Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
Generating power using an Ion Transport Membrane
This application claims the benefit of priority to U.S. Provisional
Application
Serial No. 61/392,413 filed October 12, 2010. The entire contents of the
aforementioned related application are incorporated by reference herein.
TECHNICAL FIELD
This invention relates to the simultaneous production of power and pure
oxygen and, more particularly, to integrating an oxygen ion transport membrane
with
a gas turbine.
1
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
BACKGROUND
Hydrocarbon and carbonaceous feedstock can be converted into H2 and CO
synthesis gas mixtures with varying ratios of H2 to CO. Feedstock may include
coals,
natural gas, oil fractions, bitumen and tar-like refinery wastes, pet-coke and
various
forms of biomass. The synthesis gas mixtures can be converted into valuable
hydrocarbons and chemicals using catalytic processes. The synthesis gas can
also be
converted to H2 by reaction of the CO component with steam over a catalyst
followed
by CO2 removal to produce a fuel gas which can be burned in a gas turbine
combined
cycle power production system resulting in power production with CO2 capture.
The
conversion of synthesis gas to valuable hydrocarbon and chemical products
generally
requires a large additional amount of power to be provided to the process and
this can
be produced from a gas turbine system. The conversion of these fuels to
synthesis
generally requires large volumes of oxygen which is typically used in a
partial
oxidation of the feedstock. This oxygen can be produced in a high temperature
oxygen ion transport membrane system which separates oxygen from a high
pressure
high temperature air stream by diffusion from a region of high oxygen partial
pressure
to low oxygen partial pressure. The source of the high pressure high
temperature air
stream can be the compressed air stream produced in a gas turbine. It is the
objective
of this invention to disclose a method of integrating an oxygen ion transport
membrane with a gas turbine using a hydrogen rich carbon depleted fuel gas to
produce simultaneously power and pure oxygen with high efficiency. It is
apparent
that the integration of ITM 02 production modules with existing unmodified gas
turbines requires an external air compressor supplying part or all of the air
flow
required for 02 production.
It is the objective of this invention to propose a system which will allow all
the fuel gas combustion heat used for air preheating to be recovered at the
gas turbine
combustion heat input level so that recovered heat can produce electrical
power at
55% to 60% net efficiency.
It is a further objective of this invention that the fuel gas is effectively
diluted
with a nitrogen rich diluent and supplied at a temperature below 500 c without
loss of
efficiency caused by transferring heat to the steam system.
2
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
It is a further objective of this invention to ensure that the oxygen content
of
the diluent stream is reduced to a concentration at the ITM exit which will
never give
any safety hazard when diluent and H2 or (H2+CO) fuel gas at elevated
temperature
are mixed.
It is a further objective of this invention that the mixture of H2 or (H2+CO)
fuel gas and diluent is within the necessary LHV value for satisfactory
combustion in
a gas turbine. The range would be for LHV values to be greater than about 120
Btu/scf and that the diluted fuel gas mixture would be at the maximum
temperature
allowed by the gas turbine vendor.
.. Previous methods for optimizing the integration of a gas turbine and an Ion
Transport
Membrane which diffuses pure oxygen from a pressurized heated feed air stream
have
been described in references 1, and 2 which all have disadvantages compared to
the
present invention as described below.
SUMMARY
In some implementations, a system can include an Ion Transport Membrane
(ITM) module which separates pure oxygen from pressurized heated air
integrated
with a gas turbine to produce oxygen. An important use for the system is
Integrated
Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) systems with or without CO2 capture to
maximize or otherwise increase system efficiency. These implementations may
enable diluent gas with less than 1 % 02 to be mixed safely with H2 and/or
(H2+CO)
fuel gas. In addition, the combination of the ITM and the gas turbine minimize
or
otherwise reduce heat energy released in the ITM system that is transferred to
the
steam system. The air feed to the ITM module may be heated indirectly so that
the
partial pressure of 02 in the air is not degraded by direct combustion in the
feed air
stream. This maximizes or otherwise increases 02 recovery and minimizes or
otherwise reduces air flow for a fixed 02 production and membrane area. Also,
some
implementations may avoid or otherwise substantially reduce possible
contamination
of the ITM membrane from the combustion products.
The details of one or more embodiments of the invention are set forth in the
accompanying drawings and the description below. Other features, objects, and
3
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
advantages of the invention will be apparent from the description and
drawings, and
from the claims.
4
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
FIGURE 1 shows the flow scheme for the process in which all the air flow to
the ITM module is taken from the discharge of the gas turbine compressor; and
FIGURE 2 shows the flow scheme for the process in which there is an external
air compressor which together with air flow taken from the discharge of the
gas
turbine air compressor provides all the air feed to the ITM module.
Like reference symbols in the various drawings indicate like elements.
5
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
In some implementations, a system may include power generation from a gas
turbine in which a carbonaceous or hydro-carbonaceous fuel is gasified using a
partial
oxidation reaction with pure 02 generated from an ITM unit. Current systems,
using
coal or petroleum coke or residual bitumen as fuel, typically employ an 02
fired
partial oxidation process to convert the carbonaceous fuel to a fuel gas
comprising
H2+CO together with feed derived impurities such as H2S and others. This fuel
gas
stream is cooled and impurities such as H2S and others are removed. The
purified
fuel gas is then mixed with nitrogen and optionally steam before being used as
fuel in
a gas turbine combined cycle power generation system. 02 used for partial
oxidation
has traditionally been generated by separating air in a cryogenic air
separation unit to
produce substantially pure 02. The described implementations uses an 02 ion
transport membrane (ITM) comprising mixed metal oxides typically in a
perovskite
crystal structure with vacancies in the 02 ion sites. These structures allow
the 02 ions
to become mobile in the crystal at high temperatures and the diffusion of 02
across
the membrane becomes possible when there is a difference in activity
coefficient
across the ITM. The ITM
membrane then operates as a short circuited
electrochemical cell. In order to operate the ITM unit it is necessary to
provide a feed
air stream at typically 800 C to 900 C with a partial pressure of oxygen of 3
to 4 bar
in order to achieve 02 separation factors of 70% or more from the feed air in
the ITM
system and produce sufficient 02 to supply the partial oxidation gasifier. The
pure 02
may diffuse through the ITM membrane and may be available at a pressure
typically
in the range 0.3 to 0.8 bar. The adiabatically compressed air leaving the gas
turbine
air compressor may be heated to a temperature in the range 800 C to 900 C by
direct
combustion of a fuel in a first combustor. The heated air then passes through
an ITM
membrane module where some of the 02 in the air is separated. The outlet 02
depleted stream still has sufficient 02 for combustion of more fuel in the
second gas
turbine combustor which raises the temperature to the design value for entry
into the
gas turbine expander.
Gas turbines are very expensive to modify and current high output, high
efficiency gas turbines, which are commercially available have limited
capability to
extract a significant proportion of air leaving the air compressor section for
external
6
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
use in an ITM system. In some implementations, the ITM air flow may be taken
not
only from the gas turbine compressor discharge up to the maximum flow
available
but also from a separate air compressor with external heating of the
compressed air
feed to the ITM unit. When burning H2+CO fuel gas, the fuel gas may be diluted
primarily with a nitrogen rich gas produced as a by-product of air separation
together
optionally with steam. This dilution may reduce the flame temperature and thus
reduces NOX formation in the combustion. It may also load the turbine to
maximize
power output. The 02 depleted non-permeate stream leaving the ITM unit may
have
excess N2 and may be effective as a diluent for the H2 or H2+CO fuel gas flow
to the
.. gas turbine burner. A typical system may have a fuel gas entering the gas
turbine
burner at a pressure in excess of the gas turbine air compressor discharge
pressure and
a composition of approximately 50% inert diluent and 50% (H2+CO) or H2 on a
molar
basis. The maximum fuel gas temperature may be limited by the design of the
gas
turbine fuel handling system and is generally below 450 C. The diluent stream
which
is the ITM non-permeate leaves the ITM module at 850 C. This stream may be
derived from an external air compressor. In general, the combined fuel gas and
diluent stream may be at a temperature below about 450 C.
In some implementations, the diluent stream may be cooled to produce high
pressure steam for the Rankine steam cycle which may be part of the combined
cycle.
The air feed stream to the ITM is heated to typically 850 C by one of two
methods:
(a) The direct combustion of fuel gas in the auxiliary air stream. This
process
may produce sufficient heat to raise the temperature of the air stream plus
combustion
products to 850 C. To illustrate this method, the following cases may be
executed:
(i) The air compressor may be isothermal with a discharge condition
of 22 bars 75 C and provide all or substantially all of the air feed to the
ITM unit with
no air feed flow from the gas turbine. In this case, about 25% of the oxygen
in the air
may be consumed in direct fuel combustion, and the air flow may have to be
increased by about 33% to compensate; and
(ii) The air compressor may be adiabatic with a discharge temperature
of 486 C and can mix with a variable quantity of similar temperature air taken
from
the gas turbine. About 14% of the 02 may be consumed for fuel combustion with
an
7
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
increased air flow of about 16%. In addition, the compressor power for the
adiabatic
machine may be 35% higher than the isothermal machine.
The second case (ii) may have a net 18% more power for compression than
case (i) but has 45% less heat generated. Based on llb mol air the extra power
0.224
kW hrs/lb mol air compressed, while the saving in heat for case (ii) is 1.27
kW. In
general, it may be more efficient to use on an adiabatic air compressor for
the external
compressor.
(b) It has been proposed that the ITM feed air can be heated from 520 C to
850 C in the heat recovery steam generator (HRSG) associated with the gas
turbine
which would require combustion of more fuel in the gas turbine exhaust to
raise its
temperature from the range 500 C-600 C to the range 900 c-1000 C to provide
the
necessary temperature driving force for heat transfer to the ITM feed air
stream. The
effect of using fuel gas for direct heating as in case a(ii) compared to
indirect heating
in the HRSG is to reduce the air flow by 14% saving about 0.174 kW/hrs/lb mol
ITM
feed air.
The method of indirect heating in the heat recovery steam generator or HRSG
may reduce the amount of compressed air flow (no combustion air may be used)
but
the whole gas turbine discharge flow may be heated from about 600 C to about
875
C. For a typical integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) system, the ITM
air
flow may be about 25% of the gas turbine air flow when direct combustion
heating is
used and the ITM module may be designed for 80% 02 recovery. The heat
transferred to the ITM air feed may be available to the power cycle at an
efficiency
(LHV) of about 60% since it produces power in the gas turbine followed by the
power
produced in the steam system. The remaining heat from the duct firing used to
raise
the temperature of the gas turbine exhaust to 875 C may only be available to
produce
power at about 40% efficiency in the Rankine steam cycle alone. This means
that duct
firing in the gas turbine exhaust entering the HRSG to allow indirect heating
of the
ITM feed air stream is a grossly inefficient use of the H2 or (H2+CO) fuel
generated
in the gasification system. A detailed analysis of the performance of the duct
fired
HRSG with indirect heating of the ITM feed air stream is given in the
examples.
In all of these cases, in order to produce the diluted fuel gas stream at
typically
450 c, heat is recovered from the non-permeate ITM stream by cooling from 850
C
8
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
and rejecting this heat into the steam system where the maximum efficiency for
the
recovered heat to produce power is typically 40% and even with supercritical
steam
conditions will not exceed 44%. For a General Electric 9FA gas turbine linked
to a
coal based GE/Texaco quench gasifier, the duct firing heat load based on a
normal
gas turbine exit temperature of 600 C would be 168 MW. The duct firing
produces a
hot gas for ITM feed air heating with a heat load requirement of 52.7 MW.
Thus, an
extra 115.2 MW of fuel gas must be consumed producing power at say 42% instead
of 60% efficiency ¨ a loss of 20.7 MW of electrical power.
The proposed prior art process uses the pressurized ITM non-permeate stream
as a diluent for the H2 or (H2+CO) fuel gas stream to reduce the combustion
temperature to minimise NOX formation and to maximise turbine flow to fully
load
the turbine. There is a very significant hazard in this proposal since it is
necessary to
ensure that there will never be any chance of an 02 concentration arising
which would
exceed the lower flammable limit for the mixture and cause an explosion. If we
take a
conservative view that the ITM 02 recovery for the direct combustion case with
a
separate adiabatic air compressor was 70% then the 02 concentration in the
proposed
diluent would be about 6% 02. This is far too high for safe operation. A level
of less
than 1% has been accepted in previous IGCC cases, where N2 from a cryogenic
ASU
is mixed with fuel gases derived from a gasifier, as the maximum 02
concentration
permissible in the diluent N2 stream
Integration of ITM 02 production modules with existing unmodified gas
turbines may include an external air compressor supplying part or all of the
air flow
for 02 production. In some implementations, the proposed system may allow all
or
substantially all of the fuel gas combustion heat used for air preheating to
be
recovered at the gas turbine combustion heat input level so that recovered
heat can
produce electrical power at 55% to 60% net efficiency. Alternatively or in
addition,
the fuel gas may be effectively diluted with a nitrogen rich diluent and
supplied at a
temperature below 500 C without loss of efficiency caused by transferring heat
to the
steam system. In addition, the oxygen content of the diluent stream may be
reduced
to a concentration at the ITM exit to reduce safety hazards when diluent and
H2 or
(H2+CO) fuel gas at elevated temperature are mixed. Also, the mixture of H2 or
(H2+CO) fuel gas and diluent may be within an LHV value for satisfactory
9
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
combustion in a gas turbine. The range may be for LHV values to be greater
than
about 120 Btu/scf and that the diluted fuel gas mixture may be at the maximum
or
otherwise an upper temperature allowed by the gas turbine vendor.
In some implementations, an ITM 02 generation system coupled to a standard
gas turbine modified to burn H2 or H2 rich fuel gas may be designed to include
or
execute one or more of the following: (1) the oxygen production may be
sufficient to
provide the 02 required for a gasifier or other process consuming 02(e.g., an
IGCC
process which converts a carbonaceous or hydro-carbonaceous fuel to H2 or a H2
rich
fuel gas with or without carbon dioxide capture and provides sufficient clean
fuel gas
to power the gas turbine); (2) the H2 fuel gas may be diluted with inert gas
to reduce
NOX level and provide sufficient fuel gas to load the gas turbine but the LHV
heating
value of the fuel gas may be above 120 Btu/scf to favour combustion; (3) all
or
substantially all of the fuel gas used for heating air to ITM operating
temperature of
typically 850 C may be used as part of the fuel gas input to the gas turbine
even in the
case when the ITM feed air stream is provided from a separate air compressor;
(4) to
maximize or otherwise increase 02 production from a given ITM feed air flow
the air
may be heated indirectly; (5) the oxygen permeate and non-permeate streams
leaving
the ITM unit may be transfer the maximum or increased quantity of heat to or
become
part of the feed streams to either the gas turbine combustor or the upstream
gasifier
and, in some cases, any high grade heat transferred to the steam system may be
minimized or otherwise reduces; (6) the maximum or upper temperature of the
diluted
H2 feed gas to the gas turbine combustor may be 450 C and the maximum or upper
02
feed gas temperature to the gasifier may be 350 C; (7) the 02 content of the
diluent to
the H2 fuel gas may be 2.5% 02 to prevent possible ignition and explosion
(e.g., 02
content below 1% molar); (8) depending on the amount of side-draw air that can
be
withdrawn from the gas turbine, an air compressor in parallel to the gas
turbine
compressor may be included to make-up air feed to the ITM module. One or more
of
these objectives may be achieved by the following ITM gas turbine integration.
The ITM module may be fed with adiabatically compressed air drawn from
the gas turbine air compressor discharge or a separate air compressor or both
together.
The gas turbine side-draw air stream which may form part or all of the air
feed to the
ITM module may be raised in pressure so that the non-permeate stream which is
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
depleted in 02 is at a sufficiently high pressure to be mixed with the gas
turbine fuel
gas stream, which passes through a regulation system and through the burner
nozzles
before mixing with the main gas turbine compressed air stream. In practice,
the
pressure may be raised in a single stage compressor by 2bar to 5bar. Air
compressed
isothermally in a separate air compressor may be heated by indirect heat
transfer with
the 02 permeate stream from the ITM module in a first stage heat exchanger
then
mixed with any side-draw air from the gas turbine compressor discharge
following
compression. The non-permeate stream leaving the ITM module may be raised to a
temperature in the range 850 C to 950 C in a directly fired combustor using
diluted
fuel gas. The total ITM feed air stream may then be heated by indirect heat
transfer
in a heat exchanger against the heated ITM non-permeate stream to raise its
temperature in a range from about 800 C to about 900 C. The ITM non-permeate
stream may be heated by direct combustion of fuel gas to raise the temperature
to a
level sufficiently high to achieve two objectives: (2) to heat the ITM inlet
air to
850 C; and (2) to achieve an exit temperature from the air pre-heater for the
non-
permeate stream to ensure that when all or part of this stream is used as
diluent for the
fuel gas, which is close to ambient temperature the resulting mixed
temperature is at
450 C. By partially removing 02 from the non-permeate stream by oxidising fuel
gas
in the combustor, the resultant 02 concentration may be kept below 2.5% 02
(e.g.,
below 1% molar).
There may be an excess of non-permeate gas which is not needed or otherwise
used for fuel gas dilution. This may be reduced in pressure and added to the
gas
turbine air compressor discharge or injected into the mixing section of the
gas turbine
combustors. Optionally, the two heat exchangers may be in parallel rather than
in
series. In a parallel arrangement the oxygen permeate stream which is at sub-
atmospheric pressure, typically about 0.3 to 0.8 bar, may be passed through a
heat
exchanger which heats part of the air feed to the ITM unit. In a typical
application,
part of the ITM feed air may be heated to 820 C against 02 at 850 C and the
parallel
heat exchanger may heat the remaining ITM air feed stream against heated non-
permeate stream to a higher temperature than 850 C so that total air stream
after
mixing was at about 850 C. The low pressure 02 stream may then pass into a
second
heat exchanger which heats the compressed 02 feed for the gasifier to about
350 C.
11
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
The system shown in Fig 1 uses a gas turbine 1 coupled to an electric
generator 2 which is also coupled to a steam turbine 3. The steam is generated
in a
heat recovery steam generator 4 which includes boiler feed-water treatment and
pumps and which is heated by the gas turbine exhaust stream 5. Part of the air
which
has been adiabatically compressed in the gas turbine compressor section 6 at
18bar is
compressed to 22bar in compressor 7. The air stream is heated in the parallel
heat
exchangers 8 and 9 to form a mixed steam 10 with a temperature of 850 C. The
air
enters an ITM module 11 where an oxygen stream 12 is separated at a pressure
of, for
example, 0.6bar leaving a non-permeate stream 13. A fuel gas stream 14 is
divided
into two streams. One stream 15 is the fuel for the gas turbine combustor 16
and the
second stream 17 is the fuel for a combustor 18 in which the non-permeate
stream 13
is heated to 1380 C and leaves as stream 19 with an oxygen content of, for
example,
1% molar. The oxygen permeate stream cools to 500 C in heat exchanger 9 and
the
non-permeate stream cools to 860 C. The oxygen stream 20 leaving 9 is cooled
in
heat exchanger 21 where it heats the product oxygen stream 22 at 65bar to 350
C. The
intercooled compressor 23 raises the oxygen pressure from 0.35bar to 65bar.
The non-
permeate stream 29 leaving 9 is cooled in heat exchanger 24 to a temperature
at which
part 25 can be mixed with the fuel gas stream 15 to give 50% fuel gas +50%
diluent
fuel gas stream which is at a mixed temperature which is below a maximum or
predefined fuel stream inlet temperature specified by the gas turbine vendor
which in
this case is 450 C. The remaining non-permeate stream 26 is mixed with the
inlet gas
stream to the gas turbine compressor section 27. Steam can be generated and/or
superheated in heat exchanger 24 to increase the power produced in the steam
turbine
3. Note that in order to simultaneously achieve the required temperature and
composition of the mixed fuel gas stream 28 which is entering the gas turbine
combustor 16, the stream 29 can be divided so that part 30 bypasses the heat
exchanger 24.
The system shown in Fig 2 is very similar to the system shown in Fig 1 with
the addition of an external intercooled air compressor 34 which produces half
of the
total ITM feed air flow 10 as stream 35 at a pressure 0.5bar higher than the
pressure
of the gas turbine air side-draw flow leaving the compressor 7 and at a
temperature of
75 C. Stream 35 is heated to 192 C in heat exchanger 9 which cools the oxygen
12
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
permeate stream 12 at 0.6bar from the ITM module 11 to 500 C from 850 C. The
oxygen stream 20 leaving heat exchanger 9 is used in heat exchanger 21 to heat
the
compressed oxygen stream at 65bar from the compressor 23 to a temperature of
350 C. The externally compressed air stream 36 leaving heat exchanger 9 is
heated to
about 500 C in heat exchanger 8 and at this point it is mixed with the gas
turbine side-
draw air stream which is also at about 500 C. The mixed total air feed stream
is then
heated to 850 C. The heating medium in heat exchanger 8 is as before the
heated non-
permeate stream from the ITM module. The remaining parts of the system are
identical to those shown in Fig 1.
An approximate scaling exercise REF 3 is based on published data for
Pittsburg No 8 coal used in an IGCC system with carbon monoxide sour shift
reactors
and 75% CO2 capture. The system may use GE 9FA gas turbines, cryogenic 02
production and a Texaco quench gasifier with CO2 capture. Fuel gas dilution
may be
with steam and some CO2. The base case performance follows:
Gross power (gasturbine+steam turbine+expansion turbine) = 481Mw
Cryogenic ASU power = 47.7Mw
Internal power consumption = 14.1Mw
Net power output = 419.2Mw
Net efficiency(LHV) _ 39%
Using the system described above with an ITM module and an oxygen compressor
in
place of the cryogenic oxygen plant may give the following results:
1. All ITM air taken from the gas turbine air compressor outlet
Net Power = 466.6Mw
Net Efficiency = 40.52%
2. Half ITM air from the gas turbine and half from a separate air compressor
Net power = 462.3Mw
Net efficiency = 41.37%
13
CA 02813957 2013-04-05
WO 2012/051315
PCT/US2011/055983
3. All ITM air taken from a separate air compressor
Net power = 448.4Mw
Net efficiency = 41.2%.
A number of embodiments of the invention have been described.
Nevertheless, it will be understood that various modifications may be made
without
departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. For example, an
approximate
scaling exercise based on published data for coal IGCC using 9FA gas turbines,
cryo
02 and a Texaco quench gasifier with CO2 capture showed an efficiency increase
(LHV basis) from 39% to 41.65% with a power output increase of 6.8%.
Accordingly, other embodiments are within the scope of the following claims.
14
