Note : Les descriptions sont présentées dans la langue officielle dans laquelle elles ont été soumises.
1059149
The present invention relates to reactions of
phenolic compounds and sulfur halides, in general, to form
a broad spectrum of the reaction products too numerous to
mention which are well-known in the prior art. Many of these
prior art reactions provide for the formation of a mixture of
reaction products. However, others require the reaction of
specific phenols and sulfur halides while maintaining a myriad
of reaction conditions, to form specific thiophenolic materials.
More specifically, the product recovered on contacting a
phenol and sulfur dichloride generally contains a combination
of mono- and poly- sulfides, chlorinated phenols, sulfonium
compounds, polymeric materials, and the like. However, if a
specific 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic compound, such as 4,4'-thio-
diphenol, were the desired product, any other materials present
would be considered by-products and would require separation
from the total material produced and recovered. Recovery is
a particularly acute problem in the case of the polysulfide
by-products since they are formed as part of the solid, crys-
talline product phase along with the desired 4,4'-monothiodi-
phenolic product. Thus, when polysulfides are present, further `-
recovery steps are necessary to separate the respective solid -
phases. Unlike their monothiophenolic counterparts, polysul-
fides contain relatively weak sulfur-to-sulfur bonds. There-
fore, on polymerization of these polysulfides, the resultant
polymeric product will be relatively weak because of this
defective bonding characteristic.
The yield of specific monothiodiphenols formed by
the direct contact of a phenolic compound and a sulfur halide,
- according to the prior art processes, in cases where the forma-
tion of specific materials is desired, is relatively poor.
And, in addition to the aforementioned drawbacks, known pro-
ce~es teach that relatively long contact time~ are generally
-1- ~
1059149
required for specific product formation, in relatively poor
yields. Furthermore, due to the relatively long contact
times exhibited by the prior art processes, difficulties
will result in conducting a continuous reaction, in an
efficient manner, to selectively form high yields of specific
` 4,4'-monothiodiphenols. Moreover, the economic feasibility
of such a process is highly questionable.
Many of the aforementioned phenolic reactions
have been employed in preparing either stabilizers or anti-
10 oxidants. For example, U. S. Patent 1,84~,489 to Howland
describes the formation of a class of chemical compounds
"adapted to retard deterioration of rubber." These compounds
include sulfides of phenol. An example of this reaction is
shown on page 2, beginning on line 55, wherein a relatively
high concentration of phenols is reacted with a sulfur chlor-
ide compound in a chloroform solvent. A low yield of phenol
sulfides was seemingly formed after a 2-hour reaction period. -~
Furthermore, any combination of sulfides, polysulfides or
isomers thereof provides an acceptable reaction product for
use therein. A high specific product yield is not required
in the above formation process.
Another process which d~scribes the production of
sulfur-containing phenols useful as antioxidants is found in
U. S. Patent 3,678,115 to Fujisawa et al. In this case, the
production of a sulfur-containing sterically-hindered phenol,
i.e., 4,4'-thiobis(2,6-di-t-butyl phenol) is disclosed. The
formation of the above sterically-hindered phenolic product
is conducted according to an entirely different reaction
system than is provided for its nonhindered counterpart. The
Fujisawa process, for instance, includes reacting a high
concentration (greater than 25% by weight) of 2,6-di-t-butyl
phenol (a hindered phenolic reactant~ employing either sulfur
-- 2 --
-
lOS9149
chloride or sulfur dichloride, and requiring, in the sulfur
dichloride reaction, a reaction period of greater than about
24 hours. The use of relatively high concentrations of
phenol causes additional problems in mass transport of the
product mixture formed, thereby further increasing the total
reaction time and, in case of reaction of a phenol and sulfur
dichloride, promotes the formation of a noncrystalline phase
in the reaction system which is detrimental to the facilita-
tion of high yields of the desired product. Example 1 of "
Fujisawa indicates that the 4,4'-thiobis-(2,6-di-t-butyl
phenol) was present in only a 23% yield after an initial
18-hour reaction period, 53% of the total product formed
being polysulfides. Thereafte~ in order to provide a higher
yield of the monothiophenolic product, the polythiobisphenols
present in the mixture were further reacted for about 14 --
hours with a strong base in order to cleave the sulfur bridges
to form a mercapto compound which, in turn, recombines with
the unreacted phenolic reactant to form additional amounts
of the desired 4,4'-thiobis product.
U. S. Patent 2,139,766 to Mikeska et al. provides
for the formation of a dialkyl diphenol thio ether compound
by the relatively limited reaction of a high concentration
of phenol with sulfur dichloride in a carbon disulfide sol-
vent. The product, which is then added to a mineral lubri-
cating oil, acts as an antioxidant. As previously discussed
with respect to the above cited patents, when the end use of
a thiodiphenolic product is as an antioxidant, selectivity
in forming a high yield monothiodiphenolic product, having a
minimum amount of by-products, is not required.
In another prior art method (see U. S. Patent
3,296,310 to Gilbert)~ the process for producing thiobis
phenols is conducted by reacting elemental sulfur with the
lOS~l~9
phenol in the presence of a halogen. The process is claimed
by the inventor as an improvement over methods which employ
the reaction of phenol with sulfur halide, such as sulfur
chloride or sulfur dichloride. In this latter case, the
halide employed as a catalyst is either iodine or bromine,
not chlorine. Selectivity, yield and reaction time problems
previously expressed are again present in the Gilbert pro-
cess. In fact, many of the aforementioned problems are
further magnified since a mixture of thiobis phenols are
formed in which the sulfur atoms are attached to the phenol
in either the ortho- or para- positions, as opposed to
selectively providing a predominant attachment in only the
para- position.
U. S. Patent 2,425,824 to Peters et al. provides
a process in which sulfur halides are reacted with a high
concentration of a phenolic compound, in a mole ratio of
from about 1.25 to 1.75:2.0, and preferably 1.5:2Ø Poor
selectivity and yield are evident on examining the product
material. The products formed are continuously discharged
from the reactor. The use of sulfur monochloride, sulfur
dichloride, or mixtures thereof, respectively, as the
reactant herein, is shown to be equivalent. As described
in column 3, beginning at line 2, "the important point of
the process is to at all points maintain the desired narrow
limits of ratios of the reactants . . ." Therefore, one
would conclude that only by employing the above specified
reactant ratio could a continuous phenolic-sulfur chloride
reaction process be maintained.
U. S. Patent 3,057,926 to Coffield relates to the
production of an antioxidant wherein a substituted phenol
i8 reacted with either sulfur monochloride or sulfur di-
chloride to produce a substituted thio bis phenol compound
1059149
having one or more sulfur atoms attached to the respective
rings. Stoichiometric amounts, 2:1 mole ratios of phenol
per mole of sulfur halide, and high concentrations of phenol
are employed in the Coffield process. The previously
enumerated problems associated with selectivity, yield,
reaction time, and high concentration are once more present
herein. In addition, the patent does not distinguish between
the use of the respective sulfur halides as reactants.
Finally, complicated and arduous addition techniques are
provided in the examples of Coffield in order to produce, as
in Example 2, a thio bis phenolic product.
Finally, U. S. Patent 3,390,190 to Curtis et al.
provides a process for purifying a conventionally produced
thiophenolic product prepared by the reaction of phenol and
sulfur dichloride in toluene. The final product is obtained
by refluxing the initial crude reaction mixture, separating
a tar phase, and purifying the crude product so obtained by
dissolving it in an alkaline solution of a weak, inorganic
base, such as sodium carbonate. Curtis provides a 4,4'-
dihydroxy diphenyl sulfide material produced, as illustrated
in Example 1, in a 55.2% yield based on theory. Furthermore,
after purification thereof, the actual yield based on start-
ing materials of the final purified product is about 47%,
due to losses in product incurred during the above purifica-
tion. And, even after performing these elaborate purifica-
tion steps, which require a substantial period of time to
complete, the amount of polysulfides present in the final
4,4'-isomeric product recovered (see Tables III-IV) is still
2.40/~3.5% by weight.
In contradistinction to prior art processes, the
subject process, which includes the reaction of a phenolic
compound and sulfur dichloride, provides for the selective
10~9149
formation of high yields of the 4,4'-monoisomer of various
thiodiphenolic compounds, while producing only a minimum
amount of undesirable by-products, i.e., polysulfides, non-
para- sulfur-substituted thiodiphenols, chlorinated phenols,
sulfonium compounds, and polymeric materials. Since the
removal of polysulfides from the recovered product is parti-
cularly troublesome, the formation of a minimum amount
thereof is desirable. Preferably, the amount of polysulfides
present in the product recovered is less than 1%, and more
preferably less than 0.5% by weight, based on the total
weight of product material recovered. The selectively-
produced 4,4'-monothiodiphenol is recovered, on substantial
completion of the phenolic compound-sulfur dichloride reaction
step, without requiring any additional reaction steps, in
hereinafter defined yields of at least about 70% by weight,
and preferably at least about 80% by weight. In determining
the product conversion, the amount of phenolic compound actu-
ally consumed or used is derived by subtracting the amount of
recovered, unreacted phenolic compound (since an excess of
phenol is employed) from the total amount of phenol charged
to the system. The selectivity, i.e., the weight percentage
of 4,4'-mono-isomer present in the reaction product, is at
least about 80% by weight, based on the total weight of
recovered material, and preferably at least about 90% by
weight.
The process of the present invention is character-
ized by a novel crystalline reaction system. The presence
of this crystalline reaction system at the outset of the
reaction i8 necessary for selective formation of high yields
of the above described 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic product. More
specifically, this novel reaction system is comprised of a
reactant portion including the hereafter described phenolic
` ` 1059149
..:
compound and ~ulfur dichloride, an initiation promoter portion
including crystals of the desired 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic pro-
duct and a catalytic amount of anhydrous hydrogen chloride and,
finally, a solvent portion, as later defined,
Thus according to the invention thexe is provided a
process for selectively producing 4,4'-monothiodiphenol compounds
; in high yields, which comprises: a. forming a reaction system
having a reactant portion including either one of an unsub-
stituted and sterically nonhindered ortho-substituted phenolic
compound and sulfur dichloride, an initiation promoter portion
including a cry~talline additive of said 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic
product compound and a catalytic amount of anhydrous hydrogen
chloride, and a solvent portion including a substantially
saturated compound having a solubility parameter of at least
about 7.0 (Cal/cc)% up to 9.0 (Cal/cc)~ and a low degree of
hydrogen bonding, b. reacting said phenolic compound and ~ulfur '
dichloride, in the presence of ~aid initiation promoter and
qolvent portions, re3pectively, at a temperature greater than the
freezing point of the phenolic compound and solvent portion,
and less than the temperature at which a substantial amount of
undesirable, noncrystalline by-product will be produced, to
produce said 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic, selective, high yield
product, and c. recovering said 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic product
from ~aid reaction system. '
According to another aYpect of the invention there is pro-
vided a reaction composition for selectively producing 4,4'-mono-
thiodiphenol compounds in high yield which comprisas a reaction
portion including either one of an unsubstituted and sterically
nonhindered, ortho-substituted phenolic compound and sulfur di-
chloride: an initiation promoter portion including a crystallineadditive of ~aid 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic compound and a catalytic
amount of hydrogen chloride and a solvent portion including a
-- 7 --
` ~ 1059149
substantially saturated compound having a ~olubility parameter
of at least about 7.0 (Cal/cc)~ up to about 9.0 (Cal/cc)~ and a
low degree of hydrogen bonding, said reaction system being sub-
stantially free of undesirable noncrystalline by-products,
including polysulfides, non-para- sulfur-substituted thiodi-
phenols, chlorinated phenols, sulfonium compounds and polymeric
materials.
The subject selective reaction process provides for the
reaction of a sterically nonhindered phenolic compound and sulfur
dichloride in the presence of the above initiation promoter and
solvent portion~, respectively. In addition, by preferably pro-
viding a relatively low concentration of the subject phenolic
compound, it has been discovered that the yield and selectivity
of the reaction are unexpectedly increased while the amount of
polysulfides in the recovered product is decreased. Under pre-
ferred conditions, such as when the product formed by the re-
action ~ystem of the present invention is continuously produced
and recovered, a substantial reduction in contact time, i e., the
time required to produce the thiodiphenolic material after the
crystalline reaction system is formed, is provided. More speci-
fically, contact times of not more than about 0.5 hour, and pre-
ferably not more than about 0.25 hour, are provided for formation
of the requisite 4,4'-isomer. -
The phenolic compounds, as defined for purposes of this
invention, which are included in the reactant portion of the
crystalline reaction system, may comprise any compound having a
hydroxyl group substituted on a benzene ring, which will effect-
ively direct the para-substitution, with respect to the pendant
hydroxy group, of a single sulfur atom, to the selective form~
ation of a 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic compound. For example, if
phenol, the most ~referred compound herein, were employed as the
phenolic compound in the reaction system of the present invention,
the predominant reaction would provide for a single sulfur atom
to be selectively substituted
- 7a -
.
1059149
on a phenol ring in the 4-position, a second phenol group
then being attached at its 4-position to the pendant sulfur
of the above formed phenol monosulfide intermediate, the
resulting product being 4,4'-thiodiphenol (hereinafter TDP).
Various unsubstituted and mono- or di-substituted ~ -
phenolic compounds can be employed in the reactant portion
of this invention provided that the latter compounds are
mono- or di-substituted in only the ortho- (2- or 2,6-)
position, and, additionally, are not sterically hindered.
Preferably, the mono~ or di-ortho-substituted phenolic com-
pounds employed in the present invention are characterized
by the fact that the pendant groups substituted on the
; phenol ring include lower alkyl groups having from 1 to 3
carbon atoms, the total number of carbon atoms present in
the ortho-di-substituted phenolic compound being from 1 to
5. More preferably, examples of the nonsterically hindered
ortho-, mono-, and di-substituted phenolic compounds contem-
plated herein include phenol, o-cresol, 2,6-xylenol, and
the like. --
The second component of the subject reactant
portion is sulfur dichloride. The dichloride, and not the
monochloride, is specifically required for purposes of form-
ing the subject compounds. It is preferred that the sulfur
dichloride employed have a purity greater than about 98% by
weight.
It is required in the high yield, selective process
for preparing 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic compounds that the re-
action of the above defined phenolic compounds and sulfur
dichloride be conducted in the presence of an initiation
promoter. The initiation promoter is comprised of two com-
ponents. The first of the~e components is a crystalline
additive of the particular 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic product
-- 8 --
A ~059149
to be formed. The second component is a catalytic amount
of anhydrous hydrogen chloride. Both of these components
must be present in the crystalline reaction system in order
for the selective process of this invention to proceed.
For example, in the case of the formation of the previously
identified TDP compound, TDP crystals are provided in the
crystalline reaction system in an amount sufficient to main-
tain the system in a crystalline state. ~he actual amount
of monothiodiphenol crystals present is dependent on the
solvent, the reaction temperature, and the concentration
and nature of phenol compound employed. Preferably, the
product crystals are present in an amount sufficient for
saturation of the crystalline reaction system, and more pre-
ferably, an amount in excess of that required for saturation.
It is also necessary that a catalytic amount of
anhydrous hydrogen chloride be present in the initiation
portion to provide efficient promotion of the selective
reaction process. Preferably, the crystalline reaction
system is saturated with the anhydrous hydrogen chloride in
j 20 order to promote maximum selectivity and yield. The actual
amount of hydrogen chloride needed for saturation is depend-
ent on the solvent employed, the reaction temperature, the
concentration of phenol, and the reaction pressure.
The subject reaction is conducted in the presence
of a solvent portion which is substantially nonreactive with
respect to the reactant, initiation promoter, and product
phases, respectively, but is capable of at least partially
dissolving the initiation and product portions, while sub-
stantially dissolving the reactant portion. A more accurate
characterization of the suitability of a given reaction
medium is the "solubility parameter" (~s) of the solvent.
1059149
A detailed description of solubility parameters can be
found in an article entitled "Solubility Parameters for
Film Formers", by H. Burrell, which appeared in the Official
Digest, October 1955, on pages 726-758. Another article
entitled "New values of the Solubility Parameters from
Vapor Pressure Data", by H. L. Hoy, in the Journal of
Paint Technology, Volume 42, No. 541, February 1970, pages
76-118, updates the Burrell work. In general, a solvent
is employed which is a saturated compound having a solubi-
lity parameter as shown in Table 7, page 742, of the Bu~rellarticle, and pages 91-102 of the Hoy article, of at least
7.0 (Cal/cc)~ and up to about 9.0 (Cal/cc)~, and preferably
at least about 7.5 (Cal/cc)~ and up to about 8.5 ~Cal/cc)~.
In addition, the above preferred solvents exhibit, as `
explained in the above Burrell article, a low degree of
hydrogen bonding. More preferably, compounds such as cyclo-
aliphatics, aliphatics, halogenated aliphatics, substituted
or unsubstituted, and mixtures thereof, are employed as
solvents herein. More specifically, compounds such as
cyclohexane, methylcyclopentane, methylcyclohexane, hexane,
and heptane, are the solvents most preferred for use in the
process of the invention herein.
The crystalline reaction system of the present
invention can be formed by various techniques which provide
for high dispersion, good dilution, and intimate mixing of
the respective components. However, the preferred method
of preparïng the subject 4,4'-thiodiphenolic compound of
this invention includes directly admixing the respective
reactants, initiation promoter, and solvent portions to-
gether, one with the other, to produce the crystallinereaction system of this invention. Thereafter, the phen-
olic compound and sulfur dichloride can be reacted,
-- 10 --
1059149
continuously or batch-wise, in the presence of the above
initiation promoter and solvent portions, to selectively
produce high yields of thiodiphenolic compounds having a
relatively small amount of by-products, especially polysul-
fides. In any case, once the crystalline reaction system is
established, high yields of the 4,4'-isomer can be select-
ively and expeditiously produced.
~ lthough the novel process of this invention may
be conducted quite readily in a batch or semi-batch system,
it is a preferred embodiment of this novel process that the
reaction herein be selectively conducted by continuously
adding the reactant portion to the crystalline reaction
system while, at the same time, continuously drawing off
the subject product formed. Thus, as previously indicated,
the contact time of the subject reaction can be substantially
reduced.
In order to specifically effectuate a preferred
reaction environment, certain select conditions are estab-
lished. For instance, it has been discovered that if a low
concentration of phenol is provided in the crystalline
reaction system, the reaction selectivity will favor crystal-
line formation, and not, as in the prior art processes, the
formation of undesirable, noncrystalline by-products. There-
fore, it is preferred that the concentration of phenolic com~
pound in the crystalline reaction system be maintained at
least at about 0.5 weight percent, based on the total weight
of the reaction system, and up to about an amount of phenolic
material which would result in the formation of a substantial
amount of noncrystalline by-products, the actual concentra-
tion of phenolic reaction product being dependent on thesolvent employed and the reaction temperature. More prefer-
ably, a concentration of at least about 1% by weight and up
~059149
to about 20% by weight of the subject phenolic compound is
employed herein.
It is a further preferable embodiment of thls
invention that the amount of phenol with respect to sulfur
dichloride be maintained at a sufficiently high level. For
example, the stoichiometric mole ratio of phenol to sulfur
dichloride is 2:1. Unfortunately, when the above mole ratio
of reactants is employed in the present system, the reaction
selectivity will result in higher by-product formation. Pre-
ferably, therefore, the mole ratio of phenolic compounds tosulfur dichloride in the reactant portion of the crystalline
reaction system is maintained in at least a minimum ratio of
3:1, and more advantageously, a mole ratio of at least 4:1, -
up to a ratio of about 10:1, can be employed herein.
The pressure in the reactor during the selective
reaction of the present invention, based on economic consi-
derations, is generally maintained at an atmospheric level.
However, superatmospheric pressure may be employed up to
about 500 psig. In this latter case, a faster reaction rate
is generally provided.
The reaction temperature employed depends on the
concentration and the nature of the phenolic compound as well
as the reaction solvent employed. For optimum results, the
reaction temperature is greater than the freezing point of
the respective phenolic compound reaction solvent, and less
than the temperature at which a substantial amount of unde-
sirable, noncrystalline by-product will be produced. For -
example, if cyclohexane were the solvent in a phenol-sulfur
dichloride reaction system, the preferred temperature range
would be from about 20 C. to 30 C.
- 12 -
10591~9
A sufficient degree of agitation should be provided
so that the reactant and initiation promoter portions are
thoroughly dispersed in the solvent portion. More specifically,
mixing intensity must be maintained to insure that sufficient
interfacial contact between the respective portions is main-
tained.
The following are illustrative examples showing
the typical results obtained by the process of the present
invention:
ExamPle 1
This example illustrates the continuous process of
the subject invention.
A reaction vessel for continuously producing 4,4'-
thiodiphenolic compounds was constructed from a 12-inch long
section of 6-inch (i.d.) glass pipe mounted vertically and
closed at its respective ends by a pair of flat plates. The
vessel was equipped with baffles, a thermocouple, cooling
coils, and a stirrer with a 3-inch pitched blade stirrer.
The upper plate was fitted with two inlet tubes for introduc-
ing the respective reactant solutions, and an outlet tube forremoving excess gaseous hydrogen chloride. The bottom plate
was fitted with an overflow tube for removal of the reaction
product formed. The overflow tube was designed to permit - ~-
variation in the depth of the crystalline reaction system.
Solutions of the phenolic compound and sulfur dichloride
reactants were individually prepared before use and stored
separately. The solutions were then delivered to the reaction
vessel at auitable rates employing adjustable metering pumps.
The combination of concentration of reagents and individual
pumping rates permitted various ratios of reactants to be
aelected, and the pumping rates in conjunction with the height
of the overflow outlet tube in the reactor permitted variation
- 13 -
. . . . . .
.
1059149
.
of the contact times of the respective reactants. A continu-
ous run was made in which a solution of phenol in cyclohexane
was prepared by dissolving 454 g of phenol (4.83 moles) in
sufficient cyclohexane to form a total of one gallon of the
above solution by volume. The phenol solution was then satur-
ated with anhydrous hydrogen chloride gas. The reactant solu-
tion contained 14.7% by weight phenol and 0.22% by weight
hydrogen chloride. A second reactant solution was prepared -
by dissolving 124.5 g of sulfur dichloride in sufficient
cyclohexane to make a solution totaling about one gallon by
volume. This solution contained 4.15% sulfur dichloride by
weight. The two reactant solutions were stored in separate
containers. The containers were connected through separate,
adjustable, metering pumps to the inlet tubes in the reactor
top. ~`~
The reaction was commenced by running cool water
through the cooling coils, starting the stirrer, injecting a
slow stream of nitrogen into and through the reactor, placing :
in the reactor about one liter of the above phenol-cyclohexane
solution, and then adding to the solution 4,4'-thiodiphenol
crystals in an amount in excess of that which is required
for saturation.
The metering pumps were started and each was -
adjusted to deliver 50 ml per minute of the respectiv~ phenol
and sulfur dichloride solutions. Under these conditions of
concentration and pumping rate, the phenol was delivered at
twice the stoichiometric requirement of the sulfur dichloride
(at about a molar ratio of 4:1). The stirrer was maintained
at about 1200 to 1400 revolutions per minute and the water
flow was regulated to control the reaction slurry temperature
at about 25 C. to 28 C. With the overflow outlet tube
adjusted to three inches above the reactor vessel bottom
- 14 -
1059149
plate, the retained volume of the slurry in the reactor during
agitation was 700 to 800 ml. At a total pumping rate of about
100 ml per minute, this provided a contact time of about O.10
to 0.13 hour.
Once about one gallon of 4,4'-thiodiphenol product had
pas~qed through the reactor, the crystal reaction sy~tem wa~
essentially at "steady state". The TDP product slurry was
collected and filtered, and the accrued product was extracted
with fresh, hot cyclohexane. The dried product was a colorlesq
microcrystalline and solid, which weighed about 118 g and
represented about 91% of the expected theoretical conversion of
4,4'-thiodiphenol. Moreover, the 4,4'-monothiodiphenol
selectivity was derived by determining the percent by weight
of 4,4'-isomer in the total crude product. More ~pecifically,
gas-liquid chromatographic analysiq (GLC) of subject product
was performed using a Hewlett-Packard Model ~o. 5750 chromato-
graph equipped with a thermal conductivity detector. The con-
ditionR employed in the above analysi~ were as follows:
1. Column - 10 feet, l~/o SE 30 (trademark for a silicone gum
; 20 rubber) on high performance Chromosorb W (AW-DMSC)
trademark for a granular material functioning as ~ -
- an inert support, and which comprises washed alumina
treated with dimethyl dichloro silane.
2. Carrier Gas - helium at 30 cc per minute
; 3. Detector - thermo conductivity - 175 milliamps
4. Inlet and Detector Temperature - 270C.
5. Sample Size - 10 microliters of ether solution thereof con-
taining about 16 g of product per liter
6. Procedure - sample wa~ injected into a preheated column
(100 C.), the temperature being retained at that
level for six minutes. The temperature in the
column was then raised, at the rate of 20C. per
minute, to 250C. and maintained at that temperature
for a period of about 11 minutes. The chromato-
graphic data waq then read and interpreted.
- 15 _
,'",: . ' , . ': '
1059~49
The selectivity of the above TDP material was 97%.
The conversion to 4,4'-monothiodiphenol product,
based on the amount of consumed phenolic compound, was cal-
culated as follows:
Moles of phenol actually converted to
Conversion = Product x 100
Moles of phenol consumed by the process
of the present invention
The actual yield of 4,4'-monothiodiphenolic material
produced by the subject formation process is calculated by
multiplying "conversion" times "selectivity". For example,
in the above case the yield was about 88.3%.
As previously described, polysulfides present in
the solid final product are difficult to remove. Therefore, -
the smaller the amount of polysulfide present, the better
the quality of the final product recovered. Polarographic
analysis is used to determine the polysulfide contents of
the material formed by the subject process. A Heath polaro- -
graph Model E~A 19-2 and XY Recorder HP Model 2V-2 were
employed to conduct the above polarographic study. The
average polysulfide content of the material produced during
the course of the above run was about 0.4%.
The above results clearly demonstrate a direct,
continuous process for selectively producing the subject
4,4'.monothiophenols in high yields, with a minimum amount
of by-products, the requisite crystalline reaction system
being employed to facilitate the process of the present in-
vention. In addition, contact time is significantly reduced.
ExamPle 2
. . ,
The example illustrates the batch process of the
subject invention.
A solution of 79 g of phenol (0.84 mole) in 800 cc
of cyclohexane was added to a 3-liter flask. The solution
was saturated with anhydrous hydrogen chloride and a small
- 16 -
lQ59149
amount of 4,4'-thiodiphenol crystals added, thus forming
the requisite crystalline reaction system. A solution of
21.6 g (0.21 mole) of sulfur dichloride in 862 cc of cyclo-
hexane was then added to the flask, with stirring, and the
subject reaction begun. The temperature in the reaction
vessel was maintained at about 25 C. The reaction was
continued for about an hour. The entire reaction mixture
was recovered and extracted with caustic, the caustic solu-
tion acidified, and the precipitated phenols extracted with
ether. The material was then extracted with ether. The re-
maining 4,4'-thiodiphenol product had about a 90% selecti-
vity, about an 87.3% yield, and contained about 0.1% poly- -
sulfides.
The above data clearly demonstrates that when a
batch process is run according to the present invention, the -
subject crystalline reaction system again being employed, -
high yields, and selectivity, and a low polysulfide content
will result.
Example 3
This example illustrates the effect of employing
sterically hindered and sterically nonhindered phenol to
produce 4,4'-thiodiphenol materials.
In an attempt to prepare 4,4'-thiobis(2,6-di-tert-
butyl phenol), 41.3 g (0.2 mole) of 2,6-di-tert-butylphenol
was dissolved in 400 ml of heptane in a l-liter round-bottom
flask equipped with a stirrer, a condenser and drying tube.
A sulfur dichloride solution was prepared by dissolving 6.4 cc
(0.1 mole) of freshly distilled sulfur dichloride in 40 ml of
heptane which was, in turn, added to the flask at room tempera-
ture with stirring. No reaction was noted after one hour at
room temperature. The mixture was then heated to about
80~-90 C. for one hour. No reaction was observed.
- 17 -
, ' , ' ' , . ' '
1059149
~ nother run was made in an Erlenmyer flask, with
the same amounts of the above phenolic compound and sulfur
dichloride but with only 80 ml of heptane. No reaction was
apparent after the passage of about one and one-half hours.
Accordingly, the mixture was warmed to between about 50 -54
C. for half an hour. No hydrogen chloride gas was given off.
A small amount of ferric chloride catalyst was added at room
temperature. The temperature of the reaction was then again
raised to about 53 C. for a period of about an hour and the
mixture allowed to cool overnight. Some hydrogen chloride
gas was evolved during heating and the color of the mixture
turned much darker. After overnight cooling, the reaction
was analyzed by gas chromatography. Analysis thereof indi-
cated that most of the starting material had not been reacted.
Another run was made using the same amounts of reactants while
employing a total of 25 ml of petroleum ether as a solvent.
One-half of the sulfur dichloride solution was added to the
phenol solution at 16-18 C. in about half an hour. This
mixture was tnen refluxed at about 56 to 57 C. for half an
hour, and then cooled to about 16 C. to 18 C. The remain-
ing sulfur dichloride was added in about half an hour and the
mixture again refluxed. Hydrogen chloride gas was driven
off slowly during refluxing. The reaction mixture was fur- -
ther refluxed overnight and then analyzed by gas chroma- ~
tograph. Analysis again showed that a considerable amount `
of starting material was still present in the reaction mix-
ture.
The procedure employed in Example 2 was used,
whereby 90.5 g (0.84 mole) of o-cresol in 783 cc of cyclo-
30 hexane was combined with 21.6 g (0.21 mole) of sulfur di-
chloride in 861 cc of cyclohexane. 4,4'-thiobis(o-cresol)
crystals and a catalytic amount of hydrogen chloride were
-- 1~ --
1059149
added as before. The 4,4'-monothiodiphenol-containing
product formed, after extraction, was analyzed by gas
chromatograph and found to have a selectivity of 93%, and
~` a yield of 74.5%.
` In a similar manner, 102 g (0.8 mole) of 2,6-
xylenol in 778 cc of cyclohexane was combined with 21.6 g
; (0.21 mole) of sulfur dichloride in 862 cc of cyclohexane.
Analysis of the resultant product shows a yield of about
95% and a selectivity of about 95% 4,4'-isomer.
The above results clearly demonstrate that steri-
cally hindered phenols do not react with sulfur dichloride
in a similar manner to sterically nonhindered phenols
employed according to the process of the present invention,
this being true even when a Lewis acid is employed along
with the above sterically hindered phenols for purposes of
initiating the reaction thereof.
ExamPle 4
This example illustrates the effect upon the
formation of polysulfide by-products by varying the mole
ratio of phenol to sulfur dichloride (stoichiometric ratio -
2~
A continuous reaction system, similar to that pro-
vided in Example 1, was employed varying the mole ratio of
phenol with respect to sulfur dichloride, the results obtained
being as follows:
Phenol: Sulfur Dichloride
(Mole Ratio) Percent Polysulfide Formed
2.7 2.4
3 0 0.8
3,3 0.3 to 0.6
4.0 0.2 to 0.4
By polarographic analysis, an average of 2.4%
polysulfide by-products were found to be contained in the
accrued TDP product prepared by employing a 2.7:1 mole ratio
-- 19 --
` 1059149
of phenol to sulfur dichloride. In contradistinction, when
- accrued products are prepared from 3.0:1, 3.3:1, or 4.0:1
ratios of phenol to sulfur dichloride, less than about 1%
by weight polysulfide by-products were present in the recov-
ered material.
ExamPle 5
The following table illustrates the effect on
selectivity and yield of various saturated solvents employed
within the scope of the present invention, each solvent hav-
ing a different solubility parameter:
Hydrogen Percent
Solubility Bonding Selecti- Percent
Solvent Parameter EnerqYvity Yield
n-Pentane 7.0 Low 94 71.5
n-Heptane 7.4 Low 92 79.1
Methylcyclohexane 7.8 Low 90 81.9
Methylcyclopentane 7.9 Low 90 81.9
Cyclohexane 8.2 Low 90 87.2 - ;
Butyl Chloride 8.3 Low 84 82.5
Carbon Tetrachloride 8.6 Low 85 76.0
The above results clearly indicate that high yields
and selectivity will result when the requisite solvent is
employed within the scope of the subject invention. ;~
ExamPle 6
The optimum temperature range for a given reaction
within the scope of the present invention was analyzed by
monitoring the reaction o~ phenol and sulfur dichloride.
Reaction was continuously run in a similar manner to the
reaction outlined in Example 1, varying only the reaction
temperature over a period of time. The results based on the
percent polysulfide generated at a given temperature are as
follows:
- 20 -
`lOS9149
Temperature in Percent
Deqree Centigrade Polvsulfide
2.4 --
26 0,2 to 0.5
38 2.3
44 4.3
When the temperature is maintained at about 26 --
C., the product exhibited a polysulfide content, determined
by polarographic analysis, of about 0.2% to 0.5% by weight
based on the total yield of material produced. However,
when the temperature was dropped to 10 C., a 2.4% yield
of polysulfides was produced due to the separation of
phenols at that temperature, which resulted in a lower molar
ratio of phenol to sulfur dichloride actually present in the -
subject reaction system. Moreover, when the temperature was -
raised to 38 C. and 44 C., respectively, polysulfide yields
of 2.3% and 4.3%, respectively, were observed.
The above results indicate that the amount of poly-
sulfide by-products will be significantly reduced in the above
described reaction of phenol and sulfur dichloride under the `-
20 above reaction conditions. -
The terms and expressions which have been employed
in the foregoing abstract and specification are used therein
as terms of description and not of limitation, and there is
no intention in the use of such terms and expressions of ex-
cluding equivalents of the features shown and described or -~
portions thereof, it being recognized that the scope of the
invention is defined and limited only by the claims which
foll~w:
- 21 -
.
.. . . .
