Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
A METHOD FOR PRODUCTION OF METHYL METHACRYLATE
BY OXIDATIVE ESTERIFICATION USING A HETEROGENEOUS CATALYST
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to a method for preparing methyl methacrylate from
methacrolein and methanol using a heterogeneous catalyst.
Methyl methacrylate has been produced by oxidative esterification reactions in
which decreases in pH of the reaction mixture are known to be detrimental. The
prior art
teaches addition of base to the reactor to raise pH to extend catalyst life
which otherwise
would be shortened under acidic conditions. The solution to this problem has
been to mix
the base into a portion of the reaction mixture in a separate vessel, see,
e.g., U.S. Pub. No.
2016/0251301. However, there is a need for a more efficient process which can
provide
high space-time yield, improved selectivity and reduced costs.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention is directed to a method for preparing methyl
methacrylate
from methacrolein and methanol; said method comprising contacting in a reactor
a mixture
comprising methacrolein, methanol and oxygen with a heterogeneous catalyst
comprising a
support and a noble metal, wherein pH at the reactor outlet is from 3 to 6.7.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
All percentage compositions are weight percentages (wt%), and all temperatures
are
in C, unless otherwise indicated. Averages are arithmetic averages unless
otherwise
indicated. A noble metal is any of gold, platinum, iridium, osmium, silver,
palladium,
rhodium and ruthenium. More than one noble metal may be present in the
catalyst, in
which case the limits apply to the total of all noble metals. The "catalyst
center" is the
centroid of the catalyst particle, i.e., the mean position of all points in
all coordinate
directions. A diameter is any linear dimension passing through the catalyst
center and the
average diameter is the arithmetic mean of all possible diameters. The aspect
ratio is the
ratio of the longest to the shortest diameters.
Preferably, pH at the reactor outlet is at least 3.5, preferably at least 4,
preferably at
least 4.5, preferably at least 4.8, preferably at least 5; preferably no more
than 6.6,
preferably no more than 6.5, preferably no more than 6.4, preferably no more
than 6.3,
preferably no more than 6.2. Preferably, base is not added to the reactor or
to liquid streams
entering the reactor. Preferably, the reactor is not connected to an external
mixing tank
through which base is introduced. pH in the reactor is likely to be higher,
possibly above 7
1
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
near the inlet and dropping below 6 at the outlet. Preferably, pH at the inlet
is no greater
than 8, preferably no greater than 7.5, preferably no greater than 7.
Preferably, the support is a particle of a refractory oxide; preferably y-, 6-
, or 0-
alumina, silica, magnesia, titania, zirconia, hafnia, vanadia, niobium oxide,
tantalum oxide,
ceria, yttria, lanthanum oxide or a combination thereof; preferably titania or
y-, 6-, or 0-
alumina. Preferably, in portions of the catalyst comprising the noble metal,
the support has
a surface area greater than 10 m2/g, preferably greater than 30 m2/g,
preferably greater than
50 m2/g, preferably greater than 100 m2/g, preferably greater than 120 m2/g.
In portions of
the catalyst which comprise little or no noble metal, the support may have a
surface area
less than 50 m2/g, preferably less than 20 m2/g.
Preferably, the aspect ratio of the catalyst particle is no more than 10:1,
preferably
no more than 5:1, preferably no more than 3:1, preferably no more than 2:1,
preferably no
more than 1.5:1, preferably no more than 1.1:1. Preferred shapes for the
catalyst particle
include spheres, cylinders, rectangular solids, rings, multi-lobed shapes
(e.g., cloverleaf
cross section), shapes having multiple holes and "wagon wheels:" preferably
spheres.
Irregular shapes may also be used.
Preferably, at least 90 wt% of the noble metal(s) is in the outer 70% of
catalyst
volume (i.e., the volume of an average catalyst particle), preferably the
outer 60% of
catalyst volume, preferably the outer 50%, preferably the outer 40%,
preferably the outer
35%, preferably in the outer 30%, preferably in the outer 25%. Preferably, the
outer volume
of any particle shape is calculated for a volume having a constant distance
from its inner
surface to its outer surface (the surface of the particle), measured along a
line perpendicular
to the outer surface. For example, for a spherical particle the outer x% of
volume is a
spherical shell whose outer surface is the surface of the particle and whose
volume is x% of
the volume of the entire sphere. Preferably, at least 95 wt% of the noble
metal is in the
outer volume of the catalyst, preferably at least 97 wt%, preferably at least
99 wt%.
Preferably, at least 90 wt% (preferably at least 95 wt%, preferably at least
97 wt%,
preferably at least 99 wt%) of the noble metal(s) is within a distance from
the surface that is
no more than 30% of the catalyst diameter, preferably no more than 25%,
preferably no
more than 20%, preferably no more than 15%, preferably no more than 10%,
preferably no
more than 8%. Distance from the surface is measured along a line which is
perpendicular to
the surface.
Preferably, the noble metal is gold or palladium, preferably gold.
2
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
Preferably, the average diameter of the catalyst particle is at least 60
microns,
preferably at least 100 microns, preferably at least 200 microns, preferably
at least 300
microns, preferably at least 400 microns, preferably at least 500 microns,
preferably at least
600 microns, preferably at least 700 microns, preferably at least 800 microns;
preferably no
more than 30 mm, preferably no more than 20 mm, preferably no more than 10 mm,
preferably no more than 5 mm, preferably no more than 4 mm. The average
diameter of the
support and the average diameter of the final catalyst particle are not
significantly different.
Preferably, the amount of noble metal as a percentage of the noble metal and
the
support is from 0.2 to 5 wt%, preferably at least 0.5 wt%, preferably at least
0.8 wt%,
preferably at least 1 wt%, preferably at least 1.2 wt%; preferably no more
than 4 wt%,
preferably no more than 3 wt%, preferably no more than 2.5 wt%.
Preferably, the catalyst is produced by precipitating the noble metal from an
aqueous
solution of metal salts in the presence of the support. In one preferred
embodiment, the
catalyst is produced by an incipient wetness technique in which an aqueous
solution of a
suitable noble metal precursor salt is added to a porous inorganic oxide such
that the pores
are filled with the solution and the water is then removed by drying. The
resulting material
is then converted into a finished catalyst by calcination, reduction, or other
pre-treatments
known to those skilled in the art to decompose the noble metal salts into
metals or metal
oxides. Preferably, a C2-C18 thiol comprising at least one hydroxyl or
carboxylic acid
substituent is present in the solution. Preferably, the C2-Cis thiol
comprising at least one
hydroxyl or carboxylic acid substituent has from 2 to 12 carbon atoms,
preferably 2 to 8,
preferably 3 to 6. Preferably, the thiol compound comprises no more than 4
total hydroxyl
and carboxylic acid groups, preferably no more than 3, preferably no more than
2.
Preferably, the thiol compound has no more than 2 thiol groups, preferably no
more than
one. If the thiol compound comprises carboxylic acid substituents, they may be
present in
the acid form, conjugate base form or a mixture thereof. Especially preferred
thiol
compounds include thiomalic acid, 3-mercaptopropionic acid, thioglycolic acid,
2-
mercaptoethanol and 1-thioglycerol, including their conjugate bases.
In one embodiment of the invention, the catalyst is produced by deposition
precipitation in which a porous inorganic oxide is immersed in an aqueous
solution
containing a suitable noble metal precursor salt and that salt is then made to
interact with
the surface of the inorganic oxide by adjusting the pH of the solution. The
resulting treated
solid is then recovered (e.g. by filtration) and then converted into a
finished catalyst by
3
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
calcination, reduction, or other pre-treatments known to those skilled in the
art to
decompose the noble metal salts into metals or metal oxides.
Preferably, the process for producing methyl methacrylate (MMA) is performed
in
an oxidative esterification reactor (OER). The catalyst particles may be
present in a slurry
or in a catalyst bed, preferably a catalyst bed. The catalyst particles in the
catalyst bed
typically are held in place by solid walls and by screens or catalyst support
grids. In some
configurations, the screens or grids are on opposite ends of the catalyst bed
and the solid
walls are on the side(s), although in some configurations the catalyst bed may
be enclosed
entirely by screens. Preferred shapes for the catalyst bed include a cylinder,
a rectangular
solid and a cylindrical shell; preferably a cylinder. The OER further
comprises a liquid
phase comprising methacrolein, methanol and MMA and a gaseous phase comprising
oxygen. The liquid phase may further comprise byproducts, e.g., methacrolein
dimethyl
acetal (MDA) and methyl isobutyrate (MIB). Preferably, the liquid phase is at
a
temperature from 40 to 120 C; preferably at least 50 C, preferably at least
60 C;
preferably no more than 110 C, preferably no more than 100 C. Preferably,
the catalyst
bed is at a pressure from 0 to 2000 psig (101 kPa to 14 MPa); preferably no
more than 2000
kPa, preferably no more than 1500 kPa.
The OER typically produces MMA, along with methacrylic acid and unreacted
methanol. Preferably, methanol and methacrolein are fed to the reactor in a
methanol:methacrolein molar ratio from 1:10 to 100:1, preferably from 1:2 to
20:1,
preferably from 1:1 to 10:1. Preferably, a catalyst bed further comprises
inert materials
above and/or below the catalyst. Preferred inert materials include, e.g.,
alumina, clay, glass,
silica carbide and quartz. Preferably, the inert material has an average
diameter equal to or
greater than that of the catalyst, preferably no greater than 20 mm.
Preferably, the reaction
products are fed to a methanol recovery distillation column which provides an
overhead
stream rich in methanol and methacrolein; preferably this stream is recycled
back to the
OER. The bottoms stream from the methanol recovery distillation column
comprises
MMA, MDA, methacrylic acid, salts and water. In one embodiment of the
invention, MDA
is hydrolyzed in a medium comprising MMA, MDA, methacrylic acid, salts and
water.
MDA may be hydrolyzed in the bottoms stream from a methanol recovery
distillation
column; said stream comprising MMA, MDA, methacrylic acid, salts and water. In
another embodiment, MDA is hydrolyzed in an organic phase separated from the
methanol
recovery bottoms stream. It may be necessary to add water to the organic phase
to ensure
that there is sufficient water for the MDA hydrolysis; these amounts may be
determined
4
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
easily from the composition of the organic phase. The product of the MDA
hydrolysis
reactor is phase separated and the organic phase passes through one or more
distillation
columns to produce MMA product and light and/or heavy byproducts. In another
embodiment, hydrolysis could be conducted within the distillation column
itself.
One preferred embodiment is a recycle reactor with cooling capacity in the
recycle
loop. Another preferred embodiment is a series of reactors with cooling and
mixing capacity
between the reactors.
Preferably, oxygen concentration at a reactor outlet is at least 0.5 mole %,
preferably
at least 2 mole %, preferably at least 3 mole %; preferably no more than 7
mole %,
preferably no more than 6.5 mole %, preferably no more than 6 mole %.
One preferred embodiment of the fixed bed reactor for oxidative esterification
is a
trickle bed reactor, which contains a fixed bed of catalyst and passes both
the gas and liquid
feeds through the reactor in the downward direction. In trickle flow, the gas
phase is the
continuous fluid phase. Thus, the zone at the top of the reactor, above the
fixed bed, will be
.. filled with a vapor phase mixture of nitrogen, oxygen, and the volatile
liquid components at
their respective vapor pressures. Under typical operating temperatures and
pressures (50-
90 C and 60-300 psig), this vapor mixture is inside the flammable envelope if
the gas feed
is air. Thus, only an ignition source would be required to initiate a
deflagration, which
could lead to loss of primary containment and harm to the physical
infrastructure and
.. personnel in the vicinity. In order to address process safety
considerations, a means to
operate a trickle bed reactor while avoiding a flammable headspace atmosphere
is operation
with a gas feed containing a sufficiently low oxygen mole fraction to ensure
the oxygen
concentration in the vapor headspace is below the limiting oxygen
concentration (LOC).
Knowledge of the LOC is required for the fuel mixture, temperature, and
pressure of
concern. Since the LOC decreases with increasing temperature and pressure, and
given that
methanol gives a lower LOC than the other two significant fuels (methacrolein
and methyl
methacrylate), a conservative design chooses a feed oxygen to nitrogen ratio
that ensures a
composition with less than the LOC at the highest expected operating
temperature and
pressure. For example, for a reactor operated at up to 100 C and 275 psig, the
feed oxygen
concentration in nitrogen should not exceed 7.4 mol%.
5
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
EXAMPLES
Example #1
Feed consisting primarily of methacrolein, methanol and sometimes base were
fed to a fixed
bed reactor in order to produce MMA. The fixed bed reactor was operated as an
adiabatic
packed bubble column. Air and liquid feed were fed into the bottom of the
vertically
aligned reactor (a 2-inch (51 mm) OD (1.624-inch (41.2 mm) ID) x 108 inch (274
cm)
insulated 316SS tube). The liquid feed was approximately 35 wt% methacrolein
and was
pumped from the feed mix tank to the suction of a positive displacement pump.
The
positive displacement pump recycles reactor product from the gas-liquid
separation tank
with make-up from the feed mix tank. Gas was introduced into the reactor using
a frit
located at the base of the reactor. The pH of the feed entering the reactor
was measured.
The liquid feed is pre-heated to the desired temperature using a heat
exchanger. The reactor
product is sent to the gas-liquid separation vessel, which is jacketed and
cooled with cooling
water. Base (25 wt% NaOH in water) is optionally pumped into the gas-liquid
separation
tank. The addition of base was designed to neutralize the methacrylic acid
formed in the
reactor. The target acid neutralization was 50 mol%, corresponding to a
measured pH near
7. To maintain adequate mixing for acid-base neutralization, the gas-liquid
separation tank
was agitated, with impellers approximately equally separated in the liquid
from top to
bottom. Vapors from the gas-liquid separation tank passed through a condenser,
where
noncondensable gases exit through a vent. Oxygen concentration in the vented
noncondensable stream is monitored using an online oxygen analyzer downstream
of the
condenser. A polymerization inhibitor is pumped into the top of the condenser,
where it
drips back into the gas-liquid separation tank. Inhibitor also enters with the
feed.
Description of catalyst 1: The catalyst is 1.44 +/- 0.05 wt% Au (measured by
NAA-ICP) on
1 mm high-surface-area A1203 spheres. The catalyst is produced by incipient
wetness
technique using Au thiomalate as a gold precursor, which has been shown to
provide an
eggshell loading of the Au around the 1 mm A1203 spheres.
Description of catalyst 2: The catalyst is approximately 1.5 wt% Au on 3.2 mm
high-
surface-area A1203 spheres. The catalyst is produced by incipient wetness
technique using
Au thiomalate as a gold precursor, which has been shown to provide an eggshell
loading of
the Au.
6
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
STY
Feed +
base pH at (mol Prod" Air Feed
Cat. MMA / MMA
cony MIB Piniet Po.det Rate, Rate Recycle T
outlet
inlet* kg cat (%) SLPM (g/hr) FB
(%) (ppm) (psig) (psig) Rate (C)
hr) (g/hr)
1 Off 5.7 54.60 4.5 97% 280 281 276 9.7 2636 13256 78
1 On 7.0 66.70 5.0 98% 227 280 275 11 2636 15877 80
2 On 6.7 58.20 3.4 97% 507 164 161 7.5 1810 15813 70
2 Off 5.7 62 3.2 97% 318 163 160 7.2 1767 15501 69
* Estimated from MAA content.
Notes:
1. Performance is similar with or without base. Prod MMA is the percent MMA
among
products originating as methacrolein reactant. MIB is on a 100% MMA basis.
2. Fouling of Downstream Separations Section:
When base was added, the column pressure drop kept increasing which made it
difficult to
continue operation of the downstream distillation column. In particular, for
the catalyst 1
case, pressure drop in at least one column of the distillation section
increased by 10% over
the course of approximately 3 days which prohibited further operation.
Analysis of residues
in the column showed the presence of aluminum salts and solids appear to form
more
readily in the distillation section in the base addition case. In the absence
of base, the
downstream distillation operated without any pressure drop buildup.
Example #2
A series of runs was conducted in which 20 wt% methacrolein, 200 ppm
inhibitor, and a
balance of methanol were fed to a 3/8" stainless steel tubular reactor
containing a short front
section of silica carbide followed by 10 g of catalyst. The catalyst consisted
of 1.5wt% Au
on a Norpro lmm diameter high surface area alumina spherical support. Air or a
gas
containing 8 mol% oxygen in nitrogen were also feed to the reactor. The
reactor was
operated at 60 C and 160 psig (1200 kPa). The product of the reactor was sent
to a liquid-
vapor separator and the vapor was sent to a condenser with liquid return. A
portion of the
product stream from this separator was recycled in some cases to the reactor
inlet and
combined with the feed entering the reactor. Results are described in the
below table. MIB
is reported in ppm on a 100% MMA product basis. Product MMA is the percent MMA
among products originating as methacrolein reactant.
7
CA 03071244 2020-01-27
WO 2019/022892
PCT/US2018/039242
Base pH Gas Prod
type Feed recyc. Base out Gas Type MMA Cony STY MIB
MMA, (m/Kg
(g/hr) (g/hr) (g/hr) (sccm) % (%)
hr) (PP111)
None 20 0 0 5.7 450 8% 02 97.8 76 3.8
460
None 20 180 0 5.7 380 8%02 97.8 63 3.2 480
None 200 0 0 6.3 190 AIR 97.9 15 8.2
600
0.15wt%
Na0Me 20 180 20 6.8 300 8% 02 93.7 60
2.7 800
None 100 0 0 na 120 AIR 97.5 29 6.5
na
None 150 0 0 na 120 AIR 97.2 21 6.8
220
Note: Performance is similar with or without base.
8
