Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
COBALT CHROME ETCHING PROCESS
RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0001] This paragraph is intentionally blank.
TECHNICAL FIELD
[0002] This invention pertains generally to compositions for the controlled
etching of
cobalt chromium-based alloys and methods of use thereof to etch cobalt
chromes.
BACKGROUND
[0003] Cobalt chromium alloys, commonly referred to as Cobalt-Chrome (CoCr),
are
generally corrosion resistant and extremely hard. These outstanding properties
result from the
crystallographic nature of cobalt, the strengthening effect of chromium and
other alloying
elements, the formation of extremely hard carbides, and the corrosion
resistance imparted by
chromium. These qualities make CoCr alloys desirable in industrial, medical
and technical fields.
It also makes the alloys very difficult to chemically mill or chemically
machine, by which we mean
to intentionally corrode or etch the material in a predictable and controlled
manner.
[0004] In several fields where CoCr is used, it is desirable to obtain as
smooth a surface
condition as practical, without excessive removal of material. This is
particularly true with respect
to aerospace applications, where the target is to prepare a surface for dye
penetrant or other
inspections, to improve air flow patterns and characteristics, and to improve
long term fatigue
performance.
[0005] Abrasive flow smoothing or machining has historically been used for
smoothing of
cobalt chromium alloys. In such a process, a highly viscous fluid comprising
an abrasive material
is forced over surfaces and through internal passageways of a work-piece to
polish those surfaces
and passageways. The viscosity of the fluid, and often highly intricate system
of piping
connections needed to direct the fluid through the passageways of the work-
piece make this
process slow and expensive. Moreover, every unique work-piece typically
requires a uniquely
designed system of piping connections, adding to the expense of the process.
[0006] Certain chemistries have been shown to provide a relatively smooth
surface while
only removing small amounts of material through chemical attack, most notably,
a mixture of
1
Date Recue/Date Received 2021-06-14
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCMJS2019/066538
concentrated hydrogen peroxide and concentrated hydrochloric acid. These
methods are suitable
only for superficial removal of material as the mixture is volatile, depletes
quickly, and suffers
from aggressive metal-ion driven decomposition of the peroxide. Further, this
solution
commonly results in significant intergranular attack (IGA) of the CoCr
materials.
100071 Accordingly, a controlled means of reliably and predictably removing
material
from CoCr alloys through chemical machining is desired, and would find
application in several
different fields, including medical, aerospace, and specialty industrial.
Moreover, means to
remove material from CoCr alloys in order to impart a particular surface
roughness or
microscopic surface profile for enhanced or accelerated bio-integration, or a
particular surface
smoothness for aerospace applications that may improve air flow patterns and
characteristics and
enhance dye penetrant or other inspections, is desired. Means to remove
material from CoCr
alloys in order to reduce weight of a part, remove 3D printed support
structures, and improve
long term fatigue performance, among other applications is also desired.
SUMMARY
100081 To meet this and other needs, the present invention provides
compositions useful
for controlled chemical etching of cobalt chromium alloys, and methods of
their use to provide
surfaces having finely tunable characteristics, such as smooth surfaces useful
in the aerospace
ndustry
100091 The presently disclosed invention includes a composition for etching a
cobalt
chromium alloy, wherein the composition comprises at least two mineral acids,
iron (Fe), and
low concentrations of certain component metals of the alloy to be etched. For
example, when
etching a cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy, the metals may include chromium
(Cr),
molybdenum (Mo), and optionally, cobalt (Co). According to certain aspects,
the composition
may comprise 50 ¨ 225 g/1 iron (Fe), 1 ¨ 10 g/1 chromium (Cr), 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1
molybdenum (Mo),
and 0 to 10 g/1 cobalt (Co).
100101 The presently disclosed invention also includes a composition for
etching a cobalt
chromium alloy, wherein the composition comprises at least two mineral acids,
and high
concentrations of component metals of the alloy to be etched. For example,
when etching a
cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy, the metals may include cobalt (Co), chromium
(Cr), and
molybdenum (Mo). Exemplary amounts of such metals in the composition include 7
to 355 g/1
cobalt (Co), 3 ¨ 170 g/1 chromium (Cr), and 1 ¨ 40 g/1 molybdenum (Mo).
According to certain
2
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
aspects, the component metals may be included in amounts that mimic the ratio
they are included
in the metal alloy (i.e., the native ratio of metals in the alloy). For
example, when the alloy is a
cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy, the component metals may be provided at
about 63-
68 wt.% Co, 27-30 wt.% Cr, and 5-7 wt.% Mo, based on the total weight of the
alloy.
100111 According to certain aspects, the at least two mineral acids may be
selected from
hydrochloric acid (HC1), nitric acid (HNO3), sulfuric acid (H2SO4), iodic acid
(HI03), and
hydrofluoric acid (HF). According to certain aspects, the at least two mineral
acids may comprise
hydrochloric acid (HC1), nitric acid (HNO3), and hydrofluoric acid (HF).
[0012] According to certain aspects, the composition may comprise 2N to 5N
hydrochloric acid (HC1), 0.05N to 0.8N nitric acid (HNO3), and 0.6N to 1.3N
hydrofluoric acid
(HF). According to certain aspects, the composition may be an aqueous
solution.
[0013] According to certain aspects of the present invention, the alloy
material may be
etched on one or more surfaces by contacting the work-piece with any of the
chemical etching
compositions disclosed herein. Before the work-piece can be etched with the
chemical etching
compositions of the presently disclosed invention, the work-piece may require
an activation step.
An exemplary activation step includes exposing the surface of the work-piece
that is to be etched
to a mineral acid such as a 10% to 100% solution of concentrated hydrochloric
acid (v/v; dilution
with an aqueous buffer or water). The surface may be exposed to the mineral
acid at a range of
temperatures, such as room temperature, wherein higher temperatures require
lower
concentrations of the mineral acid. The alloy material may be exposed to the
mineral acid by
submersion or spraying.
[0014] Immediately after activation, such as within 30 seconds, the work-piece
may be
exposed to the chemical etching compositions as described herein below.
According to certain
aspects, the work-piece may still be "wet" with the activation solution (i.e.,
mineral acid such as
the 10%-100% dilution of hydrochloric acid).
[0015] After the surface of the work-piece is activated, it may be etched by
contact with
the chemical etching compositions, which may include dipping or submersing the
work-piece in
the composition, or spraying, rolling, or brushing the composition onto one or
more surfaces of
the work-piece.
100161 Thus, the presently disclosed invention also includes methods for
etching an alloy
material. Accordiriu to certain aspects, one method may include preparing one
of the chemical
3
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
etching compositions described above, activating the alloy material (e.g., a
work-piece) with a
mineral acid, and contacting the alloy material with the chemical etching
composition.
According to certain aspects, the step of contacting with the chemical etching
composition may
be carried out immediately after the activation step, such as before the alloy
material dries (i.e.,
from exposure to the mineral acid), or within 30 seconds after exposure to the
mineral acid.
[0017] According to certain aspects, the alloy material may be contacted with
the
chemical etching composition at a temperature of from about 20 C to about 100
C, such as from
about 30 C to about 100 C, or from about 40 C to about 100 C, or from about 50
C to about
100 C, or from about 60 C to about 100 C. According to yet further aspects,
the alloy material
may be contacted with the chemical etching composition at a temperature of
from about 65 C to
about 95 C, such as from about 80 C to about 95 C, such as from about 82 C to
about 88 C, or
from about 88 C to about 91 C. Further, the alloy material may be agitated in
the chemical
etching composition. Further yet, the alloy material may be contacted with the
chemical etching
composition for an unlimited time period based on the desired depth of etch,
such as preferably
from 5 to 50 minutes, such as from 20 to 35 minutes.
[0018] According to certain aspects of the present invention, another method
for etching
an alloy material may include contacting at least one surface of a work-piece
with a chemical
etching composition. The alloy material may be agitated during contact with
the chemical
etching composition. The chemical etching composition, and the times and
temperatures used for
exposure of the alloy material to the chemical etching composition may be as
disclosed
hereinabove.
[0019] The presently disclosed invention further includes methods for etching
a patterned
design in a metal alloy. The method may comprise applying a coating which
resists chemical
etchants to at least a portion of the metal alloy, removing a portion of the
coating to form a
patterned design in the coating, and applying a chemical etching composition.
The chemical
etching composition, and the times and temperatures used for exposure of the
alloy material to
the chemical etching composition may be as disclosed hereinabove. Moreover,
prior to etching,
the alloy material may be activated as described hereinabove, such as before
etching, or even
before application of the coating material (i.e., before patterning).
4
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
[0020] The method may further comprise stripping the coating from the metal
alloy after
the patterned etching is complete. The metal alloy may form all or a portion
of a work-piece,
including parts of the work-piece or a coating thereon.
[0021] According to certain aspects, the metal alloy to be etched by the
compositions or
methods disclosed herein may be a cobalt chromium alloy such as, for example,
a cobalt
chromium molybdenum alloy, cobalt chromium tungsten nickel alloy, or a cobalt
nickel
chromium molybdenum alloy.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
100221 FIGS. 1A-1F show micrographs of cobalt-chromium alloy surfaces, where
FIGS.
1A and 1B are 150x and 1000x magnifications, respectively, of a native alloy
surface; FIGS. 1C
and 1D are 150x and 1000x magnifications, respectively, of a surface etched to
2 mil (50 micron)
depth using etch compositions in accordance with certain aspects of the
presently disclosed
invention; and FIGS. 1E and 1F are 150x and 1000x magnifications,
respectively, of a surface
etched to 12 mil (300 micron) depth using etch compositions in accordance with
certain aspects
of the presently disclosed invention.
[0023] 2A-2C show micrographs of a cross-section of a cobalt-chromium-
molybdenum
alloy surface etched with various chemistries according to certain aspects of
the presently
disclosed invention, with a 5 mil (127 micron) scale bar.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0024] In the following description, the present invention is set forth in the
context of
various alternative embodiments and implementations involving chemical
compositions for the
selective removal of surface materials from a cobalt chrome alloy (i.e.,
chemical etching
compositions), and methods of use thereof.
100251 Various aspects of the chemical etching compositions and methods
disclosed
herein may be illustrated by describing components that are coupled, attached,
and/or joined
together. As used herein, the terms "coupled", "attached", and/or "joined" are
interchangeably
recited to indicate either a direct connection between two components or,
where appropriate, an
indirect connection to one another through intervening or intermediate
components. In contrast,
when a component is referred to as being "directly coupled", "directly
attached", and/or "directly
joined" to another component, there are no intervening elements shown in said
examples.
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
[0026] Various aspects of the chemical etching compositions and methods
disclosed
herein may be described and illustrated with reference to one or more
exemplary
implementations. As used herein, the term "exemplary" means "serving as an
example, instance,
or illustration," and should not necessarily be construed as preferred or
advantageous over other
variations of the compositions or methods disclosed herein. "Optional" or
"optionally" means
that the subsequently described event or circumstance may or may not occur,
and that the
description includes instances where the event occurs and instances where it
does not. In
addition, the word "comprising" as used herein means "including, but not
limited to".
[0027] It must also be noted that as used herein and in the appended claims,
the singular
forms "a", "an", and "the" include the plural reference unless the context
clearly dictates
otherwise. Thus, reference to "a" composition, "an" alloy, or "the" metal, may
be a reference to
one or more of these or any other component as disclosed herein.
[0028] Moreover, other than in any operating examples, or where otherwise
indicated, all
numbers expressing, for example, quantities of ingredients used in the
specification and claims
are to be understood as being modified in all instances by the term "about".
Accordingly, unless
indicated to the contrary, the numerical parameters set forth in the following
specification and
appended claims are approximations that may vary depending upon the desired
properties to be
obtained by the present invention. At the very least, and not as an attempt to
limit the application
of the doctrine of equivalents to the scope of the claims, each numerical
parameter should at least
be construed in light of the number of reported significant digits and by
applying ordinary
rounding techniques.
[0029] Notwithstanding that the numerical ranges and parameters setting forth
the broad
scope of the invention are approximations, the numerical values set forth in
the specific
examples are reported as precisely as possible. Any numerical value, however,
inherently
contains certain errors necessarily resulting from the standard variation
found in their respective
testing measurements.
[0030] "Substantially free", as used herein, is understood to mean inclusive
of only trace
amounts of a constituent. "Trace amounts" are those quantitative levels of a
constituent that are
barely detectable and provide no benefit to the functional properties of the
subject composition,
process, or articles formed therefrom. For example, a trace amount may
constitute 1.0 wt.%, 0.5
wt.%, 0.1 wt.%, 0.05 wt.%, or even 0.01 wt.% of a component or constituent of
any of the
6
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
alkaline chemistries disclosed herein. "Totally free", as used herein, is
understood to mean
completely free of a component or constituent.
[0031] Unless defined otherwise, all technical and scientific terms used
herein have the
same meanings as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art.
[0032] The chemical etching compositions disclosed herein provide a means for
performing a subtractive process on a substrate, i.e., chemical etching, also
referred to as
chemical machining or milling. Chemical etching may comprise, for example,
exposure of select
surfaces of an object or work-piece, or the entire work-piece, to the chemical
etching
compositions disclosed herein for a period of time sufficient to remove a
portion of the surface to
a desired depth.
[0033] Chemical etching compositions
[0034] According to aspects of the present invention, the chemical etching
composition
includes at least two mineral acids. A mineral acid is an inorganic acid
derived from one or more
inorganic compounds. All mineral acids release hydrogen ions when dissolved in
water. Suitable
examples of mineral acids include, but are not limited to, hydrochloric acid
(HCl), nitric acid
(TrIN03), phosphoric acid (H3PO4), sulfuric acid (H2SO4), hydrofluoric acid
(TrIF), iodic acid
(H103), and hydrobromic acid (HBr).
[0035] According to certain aspects of the present invention, the at least two
mineral
acids in the chemical etching composition are selected from hydrochloric acid
(HCl), nitric acid
(HNO3), sulfuric acid (H2SO4), iodic acid (HI03), and hydrofluoric acid (HF).
According to
certain aspects, the chemical etching composition comprises hydrochloric acid
(HCl), nitric acid
(HNO3), and hydrofluoric acid (HF).
[0036] According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition
comprises
2N to 5N hydrochloric acid (HCl), 0.05N to 0.8N nitric acid (HNO3), and 0.6N
to 1.3N
hydrofluoric acid (HF). According to certain other aspects, the chemical
etching composition
comprises 3N to 5N HCl, or 4N to 5N HC1; 0.05N to 0.6N HNO3, or 0.05N to 0.4N
HNO3, or
0.05N to 0.2N HNO3, or 0.2N to 0.8N HNO3, or 0.3N to 0.7N HNO3, or 0.4N to
0.6N HNO3;
and 0.7N to 1.2N HF, or 0.8N to 1.1N HF, or 0.7N to 1.0N HF.
[0037] According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition
comprises at
least 2N hydrochloric acid (HCl), such as at least 2.2N, or at least 2.4N, or
at least 2.6N, or at
least 2.8N, or at least 3N, or at least 3.2N, or at least 3.4N, or at least
3.6N, or at least 3.8N, or at
7
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
least 4.0N. According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching
composition comprises up to
5N hydrochloric acid (HC1), such as up to 4.9N, or up to 4.8N, or up to 4.7N,
or up to 4.6N, or
up to 4.5N, or up to 4.4N, or up to 4.3N, or up to 4.2N, or up to 4.1N, or up
to 4.0N.
[0038] According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition
comprises at
least 0.05N nitric acid (HNO3), such as at least 0.1N, or at least 0.2N, or at
least 0.3N, or at least
0.4N, or at least 0.5N, or at least 0.6N, or at least 0.7N. According to
certain other aspects, the
chemical etching composition comprises up to 0.8 nitric acid (HNO3), such as
up to 0.7N, or up
to 0.6N, or up to 0.5N, or up to 0.4N, or up to 0.3N, or up to 0.2N, or up to
0.1N.
[0039] According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition
comprises
at least 0.6N hydrofluoric acid (HF), such as at least 0.7N, or at least 0.8N,
or at least 0.9N, or at
least 1.0 N, or at least 1.1N, or at least 1.2N According to certain other
aspects, the chemical
etching composition comprises up to 1.3N hydrofluoric acid (HF), such as up to
1.2N, or up to
1.1N, or up to 1.0N, or up to 0.9N, or up to 0.8N, or up to 0.7N.
[0040] According to aspects of the present invention, the chemical etching
composition
also comprises component metals of the metal alloy to be etched. For example,
the chemical
etching composition may comprise chromium (Cr) and molybdenum (Mo) for use in
etching a
cobalt chrome work-piece formed from a cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy such
as ASTM
F75, F799, or F1357. As additional examples, the chemical etching composition
may comprise
chromium (Cr), molybdenum (Mo), and nickel (Ni) for use in etching a cobalt
chrome work-
piece formed from a cobalt nickel chromium molybdenum alloy such as ASTM F562,
or
chromium (Cr), nickel (Ni), and tungsten (W) for use in etching a cobalt
chrome work-piece
formed from a cobalt chromium tungsten nickel alloy such as ASTM F90.
100411 According to aspects of the present invention, the chemical etching
composition
may optionally comprise cobalt (Co).
[0042] According to aspects of the present invention, the chemical etching
composition
may further comprise iron (Fe). Without being tied to one theory, it is
believed that the addition
of iron to the chemical etching composition may help to stabilize the reaction
rate of the
composition.
[0043] The present inventors have discovered that for a composition where all
acids are
within the concentration ranges previously discussed, and the component metals
chromium and
molybdenum are present, with or without the presence of cobalt and/or iron,
the surface of the
8
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
processed parts improves (gets smoother, i.e., the surface roughness, or Ra,
decreases) with
increased metals content.
[0044] Without being tied to one theory, the increased metals content may
improve the
surface finish (smoothness) regardless of the metals used to raise the metals
content, but the level
of improvement has been found to depend on the types and ratios of the metals
used. That is,
increasing the concentration of metals primarily by increasing the iron
content shows surface
roughness improvement, but the surface is improved further by increasing the
content of the
component metals (e.g., chromium, molybdenum, and cobalt) while leaving iron
content low or
absent.
[0045] Thus, according to a first embodiment of the presently disclosed
invention, the
chemical etching composition may comprise at least two mineral acids, iron,
and low to
moderate concentrations of certain component metals of the alloy to be etched.
For example, the
composition may comprise any two or more of the mineral acids listed herein,
and 50 ¨ 225 g/1
iron (Fe), 1 ¨ 10 g/1 chromium (Cr), 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), and
optionally cobalt (Co),
such as 0 to 10 g/1 cobalt (Co) when the alloy to be etched is a cobalt
chromium molybdenum
alloy.
[0046] According to certain other aspects of the first embodiment, the
chemical etching
composition comprises at least 50 g/1 iron (Fe), or at least 70 g/1, or at
least 90 g/1, or at least 110
g/1, or at least 130 g/1, or at least 150 g/1, or at least 170 g/l, or at
least 200 g/1. According to
certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition comprises up to 225
g/1 iron (Fe), such as
up to 200 g/1, or up to 160 g/l, or up to 140 g/l, or up to 120 g/1, or up to
100 g/1, or up to 80 g/1,
or up to 60 g/1.
100471 According to certain other aspects of the first embodiment, the
chemical etching
composition comprises at least 1 g/1 chromium (Cr), or at least 2 g/1, or at
least 3 g/l, or at least 4
g/1, or at least 5 g/l, or at least 6 g/1, or at least 7 g/l, or at least 8
g/l, or at least 9 g/l. According
to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition comprises up to 10
g/1 Chromium
(Cr), such as up to 9 g/l, or up to 8 g/1, or up to 7 g/1, or up to 6 g/l, or
up to 5 g/l, or up to 4 g/1,
or up to 3 g/l, or up to 2 g/1.
[0048] According to certain other aspects of the first embodiment, the
chemical etching
composition comprises at least 0.1 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), or at least 0.5 g/1,
or at least 1 g/l, or at
least 2 g/l, or at least 3 g/1, or at least 4 g/l. According to certain other
aspects, the chemical
9
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
etching composition comprises up to 5 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), such as up to 4
g/l, or up to 3 g/l,
or up to 2 g/1, or up to 1 g/1, or up to 0.5 g/1.
[0049] According to certain other aspects of the first embodiment, the
chemical etching
composition comprises no cobalt (Co), or at least 1 g/1, or at least 2 g/1, or
at least 3 g/l, or at least
4 g/l, or at least 5 g/l, or at least 6 g/1, or at least 7 g/1, or at least 8
g/l, or at least 9 g/1. According
to certain other aspects, the chemical etching composition comprises up to 10
g/1 cobalt (Co),
such as up to 9 g/1, or up to 8 g/1, or up to 7 g/1, or up to 6 g/1, or up to
5 g/l, or up to 4 g/1, or up
to 3 g/1, or up to 2 g/1.
[0050] According to a second embodiment of the presently disclosed invention,
the
chemical etching composition may comprise at least two mineral acids, and high
concentrations
of certain component metals of the alloy to be etched. For example, the
composition may
comprise any two or more of the mineral acids listed herein, and about 7 - 355
g/1 cobalt (Co),
about 3 - 170 g/1 chromium (Cr), and about 1 - 40 8/1 molybdenum (Mo) when the
alloy to be
etched is a cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy. The composition may be
substantially free of, or
totally free of, iron.
[0051] According to certain other aspects of the second embodiment, the
chemical
etching composition comprises at least 3 g/1 chromium (Cr), or at least 10
g/1, or at least 20 g/l,
or at least 30 g/l, or at least 40 g/1, or at least 50 g/l, or at least 70
g/1, or at least 90 g/l, or at least
110 g/1, or at least 130 g/1, or at least 150 g/1. According to certain other
aspects, the chemical
etching composition comprises up to 170 g/1 chromium (Cr), such as up to 160
g/1, or up to 150
g/1, or up to 140 g/1, or up to 130 g/l, or up to 120 g/1, or up to 100 g/l,
or up to 80 g/1, or up to 60
g/1, or up to 40 g/1. or up to 20 g/l, or up to 10 g/l.
100521 According to certain other aspects of the second embodiment, the
chemical
etching composition comprises at least 1 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), or at least 5
g/l, or at least 10
g/1, or at least 20 g/l, or at least 30 g/l, or at least 35 g/l. According to
certain other aspects, the
chemical etching composition comprises up to 40 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), such as
up to 35 g/l, or
up to 30 g/1, or up to 20 g/1, or up to 10 g/1, or up to 5 g/l.
[0053] According to certain other aspects of the second embodiment, the
chemical
etching composition comprises at least 7 g/1 cobalt (Co), or at least 15 g/1,
or at least 50 g/1, or at
least 100 g/1, or at least 150 g/1, or at least 200 g/1, or at least 250 g/1,
or at least 300 g/1, or at
least 325 g/1. According to certain other aspects, the chemical etching
composition comprises up
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
to 355 g/1 molybdenum (Mo), such as up to 325 g/1, or up to 300 g/1, or up to
250 g/1, or up to
200 g/l, or up to 150 g/1, or up to 100 g/l, or up to 50 g/l, or up to 25 g/1.
100541 According to certain aspects of the second embodiment, the component
metals
may be included in amounts that mimic the ratio in which they are included in
the metal alloy.
For example, when the alloy is a cobalt chromium molybdenum alloy, such as
ASTM F75, the
component metals may be provided as about 63-68 wt.% Co, 27-30 wt.% Cr, and 5-
7 wt.% Mo,
based on the total weight of the alloy; or when the alloy is a cobalt nickel
chromium
molybdenum alloy, such as ASTM F562, the component metals may be provided as
about 35
wt.% Co, about 35 wt.% Ni, about 20 wt.% Cr, and about 10 wt.% Mo, based on
the total weight
of the alloy. While certain examples of alloys and their component metal
ratios have been
provided herein as examples, other alloys of cobalt chrome are within the
scope of the presently
disclosed invention. One of ordinary skill in the art would know the ratio of
the component
metals in certain other alloys and be able to understand the rations in which
they would be
provided according to the description of the invention provided in this
disclosure.
100551 The chemical etching composition may be an aqueous composition. As
such, the
mineral acids and component metals may be dissolved into an aqueous medium,
such as water or
another aqueous buffer.
100561 According to certain aspects of the present invention, the work-piece
may be
etched on one or more surfaces by contacting the work-piece with any of the
chemical etching
compositions disclosed herein. According to certain aspects of the present
invention, the alloy
material may be etched on one or more surfaces by contacting the alloy with
any of the chemical
etching compositions disclosed herein.
100571 Surface activation
100581 Before the work-piece or alloy can be etched with the chemical etching
compositions of the presently disclosed invention, the work-piece or alloy may
require an
activation step. An exemplary activation step includes exposing the surface of
the work-piece to
be etched to a mineral acid, such as a 10% to 100% (v/v) aqueous solution of
the mineral acid.
An exemplary activation solution includes a 10% to 100% aqueous solution of
concentrated
hydrochloric acid or hydrofluoric acid (v/v; dilution with an aqueous buffer
or water). The
surface may be exposed to the mineral acid at a range of temperatures, such as
room temperature
11
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
or above, wherein higher temperatures require lower concentrations of the
mineral acid. The
work-piece may be exposed to the mineral acid by submersion or spraying.
[0059] According to certain aspects, certain alloys, e.g., wrought and/or
forged cobalt
chromium alloys, may benefit from activation with a mixture of concentrated
hydrogen peroxide
(50% H202) and concentrated hydrochloric acid (fuming hydrochloric acid; 37%).
For example,
according to certain aspects, the activation composition may comprise at least
25% (v/v)
hydrogen peroxide and at least 25% concentrated hydrochloric acid. The surface
may be exposed
to the mixture at a range of temperatures, such as room temperature or above,
wherein higher
temperatures require lower concentrations of the mineral acid. The work-piece
may be exposed
to the mixture by submersion or spraying.
[0060] As indicated hereinabove, such chemistry is generally only suitable for
superficial
removal of material. However, as used in the presently disclosed methods, the
activation step is
not employed to etch the alloy surface but rather to activate the alloy
surface for etching with the
novel compositions disclosed herein. Moreover, any intergranular attack (IGA)
of the CoCr
materials that may be incurred by this activation step would be removed by the
subsequent more
substantial etching compositions and methods that follow the activation step.
[0061] Immediately after activation, such as within 120 seconds, the work-
piece may be
exposed to the chemical etching compositions as described herein below.
According to certain
aspects, the work-piece may still be "wet" with the activation solution (i.e.,
mineral acid such as
the 10%-100% dilution of hydrochloric acid).
[0062] After the surface of the work-piece is activated, it may be etched by
contact with
the chemical etching compositions, which may include dipping or submersing the
work-piece in
the composition, or spraying, rolling, or brushing the composition onto one or
more surfaces of
the work-piece.
[0063] Etching methods
[0064] The presently disclosed invention provides methods for etching an alloy
material
of a work-piece. According to certain aspects, one method may include
preparing one of the
chemical etching compositions described above, activating the alloy material
with a mineral acid
or mixture of a mineral acid and hydrogen peroxide, and contacting the alloy
material with the
chemical etching composition. According to certain aspects, the step of
contacting with the
chemical etching composition may be carried out immediately after the
activation step, such as
12
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
before the alloy material dries, or within 120 seconds after activation (i.e.,
120 seconds from
exposure to the mineral acid), or within 90 seconds after activation, or
within 60 seconds after
activation, or within 30 seconds after activation.
[0065] Contacting the work-piece with the chemical etching compositions may
include
dipping or submersing the work-piece in the composition, or spraying, rolling,
or brushing the
composition onto one or more surfaces of the work-piece.
[0066] For example, the work-piece to be etched may be attached to a fixture
resistant to
the chemical etch composition and both the work-piece and at least a portion
of the fixture may
be submerged in the chemical etch composition for a specified time (e.g., the
part is suspended
over/in the chemical etch composition).
[0067] The present inventors have found that it may be preferred to position
the surfaces
to be etched horizontally, such as facing upward in the composition, or
vertically depending on
the targeted surface characteristics. The gaseous byproducts of the etch
reaction move directly
upwards and away from the surface when that surface is etched horizontally,
and do not
otherwise affect the process. When the surface to be etched is positioned
vertically, bubbles may
travel along the vertical surface and influence the etch rate through
localized microcirculation
and its effects on the replenishment of unreacted chemistry to the target
surface. In such ways,
surface geometry may be manipulated by adjusting the angle of the parts (with
respect to
horizontal) during processing.
[0068] Thus, according to certain aspects of the present invention, the work-
piece may be
etched on one or more surfaces by positioning the work-piece at an angle
within the chemical
etching composition. Exemplary angles include 0 with respect to the surface
of the "bath"
containing the chemical etch composition (i.e., horizontal facing upward), to
90 with respect to
the surface of the bath (i.e., vertical), to 180 with respect to the surface
of the bath (i.e.,
horizontal facing downward), or any angle therebetween
[0069] Alternatively, the work-piece may be placed into a drum filled with the
chemical
etch composition, and the drum may be rotated. Additional substrate, such as
inert plastic beads
or pieces, may be added to the drum to cushion the parts during rotation.
[0070] The chemical etching step may include agitating the work-piece in the
chemical
etching composition. The chemical etching step may include recirculating the
etching
composition, wherein the recirculating may include circulation of the original
chemical etching
13
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
composition (i.e., etching composition applied/used at start of method), or
circulation of the
original chemical etching composition with additional new, unused chemical
etching
composition. The chemical etching step may include exchange of used chemical
etching
composition after a certain amount of etch time for new, unused chemical etch
composition.
100711 The chemical etching step may further include heating the work-piece
and/or the
chemical etching composition to a temperature in a range of from about 20 C to
about 100 C,
such as from about 30 C to about 100 C, or from about 40 C to about 100 C, or
from about
50 C to about 100 C, or from about 60 C to about 100 C, or from about 65 C to
about 95 C, or
from about 80 C to about 95 C, or from about 82 C to about 88 C, or from 88 C
to about 91 C.
According to certain aspects, the alloy material may be contacted with the
chemical etching
composition at a temperature in a range of from about 20 C to about 100 C,
such as from about
30 C to about 100 C, or from about 40 C to about 100 C, or from about 50 C to
about 100 C, or
from about 60 C to about 100 C, or from about 65 C to about 95 C, or from
about 80 C to about
95 C, or from about 82 C to about 88 C, or from 88 C to about 91 C.
100721 According to certain aspects, the allo\, material may be contacted with
the
chemical etching composition for an unlimited time period based on the desired
depth of etch.
Etching starts as soon as the alloy material is exposed to the chemical
etching composition and
may proceed until the desired depth of etching is achieved. As such, the alloy
material may be
contacted with the chemical etching compositions from greater than 0 seconds
to greater than
several hours or days. According to certain aspects of the presently disclosed
invention, the alloy
material may be exposed to, such as agitated within, the chemical etching
composition for a time
of from 1 to 1000 minutes, such as from 2 to 200 minutes, or from 5 to 50
minutes.
100731 The chemical etching compositions and methods disclosed herein may be
used to
remove portions or all of a surface of a work-piece to a desired depth.
Moreover, the
compositions and methods disclosed herein provide removal of the material
without significant
intergranular attack (IGA).
[0074] The compositions and methods disclosed herein also provide means to
remove
artifacts of manufacture, such as support structures formed during 3D
manufacture of the work-
piece, or islands left behind during laser manufacture of a work-piece, or to
reduce debris from
the work-piece surfaces, such as artifacts of the additive manufacturing
process, e.g., powder,
particles, granules, etc. that were not completely melted or completely
sintered during the
14
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
additive building. Debris may also include external debris such as dirt or
other artifacts of
handling.
[0075] The present inventors have found that the removal of surface material
using the
compositions and methods disclosed herein are predictable and repeatable, but
unlike most other
alloys, once the material is removed, the etched surface of the alloy forms an
extremely stable
passive surface layer that inhibits further etching without a suitable
chemical or electrochemical
re-activation of the surface, such as the activation step disclosed above, or
disruption of the
surface layer (e.g., by a mechanical means such as grit-blasting). Because of
this, processing is
most easily and economically performed with full targeted removal taking place
all in one step.
[0076] Cobalt alloys
[0077] The compositions and methods disclosed herein are suitable for all
types of
Cobalt-Chromium-Molybdenum based alloys including cast, forged, machined, and
other
products with formulations such as, but not limited to, ASTM F75 (Standard
Specification for
Cobalt-28Chromium-6Molybdenum Alloy Casting and Casting Alloy for Surgical
Implants),
ASTM F799 (Standard Specification for Cobalt-28Chromium-6Molybdenum Alloy
Forgings for
Surgical Implants), and ASTM F1537 (Standard Specification for Cobalt-
28Chromium-
6Molybdenum Alloys for Surgical Implants)
[0078] This composition is also suitable for Cobalt-Chromium alloys containing
Nickel
such as ASTM F90 (Standard Specification for Wrought Cobalt-20Chromium-
15Tungsten-
10Nickel Alloy for Surgical Implant Applications) and ASTM F562 (Standard
Specification for
Wrought 35Cobalt-35Nickel-20Chromium-10Molybdenum Alloy for Surgical Implant
Applications).
[0079] Pattern generation
100801 According to certain aspects of the present invention, portions of the
work-piece
may be etched, such as in a pattern Those portions that are to remain un-
etched may be
protected from the chemical etching composition using a masking material
Masking materials
may include at least coatings applied to the surfaces to be protected, such as
coatings resistant to
the chemical etching composition. The exposed, non-masked surfaces may then be
chemically
etched by exposure to the chemical etching compositions of the present
invention.
[0081] Coatings resistant to the chemical etching composition, and the
activation solution
(mineral acid) may be applied by any means known in the art, such as at least
dipping, pouring,
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
spraying, brushing, or rolling. Exemplary coatings resistant to the chemical
etching compositions
of the present invention include, for example, maskants from AC Products, such
as ADCOAT
AC-818.
100821 Depending on the solids content of the selected coating, multiple
applications of
the coating may be necessary, allowing for sufficient drying time between
applications. The
coatings used are generally customized to protect the object from the selected
etchant while
avoiding any harm to the underlying material of the object.
100831 After each application, the coating may be allowed to cure in a manner
which
prevents damage to the preceding application, and/or which does not inhibit
future applications.
The term "cure", as used in connection with a cured coating, means that at
least a portion of the
components that form the coating are polymerized, cross-linked, or dried to
form a hardened
film. Curing or drying reactions to form the hardened film may be carried out
under ambient
conditions, or may be carried out at elevated temperatures, pressures, or in
the presence of
various gases. For example, the coating may comprise a solvent which may be
evaporated to dry
or cure the coating. The solvent evaporation may be accelerated by vacuum
removal coupled
with fresh air or inert gas supply. Depending upon the nature of the chosen
coating, heat sources
may be used to accelerate drying. Further, for certain coating chemistries,
additional processing
steps (imaging, hardening, fixing, etc.) may be necessary to make the coating
fully resistant to
the targeted etching composition.
100841 The coating may be applied in a pattern that exposes the regions of the
work-piece
to be etched and covers the regions to be protected. Alternatively, the
coating may be patterned
to remove those regions of the coating that are to be etched on the work-
piece. Such removal
may be via mechanical scribing and peeling, or by laser ablation, wherein a
laser is utilized to
remove or ablate the coating in specific regions or patterns. In both cases, a
thickness of the
coating may be matched to the characteristics of the scribing or laser
ablation equipment. In
general, the thinnest application that allows for full protection during the
chemical etching step is
desired, as thinner coatings require less drying time, less coating material,
lower laser intensities,
and less time stripping the coating after etching is complete. Moreover, for
laser ablation
processes, colorants or other additives may be added to the coating to improve
the ablation
process. The colorants and/or additives may be matched to the specific laser
type and
wavelength.
16
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
100851 For work-pieces which are to be patterned using a photoresist, the
photoresist may
be applied to the surface of the work-piece. Photoresist is a photosensitive
coating that changes
properties when exposed to light, either gaining or losing resistance to
attack by an etchant or
solvent in the areas exposed to electromagnetic radiation, most commonly in
the UV light
spectrum. The thickness and properties of the photoresist (e.g., positive or
negative photoresist)
may be matched to the equipment used for exposure of the pattern onto the
photoresist.
100861 While several methods for coating the surface of the work-piece have
been
described herein, other methods known in the art are within the scope of the
present invention.
Furthermore, more than one coating layer may be applied to the surface of the
work-piece,
wherein each coating layer may vary in thickness and identity of the coating
material. As
previously indicated, selection of the specific coating thickness and coating
material may depend
on at least the method of pattern generation to be used in future steps of the
process.
[0087] The terni "pattern generation" generally describes various methods and
implementations used to remove a portion of the coating from the surface of
the work-piece
according to a specific pattern or design. The pattern may be preset or
programmed into a
computer (e.g., translated from CAD drawings) which directs the movements of
the various
devices used to remove the portion of coating and movements of the work-piece,
either together
or individually.
100881 The patterned work-piece, whether produced through laser ablation,
mechanical
scribing and peeling, or by a photo resist process may be exposed to the
chemical etching
composition using any of dipping, rolling, brushing, or spraying. As indicated
hereinabove, if
the work-piece is contacted with the chemical etching composition in a bath,
the work-piece may
be agitated while in the bath, or alternatively, the chemical etching
composition may be provided
as a flow of material (e.g., the work-piece may be positioned in a stream of
the chemical etching
composition).
[0089] When an activation step is included prior to the chemical etch, the
patterned
surface may be activated, such as with any of the chemistries disclosed
hereinabove.
Alternatively, the surface may be activated prior to patterning using any of
the methods
discussed herein (patterned coating, coating having portions removed, or
photoresist).
100901 Moreover, either or both of the work-piece and the chemical etching
composition
may be heated to a temperature in a range of from about 20 C to about 100 C,
such as from
17
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
about 30 C to about 100 C, or from about 40 C to about 100 C, or from about 50
C to about
100 C, or from about 60 C to about 100 C, or from about 65 C to about 95 C, or
from about
80 C to about 95 C, or from about 82 C to about 88 C, or from 88 C to about 91
C.
[0091] Once etching is complete, the work-piece may be rinsed clean of all
residual
etchant and placed in a bath of stripping solution (a solvent matched to the
coatings) to remove
all remaining coating material. Alternatively, a wet blast process consisting
of a high-pressure
spray of a solution could be used in place of the stripping solution to
mechanically remove the
coating from the object. After the remaining coating is removed ("stripping"),
the work-piece
may be thoroughly washed and dried
[0092] Chemical etch characteristics
[0093] The amount of material removed by the chemical etching composition,
i.e., the
depth of the etch, is unlimited and may depend on the amount of exposure time
to the chemical
etching composition and changes in the chemistry of the composition, e.g.,
after long exposure
times. Such changes can include at least a reduction in the acid content, an
increase in the
component metals content, or any combination thereof.
[0094] The rate of etching, i.e., rate of material removal, may depend on a
combination
of the proportion of chemical components to one another, the temperature,
and/or amount of
agitation of the work-piece in the chemical etching composition. For example,
according to
certain aspects of the presently disclosed methods, a sample of cobalt chrome
may be etched at a
rate of 0.1 to 1 mil/minute in the presently disclosed chemical etching
compositions, such as 0.3
to 1 mil/minutes, or about 0.5 mil/minute, when exposed at room temperature.
[0095] The etched surface may display a surface roughness that is at least 25%
less than
the native, un-etched surface, such as a surface roughness that is at least
40% less, or at least
50% less, or at least 60% less, or at least 70% less, or at least 80% less, or
even at least 90% less
than the native, un-etched surface. The etched surface may have a surface
roughness (Ra) that is
less than 200 win, or less than 150 win, or even less than 100 win (less than
5 p.m, 3.8 Jim, or
2.5 p.m, respectively).
[0096] One unique and unexpected quality of the present chemical etching
compositions
and methods of use is that the final surface, after the chemical etching is
completed, does not
include any directionally oriented etch markings or "scratches". As discussed
above, prior art
methods for smoothing surfaces on alloys such as those disclosed herein
include abrasive flow
18
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
machining or smoothing. Such methods force a viscous liquid comprising
abrasive material past
the surface to be smoothed at high flow rates. The directionality of the flow
of abrasive material
leads to directionally oriented scratches or marks. Thus, while this process
may provide smooth
surfaces, albeit at increased time and cost compared to the presently
disclosed compositions and
methods, the surfaces include directionally oriented marks.
[0097] Another unique and unexpected quality of the present chemical etching
compositions and methods of use is that the final surface, after the chemical
etching is
completed, is a passivated surface. That is, it is generally not possible to
perform the etching
process a subsequent time. Alternate chemistries, such as the activation
chemistries disclosed
hereinabove, and/or mechanical polishing or abrasion may be used to expose
more of the
underlying surface (i.e., non-passivated surface) in preparation for a
subsequent round of
chemical etching using the chemical etching compositions of the present
invention.
[0098] Passivation may be useful to achieve complex patterning of a surface,
where
certain areas that are protected during a first round of etching, may be
uncoated and etched
during a second round of etching to a depth different than the depth of
etching achieved during
the first round of etching. Such a process may be used to achieve any number
of varied depths in
a substrate over any number of coating and etching processes. In addition, the
resultant surface
may be expected to exhibit an even higher degree of corrosion resistance at
elevated
temperatures that the pre etch base alloy.
[0099] Moreover, the present inventors have found that the chemical etching
compositions and methods of use thereof provide for unlimited chemical etching
or milling of
the surface (e.g., depth, total area, etc.) in a single etching process.
[00100] This stable surface layer, when present, may be beneficial for
enhanced
corrosion potential beyond that of standard cobalt-chrome-moly surfaces, and
further reduce
toxicity beyond standard alloys when implanted as in an orthopedic device.
[00101] Examples
[0102] The following examples provide formulations that may be used to etch
various
cobalt chromium alloys. Before each of the chemical etching steps listed in
these examples, the
alloy material is activated. Exemplary activation steps that form part of the
presently disclosed
methods include exposure of the alloy material to a mineral acid just prior to
exposure to the
chemical etching compositions, such as by submerging or spraying the alloy
material with the
19
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
mineral acid just prior to exposure to the chemical etching compositions
disclosed herein. For
example, the work-piece may be dipped in or sprayed with a 10% to 100% (v/v)
aqueous
solution of hydrochloric acid and within several minutes, such as less than
120 seconds, or even
30 seconds, exposed to one of them chemical etching solutions as detailed
below in Examples I-
III. While the activation solution is specifically indicated herein to
comprise hydrochloric acid,
other mineral acids or mixtures thereof would provide substantially the same
results.
Additionally, certain alloys, such as forged cobalt chromium alloys, may
benefit from different
activation solutions, such as mixtures of concentrated hydrochloric acid and
hydrogen peroxide.
[0103] Because it is preferred to expose the work-piece to the chemical etch
composition
within a short time after exposure to the activation solution, such as when
the work-piece is still
wet with the activation solution, it may be beneficial to apply any coatings
or patterning before
the activation step. As such, if the work-piece is to be patterned, such as by
including of a
coating to protect certain portions or surfaces of the work-piece, that
coating may be applied
before the surface is activated and/or etched.
101041 Example I: An exemplary chemical etching composition for the chemical
dissolution of CoCr alloys according to certain aspects of the presently
disclosed invention
include constituents and amounts as shown in Table I.
[0105] The etching temperature ranges useful for the above compositions
include about
20 C to about 100 C, such as from about 82 C to about 88 C.
[0106] While CoCr can be etched at many (or all) combinations of chemistry
within the
ranges above, at the preferred set-point conditions, uniform removal of
material at up to 0.015
inches and beyond was achieved with no measurable IGA, making it a suitable
composition for
flight-critical aerospace components.
Table I
Component Range Set-Point
Iron (Fe) 50 ¨ 225 g/1 115 g/1
Cobalt (Co) 0 ¨ 10 g/1 0.2 g/1
Chromium (Cr) 1 ¨ 10 g/1 3.3 g/1
Molybdenum (Mo) 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1 1.2 g/1
Hydrochloric Acid (HCl) 2 ¨ 5 N 4.0 N
Nitric Acid (HNO3) 0.05 - 0.8 N 0.5 N
Hydrofluoric Acid (HT) 0.6- 1.3N 1 0 N
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
[0107] Example II. An exemplary inventive high-iron composition for etching
CoCr
alloys is shown in Table II. This composition was found to provide surface
roughness (Ra)
improvements from a starting condition of approximately 400 .t-in (about 10
micrometer, m) to
a finished condition of approximately 125 .t-in (about 3 m), with a surface
material removal of
0.005 inches.
Table II
Component Range Set-Point
Iron (Fe) 50 ¨ 225 g/1 175 g/1
Cobalt (Co) 0 ¨ 10 g/1 5 g/1
Chromium (Cr) 1 ¨ 10 g/1 3 g/1
Molybdenum (Mo) 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1 0.5 g/1
Hydrochloric Acid (HCl) 2 ¨ 5 N 4.5 N
Nitric Acid (HNO3) 0.05 -0.8 N 0.11 N
Hydrofluoric Acid (HF) 0.6- 1.3N 0.9N
[0108] Example III: An exemplary inventive iron-free, high-metals composition
for
etching CoCr alloys is shown in Table III. The composition was found to
provide surface
roughness (Ra) improvements from a starting condition of approximately 250 -
in (about 6.4
m) to a finished condition of approximately 70 -in (less than 2 m), with a
surface material
removal of 0.005 inches.
Table III
Component Range Set-Point
Iron (Fe) 0 g/1 0 g/1
Cobalt (Co) 7 ¨355 g/1 81.7 g/1
Chromium (Cr) 3 ¨ 170 g/1 35.8 g/1
Molybdenum (Mo) 1 ¨ 40 g/1 7.5 g/1
Hydrochloric Acid (HC1) 2 ¨ 5 N 4 5 N
Nitric Acid (HNO3) 0.05 - 0.8 N 0.11 N
Hydrofluoric Acid (HF) 0.6- 1.3N 0.9N
[0109] The high metals chemical etch composition shown in Table III provides a
ratio of
metals in solution that is at or near the ratio of the elemental components in
the starting alloy,
cobalt chromium molybdenum ASTM F75, and resulted in dramatic improvement in
surface
condition. Thus, the present inventors have found that increased metal
concentrations improve
the surface roughness, i.e., provides a smoother surface, exponentially up to
the point of
saturation. Higher concentrations were found to decrease the rate of etch
(i.e., as the metals
21
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
concentrations rise, the rate of etching will begin to decrease, potentially
making the processing
of parts at or near full saturation impractical from a processing time
standpoint).
101101 Superior surface results with increasing metals at the ratios native to
the original
alloy is an important finding as it provides a processing composition that
does not require the
addition of non-native metals or metal salts. That is, the composition can be
concentrated in
metals for improved surface finish simply by etching more material while
maintaining the
appropriate acid concentrations. This greatly aids process control (i.e., the
metals will always
drift towards the alloy concentrations with increased usage) and eliminates
the need for non-
native metals addition, namely iron salts, which represents substantial
processing costs in a
production setting (e.g., iron solutions need to be made in an inert
environment to prevent
oxidization of the iron; iron solutions are generally expensive).
[0111] Thus, a preferred chemical etching composition for aerospace
applications, or any
application trying to achieve uniform removals with improved surface finish,
includes high
concentrations of native metals, up to saturation, at the elemental ratios
(i.e., native ratios)
present in the material of the parts being etched.
[0112] It should be noted that nitric acid concentrations are relatively low
for these
compositions as high metals may lead to rapid breakdown of the nitric acid
when that acid is
present in higher concentrations.
[0113] As indicated, the chemical etch compositions of the presently disclosed
invention
provide uniform material removal of up to 0.015" and beyond with no measurable
IGA, making
them suitable compositions for etching flight critical aerospace components.
[0114] Exemplary aerospace or aircraft components that may benefit from the
compositions and methods of the presently disclosed invention include at least
aircraft skin and
fuselage skin and architectural trims. For example, according to certain
aspects, the alloys etched
by the compositions and methods presently disclosed may for a component, in
part or wholly, of
an aerospace vehicle. As such, the component may be an aerospace component
attachable or
forming part of an aerospace vehicle or device.
[0115] Shown in FIGS. 1A-1F are micrographs of an unetched native cobalt
chromium
alloy at 150x and 1000x magnification (FIGS. 1A and 1B, respectively) compared
with a cobalt
chromium alloy surface that has been etched with a composition according to
the present
disclosure, with 2 mil surface removed (50 microns removed shown at 150x and
1000x
22
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
magnification in FIGS. 1C and 1D, respectively) and with 12 mil surface
removed (300 microns
removed shown at 150x and 1000x magnification in FIGS. 1E and 1F,
respectively). Note that
the native surface includes deep crevices into which the dye may fill or
adhere in a dye penetrant
test, and how the etched surfaces according to the present invention lack
these crevices.
[0116] Micrographs of surfaces etched using the compositions and methods of
the
presently disclosed invention are shown in FIGS. 2A-2C, wherein the smoother
surface of FIG.
2A was obtained with an etching composition comprising higher concentrations
of the metals
(i.e., as disclosed in the second embodiment of the etching composition). Note
that none of the
exemplary surfaces show directional surface scratches or markings (i.e., no
extended grooves).
[0117] Aspects of the invention
[0118] The presently disclosed invention provides the following aspects:
[0119] Aspect 1: A composition for etching a cobalt chromium alloy, the
composition
comprising. at least two mineral acids; certain or all of the main component
metals of the cobalt
chromium alloy; and optionally iron (Fe).
101201 Aspect 2: The comparison according to aspect 1, wherein the composition
comprises: at least two mineral acids; chromium (Cr); molybdenum (Mo);
optionally iron (Fe);
and optionally, cobalt (Co).
[0121] Aspect 3: The composition according to aspects 1 or 2, wherein the at
least two
mineral acids are selected from hydrochloric acid (HC1), nitric acid (HNO3),
sulfuric acid
(H2SO4), and hydrofluoric acid (HF).
[0122] Aspect 4: The composition according to any one of aspects 1 to 3,
wherein the at
least two mineral acids comprise hydrochloric acid (HCl), nitric acid (HNO3),
and hydrofluoric
acid (HF).
[0123] Aspect 5: The composition according to any one of aspects Ito 4,
comprising: 2N
¨ 5N hydrochloric acid (HCl); 0.05N ¨ 0.8N nitric acid (HNO3); and 0.6N ¨ 13N
hydrofluoric
acid (HF).
[0124] Aspect 6: The composition according to any one of aspects 1 to 5,
comprising: 1 ¨
g/1 Chromium (Cr); 0.1 ¨ 5 8/1 molybdenum (Mo); 0¨ 225 g/1 Iron (Fe); and 0¨
10 g/1 cobalt
(Co).
23
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
[0125] Aspect 7: The composition according to any one of aspects 1 to 6,
comprising: 50
¨ 225 g/1 Iron (Fe); 1 ¨ 10 g/1 chromium (Cr); 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1 molybdenum (Mo);
and 0 ¨ 10 g/1
cobalt (Co).
[0126] Aspect 8: The composition according to any one of aspects 1 to 7,
comprising: 2N
¨ 5N hydrochloric acid (HC1); 0.05N ¨ 0.8N nitric acid (HNO3); 0.6N ¨ 1.3N
hydrofluoric acid
(HF); 0 ¨ 225 g/1 Iron (Fe); 1 ¨ 10 g/1 chromium (Cr); 0.1 ¨ 5 g/1 molybdenum
(Mo); and 0 ¨ 10
g/1 cobalt (Co).
[0127] Aspect 9: The composition according to aspect 8, comprising: 50 ¨ 225
g/1 Iron
(Fe).
[0128] Aspect 10: The composition according to any one of aspects 1 to 9,
wherein the
composition etches cobalt chromium alloys at a rate of 0.1 to 1.0 mil/minute.
[0129] Aspect 10: The composition according to any one of aspects 2 to 5,
comprising: 7
¨ 355 g/1 cobalt (Co); 3 ¨ 170 g/1 chromium (Cr); and 1 ¨40 g/1 molybdenum
(Mo).
[0130] Aspect 11: The composition according to any one of aspects 2 to 5,
wherein the
Co, Cr, and Mo are provided in a ratio that is the same as a native ratio of
each metal in the
cobalt chromium alloy.
[0131] Aspect 12: A composition for etching cobalt chromium alloys, the
composition
comprising: 2N ¨ 5N hydrochloric acid (HC1); 0.05N ¨ 0.8N nitric acid (HNO3);
0.6N ¨ 1.3N
hydrofluoric acid (HF); 7 ¨ 355 g/1 cobalt (Co); 3 ¨ 170 g/1 chromium (Cr);
and 1 ¨ 40 g/1
molybdenum (Mo).
[0132] Aspect 13: A method for etching an alloy material, the method
comprising:
preparing an aqueous chemical etching composition comprising: at least two
mineral acids,
chromium (Cr), molybdenum (Mo), optionally, iron (Fe), and optionally, cobalt
(Co); and
contacting the alloy material with the aqueous chemical etching composition.
[0133] Aspect 14: The method according to aspect 13, wherein the aqueous
chemical
etching composition comprises: 2N ¨ 5N hydrochloric acid (HC1); 0.05N ¨ 0.8N
nitric acid
(HNO3); 0.6N ¨ 1.3N hydrofluoric acid (HF); 50 ¨ 225 g/1 Iron (Fe); 1 ¨ 10 g/1
chromium (Cr);
0.1-5 g/1 molybdenum (Mo); and 0¨ 10 g/1 cobalt (Co).
[0134] Aspect 15: The method according to aspect 13, wherein the aqueous
chemical
etching composition comprises: 2N ¨ 5N hydrochloric acid (HC1); 0.05N ¨ 0.8N
nitric acid
24
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
(HNO3); 0.6N ¨ 1.3N hydrofluoric acid (HF); 7 ¨ 355 g/1 cobalt (Co); 3 ¨ 170
g/1 chromium (Cr);
and 1 ¨ 40 g/1 molybdenum (Mo).
101351 Aspect 16: The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 15, wherein
the
alloy material is a cobalt chromium alloy.
101361 Aspect 16: The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 15, further
comprising, before the step of contacting the alloy material with the aqueous
chemical etching
composition, activating the alloy material to be etched with an activation
solution.
101371 Aspect 17: The method according to aspect 16, wherein the activating
step is
carried out immediately before the contacting step, such as within 120
seconds.
[0138] Aspect 18: The method according to aspects 16 or 17, wherein the
activation
solution comprises a concentrated mineral acid, such as a 10% to 100% aqueous
solution of
hydrochloric acid or hydrofluoric acid (v/v), or a mixture of concentrated
mineral acid and
hydrogen peroxide, such as concentrated hydrochloric acid and hydrogen
peroxide.
[0139] Aspect 19: A method for etching a cobalt chromium alloy work-piece, the
method
comprising: contacting the work-piece with a chemical etching composition
according to any one
of aspects 1 to 12 at a temperature of from about 20 C to about 100 C, wherein
the work-piece is
agitated in the chemical etching composition for a time period of 1 minute to
200 minutes.
[0140] Aspect 20: The method according to aspect 19, wherein, before the
contacting
step, the method comprises: applying a coating which resists chemical etchants
to the work-
piece; and removing a portion of the coating to form a patterned design in the
coating on the
work-piece.
[0141] Aspect 21: The method according to aspect 19 or 20 wherein, before the
contacting step, the method comprises: applying an activation solution.
[0142] Aspect 22: The method according to aspect 20 wherein the step of
applying the
activation solution is carried out immediately before the contacting step,
such as within 120
seconds.
[0143] Aspect 23: The method according to aspect 21 or 22, wherein the
activation
solution comprises a 10% to 100% aqueous solution of a mineral acid, such as
hydrochloric acid
(v/v), or a mixture of concentrated hydrogen peroxide and concentrated
hydrochloric acid, such
as at least 25% (v/v) 50% hydrogen peroxide and at least 25% (v/v) fuming
hydrochloric acid.
CA 03123405 2021-06-14
WO 2020/124079 PCT/US2019/066538
[0144] Aspect 24: The method according to any one of aspects 20 to 23,
wherein, after
the contacting step, the method comprises: stripping the coating from the work-
piece.
[0145] Aspect 25: A work-piece produced by the method according to any one of
aspects
13 to 24, having a surface roughness (Ra) of less than 200 win, such as less
than 150 win, or less
than 100 win.
[0146] Aspect 26: The work-piece according to aspect 25, wherein the work-
piece forms
a component, in part or wholly, of an aerospace vehicle.
101471 Aspect 27: A work-piece formed of a cobalt chromium alloy having a
surface
roughness (ita) of less than 200 win and no directional surface scratches.
[0148] Aspect 28: The work-piece of aspect 27, wherein the surface roughness
(Ra) is
less than 100 win, and wherein the work-piece forms at least a portion of a
component part of an
aerospace vehicle.
[0149] While specific embodiments of the invention have been described in
detail, it
should be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various modifications
and alternations and
applications could be developed in light of the overall teachings of the
disclosure. Accordingly,
the particular arrangements, systems, apparatuses, and methods disclosed are
meant to be
illustrative only and not limiting as to the scope of the invention.
26
