Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
C-treated nanoparticles and agglomerate and composite thereof as transition
metal
polyanion cathode materials and process for making.
Background and problem to solve:
Lithium ion batteries have known a phenomenal technical success and commercial
growth since the intial work by Sony (1) based on lithium insertion
electrodes: essentially
the high voltage cobalt oxide cathode investigated by J. B. Goodenough (2) and
the
carbon anode using coke or graphitized carbonaceous materials (3).
These batteries have progressively replaced existing Ni-Cd and Ni-MH because
of their
superior performances in most portable electronic applications. However,
because of their
cost and intrinsic instability under abusive conditions, especially in their
fully charged
state, only small cell size and format have been commercialized with success.
A second breakthrough by Dr. Goodenough (4, 5) was acheived when he suggested
that
polyanionic phosphate structures, namely nasicon and olivines, could raise the
redox
potential of low cost and environmentally compatible transition metal such as
Fe, until
then associated to a low voltage of insertion. For example LiFePO4 was shown
to
reversibly insert-deinsert lithium ion at a voltage of 3.45V vs a lithium
anode
corresponding to a two phase reaction. Furthermore, covalently bounded oxygen
atom in
the phosphate polyanion eliminates the cathode instability observed in fully
charged
layered oxides, making an inherently safe lithium-ion battery as confirmed
later in lab
cells and in full cell abusive testing (6 ).
As pointed out by Goodenough (4, 7), one drawback associated with the
covalently
bonded polyanions in LiFePO4 cathode materials is the low electronic
conductivity and
limited Li+ diffusivity in the material. Reducing LiFePO4 particles to the
nanoscale level
was pointed out as one solution to these problems as was the partial
supplementation of
the iron metal or phosphate polyanion by other metal or anions.
One significant improvement to the problem of low electronic conductivity of
complex
metal oxide cathode powder and more specifically of metal phosphate was
acheived with
the use of an organic carbon precursor that is pyrolysed onto the cathode
material or its
precursor to improve electrical field at the level of the cathode particles,
Ravet (8 , 9, 10),
Nazar (11).
Other ways to improve conductivity in phosphate cathode powder are described
(12, 13,
14) by using conductive carbon black or graphite powder intimately to the
cathode
powder or cathode precursors before synthesis. Such addition call usually for
relatively
large quantities of C to get good connectivity and do not result in a good
attachement of
the C to the metal phosphate crystal stucture, a characteristic judged
essential to maintain
contact despite volume variations during long term cycling.
Such recent improvements have led several battery manufacturers and users to
undertake
the developement of safe mid to large size lithium-ion batteries based on
transition metal
phosphates cathode materials for use in portable power tools, HEV and PHEV as
well as
2/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
for large stationnary batteries for backup power and energy storage from
intemittent
sources.
Problems remain however to optimize the processability, cost and performance
especially
when power, energy and cyclability are required simultaneously.
Composite electrode optimization, for example, requires short distances for
Li+ diffusion
in the solid state and the presence of an electronically conductive phase at
the level of
each nanoparticle of LiFePO4, by nanoparticle we mean particle having
dimensions
ranging from 5 nm to submicrons. Manipulation and processing (coating and
compacting)
of elementary nanoparticles or their dispersion is more complex than with
micron-size
particles given their large surfaces and low compaction.
It was found that through the use of agglomerate of nanoparticles or
nanocoposites that
are at a micron-size scale instead of elementary nano particles, one can
benefit from the
nano dimensions for ions and electron easy access while manipulating and
apparent
micron-size large particles.
As a general rule, electrochemical performance optimization of such
agglomerates of
nanoparticles or nanocomposite materials requires a maximum fraction of active
metal
phosphate, a minimum fraction of electrochemically inert conductive carbon and
a
controlled degree of open porosity of the agglomerate or nanocomposite
material,
futhermore, pore channel dimensions must be designed to allow solvated
lithiums ion of
the electrolyte to penetrate and reach elementary nano sized particle to
support high
charge or discharge rate currents.
Designing such agglomerates or composite made of nanoparticles as well as
attaching
efficiently 'nano layers of conducting carbon' to single or agglomerated nano
particle
internal or external surface becomes a challenge if one want to avoid using
too much
dead weight carbon. The present invention address this problem at the level of
presynthetised transition metal phosphates as well as at the level of the
metal phosphate
precursor.
Systematic study by the inventors have pointed out that metal phosphate
agglomerated
precursors have great impact on the structure and the properties of lithium
metal
phosphate final product (10). For example, most of the commercially available
FePO4,
H20 precursor made by wet chemistry process has large dense aggregates in the
range of
40-200 micron composed of fine primary particles with size of 0.1-1 microns.
Synthesis
of such lithium metal phosphate using large agglomerated particle precursors
requires
long sintering times and sometimes leads to large particle size, sintered
material and
impurity phases due to incomplete reaction between the reactants.
Pre-synthesis grinding, such as air jet milling of FePO4.2H20, can reduce the
size of
secondary particles to micron size, for example D50 at 2 microns and D 100 at
10 microns.
The electrochemical performance of the LiFePO4/C can be significantly improved
by
3/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
using the air jet milled FePO4.2H2O precursor but still sintering inside the
large
agglomerates lead to limited power capability as an electrode.
Further study by the inventors indicates that when certain organic carbon
precursors were
used in the process, the non-agglomerated nanosize FePO4.2H2O particles
remained un-
agglomerated even at the optimized synthesis temperatures required to obtain
lithium
metal phosphate,. On the contrary, the dense large agglomerates or aggregates
tend to
sinter to a large degree even with the use of organic precursor such as used
in (10). Such
dense and large particle made from the aglomerates or aggregates deteriorate
the rate
performance of the final products because of low Li+ diffusion and or lack of
conductive
carbon inside the particle.
It is therefore a critical step to prepare the metal phosphate precursor so as
to achieve non
agglomerated and well dispersed fine particles in the nanometre and sub-micron
range
before sintering synthesis. In another aspect of the invention, it is also
possible to create
precursor agglomerates having the right structure, porosity and carbon
precursor
localization from said well dispersed nano particles in order to design
optimized
agglomerates of nanoparticles or nanocomposites of the final product. There
are many
ways and technologies available to obtain non-agglomarated fine particles
depending on
the physical properties of the available metal phosphate. For examples, if the
metal
phosphate is not hard agglomerates or aggregates, ultrasons can be used to
break the
secondary particles and disperse the elementary particles or smaller
agglomerates and
stabilized the liquid suspension of those by using and organic stabilizer or
dispersant..
Grinding or comminuting is one of the most used processes allowing the
production of
fine particles and/or to de-agglomerate. More recently, industrial ultra fine
wet grinding
equipement have been made available commercially that can be used to reduce
particle
size down to 10 to 20 nm. However, with time the nano particles tend to re-
agglomerate
due to strong van der Waals interaction or electrical double layer
interaction. The organic
stabilizer will modify surface charge and increase the repulsive force between
particles to
counter the van de Waals force. To stabilize the dispersion or better to
control the degree
of agglomeration of nanoparticles it was found that several organic
electrostatic or
electrosteric stabilizers, surfactants, dispersant or encapsulant agents
available
commercially can be used with success.
One advantage of the present invention is then to take profit of such surface
active
organic chemical not only to disperse or agglomerate the metal phosphate or
its precursor
but also to convert those to conductive carbon through pyrolysis of the
organic chemical.
In some preferred mode of realization the organic stabilizer or dispersant of
the
suspension will act as an organic carbon precursor and when pyrolysed to
generate a
conductive carbon deposit on the precursor or optionnally on the final product
dispersion.
However, in such a case, some organic stabilizers are not desirable in this
application
because of the side effects, such as the production of highly toxic gas during
pyrolysis or
the contamination of the cathode material (Na, S...) that might affect cell
performance
and cyclability.
4/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
Until now the need to use nanoparticles or their agglomerate or nanocomposite
thereof
have led most developpers to prepare transition metal phosphates by
precipiting the final
product in so-called hydrothermal processes (15,16) in order to control
particle size and
distribution directly by the synthesis reaction.
In an earlier work the applicants have developed a low cost synthesis process
to make
phosphate cathode material have been patented (17) but that result in solid
crystalline
ingots or micron size powders as made by conventional grinding process. The
process of
the invention to make nanosized particles or agglomerates or nanocomposite
themself
coated at a nanoscale with conductive carbone make such molten process viable
for high
power cathode materials.
In another prefereed mode of realization, a low viscosity, optionnally
crosslikable,
polymerizable, or polycondensable, organic precursor will be used to wet and
penetrate
reconstituted agglomerates or aggregates of nanoparticle of the precursor or
the final
product.
Preferentially the materials of the present invention will consist of
elementary particles of
nanosize dimension of transition metal phosphate cathode material, especially
of the
'general LiMXO4 formula' or of agglomerate or nanocomposite thereof to which a
conductive carbon deposit has been 'attached' to the phosphate crystal
structure in
nanosized layers of carbon preferentially of graphitized or 'graphene' carbon.
It has been
found that the organic carbon precursor pyrolysis mechanism in contact with
transition
metal compounds allows the growth of at least partially graphitized layers on
the
phosphate crystal in a complex mechanism that might, although non
limitatively, involve
a gaz phase mechanism of carbon growth. The nature, ratio and localization of
the carbon
deposit were found to be controlled by the selection of the appropriate
organic precursor,
its mechanism of surface adsorption and pyrolysis on the external surface of
the
elementary particles or to the internal or external surface of the secondary
particles
(agglomerates or nanocomposites). Carbon layer thickness can be varied with
the
application or material but can be as low as a few to a few (x10) nanometers
thus
nessecitating only a few % wt of carbon (0.5-10% or more prefered 1-5%) with
the metal
phosphate to get efficient electronic conduction by carbon percolation
(continuous
deposit) or by short distance tunelling mechanism (discontinuous deposit).
The present invention addresses these problems with a new multi-steps process
to make
cathode material having variable combination of such characteristics.
Typically the process of the invention comprises the following steps:
1. Grinding or de-agglomerating metal phosphate or metal phosphate precursor
to
nano size or sub-micron size in the presence or not of an Organic Precursor
(OP).
2. Adsorbing and distributing OP on the external surface of elementary
particles to
stabilize their dispersion or on the external and internal surface of the
particles of
the agglomerates to distribute the futur C deposit through its precursor.
3. Pyrolysing to convert the adsorbed and localised OP to C before, during or
after
final phosphate synthesis, when a phosphate precursor is used. Alternatively
5/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
similar pyrolysis treatment can be done after synthesis to obtain similar
product,
i.e., nanosized metal phosphate on which a conductive carbon deposit is
attached
to the crystal structure. By attached C deposit we mean an intimate contact
through physical or chemical bonding between, metal phosphate crystal and the
carbon deposit. It is believed but not limitatively, that complex pyrolysis
mechanism involving radical formation and gaseous species can result in
chemical as well as physical bonding between the sp3 C and the P04 entity.
Such
an attached C deposit being used not only to induce conductivity and
homogeneity of the electrical field of the particles but also to partially or
totally
suppress extremely favorable nano particle sintering. Alternatively, the
carbon
deposit can also be used (when covering most of the surface and in sufficient
quantity) to acheive interparticle bounding by C bridges or alternatively
(when
only part of the surface is C coverred) by allowing local sintering neck to
form
from the nano phosphate particles in order to make bonded agglomerates of
nanoparticles or nanocomposites in which an open pores structure will be
present
in the micron-size agglomerates or nanocomposites, an important component to
allow solvated lithium penetration into the micron sized agglomerates or
nanocomposites.
Description of the invention
The present invention adresses the preparation and optimisation of metal
phosphate-
carbon cathode materials in which a conductive carbon additive is chemically
fixed to
the phosphate crystal structure by the process of pyrolysing an organic C
precursor that
has been intimately contacted to nanoparticles or to nanocomposite
agglomerates of the
metal phosphate or metal phosphate precursor, preferably by an adsoption
process or
other chemical linkage process to the metal phosphate or metal phosphate
precursor.
Agglomerate of nanoparticles having the meaning of micron-size assembly of
elementary
nanosized particles held together by physical or chemical interaction or by
means of
bridges of carbon or bridge of locally sintered metal phosphates containin a
minimum
degree of internal open porosity and carbon deposit.
Nanocomposite represent a limit condition of agglomerates of nanoparticles
conprising
more than one component and at least, a metal phosphate cathode material, at
least a
conductive carbon deposit, a least one binder and at least a minimum fraction
of open
pores that globally behave as a single micron size apparent particle.
Said process to make a cathode material being characterized by the steps of:
1. Making fine particles of a metal phosphate or a metal phosphate precursor
in the
nanometer or submicron range by means of 'grinding' or dispersing larger
particles or aggregates, preferentially in a liquid media.
2. Adsorbing or 'chemically contacting' the 'organic C precursor' onto the
individual or agglomerated nanoparticles consecutively or simultaneously with
the previous nano grinding step or, simultaneously with the following
pyrolysis
step. Nature, localisation and amount of the precursor being selected to
predetermine the result of the following step.
3. Pyrolysing thermally the adsorbed and distributed precursor in such a way
as to
leave a thin conductive 'carbonaceous' deposit 'attached' to the metal
phosphate
6/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
cathode material crystal stucture of the nano particles or agglomerates of
nanoparticles. Amount, nature, thickness and distribution of said carbonaceous
deposit being also used to control the final product characteristics such as:
a. to suppress nanoparticle sintering while leaving open porosity between
nanoparticle of the agglomerate
b. or, on the contrary, to allow partial bridging between nanoparticles of
agglomerates by allowing local interparticle sintering necks to form or by
creating inter nano particle carbon bridges, or by selecting in order to
allow inter nano particle partial of the agglomerates or to establish carbon
bridges.
and said cathode materials thereof being characterised by:
1. elementary particles of LiMPO4 (or LiMPO4 precursor) obtained by top-down
micromedia grinding or desagglomerating method, with a majority of the
material
particles comprised between 5nm and 900 nm diameter, preferentially between 50
and 300 nm.
2. nano-scale carbon coated elementary particles of C-LiMPO4 that are not
agglomerated or sintered and that have retained the dimension and shape of the
metal
M precursor obtained by grinding or deagglomeration.
3. alternatively, nano-agglomerates or nanocomposite of elementary
nanoparticles after
adsoption and/or pyrolysis steps, with a preferred agglomerate-nanocomposite
particle dimension ranging from 0.5 to 10 microns, preferentially ranging from
1-5
microns.
4. the presence of an carbonaceous nanometric scale conductive carbon deposit
attached
to the metal phosphate crystal structure on at least part of the surface of
the
nanoparticle.
5. the optional presence of a partial nanoparticle to nanoparticle sintering
of the metal
phosphate agglomerates where no carbonaceous deposit is present
6. alternatively, inter nanoparticle carbonaceous bridges in the metal
phosphate
agglomerates or nanocomposite
7. the optional presence of an electrochemically inert interparticle binder or
electron
conduction additive in addition to the metal phosphate cathode and the
attached
carbonaceous deposit.
8. the presence of an 'open' porosity or channels between carbon deposited
nanoparticles of the agglomerate or nanocomposite, volumetric fraction of open
pore
size ranging from 0.30 to 0.05 micron, preferentially from 0.2 to 0.1.
Preferred mode of realization:
In one prefered mode of realization, elementary nanoparticles suspensions are
obtained
by micromedia bead mill grinding or deagglomeration of a suspension of solid
particle of
the metal phosphate or the metal phosphate precursor in a liquid media.
Without numerating every equipments for grinding, all type comminuting or
dispering
machines that can reduce the particles size down to nanometer or submicron
meter range
7/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
can be used for fine grinding or deagglomeration, such as attritor ball mill,
disc mill, high
pressure homogenizer. Examples include:
Ultra APEX Mill by Kotobuki Industries Co. Ltd of Japan
High speed Netzsch Zeta agitator bead mill by Netzsch of Germany.
Using micro grinding beads of as small diameters as 0.03mm.... made of
alumina, zirconia
or carbides for example.
Prefered organic precursors being selected for their capacity to:
Form conductive carbon deposit upon pyrolysis in the presence of metal
phosphate
material or its precursor.
To wet, impregnate, encapsulate and preferentially adsorb and/or self-organize
on at least
part of the surface of the metal phosphate or its precursor in order to:
Stabilize the nanoparticle dispersion
To help control the re-agglomeration of the metal phosphate or of the metal
phosphate precursor during or after the grinding/desagglomeration step in
solution or
during spray/evaporation techniques.
To leave by pyrolysis a C deposit localised on the surface of the elementary
nanoparticles or on the external or internal surface of the agglomerated
nanoparticles. See
Figure 1 showing the intimate contact between the LiFePO4 crystal stucture and
a thin
carbon coating applied through an organic precursor at about 700 C under inert
atmosphere.
To create C bounding between elementary particles or metal phosphate bounding
between elementary particles to form micron size agglomerated or
nanocomposites. See
Figure l:
'y ' ... -~.S.y. . .
:..~ . ) nn.
i
Typical organic precursors comprising in a non limitative manner:
Crosslinkable monomers or oligomers, copolymers especially block copolymers or
surfactants.
Numerous stabilizers are commercially available, especially surface active
agents (a.k.a
surfactants) or tensio-active agents. It is an important aspect of the
invention to use low-
cost and registred stabilizers. Most of those organic compounds are amphilic
product
8/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
containing an hydrophilic (ionic or non-ionic) and hydrophobic part allowing
modification of particles/solvents surface tension, wettability and more
efficient
dispersions. Those products and their mixtures are often characterized by
their HLB
number corresponding to balance between hydrophobic and hydrophilic moieties.
A large
set of possible surfactant is provided in Stepan Global Product Catalog join
in the present
invention, but such commodities compounds are available from many worldwide
speciality chemicals manufacturers, which is a guarantee of cost-effective
industrial
solutions.
One important family of surfactant is based on fatty acid ester, due to the
simple
synthesis process through esterification, numerous cost-effective combination
exists
allowing for fine tuning of surfactants properties in terms of
solubility/insolubility in
various solvent, dispersibility of submicron or nanosize phosphate cathode
material and
quality of carbon coating generated during pyrolysis of fatty acid chains. Non-
ionic fatty
acids are mainly obtained by esterification of fatty acid with glycol products
(glycerol,
glymes,...), carbonization ratio depends in this case on fatty acid contents,
surfactant and
fatty acid weight. To avoid low carbonization ratio and generation of a large
amount of
ashes during carbonization process, fatty acid with molecular weight > 250 are
preferred.
Thus among common fatty acid (caprylate, undecylenate, palmitate, laurate,
myristate,
oleate, ricinoleate, stearate), oleate, stearate and ricinoleate are
preferred, oleate and
stearate most preferred on handling/safety concerns. As far as high
carbonization ratio is
a concern, product such as glycerol monooleate and monostearate, soluble in
alcohol such
as IPA, are of particular interest. By extension use of fatty acid salt could
be used as
surfactant and carbon-coating precursor, particular attention is drawn to the
use of some
metallic salt of fatty acid to produce carbon nanotubes on a cost-effective
basis especially
by combining fatty acid carbon precursor and suitable metallic cations as
catalyst (see for
example without any limitation J. Mater. Chem., 2005, 15, 844-849 for the use
of nickel
stearate as carbon nanotubes precursors), compounds could be used only as an
additive to
stabilizer formulation.
An other important family of surfactant is based on alcoxylated alcohol, such
as those
obtained by reaction of ethylene oxide and/or propylene oxide. Most common
alcohol
precursor are fatty alcohol, or alkyl-phenol (for example octyl or
nonylphenol) especially
those pertaining to the Igepal family. By extension, use of alcoxylated amine
is an other
possibility, a large choice of such compounds is provided by Huntsman on the
tradename
Jeffamine. Among all those compounds, Surfonamine (see Huntsman joint
documentation) EO/PO amine are of particular interest as dipersant, PO part
allowing
carbon generation during pyrolysis.
An other important family of surfactant obtained from fatty alcohol is their
ester with
sulfate or phosphate anion, including their zwiterrionic form. For application
in the
present invention phosphate derivatives are preferred, numerous example are
provided in
joint Stepan documentation. Special attention should be drawned to Degussa
styreneoxide-based phosphorylated polyether (compound (I) in Figure
surfactant).
9/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
An other interesting family of commercial surfactant is provided by Degussa on
the
tradename Tego Dispersant (compounds (II) in Figure surfactant) based on
imidazolium
and quaternary ammonium.
An other important family of surfactant is ethylene oxide/propylene oxide
copolymer
mainly known as Pluronic, PO part allowing carbon generation during control
pyrolysis
(see for example without linitation Chem. Commun., 2003, 1436-1437).
Modification of
oxide ratio mainly EO/PO ratio and molecular weight provide a large choice of
cost-
effective tensio-active with tunable properties in terms of solubility,
surface-tension,
wettability, carbonization ratio. Important physico-chenmical data on Pluronic
is provide
by BASF : http://Nvww.basf.com/perfon-nancechemicaVbcperfdata tables html.
An other important family of surfactant is general reactive surfactant family,
commonly
designed as "Surfmer", found as non-ionic, cationic and anionic compounds (see
Acta
Polym 95, 49, 671). Some example are provided on Figure Surfactant for Noigen
(compounds III produced by DKS, Japan), Hitenol (compounds IV produced by DKS
Japan), other companies propose such products for example the Maxemul family
provide
by Uniquema. Use of reactive surfactant, in whole or in part, is an important
way to
induced nano-encapsulation of phosphate cathode materials during or at the end
of
grinding process, in a specific mode of realisation of the invention, such
additives could
be used only at the end to encapsulate nano-powder. As reactive surfactant we
consider
surfactant containing a polymerizable groups through anionic, cationic or
radical
polymerization (epoxyde, allyl, vinyl, acrylate, methacrylate, vinylether,
maleimide,...), a
condensable groups (amine, carboxylic acid, alcohol,...) and chemically
reactive groups
(isocyanate, blocked isocyanate, carbodiimide, epoxyde,...).
At this step, we provide specific families of industrial compounds with the
aim to
optimize formulation to provide battery grade nanosize and submicron carbon
coated
phosphate cathode, especially for high-power batteries design, in term of cost-
effective,
safe (low hazard, low VOC,...) and efficient formulation of surfactant
combines with a
grinding process to lower phosphate cathode particles sizes. Even if a large
choice of
possibility and combination is possible, one skilled in the art is able to
understand interest
to use process described in present invention without departing from it.
Preferentially these organic precursors will be selected to form a thin C
deposit at the
nanoscale that will be intimately contacted to the metal phosphate crystal
structure, that
will be at least partially graphitized during pyrolysis. Sub group of organic
precursors
being ones that contains elements such as N, P, Si that may remains present in
the
carbonaceous deposit after pyrolysis.
Optionnally these organic precursors may be present in at least the gaz phase
in
equilibrium with surface distributed organic precursor during the pyrolysis
step and able
to grow graphite or graphene layers on the surface of the metal phosphate.
Optionnally,
iron, cobalt or nickel catalyst can be present during the pyrolysis process to
help for a
conductive C deposit of graphene or graphitic nature. Such metal catalyst
being
introduced and distributed also as a metal containing surfactant like Fe or Ni
stearate.
10/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
Preferentially the nature, distribution and amount of organic precursor (or C
after
pyrolysis) will be adjusted to suppress nanoparticle sintering (by carbon
coating) or
control partial sintering (limited C quantities) on the metal phosphate
particle or
agglomerate or nanocomposites or on the contrary to form interparticle carbon
bridge at
the nanoscale level.
Since the invention has shown that nanoscale iron phosphate precursor will
retains its
shape and size if properly coated with a carbonaceous deposit, both the final
synthesized
product or the iron precursor can be processed.
Typical equipments to grind the materials of the invention to a nanoscale
dimension in a
solvent are known and available commercially such as Nezsch agitator bead
mill, disc
mill, colloid mill, stired ball mill and high pressure homogenizer.
Optionnally, the agglomerate of nanoparticles or the nanocomposite of micron
size may
contain an interparticle binder that can be carbonaceous bridges, partial
sintering bridges
or a third component acting as a bridging additive such as a glassy phase or
present as an
impurity and/or as an additonal electrically conducting phase.
Conducting carbon or conducting carbonaceous deposit shall mean a more or less
graphitized carbon material obtained by way of pyrolysis of an organic
material that may
contain minor elements such as N, P, Si that can be covalently bounded to C.
General LiMXO4 formula means lithiated metal phosphate more or less
substituted with
other cations or anions having the overall stoichiometry of 1/1/1 within a few
percents ot
precision, including also partial doping in the structure or externally to the
crystal
structure.
References:
1 Nishi, Y. J. Power Source-s 2001, .1'(30, 101.
~2~ . K. Mizushima, P.C. Jones, P.J. Wiseman, J.B. Goodenough,. Mater. Res.
Bull. 15
(1980) 783
(3) US Patent 4,959,281
(4) US Patent 5 910 382
(5) US Patent 6 391 493
(6) Dahn sur stabilite LiFePO4
(7) US Patent 6 514 640
(8) US Patent 6 963 666
(9) US Patent 6 855 273
(10) WO 0227824 and WO 0227823
(11) Nazar sur C
(12) Sony syr C
(13) Valence sur Carbothermie
(14) Toyota sur composite poudre C
(15) Sud-Chemie
11/13
CA 02569991 2006-12-07
Patent application
(16) Umicore
(17) Molten patent
12/13
