Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
1
EPDXY FUNCTIONAL COMPOSITION PROTECTING DYES FROM PHOTO-DEGRADATION
AND CURED COATINGS PREPARED THEREFROM
The present invention relates to curable epoxy functional compositions
containing an
absorbing dye blocking wavelengths which may present an impact on the health
in which the
dye presents improved photo-resistance properties, to epoxy-based coatings
obtained
therefrom, and to optical articles, in particular ophthalmic lenses,
containing such a coating.
In the optics field, it is usual to coat articles with coatings so as to
impart the articles
various mechanical and/or optical properties. Thus, classically, coatings such
as impact-
resistant, anti-abrasion/scratch-resistant and/or antireflection coatings are
successively formed
onto an ophthalmic lens.
It may be desirable to impart a filtering function to the optical article so
as to prevent or
limit transmission of specific wavelengths of light, especially harmful light
to the retina, but this
should be done without modifying its properties such as abrasion resistance,
transparency or
adhesion of the coatings.
Indeed, visible light as perceived by humans approximately extends over a
spectrum
ranging from a 380 nm wavelength to a 780 nm wavelength. The part of this
spectrum ranging
from around 400 nm to around 500 nm does correspond to high-energy
wavelengths,
essentially blue light.
Many studies (see for example Kitchel E., "The effects of blue light on ocular
health",
Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness Vol. 94, No. 6, 2000 or Glazer-
Hockstein and al.,
Retina, Vol. 26, No. 1. pp. 1-4, 2006) suggest that part of the blue light has
phototoxic effects on
human eye health, and especially on the retina. Ocular photobiology studies
demonstrated that
an excessively prolonged or intense exposure to blue light may induce severe
ophthalmic
diseases such as age-related macular degeneration (ARMD) or cataract. Some
studies are for
example described in the paper titled "Phototoxic Action Spectrum on a retinal
Pigment
Epithelium model of Age-Related macular Degeneration Exposed to Sunlight
Normalized
Conditions", by author Arnault, Barrau et al. Published on August 23, 2013 on
the plosone.org
website. Thus, it is recommended to limit the exposure to blue light
potentially harmful, in
particular as regards the wavelength band with an increased dangerousness (420-
450 nm).
Incorporating in a coating an optical filtering dye able to cut specific
ranges of
wavelengths can be difficult, as it is necessary to adapt the formulation of
the optical coating
composition. It is especially difficult to get a transparent coating without
haze, due to poor
solubility of dyes, and the adaptation of the formulation in order to
solubilize the dyes might
modify the properties of the coating.
Another problem is that most of absorbing dyes used for making coatings with
optical
filtering capability, and in particular yellow dyes, show photostability
issues when exposed to the
UV rays and/or sunlight.
Several references such as J. C. V. P. Moura, A. M. F. Oliveira-Campos, J.
Griffiths,
Dyes and Pigments, 33(3), 1997, 173-196 are related to the effect of additives
on the
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
2
photostability of dyes in polymers. The article Y. Yang, G. Qian, D. Su, M.
Wang, Optics
Communications, 239 (4-6), 2004, 415-420 suggests the use of photostable
additives including
1,4-diazobicyclo[2,2,2]octane (DABCO), 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (TMP) and
coumarin 440
in order to improve the photostability of the dye pyrromethene 567 in silicate
coatings. WO
2008/146087 discloses inks and coatings for the production of oxygen sensitive
elements with
improved photostability, using selected photostabilizers.
However, using this traditional stabilization approach by antioxidants, UV
absorbers etc.
can be very detrimental to the final coating performances when a significant
amount of those
additives is employed, which may lead to a decrease of coating hardness,
rigidity, optical clarity,
etc. In addition, some UV absorbers may interact with the epoxy resin or dye
molecule during a
curing process, leading to changes in the absorption wavelength range of the
dye, or cause
solubility or coating haze issues.
US 2009/0311518 discloses an abrasion resistant photocurable acrylic coating
composition that can provide good adhesion to subsequent coatings deposited
thereon,
comprising three different acrylate compounds, at least one compound having at
least two
epoxy groups and that does not comprise any silicon atom bearing hydrolysable
groups or
hydroxyl groups, a hydrolyzate of an epoxysilane having from 2 to 6 functional
groups
generating a silanol group under hydrolysis, at least one non polymerizable
ether compound
and initiators.
WO 02/08309 discloses a cationically polymerizable or crosslinkable
composition
comprising an onium gallate compound as the initiator for the cationic
polymerization, and
reactive epoxy containing compounds, vinyl ether containing compounds and/or
cyclic ethers
containing compounds. Various epoxy compounds comprising at least one
cycloaliphatic or aryl
group are disclosed.
However, these patent applications are not concerned with the photo-
degradation or
photostability of dyes.
In view of the foregoing, there is a need for an optical article capable of at
least partially
blocking transmission of light in the blue wavelength range of the light
spectrum without
affecting the functional properties of other coatings. The process for
manufacturing such an
article should be simple, easy to implement and reproducible. It is also
desirable that the optical
article selectively blocks a relatively narrow range of the spectrum, and
exhibits a low level of
yellowness.
Another objective is to obtain an optical filtering coating having an improved
resistance
to photo-degradation and an improved cosmetic appearance such as low haze.
The inventors discovered that improved photostability of dyes contained in a
coating
could be achieved by using specific reactive compounds (monomers) in the epoxy
series. In
addition, the selected epoxy reactive compounds showed good compatibility with
dyes, leading
to low haze coatings.
To address the needs of the present invention and to remedy to the mentioned
drawbacks of the prior art, the applicant provides an optical filtering
coating composition,
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
3
comprising at least one dye that at least partially inhibits transmission of
light within the 380 nm
- 780 nm wavelength range, and has a conjugated chromophore, one or more epoxy
compounds comprising at least one cycloaliphatic or aryl group, the ratio of
the number of
carbon atoms / the number of oxygen atoms in said epoxy compound being higher
than or
equal to 3, and the dry extract weight of such epoxy compounds present in the
composition
representing more than 33 % of the dry extract weight of the composition.
In one embodiment, the dye that at least partially inhibits transmission of
light within the
380 nm - 780 nm wavelength range, and has a conjugated chromophore is at least
one
absorbing dye that has a conjugated chromophore and at least partially
inhibits transmission of
light in at least one selected wavelength range included within the 400 nm -
500 nm wavelength
range.
The coating composition of the present invention, which is mainly based on
epoxy
monomers, can be applied on the main surface of the substrate of an optical
article. In this
regard, the invention also relates to an optical article having at least one
main surface
comprising a coating obtained by depositing on a substrate and curing the
composition
mentioned above.
The present invention thus uses a specific coating dedicated to the filtering
function,
which avoids modifying the added values provided by the other functional
coatings that may be
traditionally present at the surface of the optical article.
As used herein, when an article comprises one or more layer(s) or coating(s)
on the
surface thereof, "depositing a layer or a coating onto the article" means that
a layer or a coating
is deposited onto the uncovered (exposed) surface of the article external
coating, that is to say
the coating that is the most distant from the substrate.
As used herein, a coating that is "on" a substrate/coating or which has been
deposited
"onto" a substrate/coating is defined as a coating that (i) is positioned
above the
substrate/coating, (ii) is not necessarily in contact with the
substrate/coating, that is to say one
or more intermediate coating(s) may be interleaved between the
substrate/coating and the
relevant coating (however, it does preferably contact said substrate/coating),
and (iii) does not
necessarily completely cover the substrate/coating. When a coating 1 is said
to be located
"under" a coating 2, it should be understood that coating 2 is more distant
from the substrate
than coating 1.
The optical article according to the invention is preferably a transparent
optical article, in
particular an optical lens or lens blank, more preferably an ophthalmic lens
or lens blank.
The term "ophthalmic lens" is used to mean a lens adapted to a spectacle frame
to
protect the eye and/or correct the sight. Said lens can be chosen from afocal,
unifocal, bifocal,
trifocal and progressive lenses. Although ophthalmic optics is a preferred
field of the invention, it
will be understood that this invention can be applied to optical elements of
other types where
filtering specified wavelengths may be beneficial, such as, for example,
lenses for optical
instruments, safety goggles, filters particularly for photography, astronomy
or the automobile
industry, optical sighting lenses, ocular visors, optics of lighting systems,
screens, glazings, etc.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
4
If the optical article is an optical lens, it may be coated on its front main
surface, rear
main side, or both sides with the coating of the invention. As used herein,
the rear face of the
substrate is intended to mean the face which, when using the article, is the
nearest from the
wearer's eye. It is generally a concave face. On the contrary, the front face
of the substrate is
the face which, when using the article, is the most distant from the wearer's
eye. It is generally a
convex face. The optical article can also be a piano article.
A substrate, in the sense of the present invention, should be understood to
mean an
uncoated substrate, and generally has two main faces. The substrate may in
particular be an
optically transparent material having the shape of an optical article, for
example an ophthalmic
lens destined to be mounted in glasses. In this context, the term "substrate"
is understood to
mean the base constituent material of the optical lens and more particularly
of the ophthalmic
lens. This material acts as support for a stack of one or more functional
coatings or layers.
The substrate of the optical article, coated on at least one main face with a
coating
according to the invention, may be a mineral or an organic glass, for instance
an organic glass
made from a thermoplastic or thermosetting plastic, generally chosen from
transparent materials
of ophthalmic grade used in the ophthalmic industry.
To be mentioned as especially preferred classes of substrate materials are
polycarbonates, polyamides, polyimides, polysulfones, copolymers of
polyethylene
therephthalate and polycarbonate, polyolefins such as polynorbornenes, resins
resulting from
polymerization or (co)polymerization of alkylene glycol bis allyl carbonates
such as polymers
and copolymers of diethylene glycol bis(allylcarbonate) (marketed, for
instance, under the trade
name CR-39 by the PPG Industries company, the corresponding marketed lenses
being
referred to as ORMA lenses from ESSILOR), polycarbonates such as those
derived from
bisphenol A, (meth)acrylic or thio(meth)acrylic polymers and copolymers such
as polymethyl
methacrylate (PMMA), urethane and thiourethane polymers and copolymers, epoxy
polymers
and copolymers, episulfide polymers and copolymers.
Prior to depositing coatings, the surface of the substrate is usually
submitted to a
physical or chemical surface activating and cleaning treatment, so as to
improve the adhesion
of the layer to be deposited, such as disclosed in WO 2013/013929.
The coating according to the invention is an epoxy coating, resulting from the
polymerization of at least one epoxy compound according to the invention,
i.e., a compound
comprising at least one epoxy group and at least one cycloaliphatic or aryl
group and having a
specific 0/0 atom ratio. Said ratio: number of carbon atoms / number of oxygen
atoms in the
epoxy compound is higher than or equal to 3, preferably higher than or equal
to 3.5.
The finding that epoxy compounds according to the invention provide benefits
in terms of
the photostability of dyes is quite surprising. Epoxy compounds according to
the invention can
be seen as electron poor epoxy compounds due to their structure and high 0/0
ratio. Without
wishing to by bound by theory, it is believed that electron rich epoxy
compounds are responsible
for dye photo-degradation and that the coatings according to the invention
show lower dye
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
photo-degradation as they contain less polymer chains obtained from electron
rich epoxy
compounds.
Further, the epoxy compounds according to the invention provide non-polar and
electron
poor groups/segments in the polymer network, which are compatible with most of
absorbing
5
dyes, leading to compositions that provide, upon curing, transparent clear
coatings with low
haze.
The epoxy compounds according to the invention are cyclic ethers and are
preferably
epoxides (oxiranes). As used herein, the term epoxide represents a subclass of
epoxy
compounds containing a saturated three-membered cyclic ether.
The term "aryl" denotes an aromatic carbocyclic radical comprising only one
ring (for
example a phenyl group) or several, optionally fused, rings (for example
naphthyl or terphenyl
groups), which may optionally be substituted with one or more groups such as,
without limitation,
alkyl (for example methyl), hydroxyalkyl, aminoalkyl, hydroxyl, thiol, amino,
halo (fluor , bromo,
iodo or chloro), nitro, alkylthio, alkoxy (for example methoxy), aryloxy,
monoalkylamino,
dialkylamino, acyl, carboxyl, alkoxycarbonyl, aryloxycarbonyl,
hydroxysulfonyl, alkoxysulfonyl,
aryloxysulfonyl, alkylsulfonyl, alkylsulfinyl, cyano, trifluoromethyl,
tetrazolyl, carbamoyl,
alkylcarbamoyl or dialkylcarbamoyl groups. Alternatively, two adjacent
positions of the aromatic
ring may be substituted with a methylenedioxy or ethylenedioxy group.
The term "aryl" also includes "heteroaryl" groups, i.e. aromatic rings in
which one or
more carbon atoms of the aromatic ring(s) have been replaced with a heteroatom
such as
nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus or sulfur.
The term "cycloaliphatic" denotes a saturated or unsaturated but non aromatic
carbocyclic radical comprising one or several optionally fused rings, which
may optionally be
substituted with one or more of the groups cited above for the aryl group. The
term
"cycloaliphatic" also includes "heterocycloaliphatic" groups, i.e. non-
aromatic monocyclic or
polycyclic rings in which one or more carbon atoms of the ring(s) have been
replaced with a
heteroatom such as nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus or sulfur. The cycloaliphatic
group is
preferably a cycloalkyl group.
The dry extract of a compound or composition is the total weight of the
compound or
composition after the full removal of volatile solvent(s) at 100 C to 110 C in
an oven. The dry
extract is also called solids content, percent nonvolatile material by weight
or %NVM. Traditional
procedures to determine solids take 60 min at 105 C to 110 C in an oven, and
require both pre-
and post weighing of the sample pan and sample (ASTM designations: D2369 and
D2926-80).
The new procedures using the commercial Mark 3 solids analyzer purchased from
Sartorius, or
SMART TurboTm purchased from OEM, take only 2 to 10 minutes, depending on the
volatile/moisture content and viscosity of the material.
Also, the dry extract can be theoretically calculated, for example as
described in
EP614957. The dry extract of epoxies having no hydrolysable groups is their
own weight.
The epoxy coating comprises epoxy compounds having at least one cycloaliphatic
or
aryl group and a 0/0 ratio higher than or equal to 3 in such an amount that
the dry extract
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
6
weight of those epoxy compounds represents more than 33 % of the dry extract
weight of the
composition, preferably at least 40 %, at least 50 %, at least 60 %, at least
70 %, at least 80 %,
at least 90 % or at least 95 % of the dry extract weight of the composition.
The composition according to the invention preferably comprises at least 30 %
by weight
of epoxy compounds comprising at least one cycloaliphatic or aryl group and
having a 0/0 ratio
3, relative to the total weight of epoxy compounds in the composition, more
preferably at
least 40 %, at least 50 %, at least 60 %, at least 70 %, at least 80 %, or at
least 90 % by weight.
In one embodiment, the composition comprises 100 % by weight of epoxy
compounds
according to the invention, i.e., epoxy compounds comprising at least one
cycloaliphatic or aryl
group and having a 0/0 ratio E 3, relative to the total weight of epoxy
compounds in the
composition.
The dry extract weight of epoxy compounds that do not comprise any silicon
atom
having at least one hydrolyzable group directly linked to the silicon atom
preferably represents
more than 45 % of the dry extract weight of the composition, more preferably
at least 50 %, at
least 60 %, at least 70 %, at least 80 %, at least 90 % or 100 % of the dry
extract weight of the
composition.
The composition according to the invention preferably comprises at least 40 %
by weight
of epoxy compounds that do not comprise any silicon atom having at least one
hydrolyzable
group directly linked to the silicon atom, relative to the total weight of
epoxy compounds in the
composition, more preferably at least 45 %, at least 50 %, at least 60 %, at
least 70 %, at least
80 %, at least 90 % by weight or 100 % by weight.
The epoxy compounds according to the invention preferably comprise at least
two epoxy
groups. Generally, these compounds contain 2 to 3 epoxy groups per molecule,
albeit
polyfunctional epoxy compounds containing more than 3 epoxy groups per
molecule (generally
4-8) can also be used in addition to or in replacement of epoxy compounds
containing 2 to 3
epoxy groups. Preferably, they contain no more than 4, better no more than 3
epoxy groups,
and even better are diepoxydes.
In one embodiment, the epoxy compounds according to the invention do not
comprise
any silicon atom having at least one hydrolyzable group directly linked to the
silicon atom. More
preferably, epoxy compounds according to the invention do not contain other
reactive function
than the epoxy group(s), capable of reacting with other polymerizable
functions present in the
composition and that would be linked to the polymer matrix of the coating. In
other words,
preferred epoxy compounds are "pure" epoxy compounds.
The epoxy compound according to the invention preferably comprises at least
one of a
glycidyl ether group (preferably an aryl glycidyl ether group) and a [3-(3,4-
epoxycyclohexyl)alkyl
group such as the [3-(3,4-epoxycyclohexyl)methyl and [3-(3,4-
epoxycyclohexyl)ethyl groups.
Glycidyl ethers are synthetic compounds characterized by the following group
in which R1
denotes a monovalent group:
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
7
R1
The preferred epoxy compounds comprising at least one cycloaliphatic group
preferably
comprise at least one group selected from the groups:
"ij/C; I -DO
id
o
in which the hydrogen atoms in the structures may be substituted by one or
more substituents
such as those cited above as substituents for an aryl group.
Examples of suitable epoxy compounds, with their trade names and formulae
where
applicable include 3',4'-epoxycyclohexylmethy1-3,4-epoxycyclohexane
carboxylate (0/0 = 3.5,
Uvacure 1500 from UCB Chemicals, Cyracure UVR-6110 and UVR 6105 from Union
Carbide, formula Xq), bis (2,3-epoxy cyclopentyl) ether (C/0 = 3.3, formula
Xr), bis (3,4-
epoxycyclohexylmethyl) adipate (C/0 = 3.3, UVR-6128 from Dow Chemical Company,
formula
Xd), vinyl cyclohexene dioxide (3-(oxiran-2-yI)-7-oxabicyclo[4.1.0]heptane,
C/0 = 4, formula Xs),
limonene diepoxide (6-methy1-3-(2-methyloxiran-2-y1)-7-
oxabicyclo[4.1.0]heptane, C/0 = 5,
Celloxide 3000 from Daicel Chemical Industries Ltd., formula Xv), 1,1,1-tris-
(p-hydroxyphenyl)
methane triglycidyl ether (C/0 = 4.7, Tactix 742 from Ciba, formula Xt), 1,1,1-
tris-(p-hydroxy
phenyl) ethane triglycidyl ether (C/0 = 4.8, EPALLOY 9000 from CVC Specialty
Chemicals,
formula Xg), glycidyl ethers of the condensation products of dicyclopentadiene
and phenol
(formula Xy hereunder where n is an integer generally ranging from 0 to 25,
C/0 ¨ 9.5, Tactix
556 from Ciba), tetrakis (4-hydroxyphenyl) ethane tetraglycidyl ether (C/0 =
4.8, Epon 1031
from Shell Chemical, formula Xp), epoxy phenol novolacs such as the resin of
formula Xw
hereunder, where n is an integer denoting the number of polymerized subunits
and is typically in
the range from 0 to 25 (C/0 = 5, Epon 155, 160, 861, 862 from Shell Chemical
or Epalloy 8230,
8240, 8250, 8330, 8350 from CVC Specialty Chemicals), epoxy cresol novolacs
such as the
resin of formula X1 hereunder, where n is an integer denoting the number of
polymerized
subunits and is typically in the range from 0 to 25 (C/0 ¨ 5.5, Epon 164, RSS-
2350 from Shell
Chemical or Araldite ECN 1235, 1871, 9699 from Ciba), epoxy bisphenol A
novolacs such as
the resin of formula Xu hereunder, where n is an integer denoting the number
of polymerized
subunits and is typically in the range from 0 to 25 (C/0 = 5.4 - 5.5, SU resin
from Shell
Chemical), bisphenol A diglycidyl ether (C/0 = 5.75, formula Xi), hydrogenated
bisphenol A
diglycidyl ether (C/0 = 5.75, Epalloy 5000 from CVC Specialty Chemicals,
formula Xh),
bisphenol A diglycidyl ether resins (C/0 ¨ 6, n generally ranging from 0 to
25, Epon 828 from
Shell Chemical, formula Xe), resorcinol diglycidyl ether (C/0 = 3.5, formula
Xj), epoxycyclohexyl
POSS Cage Mixture (C/0 = 3.2, EP0408 from Hybrid Plastics, formula Xo),
derivatives of
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679 PCT/EP2017/077266
8
hexahydrophthalic anhydride diglycidyl ester of formulae Xx and X2 (0/0 = 3),
4-glycidyloxy-
N,N-diglycidyl aniline (0/0 = 3.75, formula Xf), 4,4'-
(hexafluoroisopropylidene)diphenol
diglycidyl ether (0/0 = 5.3, formula Xc), 1,3-
bis[2-(3,4-
epoxycyclohexyl)ethyl]tetramethyldisiloxane (0/0 = 5.3, SIB1092.0 from Gelest,
formula Xa),
the 2-(3,4-epoxycyclohexyl)ethyl compound of formula Xb (0/0 = 4, available
from Gelest),
resorcinol di(3,4-epoxycyclohexylmethyl) ether (0/0 = 5, formula Xn), and the
aromatic epoxy
compounds of formulae Xk, Xz, XI, Xm (respective 0/0 = 3.5, 3.75, 5, 7). The
compounds
corresponding to the formulae cited in this paragraph are represented
hereunder:
F3c cF3
1 I
RT:} j¨si-o-s lisi
Xa i r>.c.
CY-K1
4 Xb 0 0
Xc
0
,
0 0 L = '---1
.....,
Xd - ,
Xe
O¨CH,
,L V*-7---0
0 0
0 ii, CH,
i
, N,
-CHr-CH- i il
' i \ / 1>0
0 CH, ________________________________________________________
0 0 /()\.0( ) (
)()((
Xf Xg cH3 _______ Xh
to al
1:1
. 10111
"-*X1 0,
olYN 1r o'/X
0õ,...-1
Xi Xj Xk
* 4:I = 10 010--, 4 cõ--.Do
. 0x, o xm Xn
1 5
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
9
.- ?õ,õ----N, 0')
0
it 1*
HC¨CH
II *
0
0
Xo
Xp
0oyo
0 o 011)--o---0 Xr Xq o o
Xs
r ¨
=
/o\ /o\ /0\
SO I
CH, I I
CH,
H
p 0 n
0 0
0 0 00
Xt A / \ / \ I XU XV
0
/\
I
0 T
0 o = 0-----.A
/ \ CHF CH, CH, 0 CH,/ \ 0
1 71
n XW XX
/0
0
/\
0 0--
Xy
Xz
0
/ \
0
0 CH3 0
/ \ CH()F CH, CH, 0 CH, / \ 0
n 0
H3C CH3
X1 X2
The composition according to the invention preferably comprises less than 25 %
by
weight relative to the total weight of the composition, more preferably less
than 20 % by weight,
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
of acrylic and/or methacrylic monomers, and more preferably of non-epoxy
containing
monomers. This amount can be less than 10 % or less than 5 % by weight and
even 0 %.
The dry extract weight of acrylic and/or methacrylic monomers preferably
represents
less than 30 % of the dry extract weight of the composition, more preferably
less than 25 %,
5 20 %, 10 %, 5 %. This amount can also be 0 %. These amounts also
preferably apply to non-
epoxy containing monomers.
The compositions of the present invention advantageously further contain small
amounts,
preferably from 0.005 to 1 % by weight, based on the total weight of the
composition, of at least
one surface active compound (surfactant), more preferably from 0.02 to 1 %,
still more
10 preferably from 0.025 to 0.5 %. The surfactant is important for good
wetting of the substrate
resulting in satisfactory cosmetics of the final coating. Said surfactant can
include for example
poly(alkylene glycol)-modified polydimethylsiloxanes or
polyheptamethylsiloxanes, or
fluorocarbon-modified polysiloxanes. Preferred surfactants are fluorinated
surfactant such as
Novec FC-4434 from 3M (non ionic surfactant) and EFKA 3034 from CIBA
(fluorocarbon-
modified polysiloxanes).
The epoxy compounds of the composition are submitted to a polycondensation
and/or
cross-linking reaction generally in the presence of a catalyst.
The catalysts found to be able to cure the epoxy composition at temperatures
low
enough not to damage the underlying substrate or cause adverse affects to the
dye or other
coatings are strong acid catalysts designed for ring opening polymerization of
cyclic ether
groups. In order to obtain storage-stable curable composition, the catalyst,
of course, should not
catalyze the ring-opening at room temperature. Such blocked or latent
catalysts that are inactive
at ambient temperature and activated only upon heating, generally at least 80
C, are familiar to
the skilled person. Exemplary blocked strong acid catalysts are based on
trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (triflic acid), dinonylnaphthalene sulfonic
acid, dinonylnaphthalene
disulfonic acid (DNNDSA), and ammonium antimony hexafluoride (a Lewis acid)
and are
available from King Industries for example Nacure Super A233 (diethylamine
salt of
trifluoromethanesulfonic acid), Nacure 155 (a blocked acid catalyst based on
DNNDSA),
Nacure Super XC-7231 (ammonium antimony hexafluoride catalyst), and Nacure
Super-A218
(metal salt of triflic acid, Lewis acid), the latter being the preferred
catalyst. Other useful
catalysts include carboxylic acid anhydrides such as hexahydrophthalic
anhydride,
methylhexahydrophthalic anhydride, or Lewis acid catalysts including BF3 and
BCI3 amine
complexes.
The catalyst is generally used in amounts ranging from 0.01 - 5 % by weight
based on
the weight of the composition, preferably from 0.1 to 3 % by weight. The dry
extract weight of
catalyst preferably represents from 0.025 - 12.5 % of the dry extract weight
of the composition,
preferably from 0.25 to 7.5 %.
The composition according to the invention generally contains 10-80 % by
weight of
solids (dry extract weight of the composition), preferably from 25 to 60%,
more preferably from
35 to 55 %.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
11
The composition generally contains at least one solvent, which is preferably a
glycol
monoether. The glycol monoether solvent generally exhibits low surface
tensions and is
preferably selected from alkylene glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers, more
preferably from ethylene
glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers, propylene glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers,
diethylene glycol 01-4
.. alkyl monoethers, triethylene glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers, propylene
glycol 01-4 alkyl
monoethers, dipropylene glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers, triethylene glycol 01-4
alkyl monoethers,
and tripropylene glycol 01-4 alkyl monoethers. The most preferred glycol
monoether is
propylene glycol methyl ether. Such a compound is sold commercially by Dow
Chemical under
the name Dowanol PM as a mixture of 1-methoxy-2-propanol (major isomer) and 2-
methoxy-1-
propanol. Additional or alternative solvents can be used, such as alkanols
(methanol, ethanol,
propanol...), ketones or water.
The total amount of solvent depends on the epoxy resins used, on the type of
optical
article and on the coating process. The purpose of the solvent is to achieve
good surface
wetting and a specific coating viscosity range determined by the coating
equipment used to
achieve a specific coating thickness range. The solvent typically represents
from 25 to 75 % of
the weight of the composition, preferably from 35 to 65 %, more preferably
from 40 to 60 %.
It is possible to add to the composition additional polymerizable epoxy
compounds that
are not epoxy compounds according to the invention without significantly
affecting the dye
photo-degradation level in the final coating, provided that the dry extract
weight of epoxy
.. compounds according to the invention still represents more than 33 % of the
dry extract weight
of the composition.
These additional compounds can be epoxy compounds that neither comprise any
cycloaliphatic or aryl group nor any silicon atom having at least one
hydrolyzable group directly
linked to the silicon atom, such as, without limitation to these compounds,
trimethylolpropane
.. triglycidyl ether (ErisysTM GE-30, from CVC thermoset Specialties),
sorbitol hexaglycidyl ether
(ErisysTM GE-60, from CVC thermoset Specialties) or ethylene glycol diglycydyl
ether. These
additional compounds can also be epoxy compounds comprising at least one
cycloaliphatic or
aryl group, devoid of any silicon atom having at least one hydrolyzable group
directly linked to
the silicon atom, and with a 0/0 ratio lower than 3, such as hexahydrophthalic
anhydride
diglycidyl ester (0/0 = 2.3, CY 184 from Ciba).
These additional epoxy comonomers can also be epoxy compounds bearing at least
one
silicon atom having at least one hydrolyzable group directly linked to the
silicon atom and at
least one group comprising an epoxy function linked to the silicon atom
through a carbon atom
that either do not comprise any cycloaliphatic or aryl group or do not have a
0/0 ratio 3, or
.. hydrolyzates of such compounds. In this embodiment, hybrid epoxy copolymers
will be
generated if epoxy compounds according to the invention and devoid of reactive
silicon atom
are used together with these organosilanes.
Such organosilane compounds preferably have from 2 to 6, more preferably 2 or
3
functional groups generating a silanol group under hydrolysis. They are
preferably epoxysilanes
.. of formula:
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
12
RnY,,Si(X)4-n-m (I)
wherein the R groups, identical or different, are monovalent organic groups
linked to the Si atom
by a carbon atom and comprising at least one, preferably one epoxy function;
the X groups,
identical or different, are hydrolyzable groups (such as alkoxy groups or
halogen atoms); Y is a
monovalent organic group that does not contain an epoxy group and which is
linked to the Si
atom by a carbon atom, n and m being integers such as n = 1 or 2 and n+m = 1
or 2. Hydrogen
atoms and hydroxyl groups are considered as being hydrolyzable groups in the
present
disclosure.
The preferred R groups have the following formulae V and VI:
V ¨(CH2)a¨(OCH2cH2)b-0 0
R2
0
VI
wherein R2 is an alkyl group, preferably a methyl group or a hydrogen atom,
more preferably a
hydrogen atom ; a and c are integers ranging from 1 to 6 and b is representing
0, 1 or 2 . In
formula VI, c is preferably 1, giving rise to a 6-(3,4-epoxycyclohexyl)ethyl
group.
Most preferred epoxysilanes are those wherein, in formula I, n=1, m =0 and X
is a C1-05
alkoxy group, preferably OCH3
Examples of such epoxysilanes include y-glycidoxypropyl triethoxysilane, y-
glycidoxypropyl trimethoxysilane, 2-(3,4-epoxycyclohexyl)
ethyltrimethoxysi lane, 3-
glycidoxypropyl methyldiethoxysilane, 2-(3,4-epoxycyclohexyl)
ethyltriethoxysilane. Other
suitable examples of such compounds are compounds of formula I disclosed in US
2009/0311518, compounds of formulae I, VII and VIII disclosed in US
2011/0058142, and the
epoxytrialkoxysilanes disclosed in US 4,294,950. Amongst them, y-
glycidoxypropyl
trimethoxysilane (GLYMO) is the most preferred.
According to one aspect of this invention, the epoxysilane is hydrolyzed
before being
mixed to the other components of the composition. The hydrolysis may be
performed as known
in the art, by using acidic catalysts (hydrochloric acid, acetic acid...), in
the presence of water.
Organosilanes having at least one epoxy group linked to the silicon atom
through a
carbon atom and bearing at least one silicon atom having at least one
hydrolyzable group
directly linked to the silicon atom are preferably used in an amount of less
than 30 % by weight
relative to the total weight of the composition, more preferably less than 20
% by weight. This
amount can be less than 10 % or less than 5 % by weight and even 0 %. Despite
the
epoxysilane is generally under hydrolyzed form, the amount of epoxysilane will
be
conventionally defined as the weight of the initial precursor before its
hydrolysis.
The dry extract weight of organosilanes having at least one epoxy group linked
to the
silicon atom through a carbon atom and bearing at least one silicon atom
having at least one
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
13
hydrolyzable group directly linked to the silicon atom preferably represents
less than 40 % of the
dry extract weight of the composition, more preferably less than 30 %, 20 %,
10 %, 5 %. This
amount can also be 0 %.
Epoxy compounds that do not comprise any silicon atom having at least one
hydrolyzable group directly linked to the silicon atom and either do not
comprise any
cycloaliphatic or aryl group or exhibit a 0/0 ratio lower than 3 are
preferably used in an amount
of less than 20 % by weight relative to the total weight of the composition,
more preferably less
than 15 % by weight. This amount can be less than 10 % or less than 5 % by
weight and even
0 %. Their dry extract weight preferably represents less than 30 % of the dry
extract weight of
the composition, more preferably less than 20 %, 15 %, 10 %, 5 %. This amount
can also be
0 %.
The composition can also include at least one compound, or a hydrolyzate
thereof, of
formula M(Z)y, wherein M represents a metal or a metalloid, preferably Si, the
Z groups, being
the same or different, are hydrolyzable groups and y, equal to or higher than
4, is the metal or
metalloid M valence. Such compounds are described in detail in US
2011/0058142. The
preferred compounds are compounds of formula Si(Z)4, wherein the Z groups,
being the same
or different, are hydrolyzable groups, such as tetraethoxysilane.
The composition can further include fillers such as oxides of metals or
metalloids, for
example silica, preferably used under a colloidal form, and various additives
such as
curing/cross-linking agents (e.g. silane coupling agents or comonomers such as
polyamines,
polythiols, polyols, polycarboxylic acids), rheology modifiers, flow and
leveling additives, wetting
agents, antifoaming agents, stabilizers, and color balancing agents. The
composition can be a
solution or a dispersion. The color balancing agents can be powders, solutions
or dispersions in
which dye(s) or pigment(s) are used to adjust the final article into specific
colors, particularly
neutral colors.
According to the invention, the coating composition comprises at least one dye
that at
least partially inhibits transmission of light within the visible blue light
range (400-500 nm) and
has a conjugated chromophore, i.e., a chromophore comprising a conjugated
system. As used
herein a chromophore refers to the part of a dye molecule, generally a group
of atoms, which is
responsible for the dye's color, and a dye may refer to both a pigment and a
colorant, i.e., can
be insoluble or soluble in its vehicle.
In the present disclosure, the dye will be referred to as a blue light
blocking dye and is
typically a yellow dye. The chemical nature of this dye is not particularly
limited, provided that it
has an absorption peak, ideally a maximum absorption peak, within the 380-780
nm wavelength
range. The FWHM (Full Width at Half Maximum) is preferably lower than 80 nm,
more
preferably lower than 60 nm, even more preferably lower than 60 nm. The dyes
are selected
and processed in a way such that they are compatible with the epoxy monomers
according to
the invention, and well and stably distributed or dispersed in the matrix of
the coating, providing
low haze coatings.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
14
The optical article inhibits transmission of incident light through at least
one
geometrically defined surface of the substrate of the optical article,
preferably an entire main
surface. In the present description, unless otherwise specified, light
blocking is defined with
reference to an angle of incidence ranging from 0 to 15 , preferably 0 .
The dye preferably at least partially inhibits transmission of light within
the 415-455 nm
wavelength range, by absorption more preferably within the 420-450 nm range,
in order to
provide a high level of retinal cell protection against retinal cell apoptosis
or age-related macular
degeneration.
It may be particularly desirable in some cases to selectively filter a
relatively small
portion of the blue spectrum, i.e., the 420 nm - 450 nm region. Indeed,
blocking too much of the
blue spectrum can interfere with scotopic vision and mechanisms for regulating
biorhythms,
referred to as "circadian cycles". Thus, in one embodiment, the preferred dye
blocks less than
10%, preferably less than 5 % of light having a wavelength ranging from 465 to
495 nm,
preferably from 450 to 550 nm. In this embodiment, the dye selectively
inhibits the phototoxic
blue light and transmits the blue light implicated in circadian rhythms.
Preferably, the optical
article transmits at least 95 % of light having a wavelength ranging from 465
to 495 nm. This
transmittance is an average of light transmitted within the 465-495 nm range
that is not
weighted according to the sensitivity of the eye at each wavelength of the
range. In another
embodiment, the dye does not absorb light in the 465-495 nm range, preferably
the 450-550 nm
range. In the present description, unless otherwise specified,
transmittances/transmissions are
measured at the center of the optical article for a thickness ranging from 0.5
to 2.5mm,
preferably 0.7 to 2 mm, more preferably 0.8 to 1.5 mm, at an angle of
incidence ranging from 0
to 15 , preferably 0 .
When the dye is a dye that absorbs within the 400-500 nm wavelength range ,
the dye
does preferably not absorb, or very little, in regions of the visible spectrum
outside the 400-500
nm wavelength range to minimize the appearance of a plurality of colors. In
this case, the dye
selectively inhibits transmission of light within the 400-500 nm wavelength
range, preferably in
the 415-455 nm and 420-450 nm ranges. As used herein, a dye "selectively
inhibits" a
wavelength range if it inhibits at least some transmission within the
specified range, while
having little or no effect on transmission of wavelengths outside the selected
wavelength range,
unless specifically configured to do so.
In certain embodiments, the dye comprises one or more porphyrins, porphyrin
complexes, other heterocycles related to porphyrins, including corrins,
chlorins and corphins,
derivatives thereof, or the perylene, coumarin, acridine, indolenin (also
known as 3H-indole),
anthraquinone, azobenzene, phthalocyanine, cyanines, quinoline, benzotriazole,
nitrobenzene,
isoquinoline, isoindoline, diarylmethane and indo1-2-ylidene families.
Derivatives are substances
generally issued by an addition or substitution. The preferred dyes are
diarylmethane dyes such
as auramine 0 and porphyrin dyes.
Porphyrins are well-known macrocycle compounds composed of four modified
pyrrole
subunits interconnected at their carbon atoms via methine bridges. The parent
porphyrin is
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
porphine and substituted porphines are called porphyrins. Porphyrins are the
conjugate acids of
ligands that bind metals to form (coordination) complexes.
Certain porphyrins or porphyrin complexes or derivatives are interesting in
that they
provide selective absorption filters having a bandwidth in some cases of for
example 20 nm in
5 the selected blue range of wavelengths. The selectivity property is in
part provided by the
symmetry of the molecules. Such selectivity helps to limit the distortion of
the visual perception
of color, to limit the detrimental effects of light filtering to scotopic
vision and to limit the impact
on circadian rhythm.
For example, the one or more porphyrins or porphyrin complexes or derivatives
are
10 selected from the group consisting of Chlorophyll a; Chlorophyll b;
5,10, 15,20-tetrakis(4-
sulfonatophenyl) porphyrin sodium salt complex; 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(N-alkyl-4-
pyridyl) porphyrin
complex; 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(N-alkyl-3-pyridyl) porphyrin complex, and
5,10,15,20-tetrakis(N-
alky1-2-pyridyl) porphyrin complex, the alkyl being preferably an alkyl chain,
linear or branched,
comprising 1 to 4 carbon atoms per chain. For example the alkyl may be
selected from the
15 group consisting of methyl, ethyl, butyl and propyl.
The complex usually is a metal complex, the metal being selected from the
group
consisting of Cr(III), Ag(II), In(111), Mn(III), Sn(IV), Fe (111), Co (II),
Mg(II) and Zn(II). Cr(III), Ag(II),
In(111), Mn(III), Sn(IV), Fe (111), Co (II) and Zn(II) demonstrate absorption
in water in the range of
425nm to 448nm with sharp absorption peaks. Moreover, the complexes they
provide are stable
and not acid sensitive. Cr(III), Ag(II), In(111), Sn(IV), Fe (111), in
particular, do not exhibit
fluorescence at room temperature which is a useful property in optical lenses
such as
ophthalmic lenses.
In some embodiments the one or more porphyrins or porphyrin complexes or
derivatives
are selected from the group consisting of magnesium meso-tetra(4-
sulfonatophenyl) porphine
tetrasodium salt, magnesium octaethylporphyrin, magnesium
tetramesitylporphyrin,
octaethylporphyrin, tetrakis (2,6-dichlorophenyl) porphyrin, tetrakis (o-
aminophenyl) porphyrin,
tetramesitylporphyrin, tetraphenylporphyrin, zinc octaethylporphyrin, zinc
tetramesitylporphyrin,
zinc tetraphenylporphyrin, and diprotonated-tetraphenylporphyrin.
The dye may also include one or more dyes from the group consisting of:
coumarin 343;
coumarin 314; nitrobenzoxadiazole; lucifer yellow CH; 9,10-
bis(phenylethynyl)anthracene;
proflavin; 4-(d icyanomethylene)-2-methyl-6-(4-d imethyl
aminostyryI)-4H-pyran; 2-[4-
(dimethylamino)styry1]-1-methypyridinium iodide, lutein, zeaxanthin, and
yellow dyes having a
narrow absorption peak available from Exciton Inc. such as ABS-419 , ABS-420
or ABS-430 .
The amount of dye used in the present invention is an amount sufficient to
provide a
satisfactory inhibition of light within the 380-780 nm wavelength range,
preferably within the
400-500 nm wavelength range. For example the dye can be used at a level of
0.005 to 0.50 %
or 0.01 to 0.2 % based on the weight of the coating composition, depending on
the strength of
the dye and the amount of inhibition/protection desired. It should be
understood that the
invention is not limited to these ranges, which are only given by way of
example.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
16
The dye is typically present in an amount ranging from 0.005 to 1.25 %
relative to the dry
extract weight of the composition, preferably from 0.01 to 1 %, more
preferably from 0.02 to
0.5 %.
The coating composition of the invention provides a coating that limits or
avoids the
photo-degradation of dyes that are generally sensitive to light, in particular
UV light, without the
need to include UV absorbers and/or free radical scavengers in the coating
composition, in
another layer or in the substrate, and without the need to use another coating
protecting the dye
from photo-degradation such as an interferential filter absorbing or
reflecting UV light or acting
as an oxygen barrier protection.
In one embodiment of the invention, the coating composition/the coating
comprises less
than 0.5 % by weight of compounds selected from UV absorbers and free radical
scavengers
relative to the coating composition/coating total weight, preferably less than
0.2 % by weight,
more preferably less than 0.1 % by weight. In some instances, the composition
neither
comprises any UV absorber nor free radical scavenger.
However, the coating composition can also comprise at least one UV absorber
and/or at
least one free radical scavenger in order to further limit or even eliminate
photo-degradation of
the dye contained therein. These species can also be incorporated into another
coating present
at the surface of the optical article coated with the inventive epoxy coating.
UV absorbers are frequently incorporated in optical articles in order to
reduce or prevent
UV light from reaching the retina (in particular in ophthalmic lens
materials), but also to protect
the substrate material itself, thus preventing it from weathering and becoming
brittle and/or
yellow.
The UV spectrum has many bands, especially UVA, UVB and UVC bands. Amongst
those UV bands reaching the earth surface, UVA band- ranging from 315 nm to
380 nm, and
UVB band- ranging from 280 nm to 315 nm- are particularly harmful to the
retina.
The UV absorber that may be used in the present invention preferably has the
ability to
at least partially block light having a wavelength shorter than 400 nm,
preferably UV
wavelengths below 385 or 390 nm.
Most preferred ultraviolet absorbers have a maximum absorption peak in a range
from
350 nm to 370 nm and/or do not absorb light in the 465-495 nm range,
preferably the 450-550
nm range, and/or have an absorption spectrum extending to a selected
wavelength range within
the 400-500 nm region of the electromagnetic spectrum. In one embodiment, the
UV absorber
does not absorb any substantial amount of visible light.
Suitable UV absorbers include without limitation substituted benzophenones
such as 2-
hydroxybenzophenone, substituted 2-hydroxybenzophenones disclosed in U.S. Pat.
No.
4,304,895, 2-hydroxy-4-octyloxybenzophenone (Seesorb 102 ) 2,7-bis(5-
methylbenzoxazol-2-
yI)-9 ,9-d ipropy1-3-hyd roxyfluorene, 1,4-bis(9,9-
dipropy1-9H-fluoreno [3,2-d] oxazol-2-y1)-2-
hydroxyphenyl, 2-hydroxyphenyl-s-triazines and benzotriazoles compounds.
The UV absorber is preferably a benzotriazole compound. Suitable UV absorbers
from
this family include without limitation 2-(2-hydroxyphenyl)-benzotriazoles such
as 2-(2-hydroxy-3-
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
17
t-butyl-5-methylphenyl) chlorobenzotriazole, 2-(2'-hydroxy-5'-t-octylphenyl)
benzotriazole, 2-(3'-
methally1-2'-hydroxy-5'-methyl phenyl) benzotriazole or other allyl
hydroxymethylphenyl
benzotriazoles, 2-(2-hydroxy-5-methylphenyI)-2H-benzotriazole (Seesorb 701),
2-(3,5-di-t-
amyl-2-hydroxyphenyl) benzotriazole, and the 2-hydroxy-5-acryloxypheny1-2H-
benzotriazoles
disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,528,311. Preferred absorbers are of the
benzotriazole family.
Commercially available products include Tinuvin and Chimassorb compounds
from BASF
such as Tinuvin 326, Seeseorb 701 and 703 from Shipro Kasei Kaisha, Viosorb
550 from
Kyodo Chemicals, and Kemisorb 73 from Chemipro and TCP Tinuvin Carbo Protect
from
BASF.
The UV absorber is preferably used in an amount representing from 0.3 to 2 %
of the
weight of the coating.
In some embodiments, the coating composition comprises at least one free
radical
scavenger. Free radical scavengers inhibit the formation of or scavenge the
presence of free
radicals, and include hindered amine light stabilizers (HALS), which protect
against photo-
degradation, and antioxidants, which protect against thermal oxidation.
Preferably, the coating composition comprises at least one hindered amine
light
stabilizer, and/or at least one antioxidant, more preferably at least one
hindered amine light
stabilizer and at least one antioxidant. This combination of free radical
scavengers offers the
best protection from thermal and photo degradation to dyes.
In one embodiment, the free radical scavenger is a sterically hindered phenol
or amine.
Preferred hindered amine light stabilizers are derivatives of piperidine, such
as
derivatives of 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl piperidine. They are commercially available
from BASF under
the trade names Tinuvin and Chimassorb .
Preferred antioxidants are sterically hindered phenols, thioethers or
phosphites. They
are commercially available from BASF under the trade names Irganox and
Irgafos .
The amount of free radical scavenger that is used is an amount that is
effective to
stabilize the composition, which will depend on the specific compounds chosen
and can be
easily adapted by those skilled in the art.
Protection of dyes from photo-degradation can also be reinforced by the
presence on the
optical article of at least one mineral/dielectric layer, preferably at least
one mineral layer of an
antireflection coating.
In this regard, the substrate's main surface can be further coated with
several functional
coating(s) to improve its optical and/or mechanical properties. The term
"coating" is understood
to mean any layer, layer stack or film which may be in contact with the
substrate and/or with
another coating, for example a sol-gel coating or a coating made of an organic
resin. A coating
may be deposited or formed through various methods, including wet processing,
gaseous
processing, and film transfer. The functional coatings used herein can be
selected from, without
limitation to these coatings, an impact-resistant coating, an abrasion-
resistant and/or scratch-
resistant coating, an antireflection coating, a polarized coating, a
photochromic coating, an
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
18
antistatic coating, an anti-fouling coating (hydrophobic and/or oleophobic
coating), an antifog
coating, a precursor of an antifog coating or a stack made of two or more such
coatings.
The primer coatings improving the impact resistance and/or the adhesion of the
further
layers in the end product are preferably polyurethane latexes or acrylic
latexes. Primer coatings
and abrasion-resistant and/or scratch-resistant coatings may be selected from
those described
in the application WO 2007/088312.
Abrasion- and/or scratch-resistant coatings (hard coatings) are preferably
hard coatings
based on poly(meth)acrylates or silanes. Recommended hard abrasion- and/or
scratch-resistant
coatings in the present invention include coatings obtained from silane
hydrolyzate-based
compositions (sol-gel process), in particular epoxysilane hydrolyzate-based
compositions such
as those described in the US patent application US 2003/0165698 and in US
4,211,823 and
EP614957.
The antireflection coating may be any antireflection coating traditionally
used in the
optics field, particularly ophthalmic optics. An antireflective coating is
defined as a coating,
deposited onto the surface of an optical article, which improves the
antireflective properties of
the final optical article. It makes it possible to reduce the light reflection
at the article-air interface
over a relatively large portion of the visible spectrum.
As is also well known, antireflection coatings traditionally comprise a
monolayered or a
multilayered stack composed of dielectric materials (generally one or more
metal oxides) and/or
sol-gel materials and/or organic/inorganic layers such as disclosed in WO
2013/098531. These
are preferably multilayered coatings, comprising layers with a high refractive
index (HI) and
layers with a low refractive index (LI).
In some aspects, the present invention provides an optical article further
comprising a
sub-layer, deposited before the antireflective coating, said sub-layer having
preferably a
refractive index lower than or equal to 1.55. Unless otherwise specified, the
refractive indexes
referred to in the present invention are expressed at 25 C at a wavelength of
550 nm. The sub-
layer is generally less than 0.5 micrometer thick and more than 100 nm thick,
preferably more
than 150 nm thick, more preferably the thickness of the sub-layer ranges from
150 nm to 450
nm. In another embodiment, the sub-layer comprises, more preferably consists
in, silicon oxide,
even better silica. Examples of usable sub-layers (mono or multilayered) are
described in WO
2012/076174.
In some embodiments, the antireflective coating of the invention includes at
least one
electrically conductive layer. In a particular embodiment, the at least one
electrically conductive
layer has a refractive index greater than 1.55. The at least one electrically
conductive layer
serves as an antistatic agent. Without being bound by theory, the at least one
electrically
conductive layer prevents the multilayer antireflective coating stack from
developing and
retaining a static electric charge. The electrically conductive layer is
preferably made from an
electrically conductive and highly transparent material. In this case, the
thickness thereof
preferably varies from 1 to 15 nm, more preferably from 1 to 10 nm.
Preferably, the electrically
conductive layer comprises an optionally doped metal oxide, selected from
indium, tin, zinc
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
19
oxides and mixtures thereof. In another embodiment, the preferred electrically
conductive and
optically transparent layer is a tin-indium oxide layer (ITO) or a tin oxide
layer.
More details concerning the constitution and location of the antistatic layer
can be found
in the applications WO 2012/076714 and WO 2010/109154.
The structure and preparation of antireflection coatings are described in more
details in
patent application WO 2010/109154, WO 2011/080472 and WO 2012/153072.
The antifouling top coat is preferably deposited onto the outer layer of the
antireflective
coating. As a rule, its thickness is lower than or equal to 10 nm, does
preferably range from 1 to
nm, more preferably from 1 to 5 nm. Antifouling top coats are generally
coatings of the
10
fluorosilane or fluorosilazane type. They may be obtained by depositing a
fluorosilane or
fluorosilazane precursor, comprising preferably at least two hydrolysable
groups per molecule.
Fluorosilane precursors preferably comprise fluoropolyether moieties and more
preferably
perfluoropolyether moieties.
Optool DSXTM, KY13OTM, OF21OTM, AulonTM are examples of hydrophobic and/or
oleophobic coatings. More detailed information on these coatings is disclosed
in WO
2012076714.
Coatings such as primers, hard coats, antireflection coatings and antifouling
coatings
may be deposited using methods known in the art, including spin-coating, dip-
coating, spray-
coating, evaporation under vacuum, sputtering, chemical vapor deposition and
lamination.
In one embodiment, the optical article of the invention is preferably
configured to reduce
reflection in the UVA- and UVB-radiation range, in addition to reducing
transmission of light in
the 380-780 nm wavelength range (preferably the 400-500 nm range), so as to
allow the best
health protection against UV and harmful blue light.
The UV radiation resulting from light sources located behind the wearer may
reflect on
the lens rear face and reach the wearer's eye if the lens is not provided with
an antireflective
coating which is efficient in the ultraviolet region, thus potentially
affecting the wearer's health.
In this regard, the optical article preferably comprises on its rear main
face, and optionally on its
front main face, an anti-UV, antireflective coating possessing very good
antireflective
performances in the visible region, and which is at the same time capable of
significantly
reducing the UV radiation reflection, especially ultraviolet A- and
ultraviolet B-rays, as compared
to a bare substrate or to a substrate comprising a traditional antireflective
coating. Suitable anti-
UV, antireflective coatings are disclosed in WO 2012/076714.
The optical article according to the invention preferably has a relative light
transmission
factor in the visible spectrum Tv higher than or equal to 85 or 87 %,
preferably higher than or
equal to 90 %, more preferably higher than or equal to 92 %, and better higher
than or equal to
95 %. Said Tv factor preferably ranges from 87 % to 98.5 %, more preferably
from 88 % to 97
%, even better from 90 % to 96 %. The Tv factor, also called "luminous
transmission" of the
system, is such as defined in the standard NF EN 1836 and relates to an
average in the 380-
780 nm wavelength range that is weighted according to the sensitivity of the
eye at each
wavelength of the range and measured under D65 illumination conditions
(daylight).
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
The invention also relates to a process to manufacture an optical article such
as herein
described, comprising providing a substrate, depositing on at least one main
surface of said
substrate a composition according to the invention including at least one dye
that at least
partially blocks transmission of light within the 380-780 nm wavelength range,
preferably within
5 the 400-500 nm wavelength range, and curing said composition.
The epoxy coating of the invention is deposited on the substrate of the
optical article and
is preferably in direct contact with said substrate. The deposition is
preferably carried out by
spin coating or dip coating, and more preferably by dip coating into a bath
containing the
curable composition.
10
The composition according to the invention is generally a heat-curable
composition.
Curing the composition can be performed in two steps, a first pre-curing step
to a temperature
of at least 75 C, preferably of 80 C to 100 C, for at least 5 minutes,
generally from 10 to 25
minutes, so as to form a tack-free coating, and a second step of heating the
optical article
coated with the tack-free coating to a temperature of at least 95 C,
preferably of 98 to 115 C,
15
for at least two hours, preferably for 2.5 to 3.5 hours, so as to obtain a
completely cured
insoluble coating. The temperature of the first curing step depends on the
blocked catalyst
used. In case the catalyst activation temperature is higher than 80 C, the
optical article must be
heated to a higher temperature. The heating temperature of the second curing
step preferably
does not exceed 115 C, or 110 C. Higher temperatures could be harmful to the
dye.
20
The thickness of the cured coating may be adapted to the specific application
required
and generally ranges from 0.5 to 50 pm, preferably from 1 to 20 pm, more
preferably from 2 to
10 pm. The coating thickness can be easily adjusted by modifying the
withdrawal speed in case
of deposition by dip coating. The longer the withdrawal time, the thinner will
be the final dry
coating.
In one embodiment, the process comprises forming on the substrate the epoxy
coating
according to the invention, an impact-resistant coating, an abrasion-resistant
and/or scratch-
resistant coating, an antireflection coating and an antifouling coating.
The coatings are preferably directly deposited on one another. These coatings
can be
deposited one by one, or a stack of one or more coatings can be formed on the
substrate, for
example by lamination.
In one embodiment, the present optical article is prepared by forming on the
substrate
the epoxy coating in a first manufacturing site, while the other coatings are
formed in a second
manufacturing site.
The following examples illustrate the present invention in a more detailed,
but non-
limiting manner. Unless stated otherwise, all thicknesses disclosed in the
present application
relate to physical thicknesses. The percentages given in the tables are weight
percentages.
EXAMPLES
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
21
The optical articles used in the examples comprise an ORMA lens substrate
from
ESSILOR, having a 65 mm diameter, a refractive index of 1.50, a power of -2.00
diopters and a
thickness of 1.2 mm.
Various epoxy coating compositions were prepared and are shown in the tables
below.
Some of them were compositions of epoxy homopolymers (examples 1, 2 and
comparative
examples 01-02), while the others were compositions of epoxy copolymers. The
compositions
comprise at least one epoxy compound that is not a silicon compound having at
least one
hydrolyzable group directly linked to the silicon atom, a Lewis acid
polymerization catalyst for
the epoxy groups (Nacure Super A218, metal salt of triflic acid in n-butanol,
25 % wt., from
King Industries), a surfactant (EFKA 3034, which is a fluorocarbon containing
organically
modified polysiloxane, 50 % wt. in methoxypropanol sold by CIBA), propylene
glycol methyl
ether as a solvent (Dowanol PM from Dow Chemical Company) and a dye. Optional
compounds were included in some compositions, such as colloidal silica (MASTHV
from
Nissan Chemical, 30 % wt. dispersion in methanol) and hydrolyzed epoxysilanes.
The following epoxy compounds according to the invention were used in the
examples:
UVACure 1500 (3',4'-epoxycyclohexylmethy1-3,4-epoxycyclohexanecarboxylate,
from Allnex
USA Inc.) and EPALLOY 9000 (1,1,1-tris-(p-hydroxy phenyl) ethane triglycidyl
ether).
The following comparative epoxy compounds were investigated: EGDGE (ethylene
glycol diglycydyl ether), ErisysTM GE-30 (trimethylolpropane triglycidyl
ether, abbreviated as GE-
30, from CVC thermoset Specialties), ErisysTM GE-60 (sorbitol hexaglycidyl
ether, abbreviated
as GE-60, from CVC thermoset Specialties), Glymo (3-glycidoxypropyl-
trimethoxysilane, from
Evonik Industries) and KBE-402 (3-glycidoxypropyl methyldiethoxysilane). These
epoxy
compounds are relatively electron rich monomers, and the last two of them are
epoxysilanes,
which generate hybrid epoxy copolymers when used together with epoxy compounds
devoid of
reactive silicon atom.
The structures of the various epoxy compounds devoid of silicon atom are
recalled
hereunder:
Epoxy EGDGE Erisys'm GE-30
Erisys'm GE-60 UVACure EPALLOY(')
compound (comparative) (comparative) (comparative) 1500 9000
Structure
o o
CV7
0
1>N/0
C/O ratio 2 2.5 2 3.5
4.8
The following dyes were used in the various compositions:
Dye A: ABS-420 max = -421 nm), from Exciton Inc. (blue light blocking dye)
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
22
Dye B: Solvent Yellow 114 (2, max = -446 nm, quinoline dye), from American
Dyestuff
Corp.
Dye C: Solvent Blue 45 (2, max = -624 nm, anthracene dye, also called Savinyl
Blue RS),
from Clariant International Ltd.
The prepared formulations contained around 39-44 % by weight of solids (dry
extract
weight relative to the weight of the composition). The dye was the last
ingredient added to the
compositions. Each of the coating solutions was deposited by spin coating onto
a cleaned face
of an Orma lens previously cleaned with diluted NaOH (500 rpm for 5s, then
1000 rpm for 10s,
examples 1-2, C1-C2), or by dip coating onto both faces of such lens (at a
speed of 2.0 mm/s,
all examples except examples 1-2, C1-C2). A pre-curing at 80 C for 15 minutes
and a curing at
110 C for 3 hours were then performed. The coating thicknesses were 5 pm.
Evaluation of the coating performances
a) Dye photo-degradation in epoxy coatings was measured by subjecting the
prepared
lenses to the Q-sun test. This test uses a Q-SUN Xe-3 xenon chamber,
purchased from Q-LAB,
at a relative humidity of 20% ( 5%) and at a temperature of 23 C ( 5 C),
reproducing full
spectrum sunlight.
A sample lens coated with an epoxy coating containing at least one dye was
measured
by a Cary 50 spectrophotometer to get a transmission (T%) spectrum. Then the
lens was
introduced in the xenon chamber and its convex side was exposed to the light
for 40h inside the
Q-sun chamber. The lens was measured by the Cary 50 spectrophotometer again
to get a T%
spectrum. An uncoated Orma lens was used as the reference lens, tested before
& after the
40h sun exposure test as well. Because there was very little change of the
Orma lens
spectrum before & after the sun exposure test, its change was neglected during
the calculation.
The formula used to calculate the photo-degradation level of the dye in an
epoxy coating
coated on Orma lens is described below, using the transmittance % at 2, max:
Dye photo-degradation = (r)/0 dye? max 40h - TOA dye? max Oh) / (TO/0 Orma k
max 40h - TOA dye? max Oh)
For example, an Orma lens coated with a blue dye coating (2nax of the dye:
580nm)
showed 80% of transmittance initially, which changed to 86% after 40h of Q-sun
exposure test.
The reference Orma lens showed 92% of initial transmittance at 580nm, which
only changed to
91.8% after 40h of Q-sun exposure, indicating almost no change of Orma lens
at this
wavelength. In this case, blue dye photo-degradation = (86-80)! (92-80)*100 =
50%.
b) Haze was measured as disclosed in WO 2012/173596, on a Hazeguard XL 211
Plus
apparatus from BYK-Gardner in accordance with the standard ASTM D1003-00. As
haze is a
measurement of the percentage of transmitted light scattered more than 2.5
from the axis of
the incident light, the smaller the haze value, the lower the degree of
cloudiness. Generally, for
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
23
optical articles described herein, a haze value of less than or equal to 0.3 %
is acceptable, more
preferably of less than or equal to 0.2 %.
c) Oxygen transmission rate was measured according to ASTM F1307-02 using a
MOCON OX-TRAN Model 2/21. The coated lens or BOPP (biaxially-oriented
polypropylene)
film samples were glued on metal masks using epoxy glue, allowed for air
drying overnight in
the ambient conditions, near 23 C, 50% relative humidity. The test conditions
were at 35 C, 70%
relative humidity. Minimum seven cycles of measurements were performed. One
side of testing
samples was exposed to a dry carrier gas (nitrogen with <2% hydrogen) and the
other side was
exposed to 100% dry oxygen gas. A permeation rate was calculated from the flow
rate and
concentration of the certified tank gas.
Compositions and results
The various ingredients used to prepare the compositions 1-8 according to the
invention
and the comparative compositions C1-C2 as well as the results of the tests
performed are
shown in the tables hereunder.
Example Cl C2
Epoxy compound EGDGE GE-30
( /0) 37.7 37.7
Nacure Super
5.7 5.7
A218(%)
EFKA) 3034 ( /0) 0.1 0.1
Dowanor PM
56.5 56.5
( /0)
C1-1 C1-2 C1-3 C2-1 C2-2 C2-
3
Dye Dye A Dye B Dye C Dye A Dye B Dye C
0.04 % 0.04 % 0.15% 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.15%
Wt. % of epoxy
compounds 0 0
according to the
invention (*)
Haze (%) 0.4 2.0 0.9 0.6 1.0 0.8
Photo-
94 41 87 89 39 75
degradation (%)
Example 1
EPALLOY) 9000
Epoxy compound (%)
37.7
Nacure Super A218 ( /0) 5.7
EFKA) 3034 ( /0) 0.1
Dowanor PM ( /0) 56.5
1-1 1-2 1-3
Dye Dye A Dye B Dye C
0.04% 0.04% 0.15%
Wt. % of epoxy
compounds according to 100
the invention (*)
Haze (%) 0.1 0.1 0.1
Photo-degradation ( /0) 16 7 13
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
24
Example 2 3 4
GE-60 ( /0) 3.4 10.3 3.4
-0
c GE-30 ( /0) 6.9 0 0
>, =
x UVACure
o 1500 ( /) 28.1 0 28.1
a g 0
o EPALLOY)
0 0 28.1 6.9
9000 ( /0)
Nacure Super A218 (%) 5.5 5.8 5.5
EFKA) 3034 (%) 0.1 0.1 0.1
Dowanor PM ( /0) 56.0 55.7 56.0
2-1 2-2 3-1 3-2 4-1 4-2
Dye Dye A Dye B Dye A Dye B Dye A Dye B
0.04 % 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.04 %
Wt. % of epoxy compounds
73 73 91
according to the invention (*)
Haze (%) 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
Photo-degradation ( /0) 12 14 5 0 4 1
Oxygen transmission rate
(cmi. mil/(100 in2.day.atm)) 12.4 n.a. n.a.
(**)
(*) Relative to the total weight of epoxy compounds in the composition.
(**) Measured in the absence of dye, fora 10 pm thick coating.
Example 5 6 7
GE-60 ( /0) 1.7 2.3 2.77
-0
c GE-30 ( /0) 3.45 4.66
5.63
>, =
x UVACure
o s g 1500 (%) 14.05 18.97
22.93
ua0
o Glymo ( /0) 9.8 18.3
11.7
0
KBE-402) ( /0) 5.1 0 0
Nacure Super A218 (%) 2.75 3.71 4.49
EFKA) 3034 (%) 0.05 0.068 0.082
0.1 N HCI ( /0) 3.3 4.2 2.7
Colloidal silica
31.6 0 0
(30 % wt. in Me0H) (%)
Dowanor PM ( /0) 28 47.8 49.7
Dye A ( /0) 0.04 0.04 0.04
Wt. % of epoxy
compounds according to 41 43 53
the invention (*)
Dry extract weight % of
epoxy compounds
35 48 56
according to the invention
(**)
Haze (%) 0.1 0.1 0.1
Photo-degradation ( /0) 16 13 11
(*) Relative to the total weight of epoxy compounds in the composition.
(**) Relative to the dry extract weight of the composition.
In the lenses having epoxy coatings according to the invention, degradation of
the
various dyes was reduced to less than 30 %, generally less than 20 % under the
Q-sun test
conditions, while lenses having comparative epoxy coatings (with no epoxy
compounds
comprising a cycloaliphatic or aryl group such as in comparative examples 01-
02 or with such
epoxy compounds in an insufficient amount) tend to photo-degrade the same dyes
up to 94 %
under the same conditions.
CA 03040582 2019-04-15
WO 2018/095679
PCT/EP2017/077266
As can also be seen, all epoxy coatings according to the invention showed low
haze
(0.1 %) with all the dyes, while comparative coatings generally had higher
haze levels, up to 2 %
(comparative example Cl). These low haze results demonstrate that there is a
good
compatibility between the epoxy compounds according to the invention and the
dye molecules.
5
The photo-degradation of the dyes can be further reduced by incorporating in
the coating
composition at least one UV absorber. For example, when 3 % by weight of
Tinuvin 1130 were
incorporated in the compositions of examples 5-7, photo-degradation of the ABS-
420 dye
during the Q-sun test was reduced from 11-16 % down to 5-8 %.
Another means to reduce the photo-degradation of the dye is to deposit on the
epoxy
10
coating according to the invention an antireflection coating acting as an
oxygen barrier or an UV
shield. Two of such antireflection coatings have been used in examples 3-1B
and 3-10 shown
in the table below and reduced the photo-degradation of the ABS-420 dye
during the Q-sun
test from 12 % down to 0 (%:
Example 3-1 3-1A 3-1B 3-1C
Epoxy coating
Yes Yes Yes Yes
containing 0.04 % dye A
Primer No Yes Yes Yes
Hard coat No Yes Yes Yes
Antireflection coating 1 No No Yes No
Antireflection coating 2 No No No Yes
Haze ( /0) 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1
Photo-degradation ( /0) 12 15 0 0
The lens of example 3-1A is the lens of example 3-1, further coated in this
order with a
polyurethane-based impact-resistant primer with a thickness of 1 micron
(Witcobond latex W-
234 ), and an abrasion-resistant coating with a thickness of 3 microns
obtained by depositing
and curing the composition of example 3 of the patent EP 0614957 (comprising y-
glycidoxypropyl trimethoxysilane, dimethyldiethoxysilane, colloidal silica and
aluminium
acetylacetonate). It can be seen that such coatings hardly alter the
resistance to photo-
degradation of the dye present in the epoxy coating.
The lens of example 3-1B is the lens of example 3-1A, further coated with the
antireflective coating of example 6 of the patent application WO 2008/107325.
Said coating was
deposited by evaporation under vacuum on the abrasion resistant coating of the
lens of
example 3-1A. Said antireflection coating comprises a 150 nm thick 5i02 sub-
layer and the
stack Zr02/5i02/Zr02/1TO/5i02 (respective thicknesses of the layers: 29, 23,
68, 7 and 85 nm).
An ITO layer is an electrically conductive layer of indium oxide doped with
tin (In203:Sn).
The lens of example 3-10 is the lens of example 3-1A, further coated with the
front face
antireflective coating of example 1 of WO 2013/171435, with a 6.5 nm thick
indium tin oxide
layer interleaved between the 73 nm thick ZrO2 layer and the 110 nm thick 5i02
layer.
