APP, talc and ATH) were first hand mixed and,
when mixed properly, the process oil was added. The emulsion/dispersion was
then added to the mixture and thoroughly mixed using an overhead mixer at
medium speed with a dispersion head attachment, for about 5 minutes to
produce a paste like material. The paste was cast on a PET sheet and air dried
at room temperature for 3 days. Samples were then cut from the cast plaque
and fired under the slow firing conditions as described in Example 1 and
tested
as described in Example 4.
All these compositions based on emulsions/dispersions of polymers produced
self supporting ceramics after slow firing with less than 10% change in linear
dimensions and greater than 2 MPa flexural strength.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
38
Example 9
This example relates to preparation of polyimide (PI) composition in
accordance
with the invention. Compositions in Table 8 were prepared.
Table 8
Polyimide AD
_._._........._---
PI
!Polyimide 24
._....
.......... ...............
......._.......................................................................
... _....................... ..._.............. _................
.............. ......... _...................__._...__ ........ .........
APP 26 _j
talc 32~_
ATH 18
_...._...._ .........._..._.._....._... .........._.__ ..._.....
'Total 100
Firing conditions Slow
Change in linear dimensions approx -15%
Strength of ceramic residue strong
.............. ............. _..... _...................... ..............
...................... ......... _.... .......... ...............
...................i......................... ....................
Able to self support yes
Polyimide was prepared by the following method:
1. 0.04 moles (8.01 g) of oxydianaline bis(4-aminophenyl)ether polymer
(ODA) was dissolved in 25 g of N,N-dimethyl acetamide (DMAc) and
stirred for 1 hour (a clear solution was obtained.)
2. 0.04 moles (8.72 g) of pyromellitic dianhydride (PMDA) were added to
the above solution and the mixture was stirred for 30 minutes. Another
g of DMAc was added to this mixture to facilitate the mixing. Mixture
15 was stirred until a homogenous and viscose mixture (poly(amic acid) pre-
polymer) was obtained
3. The inorganic components were mixed properly and the mixture was wet
with 25 g of DMAc.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
39
The inorganic components were then gradually added to the pre-polymer to
give the composition AD in Table 8, which was then stirred for 45 minutes. The
mixture was homogenous and viscose with a paint-like consistency.
After casting the pre-polymer based composition onto petri-dishes, samples
were cured according to the following heat program: 100 C for 1 hour, then
150 C for 1 hour, then 200 C for 45 minutes, then 250 C for 1 hours, then
cooled slowly in the oven overnight.
During heating the polyimide solution moved to the surface of the mixture and
formed a thin brittle polymer layer. This PI composite was brittle.
Two pieces of PI samples were fired under the slow firing conditions as
described in Example 1. The resulting ceramic shrank by an estimated 15%. It
was self-supporting and strong.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
Example 10
This example relates to preparation of thermosetting resins in accordance with
the invention. Thermosetting resins shown in Table 9 were prepared.
5
;Table 9 iIIIITi*_IiP
Thermosettin Resins AE AF
AG
epoxy polyester vinyl ester
epoxy monomer 19.4
cycloaliphatic anhydride
hardener 15.6
polyester resin 21.6
................ ........... ........................... ...... ....
........... _. ..................................
vinyl esters 23.6
..... __.... _.... _._.__......._... ........... .... .............
!benzoyl peroxide I 0.3 0.3
APP
26.2 31.5 40.5
talc 24.2 29.1 13.1
ATH 14.6 17.5 22.5
Total 100 100 100
........._......_......_................_...._.................. .........
..... ..._.............._
firing conditions Slow i Slow Slow
Change in linear dimensions -0.7 -2.9 -5.5
Strength of ceramic residue
(MPa)
5.0 3.3 4.0
................._____._...__.pp___.._......___...._......___.._.._-._......
_....__....._.._ _.... _.......__ _..._...._.._y-.__. _.._._..._..._.-
__._.__.~
y
Able to self support yes yes
j es
Composition AE was prepared by first mixing an epoxy monomer (Huntsman
Araldite CY179) with a cycloaliphatic anhydride (Huntsman Aradur HY906). This
mixture was pre-heated to 80 C, then the talc, aluminium trihydrate and
10 ammonium polyphosphate were added with continuous stirring. The uncured
mixture, in the form of a paste, was compressed into an aluminium plate mould
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
41
(3 mm thick, x 100 mm x 100 mm) and cured for 3h at 120 C, and then post-
cured for 16h at 160 C.
Composition AF was prepared by mixing a polyester resin (Huntsman Estarez
1030 PALSE) with benzoyl peroxide, talc, alumina trihydrate and ammonium
polyphosphate. This mixture was stirred to form a smooth paste, which was
compressed into an aluminium mold (100 x 100 x 3 mm thick) and cured at
50 C for 12h.
Composition AG was prepared by mixing vinyl ester resin (Huntsman Estarez
7222 PAS), benzoyl peroxide, talc, alumina trihydrate and ammonium
polyphosphate. This mixture was stirred to form a smooth paste, which was
compressed into an aluminium mould (100 x 100 x 3 mm thick) and cured at
35 C for 18h.
Test specimens were machined from the cured formulations, then fired under
the slow firing conditions and tested as above.
These compositions produced self-supporting ceramics with linear shrinkage of
less than 10% and flexural strength in excess of 2 MPa.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
42
Example 11
This example relates to preparation of polyurethane (PU) foam compositions in
accordance with the invention. The foams were of the composition shown in
Table 10.
r_....._........___.......... ................ - ...............
.............. .._._.................. ....... ................... _.....
....... .... ................. ..... _..._._...................
................ __........-
.......1..............__...............,...............__........-
Table 10
.................................._.........'
........ ............... .....................................
...................Polyurethane Foams ..... AH Al
flexible PU rigid PU
Polyol (Daltoflex JC 88870) 33.3
..... ..... .. .. ......... ............ ............ ..........._
Polyol..._(Daltofoam...._MO...._90400)..........? ............... _._...._._ .
.. 28.3
___....._...;
_
Isocyanate (Suprasec 7114) 26.7
Isocyanate (Suprasec 5005) 31.7
APP 15 15
...............
........ ......... ......................
talc 15 15
H
---
100 100
Tots
firing conditions (Slow Slow
`Change in linear dimensions -27.8 -11.9
.`Able to self support yes yes
The foamed compositions in Table 10 were prepared by combining the
10 inorganic components with the polyol component in a 1 litre beaker using a
high
torque mixer at 500 rpm. The isocyanurate component was then added and
stirring was continued until the composition began to foam. The samples were
allowed to cure for at least 72 hours at room temperature before cutting
samples of approximately 30 x 15 x 15 mm using a band saw. One set of
specimens was fired under the slow firing conditions and tested as described
above. Due to the low density foamed nature of these materials, the strength
of
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
43
the ceramic was relatively low. In both cases the change in linear dimensions
was less than 30% and the ceramics were self-supporting.
Example 12
A copper conductor of 1.5 mm2 cross section was insulated with a single layer
of 0.8 mm wall thickness of a ceramifiable composition R (Table 4). This
insulated conductor was twisted together with three other insulated conductors
made in the same way to form an assembly of four insulated conductors.
The assembly of twisted, insulated conductors was then sheathed with a
commercially available halogen-free, low-smoke, low-toxicity thermoplastic
compound, forming a finished cable. Segments of this cable were then
subjected to the circuit integrity tests of:
AS/NZS3013:1995,
IEC 60331 2002
BS6387 Cat C, W, Z
The AS/NZS3013 test requires the cable segments to be energised at 240 Volts
and then subjected to a furnace test of 2 hours duration to reach a final
temperature of 1,050 C, and then subjected to a water jet spray for 3 minutes.
Three segments of cable made and tested as described were able to maintain
circuit integrity and thus meet the requirements of the circuit integrity test
of
AS/NZS3013:1995. The cable made with composition R as described above
satisfactorily passed the requirements of the test.
The IEC 60331 test involves supporting a length of cable above a ribbon burner
on earthed metal rings. The temperature of the burner is adjusted to 950 C
before the energised cable is placed in position over it, and the cable must
withstand this exposure for three hours. The cable made with composition R as
described above satisfactorily passed the requirements of the test.
CA 02561824 2006-10-12
WO 2005/095545 PCT/AU2005/000465
44
The BS6387 Tests are in three parts, with the cat C being almost identical to
the
IEC60331 test, the cat Z being 15 minutes of 950 C burner exposure with a
mechanical shock every 30 seconds and the cat W being 15 minutes of 650 C
burner exposure followed by 15 minutes of simultaneous water spray and
burner exposure. The cable made with composition R as described above
satisfactorily passed the requirements of the tests.
