Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
EXP-8-CANAD
GRIPPER FOR TEST AND ISOLATION PLUGS
BACKGROUND
[0001] The present invention relates to plugs for gripping and forming fluid-
tight seals with inner or outer peripheries of pipes, pipelines, tubes,
pressure vessels and
the like adjacent open ends thereof More specifically, the present invention
relates to
components of plugs enabling the plug to grip and/or bite into the inner or
outer diameter
of pipe or tube walls and/or to withstand differential pressure across the
seal created by
the plug. For purposes of example, the plugs may include hydrostatic test
plugs, vacuum
test plugs or the like for use in pressure testing pipes, pipelines, tubes,
pressure vessels,
pressure retaining components, and the like and isolation plugs for use in
isolating
segments of pipes and tubes for any reason such as painting or the like, for
forming night
caps, for hydrostatically testing weld joints of welded flange-to-pipe
connections, and for
isolating pipe or tube ends during cutting, grinding and/or welding
operations.
100021 It is often required to perform leak tests or verify structural
integrity or
strength of pipes, pipelines, tubes, pressure vessels, flange-to-pipe
connections, pipe-to-
pipe connections, and the like. It may also be necessary to isolate the open
end of a pipe
from vapors that may be contained within the pipe when performing operations
adjacent
the end of the pipe, such as adding a flange or making some other pipe
connection. For
example, a pipe may need to be temporarily sealed adjacent to an open end
thereof and
1
CA 2874623 2017-06-16
pressurized with a fluid such as gas, including air or nitrogen, or a liquid
such as a
hydraulic fluid. Depending upon the material and thickness of the pipe, the
pipe may be
pressure rated, and a test or isolation plug used to form one or more seals
adjacent an
open end of the pipe must be able to withstand at least the pressure rating of
the pipe and
must be able to resist movement, sliding, failure, blow-out and/or leakage
during such
working pressures.
[0003] High-pressure test and isolation plugs may include components
configured to be urged radially outward into engagement with an inner
peripheral wall of
a pipe or tube or radially inward into engagement with an outer peripheral
wall of a pipe
or tube. A gripping function is required to enable the plug to resist
movement, sliding,
failure, blow-out and/or leakage during testing at working pressures. Any
movement of
the plug or its gripping components relative to the sealed pipe must be
avoided,
particularly when testing at high pressures.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0003a] In a broad aspect of the invention, a gripper for a test or isolation
plug is
provided that includes a gripper segment having a pipe or tube confronting
surface with at
least three separate circumferentially-extending rows of gripper teeth
longitudinally-
spaced apart on the surface. Each of the separate rows of gripper teeth
include an
alternating array of individual tips and gaps such that each row is serrated,
where each of
the individual tips have a truncated oblique pyramidal shape.
2
CA 2874623 2017-06-16
[0003b] In another aspect of the invention, a test or isolation plug is
provided
that includes a plug body extending along a longitudinal axis. At least one
elastic seal is
carried on the plug body. There are a plurality of gripper segments aligned in
an
assembly on the plug body such that an open slot is located between each
adjacent pair of
gripper segments. Each of the gripper segments have a pipe or tube confronting
surface
with at least three separate circumferentially-extending rows of gripper teeth
longitudinally-spaced apart on the surface. Each of the separate rows of
gripper teeth
include an alternating array of individual tips and gaps such that each row is
serrated,
where each of the individual tips have a truncated oblique pyramidal shape.
[0003c] In yet another aspect of the invention, a pipe and test or isolation
plug
assembly is provided that includes a pipe or tube having an open end with a
plug body
extending within or about the pipe or tube. There is at least one annular
elastic seal
carried on the plug body and in sealing engagement with a wall of the pipe or
tube. Also
included is the plurality of gripper segments in the aforementioned
configuration.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0004] The foregoing and other aspects, features and advantages of the
embodiments disclosed herein should become apparent from the following
description
when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0005] FIG. 1 is an elevational view of a prior art test plug having a
standard set
of gripper segments loosely positioned within a broken-away showing of a pipe
wall.
[0006] FIG. 2 is a cross-sectional view of the test plug of FIG. 1 along line
2--2.
2a
CA 2874623 2017-06-16
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0007] FIG. 3 is a cross-sectional view of the prior art test plug of FIG. 1
expanded into engagement with the inner diameter of the pipe wall.
[0008] FIG. 4 is a cross-sectional view of the test plug of FIG. 3 along line
4--4.
[0009] FIG. 5 is an elevational view of a test plug having a serrated set of
gripper segments in accordance to an embodiment.
[0010] FIG. 6 is a magnified elevational view of serrated teeth of the test
plug
of FIG. 5 in accordance to an embodiment.
[0011] FIG. 7 is a top plan view of a prior art of a standard gripper segment.
[0012] FIG. 8 is a side elevational view of the standard gripper segment of
FIG.
7.
[0013] FIG. 9 is a perspective view of the standard gripper segment of FIG. 7.
[0014] FIG. 10 is a top plan view of a gripper segment in accordance with an
embodiment.
[0015] FIG. 11 is a side elevational view of the gripper segment of FIG. 10 in
accordance with an embodiment.
[0016] FIG. 12 is a perspective view of the gripper segment of FIG. 10 in
accordance with an embodiment.
[0017] FIG. 13 is a magnified perspective view of a portion of the gripper
segment of FIG. 10 in accordance with an embodiment.
[0018] FIG. 14 is a partial cross-sectional view of the gripper segment of
FIG.
in accordance with an embodiment.
3
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
=
[0019] FIG. 15 is a partial cross-sectional view of the gripper segment of
FIG.
in accordance with an embodiment.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] Embodiments disclosed herein are directed to components enabling a
test or isolation plug to engage, frictionally engage, grip, bite, or make
intimate contact
with an inner diameter or outer diameter wall of a pipe or tube. Embodiments
are also
provided with respect to test and isolation plugs and assemblies of test and
isolation plugs
installed within the ends of pipes, tubes or the like.
[0021] As discussed above, some test and isolation plugs include one or more
grippers capable of being urged radially outward or radially inward into
engagement with
an inner or outer peripheral wall of a pipe or tube to hold the plug in
position during
testing or isolation despite the use of high pipe pressurization or other
forces that may be
present. The grippers may be provided in a set, comprising one or more gripper
segments, such as two, four, six or more separate segments or any even or odd
number of
gripper segments.
[0022] When provided in a set of separate grippers, the set may comprise a
plurality of separate, aligned segments interconnected and biased inward or
outward
relative to a section of a test or isolation plug by a spring clip or the
like. The set of
segments may be closely aligned about or within the test plug; however, they
may only be
interconnected by a spring clip or the like to enable the gripper segments to
expand
4
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
outward or contract inward in a radial direction into engagement with an inner
or outer
diameter pipe or tube wall or to be placed in a non-engaging position
permitting the plug
to be inserted into or onto an open end of a pipe or tube or removed from the
open end.
[0023] Before turning to embodiments of grippers, a discussion of an
exemplary test plug is provided. It should be understood that grippers may be
used on
any type of plug including test plugs, isolation plugs, plugs having one seal,
plugs having
two or more longitudinally spaced seals, plugs having passages for
pressurizing or
depressurizing sections of a pipe, plugs baying vents permitting vapor to be
vented from
within the pipe on an opposite side of the test or isolation plug, plugs that
form seals
against the inner diameter walls of pipes or tubes, and plugs that form seals
against the
outer diameter walls of pipes or tubes. It should also be understood that the
grippers may
be designed to engage substantially circular inner or outer diameters of pipe
or tube walls
as well as out-of-round pipe or tube walls, square pipe or tube walls, and any
other shape
of pipe or tube walls.
Test Plugs
[0024] Merely for purposes of example, and not for purposes of limitation, an
embodiment of a prior art inner diameter test plug 10 is shown in FIGs. 1-4.
This
particular type of test plug may be used to create a fluid-tight seal against
an inner
periphery 12 of a pipe or tube 14 adjacent its open end so that the pipe or
tube may be
subject to pressure testing. For instance, after the plug 10 is properly
installed, the pipe or
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
tube 14 may be pressurized with sufficient pressure to test for leaks or for
any other
purpose. The amount of pressure applied within the pipe 14 depends on the
design
pressure rating of the pipe 14. The test plug 10 must be able to create a
fluid-tight seal
that is able to withstand internal pipe working pressures and must remain in a
fixed, non-
sliding, stationary position within the pipe 14 during testing and resist
sliding, movement,
blow-out or failure.
[0025] The plug 10 must be capable of being placed in a condition such that it
is
capable of being readily inserted into and through the open end of the pipe or
tube 14
without interference from the inner diameter 12 of the pipe 14. See FIGs. 1
and 2. The
plug 10 must also assume this position upon removal after testing has been
completed.
Likewise, for an outer diameter plug, the plug must be capable of being placed
in a
condition such that it is capable of being readily inserted onto and about the
open end of
the pipe or tube without interference from the outer diameter of the pipe or
tube.
[0026] The plug 10 includes a pair of compression elements, such as end plates
16 and 18 and means for causing the end plates, 16 and 18, to move together.
Moving the
plates, 16 and 18, toward each other ultimately causes the inner diameter 12
of the pipe
14 to be engaged by a set of gripping segments 20 and a sealing element 22.
Merely as an
example, the end plates, 16 and 18, may be interconnected with a shaft 24, and
the end 26
of the shaft 24 may be threadably engagable with a nut 28 so that an installer
can screw
the nut 28 onto the shaft 24 to cause relative displacement of the end plates,
16 and 18,
toward one another.
6
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0027] A camming element 30 or other mechanism may be located between the
end plates, 16 and 18, to control the position of the gripper segments 20. For
instance,
according to one embodiment, the gripper segments 20 may be slidably engagable
relative
to a frustoconical wall of the camming element 30 on which the set of gripper
segments
20 is seated. Relative movement between the camming element 30 and the set of
gripper
elements 20 can force the set of grippers 20 into positive engagement and
intimate
contact with the inner periphery 12 of the pipe or tube 14 such that the outer
surface of
the grippers 20 contact, grip, or bite into the pipe or tube wall thereby
gripping the pipe or
tube wall. See FIGs. 3 and 4. It should be understood that the camming element
30
provides one means for expanding a set of grippers and that various other
different
mechanisms could be used to expand a set of grippers into engagement with an
inner
diameter wall or contract the set of gripper into engagement with an outer
diameter wall.
[0028] The set of grippers 20 in the illustrated embodiment may include four,
annularly-aligned, separate, arc-shaped, segments (see FIGs. 3 and 4)
interconnected and
biased inwardly into close engagement with the camming clement 30 by a spring
clip 32.
Of course, more or less segments can be utilized and the segments are not
required to be
arc-shaped or annularly-aligned. This shape and alignment ultimately depends
upon the
cross-sectional shape of the inner or outer wall of the pipe or tube to be
gripped. For
instance, the cross-sectional shape of the inner or outer wall could be
square, multi-sided,
oval, out-of round, or the like.
7
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0029] In the illustrated embodiment, each gripper segment 20 has an inner
peripheral tapered wall for slidably engaging the proximal outer frustoconical
wall of the
eamming element 30. Thus, when the end plates, 16 and 18, are inwardly
compressed,
the grippers 20 are forced up the slope of the outer frustoconical wall and
thereby radially
outward into gripping engagement with the inner periphery 12 of the pipe 14.
See FIG. 3.
Of course, this provides only one means of expanding or contracting the set of
grippers
and any other means, such as levers, pivots, rotation or the like could be
utilized.
[0030] In addition to the set of grippers 20, the plug 10 may also include a
seal
element 22 made of elastomeric material which is configured to be deformed
into contact
with the inner or outer peripheral wall of a pipe or tube. The resiliency of
the seal
element 22 enables it to conform to a larger or smaller dimension while
maintaining
integrity or being a pressure boundary and then return to its as fabricated
dimension after
the pipe or tube is depressurized and the end plates, 16 and 18, are displaced
away from
one another. For instance, as shown in FIG. 3, the set of grippers 20 are in
gripping
engagement with the inner periphery 12 of the pipe or tube 14 and further
tightening of
nut 28 will cause further movement of end plate 18 toward end plate 16 to
radially
expand seal element 22 into sealing engagement with the inner periphery 12 of
the pipe or
tube 14.
[0031] In use, the plug 10 may be placed inside the pipe or tube 14 through
its
open end (see FIGs. 1 and 2). The nut 28 is tightened to force the end plates,
16 and 18,
toward each other which in turn causes the set of grippers 20 to be forced
into
8
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
engagement with the inner peripheral wall 12 of the pipe 14 (see FIGs. 3 and
4). Further
tightening of nut 28 results in the seal element 22 being placed in an
expanded condition
which is required to form a fluid-tight seal against the inner peripheral wall
12 of the pipe
14. This enables the pipe 14 to be pressured and tested.
[0032] A corresponding test plug 40 is shown in FIG. 5. The test plug 40
includes end plates 42 and 44, a shaft 46, a nut 48, an annular sealing
element 50, a
camming element 52, a set of grippers 54 and a spring clip 56. However, the
test plug 40
differs from test plug 10 in that the outer surface of each gripper segment 54
is different
as is discussed in greater detail below and as shown in FIG. 6.
[0033] Of course as discussed above, there are many different variations of
test
and isolation plugs. Some are adapted to test pipes or tubes downstream of the
plug, and
some are adapted to test the pipe or tube, connection, or flange segment
adjacent the open
end of the pipe or tube. Some isolation plugs include a pair of spaced apart
sealing
elements to isolate the end of the pipe or tube from vapors or other
substances within the
pipe or tube or to test welded connections or the like. Some include vents and
other
passages for pressurizing, depressurizing, or venting sections of pipe or tube
relative to
the plug. Still further, some plugs create a seal about the outer wall of a
pipe or tube. It
should be understood that the gripper design discussed below may be used on
any type of
test or isolation plug which is provides a pipe or tube wall gripping feature.
9
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
Standard Gripper Segment
[0034] A so-called "standard" gripper segment 20 used commercially and in test
plug 10 is shown in greater detail in FIGs. 7-9. As shown in FIG. 7, the
gripper segment
20 forms a segment of a circle so that when multiple of these segments 20 are
secured
circumferentially about a test or isolation plug, the set of gripper segments
20 are aligned
in an annular assembly in position to be expanded into engagement with an
inner
diameter of a pipe having a circular cross-section as discussed above. As
shown in FIG.
8, the segments 20 include an inner peripheral wall 62 that is sloped or
tapered for riding
up the tapered surface of a camming element. Further, the gripper segment 20
includes a
circumferentially-extending recess or slot 64 for receiving a spring clip as
discussed
above.
[0035] The so-called "standard" gripper segment 20 includes an outer surface
60
having a series of elongate, continuous, teeth 66 for engaging, contacting,
gripping or
biting into the inner diameter of a pipe or tube wall. As best shown in FIG.
8, the gripper
segment 20 includes ten, arc-shaped, separate, circumferentially-extending,
continuous
teeth 66 that are longitudinally spaced-apart. In the illustrated embodiment,
five of the
elongate, continuous teeth 66 are located on one side of the circumferentially
extending
spring recess 64 and five are located on the other side of the spring recess
64. Each of the
teeth 66 has a tip 68 that extends continuously across the entire
circumferential extent of
the gripper segment 20. In cross-section, each of teeth 66 has a generally
triangular tip 68
for engagement with the pipe wall.
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0036] Thus, the standard test plug has gripper segments 20 with a series of
continuous, arc-shaped teeth 66 provided as a set of continuous ridges as
shown for
instance in FIG. 9. Each of the ridges 66 on the outer surface 60 of the
gripper 20 may
have a buttress thread shape as shown in FIG. 8 or other threaded pitch. The
number of
ridges or continuous arc-shaped teeth 66 may vary depending upon the size of
the set of
gripper segments 20 and the test pressure.
[0037] The profile provided by the gripper segment 20 shown in FIGs. 7-9
requires an amount of force to be applied during installation to cause the
teeth 66 to
engage and frictionally grip the pipe or tube wall to an extent needed to
prevent sliding or
other unwanted movement of the test plug relative to the pipe or tube. In some
instances,
the teeth 66 may bite into the wall and deform the pipe or tube by creating a
groove in the
pipe or tube wall which secures the test plug to the pipe or tube wall during
a pressure
test. In other instances, the teeth 66 may only need to contact and
frictionally engage the
wall without deforming the wall.
[0038] The continuous circular profile of each of the gripper teeth 66
generally
contacts the pipe wall over a relatively large surface area and thereby may
require a
significant amount of force to create a required grip sufficient to prevent
plug sliding,
movement, failure or blow-out. In some instances, this may require the gripper
to
overcome the yield strength and/or hardness of the pipe material making a
sufficient grip
difficult to achieve on a pipe or tube of relatively high yield strength,
hardness and
toughness. In addition, problems with creating a sufficient grip relative to
non-metallic
11
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
pipes such as polyethylene (PE), glass reinforced epoxy (GRE), fiberglass and
the like
may be encountered.
[0039] By way of example, the standard gripper segments 20 may be able to
engage and grip many types and grades of pipes and tubes. However, the
standard gripper
segments 20 may not be able to provide sufficient retention force in certain
hardened
pipes, such as pipes greater than Rockwell C hardness (HRC) 20, tougher steels
and
alloys, such as 304L Stainless Steel and Nickel based metal alloys, high
strength steel,
drill pipes, pipes with nickel or alternate high alloy cladding, many grades
of stainless
steel and high alloys.
[0040] Thus, for instance, as test pressure requirements increase and pipes
made
of harder materials are required, larger amounts of force must be used to
cause gripper
segments 20 to adequately grip pipe and tube walls. Standard gripping
technology is
generally limited to use on pipes made of materials having a hardness of no
greater than
HRC 20. In addition, grippers providing performance and wear improvements
relative to
all types of pipes and tubes are desired, grippers of prolonged life are
desired, grippers
that create less continuous damage and deformation of pipe wall are desired,
grippers that
eliminate damage created by sliding is desired, and grippers that minimize or
eliminate
the need for pipe repair or rework after testing are desired.
[0041] For instance, the gripper segments 20 may bite into a pipe or tube wall
and permanently deform the pipe and form relatively circular pattern grooves
(i.e., same
shape as continuous ridges or teeth of the grippers). At these locations, the
pipe or tube
12
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
material is pushed outward or inward creating ribs in the outer or inner
diameter of the
pipe wall. In most cases, these ribs are required to be removed after the
completion of the
test. Even though the deformation created by the gripper 20 may not affect the
performance of the pipe, it necessarily creates an undesired appearance and
requires
additional work and process time to remove. Alternatively, the test section
(i.e., section
deformed by the gripper biting into the pipe) of the pipe may need to be cut
and removed
which also results in additional process time and cost.
Serrated Gripper Segments
[0042] Thus, according to an embodiment, a gripper segment 54 having an outer
surface 70 providing a profile different than that disclosed by FIGs. 7-9 is
provided. The
gripper profile shown in FIGs. 5, 6 and 10-13 is useful for plugs for use in
any type of
tube or pipe including and not limited to pipes and tubes made of stainless
steel, alloys
and other materials of high hardness, non-metallic materials, PE, GRC,
fiberglass, or the
like. The gripper segment 54 provides improved capabilities to engage,
frictionally
contact, grip and/or bite into a pipe wall with less force required to install
a set of grippers
as compared to the gripper segments 20 shown in FIGs. 1-4 and 7-9 and is
therefore
capable of holding higher test pressure than the gripper segment 20. The
gripper segment
may be made of metal, plastic, ceramic, or other material.
[0043] Thus, the gripper segment 54 is capable of engaging the walls of pipes
and tube, including those of hardness higher than HRC 20, with less area of
contact of
13
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
gripper teeth as compared to the gripper 20. In addition, the gripper 54
provides
improved holding capacity, an increased safety factor for pressure-assisted
sealing,
reduced installation torque requirement, and extended service life of the pipe
or tube and
the grippers.
[0044] The gripper segment 54 shown in FIGs. 10-13 is able to provide the
above features due to the profile of its surface 70 which, in the illustrated
embodiment, is
intended to engage an inner diameter of a pipe or tube wall. Of course, the
segment could
be designed to engage an outer diameter of a pipe or tube wall, or grip a pipe
or grip wall
that is not circular in cross-section. The gripper segment 54 of the
illustrated embodiment
may be similar to the standard gripper segment 20 in that it may include a
series of
circumferentially-extending rows or outward projections that are
longitudinally spaced-
apart. For instance, the gripper segment 54 may include ten rows of teeth 72
and a spring
recess 74. Of course, any number of rows of teeth 72 may be used including as
few as
two or as many as desired. In addition, the gripper segment 54 may have a
tapered wall
76 for sliding on a tapered wall of a camming element.
[0045] The gripper segment 54 differs from the standard gripper segment 20 in
that each of the rows of teeth 72 has a plurality of gaps 78, such as V-shaped
or U-shaped
gaps or gaps of any other shape, cut or formed therein. See FIGs. 10 and 13.
Thus, each
circumferential row 72 is not in the form of a continuous ridge; rather, each
row 72
includes an array of gaps 78 that provides each row with serrations thereby
providing an
alternating array of individual bites or tips 80 and open gaps 78. Thus, the
rows 72 do not
14
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
provide a continuous tip; rather, they are serrated and are provided by a
series of spaced-
apart individual bites or tips 80 separated by gaps 78.
[0046] Each individual bite or tip 80 may have a generally pyramidal shape
with
a pointed or flat top 82. See FIG. 13. Of course, the bites or tips 80 could
be any shape
provided that they are separated by gaps 78 and do not form a continuous
ridge. The gaps
78 cut into the rows 72 may be axial grooves machined in a direction
perpendicular to the
radial buttress thread shape grooves to create the arrays of bites or tips 80
and open gaps
78. The depth, shape and the amount of axial grooves may vary and depend upon
the size
of the gripper, pipe and/or gripper materials, test plug rated pressure, and
other factors
related to perfoiiiiance and reliability of test and isolation plugs.
[0047] The serrated gripper segments 54 require less force to deform and bite
into the material forming the wall of a test pipe or tube. The serrated
gripper segments 54
also allow tests to be performed in pipes and tubes made of harder materials
due to the
unique shape of the gripper bites 80. The serrated gripper segments 54 also
provide
increased holding capability.
[0048] The bites or tips 80 as shown in FIG. 13 increase the strength and
performance of the serrated gripper 54. Smaller contact area is required and
permits the
gripper segment 54 to more readily penetrate or bite into a pipe or tube wall.
The bites or
tips 80 also provide improved strength to withstand higher stress loads in
comparison to
the continuous solid circular tooth profile shown in FIGs. 1-4 and 7-9. In
addition, the
serrated gripper segment 54 is more flexible and therefore performs better in
polygonal
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
shaped pipes and out-of-round pipes. Here, the gaps 78 provide pivot points
permitting
the segment 54 to flex into contact with the pipe wall to thereby compensate
for any
unintentionally out-of-round pipe or tube wall or for pipe or tube walls that
may not be
circular in cross-section.
[0049] The serrated gripper segments 54 also reduce damage to walls of pipes
or
tubes. As these grippers 54 have reduced contact area in conjunction with a
sharper bite
or tooth tip profile, less pipe or tube material is deformed. As a result,
secondary work
(such as grinding away of deformations created by grippers) can be eliminated.
Further,
the serrated gripper segments 54 can provide retention in standard material
pipes, ASTM-
A106, hardened steel and tough alloys such as 304L Stainless Steel and Nickel
based alloy
metals, non-metallic materials, PE, GRC, fiberglass, and the like.
[0050] FIGs. 14 and 15 provide cross-sectional views longitudinally and
circumferentially of the serrated gripper segments 54. In FIG. 14, the pitch
"P" of the
circumferential-extending rows 72 of bites or individual tooth tips 80 may be
about 0.12
inch. Each wall of the tooth tip 80 may or may not be uniformly tapered. Thus,
each
tooth tip 80 may lean or point in a particular direction (upstream or
downstream
directions relative to the pipe or tube). For instance, the angle of taper of
the rear wall 84
of each bite or tip 80 may be about 55 and the angle of taper of the front
wall 86 of each
bite or tip 80 may be about 0 to 5 . See FIG. 14. Alternatively, the angle of
taper may
be, for instance, 30 for both the front and rear walls, 86 and 84, if
directionality is not
desired.
16
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0051] In FIG. 15, the gaps 78 between adjacent bites or tips 80 in the same
row
72 may be formed by an axial groove such that the angle "A" between adjacent
side walls
88 and 90 of bites or tips 80 in the same row 72 is about 900. Thus, the angle
of taper of
each of the side walls 88 and 90 may be about 45 . As shown in the illustrated
embodiments, the bites or tips 80 in adjacent circumferential rows 72 of bites
or tips 80
are aligned; however, the bites or tips 80 may also be offset or staggered in
different rows
72.
[0052] Although the gripper segment 54 is shown with respect to a gripper for
engaging an inner diameter of a round pipe or tube, the rows of teeth can be
provided
such that they are positioned to engage an outer diameter of a circular pipe
or tube.
Alternatively, the segment can be provided in a shape to grip a square, multi-
sided, or
oval pipe or tube cross-sectional shape. In addition, the gripper segment 54
can be used
in pipes or tubes harder than HRC 20, can be used to enhance performance and
wear in
all types of pipes or tubes, provide grippers of longer life, produce less
deformation of
pipe wall, prevent damage created by sliding, and prevent the need for pipe
repair of
rework after testing.
Example and Comparative Example
[0053] A test plug such as shown in FIG. 5 having a set of standard gripper
segments 20 and an otherwise identical test plug having a set of serrated
gripper segments
54 were prepared and tested in 4SCH40 sized pipes. The tests were conducted in
pipes
17
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
made of five different materials, namely A106 Grade B, 304 Stainless Steel,
304L
Stainless Steel Polished, 4142 High Strength Steel, and 4142 High Strength
Steel
hardened to HRC 27. The test results are listed in Table 1 provided below.
Table 1
Test Pipe Serrated Gripper
Pipe Material Standard Plug Results
Ref. Size Plug Results
3144 PSI - Test
Standard Rated
1 4SCH40 A106 Grade B Completed
Operation
Grippers Held
2203 PSIG - Test
3205 PSI-Test
304 Stainless Aborted -Plug
2 4SCH40 Completed
Steel movement, Gripper
Grippers Held
sliding
887 PSIG - Test Aborted 2725 PSI - Test
304L Stainless
3 4SCH40 Plug movement, Gripper Completed
Steel Polished
sliding Grippers Held
3025 PSIG - Test
8098 PSI-Test
4142 High Aborted -Plug
4 4SCH40 Completed
Strength Steel movement, Gripper
Grippers Held
sliding
4142 High
10,123 PSI-Test
Strength Steel
4SCH40 n/a Completed
Hardened to
Grippers Held
HRC 27
[0054] Both plugs performed acceptable when used in a pipe made of A106
Grade B. However, for all other pipes, the plug having standard gripper
segments 20 was
aborted before completion due to plug movement and gripper sliding relative to
the pipe.
The tests were aborted on the basis that if the test was continued, ultimate
failure would
result in the test plug being expelled from the pipe with significant force
(i.e., plug blow-
out).
18
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0055] For a pipe made of 304 Stainless Steel, the plug having the standard
gripper segments 20 was aborted due to gripper sliding at 2203 PSI; whereas,
in
comparison, the test was completed with the plug having the serrated gripper
segments 54
at 3205 PSI with no gripper movement. For a pipe made of 304L Stainless Steel
Polished, the plug having the standard gripper segments 20 was aborted due to
gripper
sliding at 887 PSI; whereas, in comparison, the test was completed with the
plug having
the serrated gripper segments 54 at 2725 PSI with no gripper movement. For a
pipe made
of 4142 High Strength Steel, the plug having the standard gripper segments 20
was
aborted due to gripper sliding at 3025 PSI; whereas, in comparison, the test
was
completed with the plug having the serrated gripper segments 54 at 8098 PSI
with no
gripper movement. For a pipe made of 4142 High Strength Steel hardened to HRC
27, a
test was completed with the plug having the serrated gripper segments 54 at
10,123 PSI
with no gripper movement.
[0056] Accordingly, a test plug having a set of the serrated gripper segments
54
outperformed a test plug having a set of standard gripper segments 20. In
addition, the
tests show that a test plug having a set of the serrated gripper segments 54
may be
successfully used on pipes made of 304 Stainless Steel, 304L Stainless Steel
Polished,
4142 High Strength Steel, 4142 High Strength Steel hardened to HRC 27, and
materials
of like hardness. Of course, the serrated gripper segments 54 also provide
advantages
with respect to all types and sizes of pipes and tubes including non-metallic
pipes or
tubes.
19
CA 02874623 2014-12-15
[0057] The foregoing description and specific embodiments are merely
illustrative of the principles thereof, and various modifications and
additions may be
made to the apparatus by those skilled in the art, without departing from the
scope of
the invention defined by the appended claims.
