CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 1
PCT/EP2007/007601
An antenna for an electromagnetic probe for investigating geological
formations
and its applications
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to a cross dipole antenna and an electromagnetic probe
comprising such an antenna for measuring the electromagnetic properties of a
subsurface formation in a limited zone surrounding a borehole. Another aspect
of the
invention relates to a logging tool for performing logs of subsurface
formation bore hole.
A particular application of the probe and the logging tool according to the
invention
relates to the oilfield services industry.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Logging devices that measure formation electromagnetic properties (e.g.
dielectric
constant) are known, for example from US 3,849,721, US 3,944,910 and US
5,434,507.
The logging device includes a transmitter and spaced receivers mounted in a
pad that is
urged against a borehole wall. Microwave electromagnetic energy is transmitted
into the
formations, and energy that has propagated through the formations is received
at the
receiving antennas. The phase and amplitude of the energy propagating in the
formations is determined from the receiver output signals. The dielectric
constant and
the conductivity of the formations can then be obtained from the phase and
amplitude
measurements.
The transmitters and receivers comprise antennas that are assimilated to
magnetic
dipoles. These dipoles are tangential to the pad face and are orientated in
different
directions. A broadside mode corresponds to the dipoles oriented orthogonally
to the
pad-axis. An endfire mode corresponds to the dipoles oriented in alignment
with the pad
axis. The depth of investigation for the broadside mode is very poor. The
investigation
depth for the endfire mode is greater than for the broadside mode, but the
signal is
weaker. The attenuation and phase-shift are measured between the two
receivers. A
simple inversion allows in case of a homogeneous formation to retrieve the
dielectric
constant and the conductivity. Typically, such a logging device is unable to
provide an
accurate measurement of the formation properties because of its high
sensitivity to the
standoff of the pad relatively to the formation or the presence of a mudcake
on the
borehole wall.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 2
PCT/EP2007/007601
The document US 5,345,179 proposes a solution to improve the logging device
response and accuracy in the presence of a mudcake. The logging device
comprises a
plurality of cross-dipole antennas, each being located in a cavity. The cross-
dipole
antenna houses both endfire and broadside polarizations in the same cavity.
FIGS. 3 and 4 are perspective and cross-section views schematically showing a
cross
dipole antenna according to the prior art. Typically, such a cross dipole
antenna 103
comprises two wires 132, 142 embedded in a non-resonant cavity 133 filled with
a
dielectric material and short-circuited to the conductive cavity wall at one
end.
FIG. 5 illustrates the current distribution for a cross dipole antenna
according to the prior
art. The current distribution J is approximated from the analogy with a short-
circuited
transmission line. The current distribution on the radiating wire in the
cavity can be
approximated to:
Ay) = J0 cos0 c o[y ¨ ap
where:
-.J0 is the current amplitude,
- a is the aperture size,
-1(0 is the wave number in the cavity and is equal to: lc() =ET--
6 cavity $
C
- Ccavity is the relative dielectric constant of the material filling the
cavity,
- w is the angular frequency, and
- c is the speed of light in vacuum.
The current is maximal at the short-circuit location. This cosinusoidal and
asymmetric
current distribution excites a strong, parasitic electric dipole.
FIGS. 6 and 7 illustrate the electromagnetic field components Ey and Ez in the
yz plane
of a cross dipole antenna 103 (more precisely of the radiating wire) of the
prior art,
respectively.
The current flowing on the wire, for example wire 132, excites modes in the
cavity. The
dominant mode is the transverse electric mode TE10. This mode contributes to a
radiation pattern, which is close to a magnetic point dipole m orthogonal to
the wire. The
current distribution on the wire will also excite parasitic modes, the
dominant one being
the transverse magnetic mode TMi 1. This mode corresponds to an electric
dipole p
normal to the aperture. These parasitic modes cause a strong asymmetry of the
electromagnetic field Ey and Ez in the yz plane.
Thus, the antennas of the prior art are far from being pure magnetic dipoles.
In
particular, the parasitic electric dipole, normal to the aperture affects the
measurement
CA 02663477 2016-06-09
3
accuracy. Further, due to the parasitic electric dipole, the crosstalk between
the two
polarizations is important and "cross-fire" measurements (i.e. transmitters in
broadside
mode and receivers in endfire mode) cannot be performed.
SUMMARY
One goal of the present disclosure is to propose a cross-dipole antenna and an
electromagnetic probe comprising such a cross-dipole enabling measurement of
the
electromagnetic properties of a subsurface formation in a limited zone
surrounding a
borehole avoiding, at least reducing the drawbacks of the prior art antennas
and probes.
According to a first aspect, an antenna element is proposed comprised of at
least one
center-split half-coaxial wire embedded in a cavity to define a symmetrized
radiation
pattern.
More precisely, the first aspect relates to an antenna of an electromagnetic
probe used in
investigation of geological formations surrounding a borehole comprising a
conductive
base and a first antenna element, the conductive base comprising an opened non-
resonant cavity, the first antenna element being embedded in the cavity and
going right
through the cavity. The first antenna element includes a center-split half-
coaxial wire so
as to define a symmetrized antenna radiation pattern.
The first antenna element may comprise a connection wire coupled to a dipole
wire, the
connection wire passing through the conductive base and being insulated
relatively to the
conductive base.
The dipole wire may extend through the cavity from a first cavity wall to a
second cavity
wall, the dipole wire being shorted to the second cavity wall, the dipole wire
having a first
portion of a first diameter and a second portion of a second diameter superior
to the first
diameter, an outer cylindrical conductor shorted to the first cavity wall
shielding the wire
substantially around the first portion, the outer cylindrical conductor having
a diameter
substantially equal to the second diameter, a gap separating the outer
cylindrical
conductor from the second portion, the gap being positioned at substantially
half of a
length of the dipole wire.
Advantageously, the antenna may be a cross-dipole antenna comprising a first
antenna
element and a second antenna element, the second antenna element having a
structure
CA 02663477 2016-06-09
4
identical to the first antenna element, and wherein the second antenna element
is
positioned into the cavity and according to a direction defined by a dipole
wire of the
second antenna element substantially orthogonal to a first antenna element
dipole wire
defined direction.
The cavity may have a parallelepipedic or a cylindrical shape. The cavity may
be filled
with a dielectric material or a shaped core made of a magnetically permeable
material.
Advantageously, the cavity may be closed by a cover made of a protective
material.
Another aspect relates to an antenna module comprising an antenna disclosed
herein,
wherein the conductive base further comprises a printed circuit board coupled
to the
antenna by means of the connection wire, the printed circuit board comprising
an
impedance-matching network and being located at a distance inferior to a size
of the
cavity from the dipole wire.
Still another aspect relates to an electromagnetic logging apparatus used in
investigation
of geological formations surrounding a borehole, comprising:
- a logging tool moveable through the borehole,
- an electromagnetic probe comprising a pad mounted on the logging device,
adapted for
engagement with the borehole wall by a wall-engaging face of the pad,
- at least one antenna mounted in the wall-engaging face and used as a
transmitting
antenna,
- a plurality of spaced antennas mounted in the wall-engaging face and used
as receiving
antennas positioned in spaced relation to the transmitting antenna,
- a transmitter module adapted for energizing the transmitting antenna to
transmit
electromagnetic energy into the formations at a determined frequency, and
- a receiver module adapted for receiving and processing an output signal
at each of the
receiving antennas representative of electromagnetic energy received from the
formations,
wherein at least one of the receiving antennas is an antenna disclosed herein.
CA 02663477 2016-06-09
A further aspect relates to a cross-polarization measurement method using an
electromagnetic logging apparatus disclosed herein and comprising the steps
of:
- running a logging tool through a borehole and engaging a pad with a borehole
wall,
- radiating electromagnetic signals into a formation surrounding the borehole
by means of
5 at least one transmitting antenna according to the invention and mounted
in a wall-
engaging face of the pad, the formation comprising a plurality of geological
feature, the
electromagnetic signals being radiated in two orthogonal polarizations with a
high degree
of mutual signal rejection, one polarization being parallel to an axis of the
pad, the other
being orthogonal to said axis,
- performing a plurality of cross-polarization measurements by means of at
least one
receiving antenna according to an antenna disclosed herein, the cross-
polarization
measurements consisting in measuring magnetic moments according to two
orthogonal
polarization directions and generating a broadside signal corresponding to a
horizontal
magnetic moment excitation and an endfire signal corresponding to a vertical
magnetic
moment excitation, and
- deducing the plurality of geological feature surrounding the borehole based
on the
broadside and endfire signals.
The cross-polarization measurement may further comprise the steps of:
- combining the cross-polarization measurements so as to form a cross-
polarization
signal, and
- deducing the plurality of geological feature surrounding the borehole based
on the
cross-polarization signal.
The geological feature may be a laminate, a fracture, a bed boundary or a vug.
A non-zero broadside signal and a substantially zero endfire signal may
correspond to a
heterogeneous formation comprising horizontal fractures filled with a
resistive fluid. A
non-zero endfire signal and a substantially zero broadside signal may
correspond to a
heterogeneous formation comprising vertical fractures filled with a resistive
fluid.
CA 02663477 2014-10-29
6
A cross-polarization signal substantially equal to zero may correspond to a
homogeneous, isotropic formation comprising horizontal laminates or horizontal
bed
boundaries.
A cross-polarization signal proportional to a product sine x cose to a lowest
order may
correspond to a heterogeneous formation comprising laminates, fractures or bed
boundaries tilted against the polarization directions by an angle O.
A localized, non-zero cross-polarization signal may correspond to a
heterogeneous
formation comprising randomly sized and distributed vugs.
An antenna for an electromagnetic probe used in geological surveys disclosed
herein can
enable a better measurement accuracy than the antenna of the electromagnetic
propagation tool as described in the prior art.
A cross-dipole antenna as disclosed herein can enable radiating
electromagnetic signals
in either of two orthogonal polarizations. The cross-dipole antenna can enable
eliminating
parasitic, higher-order modes and improve the mutual electromagnetic
insulation. Thus,
the orthogonality of the two modes may be ensured with a high degree of mutual
insulation, any common mode being suppressed by the cross-dipole antenna of
the
invention.
The decoupled modes for transmitter and receiver antennas enable additional
measurements that vanish in homogeneous, isotropic media. These measurements
provide an estimation of the formation anisotropy, presence of tilted bed
boundaries or
fractures and also vug identification.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The present invention is illustrated by way of examples and not limited to the
accompanying figures, in which like references indicate similar elements:
FIG. 1 schematically illustrates a typical onshore hydrocarbon well location;
FIG. 2 schematically shows a borehole wall contacting side view of a pad for
measuring
the electromagnetic properties of a subsurface formation;
CA 02663477 2014-10-29
6a
FIG. 3 is a perspective view schematically showing in greater details a cross
dipole
antenna of the pad of FIG. 2 according to the prior art;
FIG. 4 is a cross-section view schematically showing in greater details a
cross dipole
antenna according to the prior art;
FIG. 5 illustrates the current distribution for a cross dipole antenna
according to the prior
art;
FIGS. 6 and 7 illustrate the electromagnetic field Ey in yz plane and Ez in yz
plane of a
cross dipole antenna according to the prior art, respectively;
FIG. 8 is a partial perspective view schematically showing in details a cross
dipole
antenna according to the invention;
FIG. 9 is a cross-section view schematically showing in details a cross dipole
antenna
according to the invention;
FIG. 10 illustrates the current distribution for a cross dipole antenna
according to the
invention;
FIGS. 11 and 12 illustrate the electromagnetic field Ey in the yz plane and Ez
in the yz
plane of a cross dipole antenna according to the invention, respectively;
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 7
PCT/EP2007/007601
FIG. 13 is a graphic showing two curves comparing the ratio of the direct
signals to the
cross signals measured by the antennas in a range of frequency according to
the
invention and according to the prior art;
FIG. 14 schematically illustrates horizontal laminate, perpendicular with the
pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 15 schematically illustrates dipping laminate, tilted by 300 against the
pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 16 schematically illustrates horizontal bed boundaries, perpendicular
with the pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 17 schematically illustrates dipping bed boundary, tilted by 30 against
the pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 18 schematically illustrates horizontal fractures, perpendicular with the
pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 19 schematically illustrates vertical fractures, parallel to the pad
measurement axe;
FIG. 20 schematically illustrates dipping fractures, tilted by 30 against the
pad
measurement axis;
FIG. 21 schematically illustrates randomly sized and distributed vugs
affecting the
measurements;
FIG. 22-23 is a perspective view above the pad schematically showing a cross-
dipole
antenna of to the invention according to a particular embodiment; and
FIG. 24 is a graphic showing two curves comparing the transmission efficiency
measured in a range of frequency with an antenna of the invention with a
cavity filled
with a dielectric material compared to a cavity filled with a ferrite
material.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
FIG. 1 schematically shows a typical onshore hydrocarbon well location and
surface
equipments SE above a hydrocarbon geological formation GF after drilling
operations
have been carried out. At this stage, i.e. before a casing string is run and
before
cementing operations are carried out, the wellbore is a borehole WBH filled
with a fluid
mixture DM. The fluid mixture DM is typically a mixture of drilling fluid and
drilling mud.
In this example, the surface equipments SE comprises an oil rig OR and a
surface unit
SU for deploying a logging tool TL in the well-bore. The surface unit may be a
vehicle
coupled to the logging tool by a line LN. Further, the surface unit comprises
an
appropriate device DD for determining the depth position of the logging tool
relatively to
the surface level. The logging tool TL comprises various sensors and provides
various
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 8
PCT/EP2007/007601
measurement data related to the hydrocarbon geological formation GF and/or the
fluid
mixture DM. These measurement data are collected by the logging tool TL and
transmitted to the surface unit SU. The surface unit SU comprises appropriate
electronic
and software arrangements PA for processing, analyzing and storing the
measurement
data provided by the logging tool TL.
The logging tool TL comprises a probe 1 for measuring the electromagnetic
properties
of a subsurface formation according to the invention. Once the logging tool is
positioned
at a desired depth, the probe 1 can be deployed from the logging tool TL
against the
borehole wall WBW by an appropriate deploying arrangement, for example an arm
AR.
FIG. 2 schematically shows a well-bore wall contacting face view of the probe
1. The
probe 1 comprises a pad 2. The pad is a conductive metal housing, for example
made
in a metallic material like stainless steel arranged to be positioned in
contact with a well-
bore wall WBW. The pad 2 is coupled to the tool TL by the arm AR (shown in
FIG. 1).
The arm enables the deployment of the pad 2 into the borehole WBH against the
well-
bore wall WBW.
The probe 1 further comprises transmitting and receiving antennas, for example
two
transmitting antennas 3B and 3C, and two receiving antennas 3A and 3D. The
transmitting antennas 3B and 3C and the receiving antennas 3A and 3D are
positioned
in the pad along a line AA' in the pad face arranged to be positioned in
contact with the
well-bore wall WBW. The number of the transmitting and receiving antennas, and
their
positions relatively to each other, as illustrated in FIG. 2, is only an
example. The
number and positions of the transmitting and receiving antennas may be
different.
The probe 1 further comprises an electronic arrangement 4 connected to the
transmitting and receiving antennas. Typically, the electronic arrangement 4
is designed
such that the antenna may operate in a frequency range from around 10 MHz to
around
2GHz. The electronic arrangement 4 comprises a transmitter module 4T and a
receiver
module 4R. The transmitter module 4T is arranged to excite the transmitting
antennas
3B and/or 3C by applying an excitation signal. The receiver module 4R is
arranged to
determine an attenuation and a phase shift of a reception signal provided by
the
receiving antenna 3A and 3D relatively to the excitation signal ES.
Additionally, the electromagnetic probe 1 may comprise other type of sensors
(not
shown), for example a temperature sensor, for measuring characteristic
parameters of
the fluid mixture, the mudcake, and/or the formation.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 9
PCT/EP2007/007601
One or more coaxial cables (not shown) may be run though the arm AR for
connecting
the electronic arrangement 4 with the tool TL. The tool TL contains the bulk
of the down-
hole electronics (not shown) and provides energy and control commands, and
gathers
measurements from the electromagnetic probe 1. Alternatively, the electronic
arrangement 4 may comprise a data communication module (not shown) for
directly
transmitting measurements to the surface equipment SE and receiving control
commands from it.
FIGS. 8 and 9 illustrate a partial perspective view and cross-section view of
a cross
dipole antenna according to the invention, respectively. The antenna that will
be
described hereinafter may be used as a transmitting antenna or as a receiving
antenna.
In FIG. 9, the cross-dipole antenna is shown fitted into the pad 2, while the
pad contacts
the well-bore wall WBW. Typically, as in this example, the well-bore wall WBW
consists
in the formation covered by a mudcake MC. The mudcake MC is formed on the
wellbore
wall WBW by the screening of the particles of mud suspended into the fluid
mixture
when the fluid mixture invades the formation.
The antenna 3 comprises a conductive base 31 and a first antenna element 32.
The
conductive base 31 comprises an open, non-resonant cavity 33. The antenna may
comprise a second antenna element 42 as illustrated in FIGS. 8 and 9. Both
antennas
are positioned within the cavity not touching where they cross each other.
The cavity 33 has a parallelepipedic shape. Nevertheless, the cavity 33 may
have other
shapes, for example a cylindrical shape. Advantageously, the cavity is filled
with a
dielectric material. Any dielectric material may be used as the dielectric
constant of said
material filling the cavity has no impact on the radiation purity. The cavity
is closed by a
cover or window 43 in order to retain and protect the dielectric material.
Advantageously, the cover 43 is made of a protective material, resistant to
abrasion, for
example PEEK (thermoplastic PolyEtherEtherKeton). However, any other material
that
does not perturb high-frequency-wave propagation and shows an appropriate
mechanical resistance to abrasion is acceptable. As example, the aperture size
a
defined by such a cavity may be around 10 mm.
The first antenna element goes right through the cavity. The first antenna
element 32
comprises a connection wire 34 coupled to a dipole wire 35. The connection
wire 34
passes through the conductive base 31 and is insulated relatively to the
conductive
base.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 10
PCT/EP2007/007601
The dipole wire 35 extends through the cavity from a first cavity wall 33A to
a second
cavity wall 33B. The dipole wire 35 is shorted to the second cavity wall 33B.
The dipole
wire has a first portion 35A of a first diameter and a second portion 35B of a
second
diameter superior to the first diameter. The first portion 35A is coupled to
the connection
wire 34. The second portion 35B is shorted to the second cavity wall. The
dipole wire is
shielded by an outer cylindrical conductor 36 shorted to the first cavity wall
33A
substantially around the first portion 35A. The outer cylindrical conductor 36
has a
diameter substantially equal to the second diameter. The outer cylindrical
conductor 36
has a thickness such that it does not contact the first portion 35A. The first
portion 35A
and the outer cylindrical conductor 36 form a coaxial wire.
A gap 37 separates the outer cylindrical conductor from the second portion
35B. The
gap is positioned at substantially half of a length of the dipole wire 35.
Advantageously,
the gap is thin, for example inferior to 1mm for a 10 mm aperture size.
Further, the gap
is advantageously centered in the cavity with a tight tolerance, for example
smaller than
2% of the aperture size.
The second antenna element 42 has a structure identical to the first antenna
element
and will not be further described. The second antenna element is positioned
into the
cavity over or under the first antenna element. The direction D2 defined by
the dipole
wire 45 of the second antenna element 42 is substantially orthogonal to the
direction D1
defined by the dipole wire 35 of the first antenna element 32.
The metallic parts of the antenna may be gold-plated to minimize Ohmic losses.
The antenna 3 may be designed under the form of an antenna module inserted
into a
slot of the pad 2. In this case, the conductive base 31 may advantageously
comprise a
printed-circuit board 44 coupled to the antenna 32 by means of the connection
wire 34.
Advantageously, the printed-circuit board 44 comprises an impedance-matching
network (not shown). The impedance-matching network enables maximizing the
power
transmitted into the formation when the antenna is a transmitter, or, by
reciprocity, the
power received when the antenna is a receiver. Further, the impedance-matching
network is located closely to the dipole wire 35 in order to improve its
efficiency. For
example, the printed-circuit board 44 may be located at a distance inferior to
a size of
the cavity 33 from the dipole wire. Finally, the matching network may be
designed for
several discrete frequencies with passive components (inductances or
capacitances) or
active components (variable capacitance). The active components enable
operating in a
frequency range from 0.1 GHz to 2.0 GHz with a maximized efficiency.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 11
PCT/EP2007/007601
According to an alternative embodiment of the antenna, the cavity may be
filled with a
magnetically permeable material. For example, a shaped core 45 comprising two
crossed and superposed grooves adapted to fit into the cavity and to receive
the
antenna elements 32 and 42 is shown in FIG. 22-23. Advantageously, the
material has
a high magnetic permeability. As an example, the shaped core may be made of a
ferrite
material. The antenna according to this alternative embodiment enables
increasing the
antenna efficiency; in particular the magnetic flux is increased. The gain in
efficiency is
proportional to the square root of the material relative magnetic permeability
(the ferrite
relative permeability is around 10).
FIG. 24 shows two curves comparing the transmission efficiency measured in a
range
of frequency for a cavity filled with a dielectric material (unbroken line DM)
compared to
a cavity filled with a ferrite material (dashed line FM). The gain in signal
level at a
receiving antenna can be around 30 dB, especially at low frequency.
The behavior of the antenna according to the invention will now be described
in relation
with FIGS. 10-13. The antenna according to the invention behaves like two
orthogonal
and independent pure magnetic dipoles.
A small aperture, compared to wavelength and observation point, in a
conductive plane
can be considered, in term of radiation, as the superposition of a magnetic
dipole,
tangential to the conductive plane, and an electric dipole normal to the
aperture. The
magnetic and electric dipole moments can be expressed as function of the
tangential
electric field at the aperture:
m = --2 fri x Eada and p = fie f(r = Ejda
i(DP aperture aperture
where:
- a is the size of the aperture,
- Ea is the tangential electric field at the aperture,
- m is the magnetic dipole moment,
- p is the electric dipole moment,
- w is the angular frequency,
- e is the medium permittivity,
- p is the magnetic permeability,
- n is a unit vector normal to the aperture, and
- r is a vector, i.e. the center of the aperture is the origin of the
referential, the
vector pointing towards the integration point in the aperture plane.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 12
PCT/EP2007/007601
The antenna according to the invention considerably reduces the electric-
dipole
moment p, compared to the prior art antenna described hereinbefore. The field
Ea at the
antenna aperture is linked to the current variation on the wire acting as a
radiating
element extending into in the cavity.
FIG. 10 illustrates the current distribution J as a function of y (position
along the wire 35)
of the antenna according to the invention. In the coaxial wire (the first
portion 35A and
the outer conductor 36) the current that flows in the first portion 35A is
equal to the
current on the internal side of the outer conductor 36, but with an opposite
direction.
The current on the external side of the second portion 35B flows in the same
direction
as for the first portion 35A, but with a symmetric distribution.
õ {Jo cos(koy) for 0 < y <a12
AY)=
Jo cosOco[y ¨aD for a/2 < y < a
With this current distribution, the electric field at the aperture is fully
symmetric.
The electric dipole moment p is given by:
p = lig .1(r = Ejda
aperture
Hence, the electric dipole moment p is theoretically null for the antenna
according to the
invention, while the magnetic dipole moment m remains unchanged.
FIGS. 11 and 12 illustrate the electromagnetic field Ey in the yz plane and Ez
in the yz
plane of the cross dipole antenna (more precisely of the radiating wire) of
the invention,
respectively. These Figures clearly show that the antenna of the invention
symmetrizes
the fields. The antenna of the invention behaves like a pure magnetic dipole
with no
parasitic radiation.
FIG. 13 shows two curves comparing the ratio of the direct signals (broadside
mode) to
the cross signals (endfire mode) measured by the antennas according to the
invention
(unbroken line curve A2) and according to the prior art (dashed line curve
Al), in a
range of frequency from 0.5 GHz to 2.0 GHz. These measurements combine the
effect
of the parasitic electric dipole and the crosstalk between two orthogonal
polarizations in
the same cavity. These measurements have been performed with antennas having
the
same dimensions and the same material filling the cavity. The antennas are
both cross
dipole antennas. A transmitter is excited in broadside mode and the signals
received
are measured at the antenna. A first polarization is measured with a first
wire, e.g. wire
CA 02663477 2014-10-29
13
132 for the antenna of the prior art (FIG. 3) and wire 32 for the antenna of
the invention
(FIG. 8). A second polarization is measured with a second wire orthogonal to
the first
wire, e.g. wire 142 for the antenna of the prior art (FIG. 3) and wire 42 for
the antenna of
the invention (FIG. 8). It is observed that with the antenna of the invention,
the "cross-
talk" between the two polarizations becomes negligible compared to the antenna
of the
prior art. Up to 2.0 GHz, the ratio is less than -60dB for the antenna of the
invention,
while it is always more than -20dB for the antenna of the prior art. This
difference shows
the excellent cross-polarizations rejection of the antenna of the invention.
Thus, with an electromagnetic logging apparatus using the antenna of the
invention, a
cross-polarization measurement method can be implemented. The cross-dipole
antennas
are used in an electromagnetic logging apparatus. The structure and operation
of such
an electromagnetic logging apparatus is described in details in the patent
application
published under No EP 1 693 685 (filed on 22 February 2005). The
electromagnetic
probe of the present invention differs from the one of EP 1 693 685 in that it
comprises
the cross-dipole antennas of the invention as hereinbefore described that
radiate
electromagnetic waves in two orthogonal polarizations. With the invention, the
cross-
dipole antennas radiate electromagnetic waves in two orthogonal polarizations
with a
high degree of mutual signal rejection which is accomplished by means of the
elimination
of all parasitic, common radiating modes between the antennas.
While the logging tool is being run through a borehole and the pad engaged
with the
borehole wall (FIG. 1), electromagnetic signals are radiated into the
formation
surrounding the borehole (FIGS. 14-21) by transmitting antenna 3T. The
formation GF
has a structure that may comprise various types of heterogeneous geological
feature, for
example laminates (L), fractures (F), bed boundaries (BB) or vugs (V);
examples of which
are schematically represented in FIGS. 14-21. A plurality of electromagnetic
measurements are performed in two orthogonal polarization directions, one
being parallel
to an axis of the pad, the other being orthogonal to said axis. Then, the
electromagnetic
measurement according to one polarization is compared to the electromagnetic
measurement according the other orthogonal polarization. From the result of
this
CA 02663477 2014-10-29
13a
comparison, the type of the heterogeneous geological feature surrounding the
borehole
can be deduced.
FIGS. 14 to 21 illustrate various types of heterogeneous geological feature
that may be
detected and characterized with the cross-dipole antennas according to the
invention. In
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 14
PCT/EP2007/007601
FIGS. 14 to 21, a vertical magnetic moment is indicated by the vertical double
arrow
(corresponding to the transmitting 3T and receiving 3R1 and 3R2 antennas) and
unbroken line arrow, and a horizontal magnetic moment are indicated by the
horizontal
arrow (corresponding to the transmitting 3T and receiving 3R1 and 3R2
antennas) and
dashed line arrow. The receiving antennas are excited by the electromagnetic
energy
having a particular magnetic moment reflected by the geological formation GF.
The
horizontal element provides an endfire signal when excited by a vertical
magnetic
moment, while the vertical element provides a broadside signal when excited by
a
horizontal magnetic moment.
The electromagnetic probe 1 simultaneously provides multiple electromagnetic
measurements in two orthogonal polarization directions. These simultaneous
measurements are combined and compared so that the orthogonal polarizations
illuminate heterogeneous features in the rock in different manners. It is
possible to
quantitatively characterize finely bedded or laminated geological formations.
For
example, the response to bed boundaries or fractures depends on the
orientation of the
polarizations with respect to these structures.
Below the typical 25 mm thin-bed resolution limit of prior art electromagnetic
probe, the
laminated formation is encountered as effectively anisotropic medium. The two
orthogonal polarizations of the electromagnetic probe with antennas of the
invention can
discriminate this anisotropy. The two orthogonal polarization directions
completely
decouple the measurements in homogeneous, isotropic formations. In
anisotropic,
fractured or high-contrast bedded formations the measurements may show
interferences between the two modes if the formation structure is tilted at
some skewed
angle against the polarization direction. Therefore, the cross-polarization
measurements, which are zero in isotropic media, provide quantitative
information on
the relative inclination angle and the conductivity-permittivity contrast in
the
heterogeneous medium. In anisotropic media the anisotropy-tensor axes may be
tilted
against the polarization directions by an angle 0. In this case, the cross-
polarization
signal will be proportional to the product sin0 x cos to the lowest order.
Bed boundaries
or fractures may be tilted against the polarization axes by the angle 0. The
cross-
polarization signal will be proportional to the hereinbefore mentioned
product. A known
two-dimensional Eigenmode analysis of the in-line and cross-polarization
measurements will estimate the tilt angle 0 and determine the anisotropic
formation
parameters (permittivity and conductivity) or the fluid content of the
fracture or the
permittivity-conductivity contrast across the bed boundary.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 15
PCT/EP2007/007601
FIG. 14 schematically illustrates a formation comprising horizontal laminates
that are
perpendicular with the pad/probe measurement axis AA'. This situation
corresponds to
a homogeneous, isotropic medium, resulting in a cross-polarization signal
substantially
equal to zero.
FIG. 16 schematically illustrates a formation comprising horizontal bed
boundaries that
are perpendicular with the pad measurement axis AA'. The response of the probe
is
analogous to the situation with a horizontal laminate.
FIG. 15 schematically illustrates a formation comprising a dipping laminate
that is tilted
by an angle of around 300 against the pad-measurement axis AA'. The combined
endfire and broadside measurements enable inverting the anisotropic
permittivity and
conductivity of such a laminated formation with known tilt angle 0.
FIG. 17 schematically illustrates a formation comprising dipping bed boundary
that is
tilted by an angle of around 30 against the pad-measurement axis AA'. In this
situation,
the response of the probe is a signal being a combination of the broadside
mode and
the endfire mode.
FIGS. 18-20 schematically illustrate a formation comprising fractures. The
fractures may
be natural fractures due to the geological formation stress or fractures
induced by the
drilling operation. The fractures may be filled with the fluid mixture from
the borehole
(generally conductive because enriched in water) or with hydrocarbon fluid
mixture
(generally resistive). Assuming that the electromagnetic properties of the
fluid mixture
invading the geological formation are known, it is possible to identify the
fractures
orientations within the formation.
FIG. 18 schematically illustrates a formation comprising horizontal fractures
that are
perpendicular to the pad-measurement axis AA'. In this situation, a resistive,
fluid filled
fracture will create an important signal according to the broadside mode and a
substantially zero signal according to the endfire mode.
FIG. 19 schematically illustrates a formation comprising vertical fractures
that are
parallel to the pad-measurement axis AA'. In this situation, a resistive,
fluid filled fracture
will create a substantially zero signal according to the broadside mode and an
important
signal according to the endfire mode.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 16
PCT/EP2007/007601
FIG. 20 schematically illustrates a formation comprising dipping fractures
that are tilted
by an angle of around 300 against the pad-measurement axis AA'. In this
situation, a
resistive fluid filled fracture will create a signal being a combination of
the broadside
mode and the endfire mode.
FIG. 21 schematically illustrates a formation comprising randomly sized and
distributed
vugs. It has been observed a typical measurement response of the cross-
polarization
signals to vugs on log data from field tests. From these observations, the
cross-
polarization measurements provide a localized, non-zero signal in the presence
of vugs.
These measurements may be used to quantitatively characterize the vugs and/or
their
statistical size and/or spatial distribution.
FINAL REMARKS
A particular application of the invention relating to a wireline tool has been
described.
However, it is apparent for a person skilled in the art that the invention is
also applicable
to a logging-while-drilling tool. A typical logging-while-drilling tool is
incorporated into a
bottom-hole assembly attached to the end of a drill string With a drill bit
attached at the
extreme end thereof. Measurements can be made either when the drill string is
stationary or rotating. In the latter case an additional measurement is made
to allow the
measurements to be related to the rotational position of the drill string in
the borehole.
This is preferably done by making simultaneous measurements of the direction
of the
earth's magnetic field with a compass, which can be related to a reference
measurement made when the drill string is stationary.
It will also be apparent for a person skilled in the art that the invention is
applicable to
onshore and offshore hydrocarbon well location.
It is apparent that the term "pad" used hereinbefore generically indicates a
contacting
element with the surface of the borehole wall. The particular contacting
element shown
in the Figures for maintaining the antennas in engagement with the borehole
wall is
illustrative and it will be apparent for a person skilled in the art that
other suitable
contacting element may be implemented, for example a sonde with a backup arm.
The same remark is also applicable to the particular probe deploying system
shown on
the Figures.
CA 02663477 2009-03-13
WO 2008/031505 17
PCT/EP2007/007601
Finally, it is also apparent for a person skilled in the art that application
of the invention
to the oilfield industry is not limited as the invention can also be used in
others types of
geological surveys.
The drawings and their description illustrate rather than limit the invention.
Any reference sign in a claim should not be construed as limiting the claim.
The word
"comprising" does not exclude the presence of other elements than those listed
in a
claim. The word "a" or "an" preceding an element does not exclude the presence
of a
plurality of such element.
