Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
Method, system and signal generator for quality determination of an IP network
connection
Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to the field of Internet telephony, in short
VoIP (Voice over
Internet Protocol). In particular, the invention relates to a method, a system
and a signal
generator for quality determination of an IP network connection.
Background of the Art
VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) is a technology that makes it possible to
transmit the
continuous audio stream of a telephone call in the form of data packets over a
packet-
oriented network (IP network). In contrast to other forms of data transmission
in IP
networks, the speech medium (audio), if transported in the form of data
packets, requires
a continuous data flow where the packets are always transmitted at the same
time
intervals (isochronously). IP networks, however, are not generally suitable to
guarantee
the isochronous transmission of a stream of data packets. Moreover, the VoIP
data
packets compete with the data packets of other applications for the same
transmission
infrastructure (IP network and its active components). The IP network may be a
local area
network (LAN) and/or a wide area network (WAN).
Therefore, VoIP data transmission is subject to numerous interferences
resulting in a poor
quality ¨ e.g. a poor speech quality. For avoiding poor quality as much as
possible,
producers of VoIP systems usually suggest testing the IP networks for their
VoIP
capabilities before using a VoIP system. These tests (also called VoIP
assessment, VoIP
pre-deployment etc.) involve feeding simulated VoIP traffic into the IP
network to be
tested and assessing the transmission quality after transmission. If the test
results are
poor, the efficiency of the IP network may be enhanced (greater band width,
traffic
priorisation, physical and/or logical restructurisation, other active
components etc.).
If the VoIP capability of an IP network is to be tested, simulated VoIP
traffic is to be
provided by so-called load or call generators. The simulated VoIP traffic has
to
correspond to the VoIP traffic of the device planned to be used. Moreover, the
simulated
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
2
VoIP traffic has to meet the requirements of an undisturbed, ideal measuring
signal (e.g.
isochronous, complete, having the correct order etc.).
Since the VoIP calls are only transmitted between a transmitter and a receiver
(as remote
end), the call generators are usually also capable of receiving or terminating
VoIP calls.
Thus, two devices are always necessary for generating a VoIP call ¨ a
transmitting and a
receiving call generator. The receiving call generator tests the IP network
for its VoIP
capability using the received measuring signals. However, the received
measuring signal
is subject to two different interfering influences ¨ the influence of the IP
network to be
tested and the influence of the transmitting call generator. In practice,
however, it is
basically assumed that the measuring signal generated by the call generator
has a suitable
(good) quality ¨ a poor quality is thus exclusively attributed to the IP
network. Moreover,
the assessment methods on the receiver side are often quite inaccurate due to
the
calculation of a quality factor and do not allow for a definite distinction
between good
and poor quality. It is by no means possible with these methods to distinguish
whether a
poor quality has to be attributed to the IP network to be tested or already to
the
transmitting call generator.
Basically, there are two different types of call generators available ¨
hardware and
software. In laboratories of VoIP producers and for carriers, very expensive,
powerful
hardware generators are preferred which often consist of specific hardware
modules and
are capable of generating thousands of simultaneous VoIP calls of high quality
(isochronous). However, they are disadvantageous in that due to their sizes
and for
economic reasons, they are unsuitable for a flexible use in the aforementioned
pre-
deployments, which are made outside test laboratories.
Alternatively, software-based call generators are available, e.g. on CDs or as
downloads.
The user is then responsible for downloading or installing this software on a
(mostly
inexpensive) computer (often laptop). The producers/providers of the software-
based call
generators can no longer control this signal generation process ¨ therefore,
it is no longer
possible to provide reliable information on the quality of the measuring
signal that is later
generated. Since computers are no special hardware, the stability
(isochronicity) of the
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
3
simulated VoIP traffic can by no means be guaranteed. Although the generation
of an
isochronous VoIP call already involves considerable difficulties, software-
based call
generators allow for the generation of numerous simultaneous VoIP calls.
The instability of the generated VoIP calls is, e.g, due to hardware
performance
(processor, timing device, RAM etc.), the system software or its interrupts
(Windows,
Linux etc.), the VoIP call generation and other background applications on the
same
computer.
Interferences are often highly sporadic and non-reproducible. It is neither
predictable
when a simulated VoIP call has a poor quality nor which or how many VoIP calls
are of
poor quality. Thus, on principle, the quality of a measuring signal is
unknown.
If an actually or latently/possibly unstable measuring signal is used, it
cannot be definitely
decided on the receiver side whether the measured poor quality has to be
attributed to the
IP network to be tested or whether it has already been caused by the unstable
transmitter
(transmitting call generator). Consequently, the result of the pre-deployment
is virtually
unusable.
Summary
It is not possible to generate stable, i.e. isochronous, VoIP calls using
software-based call
generators in combination with simple, inexpensive computers. It is therefore
the object
of the present invention to make it possible to avoid measuring errors
generated by
unstable measuring signals during the quality determination of IP network
connections.
The present invention is based on the idea that the call generator itself
monitors the
quality (e.g., isochronicity, packet loss etc.) of the VoIP call it has
generated. According
to the present invention, the isochronicity (hereinafter the term
isochronicity shall
encompass all further disturbances, such as packet loss) of the call generator
and the
respective automatic reaction of the call generator is permanently monitored.
According to a first aspect, the present invention provides a method of
determining the
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
4
quality of an IP network connection. According to the present invention, a
signal
generator generates at least one measuring signal for measuring the quality of
an IP
network connection. Moreover, the signal generator determines for each of the
at least
one generated measuring signals the signal quality of each generated measuring
signal.
Then, the at least one measuring signal and the respective quality information
are
simultaneously transmitted to the receiver via the IP network connection.
According to the invention, the at least one received measuring signal and the
respective
quality information are evaluated by a receiver, e.g., belonging to a signal
generator of the
remote end. The receiver uses the quality information transmitted for each
measuring
signal to reject those signals whose quality is already insufficient for the
measuring task
when being generated by the signal generator.
In one embodiment, the signal generator transmits the determined quality
information at
the end of the measuring signal. Alternatively, the signal generator transmits
the
determined quality information at the end of a whole measuring signal series.
In one embodiment, the signal generator simultaneously generates x measuring
signals.
According to a another embodiment, the signal generator analyses during the
signal
transmission the determined signal quality of the x generated measuring
signals and
repeats the signal generation if the number of simultaneously generated
measuring signals
is insufficient. Alternatively, the signal generator analyses the determined
signal quality
of the x generated measuring signals during the signal transmission and
repeats the signal
generation of the measuring signals with a number smaller than x if the number
of
simultaneously generated measuring signals of sufficient quality is
insufficient.
In some instances, information describing the exact point in time of the
interference is
determined as quality information.
According to the invention, each measuring signal is a simulated Voice over IP
call.
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
According to a further aspect, a system for the quality determination of an IP
network
connection is provided. The system comprises a signal generator for generating
at least
one measuring signal for measuring the quality of an IP network connection.
The signal
generator determines for each of the generated at least one measuring signals
the
5 respective signal quality of the respective measuring signal during the
generation of the
measuring signal and transmits the at least one measuring signal and the
respective
quality information simultaneously over the IP network connection to a
receiver
belonging e.g. to a signal generator of the remote end.
According to a third aspect, the present invention provides a signal generator
for
determining the quality of an IP network connection. The signal generator
according to
the invention comprises means for generating at least one measuring signal for
measuring
the quality of an IP network connection, means for determining the signal
quality of each
of the generated at least one measuring signals, means for simultaneously
transmitting a
measuring signal and the respective quality information and a receiver, e.g.,
belonging to
the signal generator of the remote end for evaluating the measuring signals
transmitted
over the IP network connection as well as the respective quality information.
According to a further aspect of the present invention, a device for receiving
and
evaluating at least one measuring signal transmitted over an IP network
connection and
the respective quality information is provided. The device according to the
invention
comprises means for selectively rejecting received measuring signals or,
alternatively,
only the sequences of received measuring signals not having the necessary
quality of a
measuring signal when being generated upon evaluation of the respective
quality
information.
Moreover, the present invention provides a method of determining the quality
of an IP
network connection. The method comprises the following steps: receiving, by a
signal
receiver, at least one measuring signal for measuring the quality of an IP
network
connection and a respective quality information simultaneously transmitted
with the at
least one measuring signal determined on the transmitter side; evaluating the
respective
quality information; and rejecting on the receiver side the received measuring
signals or,
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
6
alternatively, only sequences of the received measuring signals lacking the
necessary
quality of a measuring signal already when being generated.
Brief Description of the Drawings
The present invention will be illustrated in the following in more detail by
the attached
drawings, in which:
Fig. 1 shows a schematic view of an embodiment of the present invention;
Fig. 2 shows a schematic view of the method according to the present
invention;
Fig. 3 shows a flow chart of a further embodiment; and
Fig. 4 shows a flow chart of an alternative embodiment.
Detailed Description
As shown in Fig. 1, according to an embodiment of the present invention, the
call
generator or signal generator (e.g. transmitter 1) permanently assesses by
means of
measurements whether the quality of each VoIP call simultaneously generated by
it
satisfies the quality of an ideal measuring signal or not. This results in a
"yes/no"
information on the transmitter quality 1.
This "yes/no" information on quality is preferably generated in relation to
the call. Should
the call generator detect during a simulated VoIP call a poor quality even
though only
once or for a short period, the whole VoIP call is classified as having a poor
quality. This
quality information generated on the transmitter side is then transmitted by
the
transmitting call generator either at the end of the VoIP call or at the end
of the VoIP call
series (measuring task) to the receiving call generator (e.g. receiver 2). The
receiving call
generator is thus capable of rejecting from the whole amount of received VoIP
calls those
already having a poor quality when being generated (e.g. transmitter quality
1) and thus
being unsuitable for a pre-deployment.
Fig. 1 shows two call generators 1 and 2 in communication with each other. For
calls in
the outward direction, i.e. from call generator 1 to call generator 2, call
generator 1 forms
transmitter 1 whereas call generator 2 forms receiver 2. The transmitter
quality 1 for this
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
7
signal is determined by call generator 1, transmitted as the quality
information as regards
transmitter 1 and evaluated by call generator 2. There, the receiver quality 2
is determined
in the same way.
For calls in the opposite direction, call generator 2 forms transmitter 2
whose transmitter
quality 2 is determined and transmitted with the call.
Since, according to the invention, the call generator has information on the
quality of the
VoIP calls it has generated, it is moreover capable in connection with the
measuring task
set (e.g., generation of a certain number "x" of simultaneous VoIP calls, see
Fig. 2) of
deciding even without quality information from the receiver whether the entire
pre-
deployment is successful or practically usable. If the number of
simultaneously generated
stable VoIP calls is insufficient, the call generator automatically decides to
repeat the
measuring task (pre-deployment) (see Fig. 4), the maximum number of
repetitions of the
measuring task being preferably limited.
In any case, the monitoring of the quality on the transmitter side, which is
made
simultaneously with the generation of the measuring signal, is a process
independent of
the generation of the VoIP call so as to avoid mutual influence.
According to a further embodiment, variations of the measuring task, such as a
reduction
of the number of simultaneous VoIP calls, is possible in addition to a mere
repetition of
the measuring task. This is shown in Fig. 3. The number of simultaneous VoIP
calls can
either be reduced when the measuring task is repeated or when the measuring
task is
executed. Thus, the call generator can be caused to generate exclusively
isochronous
VoIP calls. Information is retrieved whether all calls have a sufficient
quality. If not, their
number x is reduced and the generation of calls is restarted.
According to a further alternative of the present invention, the quality
information on
VoIP calls on the transmitter side are refined. It is for example conceivable
to supply
information on the exact point in time (e.g., packet number, time stamp) of an
interference of the measuring signal to the receiver instead of a "yes/no"
information.
CA 02738141 2011-03-22
8
Preferably, the extent of the interference (such as type and number of
interferences) is
considered so that this method is applied only to slightly disturbed measuring
signals and
the time and effort spent on monitoring the measuring signal is reasonably
restricted. The
advantage of such a solution is that, using the interference information
provided by the
call generator on the receiver side of the call generator, at least slightly
disturbed
measuring signals may also be used for assessing the IP network as regards its
VoIP
capability, in that only the disturbed sequences of a measuring signal are
rejected but not
the whole measuring signal. Thus, the number of potential repetitions as
described in the
preceding paragraph is reduced.
