Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
MLTLTI-FREQUENCY HEAT TREATMENT OF A WORKPIECE
BY INDUCTION HEATING
Cross Reference To Related Applications
[0001] This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent
Application Serial
No. 60/564,03 filed April 21, 2004, hereby incorporated herein by reference in
its entirety.
Field of the Invention
[0002] The present invention relates to heat treatment of an electrically
conductive workpiece
wherein a combination of two distinct forms of induction heating at different
frequencies is used
to accomplish the heat treatment.
Background of the Invention
[0003] A gear, or other workpiece, may be inductively heat treated by passing
an ac current
through an induction coil. The current creates a magnetic field around the
coil that magnetically
couples with the gear to induce eddy current in the gear. Induction hardening
of gears provides a
martensitic layer at the tooth surface of the gear to increase hardness and
wear resistance while
allowing the remainder of the gear to be unaffected by the process. The
increase in hardness also
improves contact fatigue strength and other mechanical properties. The
geometrical complexity
of gears and variation in electromagnetic coupling between the induction coil,
and tooth tip and
root fillet, results in different induced heat intensities in the tip versus
the root of the gear.
[0004] Frequency of the current makes a noticeable effect on eddy current flow
within the gear
and heat distribution. Basically when it is necessary to harden the tooth tips
only with a single
frequency of current using a single-turn or multi-turn solenoid coil, a
relatively high frequency
(e.g. 30 kHz to 450 kHz) and high power density are applied. See for example
FIG.1(a). When
relatively high frequency current (power) is applied to coil 100, eddy current
induced heating in
gear 102 follows the contour of the gear as indicated by representative
heating profile lines 104.
Since the highest concentration of the current density will be in the tip of
tooth 106, there will be
a power surplus in the tip compared to root 108. Taking also into account that
the tip of the tooth
has the minimum amount of metal to be heated compared to root 108, the tip
will experience the
most intensive temperature rise over the entire heating cycle. In addition,
from the thermal
perspective, the amount of metal beneath the gear root represents a much
greater heat sink
compared to the tooth tip. Another factor that also complements the more
intensive heating of
the tooth tip deals with a better electromagnetic coupling due to the
electromagnetic proximity
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
effect between the inductor coil and tooth tip in comparison to the root;
higher frequency has a
tendency to make the proximity effect more pronounced. '
[0005] When inductively hardening tooth root 108, a relatively low frequency
(e.g., 50 Hz to
20 kHz) is preferable. With a low frequency, the eddy current penetration
depth is much greater
than with high frequency. When heating fine pitch and medium pitch gears it is
much easier for
low frequency induced current to make a short path and follow the base circle
or root line of the
gear instead of following the tooth profile. See for example FIG.1(b) and
representative heating
profile lines 110. The result is more intensive heating of the root fillet
area compared to the tip
of the tooth.
[0006] Typically, in order to provide a hardness pattern that follows the
profile of the gear tooth
(from tip to root) preheating of the gear is required. Depending upon the gear
geometry,
preheating is usually accomplished by using a medium or low frequency (e.g.
less than 20kHz).
High frequency (e.g. 30 kHz through 450 kHz) is applied during the final
heating stage.
[0007] FIG. 2 illustrates one prior art method of inductive heating that
utilizes a single coil 114
and two inverters 116a and 116b that are sources of low (or medium) frequency
power, at low
power density, and high frequency power, at high power density, respectively.
The salient steps
of the method are: place a gear within coil 114; rotate the gear; apply low
frequency current from
inverter 116a (by opening contacts 118 and closing contacts 120) to the coil
to inductively
preheat the gear; disconnect the coil from inverter 116a (by closing contacts
118) and apply high
frequency current from inverter 116b (by opening contacts 120) to heat the
gear to hardening
temperature; remove the high frequency current from the gear; and quench the
gear. Major
drawbacks of this method is the system's low reliability and high cost. High
currents are required
for induction heating, and high current electromechanical contacts usually
have a short life.
Longer lasting electronic switches can be used in lieu of mechanical switches,
but this would
increase the overall cost of the system.
[0008] FIG. 3 illustrates another prior art method of inductive heating that
utilizes two coils,
namely preheat coil 128a and final heat coil 128b, and two inverters 130a and
130b. Medium
frequency power inverter 130a supplies power to the preheat coil at low power
density and high
frequency power inverter 130b supplies power to the final heat coil at high
power density. In this
method gear 102 is sequenced by a suitable mechanical transfer system (in
direction of arrow
shown in FIG. 3) through preheat coil 128a, final heat coil 128b and quench
ring 132 to harden
gear 102 (shown in preheat coil). A major drawback of this method is that a
short time between
preheating and final heating (e.g. less than 1 second) may be required. This
results in increased
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
equipment cost, since the mechanical transfer system must be of a precision
design for fast
(fraction of a second) and accurate gear transfer from the preheating position
to the final heat
position.
[0009] In another prior art method simultaneous dual frequency power supply is
used for gear
hardening, for example, as disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 2,444,259 (Method of
High Frequency
Induction Heating). The output of the simultaneous dual frequency power
supplies consists of
two appreciably different frequencies. One of frequencies provides heating of
the root fillet and
the other frequency provides heating of the tooth contour. A major drawback of
this
simultaneous dual frequency heating method is that the shape of the single
coil cannot be
optimized for both frequencies.
[0010] One objective of the present invention is improving the uniformity of
induction
hardening of gears (in particular, but not limited to, conical gears and
pinion gears) and the
reduction of gear distortion by using a relatively low frequency C-core type
induction heating of
the workpiece in combination with a relatively high frequency of induction
heating of the
workpiece using a separate induction coil.
Brief Summary of the Invention
[0011] In one aspect, the present invention is an apparatus for, and method
of, heat treating a
workpiece by using a combination of two different types (configurations) of
induction coils. The
workpiece is inductively heated by a first ac current flow through a first
induction coil that
surrounds the workpiece. The first ac current establishes a magnetic field
that inductively
couples with the workpiece. The workpiece is also heated by placing the
workpiece in an
opening in a low frequency C-core type inductor that is coupled to a second
induction coil that
represents a primary winding. The second induction coil is connected to a
second ac current
source. The magnetic flux generated by the primary winding flows through the C-
core (that acts
as a magnetic flux diverter) and also through the workpiece. This induces a
current in the
workpiece that heats the workpiece due to the Joule effect. Basically the same
magnetic flux will
flow though the laminated C-core and through the heated component. However,
since the C-core
is made from a laminated magnetic material, or a powder-based magnetic
material, it has a much
higher electrical resistivity to the induced eddy current. This results in a
drastically reduced
amount of induced eddy current in the C-core compared to the eddy current
induced within the
workpiece, and consequently, more intense heating of the workpiece than the C-
core. Generally
the first ac current is higher in frequency than the second ac current.
Inductive heating of the
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
4
workpiece using eddy currents generated by a first ac source and the second ac
source may be
simultaneous or non-simultaneous.
[0012] ~ther aspects of the invention are set forth in this specification and
the appended claims.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0013] For the purpose of illustrating the invention, there is shown in the
drawings a form that is
presently preferred; it being understood, however, that this invention is not
limited to the precise
arrangements and instrumentalities shown.
[0014] FIG.1(a) illustrates typical eddy current flow and gear induction
heating profiles with a
high frequency current.
[0015] FIG.1(b) illustrates typical eddy current flow and gear induction
heating profiles with a
low frequency current.
[0016] FIG. 2 illustrates one prior art method of sequential induction
preheating and final
heating of a workpiece.
[0017] FIG. 3 illustrates another prior art method of sequential induction
preheating and final
heating of a workpiece.
[0018] FIG. 4 illustrates one example of the mufti-frequency heat treatment
apparatus of the
present invention.
[0019] FIG. 5 illustrates another example of the mufti-frequency heat
treatment apparatus of the
present invention.
[0020] FIG. 6 illustrates another example of the mufti-frequency heat
treatment apparatus of the
present invention.
[0021] FIG. 7 illustrates another example of the mufti-frequency heat
treatment apparatus of the
present invention.
[0022] FIG. 8 illustrates another example of the mufti-frequency heat
treatment apparatus of the
present invention.
[0023] FIG. 9 illustrates another example of the mufti-frequency heat
treatment apparatus of the
present invention.
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
Detailed Description of the Invention
[0024] There is shown in FIG. 4 one example of the induction heat treating
apparatus 10 of the
present invention. While workpiece 14 illustrated in FIG. 4 is
diagrammatically represented as a
pinion gear, the induction heat treating apparatus of the present invention is
also applicable to
other types of gears, and other types of electrically conductive workpieces.
High frequency (HF)
solenoidal coil 12 at least partially surrounds workpiece 14. Coil 12 may be a
single or
mufti-turn coil. Low frequency C-core inductor 16 comprises a stationary core
segment 16a and
moveable core segment 16b. The low frequency core may be formed from magnetic
materials
known in the art, such as a laminated magnetic material, or a powder-based
magnetic material,
such as a ferrite or iron based material. Low frequency (LF) solenoidal coil
18 surrounds a
portion of stationary core segment 16a.
[0025] HF solenoidal coil 12 is suitably connected to a power source of high
frequency current
(not shown in the figure) and LF solenoidal coil 18 is suitably connected to a
power source of
low frequency current (not shown in the figure). The HF magnetic field
generated by the flow of
high frequency current in HF solenoidal coil 12 magnetically couples with
workpiece 14 to
achieve high frequency induction heating of the workpiece.
[0026] The LF magnetic field generated by the flow of low frequency current in
LF solenoidal
coil 18 magnetically couples with C-core inductor 16 to induce a low frequency
magnetic field in
the C-core. Since workpiece 14 is disposed in the gap in the C-core inductor,
the workpiece
forms a part of the magnetic circuit. Since workpiece 14 is generally not
laminated or otherwise
formed to inhibit low frequency current flow through it, low frequency induced
current will flow
through the workpiece to heat it by the Joule effect, while the low frequency
C-core remains
relatively unheated. When the workpiece temperature is below the Curie point
there will be an
additional heating generated by hysteresis losses.
[0027] Flux concentrators 15, as known in the art, can be used to focus on the
ends of the
workpiece to allow an appropriate distribution of the electromagnetic field in
the C-core end
areas, and at the same time, provide space for the HF solenoidal coil to be
simultaneously
positioned around the outside diameter of the gear. The workpiece can be
inductively heated by
simultaneous or non-simultaneous application of the HF magnetic field to the
workpiece and the
LF magnetic field to the C-core while the workpiece is in the gap of the C-
core.
Non-simultaneous applications may be accomplished by a number of different
methods. For
example, inductive heating using the low frequency solenoid coil and high
frequency C-core coil
may be sequential in time, or partially overlapped in time.
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
[0028] In the prior art as discussed above, unlike in the present invention, a
LF solenoidal coil is
used to accomplish low frequency induction heating. Skin effect and proximity
effect both
define the induction heating temperature profile when using a LF solenoidal
coil that wraps
around the outside of a tapered gears such as pinion gears. Proximity effect
draws the current
flow within the gear to the surfaces closest to the coil. Because a pinion
gear is tapered, the
current will flow more in the large diameter portion of the gear and less in
the small diameter
portion. This uneven heating due to unequal electromagnetic coupling or
proximity effect can be
somewhat compensated for by tapering the inside diameter of the LF solenoidal
coil to match the
taper of the pinion. This approach is very position sensitive and seldom
results in good
uniformity.
[0029] Only skin effect and the geometry of flux concentrators located at the
end areas define
the low frequency heating temperature profile within a tapered gear such as a
pinion when using
a C-core inductor as in the present invention. Skin effect causes the induced
current to flow near
the outer surface of the gear. The higher the frequency, the nearer to the
outer surface the current
will flow, causing more shallow heating and conversely, inducing current at
lower frequency,
will result in deeper current flow and subsurface heating. The lack of
proximity effect when
using a C-core inductor therefore allows for a much more uniform heating along
the taper of the
pinion. While the use of a C-core inductor for low frequency heating in the
present invention has
important advantages over more conventional heating with a solenoid-type
induction coil when
heating tapered gears including pinions, the scope of the invention is not
limited to heating those
types of workpieces..
[0030] Successive workpieces can be loaded into the heating position shown in
FIG. 4 by:
lowering moveable (drop-down) core segment 16b with a suitable mechanical
transfer system to
remove a hardened workpiece; inserting a non-heat treated workpiece in its
place; and raising the
moveable core segment so that the non-heat treated workpiece is positioned as
shown in FIG. 4
for the heat treating process.
[0031] In other examples of the invention the workpiece is located between
centering
elements 30 that are part of the C-core circuit shown in FIG. 5. The centering
elements provide
a means for holding and rotating the workpiece during the heating process. In
this non-limiting
example of the invention the centers are positioned through the C-core
inductor. In order to
reduce undesirable heating of the centering elements, the centering elements
preferably comprise
non-magnetic materials, such as a non-magnetic stainless steel.
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
[0032] FIG. 6 illustrates another example of the induction heating apparatus
of the present
invention. In this arrangement sufficient moveable C-core segment 16b is
provided to allow
vertical movement of the workpiece 14 so that the workpiece can alternatively
be brought within
HF solen~idal coil 12 and removed therefrom for LF induction heating of the
workpiece or vice
versa. When the workpiece is not within the HF solenoidal coil as shown in
FIG. 6 (LF heating
position designated "B" in FIG. 6) induction heating by the C-core circuit can
be accomplished;
when the workpiece is disposed within HF solenoidal coil 12 (HF heating
position designated
"A" in FIG. 6) the HF magnetic field causes the workpiece to be inductively
heated.
[0033] In other examples of the invention, as shown in FIG. 7 and FIG. 8, a
double C-core
inductor 17, comprising fixed core segments 17a, 17b,17c and 17d, and moveable
core segments
17e and 17f. Each of the C-core inductors can be provided with a LF solenoidal
coil. By way of
the non-limiting example in FIG. 7, LF solenoidal coils 18a and 18b are wound
around fixed
core segments 17a and 17b, respectively. Coils 18a and 18b are preferably
connected in series,
but may also be connected in parallel, to a suitable common power'source of
low frequency
current (not shown in the figure). The example of the invention in FIG. 7 also
incorporates
separate upper and lower positions for LF and HF inductive heating,
respectively, as also
illustrated in FIG. 6.
[0034] FIG. 8 is similar to FIG. 7 except that rather than using separate LF
and HF inductive
heating stations, the workpiece is positioned between the two C-cores and in
the HF solenoidal
coil so that, if desired, simultaneous heating could be accomplished as
previously discussed
relative to FIG. 4.
[0035] FIG. 9 illustrates another example of the induction heating apparatus
of the present
invention. In this arrangement C-core inductor 19 comprises core segments 19a
and 19b and
workpiece 14a has an opening, such as but not limited to the gear shown in
FIG. 9. LF
solenoidal coil 18c surrounds a section of the C-core inductor and is
connected to a power source
of low frequency current. HF solenoidal coil 12a (shown in this non-limiting
example as a single
turn coil) is connected to a power source of high frequency current. The flow
of low frequency
current in LF solenoidal coil 18c establishes a magnetic field that couples
with the C-core
inductor, which in turn, magnetically couples with workpiece 14a when it is
inserted in the C-
core inductor through its opening, to inductively heat the workpiece. The flow
of high frequency
current in HF solenoidal coil 12a establishes a magnetic field that couples
with workpiece 14a
when the workpiece is brought within the vicinity of the field, to inductively
heat the workpiece.
Low frequency and high frequency heating may be accomplished simultaneously or
alternatively
by either moving the workpiece away from the HF solenoidal coil (low frequency
heating only)
CA 02562192 2006-10-05
WO 2005/107325 PCT/US2005/013670
or applying power to only the LF or HF solenoidal coil. A segment of the C-
core inductor,
representatively shown as core segment 19b in FIG. 9 may be moveable
(illustrated by double
headed arrow) to allow removal of the workpiece from the C-core inductor.
[0036] In all examples of the invention HF solenoidal coil 12 and 12a may be
configured in
other shapes than those shown in the figures. In the figures, since the non-
limiting electrically
conductive workpiece used is a pinion gear, the HF solenoidal coil assumes the
shape of an open
conic section to generally conform to the outer shape of the pinion gear. In
other examples of the
inventions, depending upon the workpiece and desired induction heating
pattern, the HF
solenoidal coil may be differently shaped. For example the inside perimeter of
HF solenoidal
coil 12 might not be parallel to an outside diameter of a pinion gear.
Depending upon the
application, a variation of the electromagnetic coupling between coil 12 and
the surface of the
workpiece can be used as an additional tool to control the heat distribution
as known by one
skilled in the art and without deviating from the scope of the present
invention.
[0037] Although in the above examples of the invention a solenoidal coil is
used for the HF
induction coil, other types of induction coils are also suitable for use in
the invention. For
example, the HF coil may be a single-shot or channel type inductor where
current would
predominantly flow in the longitudinal direction compared to circumferential
current induced by
a solenoidal coil.
[0038] The terms "low frequency" and "high frequency" when used with the
present invention,
in the broadest sense, means that the "high frequency" is higher than the "low
frequency."
Typically but not by way of limitation the "high frequency" will be in the
preferable range of 30
kHz to 450 kHz, and the "low frequency" will be in the preferable range of 50
Hz to 20 kHz.
[0039] While a moveable core segment is used in all of the above examples of
the invention, in
the examples wherein simultaneous LF and HF induction heating is possible (see
e.g. FIG. 4,
FIG. 5, and FIG. 8) the C-core inductor may comprise a totally stationary C-
core while means
are provided for movement of HF solenoidal coil 12 so that progressive
workpieces may be
inserted into the gap in the C-core inductor.
[0040] The foregoing examples do not limit the scope of the disclosed
invention. The scope of
the disclosed invention is further set forth in the appended claims.
