Note : Les descriptions sont présentées dans la langue officielle dans laquelle elles ont été soumises.
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Optimized Solid/liquid Separation System for Multiphase Converters
STATEMENT REGARDING FEDERALLY SPONSORED
RESEARCH OR DEVELOPMENT
Not applicable.
TECHNICAL FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates generally to methods and apparatus for removing
liquid/wax products from a slurry used in a Fischer-Tropsch reactor.
Particularly this
invention relates to methods of operating a filtration system with better
filtrate quality, and
longer filtration cycle times. The present invention also includes a method to
remove the
cake, at least partially, without compromising the filtrate quality during the
next filtration
cycle and minimizing the need of traditional backwash or blowback cleaning
methods.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Natural gas, found in deposits in the earth, is an abundant energy resource.
For
example, natural gas commonly serves as a fuel for heating, cooking, and power
generation,
among other things. The process of obtaining natural gas from an earth
formation typically
includes drilling a well into the formation. Wells that provide natural gas
are often remote from
locations with a demand for the consumption of the natural gas.
Thus, natural gas is conventionally transported large distances from the
wellhead to
commercial destinations in pipelines. This transportation presents
technological challenges
due, in part, to the large volume occupied by a gas. Because the volume of a
gas is so much
greater than the volume of a liquid containing the same number of gas
molecules, the process of
transporting natural gas by means other than pipelines typically includes
chilling and/or
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
pressurizing the natural gas in order to liquefy it. However, this contributes
to the final cost of
the natural gas.
Further, naturally occurring sources of crude oil used for liquid fuels such
as gasoline
and middle distillates have been decreasing and supplies are not expected to
meet demand in the
coming years. Middle distillates typically include heating oil, jet fuel,
diesel fuel, and kerosene.
Fuels that are liquid under standard atmospheric conditions have the advantage
that in addition
to their value, they can be transported more economically than natural gas,
since they do not
require energy, equipment, and expense for liquefaction.
Thus, for all of the above-described reasons, there has been interest in
developing
technologies for converting natural gas to more readily transportable liquid
fuels, i.e. to fuels
that are liquid at standard temperatures and pressures. One method for
converting natural gas to
liquid fuels involves two sequential chemical transformations. In the first
transformation,
natural gas or methane, the major chemical component of natural gas, is
reacted with oxygen to
form syngas, which is a combination of carbon monoxide gas and hydrogen gas.
In the second
transformation, known as the Fischer-Tropsch process, carbon monoxide is
reacted with
hydrogen to form organic molecules containing carbon and hydrogen. Those
organic molecules
containing only carbon and hydrogen are known as hydrocarbons. In addition,
other organic
molecules containing oxygen in addition to carbon and hydrogen known as
oxygenates may be
formed during the Fischer-Tropsch process. Hydrocarbons having carbons linked
in a straight
chain are known as aliphatic hydrocarbons that may include paraffins and/or
olefins. Paraffins
are particularly desirable as the basis of synthetic diesel fuel.
Typically the Fischer-Tropsch product stream contains hydrocarbons having a
range of
numbers of carbon atoms, and thus having a range of molecular weights. Thus,
the Fischer-
Tropsch products produced by conversion of natural gas commonly contain a
range of
2
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
hydrocarbons including gases, liquids and waxes. Depending on the molecular
weight product
distribution, different Fischer-Tropsch product mixtures are ideally suited to
different uses. For
example, Fischer-Tropsch product mixtures containing liquids may be processed
to yield
gasoline, as well as heavier middle distillates. Hydrocarbon waxes may be
subjected to an
additional processing step for conversion to liquid and/or gaseous
hydrocarbons. Thus, in the
production of a Fischer-Tropsch product stream for processing to a fuel, it is
desirable to
maximize the production of high value liquid hydrocarbons, such as
hydrocarbons with at least 5
carbon atoms per hydrocarbon molecule (CS+ hydrocarbons).
The Fischer-Tropsch process is commonly facilitated by a catalyst. Catalysts
desirably
have the function of increasing the rate of a reaction without being consumed
by the reaction. A
feed containing carbon monoxide and hydrogen is typically contacted with a
catalyst in a
reaction zone that may include one or more reactors.
Common reactors include packed bed (also termed fixed bed) reactors, fluidized
bed
reactors and slurry bed reactors. Originally, the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis
was carried out in
packed bed reactors. These reactors have several drawbacks, such as
temperature control, that
can be overcome by gas-agitated slurry reactors or slurry bubble column
reactors. Gas-agitated
multiphase reactors sometimes called "slurry reactors" or "slurry bubble
columns," operate by
suspending catalytic particles in liquid and feeding gas reactants into the
bottom of the reactor
through a gas distributor, which produces gas bubbles. As the gas bubbles rise
through the
reactor, the reactants are absorbed into the liquid and diffuse to the
catalyst where, depending
on the catalyst system, they are typically converted to gaseous and liquid
products. The
gaseous products formed enter the gas bubbles and are collected at the top of
the reactor.
Liquid products are recovered from the suspending liquid by using different
techniques like
filtration, settling, hydrocyclones, magnetic techniques, etc. Gas-agitated
multiphase reactors,
3
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
or slurry bubble column reactors (SBCRs), inherently have very high heat
transfer rates, and
therefore, reduced reactor cost. This, and the ability to remove and add
catalyst online are
some of the principal advantages of such reactors as applied to the exothermic
Fischer-Tropsch
synthesis. Sie and Krishna (Applied Catalysis A: General 1999, 186, p. 55),
incorporated
herein by reference in its entirety, give a history of the development of
various Fischer Tropsch
reactors.
One of the critical design considerations in a SBCR is the recovery of usable
liquid
products (commonly called waxes in this context) from the reactor slurry. The
recovered
waxes need to be generally free of catalyst particles before being further
processed into
commercial products. One problem with the removal of usable liquid products,
however, is
that catalyst particles are dispersed in the liquid and must be separated from
the slurry. It is
also often desired to return substantially all of the catalyst particles to
the reactor in order to
maintain a constant inventory of catalyst in the reactor.
In order to reduce catalyst loses and minimize replacement costs, it is highly
desirable
to obtain a wax product with a minimum solid content from a Fischer-Tropsch
slurry reactor.
Some of the early work on catalyst/wax separation techniques involved placing
a filter on an
external slurry circulation loop is described in an article by M.D.
Schlesinger, J.H. Crowell,
Max Leva and H.H. Storch titled "Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis in Slurry Phase"
from the U.S.
Bureau of Mines (Engineering and Process Development, Vol. 43, No. 6, page
1474 to 1479,
June 1951). Several methods, such as filtration, magnetic separation and
settling, are
disclosed in "Status Review of Fischer-Tropsch Slurry Reactor/Catalyst Wax
Separation
Techniques" prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy, Pittsburgh Energy
Technology center
by P. Z. Zhou, Bums and Roe Services Corporation, February, 1991. These
methods have
4
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
been developed for separating catalyst particles from Fischer-Tropsch wax but
have proved
less than ideal or were not deemed commercially viable.
In a commercial SBCR, the severe hydrodynamic conditions inside the reactor,
coupled with the desired long lifetime of the catalytic material, can result
in catalyst attrition.
In the case of some attrition-prone catalyst particles, as the catalyst
particles break down over
time, sub-particles of various sizes may be created, including very small
particles known as
"fines," some of which may even be sub-micron in size. The presence of fines
in the reactor
tends to greatly reduce the effectiveness of the catalyst-liquid separation
system.
In a catalyst-liquid separation system utilizing filtration, the frequency of
the
backwashing operations affects the solids content of the filtrate thus the
filtrate quality. The
higher the backwashing frequency the poorer the quality of the filtrate. This
is because at the
beginning of the filtration cycle, which follows the backwashing and before
the cake is
established, many particles of size smaller than the substrate nominal opening
will traverse it
and therefore degrading the filtrate quality.
Thus, there remains a need in the art for methods and apparatus to improve the
removal of wax products from a slurry with a high solids content, such as a
Fischer-Tropsch
slurry. Therefore, the embodiments of the present invention are directed to
methods and
apparatus, for improved operation of a filtration system for recovering an
improved-quality
product from a slurry and to extend cycle times of the filtration system, that
seek to overcome
these and other limitations of the prior art.
SUMMARY OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Accordingly, there are provided herein methods and apparatus for removing wax
products from a slurry used in a Fischer-Tropsch reactor. The preferred
embodiments of the
present invention are characterized by a solid/liquid separation system that
continuously
5
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
removes liquid products from a slurry containing the liquid products and solid
particles. The
solid/liquid separation system has a slurry chamber and a filtrate chamber
separated by a
filter medium. The slurry chamber has an inlet and an outlet to provide for
the flow of slurry
through the chamber at a predetermined flow rate. The filtrate chamber
includes a filtrate
outlet and is preferably maintained at a pressure lower than the pressure in
the slurry
chamber. The separation is effected by drawing the fluid across a filter
medium composed of
a filter cake disposed on a substrate, so that the cake filter performs the
substantial majority of
the filtration activity. The thickness of the filter cake can be maintained
within a desired
range by controlling the slurry velocity and/or the pressure differential
across the filter
medium. As used herein, the slurry linear velocity is calculated by the ratio
of the slurry
volumetric flow rate to the cross-sectional area of the slurry chamber
available for slurry flow
before forming the cake. The substrate is preferably a cylindrical filter
element having a
central axis parallel to the slurry velocity.
The filtration method according to this invention is different than a method
known as
cross-flow filtration, where a cake is not needed, and furthermore is avoided
or 'barely'
tolerated. Moreover, in this invention the resulting fluxes are much higher
than the fluxes
associated with cross-flow filtration, thereby making it more efficient in
product recovery and
more cost effective. This filtration method is also different from a method
known as dead-
end filtration, as the filtration in this invention can be operated in a
continuous manner and is
well suited for high solid content.
The embodiments of the present invention provide a filtration system that
provides
enhanced filter life and performance while being resistant to the deleterious
effects of fine
catalyst particles bypassing the filter medium and contaminating the liquid
products. The
enhanced filter life and performance results at least in part from the less-
frequent use of
6
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
backwashing or blowback. Typically, at the beginning of a backwash, some fines
can pass
through the substrate, resulting in an increased probability of clogging the
substrate and
causing a degradation in the quality of the filtrate in terms of solids
content. By minimizing
the frequency of backwashes, the presence of fines inside the substrate is
less prominent and
S therefore the probability of fines into the filtrate is lessened. The
present invention also
relates to the filtrate product obtained from such methods, which is
characterized by an
improved quality and a very small solid content.
When the filtrate flow rate or flux (flux defined as filtrate flow rate
divided by the
area of substrate) is below a determined level, it may become necessary to
restore the filtrate
flow to a more desirable value. The restoration of filtrate flow can be
achieved by reducing
the cake thickness. To remove some or all of the cake, any known cleaning
method or
combination of methods which use a reverse flow of fluid (gas, liquid, or
combinations) such
as backwashing or blowback can be used. Alternatively, the applicants
discovered a novel
technique for cleaning the substrate that comprises stopping the filtration
flow for a short
period of time, maintaining constant slurry flow through the slurry chamber,
and resuming
filtration rate to a more desirable level. This technique will result in a
reduction or
minimization of the backwash frequency. Any combination of these cleaning
methods or any
alternation of techniques is also contemplated in this invention.
As the filter cake thickness increases, the flow area through the slurry
chamber in
which the slurry enters decreases, causing a corresponding increase in the
slurry velocity and
an increase in pressure differential across the filter medium, while
decreasing the filtration
rate. 1.~ this condition, the flow rate of slurry can be increased to further
increase the slurry
velocity so as to erode the filter cake and decrease the cake thickness. It
has been discovered
that a velocity of greater than 5 feet/second (ft/sec) across the filter cake
will result in a loss
7
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
of cake thickness and stability. Therefore, by periodically increasing the
linear velocity of
the slurry entering the filtration system for a short period of time, the cake
thickness will
decrease, thus increasing the filtrate flow through the filter medium and
resulting in an
extended period of time between backwashes or blowbacks. By maintaining a
slurry velocity
of at least 0.3 ft/sec and not more than 5 ftlsec combined with a pressure
differential across
the filter medium of not more than 30 psi (207 kPa), preferably not more than
15 psi (103
kPa), and most preferably not more than 5 psi (34 kPa), the filtration cycle
time can be
extended to several hours between cleanings, such as backwashes, blowbacks, or
other
cleaning techniques.
A preferable filtration system provides for a filtration rate of at least 0.2
gallons per
minute per square foot of filter area, or gpm/ft2, (about 490 L/mz/hr) and as
much as 8
gpm/ft2 (about 19,600 L/m2hr) or more. In some embodiments the filtration rate
is greater
than 0.4 gpm/ft2, preferably between 0.4 gpm/ftz to 8.0 gpm/ft2. The slurry
exiting the
filtration system through the outlet has between 1 and 30%, and preferably
between 2 and
. 10%, less liquid content than the slurry entering the system. The production
and efficiency of
the filtration system can be controlled by varying the flow rate of slurry
through the system
and/or the pressure differential between the slurry chamber and the filtrate
chamber.
In some embodiments, the flow rate of slurry can be increased by recycling a
portion
of the filtrate back through the filtration system. Slurry flow rate may also
be increased by
additional slurry from the reactor or by recycling filtered slurry through the
filtration system.
One preferable filtration system is supplied by a slurry that is gravity-fed
from an SBCR. In
another embodiment, a separation system includes parallel separation units.
Individual
separation units can be taken off-line to be cleaned or maintained while
filtration is continued
8
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
with the other units. Slurry flow to one unit can also be partially or
completely diverted to
the other unit in order to control the flow rate of slurry to one or both
units.
In another embodiment, the filtration system is coupled with a settler so that
the
method for operating the filtration system includes flowing the slurry to a
settler. The settler is
used to extract a portion of the slurry containing a high concentration of
large diameter
particles, which is then passed through a filter housing comprising a slurry
chamber and a
filtrate chamber separated by a filter medium. The large diameter particles
are deposited on the
substrate to form a filter cake that has a thickness and provides a
substantial majority of the
filtration activity. The cake formed primarily from large diameter particles
allows for greater
permeability and filtrate flux than is available from a conventionally formed
cake. The flow of
slurry is then shifted to bypass the settler and passed through the filter
housing so as to
permeate a portion of the slurry liquid phase through the filter cake and the
substrate to
generate a filtrate flux. The thickness and continued operation of the filter
cake can then be
regulated by any of the above described methods.
Thus, the present invention comprises a combination of features and advantages
that
enable it to substantially increase efficiency of removing liquid products
from a slurry having
a high solids concentration. These and various other characteristics and
advantages of the
present invention will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art upon
reading the
following detailed description of the preferred embodiments of the invention
and by refernng
to the accompanying drawings.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
For a more detailed understanding of the preferred embodiments, reference is
made to
the accompanying Figures, wherein:
9
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Figure 1 is a schematic view of one embodiment of an SBCR and filtration
system
having filtrate recycle;
Figure 2 represents a laboratory setup used to test a filtration system
according to one
embodiment of this invention;
Figures 3 represent the filtrate flow rate over time on stream at a given
slurry velocity
and a relatively constant pressure differential of 2 psi using a 20 microns
nominal rating
substrate;
Figure 4 shows the effect of slurry velocity on filtrate flow rate.
Figure 5 is one embodiment of a novel method for cleaning of a substrate to
remove at
least a portion of the cake according to this invention; it also shows the
quality of the filtrate in
terms of solids content during the duration of the experiment; and
Figure 6 is a schematic representation of one embodiment of a filtration
system.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
In the description that follows, like parts are marked throughout the
specification and
drawings with the same reference numerals, respectively. The drawing figures
are not
necessarily to scale. Certain features of the invention may be shown
exaggerated in scale or
in somewhat schematic form and some details of conventional elements may not
be shown in
the interest of clarity and conciseness.
The preferred embodiments of the present invention relate to methods and
apparatus
for removing liquid wax products from a slurry having a heavy solids content.
The present
invention is susceptible to embodiments of different forms. There are shown in
the drawings,
and herein will be described in detail, specific embodiments of the present
invention with the
understanding that the present disclosure is to be considered an
exemplification of the
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
principles of the invention, and is not intended to limit the invention to
that illustrated and
described herein.
In particular, various embodiments of the present invention provide a number
of
different methods and apparatus for removing wax products from a slurry. It
should be
understood that, while reference may be made to particular substrates, any
permeable or
porous substrate may be used. Suitable substrate materials may include,
sintered powder
metal, sintered woven wire-mesh , wedge wire, porous metal fiber, and metal
supported
membranes. It is to be fully recognized that the different teachings of the
embodiments
discussed below may be employed separately or in any suitable combination to
produce
desired results.
As used herein,. the number average particle size, DQVg, is defined by
Equation (1) to be
the summation over the total number of particles, of the relative frequency of
particles of size i,
f, times the diameter of particles of size i, d;.
N
Dnvg - ~ fi~i (1)
i=1
The relative frequency of particles of size i, f, is determined in Equation
(2) by dividing the
number of particles of size i, n;, by the total number of particles, N.
.f; __ n i (2)
N
Figure 1 shows a schematic representation of a solid/liquid separation system
300
having a slurry chamber 310 and a filtrate chamber 320. Slurry chamber 310 has
inlet 330
and outlet 340. Filtrate chamber 320 is disposed within slurry chamber 310 and
at least a
portion of chamber 320 is constructed of filter medium 350. Filter medium 350
includes
11
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
filter cake 360 formed on substrate 370. Filtrate chamber 320 also has
filtrate outlet 380, the
flow through which is controlled by a valve (not shown).
Syngas, containing hydrogen and carbon monoxide, is fed through inlet 420 into
reactor vessel 410, which contains a solid catalyst suspended in a slurry. The
catalyst may
preferably include cobalt, ruthenium, or iron on a support of alumina, silica,
titania, zirconia,
or combinations thereof. As the syngas travels through reactor 410, the
reactants (hydrogen
and carbon monoxide) are absorbed into the slurry and diffuse to the catalyst
where they are
converted to gaseous and liquid (wax) products. The gaseous products are
removed from
reactor 410 through outlet 430. The wax products mix with the slurry. An
exemplary reactor
system is described in U.S. Patent Application No. 10/023,258, titled "Slurry
Bed Reactor
Operated in Well-Mixed Gas Flow Regime," (Attorney Docket No. 1856-23900) the
entirety of
which is hereby incorporated by reference herein for all purposes.
A fraction of the particles making up the solid phase of the slurry may have a
size
smaller than the nominal rating of the substrate. In one preferred embodiment,
the solid
catalyst suspended in the slurry has a particle size distribution between 1
and 250 um. In one
preferable slurry, 95 weight percent of the catalyst particles are between 10
and 200 um with
a number average particle size between 20 and 50 um. The solid particles form
between 5
and 25 volume percent of the slurry.
Slurry leaves reactor 410 through outlet 440 and enters degassing unit 480
where
residual gas is removed through outlet 490. The slurry flow into or out of
reactor 410 may be
gravity driven or controlled by a pump. The degassed slurry then enters
separation system
300 through inlet 330. As the slurry flows through slurry chamber 310 a
pressure differential
across filter medium 350 causes a portion of the liquid products contained in
the slurry to
permeate into filtrate chamber 320. The filtrate entering filtrate chamber 320
is substantially
12
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
free of solid catalyst particles and is removed through outlet 380. The
remainder of the
slurry, which now contains approximately 1 to 30% less liquid, is recycled
back into reactor
410 through outlet 340 and inlet 460.
As previously discussed, the flow of filtrate through slurry chamber 310 can
be
regulated to adjust the flow rate of slurry over the filter medium 350. This
flow rate can be
adjusted by opening one or more of valves 390 to increase the flow of slurry
to an individual
slurry chamber, by adjusting the flow through valve 450 or 470 to control the
flow to the
entire filtration system, by adding a supplemental liquid stream (not shown)
to mix with
slurry entering the chamber 310, or by recycling a portion of the filtrate
through a recycle line
395, with the help of a pump (not shown), to mix with slurry entering the
chamber 310. The
supplemental liquid stream preferably would contain compounds compatible with
the overall
process, for example a stream comprising naphtha, diesel range hydrocarbons,
hydrocarbons
such as found in the filtrate stream 380 that will remain liquid at reactor
conditions, or
combinations thereof.
The slurry velocity may also be controlled by the design of the solid/liquid
separation
system 300 and by the slurry circulation loop that circulates slurry to and
from the FT reactor.
The slun-y velocity may be also be varied by means of a slurry pump, not
shown. Other
methods and apparatus for operating and regulating a solid/liquid separation
system are
discussed in concurrently filed Patent Application , titled "Solid/liquid
Separation System for Multiphase Converters," (Attorney Docket No. 1856-21401)
the
entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference herein for all purposes.
According to some embodiments of this invention, the filtration system using a
filter
cake has the benefit of having longer filtration cycle and also results in
recovering a filtrate
13
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
with improved quality. This extended cycle time will reduce the number of
backwashes
and/or blowbacks, which are believed to be detrimental to the lifetime of the
substrate.
When the filtrate flow is below a determined level, it may become necessary to
remove some or all of the cake to reduce or eliminate its thickness by any
known cleaning
methods which uses a reverse flow of fluid (gas, liquid, or combinations) such
as
backwashing or blowback. The Applicants discovered a novel technique for
cleaning of the a
substrate that comprises of stopping the filtrate flow for a short period of
time, preferably
between about 0.5 min to about 120 minutes, more preferably between 1 min and
30 minutes,
and most preferably between 2 min and 15 minutes, while maintaining slurry
flow through
the slurry chamber, and resuming filtrate flow to a higher more desirable
level. It is believed
that some of the cake thickness is removed by stopping the filtrate flow. This
cake erosion,
even if partial, restores a filtration flow within a desirable range of
fluxes.
This technique can be used alternatively or in conjunction with conventional
cleaning
techniques of filters such those listed above. This method does not result in
a surge of solid
content in the filtrate after the surface cleaning time is terminated. The
time necessary for the
intermittent interruption of filtrate flow should last not more than 5% of the
overall filtration
cycle length, preferably not more than 3% of the overall filtration cycle
length. An overall
filtration cycle wash is defined as the period between two cleanings, whether
these techniques
are conventional backwash, blowback, or the cleaning technique disclosed in
this invention.
Also the higher frequency of backwashes leads to poorer filtrate quality over
time due to
relatively high amount of solids particles traversing the substrate every time
a new cake is
being formed, as shown in Figure 5. Similar results can also be achieved by
periodically
increasing the slurry linear velocity for a short period of time without
stopping the filtrate
flow.
14
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Regardless of the general configuration of a solid/liquid separation system
constructed
in accordance with the current invention, it is understood that the specific
design of the
system is dependant on the characteristics of the slurry to be processed. The
parameters of a
separation system that may be varied for a particular slurry composition
include, but are not
S limited to, the solid particle size distribution, the permeability of the
substrate, the nominal
rating or nominal size of the openings in the substrate, the flow rate of
slurry through the
system, the size of the slurry chamber and the filtrate chamber, the pressure
drop across the
filter medium, and the flow rate of filtrate out of the system.
Referring again to Figure 1, for the purpose of discussion only, and by way of
an
example, the operation of solid/liquid separation system 300 will be described
as a
component of Fischer-Tropsch reactor system 400. Reactor system 400 includes
reactor
vessel 410 which has a gas inlet 420, gas outlet 430, slurry inlet 460, and
slurry outlet 440.
Valves 450 and 470, respectively, control the flow of slurry out of and into
vessel 410.
System 400 also includes degassing unit 480, gas outlet 490, and solid/liquid
separation
system 300. System 400 may also optionally include additional separation
systems 305 and
315. Syngas, containing hydrogen and carbon monoxide, is supplied by inlet 420
into reactor
vessel 410, which contains a solid catalyst suspended in a slurry. As the
syngas travels
through reactor 410, the reactants (hydrogen and carbon monoxide) are absorbed
into the
slurry and diffuse to the catalyst where they are converted to gaseous and
liquid (wax)
products. The gaseous products are removed from reactor 410 through outlet
430. The wax
products mixed with solid particles in the slurry need to be separated out.
The feed gases charged to the process of the invention comprise hydrogen, or a
hydrogen source, and carbon monoxide. H2/CO mixtures suitable as a feedstock
for
conversion to hydrocarbons according to the process of this invention can be
obtained from
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
light hydrocarbons such as methane by means of steam reforming, partial
oxidation, or other
processes known in the art. Preferably the hydrogen is provided by free
hydrogen, although
some Fischer-Tropsch catalysts have sufficient water gas shift activity to
convert some carbon
monoxide and water to carbon dioxide and hydrogen for use in the Fischer-
Tropsch process. It
is preferred that the molar ratio of hydrogen to carbon monoxide in the feed
be greater than
0.5:1 (e.g., from about 0.67:1 to 2.5:1).
It is also preferred that when cobalt, nickel, iron, and/or ruthenium
catalysts are used,
the feed gas stream contains hydrogen and carbon monoxide in a molar ratio of
about 1.4:1 to
2.3:1. The feed gas may also contain other gases, known as inerts, that are
considered inert at
reaction conditions. Examples of inerts are nitrogen and light gaseous
hydrocarbons, like
methane. The feed gas stream should contain a low or no concentration of
compounds or
elements that have a deleterious effect on the catalyst, such as poisons. For
example, the feed
gas may need to be pretreated to ensure that it contains low concentrations of
sulfur or nitrogen
compounds such as hydrogen sulfide, hydrogen cyanide, ammonia and carbonyl
sulfides.
The catalyst used in the Fischer-Tropsch reactor system 400 comprises any
suitable
supported or precipitated catalyst active in the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis,
such as a catalytically
active metal from Groups 8, 9, and 10 of the Periodic Table of the Elements,
New Notation, as
found in, for example, the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 82°d
Edition, 2001-2002,
and used throughout this specification as the reference for all element group
numbers. The
catalyst preferably contains cobalt, nickel, iron or ruthenium. For cobalt,
the catalyst preferably
contains about 5 to 75 wt% cobalt and more preferably from about 10 to about
60 wt% cobalt.
For iron, the catalyst preferably contains about 10 to 95 wt% iron, and more
preferably from
about 20 to about 85 wt% iron. """""""""""""""'For ruthenium, the catalyst
preferably
16
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
contains about 0.5 to 10 wt% ruthenium and more preferably from about 1 to
about 6 wt%
ruthenium.
The catalyst may contain additionally one or more promoters comprising a metal
selected from Group 1-17. A promoter metal is preferably selected from Group 1
(Li, K), 7
(Re), 8 (Ru, Os), 9 (Co, Rh, Ir), 10 (Ni, Pd, Pt), 11 (Cu, Ag), and 13 (B,
Al). If a catalyst
support is used, the support preferably comprises unmodified, stabilized or
modified alumina,
silica, titanic, zirconia, or combinations thereof. More preferably the
catalyst support comprises
alumina or silica-alumina. Cobalt catalysts are most preferred as they have a
high activity and
selectivity for the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis. A cobalt catalyst using
stabilized or modified
alumina is highly preferred when it is stabilized by using structural
promoters and/or when it is
derived from Boehmite or a boehmitic support. The feed gas is contacted with
the catalyst in a
reaction zone. Mechanical arrangements of conventional design may be employed
as the
reaction zone including, for example, fluidized bed, slurry bubble columns or
ebulliating bed
reactors, among others. Accordingly, the preferred. size and physical form of
the catalyst
particles may vary depending on the reactor in which they are to be used.
The Fischer-Tropsch process is typically run in a continuous mode. In this
mode, the
gas hourly space velocity through the reaction zone typically may range from
about 50 to about
10,000 hr ~ , preferably from about 300 hr-~ to about 2,000 hr ~. The gas
hourly space velocity
is defined as the volume of reactants per hour per reaction zone volume. The
volume of
reactant gases is at a standard pressure of 101 kPa, and standard temperature
of 0°C . The
reaction zone volume is defined by the portion of the reaction vessel volume
where reaction
takes place and which is occupied by a gaseous phase comprising reactants,
products and/or
"inerts"; a liquid phase comprising liquid/wax products and/or other liquids;
and a solid phase
comprising catalyst. The reaction zone temperature is typically in the range
from about 160°C
17
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
to about 300°C. Preferably, the reaction zone is operated at conversion
promoting conditions at
temperatures from about 190°C to about 260°C. The reaction zone
pressure is typically in the
range of about 80 psia (552 kPa) to about 1000 psia (6895 kPa), more
preferably from 80 psia
(552 kPa) to about 600 psia (4137 kPa), and still more preferably, from about
140 psia (965
kPa) to about 500 psia (3447 kPa).
A filtration system to support a commercial Fischer-Tropsch reactor may
preferably
comprise a plurality of individual filtration assemblies constructed in
accordance with the
described embodiments. The flow of slurry from the reactor can then be divided
among the
plurality of filtration assemblies so that the quality of the slurry in the
reactor can be
continuously maintained without shut down of the system. Having a plurality of
filtration
assemblies allows individual assemblies to be taken off-line periodically so
that the substrate
for each shut-down filtration assembly can be cleaned or replaced as required.
The substrate
used in the above described embodiments is preferably cleaned by filling the
inner conduit
with a liquid or gas that is at a higher pressure than the slurry, therefore
forcing solid particles
out of the substrate and collapsing the cake that might have grown too thick
during an
extended period of operation. Thus, a new cycle can be started. It should be
noted that
different types of substrates could be used if necessary. It should also be
understood that
each individual filter housing may have its own slurry flow rate control
system, or a
combination of filter housings could share one slurry flow rate control
system. At times a
chemical or ultrasonic cleaning of the substrate may be needed.
Examples
Experiments were conducted using the laboratory setup 500 described in Figure
2. A
slurry was formed in a slurry mixing tank 510. The slurry was a mixture of
model wax (n-
decane) and solid particles of a cobalt-based catalyst. The cobalt-based
catalyst is supported on
18
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
an alumina material and is active in the Fischer-Tropsch reaction. The solid
concentration in the
slurry was approximately 23-25% by weight (or about 10% by volume). The
catalyst particle
size when the catalyst was fresh and first loaded in the slurry mixing tank
510, was in the range
of 20 to 150 microns An agitator (not shown) placed inside slurry mixing tank
510 was used to
maintain the solids suspended in the slurry. A slurry pump 520 sent a portion
of the slurry from
slurry mixing tank 510 either back to the slurry mixing tank 510 or to a
filtration housing 540.
A valve (not shown) was used to direct the slurry flow to the appropriate
location. The filtration
housing 540 comprises a substrate. The substrate was a 1" outer diameter, 20
inch long, porous
metal membrane of the sintered woven wire-mesh or sintered powder metal type
with average
openings, i.e. a nominal rating, of approximately 20 microns. The substrate
was placed
concentrically in the filter housing made from a pipe. The filtrate and the
slurry exiting the
filtration housing 540 were recycled to slurry mixing tank 510. At times all
of the filtrate
coming from the filtration housing 540 was routed to storage tank 550 which
could be used for
backwashing purpose. A valve (not shown) was used to direct the filtrate flow
to either to the
slurry mixing tank 510 or to storage tank 550. Flow meters such as those
represented by labels
560 and 570 were used to measure the slurry and filtrate flow rates
respectively. The
experiments were performed at a room temperature of approximately 70°F
(ca. 21°C). Constant
trans-membrane differential pressure (dP) of 2 and 3 psi were used.
In the example of Fig. 3 the slurry flow rate was maintained at 15.5 gpm for a
corresponding slurry linear velocity of 0.8 fbs. The substrate was a porous
metal membrane
with an average opening or nominal rating of approximately 20 microns placed
in a 3" nominal
diameter housing. The solid content of the slurry was 23.4 % by weight.
Results on filtrate flow
is shown in Figure 3. Constant traps-membrane differential pressure (dP) of 2
psi was used.
19
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Figure 3 shows the filtrate flow variation with run time. Initially, the
filtrate flux was
high because the filter cake was starting to form. The flux decreased as the
cake thickness
increased until when the shear stress due to the flowing slurry, and acting at
the cake-slurry
interface, balanced the forces) holding the catalyst particles onto the cake.
A cake of uniform
thickness was thus formed. Compaction of cake, rearrangement of cake particles
and fines
inclusion accounted for the gradual filtrate flow decline before attaining a
steady value. The
steady value of the filtrate flow, or the steady state flow, was virtually
maintained for the
remaining duration of run (over 9 hrs). Correspondingly, the filtrate quality
of less than lOppm
of solids was maintained over this period. The filtrates at the initial period
of run contained
higher ppm of solids. This confirmed that the filter cake, once formed and
steady, performed
the filtration and resulted in high filtrate quality. Filtrate solids content
of greater than 20 ppm
by weight solids was measured during the cake formation stage Actually, the
solid content in
the filtrate was as high as 150 ppm by weight in some runs during the initial
cake forming
period and when the cake was lost. The steady state filtration flux for this
demonstration runs
ranged from 0.5 to 1.0 gpm/ft2.
Fig. 4 shows the change in filtrate flow by changing the slurry linear
velocity. This is in
agreement with the principles of the invention disclosed in our concurrently
filed Patent
Application , titled "Solid/liquid Separation System for Multiphase
Converters," (Attorney Docket No. 1856-21401), which has been incorporated by
reference
herein. This principle can also be applied to increase the time in between
backwashing
operations. By periodically increasing the linear velocity of the slurry for
short periods of time,
the maximum cake thickness can be controlled and therefore maintaining a
higher average
filtration flux (filtrate flow rate)during the lenght of the filtration cycle
(during the time in
between backwashing operations).
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Figure 5 similarly to example in Fig. 3, shows that initially, the filtrate
flow was high
and as the filter cake begun to build up and its thickness increased, the
filtrate flow decreased.
The solids content of the filtrate at the very beginning of the filtration
time was as high as 644
ppm by weight indicating the substrate was allowing some of the particles to
pass through. As
the cake started to build up, the filtrate quality rapidly improved after a
few minutes as the
solids content dropped to 128 ppm after 3 minutes and 39 ppm after 12 minutes,
to finally
stabilize below 10 ppm.
Figure 5 also illustrates quite well how the new cleaning method can be used
during
operation of the cake filtration. When the filtrate flow dropped below 1.3
LJmin, the filtration
flow was stopped for 5 minutes while the slurry flow was maintained at 19 gpm.
As a result of
the filtration interruption, the pressure differential dropped (not shown in
Figure 6) between the
filter chamber and the filtrate chamber thereby resulting in loosening the
cake as there is less or
no force to retain its compaction. Once the filtration was resumed, the
filtration flow was
increased to 2.05 L/min, demonstrating that some of the cake was indeed
removed. It should be
observed that since the filtrate flow after interruption of filtration did not
return to the initial
filtrate flow of about 3.4 LJmin obtained at time 0, the cake was not entirely
removed. It should
be noted that the stability of the filtration flux (filtrate flow arte) after
the interruption in
filtration improved as compared to the period just before the interruption.
Since the cake is not
entirely removed, the solid content of the filtrate was still below 10 ppm by
weight. This shows
that the method of controlling the cake presented in this invention achieves
an increased flux
and flux stability without degrading the filter quality at the start of the
new cycle.
Cake filtration performance may also be influenced by controlling the
particles used to
construct the cake. The size of the particles forming the filter cake have an
effect both on the
quality, i.e. ppm solids, and the quantity, i.e. flux, of the filtrate.
Filtrate flux can be maximized
21
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
by using larger particles to form at least the initial layers of the cake.
When a cake is formed
by relatively large diameter particles, the cake, interstitial volumes are
maintained between the
particles. In a cake formed by a mixture of large and small particles will
tend to be more
densely packed, with the smaller particles filling the interstitial volumes
between the larger
particles. It is through these interstitial volumes that the filtrate must
pass. Thus, the larger
interstitial volumes in a cake formed primarily from larger particles will
offer a greater
permeability than a cake formed from a mixture of both large and small
particles.
Figure 6 shows one system for building a filter cake formed primarily of
larger
particles. Solid/liquid separation system 800 includes a slurry inlet 810 and
slurry outlets 826
and 818. The slurry fed to system 800 through inlet 810 is withdrawn from a
Fischer-Tropsch
reactor (not shown) through line 808 to supply slurry to a settler 820, which
feeds slurry to a
filtration system 830. Valve 809 can be used to modify the slurry flow rate
fed to settler 820.
Filtration system 830 can be fed with slurry coming from the bottom of the
settler through
outlet 836 or with slurry from the FT reactor through line 812 or a
combination of both. Settler
820 includes a plurality of outlets 822, 824, 826 each adapted to draw slurry
from a different
vertical location in settler 820. The closer the outlet is to the bottom of
settler 820, the higher
the concentration of large catalyst particles. Thus, in Figure 6, outlet 822
has the smallest
concentration of large catalyst particles and outlet 826 has the highest
concentration of large
particles. The streams from outlets 822 and 824 contain much less amount of
solids that slurry
streams in 810, 811, 818, 826 and 834. Also, the solids in 822 and 824 are of
a smaller size than
the solids in the other streams. The streams 822 and 824 can be directed
either back to the FT
reactor or to a filtration system that may be called also polishing filters,
not shown, which
eliminates or minimizes the solids content of the these streams before these
streams are used in
another areas of the plant. The flow from each outlet 822, 824, and 826 can be
controlled by
valves 823, 825, and 827.
22
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
Filter housing 830 included slurry inlets 812 and 832, slurry outlet 834,
filter medium
840, and filtrate outlet 836. Filter medium 840 surrounds a filtrate chamber
850 and comprises
a substrate 842 onto which a filter cake 844 is formed. The buildup of filter
cake 844 on
substrate 842 can be regulated by controlling the velocity of the slurry
flowing through housing
830 by any of the methods previously discussed. In operation, a pressure
differential is
maintained across filter medium 840, drawing a portion of the liquid component
of the slurry
into the filtrate chamber 850 while the solid portion of the slurry is
separated by the filter
medium 840 and returned to the reactor through slurry outlet 834.
The operation of system 800 may include initiating operation of the filtration
system
830 with a slurry stream 828 having a high concentration of large diameter
particles, such as
from outlet 826. Once a filter cake 844 has been formed on substrate 842, the
filtration system
can be fed with at least a portion of the slurry from the FT reactor through
inlet 812. After a
certain period of time it may be necessary to partially remove the filter cake
844, which can be
done by any of the methods disclosed in this invention. Also, after certain
time the filtrate flow
rate through outlet 836 may reach a pre-determined minimum at which point the
filter cake
needs to be completely removed and then a new cycle of operation for system
800 is started by
reforming the cake with slurry stream 828 as explained above.
The embodiments and examples set forth herein are merely illustrative and do
not
limit the scope of the invention or the details therein. It will be
appreciated that many other
modifications and improvements to the disclosure herein may be made without
departing
from the scope of the invention or the inventive concepts herein disclosed.
Because many
varying and different embodiments may be made within the scope of the
inventive concept
herein taught, including equivalent structures or materials hereafter thought
of, and because
many modifications may be made in the embodiments herein detailed in
accordance with the
23
CA 02482062 2004-10-13
WO 03/089103 PCT/US03/11662
descriptive requirements of the law, it is to be understood that the details
herein are to be
interpreted as illustrative and not in a limiting sense.
24
