Note : Les descriptions sont présentées dans la langue officielle dans laquelle elles ont été soumises.
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
-1 - 2138946
PRESSURE RELIEF VALVE
The present invention relates to a pressure relief
valve particularly, but not exclusively, for use with
pipelines carrying fluid at a predetermined pressure above
which the fluid requires to be vented so as to reduce
pressure in the system to a level beneath the
predetermined threshold. In particular, the pressure
relief valve is for use in hydrocarbon production
exploration industries and similar pressurised fluid
environments.
Hydrocarbon fluid in a well test or well production
environment is maintained initially at pressure
substantially higher than atmosphere. The pipeline
containing the pressurised hydrocarbon fluid usually
contains a piece of equipment, such as a safety valve,
such that if an over-pressure situation occurs the well
fluid is vented to atmosphere via a oil rig pressure
relief burner boom. Such pressure relief valves have
been available for many years and one common type is a
flanged pressure relief valve which is spring-loaded and
which is coupled to the hydrocarbon pipeline. In the
event of an over-pressure situation arising, a valve
closure member is forced from a valve seat, against a
spring force to open the valve, whereby pressurised fluid
is allowed to flow through a valve outlet. A typical
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
_2 _ 2138946
type of prior art valve is a Crosby spring-loaded flanged
pressure relief valve style JOS and JBS. Although these
types of valve are common in the industry, they suffer
from a number of disadvantages. One significant
disadvantage of this type of valve is that a back-pressure
at the valve outlet of approximately 10% of the inlet
pressure is sufficient to act together with a spring force
to close the valve leading to a potentially hazardous
situation. In addition, the top housing which contains
the spring element is rated at 120 p.s.i. which is
believed insufficient to use with a large range of
pressures commonly encountered in hydrocarbon process
equipment. In order for the valve to be used such that
the outlet pressure is less than 10% ef the inlet pressure
large diameter piping is required at the outlet. This
piping is not only heavy, but is also relatively
expensive. A further consequence of the weight of the
piping is that in the production and exploration structure
at least 9 times the amount of piping weight requires to
be added for structural considerations. Therefore, where
considerable amount of piping is required, as is common in
oil exploration and production platforms, this can result
in a significant add-on cost in terms of weight and
overall structural costs as a consequence of having to use
large diameter piping to reduce the pressure relief valve
back-pressure. A further disadvantage of the
aforementioned prior art valves is that most of the valve
_ _~___ r ~_..__._ . .~
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
213894fi
- 3 -
closure elements are of the plate type which can result in
hydrate formation as the gas expands and cools in the
nozzle because of the throttling effect. If this happens
and venting does not occur, the line pressure is retained
and the well test equipment is likely to fail at the next
weakest point which is probably the piece of equipment
which the valve is intended to protect.
A further disadvantage of existing prior art relief
valves is that it is not possible to test the valve in
situ. The system requires to be closed down, the valve
physically removed and tested and then re-inserted into
the process equipment. It will be appreciated that this
is an extremely time-consuming and expensive operation,
especially on exploration and production rigs, which add
significantly to the cost of operating the rig. Yet
another disadvantage of the prior art pressure relief
valves is that with a plate valve fluid impinges on the
valve nozzle and the valve plate, with the result that the
nozzle and the plate can wear, thus rendering the valve
susceptible to leakage in the absence of an over-pressure
situation which is, of course, undesirable.
Another type of pressure relief valve is a balanced
bellows type valve which is used to isolate the back
pressure from the top of the disc with the effective area
of the bellows being equal to the seat area. Therefore,
although this type of valve is claimed to operate with
back pressures up to 50% of gauge pressure at set
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
~~.~8946
- 4 -
pressures of 100 psig or greater at present. Such valves
are incapable of withstanding back pressures in excess of
200 psig, therefore, large relief systems are still
required to maintain the pressure relief below this.
Another type of pressure relief valve mentioned in ANSI
Standard B951 is pilot-operated valves and although these
valves have no back pressure limitations, they are not
widely used in the industry because of complexity of
design and the possibility of increased system failure.
An object of the present invention is to provide a
pressure relief valve which obviates or mitigates at least
one of the aforementioned disadvantages of the prior art.
This is achieved by providing a pressure relief valve
having an apertured ball valve element which is
spring-loaded and which is rotatably and axially mounted
in the valve bore so that when an over-pressure situation
arises fluid forces the ball off a ball valve seat against
a spring force and causes the ball valve to rotate such
that the aperture in the ball valve connects the inlet
bore and outlet bore of a valve housing so that fluid can
flow through the pressure relief valve. When pressure at
the inlet falls beneath a predetermined value, the spring
force forces the ball to rotate and move back against the
valve seat, thus closing the valve.
With this arrangement there is minimal pressure
exerted on the valve housing and the valve will operate
with a back-pressure up to 50% of the inlet pressure.
t _.
Mar-03-5~ 05:41pm From-51M MCBURNEY 4165951163 T-129 P 02/03 F-115
-5- 2 1 3 8 9 4 6
This means that much smaller bore outlet piping can be used with savings in
weight and, consequently, cost. For example, 3 in. piping nay be used instead
of
8 in. or larger piping for the equivalent rated valves.
Therefore, various aspects of the invention are provided as follows:
A pressure relief valve for relieving pressure above a predetermined value
in fluid flow lines, said pressure relief valve comprising:
a valve housing defining a through-bore with a bore inlet and a bore
outlet,
a ball valve element mounted in said through-bore, said ball valve element
having a through-aperture, and being mounted on said through-bore such chat
said bah valve element is rotatable and axially moveable within said through-
bore,
said ball valve element being coupled to spring means biased to urge said
ball valve element into a closed position, the arrangement being such that in
response to fluid at said through-bore inlet exceeding a predetermined
pressure,
said ball valve is axially moved off a valve seat against said spring means
and rotated such that said through-bore allows fluid communication between
said through-bore inlet and said through-bore outlet, and when fluid pressure
at
said through-bore inlet falls beneath said predetermined level said spring
means
providing a restoring force to rotate and axially move said ball valve element
onto said valve seat to close said pressure relief valve.
A pressure relief valve for relieving pressure above a predetermined value
in fluid flow lines, said pressure relief valve comprising:
a valve housing de$ning a through-bore with a bore inlet and a bore
outlet,
a ball valve element mounted in said bore, said ball valve element having
a through-aperture, and being mounted on said bore such that said ball valve
element is rotatable and axially moveable within said bore,
-5a- 2 1 3 8 9 4 6
said ball valve element being coupled to spring means
biased to urge said ball valve element into a closed position,
the arrangement being such that in response to fluid at said
bore inlet exceeding a predetermined pressure,
said ball valve is axially moved off a valve seat against
said spring force and rotated such that said through bore
allows fluid communication between said bore inlet and said
bore outlet, and when fluid pressure at said bore inlet falls
beneath said predetermined level said spring means providing a
restoring force to rotate and axially move said ball valve
element onto said valve seat to close said pressure relief
valve.
A method of relieving pressure above a predetermined
value in fluid flow lines comprising the steps of:
applying a spring force to force a ball valve element
against a valve seat in the absence of pressure in said fluid
flow lines above said predetermined value,
and when pressure in said fluid flow lines exceeds said
predetermined value urging said ball valve axially from said
valve seat against said spring force,
rotating said ball valve element such that fluid flows
through said ball valve element to relieve said excessive
pressure, and when said pressure falls beneath said
predetermined value said spring force provides a restoring
force to return the ball valve element into sealing engagement
WO 94/00709
PCT/GB93/Ol 110
-6 - 2138946
Preferably, said spring means is adjustable so that
the predetermined pressure at which the ball valve element
is moved is variable. Conveniently, the pressure relief
valve means includes test coupling means for coupling to
valve test apparatus by which the valve operation can be
tested in situ.
Preferably, the area of the valve seat is exactly the
same as the area of the seat seal.
Preferably, the spring means is provided by
Belleville washers the properties of which are selected to
give a selected response to predetermined inlet pressure
values.
Preferably also, the ball valve element is coupled to
the spring means by means of a cylindrical piston located
between said ball valve element and a spring-pusher and
which is axially moveable within said valve housing.
Conveniently, the ball valve element in the housing
bore has machined slots of a predetermined shape which are
mounted on caroming spigots such that as the valve is moved
off the valve seat axially in response to inlet pressure
above a predetermined threshold, it is simultaneously
rotated such that at the full open position, the aperture
of the ball element is aligned with the inlet and outlet
bores. Conveniently, the ball valve element seals are
made of beryllium copper. Conveniently, the ball valve
element is displaced by a very small amount, such as 0.2
in., before it starts to
._....... " ..__._...~.._._r..._._ _....,......_........... .... ........T...
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
_, _ 21 389 ~6
rotate and is rotated to a fully open position when
displaced axially by 0.635 in.
These and other aspects of the invention will become
apparent from the following description, when taken in
combination with the accompanying drawings in which:-
Fig. 1 is a longitudinal split sectional view through
a pressure relief valve in accordance an embodiment of the
present invention, and
Fig. 2 is an enlarged side view of the ball valve
element taken in the direction of arrow 2 shown in Fig. 1.
Reference is made to the drawing which depicts a
pressure relief valve, generally indicated by reference
numeral 10, having a valve inlet flange 12 and a valve
outlet flange 14 for connection to inlet and outlet
piping, which are not shown in the interests of clarity.
The valve 10 has a valve housing generally indicated by
reference numeral 16 which defines the longitudinal valve
bore 18 which extends throughout the length of the valve
element such that when the pressure relief valve is open,
as will be later described, the valve bore is in
communication with a bore inlet 20 at the inlet flange and
bore outlet 22 at the outlet flange so that fluid can flow
through the valve and relieve excess pressure in fluid
pipeline.
The valve housing 16 has a lower or inlet bush 24
into which is fixed a cylindrical ball valve element
carrier 26. A ball valve element 28 is disposed in the
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
- 213894
bore 18 and is rotatably mounted on spigots 30 of carrier
26 and carrying brackets 27 (one of which is shown) which
is a plate with a circular cut-out for receiving a
machined circular slot 29 (Fig. 2) of the ball element 28
such that the ball can be rotated and moved axially
between an open and a closed position as will be later
described in detail. The ball valve element 28 has
through-aperture 32 which is of substantially the same
diameter as the bore 18 such that when the ball valve is
fully open, the through channel 32 is aligned with the
bore 18 such that there is a continuous bore between the
inlet bore 20 and the outlet bore 22.
A cylindrical piston 34 is disposed in the valve
housing and the top surface of the piston is shaped to
abut the spherical surface portion 36 of the ball valve
element 28. The piston is, as will be later described,
axially moveable within said housing and abuts a
spring-pusher 38.
A biasing spring 4o in the form of a plurality of
Belleville washers 42 arranged as shown is disposed in a
chamber 44 defined between the exterior of the housing 16
and a spring carrier 46 which is secured within the
housing 16. The spring is contained in chamber 44 by
means of the spring-pusher 38 and an adjustable stop 48.
The adjustable stop 48 can be used to test the operation
of the pressure relief valve in situ, as will be later
described in detail. The adjustable stop is secured in
1 _._._ j
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
-9 - 213894fi
position thus, in turn, confining the spring 42 within the
chamber 44 as shown.
The ball valve element 28 has a valve seat 50 which
abuts a similar annular valve seat 52 of the annular
cylinder 54, the interior surface of which defines inlet
bore 20. It will be seen that there is clearance between
each ball element spigot 30 and spigot locating slot 54
such that the ball valve element 28 can be moved axially
within the housing. Each spigot 30 has a cylindrical
portion 31 and a conical portion 33 which fits into the
slot 54 which is best seen in Fig. 2. The slot (54) has
an outside track (55) and an inside track (58). The
outside track (55) acts upon the cylindrical portion (31)
of the spigot 30 and rotates the valve open and
correspondingly the inside track (58) acts upon the
opposite side (33) of the spigot (30) and rotates the
valve to the closed position. The upper area of the
inside track (57) allows the valve element to move axially
relative to the spigot (30) prior to rotation of the
element.
In operation, the pressure relief valve 10 is coupled
to an inlet pipe and an outlet pipe (not shown) and when
the fluid pressure in the inlet pipe, which enters bore 20
and presses on the valve element 28, is sufficient to
force the valve element axially along the bore 18 against
the spring force of the biasing washer spring 40, the seal
50,52 between the spherical valve seat and annular seal is
.. .
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
-1~- 2138946
broken as the ball valve element 28 moved axially along
bore 18 which is allowed by the track 57 moving past flat
surface 35. The spigot 30 performs a caroming function
such that, after the ball valve element is moved by 0.2
in., the element 28 is simultaneously rotated about the
spigots 30 such that the aperture 32 turns into alignment
with the bore 18. When the ball valve is fully open,
that is it is moved 0.635 in., the aperture 32 is in
alignment with the bore 18 and fluid communicates through
the valve 10 from the inlet bore 20 through bore 18 to the
outlet bore 22 and to any pipe coupled to the outlet
flange 14. Pressure is exerted on the biasing spring 40
by means of the annular piston 34 acting on the
spring-pusher 38. The Belleville washers are Mubea disc
springs of the type such as 022,5 GR1 which has a
regressive force deflection curve. This means that the
force deflection curve is not linear and that at a certain
force a smaller increase in force, for example, 400N an
increase of 50N provides about a 2.5mm deflection whereas
at 100N an increase of 50N gives about a 0.5mm
deflection. This means that the spring force can be fine
tuned to enable the valve to be actuated at predetermined
pressures at the valve inlet 20. When the valve is open,
fluid rushes through the valve 10 to the outlet pipework
to be vented. T'~e interior of the bore 18 is slightly
constricted by the internal bore tube 56 which fonas a
nozzle 58 near the outlet. It will be appreciated that
_..._,..
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
-11- 2138946
because this nozzle is displaced from the valve element
any hydration or freezing of well fluid will not affect
the operation of the valve element.
When pressure at the inlet falls beneath the
predetermined level, the biasing spring 40 acts on the
spring-pusher 38 and the annular piston 34 to urge the
ball valve element 36 axially towards the inlet 12. As
the valve element is urged in this direction it is rotated
because of the spigot/slot arrangement as before so that
the aperture 32 is rotated through 90o to the position
shown in the drawing. In this position, the valve seats
50,52 are again in contact and the valve is effectively
closed.
Thus, it will be appreciated that with the
afore-described embodiment of pressure relief valve
various advantages are provided over the aforementioned
prior art. In particular, back-pressure has nominal
affect on the valve element, this being driven by the
biasing spring means which is effectively separated from
the bore, unlike the prior art. Therefore, the valve is
able to operate with up to 50% back-pressure which means
that the outlet pipe bore is very much smaller for a given
pressure relief requirement providing savings in weight
and, of course, cost. This results in a similar weight
saving in the structure further improving cost savings.
A further advantage is that the nozzle is removed from the
valve element so that there is minimal wear of the valve
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
-i2- 2138946
seat and valve element due to fluid flow, unlike the prior
art.
In addition, the adjustable stop 48 can be coupled to
an external hydraulic test jig which can be used to test
the operation of the valve in situ which has hitherto not
been possible with existing valves. The set pressure of
the valve is checked by locating hydraulic jig (not shown)
on the lower valve body and the adjustable stop 48.
Ideally the hydraulic area of the jig is equal to that of
the annular valve seat 50. Therefore by the application
of hydraulic pressure to the jig until the springs 40
begin to compress would provide a reliable indication of
the cracking pressure of the valve. Increasing the
pressure until the jig and springs had moved by circa
0.625" (full travel equivalent to full open position)
would provide a reliable indication of the full valve open
pressure. To set the valve at the required pressure a
lock ring 49 can be adjusted to abut the stop 48 and
therefore maintain the stop 48 in the correct position.
For the purpose of safety a mechanism is provided (not
shown) to enable the stop to be locked by either a lead
seal or padlock. A plug 60 can be located in the housing
as shown to secure the spring pusher 38 to facilitate
transport of the multi-sensor relief valve. The plug 60
is of course removed when the valve is in situ to
facilitate operation.
Various modifications may be made to the embodiment
. ~..._ .. .. . .. . _ .._. ...w..._
WO 94/00709 PCT/GB93/01110
- ~ 2138946
hereinbefore described without departing from the scope of
the invention. For example, more than one valve spring
may be used disposed at various positions around the
periphery of the valve housing. The seals may be made of
any other suitable material than beryllium copper and the
spring means could be a coil spring instead of Belleville
washers or any other suitable resilient material which
could be tuned to provide the suitable valve opening and
valve closing positions.
