Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 1 -
TITLE: DERIVATIVES OF NATIVE LIGNIN
FIELD
This invention relates to derivatives of native lignin recovered from
lignocellulosic
feedstocks, and industrial applications thereof. More particularly, this
invention relates to
derivatives of native lignin having certain chemical properties as well as
uses, processes, methods,
and compositions thereof.
BACKGROUND
Native lignin is a naturally occurring amorphous complex cross-linked organic
macromolecule that comprises an integral component of all plant biomass. The
chemical structure
of lignin is irregular in the sense that different structural units (e.g.,
phenylpropane units) are not
linked to each other in any systematic order. It is known that native lignin
comprises pluralities of
two monolignol monomers that are methoxylated to various degrees (trans-
coniferyl alcohol and
trans-sinapyl alcohol) and a third non-methoxylated monolignol (trans-p-
coumaryl alcohol).
Various combinations of these monolignols comprise three building blocks of
phenylpropanoid
structures i.e. guaiacyl monolignol, syringyl monolignol and p-hydroxyphenyl
monolignol,
respectively, that are polymerized via specific linkages to form the native
lignin macromolecule.
Extracting native lignin from lignocellulosic biomass during pulping generally
results in
lignin fragmentation into numerous mixtures of irregular components.
Furthermore, the lignin
fragments may react with any chemicals employed in the pulping process.
Consequently, the
generated lignin fractions can be referred to as lignin derivatives and/or
technical lignins. As it is
difficult to elucidate and characterize such complex mixture of molecules,
lignin derivatives are
usually described in terms of the lignocellulosic plant material used, and the
methods by which they
are generated and recovered from lignocellulosic plant material, i.e. hardwood
lignins, softwood
lignins, and annual fibre lignins.
Native lignins are partially depolyrnerized during the pulping processes into
lignin
fragments which dissolve in the pulping liquors and subsequently separated
from the cellulosic
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 2 -
pulps. Post-pulping liquors containing lignin and polysaccharide fragments,
and other extractives,
are commonly referred to as "black liquors" or "spent liquors", depending on
the pulping process.
Such liquors are generally considered a by-product, and it is common practice
to combust them to
recover some energy value in addition to recovering the cooking chemicals.
However, it is also
possible to precipitate and/or recover lignin derivatives from these liquors.
Each type of pulping
process used to separate cellulosic pulps from other lignocellulosic
components produces lignin
derivatives that are very different in their physico-chemical, biochemical,
and structural properties.
Given that lignin derivatives are available from renewable biomass sources
there is an
interest in using these derivatives in certain industrial applications. For
example, lignin derivatives
obtained via organosolv extraction, such as the Alcell process (Alcell is a
registered trademark of
Lignol Innovations Ltd., Burnaby, BC, CA), have been used in rubber products,
adhesives, resins,
plastics, asphalt, cement, casting resins, agricultural products, oil-field
products and as feedstocks
for the production of fine chemicals. However, large-scale commercial
application of the extracted
lignin derivatives, particularly those isolated in traditional pulping
processes employed in the
manufacture of pulp for paper production, has been limited due to, for
example, the inconsistency
of their chemical and functional properties. This inconsistency may, for
example, be due to
changes in feedstock supplies and the particular
extraction/generation/recovery conditions. These
issues are further complicated by the complexity of the molecular structures
of lignin derivatives
produced by the various extraction methods and the difficulty in performing
reliable routine
analyses of the structural conformity and integrity of recovered lignin
derivatives. For instance,
lignin derivatives are known to have antioxidant properties (e.g. Catignani
G.L., Carter M.E.,
Antioxidant Properties of Lignin, Journal of Food Science, Volume 47, Issue 5,
1982, p. 1745; Pan
X. et al. J. Agric. Food Chem., Vol. 54, No. 16, 2006, pp. 5806-5813) but, to
date, these properties
have been highly variable making the industrial application of lignin
derivatives as an antioxidant
problematic.
Thermoplastics and thermosets are used extensively for a wide variety of
purposes.
Examples of thermoplastics include classes of polyesters, polycarbonates,
polylactates, polyvinyls,
polystyrenes, polyamides, polyacetates, polyacrylates, polypropylene, and the
like. Polyolefins such
as polyethylene and polypropylene represent a large market, amounting to more
than 100 million
,
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 3 -
metric tons annually. During manufacturing, processing and use the physical
and chemical
properties of certain thermoplastics can be adversely affected by various
factors such as exposure
to heat, UV radiation, light, oxygen, mechanical stress or the presence of
impurities. Clearly it is
advantageous to mitigate or avoid these problems. In addition, the increase in
recycling of material
has led to an increased need to address these issues.
Degradation caused by free radicals, exposure to UV radiation, heat, light,
and
environmental pollutants are frequent causes of the adverse effects. A
stabilizer such as an
antioxidant, anti-ozonant, or UV block is often included in thermoplastic
resins for the purpose of
aiding in the production process and extending the useful life of the product.
Common examples
of stabilizers and antioxidants include amine types, phenolic types, phenol
alkanes, phosphites, and
the like. These additives often have undesirable or even unacceptable
environmental, health and
safety, economic, and/or disposal issues associated with their use.
Furthermore, certain of these
stabilizers/antioxidants can reduce the biodegradability of the product.
It has been suggested that lignin may provide a suitable polymeric natural
antioxidant
which has an acceptable toxicity, efficacy, and environmental profile. See,
for example, A.
Gregorova et al., Radical scavenging capacity of lignin and its effect on
processing stabilization of
virgin and recycled polypropylene, Journal of Applied Polymer Science 106-3
(2007) pp. 1626-
1631; C. Pouteau et al. Antioxidant Properties of Lignin in Polypropylene,
Polymer Degradation
and Stability 81(2003) 9-18. Despite the advantages of lignin, for a variety
of reasons, it has not
been adopted for widespread use as an antioxidant. For instance, it is often
problematic to provide
lignins that perform consistently in terms of antioxidant activity. Also, the
processing of the lignin
may introduce substances that are incompatible for use with chemicals such as
polyolefins.
Additionally, the cost of producing and/or purifying the lignin may make it
uneconomic for certain
uses.
SUMMARY
The present invention provides derivatives of native lignin having a certain
aliphatic
hydroxyl content. Surprisingly, it has been found that consistent and
predictable antioxidant
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 4 -
activity may be provided by selecting for derivatives of native lignin having
certain aliphatic
hydroxyl contents.
As used herein, the term "native lignin" refers to lignin in its natural
state, in plant material.
As used herein, the terms "lignin derivatives" and "derivatives of native
lignin" refer to
lignin material extracted from lignocellulosic biomass. Usually, such material
will be a mixture of
chemical compounds that are generated during the extraction process.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Figure 1 shows the HSQC spectrum of non-acetylated hardwood lignin derivatives
(arrows
indicate the signals corresponding to the ethoxyl groups).
Figure 2 shows the quantitative "C NMR spectrum of non-acetylated hardwood
lignin
derivatives.
Figure 3 shows the quantitative 13C NMR spectrum of acetylated hardwood lignin
derivatives.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
The present invention provides derivatives of native lignin having certain
aliphatic hydroxyl
contents. Lignin derivatives having lower aliphatic hydroxyl contents have
been found to score
more highly on the Radical Scavenging Index (RSI), a measure of antioxidant
activity. Thus,
selecting for derivatives of native lignin having a lower aliphatic hydroxyl
content results in a
product having a higher and more predictable antioxidant activity. It has been
found that
derivatives of native lignin having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about
2.35 mmol/g or less
result in a good level of antioxidant activity. For example, about 2.25 mmol/g
or less, about 2
mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less.
Radical Scavenging Index (RSI) is a measure of radical scavenging capacity.
The assay uses
2,2-dipheny1-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH), a stable free radical which absorbs
light strongly at 515 nm,
).5
to measure a compound's radical scavenging index (RSI). In its radical form,
DPPFI. absorbs
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 5 -
strongly at 515 nm and has a deep purple colour. As DPPH gives up its free
electron to radical
scavengers, it loses its purple colour and its absorbance shifts to 520 nm.
The greater the drop in
DPPH absorbance at 515 nm after a test compound has been added to the DPPH
solution, the
higher the compound's free RSI and also, its antioxidant activity. In the
present invention, Vitamin
E (Vit. E) and butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) are used as positive controls.
The lignin derivative
samples (1.0 ¨ 2.0 mg), Vit. E control samples (1.0-2.0 mg), and BHT control
samples (6.0 ¨ 8.0
mg) are prepared for testing by being placed into microcentrifuge tubes after
which each was
diluted with 1.0 mL of 90% (v/v) aqueous dioxan, vortexed, transferred to new
microcentrifuge
tubes and further diluted 50/50 with 90% aqueous dioxane to give stock
concentrations of 0.5-1.0
mg/mL for samples and Vitamin E and 3.0-4.0 mg/mL for BHT. An indicating
(purple) DPPH
stable free radical solution is made by dissolving 3.78 mg DPPH in 100 mL 90%
dioxane (95.9
M). Samples and standards are serially diluted to fill columns of a quartz 96-
well plate (8
dilutions). The assays are performed by placing aliquots of the sample stock
solutions into two
rows of wells in a 96-well plate. The first row served as the reference row
while the second row
received DPPH aliquots. 165 !IL of 90% dioxane was added to each well and
mixed. Aliquots of
the mixed samples in each row are transferred to the adjacent row which is
further diluted with 165
of 90% dioxane in each well. The mixing, transferring and dilution are
repeated until the last
row of wells is prepared. The same volume of aliquots is removed from the last
row. The 96-well
plate also contains a row of wells that received only the 90% dioxane. In the
final step of the
preparation procedure, 165 1iL of the DPPH solution is added as quickly as
possible to all the
control and analytical columns by using an 8-channel auto-pipette and an
Eppendore reagent
reservoir. As soon as all reagents are added, the plate is placed into a plate-
reading
spectrophotometer (Spectra Max Plus, Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA, USA),
and absorbance
measurements are carried out. The program for the spectrophotometer (SOFTmax
software)
consists of a timing sequence of 16 min and a reading of the entire plate at
515 nm. RSI is defined
as the inverse of the concentration which produces 50% inhibition in DPPH
absorbance at 515
nm. The results are then 'normalized' by dividing the sample RSI by the RSI
value for the BHT
control. The normalized RSI is represented by this acronym "NRSI".
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 6 -
The present invention provides derivatives of native lignin recovered during
or after
pulping of lignocellulosic feedstocks. The pulp may be from any suitable
lignocellulosic feedstock
including hardwoods, softwoods, annual fibres, and combinations thereof.
Hardwood feedstocks include Acacia; Afzelia; Synsepalum duloificum; Albizia;
Alder (e.g.
Alnus glutinosa, Alnus rubra); Applewood; Arbutus; Ash (e.g. F. nigra, F.
quadrangulata, F. excelsior, F.
pennsylvanica lanceolata, F. latifolia, F. profunda, F. americana); Aspen
(e.g. P. grandidentata, P. tremula, P.
tremuloides); Australian Red Cedar (Toona ciliata); Ayna (Distemonanthus
benthamianus); Balsa (Ochroma
pyramidale); Basswood (e.g. T. americana, T. heterophylla); Beech (e.g. F.
glvatica, F. grandifolia); Birch;
(e.g. Betula populifolia, B. nigra, B. papyrifera, B. lenta, B.
alleghaniensisl B. lutea, B. pendula, B. pubescens);
Blackbean; Blackwood; Bocote; Boxelder; Boxwood; Brazilwood; Bubinga; Buckeye
(e.g. Aesculus
hippocastanum, Aesculus glabra, Aesculus )(lava' Aesculus octandra);
Butternut; Catalpa; Cherry (e.g. Prunus
serotina, Prunus pennglvanica, Prunus avium); Crabwood; Chestnut; Coachwood;
Cocobolo; Corkwood;
Cottonwood (e.g. Populus balsatMfera, Populus deltoides, Populus sargentii,
Populus heterophylla);
Cucumbertree; Dogwood (e.g. Cornusfiorida, Comas nuttallii); Ebony (e.g.
Dio0ros kurii, Diaipyros
melanida, Diospyros cras.qflora); Elm (e.g. Ulmus americana, Ulmus procera,
Ulmus thomasii, U lmus rubra,
Ulmus glabra); Eucalyptus; Greenheart; Grenadilla; Gum (e.g. Nyssa glvatica,
Eucalyptus globulus,
Liquidambar sgraciflua, Nyssa aquatica); Hickory (e.g. Caga alba, Caga glabra,
Caga ovata, Caga
laciniosa); Hornbeam; Hophornbeam; Ipe; Iroko; Ironwood (e.g. Bangkirai,
Carpinus caroliniana,
Casuarina equisetifolia, Choricbangarpia subargentea, Copaifera spp.,
Eusideroglon zwageri, Guajacum
officinale, Guajacum sanctum, Hopea odorata, Ipe, Krugiodendron ferreum,
Lyonothamnus lyonzi (L.
floribundus), Mesua ferrea, Olea spp., 0 lnga tesota, Ostga virginiana,
Parrotia persica, Tabebuia serra4folia);
Jacaranda; Jotoba; Lacewood; Laurel; Limba; Lignum vitae; Locust (e.g. Robinia
pseudacacia, Gleditsia
triacanthos); Mahogany; Maple (e.g. Acer saccharum, Acer nigrum, Acer negundo,
Acer rubrum, Acer
saccharinum, Acer pseudoplatanus); Meranti; Mpingo; Oak (e.g. Quercus
macrocarpa, Quercus alba, µQuercus
stellata, Quercus bicolor, Quercus virginiana, Quercus michauxii, Quercus
prinus, Quercus muhlenbergii, Quercus
chgsolepilr, Quercus lyrata, Quercus robur, Quercus petraea, Quercus rubra,
Quercus velutina, Quercus laurrjblia,
Quercus falcata, Quercus nigra, Quercus phellos, Quercus texana); Obeche;
Okoume; Oregon Myrtle;
California Bay Laurel; Pear; Poplar (e.g. P. balsamifera, P. nigra, Hybrid
Poplar (Populus x
canadensis)); Ramin; Red cedar; Rosewood; Sal; Sandalwood; Sassafras;
Satinwood; Silky Oak; Silver
Wattle; Snakewood; Sourwood; Spanish cedar; American sycamore; Teak; Walnut
(e.g. Juglans nigra,
CA 02798158 2016-12-08
- 7 -
Juskens er.gia); Willow (e.g. Salix nigra, Salix alba); Yellow poplar
(Liriodendron tuligera); Bamboo;
Palmwood; and combinations/hybrids thereof.
For example, hardwood feedstocks for the present invention may be selected
from Acacia,
Aspen, Beech, Eucalyptus, Maple, Birch, Gum, Oak, Poplar, and
combinations/hybrids thereof.
The hardwood feedstocks for the present invention may be selected from Popubis
spp. (e.g. Popu
term:dales), Ewa#plus spp. (e.g. Exabptits slobulus), Amid spp. (e.g. Acacia
dealbata), and
combinations/hybrids thereof.
It has been found that derivatives of native lignin from hardwood feedstocks
having an
aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less have a good level of
antioxidant activity.
For example, about 2.25 mmol/g or less, about 2 mtnol/g or less, or about 1.75
mmol/g or less.
In the present invention, "aliphatic hydroxyl content" refers to the quantity
of aliphatic
hydroxyl groups in the lignin derivatives and is the arithmetic sum of the
quantity of primary and
secondary hydroxyl groups (OHal = 0Hpr + OHsec). The aliphatic hydroxyl
content can be
measured by quantitative "C high resolution NMR spectroscopy of acetylated and
non-acetylated
lignin derivatives, using, for instance, 1,3,54:donne and tetramethyl silane
(TMS) as internal
reference. For the data analysis "BASEOPT" TM (DIGMOD set to baseope) routine
in the software
package TopSpie 2.1.4 was used to predict the first FID data point back at the
mid-point of "C r.f.
pulse in the digitally filtered data was used. For the NMR spectra recording a
Bruker AVANCE II TM
digital NMR spectrometer running TopSpinTm2.1 was used. The spectrometer used
a Bruker 54 mm
l0 bore Ultrashield magnet operating at 14.1 Teak (600.13 MHz for 'H,
150.90 MHz for "C). The
spectrometer was coupled with a Bruker QNP cryoprobe (5 mm NMR samples, "C
direct observe
on inner coil, 'H outer coil) that had both coils cooled by helium gas to 20K
and all preamplifiers
cooled to 77K for maximum sensitivity. Sample temperature was maintained at
300 K using
a Bruker BVT 3000 temperature unit and a Bruker BCUO5 cooler with ca. 95%
nitrogen gas
).5 flowing over the sample tube at a rate of 800 L/h.
The lignin derivatives herein may, for example, have an aliphatic hydroxyl
content of 0.001
mmol/g or greater; 0.1 mmol/g or greater; 0.2 mmol/g or greater; 0.4 mmol/g or
greater; 0.5
mmol/g or greater.
CA 02798158 2016-12-08
- 8 -
Quantification of ethoxyl groups was performed similarly to aliphatic
hydroxyls
quantification by high resolution "C NMR spectroscopy. Identification of
ethoxyl groups was
confirmed by 2D NMR HSQC spectroscopy. 2D NMR spectra were recorded by a
Bruker 700
MHz UltraShield TM Plus standard bore magnet spectrometer equipped with a
sensitive cryogenically
cooled 5rxim TO gradient probe with inverse geometry. The acquisition
parameters were as follow:
standard Bruker pulse program hsqcetgp, temperature of 298 K, a 90 pulse, 1.1
sec pulse delay
(dl), and acquisition time of 60 msec.
Derivatives of native lignin according to the present invention, coming from
hardwood
feedstocks tend to have a NRSI of 30 or greater, 40 or greater, 50 or greater,
00 or greater, 70 or
greater, 80 or greater, 90 or greater, 100 or greater, 110 or greater, 120 or
greater.
Softwood feedstocks include Araucaria (e.g. A runningbamii, A angustifi4a, A.
araucana);
softwood Cedar (e.g. JunOents virginiana, Thmja p#cata, Tbuja occidentalis,
Chamaegparis tbyoides
Callitropsis trootkatensis); Cypress (e.g. Cbamaegparis, Cmpressies Taxodimm,
Cupnssus aritonica, Taxodium
disticbum, Chamaeypans obtusa, Chamaegparir lawsoniana, Cupressus
semperviren); Rocky Mountain
Douglas fir; European Yew; Fir (e.g. Abies bairamea, Abies alba, Abies
procera, Abies arnabilt10;
Hemlock (e.g. Tsuga canadensis, Tsuga mertensiana, Tsuga hetemphylla); Kauri;
Kaya; Larch (e.g. Larix
decidua, Lath( kaempferi, Larix Larix occidentafis); Pine (e.g. Pinus
nigra, Pinus banle-riana, Pinus
contorta, Pinus radiata, Pima ponderosa, Pinus resinosa, Pinus glvestrir,
Pinus strobus, Pinus monticola, Pinus
lambertiana, Pima taeda, Pima palustris, Pinta ngida, Pinus echinata);
Redwood; Rirnu; Spruce (e.g. Picea
abies, Picea =liana, Picea rubens, Picea sikbensis, Picea glaiica); Sugi; and
combinations/hybrids thereof.
For example, softwood feedstocks which may be used herein include cedar; fir;
pine;
spruce; and combinations thereof. The softwood feedstocks for the present
invention may be
selected from loblolly pine (Pima taeda), radiata pine, jack pine, spruce
(e.g., white, interior, black),
Douglas fir, Pinus silvestris, Picea abies, and combinations/hybrids thereof.
The softwood feedstocks
for the present invention may be selected from pine (e.g. Pins radiata, Pinus
taeda); spruce; and
combinations/hybrids thereof.
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 9 -
It has been found that derivatives of native lignin from softwood feedstocks
having an
aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less have a good level of
antioxidant activity.
For example, about 2.25 mmol/g or less, about 2 mmol/g or less, or about 1.75
mmol/g or less.
Derivatives of native lignin according to the present invention, coming from
softwood
feedstocks tend to have a NRSI 15 or greater, 25 or greater, 30 or greater, 35
or greater, 40 or
greater, 45 or greater, 50 or greater, 55 or greater, 60 or greater.
Annual fibre feedstocks include biomass derived from annual plants, plants
which
complete their growth in one growing season and therefore must be planted
yearly. Examples of
annual fibres include: flax, cereal straw (wheat, barley, oats), sugarcane
bagasse, rice straw, corn
stover, corn cobs, hemp, fruit pulp, alfa grass, switchgrass, and
combinations/hybrids thereof.
Industrial residues like corn cobs, fruit peals, seeds, etc. may also be
considered annual fibres since
they are commonly derived from annual fibre biomass such as edible crops and
fruits. For
example, the annual fibre feedstock may be selected from wheat straw, corn
stover, corn cobs,
sugar cane bagasse, and combinations/hybrids thereof.
Derivatives of native lignin according to the present invention, coming from
annual fibre
feedstocks tend to have a NRSI of 15 or greater, 20 or greater, 25 or greater,
30 or greater, 35 or
greater, 40 or greater, 45 or greater, 50 or greater.
In an embodiment of the present invention, derivatives of native lignin from
annual fibre
feedstocks have an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 3.75 mmol/g or less;
3.5 mmol/g or less;
3.25 mmol/g or less; 3 mmol/g or less; 2.75 mmol/g or less; 2.5 mmol/g or
less; 2.35 mmol/g or
less; 2.25 mmol/g or less.
The derivatives of native lignin will vary with the type of process used to
separate native
lignins from cellulose and other biomass constituents. Preparations very
similar to native lignin can
be obtained by (1) solvent extraction of finely ground wood (milled-wood
lignin, MWL) or by (2)
acidic dioxane extraction (acidolysis) of wood. Derivatives of native lignin
can be also isolated
from biomass pre-treated using (3) steam explosion, (4) dilute acid
hydrolysis, (5) ammonia fibre
expansion, (6) autohydrolysis methods. Derivatives of native lignin can be
recovered after pulping
of lignocellulosics including industrially operated (3) kraft and (4) soda
pulping (and their
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 10 -
modifications) and (5) sulphite pulping. In addition, a number of various
pulping methods have
been developed but not industrially introduced. Among them four major
"organosolv" pulping
methods tend to produce highly-purified lignin mixtures. The first organosolv
method uses
ethanol/solvent pulping (aka the Alcell process); the second organosolv
method uses alkaline
sulphite anthraquinone methanol pulping (aka the "ASAM" process); the third
organosolv process
uses methanol pulping followed by methanol, NaOH, and anthraquinone pulping
(aka the
"Organocell" process); the fourth organosolv process uses acetic
acid/hydrochloric acid or formic
acid pulping (aka the "Acetosolv" process).
It should be noted that haft pulping, sulphite pulping, and ASAM organosolv
pulping will
generate derivatives of native lignin containing significant amounts of
organically-bound sulphur
which may make them unsuitable for certain uses. Acid hydrolysis, soda
pulping, steam explosion,
Alcell pulping, Organocell pulping, and Acetosolv pulping will generate
derivatives of native
lignin that are sulphur-free or contain low amounts of inorganic sulphur.
Organosolv processes, particularly the Alcell process, tend to be less
aggressive and can
be used to separate highly purified lignin derivatives and other useful
materials from biomass
without excessively altering or damaging the native lignin building blocks.
Such processes can
therefore be used to maximize the value from all the components making up the
biomass.
Organosolv extraction processes however typically involve extraction at higher
temperatures and
pressures with a flammable solvent compared to other industrial processes and
thus are generally
considered to be more complex and expensive.
A description of the Alcell process can be found in US Patent 4,764,596
(herein
incorporated by reference). The process generally comprises pulping or pre-
treating a fibrous
biomass feedstock with primarily an ethanol/water solvent solution under
conditions that include:
(a) 60% ethanol/40% water, (b) temperature of about 180 C to about 210 C,
(c) pressure of
about 20 atm to about 35 atm, and (d) a processing time of 5-120 minutes.
Derivatives of native
lignin are fractionated from the native lignins into the pulping liquor which
also receives solubilised
hemicelluloses, other carbohydrates and other extractives such as resins,
organic acids, phenols,
and tannins. Organosolv pulping liquors comprising the fractionated
derivatives of native lignin
and other extractives from the fibrous biomass feedstocks, are often called
"black liquors". The
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 11 -
organic acid and extractives released by organosolv pulping significantly
acidify the black liquors to
pH levels of about 5 and lower. After separation from the cellulosic pulps
produced during the
pulping process, the derivatives of native lignin are recovered from the black
liquors by
depressurization followed by flashing with cold water which will cause the
fractionated derivatives
of native lignin to precipitate thereby enabling their recovery by standard
solids/liquids separation
processes. Various disclosures exemplified by US Patent No. 7,465,791 and PCT
Patent
Application Publication No. WO 2007/129921, describe modifications to the
Alcell organosolv
process for the purposes of increasing the yields of fractionated derivatives
of native lignin
recovered from fibrous biomass feedstocks during biorefining. Modifications to
the Alcell
organosolv process conditions included adjusting: (a) ethanol concentration in
the pulping liquor
to a value selected from a range of 35% - 85% (w/w) ethanol, (b) temperature
to a value selected
from a range of 100 C to 350 C, (c) pressure to a value selected from a
range of 5 atm to 35 atm,
and (d) processing time to a duration from a range of 20 minutes to about 2
hours or longer, (e)
liquor-to-wood ratio of 3:1 to 15:1 or higher, (f) pH of the cooking liquor
from a range of 1 to 6.5
or higher if a basic catalyst is used.
The present invention provides a process for producing derivatives of native
lignin, said
process comprising:
(a) pulping a fibrous biomass feedstock with an organic solvent/water
solution,
(b) separating the cellulosic pulps or pre-treated substrates from the pulping
liquor or pre-
treatment solution,
(c) recovering derivatives of native lignin.
The organic solvent may be selected from short chain primary and secondary
alcohols,
such as such as methanol, ethanol, propanol, and combinations thereof. For
example, the solvent
may be ethanol. The liquor solution may comprise about 20%, by weight, or
greater, about 30% or
greater, about 50% or greater, about 60% or greater, about 70% or greater, of
ethanol.
Step (a) of the process may be carried out at a temperature of from about 100
C and
greater, or about 120 C and greater, or about 140 C and greater, or about 160
C and greater, or
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 12 -
about 170 C and greater, or about 180 C and greater. The process may be
carried out at a
temperature of from about 300 C and less, or about 280 C and less, or about
260 C and less, or
about 240 C and less, or about 220 C and less, or about 210 C and less, or
about 205 C and less,
or about 200 C and less.
Step (a) of the process may be carried out at a pressure of about 5 atm and
greater, or
about 10 atm and greater, or about 15 atm and greater, or about 20 atm and
greater, or about 25
atm and greater, or about 30 atm and greater. The process may be carried out
at a pressure of
about 150 atm and less, or about 125 atm and less, or about 115 atm and less,
or about 100 atm
and less, or about 90 atm and less, or about 80 atm and less.
The fibrous biomass may be treated with the solvent solution of step (a) for
about 1 minute
or more, about 5 minutes or more, about 10 minutes or more, about 15 minutes
or more, about 30
minutes or more. The fibrous biomass may be treated with the solvent solution
of step (a) at its
operating temperature for about 360 minutes or less, about 300 minutes or
less, about 240 minutes
or less, about 180 minutes or less, about 120 minutes or less.
The pH of the pulp liquor may, for example, be from about 1 to about 6, or
from about 1.5
to about 5.5.
The weight ratio of liquor to biomass may be any suitable ratio. For example,
from about
5:1 to about 15:1, from about 5.5:1 to about 10:1; from about 6:1 to about
8:1.
The volume of extraction solution is from about 5 to about 10 times the volume
of the
biomass feedstock. For example, the volume of extraction solution may be from
about 6 to about
8 times that of the biomass
The present invention provides a process for producing a lignin derivative
having an
aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less, about 2.25 mmol/g or
less, about 2
mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less. Said process comprises:
a) pulping or pre-treating a fibrous biomass feedstock in a vessel with an
organic
solvent/water solution to form a liquor, wherein:
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 13 -
i. the solution comprises about 30% or greater, by weight, of organic solvent;
and
the pH of the liquor is from about 1 to about 6;
b) heating the liquor to about 100 C or greater;
c) raising the pressure in the vessel to about 5 atm or greater;
d) maintaining the elevated temperature and pressure for 1 minute or longer;
e) separating the cellulosic pulps from the pulp liquor
f) recovering derivatives of native lignin.
The present invention provides a process for producing a hardwood lignin
derivative
having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less, about 2.25
mmol/g or less,
about 2 mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less, said process comprises:
a) pulping or pre-treating a fibrous biomass feedstock in a vessel with an
organic
solvent/water solvent solution to form a liquor, wherein:
i. the solution comprises about 30% or greater, by weight, of organic solvent;
and
the pH of the liquor is from about 1 to about 6;
b) heating the liquor to about 100 C or greater;
c) raising the pressure in the vessel to about 5 atm or greater;
d) maintaining the elevated temperature and pressure for 1 minute or longer;
e) separating the cellulosic pulps from the pulp liquor
f) recovering derivatives of native lignin.
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 14 -
The present invention provides a process for producing a softwood lignin
derivative having
an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less, about 2.25 mmol/g
or less, about 2
mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less, said process comprises:
a) pulping or pre-treating a fibrous biomass feedstock in a vessel with an
organic
solvent/water solvent solution to form a liquor, wherein:
i. the solution comprises about 30% or greater, by weight, of organic solvent;
and
ii. the pH of the liquor is from about 1 to about 6;
b) heating the liquor to about 100 C or greater;
c) raising the pressure in the vessel to about 5 atm or greater;
d) maintaining the elevated temperature and pressure for 1 minute or longer;
e) separating the cellulosic pulps from the pulp liquor
f) recovering derivatives of native lignin.
The present invention provides a process for producing an annual fibre lignin
derivative
having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 3.75 mmol/g or less; 3.5 mmol/g
or less; 3.25
mmol/g or less; 3 mmol/g or less; 2.75 mmol/g or less; 2.5 mmol/g or less;
2.35 mmol/g or less;
2.25 mmol/g or less, said process comprises:
a) pulping or pre-treating a fibrous biomass feedstock in a vessel with an
organic
solvent/water solvent solution to form a liquor, wherein:
10
i. the solution comprises about 30% or greater, by weight, of organic solvent;
and
ii. the pH of the liquor is from about 1 to about 6;
b) heating the liquor to about 100 C or greater;
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 15 -
c) raising the pressure in the vessel to about 5 atm or greater;
d) maintaining the elevated temperature and pressure for 1 minute or longer;
e) separating the cellulosic pulps from the pulp liquor
f) recovering derivatives of native lignin.
The derivatives of native lignin herein may be incorporated into polymer
compositions.
The compositions herein may comprise a lignin derivative according to the
present invention and a
polymer-forming component. As used herein, the term 'polymer-forming
component' means a
component that is capable of being polymerized into a polymer as well as a
polymer that has
already been formed. For example, in certain embodiments the polymer-forming
component may
comprise monomer units which are capable of being polymerized. In certain
embodiments the
polymer component may comprise oligomer units that are capable of being
polymerized. In certain
embodiments the polymer component may comprise a polymer that is already
substantially
polymerized.
Polymers forming components for use herein may result in thermoplastic or
thermoset
polymers such as epoxy resins, urea-formaldehyde resins, phenol-formaldehyde
resins, polyimides,
isocyanate resins, and the like. For example, polyalkenes such as polyethylene
or polypropylene.
Typically, the lignin derivative will comprise from about 0.1%, by weight, or
greater, about
0.5% or greater, about 1% or greater, of the composition. Typically, the
lignin derivative will
comprise from about 80%, by weight, or less, about 60% or less, about 40% or
less, about 20% or
less, about 10% or less, of the composition.
The compositions comprise lignin derivative and polymer-forming component but
may
comprise a variety of other optional ingredients such as adhesion promoters;
biocides
(antibacterials, fungicides, and moldicides), anti-fogging agents; anti-static
agents; bonding, blowing
and foaming agents; dispersants; fillers and extenders; fire and flame
retardants and smoke
suppressants; impact modifiers; initiators; lubricants; micas; pigments,
colorants and dyes;
plasticizers; processing aids; release agents; silanes, titanates and
zirconates; slip and anti-blocking
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 16 -
agents; stabili7ers; stearates; ultraviolet light absorbers; foaming agents;
defoamers; hardeners;
odorants; deodorants; antifouling agents; viscosity regulators; waxes; and
combinations thereof
The present invention provides the use of the present derivatives of native
lignin as an
antioxidant. For example, the present use may be as an antioxidant additive
for use with
thermoplastic polymers such as polyethylene, polypropylene, polyamides,
styrene-butadiene,
natural rubber, and combinations thereof. Other examples include: antioxidant
additives for use in
the animal health and feed industry, human food and health.
The present invention provides methods of producing derivatives of native
lignin having
an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less, about 2.25 mmol/g
or less, about 2
mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less.
The present invention provides methods of producing hardwood derivatives of
native
lignin having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less
result, about 2.25
mmol/g or less, about 2 mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less.
The present invention provides methods of producing softwood derivatives of
native lignin
having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 2.35 mmol/g or less, about 2.25
mmol/g or less,
about 2 mmol/g or less, or about 1.75 mmol/g or less.
The present invention provides methods of producing annual fibre derivatives
of native
lignin having an aliphatic hydroxyl content of about 3.75 mmol/g or less; 3.5
mmol/g or less; 3.25
mmol/g or less; 3 mmol/g or less; 2.75 mmol/g or less; 2.5 mmol/g or less;
2.35 mmol/g or less;
2.25 mmol/g or less.
The present invention provides methods of producing derivatives of native
lignin having a
NRSI of 15 or greater, 20 or greater, 25 or greater, 30 or greater, 35 or
greater, 40 or greater, 50 or
greater, 60 or greater, 70 or greater.
The present invention provides methods of producing hardwood derivatives of
native
lignin having a NRSI of 15 or greater, 20 or greater, 25 or greater, 30 or
greater, 35 or greater, 40
or greater, 50 or greater, 60 or greater, 70 or greater.
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 17 -
The present invention provides methods of producing softwood derivatives of
native lignin
having a NRSI of 15 or greater, 20 or greater, 25 or greater, 30 or greater,
35 or greater, 40 or
greater.
The present invention provides methods of producing annual fibre derivatives
of native
lignin having a NRSI of 15 or greater, 20 or greater, 25 or greater, 30 or
greater, 35 or greater.
The present invention provides lignin derivatives comprising alkoxy groups.
For example,
the present lignin derivatives may have an alkoxy content of 2 mmol/g or less;
about 1.4 mmol/g
or less; about 1.2 mmol/g or less; about 1 mmol/g or less; about 0.8 mmol/g or
less; about 0.7
mmol/g or less; about 0.6 mmol/g or less; about 0.5 mmol/g or less; about 0.4
mmol/g or less;
about 0.3 mmol/g or less. The present lignin derivatives may have an alkoxy
content of 0.001
mmol/g or greater, about 0.01 mmol/g of greater, about 0.05 mmol/g or greater,
about 0.1
mmol/g or greater.
The present invention provides lignin derivatives comprising ethoxyl groups.
For example,
the present lignin derivatives may have an ethoxyl content of 2 mmol/g or
less; about 1.4 mmol/g
or less; about 1.2 mmol/g or less; about 1 mmol/g or less; about 0.8 mmol/g or
less; about 0.7
mmol/g or less; about 0.6 mmol/g or less; about 0.5 mmol/g or less; about 0.4
mmol/g or less;
about 0.3 mmol/g or less. The present lignin derivatives may have an ethoxyl
content of 0.001
mmol/g or greater, about 0.01 mmol/g of greater, about 0.05 mmol/g or greater,
about 0.1
mmol/g or greater.
The present lignin derivatives may have any suitable phenolic hydroxyl content
such as
from about 2 mmol/g to about 8 mmol/g. For example, the phenolic hydroxyl
content may be
from about 2.5 mmol/g to about 7 mmol/g; about 3 mmol/g to about 6 mmol/g.
The present lignin derivatives may have any suitable number average molecular
weight
(Mn). For example, the Mn may be from about 200 g/mol to about 3000 g/mol;
about 350 g/mol
to about 2000 g/mol; about 500 g/mol to about 1500 g/mol.
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 18 -
The present lignin derivatives may have any suitable weight average molecular
weight (Mw).
For example, the Mw may be from about 500 g/mol to about 5000 g/mol; about 750
g/mol to
about 4000 g/mol; about 900 g/mol to about 3500 g/mol.
The present lignin derivatives may have any suitable polydispersity (D). For
example, the D
may be from about 1 to about 5; from about 1.2 to about 4; from about 1.3 to
about 3.5; from
about 1.4 to about 3.
The present lignin derivatives are preferably hydrophobic. Hydrophobicity may
be assessed
using contact angle measurements.
It has been suggested that lignins or lignin derivatives may be used in
nutritional
supplements (e.g. Baurhoo et. al., Purified Lignin: Nutritional and Health
Impacts on Farm
Animals ¨ A Review, Animal Feed Science and Technology 144 (2008) 175-184).
The present
derivatives of native lignin may be used in nutritional supplements,
nutraceuticals, functional
foods, and the like. The stable and consistent antioxidant activity may be
advantageous when
formulating such compositions.
The present derivatives of native lignin may be used for other purposes such
as, for
example, laminates, stains, pigments, inks, adhesives, coatings, rubbers,
elastomers, plastics, films,
paints, carbon fibre composites, panel boards, print-circuit boards,
lubricants, surfactants, oils,
animal feed, food and beverages, and the like.
EXAMPLES
a0 EXAMPLE 1
Recovery of lignin derivatives from hardwood feedstocks
Hardwood feedstock chips were prepared from: (1) aspen (P. tremuloides) grown
in British
Columbia, Canada; (2) acacia (A dealbata) grown in Chile; and (3) eucalyptus
(E. nitens) grown in
Chile. Five samples of the aspen chips were individually pulped using an acid-
catalyzed ethanol
15 organosolv pulping process wherein a different set of pulping conditions
was used for each sample
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 19 -
(Table 1). Process conditions for pulping four samples of the acacia chips are
shown in Table 2.
Process conditions for pulping four samples of the eucalyptus chips are shown
in Table 3.
Table 1: Pulping conditions for aspen wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-to-wood
ratio.
Acid .
Sample pH
% on Time Temperature Ethanol PL OA ,
# nun C % wt.
wood
1 2.03 1.60 104 197 68 61.4
2 1.96 2.50 42 176 51 68.7
3 2.29 0.50 115 201 73 60.1
4 2.34 0.70 44 174 68 51.3
2.10 1.10 21 166 46 38.5
*PL - precipitated lignin yield expressed as a percent of native lignin in
wood
5 Table 2: Pulping conditions for acacia wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-to-
wood ratio.
Acid .
Sample Time Temperature Ethanol PL
pH % on .
# mm C % wt. 0/0
wood
1 2.01 1.61 104 197 68 67.9
2 2.00 1.51 67 194 58 66.2
3 1.96 1.40 33 181 44 51.1
4 2.35 0.60 50 205 45 51.2
Table 3: Pulping conditions for eucalyptus wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-to-
wood ratio.
Acid .
Sample Time Temperature Ethanol PL
pH /0 on .
# nun 0C % wt. %
wood
1 1.88 1.61 104 197 68 81.7
2 2.10 0.90 83 189 64 69.4
3 1.77 2.41 30 170 59 61.6
4 2.30 0.61 87 183 54 65.6
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 20 -
For each wood chips sample, the ethanol pulping solvent was prepared to the
specified
concentration by first, partially diluting the ethanol with water after which,
a suitable amount of
sulphuric acid was added to achieve the target final acidity. Finally, the
ethanol solution was further
diluted with water to achieve the target ethanol concentration.
The original lignin content of each fibrous biomass subsample was determined
using the
methods described in National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Technical
Report entitled
"Determination of Structural Carbohydrates and Lignin in Biomass" - Laboratory
Analytical
Procedure (EP-510-42618 (25 April 2008)). Then, after adding the fibrous
biomass sample to a
pressure vessel (2L or 7 L Parr reactor (Parr Instrument Company, Moline, IL,
USA)) (100-700 g
odw chips), the pH-adjusted ethanol-based pulping solvent was added to the
vessel at a 6:1
liquor:wood ratio & the pH recorded. The vessel was then pressurized and
brought up to the target
temperature listed in Tables 1-3 (aspen, acacia, eucalyptus, respectively).
The biomass sample was
then "cooked" for the specified period of time, after which, the pulping
process was stopped.
After pulping, the contents of the pressure vessel were transferred to a
hydraulic 20 ton manual
shop press (Airco, China). The liquor was separated from the solids by first
squeezing the pulped
materials in the press to express the liquor. The expressed liquor was then
filtered through a coarse
silk screen to separate expressed chip residues from liquor stream. Next, fine
particles were
separated out from the liquor stream by filtration through fine filter paper
(Whatrnan N 1). The
recovered fine particles represent lignin derivatives that were extracted and
self-precipitated out
from the liquor during cooling of the pulped biomass. The particulate lignin
is herein referred to as
self-precipitated lignin derivatives (i.e., "SPL"). The solubilized lignin
derivatives still remaining in
the filtered liquor were precipitated from by dilution with cold water. The
lignin derivatives
precipitated by dilution with cold water are referred to as precipitated
lignin or "PL". After
determination of the dry weights of SPL and PL lignin derivatives, the
relative yield of each lignin
derivative was determined in reference to total native lignin (sum of the acid-
insoluble lignin and
acid-soluble lignin) value determined for the original biomass sample before
pulping. The yield of
PL lignin derivatives for each sample is shown in Tables 1-3 on a weight %
basis relative to their
original lignin (acid-insoluble lignin plus acid-soluble lignin values).
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 21 -
Characterization of the aliphatic hydroxyl content of lignin derivatives
recovered
from three hardwood species.
Functionalized lignin derivatives recovered from hardwood biomass samples as
described
above, were analyzed to determine the content of primary hydroxyl groups
mmol/g sample (OH-
pr mmol/g) and content of secondary hydroxyl groups mmol/g sample (OH-sec
mmol/g). These
values were then used to calculate mmol aliphatic hydroxyl groups/g sample (OH-
al mmol/g).
The hydroxyl contents were determined by quantitative 13C NMR spectroscopy on
a
Bruker 600 MHz spectrometer equipped with a cryoprobe at 300 K using ca 30%
solutions of
sample in DMSO-d,. Chemical shifts were referenced to TMS (0.0 ppm). To ensure
more accurate
baseline, especially in the carbonyl region (215-185 ppm), the spectra were
recorded in the interval
240+40) ppm. The following conditions were provided for the quantitative 13C-
NMR:
1. Inverse gate detection;
2. a 90 pulse;
3. Complete relaxation of all nuclei was achieved by addition of chromium
(III)
acetylacetonate (0.01 M) and using a 1.2 s acquisition time and 1.7 s
relaxation delay
acquisition parameters.
The NMR spectra were Fourier-transformed, phased, calibrated using TMS signals
as a
reference (0 ppm), and the baseline was corrected by using a polynomial
function. The correction
of baseline was done using the following interval references to be adjusted to
zero: (220-215 ppm)-
(185-182 ppm)-(97-92 ppm)-(5-(-20) ppm). No other regions were forced to 0.
The signals in the
quantitative 13C NMR spectra were assigned on the basis of 2D HSQC spectra
(Figure 1) and a
known database. The spectra were integrated then using the area of the
internal standard (IS),
trioxane, as the reference. Each spectrum was processed (as described) at
least twice to ensure
good reproducibility of the quantification. Some carboxyl and ester groups
resonate in the
resonance region of hydroxyl groups (171.5-166.5 ppm) in the spectra of
acetylated lignins. The
amounts of carboxyl and ester groups resonated in the interval of 171.5-166.5
ppm were
determined from the spectra of non-acetylated lignins. The corrected content
of hydroxyl groups
was obtained then by deduction of the amounts of the carboxyl and ester groups
from the
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 22 -
corresponding resonances of hydroxyl groups (Table 4). The calculation of the
quantity of the
specific moieties was done as follows:
For non-acetylated lignins: X (mmol/g lignin) = Ix*mis/(30tnug*I,$)*1000
For acetylated lignins: X (mmol/g lignin) = Ix*illis/(30/11Lig*Iis ¨
42*Iontotal mu)*1000
Where X was the amount of the specific moiety; Ix, Is and Iolitota, were the
resonance values
of the specific moiety (Table 4), the internal standard and total OH groups,
correspondingly; mug
and mu are the masses of the lignin and internal standard.
Figure 1 shows the HSQC spectrum of non-acetylated hardwood lignin derivatives
(arrows
indicate the signals corresponding to the ethoxyl groups).
The recorded 13C NMR spectroscopic data are processed and graphically
illustrated as
shown in Fig. 2 and 3.
Table 4:
Symbol Ix in Calculation Equation Analytical Method
Resonance at 171.5-169.7 ppm in the
OH-pr
quantitative 13C NMR spectra of acetylated
Quantitative 13C High Resolution NMR of
lignins minus resonance at 171.5-169.7
mmol/g lignin using 1,3,5-trioxane as internal reference
ppm in the quantitative 13C NMR spectra
of non-acetylated lignins
Resonance at 169.7-169.2 ppm in the
quantitative 13C NMR. spectra of acetylated
OH-sec Quantitative 13C High Resolution NMR. of
lignins minus resonance at 169.7-169.2
mmol/g ppm in the quantitative 13C NMR spectra lignin using 1,3,5-trioxane
as internal reference
of non-acetylated lignins
Resonance at 171.5-165.0 ppm in the
OH- quantitative 13C NMR spectra of acetylated
total lignins minus resonance at 171.5-166.5 Quantitative 13C High
Resolution NMR of
lignin using 1,3,5-trioxane as internal reference
mmol/g ppm in the quantitative 13C NMR spectra
of non-acetylated lignins
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 23 -
OH-al
OH-al = OH-pr + OH-sec
mmol/g
Resonance at 16.0-14.5 ppm in the
Quantitative 13C High Resolution NMR of
OEt quantitative 13C NMR spectra (both in
lignin using 1,3,5-trioxane as internal reference
mmol/g acetylated and non-acetylated lignins,
combined with 2D HSQC
calculated as average)
The aliphatic hydroxyl contents of the PL lignin derivatives from each of the
five samples
of aspen chips are shown in Table 5. The contents ranged from 0.58 mmol/g in
sample 1 to 2.21
mmol/g in sample 5.
Table 5: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index of
PL lignins
recovered from aspen wood chips.
Run # OH-pr OH-sec OH_al NRSI
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 0.58 0.00 0.58 94.13
2 0.87 0.11 0.98 89.64
3 1.00 0.38 1.38 67.67
4 1.24 0.54 1.78 56.62
5 1.44 0.78 2.21 61.98
The aliphatic hydroxyl contents of the PL lignin derivatives from each of the
four samples
of acacia chips are shown in Table 6. The contents ranged from 0.76 mmol/g in
sample 1 to 2.31
rnmol/g in sample 4.
Table 6: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index of
PL lignins
recovered from acacia wood chips.
Run # OH-pr OH-sec OH_al NRSI
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 0.76 0.00 0.76 121.76
2 1.08 0.38 1.46 94.91
3 1.32 0.75 2.07 75.57
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 24 -
4 1.48 0.83 2.31 80.44
The aliphatic hydroxyl contents of the PL lignin derivatives from each of the
four samples
of eucalyptus chips are shown in Table 7. The contents ranged from 0.76 mmol/g
in sample 1 to
2.31 mmol/g in sample 4.
Table 7: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index of
PL lignins
recovered from E.nitens wood chips.
OH-pr OH-sec OH -al NRSI
Run #
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 0.57 0.13 0.70 109.65
2 0.76 0.69 1.46 91.16
3 1.11 0.72 1.83 77.43
4 1.20 1.07 2.27 75.58
Characterization of the NRSI of lignin derivatives recovered from three
hardwood species.
The lignin derivatives samples produced above were assessed for their
normalized radical
scavenging index (NRSI). The potential antioxidant activity of each PL lignin
derivative was
determined by measuring its radical savaging capacity. The assay used 2,2-
dipheny1-1-picrylhydrazyl
(DPPH), a stabile free radical which absorbs light strongly at 515 urn to
measure a compound's
radical scavenging index (RSI). In its radical form, DPPH. absorbs strongly at
515 nm and has a
deep purple colour. As DPPH gives up its free electron to radical scavengers,
it loses its purple
colour and its absorbance shifts to 520 nm. The greater the drop in DPPH
absorbance at 515 nm
after a test compound has been added to the DPPH solution, the higher the
compound's free RSI
and also, its antioxidant activity. In the present study, Vit. E and BHT were
used as positive
controls. PL lignin derivative subsamples (1.0 - 2.0 mg), Vit. E control
samples (1.0 - 2.0 mg), and
BHT control samples (6.0 - 8.0 mg) were prepared for testing by being placed
into epitubes after
which, each was diluted with 1.0 mL of 90% (v/v) aqueous dioxan, vortexed,
transferred to new
epitubes and then further diluted 50/50 with 90% aqueous dioxane to give stock
concentrations of
0.5-1.0 mg/mL for samples and Vitamin E and 3.0-4.0 mg/mL for BHT. An
indicating (purple)
CA 02798158 2016-12-08
- 25 -
DPPH stable free radical solution is made by dissolving 3.78 mg DPPH in 100 mL
90% dioxane
(95.9 p.M). Samples and standards are serial diluted to fill columns of a
quartz 96-well plate (8
dilutions). The assays were performed by placing aliquots of the sample stock
solutions into two
rows of wells in a 96-well plate. The first row served as the reference row
while the second row
received DPPH aliquots. 165 pi of 90% dioxane was added to each well and
mixed. Aliquots of
the mixed samples in each row were transferred to the adjacent row and further
diluted with 165
p.L of 90% dioxane in each well. The mixing, transferring and dilution were
repeated until the last
row of wells is prepared. The same volume of aliquots was removed from the
last row. The 96-well
plate also contained a row of wells that received only the 90% dioxane. In the
final step of the
preparation procedure, 165 uL of the DPPH solution was added to all the
control and analytical
columns by using an 8-channel auto-pipette and an Eppendorft reagent reservoir
as quickly as
possible. As soon as all reagents are added, the plate is placed into a plate-
reading
spectrophotometer (Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA, USA, Spectra Max Phi?),
and absorbance
measurements are commenced. The program for the spectrophotometer (SOHMax
software)
consisted of a timing sequence of 16 min and a reading of the entire plate at
515 mu. RSI (radical
scavenging index) is defined as the inverse of the concentration which that
produced 50%
inhibition in DPPH absorbance at 515 mu. The results were then 'normalized'
(NRSI) by dividing
the sample RSI by the RSI value for the BHT control.
The NRSI values for lignin derivatives recovered from aspen wood chips are
shown in
Table 5. The NRSI values for lignin derivatives recovered from acacia wood
chips are shown in
Table 6. The NRSI values for lignin derivatives recovered from eucalyptus wood
chips are shown
in Table 7.
EXAMPLE 2
Recovery of lignin derivatives from softwood feedstocks
Softwood feedstock chips were prepared from: (1) hybrid spruce trees grown in
British
Columbia, (2) radiata pine grown in Chile, and (3) loblolly pine grown in
south eastern USA. Three
samples of the hybrid spruce wood chips were individually pulped using an acid-
catalyzed ethanol
pulping process wherein a different set of pulping conditions was used for
each sample (Table 8).
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804 PCT/CA2010/000205
- 26 -
Process conditions for pulping three samples of the radiata pine chips are
shown in Table 9.
Process conditions for pulping three samples of the loblolly pine chips are
shown in Table 10.
Table 8: Pulping conditions for hybrid spruce wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-
to-wood ratio.
Acid Time Temperature Ethanol PL
Run # pH cyo min C 0/0 0/0
1 2.02 1.20 58 191 46 44.84
2 2.08 1.40 43 189 61 67.77
3 2.09 1.60 50 183 77 72.10
Table 9: Pulping conditions for radiata pine wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-
to-wood ratio.
Acid Time Temperature Ethanol PL
Run # pH
% min C %%
1 2.04 1.20 58 191 46 34.21
2 2.12 1.40 43 189 61 65.40
3 1.92 1.80 46 187 49 42.72
Table 10: Pulping conditions for loblolly pine wood chip samples at 6:1 liquor-
to-wood ratio.
Acid Time Temperature Ethanol PL
Run # pH %min C 0/0 %
1 2.05 1.20 33 192 82 65.1
2 2.01 1.40 43 189 61 63.3
3 1.80 1.80 46 187 49 42.3
For each wood chips sample, the ethanol pulping solvent was prepared to the
specified
concentration by first, partially diluting the ethanol with water after which,
a suitable amount of
sulphuric acid was added to achieve the target final acidity. Finally, the
ethanol solution was further
diluted with water to achieve the target ethanol concentration.
The lignin content of each original fibrous biomass subsample was determined
using the
NREL method (NREL/TP-510-42618 (April 2008)). Then, after adding the fibrous
biomass
CA 02798158 2016-12-08
- 27 -
sample to a pressure vessel (2L or 7 L Parr reactor (Parr Instrument Company,
Moline, IL, USA)
(100-700 g odw chips), the pH-adjusted ethanol-based pulping solvent was added
to the vessel at a
6:1 liquor:wood ratio St the pH recorded. The vessel was then pressurized and
brought up to the
target temperature listed in Tables 8-10 (spruce, radiata pine, loblolly pine,
respectively). The
biomass sample was then "cooked" for the specified period of time, after
which, the pulping
process was stopped. After pulping, the contents of pressure vessel were
transferred to a hydraulic
20 ton manual shop press (Airco, China). The liquor was separated from the
solids by first
squeezing the pulped materials in the press to express the liquor. The
expressed liquor was then
filtered through a coarse silk screen to separate expressed chip residues from
liquor stream. Next,
fine particles were separated out from the liquor stream by filtration through
fine filter paper
(Whatman N 1). The recovered fine particles represent lignin derivatives that
were extracted and
self-precipitated out from the liquor during cooling of the pulped biomass.
The particulate lignin is
herein referred to as self-precipitated lignin derivatives (i.e., "SPL"). The
solubili7ed lignin
derivatives still remaining in the filtered liquor were precipitated from by
dilution with cold water.
The lignin derivatives precipitated by dilution with cold water are referred
to as precipitated lignin
or "PL". After determination of the dry weights of SPL and PL lignin
derivatives, the relative yield
of each lignin derivative was determined in reference to the total lignin
content (acid-insoluble plus
the acid-soluble lignin) determined for the original biomass sample before
pulping. The yield of PL
lignin derivatives for each sample is shown in Tables 8-10 on a weight % basis
relative to total
lignin in the original biomass.
Characterization of the aliphatic hydroxyl content
Functionalized lignin derivatives recovered from hardwood biomass samples as
described
above, were analyzed using the procedures described in Example 1 to determine
the weights of
primary hydroxyl groups inmol/g sample (OH-pr mtnol/g) and weights of
secondary hydroxyl
groups mmol /g sample (OH-sec nunol/g). These values were then used to
calculate the total
mmol aliphatic hydroxyl groups/g sample (OH-al mmol/g).
The aliphatic contents of the PL lignin derivatives from each of the three
samples of hybrid
spruce chips are shown in Table 11. The contents ranged from 1.72 nunolig in
sample 1 to 2.24
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 28 -
mmol/g in sample 3. The aliphatic contents of the PL lignin derivatives from
each of the three
samples of radiata pine chips are shown in Table 12. The contents ranged from
2.18 mmol/g in
sample 1 to 2.26 mmol/g in sample 3. The aliphatic contents of the PL lignin
derivatives from
each of the three samples of loblolly pine chips are shown in Table 13. The
contents ranged from
1.35 mmol/g in sample 1 to 1.87 mmol/g in sample 3.
Table 11: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index
of PL lignins
recovered from hybrid spruce wood chips.
OH-pr OH-sec OH-al NRSI
Run #
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 1.57 0.14 1.72 61.60
2 1.67 0.29 1.96 46.82
3 1.74 0.28 2.02 40.66
Table 12: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index
of PL lignins
recovered from racliata pine wood chips.
OH-pr OH-sec OH-al NRSI
Run #
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 1.74 0.44 2.18 64.24
2 1.79 0.43 2.22 35.28
3 1.90 0.35 2.26 37.44
Table 13: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index
of PL lignins
recovered from loblolly pine wood chips.
OH-pr OH-sec OH-al NRSI
Run #
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 1.16 0.19 1.35 48.73
2 1.55 0.03 1.58 46.95
3 1.74 0.13 1.87 53.44
Characterization of the NRSI of lignin derivatives
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 29 -
Each of the lignin derivatives samples produced above were assessed for their
normalized
radical scavenging index (NRSI) as described in Example 1. The NRSI values for
lignin derivatives
recovered from hybrid spruce wood chips are shown in Table 11. The NRSI values
for lignin
derivatives recovered from radiata pine wood chips are shown in Table 12. The
NRSI values for
lignin derivatives recovered from loblolly pine wood chips are shown in Table
13.
EXAMPLE 3
Recovery of fignin derivatives from annual fibre feedstocks.
Two sets of annual fibre feedstock materials were prepared from: (1) bagasse
produced
from sugarcane grown and processed in Brazil, and (2) corn cobs produced in
Europe. Four
samples of the sugarcane bagasse were individually pulped using an acid-
catalyzed ethanol pulping
process based wherein a different set of pulping conditions was used for each
sample (Table 14).
Process conditions for pulping four samples of shredded corn cob material are
shown in Table 15.
Table 14: Pulping conditions for sugarcane bagasse samples at 6:1 liquor-to-
wood ratio.
Acid Time Temperature Ethanol PL
Run pH
% min C % %
1 2.19 2.50 61 178 66 49.76
2 2.01 3.00 23 170 66 39.56
3 2.44 1.00 50 192 43 37.36
4 2.19 2.00 54 164 58 44.95
Table 15: Pulping conditions for corn cob samples at 6:1 liquor-to-wood ratio.
Acid Time Temperature Ethanol PL
Run PH 0/0 min C 0/0 cyo
1 2.18 2.20 100 190 67 56.58
2 2.10 2.10 67 189 51 52.01
3 2.04 2.90 32 187 69 45.27
4 2.17 1.20 99 183 54 50.71
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 30 -
For each biomass sample, the ethanol pulping solvent was prepared to the
specified
concentration by first, partially diluting the ethanol with water after which,
a suitable amount of
sulphuric acid was added to achieve the target final acidity. Finally, the
ethanol solution was further
diluted with water to achieve the target ethanol concentration.
The original lignin content of each fibrous biomass subsarnple was determined
using the
NREL method (NREL/TP-510-42618 (April 2008)). Then, after adding the fibrous
biomass
sample to a pressure vessel (2L or 7L Parr reactor (Parr Instrument Company,
Moline, IL, USA)
(100-700 g odw chips), the pH-adjusted ethanol-based pulping solvent was added
to the vessel at a
6:1 liquor:biomass ratio & the pH recorded. The vessel was then pressurized
and brought up to the
target temperature listed in Tables 14-15 (bagasse, corncobs, respectively).
The biomass sample
was then "cooked" for the specified period of time, after which, the pulping
process was stopped.
After pulping, the contents of pressure vessel were transferred to a hydraulic
20 ton manual shop
press (Aicro, China). The liquor was separated from the solids by first
squeezing the pulped
materials in the press to express the liquor. The expressed liquor was then
filtered through a coarse
silk screen to separate expressed chip residues from liquor stream. Next, fine
particles were
separated out from the liquor stream by filtration through fine filter paper
(Whatrnan N 1). The
recovered fine particles represent lignin derivatives that were extracted and
self-precipitated out
from the liquor during cooling of the pulped biomass. The particulate lignin
is herein referred to as
self-precipitated lignin derivatives (i.e., "SPL"). The solubilized lignin
derivatives still remaining in
the filtered liquor were precipitated from by dilution with cold water. The
lignin derivatives
precipitated by dilution with cold water are referred to as precipitated
lignin or "PL". After
determination of the dry weights of SPL and PL lignin derivatives, the
relative yield of each lignin
derivative was determined in reference to the total lignin (sum of acid-
insoluble lignin plus acid-
soluble lignin) value determined for the original biomass sample before
pulping. The yield of PL
lignin derivatives for each sample is shown in Tables 14-15 on a weight A
basis relative to their
original total lignin values.
Characterization of the aliphatic hydroxyl content
Functionalized lignin derivatives recovered from annual fibre biomass samples
as described
above, were analyzed using the procedures described in Example 1 to determine
the primary
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804
PCT/CA2010/000205
- 31 -
hydroxyl groups mmol/g per sample (OH-pr mmol/g) and the secondary hydroxyl
groups mmol
/g sample (OH-sec mmol/g). These values were then used to calculate total mmol
aliphatic
hydroxyl groups/g sample (OH-al mmol/g).
The aliphatic content of the PL lignin derivatives from each of the four
samples of
sugarcane bagasse biomass are shown in Table 16. The content ranged from 1.74
mmol/g in
sample 1 to 2.34 mmol/g in sample 4. The aliphatic content of the PL lignin
derivatives from each
of the three samples of shredded corn cobs are shown in Table 17. The content
ranged from 2.18
mmol/g in sample 1 to 2.26 mmol/g in sample 4.
Characterization of the NRSI of lignin derivatives
Each of the lignin derivatives samples produced above were assessed for their
normalized
radical scavenging index (NRSI) as described in Example 1. The NRSI values for
lignin derivatives
recovered from sugarcane bagasse biomass are shown in Table 16. The NRSI
values for lignin
derivatives recovered from corn cob biomass are shown in Table 17.
Table 16: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and normalized radical scavenging index
of PL lignins
recovered from sugarcane bagasse biomass.
OH-pr OH-sec OH-al NRSI
Run
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 1.02 0.73 1.74 52.34
2 1.19 0.89 2.09 41.80
3 1.02 1.17 2.20 46.90
4 1.31 1.02 2.34 38.74
CA 02798158 2012-11-01
WO 2010/135804 PCT/CA2010/000205
- 32 -
Table 17: Aliphatic hydroxyl content and radical scavenging index of PL
lignins recovered from
corn cobs biomass.
OH-pr OH-sec OH-al NRSI
Run
mmol/g mmol/g mmol/g
1 0.95 0.63 1.58 45.15
2 0.64 1.22 1.86 45.99
3 0.74 1.42 2.16 38.37
4 1.24 1.11 2.35 48.99
