Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
1
Process for enhancing the molecular weight of a polyester
The present invention relates to a process for enhancing the molecular weight
of a
polyester. In particular, it relates to a process for enhancing the molecular
weight of a semi-
crystalline starting polyester comprising ethylene-2,5-furandicarboxylate
units.
2,5-Furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) is a diacid that can be produced from
natural
sources such as carbohydrates. Routes for its preparation using air oxidation
of 2,5-
disubstituted furans such as 5-hydroxymethylfurfural or ethers thereof with
catalysts
comprising Co and Mn have been disclosed in e.g. W02010/132740, W02011/043660
and
W02011/043661.
US 2551731 describes the preparation of polyesters and polyester-amides by
reacting
glycols with dicarboxylic acids of which at least one contains a heterocyclic
ring, such as 2,5-
FDCA. Under melt polymerization conditions, using sodium- and magnesium
methoxide as a
catalyst, FDCA or FDCA dimethyl ester and 1.6 equivalents of ethylene glycol
were reacted in
a esterification step or transesterification step, respectively, at ambient
pressure between 160
and 220 C, after which a polycondensation was carried out between 190 and 220
C under a
few mm Hg pressure. The product had a reported melting point of 205-210 C and
readily
yielded filaments from the melt.
In US 2009/0124763 polyesters are described, having a 2,5-furandicarboxylate
moiety
within the polymer backbone and having a degree of polymerization of 185 or
more and 600
or less. These polymers are made in a three step process involving the
esterification of the
2,5-FDCA or the transesterification of the diester thereof with a diol, and a
second step
involving polycondensation, followed by solid state polymerization as third
step.
The first step is carried out at ambient pressure at a temperature within a
range of 150
to 180 00, whereas the polycondensation step is carried out under vacuum at a
temperature
within a range of 180 to 230 C. The product is then purified by dissolving
the same in
hexafluoroisopropanol, re-precipitation and drying, followed by the third
step, a solid state
polymerization at a temperature in the range of from 140 to 18000 For the
preparation of
poly(ethylene furandicarboxylate) the first two steps took over 11 hours. The
polymer is
reported to have a melting point of 170 C. In examples it is shown that
despite the step of
solid state polymerization, the molecular weight of e.g. poly(ethylene-2,5-
furandicarboxylate)
is still rather low.
In WO 2010/077133 a process for preparing furandicarboxylate-containing
polyesters
is described wherein the diester of FDCA is transesterified with a diol, and
the ester
composition thus obtained is subjected to polycondensation. The polycondensate
may then
be subjected to solid state polymerization. In an example the solid state
polymerization is
conducted for 60 hours. Although the molecular weight of the polyester
obtained is
reasonably high, the duration of the solid state polymerization is considered
too long. An
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
2
improvement is described in WO 2013/062408, wherein the dimethyl ester of FDCA
is
transesterified with ethylene glycol, or bis(2-hydroxyethyl)-2,5-
furandicarboxylate is used as
starting material. The transesterification product or this starting material
is then subjected to
polycondensation and after a drying/crystallization step the polycondensate is
subjected to
solid state polymerization to enhance the molecular weight of the
polycondensate. In an
example the polycondensate was ground and sieved and the fraction with
particle size 0,6 -
1.4 mm was crystallized overnight at 110 C overnight. This fraction was
subjected to solid
state polymerization which took two days.
In WO 2013/120989 a continuous process for the preparation of poly(ethylene
furandicarboxylate) is described wherein FDCA or a diester thereof is mixed
with ethylene
glycol at elevated temperature to give a paste or a homogeneous solution, the
paste or
solution is converted to an esterification product of FDCA and ethylene
glycol, the
esterification product is polycondensed under reduced pressure, wherein the
polycondensation is performed in two stages. According to an example the
dimethyl ester of
FDCA was reacted with ethylene glycol in a molar ratio of 1:1.7. In this
example the stages
following the production of the esterified product took 5 hours. The
polycondensation product
can be subjected, if desired, to a solid stating polymerization. However, no
details are
provided. In an example the polycondensation product was reported to have an
intrinsic
viscosity of 1.05 dlig.
KR 20140003167 describes a polyester polymer with excellent transparency which
is
manufactured by using a biomass originated furandicarboxylate ester compound
with
ethylene glycol. In comparative examples also furandicarboxylic acid has been
used. The
molar ratio of furandicarboxylate ester to ethylene glycol may be from 1:1.1
to 1:4. The ratio
of furandicarboxylic acid to ethylene glycol varies between1:1.2 to 1:2. The
document does
not disclose a solid state polymerization step.
It is apparent that it would be beneficial if the process could be altered
such that a
faster enhancement of the molecular weight of such polyesters could be
obtained. It has now
surprisingly been found that when a semi-crystalline polyester having a
particular structure is
subjected to solid-state polymerization, the solid state polymerization
proceeds faster than as
reported in the above-mentioned patent specifications.
Accordingly, the present invention provides a process for enhancing the
molecular
weight of a semi-crystalline starting polyester comprising ethylene 2,5-
furandicarboxylateunits
by heating the semi-crystalline starting polyester, having a melting point Tm,
at a temperature
in the range of (Tm-40 C) to Tm to obtain a solid stated polyester, wherein
the semi-
crystalline starting polyester has an intrinsic viscosity of at least 0.45
dl/g, and an amount of
carboxylic acid end groups in the range of 15 to 122 meq/kg. Preferably, the
semi-crystalline
starting polyester has an intrinsic viscosity of at most 1.0 dL/g.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
3
The starting polyester is semi crystalline. The crystallinity of a polymer
tends to affect
its physical properties, such as its density and melting temperature. Polymer
crystallinity can
be determined with Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) by quantifying the
heat
associated with melting of the polymer. The heat can be reported as the
percentage of
crystallinity by normalizing the melting heat to that of a 100% crystalline
sample. However,
those samples are rare. Therefore, the crystallinity is often expressed as net
enthalpy in
terms of number of Joules per gram which number is derived from the DSC
technique. The
enthalpy of melting and crystallization can be determined in accordance with
ISO 11357-3.
The semi-crystalline starting polyester preferably has a crystallinity of at
least 25 J/g,
measured by DSC. A maximum enthalpy in terms of number of Joules per gram is
typically 80
J/g. The semi-crystalline starting polyester having a certain degree of
crystallinity then also
has a melting point Tm. The melting point of a polymer is easily determined by
DSC and
measured at the top of the endothermic peak. The IS011357-3 standard describes
such a
melting point determination. In accordance with this determination, the
starting polyester
suitably has a Tm of at least 200 C. In highly crystalline polyester the Tm
may exceed 230 C
and may be as high as 245 C. It is observed that during the present process
the melting
point and crystallinity of the polyester will increase. The melting point of
the starting polyester
is preferably at least 210 C and may increase during the process such that at
the end thereof
it may exceed 220 C. The crystallinity will then preferably be greater than 40
J/g. The
crystallinity will then advantageously be in the range of 40 to 90 J/g.
The semi-crystalline starting polyester suitably consists of ethylene
furandicarboxylate
units for at least 95 mole%. The balance may comprise other monomer units,
such as other
diols and diacids. Other suitable monomer diols include diethylene glycol and
other suitable
diacids, include terephthalic acid, adipic acid, phthalic acid and isophthalic
acid. More
preferably, the polyester consists of poly(ethylene 2,5-furandicarboxylate)
that further
comprises diethylene glycol residues, wherein the amount of diethylene glycol
residues
amounts to at most 0.045 moles of diethylene glycol residues per mole of 2,5-
furandicarboxylate.
The starting polyester is typically the product of the esterification of FDCA
and
ethylene glycol, followed by a polycondensation step. The polycondensation
step generally is
conducted under melt conditions. In accordance with the teaching of WO
2013/120989 the
polycondensation may be carried out in two steps; a pre-polycondensation at
reduced
pressure and a subsequent polycondensation at a further reduced vacuum. The
resulting
polycondensate can be subjected to the solid state polymerization according to
the present
invention. Such a polycondensate already has a certain relatively high
molecular weight. If the
polycondensate has an initial IV already greater than 1.0 dL/g, the principal
purpose of such
an additional step of solid state polymerization may be to achieve a reduction
in volatiles,
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
4
such as acetaldehyde, which can form during the melt polycondensation in
addition to an
additional molecular weight increase.
The molecular weight is expressed in terms of intrinsic viscosity. First the
relative
viscosity (nrel) is determined in a 60140 w/w mixture of phenol and
tetrachloroethane at 30 C
and a concentration (c) of 0.4 g/dL. This procedure is similar to the ASTM
D4603 standard for
the determination of the inherent viscosity for poly(ethylene terephthalate).
The intrinsic
viscosity is then calculated using the Billmyer equation:
Intrinsic viscosity (l\/)= {n ,rel -1+3*In (flre, )}/(4*c)
The intrinsic viscosity is suitably greater than 0.45 dL/g and more preferably
in the
range of 0.45 to 1.0 dL/g. As the starting polyester is to undergo an
additional step of solid
stating the molecular weight is preferably in the range of 0.45 to 0.75 dL/g.
Due to solid
stating the molecular weight is increased such as to 0.65 to 1.2 dlig,
preferably to an intrinsic
viscosity of at least 0.75 dL/g, more preferably in the range of 0.75 dL/g to
1.0 dL/g.
Acetaldehyde may be formed during the melt polycondensation. Its content in
polyesters can be determined using known methods. A suitable method is
described in ASTM
F 2013; this is described for polyethylene terephthalate, but can also be used
for the
polyester used in the present invention. Applicants have found that
polycondensates can
have acetaldehyde values of 18 mg/kg, or higher, prior to the additional steps
of solid state
polymerization as described herein. Applicants have also found that the solid
state
polymerization process described herein can reduce the levels of acetaldehyde
to less than 1
mg/kg (ppm) and preferably to less than 0.5 mg/kg within a reasonably short
reaction time.
As is taught in US 6569479 acetaldehyde is naturally formed during processing
of any
polyester containing ethylene glycol linkages. The compound is formed via a
two-step
reaction: the first step is cleavage of a polymer chain, generating a vinyl
end group and a
carboxylic acid end group. The second step is reaction of the vinyl end group
with a
hydroxyethyl end group, reforming the polymer chain and releasing
acetaldehyde. When the
polymer is used in a container for beverages, the acetaldehyde may migrate
from the
container sidewall into the beverage over time. During the lifetime of a
typical container,
several hundred ppb of acetaldehyde can migrate from the container sidewall
into the
beverage. For sensitive products, such as water, these levels of acetaldehyde
are
significantly above the taste threshold. In US 4340721 it is shown that when
polyethylene
terephthalate contains more than I ppm acetaldehyde, the polymer is unsuitable
for use as
material for beverage containers. Therefore there is a great desire to limit
the amount of
acetaldehyde in polyesters comprising ethylene furandicarboxylate units also
to a level below
1 ppm (mg acetaldehyde per kg polyester).
The polycondensate can be used as such. However, it is preferred to subject it
to a
pre-treatment before it is being heated to obtain the solid stated polyester.
When the
polycondensate is recovered as solid material from the polycondensation step,
the
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
polycondensate tends to be rather amorphous and only semi-crystalline to a
certain extent. In
order to render the polycondensate into a more crystalline material, the
polycondensate is
preferably crystallized at a temperature in the range of 90 to 200 C, more
preferably from
140 to 180 C. In certain arrangements the heating step may entail controlling
the
5 temperature of the pellet during pelletization such that the final pellet
temperature is in a
range where crystallization occurs. Prior to any step of additional heating
any adhered water
from the pelletizing step is suitably removed. This procedure is suitably
carried out by cooling,
i.e., bringing the temperature of the polycondensate to the desired
temperature in the range
of 90 to 200 C. This cooling may be done by means of a liquid, e.g. water.
For poly(ethylene
2,5-furandicarboxylate) it has been found that the most rapid crystallization
occurs at
approximately 170 C. It has also been found that if the particles are held
for approximately 1
hour at 120 C the subsequent crystallization at 170 C is faster. The optimal
temperature
program will depend on the particular arrangements used for the
crystallization. Typically, the
polycondensate is kept a temperature in the range of 80 to 140 C for a period
of 0.2 to 3 hrs,
preferably 0.5 to 2.5 hrs, followed by a crystallization step for Ito 48 hours
at a temperature
in the range of 120 to 200 C. It has been found that the polyester chains in
the
polycondensate crystallize under these conditions yielding a desired semi-
crystalline
polyester. It has also been found that it can be advantageous to use a degree
of agitation
during the pre-treatment and crystallization period, to reduce the propensity
of the particles to
adhere to each other and cause clumping. Also, it has been found that a
thermal pretreatment
in water at 80 to 95 C can also reduce the tendency of particles to adhere to
each other
during the subsequent crystallization in the range of 120 to 200 C.
Accordingly, there are
several advantageous protocols to arrive at the desired crystallinity, all
being completed by a
crystallizing heating step at 120 to 200 C. One alternative is to subject the
polycondensate to
a heating step at 80 to 140 C for a period of 0.2 to 3 hrs, followed by the
crystallizing heating
step. A second alternative is to conduct such heating step at 80 to 140 C in
a liquid, e.g.
water. The melted polycondensate may also be pelletized while crystallizing by
using e.g. an
underwater pelletizer.
It has been found that the polyester chains in the polycondensate crystallize
under
these conditions yielding a semi-crystalline polyester. The polyester thus
obtained suitably
has a crystallinity of at least 25 J/g, measured by DSC. It suitably has a
melting point of at
least 200 C, preferably at least 215 C.
The semi-crystalline starting polyester has an amount of carboxylic acid end
groups.
In accordance with the present invention the semi-crystalline starting
polyester should have
an amount of carboxylic end groups of 15 to 122 meq/kg. The amount of
carboxylic end
groups is preferably in the range of 25 to 80 meq/kg. In addition the starting
polyester also
comprises hydroxyl end groups. The amount of hydroxyl end groups may vary
widely.
Preferably, the amount of hydroxyl end groups is in the range of 25 to 100
rneq/kg.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
6
In this context it is observed that during polycondensation some carboxylic
groups
may be split from the furan ring to which they were attached, leading to
decarboxylated end
groups.
In general there are a number of methods to determine the end groups in
polyesters.
Such methods include titration, infrared and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)
methods.
Often the separate methods are used to quantify the four main end groups:
carboxylic acid
end groups, hydroxyl end groups, methyl ester end groups and the end groups
that are
obtained after decarboxylation. However, in A.T. Jackson and D.F. Robertson
have published
an 1H-NMR method for end group determination in "Molecular Characterization
and Analysis
of Polymers" (J.M. Chalmers en R.J. Meier (eds.), Vol. 53 of "Comprehensive
Analytical
Chemistry", by B. Barcelo (ed.), (2008) Elsevier, on pages 171-203. In this
method the
hydroxyl end group is determined in polyethylene terephthalate (PET) by using
a selection of
harsh solvents such as 3-chlorophenol, 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoro-2-propanol,
trichloroacetic acid
or trifluoroacetic acid. It is preferred to use deuterated 1,1,2,2-
tetrachloroethane (TCE-d2) as
solvent without any derivatization of the polyester. A similar method can be
carried out for
polyesters that comprises furandicarboxylate moieties and ethylene glycol
residues. The
measurement of the end groups for the latter polyesters can be performed at
room
temperature without an undue risk of precipitation of the polyester from the
solution.This
NMR method using TCE-d2 is very suitable to determine the hydroxyl end groups
(HEG), the
decarboxylation and the content of diethylene glycol (DEG) groups. Peak
assignments are set
using the ICE peak at a chemical shift of 6.04 ppm. The furan peak at a
chemical shift of
7.28 ppm is integrated and the integral is set at 2.000 for the two protons on
the furan ring.
The HEG is determined from the two methylene protons of the hydroxyl end group
at 4.0
ppm. The content of DEG is determined from the integral of the shifts at 3.82
to 3.92 ppm,
representing four protons. The decarboxylated end groups are found at a shift
of 7.64-7.67
ppm, representing one proton. When the polyester also comprises methyl ester
end groups,
the methyl signal will occur at 3.97 ppm, representing 3 protons.
The carboxylic acid end groups are determined by using the titration method
according to ASTM D7409, adapted for poly(ethylene 2,5-furandicarboxylate). A
thus
modified method thereof involves the titration of a 4%w/v solution of
poly(ethylene 2,5-
furandicarboxylate) in ortho-cresol with 0.01M KOH in ethanol as titrant to
its equivalence
point, using 0.5 mg of bromocresol green (2,6-dibromo-447-(3,5-dibromo-4-
hydroxy-2-methyl-
phenyl)-9,9-dioxo-8-oxa-9A6-thiabicyclo[4.3.0]nona-1,3,5-trien-7-y1]-3-methyl-
phenol) in 0.1 ml
ethanol as indicator.
For the purpose of the present application the values for HEG and the
decarboxylated
end groups are obtained by 1H-NMR using TCE-d2, whereas the values for CEG are
determined by the titration method described above.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
7
The content of the various end groups can be expressed as relative to other
end
groups. It is also possible to express the amount of end groups as an absolute
value per
weight unit of polyester. Expressed as an absolute feature, the amount of
carboxylic acid end
groups in the semi-crystalline starting polyester is advantageously in the
range of 25 to 80
meq/kg. The calculation of the absolute amount of carboxylic acid end groups
is obtained
directly from the titration.
About 10 mg of a polyester is weighed and put in an 8 mL glass vial. To the
vial 0.7
mL of TCE-d2 is added and the polyester is dissolved at room temperature
whilst agitating
the mixture in the vial. The dissolved mixture is subjected to 1H-NMR, whilst
the peak for
TCE-d2 is set at 6.04 ppm. The furan peak is centered at 7.28 ppm, and it is
integrated and
the integral set to 2.000, to represent the 2 protons on the furan ring. The
1H-NMR signals are
integrated and the amounts of end groups are calculated as follows:
Hydroxyl end groups (HEG) = 5494 * integral at 4.0 ppm/2;
Decarboxylated end groups (DecarbEG) = 5494 * integral at 7.65 ppm.
When the polyester also comprises methyl ester end groups, the methyl signal
will
occur at 3.97 ppm and the content of the ester end groups is then calculated
as:
Ester end groups (EEG) = 5494 * integral at 3.97 ppm/3.
The results of these calculations are amounts of the respective end groups
expressed
in meq/kg. It is also possible to calculate a relative content of carboxylic
acid end groups
based on the sum of the carboxylic acid end groups and hydroxyl end groups.
For that
purpose, the following formula is used: CEG/(CEG + HEG).
The semi-crystalline starting polyester having an amount of hydroxyl end
groups in
addition to carboxylic acid end groups, preferably has a content of carboxylic
acid end
groups, expressed as the fraction of the molar amount of carboxylic acid end
groups divided
by the sum of the molar amounts of hydroxyl end groups and carboxylic acid end
groups, in
the range of 0.10 to 0.7. More preferably, the relative content of carboxylic
acid end groups is
in the range of 0.14 to 0.65 based on the sum of the hydroxyl and carboxylic
acid end groups.
It may be advantageous to have a reduced level of carboxylic acid end groups
in the
final product after solid state polymerization. Applicants have found that
while a high level of
CEG is desired to achieve a high rate and extent of solid state
polymerization, it may be
desired to have a lower level in the solid stated polyester. Thus, in
preferred embodiments,
the amount of CEG of the solid stated polyester is less than 30 meq/kg and
more preferably
less than 20 meq/kg. Suitably the amount of CEG is in the range of 5 to 30
meq/kg, more
preferably in the range of 7 to 20 meq/kg. It is also advantageous to have
relatively few
decarboxylated end groups, and in preferred embodiments the decarboxylated end
group
content is less than 15 meq/kg.
As indicated above, the process of the present invention also enables the
obtaining of
a solid stated polyester that has a reduced acetaldehyde content. At the same
time, the
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
8
molecular weight has been enhanced. Preferably, the enhancement has led to a
molecular
weight corresponding to an intrinsic viscosity of at least 0.75 dL/g. Such a
polyester is novel.
Such a polyester also fulfils a long-felt desire. Accordingly, the present
invention provides for
a polyester comprising ethylene-2,5-furandicarboxylate units, which polyester
has an IV of at
least 0.75 dl/g and an acetaldehyde content of at most 1 mg/kg, preferably
less than 0.5
mg/kg. Suitably the polyester has an amount of carboxylic acid end groups
below 30 meq/kg,
preferably from 5 to 30, more preferably from 7 to 20 meq/kg.
During the solid state polymerization also the crystallinity increases. The
solid stated
polyesters according to the invention thus also have preferably a
crystallinity of at least 50
J/g, measured by Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC). Preferably, the
crystallinity is in
the range of 55 to 90 J/g.
The semi-crystalline starting polyester is suitably prepared from a mixture of
FDCA
and ethylene glycol by esterification, followed by polycondensation, and
optionally, by the
heat treatment as described above. The esterification is preferably conducted
from a starting
mixture of FDCA and ethylene glycol, wherein the molar ratio of 2,5-
furandicarboxylic acid to
ethylene glycol is from 1:1.01 to 1:1.15.
The esterification reaction of furan dicarboxylic acid and ethylene glycol is
known in
the art. Hence, the skilled person will realize that although there is no need
for using an
esterification catalyst, the use of such a catalyst may be contemplated. Hence
in an
embodiment, the 2,5-furandicarboxyic acid and ethylene glycol are suitably
reacted in the
presence of an esterification catalyst. As esterification catalysts are
advantageously acidic,
and since one of the reactant is an acid, the necessity to use an
esterification catalyst is
lacking. However, when such a catalyst is used, it is suitably a Bronsted or
Lewis acid. The
Bronsted acids may be strong mineral acids such as sulphuric acid, nitric acid
or hydrochloric
acid. Suitable Lewis acids include compounds of metals such as the chlorides,
bromides,
tosylates, alkoxides and triflates of metal selected from the group consisting
of titanium, tin,
calcium, and mixtures thereof. It is also possible to use organic esters of
the metal acids,
such as the alkyl esters of titanic acid, stannic acid and the like. Hence,
the esterification
catalyst is preferably selected from catalysts containing one or more metals
selected from the
group consisting of titanium, zinc, tin, calcium and antimony. The catalysts,
if used, may be
added from the start of the esterification reaction. However, since the
esterification proceeds
easily without the use of an esterification catalyst, the esterification is
preferably carried out in
the absence of an esterification catalyst, which is dedicated to the
esterification reaction.
In the esterification reaction water is being formed. It has been found that
it is
advantageous to remove the water formed during the reaction of 2,5-
furandicarboxylic acid
and ethylene glycol. In this way the esterification reaction being an
equilibrium reaction, may
be led to completion. The removal of water from the esterification mixture may
be conducted
in any known manner. It is suitable to pass any water formed in a vaporous
phase through a
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
9
condenser and remove the condensate that includes the liquefied water. The
vaporous phase
may comprise also some ethylene glycol. Therefore, the vaporous phase is
advantageously
passed through a distillation system wherein water and ethylene glycol are
separated. The
ethylene glycol is suitably, at least partly, but preferably substantially
completely, recycled to
the esterification mixture. The water thus separated is discharged. Hence, the
method
according to the present invention is preferably carried out such that water
is removed in a
rectification system wherein any ethylene glycol that is removed with water is
separated from
water and at least partly recycled.
It will be evident that the degree with which the ethylene glycol is entrained
in the
vaporous phase of water formed is dependent on the temperature and other
conditions at
which the esterification is carried out. The conditions that are used in the
prior art include a
temperature in the range of about 180 to 280 C and about ambient pressure.
These
conditions were maintained for a period of about 4 hours. In the method
according to the
present invention the esterification reaction between 2,5-furandicarboxylic
acid and alkylene
diol is preferably carried out at a temperature of 160 to 240 C. The pressure
is suitably in the
range of 0.9 to 5 bar, and the reaction is advantageously continued for a
period of 0.5 to 4 hr.
The reaction is conveniently carried out in an inert atmosphere, such as under
nitrogen, neon,
helium or argon. The starting mixture may comprise a diluent, such as water
that is suitably
discharged during the reaction. As indicated in US 2009/0124763 the end point
of the
esterification reaction is confirmed by the time that the reaction mixture
becomes transparent,
i.e. the so-called clear point. Therefore, the esterification reaction in the
present method is
suitably pursued at least until the ester composition formed has become clear.
If desired, the
esterification reaction may be continued for a further period.
It has been found that the esterification reaction for 2,5-furandicarboxylic
acid is quite
fast and as a result it is most common to "over esterify" and leave an
inadequate amount of
carboxylic acid end groups in the polyester. The potential extent of the
esterification reaction
can be somewhat controlled by using a dimensionless parameter defined herein
as:
Esterification Potential (EsPo) = (MR-1)2*PH20(T), wherein MR represents the
molar
ratio of ethylene glycol over 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid, MR being greater
than 1;
PH20(T) represents the pure component vapor pressure (in bar) of water at
temperature T, which is the final reaction temperature in the esterification
mixture before the
pressure is reduced to enter the pre-polycondensation stage. P
= H2O is determined in
accordance with an established equation for the vapor pressure of pure water.
The Antoine
equation
log io P = A ¨ B/(C + T), where T is the temperature at the end of
esterification,
expressed in C, A = 5.2594, B = 1810.94, and C = 244.485 gives the required
vapor
pressure of pure water in bar. It has been found that the best results as to
polycondensate
are obtained if the esterification potential is at most 0.8, preferably from
0.05 to 0.5.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
At this point the ester composition is subjected to a step of pre-
polycondensation.
Thereto, the pressure is reduced and, optionally, a polycondensation catalyst
is added. The
pre-polycondensation step is used to remove excess or unreacted ethylene
glycol and to
reduce the pressure to remove most of the other volatiles, while avoiding
excessive foaming
5 or carryover into the vacuum lines. The temperature is raised and the
polycondensation
reaction begins to occur, with liberation and removal of ethylene glycol which
is generated via
reaction. It is important to note that the esterification reaction also
continues, generating water
which is also removed from the reaction mixture. In very small batch equipment
the same
reactor may be used for all stages of the reaction. When the reaction is
performed in larger
10 scale batch equipment this stage may completed in the same equipment as
the esterification
reaction, and after this stage the reactant mixture may then be transferred to
a vessel
especially designed for good mass transfer to promote the polycondensation
reaction.
Alternatively, the reactant mixture may be moved to a different vessel prior
to initiating the
pressure let-down and the pre-polycondensation and the polycondensation are
then
conducted in a single vessel. The addition of polycondensation catalyst may
already have
occurred at the start of the esterification reaction, so that no further
addition of the catalyst to
the esterification product is desired at this point.
Other compounds, such as stabilizing agents, may also be added prior to the
esterification or prior to the polycondensation. The stabilizing agents may
include
antioxidants. Preferable antioxidants are phosphite-containing compounds,
phosphate
compounds, phosphonate compounds, and hindered phenolic compounds.
Antioxidants
include such compounds as trialkyl phosphites, mixed alkyl/aryl phosphites,
alkylated aryl
phosphites, sterically hindered aryl phosphites, aliphatic spirocyclic
phosphites, sterically
hindered phenyl spirocyclics, sterically hindered bisphosphonites, alkyl
phosphates, aryl
phosphates, mixed alkyl/aryl phosphates, alkylphosphonoacetates, hydroxyphenyl
propionates, hydroxy benzyls, alkyl phenols, aromatic amines, hindered amines,
hydroquinones and mixtures thereof. Such other compounds may also be added in
batch or
any other type of operation. Hence compositions comprising the polyester
according to the
invention may comprise such compounds.
In a more continuous operation the pre-polycondensation reaction may be
conducted
in a dedicated vessel, typically with the overhead vapors being collected
separately from the
vapors generated during the esterification stage. During this process stage
the pressure is
typically reduced from approximately 1 bar or more used during esterification
down to about
20 to 700 mbar, and more preferably to about 20 to 100 mbar. The duration of
the pre-
polycondensation is suitably in the range of 0 5 to 2 hours.
At this point the ester composition is subjected to a step of
polycondensation. As is
known from the prior art the pressure at this step is further reduced.
Pressures of less than
about 5 mbar and preferably less than about 3 mbar may be applied. Lower
pressures are
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
11
preferred for good mass transfer and removal of ethylene glycol and water
being liberated in
the polycondensation and esterification reactions, respectively.
Polycondensation
temperatures according to the prior art include about 180 to 280 C. The
polycondensation
according to the invention is preferably carried out at a temperature of 245
to 270 C and
suitably at a pressure of 0.05 to 5 mbar. Under these conditions it is ensured
that the ester
composition as well as the polycondensate formed is in a molten stage. The
polycondensation is suitably continued for a period ranging from 1 to 3 hours.
Preferably, the
combined period for the pre-polycondensation and the polycondensation stages
is in the
range of 1.5 to 4 hours.
The polycondensation may be terminated when the desired intrinsic viscosity
has
been reached. This can be monitored by measuring the torque of a stirrer that
is provided in
the reactor wherein the polycondensation is being carried out. It can also be
monitored, for
example, by a melt viscometer at the outlet of the reactor in a continuous
process
arrangement. When the viscosity is sufficiently high, the polycondensation is
stopped and the
product is discharged, yielding the polycondensate.
As indicated above, the polycondensation is preferably carried out in the
presence of a
polycondensation catalyst. Many polycondensation catalysts may be used. Such
catalysts
include the catalysts comprising one or more elements selected from tin, zinc,
titanium,
antimony, calcium, manganese, cobalt, hafnium, lead, magnesium, aluminium,
cerium,
zirconium and mixtures thereof. These compounds may be the acetate or
carbonate salts of
these metals. Alternatively, metal alkoxides, alkyl metal compounds, or other
organometallic
compounds are also possible. Other suitable catalysts include the oxides and
halides of the
elements mentioned. Preferred catalysts include titanium alkoxides, antimony
acetate,
antimony oxide, and antimony glycolate, i.e. the reaction product of antimony
oxide and
ethylene glycol. The amounts of the polycondensation catalyst are typically in
the range of
0.005 mol% to 0.2 mol%, based on the number of moles of 2,5-furandicarboxylic
acid in the
starting mixture, preferably in the range of 0.01 to 0.10 mol%.
The polycondensation catalysts may be added to the ester composition when the
ester composition has been formed. It is also possible to add the
polycondensation catalyst to
the starting mixture of 2,5-fu ran dicarboxylic acid and ethylene glycol,
optionally in the
presence of an esterification catalyst. The esterification catalyst, if
present, is suitably present
in an amount of 0.005 mol% to 0.2 mol%, based on the number of moles of 2,5-
furandicarboxylic acid in the starting mixture, preferably in the range of
0.02 to 0.15 mol%.
When the polycondensation catalyst is added in the starting mixture the ester
composition
formed is suitably not isolated, but after forming of the ester composition,
the resulting
product is kept in the reaction zone where the esterification took place, and
the product is
used as such in the polycondensation step. Hence, the semi-crystalline
starting polyester
used in the process of the present invention preferably further comprises one
or more
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
12
esterification and/or polycondensation catalysts. The catalysts are suitably
as described
above, the esterification and/or polycondensation catalysts preferably having
been selected
from the esterification and polycondensation catalysts comprising a metal
selected form the
group consisting of titanium, tin, calcium, antimony, germanium, manganese,
cobalt, lead,
magnesium, aluminium, cerium, zirconium and hafnium.
When the temperature in the polycondensation step has been lowered to
terminate
the polycondensation, the polycondensate obtained will solidify. The
polycondensate thus
obtained is suitably subjected to the heat treatment as described above before
it is used in
the solid state polymerization at a temperature of (Tm-40 C) to Tm.
Poly(ethylene 2,5-furandicarboxylate) is a slowly crystallizing polyester
under
quiescent conditions. Nucleating agents may be added to the polyester to
increase the
nucleation density, and thereby increase the overall crystallization rate
under quiescent
conditions.
For crystallization of the polyester used in the process according to the
present
invention, typically prior to an SSP process, crystallization may be conducted
from the melt
(as may be done in an underwater pelletizer with in-situ crystallization) or
from the glassy
state (after cooling of polymer granulates). To this end it may be desirable
to add a nucleating
agent to the polyester after the polycondensation, typically still in the melt
phase. Typical
addition levels will be from 0.05 ¨ 2 wt%, or more preferably 0.1 to 1 wt%,
based on the total
polyester. The inorganic minerals may be added at higher levels, such as up to
5 or even 10
wt% if desired.
Nucleating agents may include inorganic minerals, organic salts, high melting
waxes,
or other polymers. Examples of inorganic minerals include talc, titanium
dioxide, fused silica,
boron nitride, mica, and calcium carbonate. Some examples of the organic salts
sodium
stearate, zinc stearate, other stearate salts, salts of other fatty acids,
FDCA disodium salt,
sodium salt of saccharine, salts of benzoic acid, aromatic phosphonates,
sulfonic acid ester
salts of isophthalic acid, and commercial materials such as bis(4-
propylbenzylidene) propyl
sorbitol, available as MilladONX88 from Milliken Chemicals and 3,4-
Dimethylbenzylidene
sorbitol, available as Millad03988, phosphate salts and esters, available as
NA-11, methylen-
bis(4,6-di-t-butylphenyl)phosphate sodium salt, or NA-21, aluminium-hydroxy-
bis[2,2"-
methylene-bis(4,6-di-t-butyl-phenyl)-phosphate. High melting waxes include
materials such as
stearamides and erucamides, or bis-amides. Polymers can include materials such
as
ionomers e.g. Surlyn ionomers from Du Pont, or Aculyn ionomers from Rohm and
Haas,
PEG2000 (polyethylene glycol), PET, PBT or others. Nucleating agents may also
be used in
the crystallization of polymers in different situations. Polymer
crystallization can be conducted
for a number of reasons, each of which would then be performed under different
conditions.
For example, to create a semi-crystalline part in an injection molding machine
it would be
required to have a rapid crystallization of the polymer during cooling from
the melt. On the
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
13
other hand, for crystallization of material prior to drying of reclaimed
scrap, it would be desired
to have the polymer crystallize rapidly from the glassy state, or on the up-
heat.
It has been found that it is very advantageous to treat the polycondensate
thus
obtained to a pelletizing step, such that solid particles are obtained.
Thereto, the melt may be
passed through a die yielding strands which are cooled in water and that are
cut into small
particles. Such particles are typically of uniform size and cylindrical in
shape. The melt may
also be subjected to a process known as "under water pelletization" or "die
face cutting",
wherein the melt is passed through a die, with a multitude of holes, which is
in contact on one
side with a cooling medium, such as water, and a rotating hub of cutters is
used to cut the
emerging melt to form pellets. Such particles are typically of uniform size
and nearly
spherical. Other methods can also be used. As an example, solid chips of
polycondensate
may be ground to small particles. The particles are suitably such that the
average number of
particles per gram is in the range of 40 to 350 particles per gram. Typically
such a particle
size boils down to polyester particles with a mass of 2.8 to 28 mg.
It has surprisingly been found that the solid state polymerization proceeds at
a higher
rate with the starting polyesters that are used in the process of this
invention. In particular,
starting polyesters which are outside of the subject of this invention have
been found to
undergo solid state polymerization at a reasonably rate when the particle size
is very small,
but to have very slow solid state polymerization for particle sizes which are
greater than about
2 mg, or fewer than 500 particles per gram. This being the case, it allows the
skilled person to
select the most feasible particle size of the polyester in order to subject it
to solid state
polymerization. Suitably, the particle size is selected such that there are 40
to 350 particles
per gram. Typically such a particle size boils down to polyester particles
with a mass of 2.8 to
28 mg. Such particles can easily be prepared directly from the polycondensate
and still
provide a good polymerization rate when they are subjected to solid state
polymerization.
Such particles are suitable for pneumatic conveyance, can been conveniently
dried with gas
flow, and can be suitably melted in typical polymer extrusion equipment,
without undue risks
due to, for example, excessive dust. The heat treatment at a temperature of 90
to 160 C that
has been described above is preferably conducted with the particles of the
polycondensate.
When starting polyesters are subjected to the process of the invention it is
possible to
obtain lift rates, determined as the increase in IV in dL/g per hour, of
greater than 0.0040
dL/g.hr, and more preferably greater than 0.0080 dL/g.hr.
The semi-crystalline starting polyester in the process according to the
present
invention is brought to a temperature in the range of (Tm-40 C) to Tm.
Suitably the polyester
is heated at a temperature in the range of (Tm-40 C) to Tm for a period of at
most 120 hr,
preferably from2 to 60 hr. This represents a significant reduction in time
compared to the
exemplified solid state polymerizations in WO 2010/077133 and WO 2013/062408.
The solid
state temperatures that are applied in the process according to the present
invention are also
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
14
higher than those applied in US 2009/0124763. Whereas the temperatures of the
solid state
polymerizations according to US 2009/0124763 are in the range of 140 to 180
C, the ranges
of (Tm-40 C) to Tm in the process according to the invention will mean that
the semi-
crystalline starting polyester is suitably heated to a temperature in the
range of 180 to 220 C,
more preferably from 185 to 210 C to obtain the solid stated polyester. As
indicated above,
the values for Tm are preferably from 200 to 220 C, and may even be as high
as 245 C.
The solid stating is suitably carried out at atmospheric pressure in the
presence of an
inert gas flow, in particular nitrogen, argon, helium or neon. Alternatively,
the solid stating may
be conducted at pressures below atmospheric, e.g. at pressures below 100 mbar,
more
preferably below 20 mbar.
Reactors, equipment, and controls for the solid state polymerization of
poly(ethylene
terephthalate) such as described in the book Modern Polyesters: Chemistry and
Technology
of Polyesters and Copolyesters by J. Scheirs and T.E. Long (eds.), Wiley,
2003, can also be
used to advantage for the solid state polymerization of the present invention.
When
conducted in an atmospheric pressure process with inert gas flow the inert gas
is preferably
subjected to a gas cleaning step after it has passed through the particles, in
order to be
efficiently recycled. Applicants have found that the solid state
polymerization can slow to
unacceptable rates at very long times, and in such cases, if the desired final
IV has not yet
been obtained then it can be helpful to stop the process, subject the resin to
extrusion and
pelletizing, then begin the crystallization and solid state polymerization
anew.
The invention will be further illustrated by means of the following examples.
EXAMPLE 1
In a first series of experiments, a polyester was used that was prepared from
the
dimethyl ester of FDCA with a large excess of ethylene glycol compared to the
diester of
FDCA, to prepare a purified bis(2-hydroxyethyl)-2,5-furandicarboxylate. This
was subjected to
polycondensation in the presence of 300 ppm of antimony as a polycondensation
catalyst,
yielding a poly(ethylene-2,5-furan dicarboxylate) with a number average
molecular weight
(Mn) of about 15,000, corresponding with an IV of 0.42 dl/g. The amount of
carboxylic acid
end groups (CEG) the polyester was assessed to be less than 10 meq/kg and the
amount of
hydroxyl end groups(HEG) was assessed at > 160 meq/kg. The relative content,
expressed
as CEG/(CEG+HEG) was less than 0.06. The polyester was divided in fractions of
different
particle size ranges. The fractions were subjected to solid state
polymerization at a
temperature of about 200 C for a period of up to 8 hours. For each fraction
the Mn was
determined during the polymerization and an equivalent IV was determined using
the
equation IV (dL/g) = 1.62*10-41A n0.820. The results are shown in Table 1.
In a second series of experiments a poly(ethylene-2,5-furan dicarboxylate)
prepared
from MEG and FDCA having an Mn of about 17,000, corresponding with an IV of
about 0.49
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
dL/g, was subjected to solid state polymerization under the same conditions as
applied in the
first series of experiments, including a solid state polymerization
temperature of 200 C. Also
in this case fractions of different particle sizes were used. The polyester
had an amount of
CEG of 66 meq/kg and an assessed amount of HEG of 87 meq/kg. The relative
content,
5 expressed as CEG/(CEG+HEG) was about 0.43. The results are also shown in
Table 2.
Table 1
Polyester with CEG of less than 10
Mn and IV of fractions after solid state polymerization
Fractions, mm ¨> 0.6-1.4 0.3-0.4 0.1-0.2
Time, hrl
Mn IV Mn IV Mn IV
0 14,700 0.423 14,700 0.423 14,700 0.423
2 16,500 0.465 21,500 0.578 22,400 0.598
8 18,500 0.511 25,200 0.659 29,400 0.747
Table 2
Polyester with CEG of 66 meq/kg,
Mn and IV of fractions after solid state polymerization
Fractions, mm 0.6-1.4 0.3-0.4 0.1-0.2
Time, hr
Mn IV Mn IV Mn IV
0 17,500 0.488 17,500 0.488 17,500 0.488
2 19,800 0.540 22,400 0.598 23,100 0.613
8 30,500 0.770 30,700 0.774 30,400 0.768
10 From a comparison between the results of Tables 1 and 2 it is apparent
that although
the solid state polymerization rates are similar for the very smallest
particles (0.1-0.2 mm
fraction), when the particle size is increased the solid state polymerization
rate of the
polyester with CEG/(CEG+HEG) of 0.43 and CEG of 66 meq/kg performs far better
than the
comparative polyester. For reference, a spherical pellet with 1 mm diameter
would have a
15 weight of 0.75 mg, or contain 1300 particles/gram.
EXAMPLE 2
Ethylene glycol (MEG) and 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) were mixed in an
MEG:FDCA molar ratio of 1.12 along with Sb203 as a catalyst, present at 314
ppm of
antimony. The reaction mixture further contained 80 ppm (0.09 mmol/mol) of
tetraethylammoniumhydroxide (TEAOH). The mixture was subjected to
esterification without
addition of an esterification catalyst for a period of time (te) at elevated
temperature. Water
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806 PCT/NL2015/050153
16
that was formed was evaporated and passed into a distillation column. The
condensed water
was removed and any MEG that was entrained or evaporated was recycled back to
the
reaction mixture. The reaction was continued at atmospheric pressure until 80%
of the
theoretical water, based on furandicarboxylic acid feed, was collected. The
temperature at
that time was 214 C and the reaction time was 175 minutes. The pressure was
reduced, and
prepolycondensation was started, the pressure reaching 20 mbar in
approximately 80
minutes. The vacuum take-off point was switched at this point so that any
additional ethylene
glycol could be removed without passing through the distillation column. The
pressure was
further reduced to below 5 mbar. The ester composition with the catalyst was
subjected to a
polycondensation at a temperature of 261 C for 150 minutes. The intrinsic
viscosity (IV) was
about 0.61 dUg. The relative CEG was determined as CEG/(CEG + HEG). The
acetaldehyde
content was well above 15 ppm. The reaction conditions and the results are
shown in Table
3.
Table 3
Esterification Polycondens. IV, dug P rate rel.
HEG, CEG,
MEG! T, C te, EsPo T, Tp, min CEG meq/kg meq/kg
FDCA min C
1.12 214 175 0.29 261 150 0.61 4.06 0.30 59 25
The polycondensate above, having an IV of 0.61 dig, a relative CEG ratio of
0.30,
and an absolute CEG content of 25 meq/kg, was crystallized by increasing its
temperature to
125 C and holding for about 1 hour, after which the material was cooled and
any
agglomerates were broken up. The material was then heated to 170 C and held
for about 3
hrs, followed by a temperature ramp to 195 C (at a rate of 12.5 C/hr) and
holding for about
12 hours. The material thus obtained exhibited a peak melting point of 204 C
and a
crystallinity of 50 J/g as determined by DSC. The material was loaded into a
rotary vacuum
tumble dryer and subjected to solid state polymerization by heating under
vacuum to 190-195
C. The chips were sampled periodically, with the results shown in Table 4
below. In the
Table the intrinsic viscosity (IV), the peak melting point (T peak) and the
crystallinity (dHm)
are shown at loading into the tumble dryer and after 13 and 50 hours in the
tumble dryer,
respectively. The Table further shows the rate of the increase of the IV,
expressed in dUg.hr
(also known as the lift rate).
Table 4
Time (hrs) IV, dUg Lift rate (from T peak, C dHm, J/g
t=0 hrs) dL/g.hr
0 0.56 204 50
13 0.67 0.0085 209 58
50 0.79 0.0046 217 66
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
17
The experiment shows that the heat treatment in the solid state results in an
increased
molecular weight, as shown by the increase in intrinsic viscosity, and in a
higher crystallinity
as shown by the higher value in the DSC measurement. The pellets had a size in
the range of
40-350 pellets/gram. The acetaldehyde content of the polyester after the solid
state
polymerization had an acetaldehyde content of 0.3 mg/kg (ppm). The diethylene
glycol
content was 0.044 mole/mole FDCA. The final CEG content was 11 meq/kg, as
determined
by titration. The decarboxylated end group content was 14 meq/kg, as
determined by NMR.
COMPARATIVE EXPERIMENT 1
An furandicarboxylate-based polymer was prepared starting from a starting
mixture
comprising the dimethylester of FDCA and ethylene glycol in a molar ratio of
1:2.0 in the
presence of 120 ppm of zinc (added as acetate) as a transesterification
catalyst and 300 ppm
of antimony (added as glycolate) for the esterification. This experiment is
according to the
teachings of WO 2013/120989. During the transesterification methanol formed
was removed
and any evaporated ethylene glycol was recycled to the reaction mixture. The
transesterification continued for 2 hours at a maximum of 21000 The mixture
obtained after
2 hrs was subjected to a pressure reduction and prepolycondensation at 390 to
530 mbar and
a temperature of 210 C for 2 hrs, and subsequently to polycondensation at a
pressure of less
than 2 mbar and a temperature of 240 C for 4 hrs. After melt polymerization
the material had
an IV of 0.33 dlig, a relative CEG ratio of less than 0.05, and an absolute
CEG content of 9
meq/kg. The methyl ester content was 13 meq/kg. The H EG content was greater
than 200
meq/kg. The acetaldehyde content was well above 15 ppm. It appeared that the
process took
over 8 hours to obtain a relatively low molecular weight polyester.
The material was sieved to remove the dust and long particles, as significant
dust was
present. The material was then heated in a rotary vacuum drum dryer, to dry,
crystallize, and
solid state the chips. Table 5 below shows the progress. The material was
heated to 180-
195 C, but agglomeration was significant and the material needed to be
frequently
discharged to break up agglomerates.
CA 02941491 2016-09-01
WO 2015/137806
PCT/NL2015/050153
18
Table 5
Time (hrs) IV, dug Lift rate (from T peak, C dHm,
J/g
t=0 hrs) dL/g.hr
0 0.33 211 41
142 211 55
330 0.49 0.0005 217 78
400 0.52 0.0005 220 74
570 0.61 0.0005 229 86
828 0.68 0.0004 228 87
972 0.76 0.0004 231 87
Table 5 shows that the polyesters that do not have the desired amount of
carboxylic
acid end groups can only be polymerized to the desired molecular weight by
exposing the
polyester to solid state conditions for a very long time and exhibit a very
low lift rate. The
pellets had a size in the range of 40-350 pellets/gram. It was not until after
972 hours that the
acetaldehyde content was measured to be 0.5 ppm and the final CEG content was
3 meq/kg.
