Note : Les descriptions sont présentées dans la langue officielle dans laquelle elles ont été soumises.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 1 -
DESCRIPTION
TITLE
Method for the breakdown of lignin
TECHNICAL FIELD
The present invention relates to the controlled
conversion of lignin to chemicals.
STATE OF THE ART
Alternative processes for producing chemical from bio-
mass are gaining increasing significance as fossil raw
materials become more scarce.
For example, processes which obtain fuels from the
cellulose or hemicellulose component of plants have
been developed. Renewable vegetable raw materials
comprise, as well as cellulose and hemicellulose, also
lignin, lignin being the second most common organic
substance on earth after cellulose.
Lignin is a main constituent of plants, with the func-
tion of imparting stiffness to the cell structure. The
lignin content may vary from plant to plant. The chemi-
cal structure of lignin likewise has plant-specific
differences. For instance, the lignin macromolecule,
according to the plant type, is composed of different
ratios of the coniferyl alcohol, sinapyl alcohol and
cumaryl alcohol monomers, the proportion of coniferyl
alcohol being dominant in many cases (especially in the
case of softwoods). Moreover, there exist numerous
processes for removing the lignin from the other cell
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 2 -
wall constituents, some of which considerably modify
the chemical structure of the natural lignin.
While various processes for producing chemicals from
cellulose have reached the large industrial scale,
there are currently still barely any economically
viable means of using the lignin component of biomass
as a starting material for producing chemicals. In
papermaking, large amounts of lignin are obtained as a
by-product or waste product. Only 1-2% of the about 50
million tonnes of lignin obtained annually in paper-
making are further processed commercially.
The use of lignin is limited principally to relatively
inexpensive dispersants and binders. Vanillin is the
only lignin-based phenolic product which is produced
commercially. A portion of global vanillin production
(12 000 tonnes/year) is achieved by oxidative
degradation of lignosulfonic acids.
The literature describes numerous methods of using
lignin as a raw material. A frequently used approach is
the gasification of biomass at high temperatures (800-
1000 C) with air and/or steam to give synthesis gas
(CO, H2, COz and CH4) . In further stages, various
commodity chemicals, such as methanol, ether, formic
acid and higher molecular weight hydrocarbons (by means
of Fischer-Tropsch), can be prepared from this synthe-
sis gas.
In these methods, the complex chemical structure origi-
nally present is completely lost. This decomposition
and recombination strategy requires a very large amount
of energy and produces undesired by-products. In addi-
tion, this process can produce only relatively simple,
cheap molecules. For economic viability, very large
conversions are therefore necessary. Alternatively,
various methods (for example oxidative and nonoxidative
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 3 -
hydrolysis, hydrogenolysis, pyrolysis) are known for
direct preparation of monomeric or low molecular weight
chemicals. While these methods are suitable for
separating lignin into smaller fractions, no method is
selective enough to produce a single product in high
yield.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The inventive method proposed here differs signifi-
cantly in terms of concept from approaches to date.
The attempts described in the literature to convert
lignin to monomeric chemicals are limited to purely
physical methods (high temperature and pressure),
simple acid- or base-catalyzed hydrolysis or biotechno-
logy.
On closer inspection of the chemistry, it becomes clear
that these relatively simple methods are not suitable
for achieving a high yield of monomeric chemicals.
The reason for this lies in the fact that the desired
products in the conversion of the lignin are degrada-
tion products. These degradation products cannot be
obtained in large amounts by means of simple methods,
owing to further reactions.
The invention takes account of the task of maximizing
the yield of degradation products, which is complex
from a chemical point of view, in two ways. Firstly,
the conversion of lignin is performed in the presence
of a catalytic system.
This catalytic system comprises what are known as poly-
oxometalates, which enables the selective scission of
bonds even at relatively low temperatures.
Secondly, what are known as free-radical scavengers are
= CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 4 -
added to the reaction mixture. These prevent
repolymerization reactions or combination reactions of
lignin fragments, and stabilize the desired target
products.
A benchmark which can be employed for the invention
presented here is the alkaline oxidation of lignin. The
conversion of 10 g of a hardwood lignin (steam
digestion) under 1.4 MPa oxygen at 170 C using a
Cu(II)/Fe(III) catalyst results in 4.7% by weight of
vanillin and 9.5% by weight of syringaldehyde. In a
very similar study on hardwood lignin, the yield of
aldehydes (vanillin and syringaldehyde) was 15% by
weight.
Various polyoxometalates have already been used for
delignification and patented, as described, for
example, in US 5,302,248, US 5,552,019 or WO 95/26438.
In these methods, the unbleached fibrous substance is
treated in a first process step with an aqueous
polyoxometalate solution (e.g.: Na7AlVW11O40) under an
inert atmosphere, the lignin being converted at the end
to carbon dioxide and water.
These processes pursue exclusively the aim of freeing
cellulose from undesired lignin. The lignin should be
converted fully to COz and H20, without destroying the
cellulose. The possibility of directly obtaining
degradation products or chemicals by treatment with
polyoxometalates was not considered.
The aim of the invention is thus to directly convert
lignin to chemicals by means of polyoxometalates. In
this invention, as well as polyoxometalates, what are
known as free-radical scavengers can be used.
The terms "lignin" and "polyoxometalates" each
encompass whole classes of substances and are therefore
= CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 5 -
presented briefly hereinafter.
There is also a definition of how the terms "free-
radical scavenger" and "chemicals" should be understood
in the context of this document.
Lignin:
It is possible by the method presented in this inven-
tion to obtain chemicals from all lignin types
irrespective or origin and pretreatment. It is also
possible to undertake a controlled pretreatment of the
lignin used in order, for example, to modify the
solubility in organic or inorganic solvent. It is also
possible to use an already partly decomposed lignin. It
is also possible to use lignin-containing biomass, for
example wood, without preceding removal of the lignin
content of the biomass.
Polyoxometalates:
Polyoxometalates form part of the compound class of the
metal-oxygen cluster anions. Polyoxometalates are
notable, among other features, for their usually simple
synthesis, their structural modifiability and their
specific redox behavior. Key properties which are
important for many reaction systems, for example
solubility behavior in organic/inorganic media, redox
potential and pH, can be adjusted by controlled synthe-
sis. The polyoxometalates are synthesized here usually
in one stage by heating an acidic aqueous solution
which comprises all constituents in the desired
stoichiometric ratio. The polyoxometalate, or the poly-
oxometalate mixture, thus arises from the amounts of
the components used. It thus also becomes clear that
there is a great variety of polyoxometalates. In the
literature, the following two terms have become
established for structurally different polyoxometa-
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
6 -
lates: "isopolyanions" and "heteropolyanions". These
anions are represented by the following general
empirical formula:
[MmOY] p- isopolyanions
[XXMmOY] 4 (X 0 m) heteropolyanions
The "M" part is termed addenda atom, and the "X" part
is referred to as heteroatom. In this document, the
term "polyoxometalates" includes both anion types:
isopoly- and heteropolyanions.
An important subgroup within the polyoxometalates is
that of the heteropolyacids. Heteropolyacids are very
strong acids which are composed of heteropolyanions
with protons as countercations. In the case that all
countercations consist of other elements, reference is
also made to heteropolysalts. A series of these poly-
oxometalates have been found to be of particular
interest for catalysis.
The most common addenda atoms ("M") are molybdenum or
tungsten; less common are vanadium or niobium, or
mixtures of these elements in the highest oxidation
states (d , d') . Useful heteroatoms ("X") include essen-
tially all elements in the periodic table. The elements
PS+r Si9+, AsS+, Ge4+, B3+ are the most frequently
mentioned in connection with polyoxometalates used
catalytically.
Compared to the very large number of polyoxometalates,
currently only few polyoxometalates are being used as
catalysts, these being restricted principally to the
class of the Keggin anions and the derived structures
thereof. It is therefore usually sufficient to use a
very simplified nomenclature. This treats polyoxo-
metalates as quasi-coordinated complexes. If a hetero-
atom is present, it is considered as the central atom
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 7 -
of the complex, which is surrounded by the addenda
parts as ligands. In the empirical formula of the
heteropolyanions, the heteroatoms precede the addenda
atoms, and the countercations precede the heteroatoms.
The heteropolyanion is placed between square brackets
and is thus separated from the countercations.
This should be clarified in the following examples:
[SiW12O40] 4- 12-tungstosilicate
H3 [PMo12O40] 12-phosphomolybdic acid
Sometimes, in the simplified representation, the
countercations, the charge of the polyanion and even
the oxygen atoms are not stated explicitly.
Na6[PzMo18O62] can thus be represented as [P2Mo18O62] or
even PZMo18.
Every polyoxometalate (isopoly- and heteropolyanions)
and acids, salts and partial salts thereof, can be used
for this invention irrespective of the preparation
process. It is also possible to use mixtures of
different polyoxometalates. In fact, depending on the
pH, many species may be present in solution in
equilibrium alongside one another, and a compound
isolated in crystalline form need not necessarily even
be the main component.
The polyoxometalates used can preferably be oxidized
and reduced reversibly, which is the case for all poly-
oxometalates of the Keggin and Wells/Dawson structures.
A preferred class of polyoxometalates is that of
components of the [Y3-18] n+ [X1-4M1-36010-60] n form where each
"X" is selectable freely from the elements of the
periodic table and/or may also be a molecular portion
with four or fewer atoms. "M" is freely selectable from
the group of the metals, "Y" represents countercations
and "n" is an integer. A further preferred class is
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 8 -
that of polyoxometalates of the [Y3-18] "+ [M1-36010-60] n form
where "Y", "M" and "n" are each as defined above.
In the preferred embodiments, each "X" is selected
freely from the group of the elements P, Si, As, Ge, B,
Al, Co, S, Fe. Each "M" is preferably selected freely
from the following group: Mo, W, V, Ti, Co, Cu, Zn, Fe,
Ni, Mn, Cr, lanthanides, Ce, Al, Ga, In, Tl. The
countercations "Y" are preferably selected freely from
the group of H, Zn, Co, Cu, Bi, Na, Li, K, Rb, Cs, Ba,
Mg, Sr, ammonium, C1-1z-alkylammonium and C1-12-
alkylamine.
In a particularly preferred embodiment, polyoxo-
metalates of the [Y] n+ [XM12040] "- form are used, where the
same definitions for "Y", "X", "M" and "n" as above
apply. The most preferred polyoxometalates are of the
[Y] n+ [XM12040] n- form where "Y" and "n" are each as
defined above, "X" is Si, P, Ge or As, and each "M" is
selected freely from Mo, V and W.
In a further preferred embodiment, polyoxometalates
according to the definitions specified above which have
been applied to a suitable support material are used.
The application of a polyoxometalate to a support
material, for example Si02, A1203 and zeolites, and the
use thereof as a heterogeneous catalyst for, for
example, oxidations with oxygen, have already been
described in the literature.
With regard to possible polyoxometalates, reference is
made to the systems as described in Hill (1998)
Chemical Reviews 98: 1-389; Pope (1983) Heteropoly and
Isopoly Oxometalates, Springer, Berlin and Okuhara et
al. (2001) Applied Catalysis A: General 222: 63-77, the
disclosure content of which is incorporated explicitly
in this regard.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 9 -
For the sake of simplicity, the abbreviation "POM" is
used hereinafter for polyoxometalates according to the
definitions specified above.
Free-radical scavenger:
In a preferred embodiment of the invention, one or more
components are used as free-radical scavengers.
In the context of this invention, free-radical
scavengers serve to scavenge the free radicals formed
during the degradation of lignin and hence to reduce
repolymerization reactions. More particularly, this
should increase the yield of desired chemicals.
Useful free-radical scavengers are generally all
components which, under the given conditions, form
radicals in one or more steps or are already present as
free radicals.
The mode of function of the free-radical scavenger is
illustrated in the following illustrative and incom-
plete reaction scheme. The mechanisms proposed here
reflect the present state of knowledge and should not
be interpreted as a restriction of the invention.
Considering, for example, two free radicals R. and R.
which form in the cleavage of lignin and hence consti-
tute lignin fragments, it is then possible that the
coupling of the lignin fragments to one another leads
to the formation of stable bonds and hence has a
counterproductive effect to the desired cleavage of
lignin fragments (equation 1) . In the case of addition
of free-radical scavengers which form S. radicals or
are already present as free radicals, it is possible
that the lignin fragments R. and R'= are converted to
the coupling products R-S and R'-S (equations 2 and 3).
It is thus possible to reduce the repolymerization of
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 10 -
lignin fragments by controlled coupling with S.
radicals:
R. + R. --> R-R' (1)
Re + S. ~ R-S ( 2 )
R. + S. ~ R'-S (3)
It is possible, for example, to use free-radical
scavengers which are already present as free radicals
in the S. form. An example is TEMPO (2,2,6,6-
tetramethylpiperidine 1-oxyl), which is used, for
example, as a free-radical scavenger in living free-
radical polymerization.
It is also possible to use free-radical scavengers
which can form free radicals through homolytic scission
of a covalent bond (equation 4) . From a thermodynamic
point of view, in the selection of the free-radical
scavenger, a relatively low bond energy of the S-S'
bond compared to the bonding energies of the possible
coupling products R-S, R'-S, R-S' and R'-S' is prefer-
able. Examples are dimethyl ether, diethyl ether,
peroxides.
S-S' -> S. + S. (4)
It is also possible to use free-radical scavengers
which form free radicals in a plurality of steps.
Especially in conjunction with catalysts, a plurality
of steps may form a free radical S=. For example, acid-
catalyzed condensation of methanol to dimethyl ether in
the presence of POM as an acid catalyst with subsequent
homolytic scission of the ether bond can lead to the
CH3O9 and CH3= radicals.
The free-radical scavenger can firstly serve as a
hydrogen donor and secondly prevent the repolymeriza-
tion of the lignin fragments. Consequently components
of the general form S-H are possible, where H repre-
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 11 -
sents a hydrogen atom available for reaction and S
denotes the rest of the free-radical scavenger, i.e.
minus the hydrogen atom in question. The free-radical
scavenger may possess a plurality of accessible
hydrogen atoms.
The mode of function of the free-radical scavenger is
illustrated in the illustrative second reaction scheme
which follows. By way of example, free radicals which
have formed through cleavage of an ether bond of lignin
(equation 5) are now considered, where R again repre-
sents lignin fragments.
The reaction scheme which follows serves again merely
to illustrate a possible free-radical scavenger mecha-
nism. The free-radical scavenger need not be activated
in one step, nor by pure hydrogen abstraction. In fact,
free radicals, in particular in the presence of POMs
and/or oxygen, can take part in a variety of reactions.
For example, free radicals of the R. (or S=) form, in
the presence of oxygen, form free radicals of the R0O=
(or SOO=) form. Owing to the sometimes very strong
tendency of POMs to take up electrons (and protons),
there may additionally be interaction of POM with free-
radical scavengers. It should be noted at this point
that phenolic degradation products of lignin are them-
selves free-radical scavengers.
R-O-R -> RO= + R. (5)
RO= + S-H -~ ROH + S= (6)
R= + S-H -~ RH + S= (7)
S= + S= ~ S-S ( 8 )
S. + R. -~ S-R (9)
S= + R0o ~ R-O-S (10)
Abstraction of a hydrogen atom from the free-radical
scavenger can provide the desired degradation products
of lignin ROH and RH (equations 6 and 7) . In addition,
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 12 -
it is also possible that the rest of the free-radical
scavenger (i.e. minus a hydrogen atom) is integrated
into the product, thus reducing free-radical repoly-
merization reactions (equations 9 and 10).
In principle, useful free-radical scavengers include,
for example, molecules which can release hydrogen atoms
under the given conditions. Therefore, when the
chemical structure is considered, H2 is the simplest
free-radical scavenger. Alcohols and acids are also
possible.
It is also possible, as explained above, to use, as
free-radical scavengers, substances which form free
radicals under the given conditions without hydrogen
abstraction, for example peroxides, including hydrogen
peroxide and the like.
Chemicals:
The structure of lignin includes a multitude of usually
phenolic compounds which are of interest for industry.
The aim of this invention is to obtain these phenolic
compounds directly from lignin in an amount of economic
interest.
This invention is clearly delimited from other methods
in that the chemicals produced here are not recombined
from synthesis gas. Moreover, in this invention, mole-
cules with a minimum molecular weight of MWmin =
78 g/mol are produced.
In a preferred embodiment, molecules which include at
least one benzene ring in their structure are produced.
In a further preferred embodiment, molecules which have
at least one benzene ring and not more than three
benzene rings in their structure are produced. Most
preferable is an embodiment in which molecules which
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 13 -
contain only one benzene ring in their structure are
produced. In the abovementioned preferred embodiments,
the benzene ring is used as the base skeleton. In this
case, the functional groups and any bonds between
benzene rings can be selected as desired. More particu-
larly, the free-radical scavengers which may be used
can be integrated into the structure of the chemicals
produced. It is possible to obtain a mixture of a
plurality of chemicals by the method explained in this
invention.
On embodiment envisages converting lignin by means of
POM in a suitable reactor. To this end, lignin and POM
are dissolved or suspended in a suitable liquid medium.
The mixture is brought for a sufficiently long time to
conditions which drive the degradation of lignin. The
temperature here may be between 0 C and 500 C, but
preferably between 25 C and 300 C. Lignin can be
degraded here under inert gas, oxygen-containing,
ozone-containing or hydrogen-containing gas, at
pressures up to 300 bar. The pH may be, or be set,
within the range of 0-10. The degradation of the lignin
should form products from the above-defined group of
chemicals. The products are thus obtained here in the
region between complete decomposition of the lignin and
virtually unchanged lignin. This approach constitutes a
new optimization task with regard to suitable POM
systems, temperatures, reaction times, etc.
The difficult task of scavenging degradation products
can be achieved by methods including the use of free-
radical scavengers.
One embodiment thus envisages converting lignin by
means of POM in the presence of free-radical scaven-
gers. The procedure here is analogous to the first
embodiment. The essential difference is that a free-
radical scavenger is added to the reaction mixture at a
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 14 -
suitable time. The free-radical scavenger may be
present as a solid, liquid or gas. Useful free-radical
scavengers generally include all components which,
under the given conditions, form free radicals in one
or more steps or are already present as free radicals.
The free-radical scavengers used may, for example, be
substances which can release one or more hydrogen atoms
under the conditions used. It is a special feature that
POMs can promote the activation of free-radical
scavengers (or the formation of free radicals) owing to
their usually strong electron (and proton) affinity. It
is also possible to use stable radicals, for example
nitroxyl radicals, as free-radical scavengers. It is
also possible to use free-radical formers, for example
dibenzoyl peroxide from the group of the peroxides, as
free-radical scavengers.
A further embodiment envisages converting lignin by
means of P0M in the presence of two liquid phases. The
procedure here is analogous to the first embodiment.
The essential difference is that two only partly
miscible or immiscible liquid phases are in contact
with one another during the degradation of lignin.
Owing to different solubilities of POM, lignin and
lignin-based degradation products in the selected
liquid phases, there may be a partial or complete
separation of the lignin, P0M and lignin-based
degradation product components. It is, for example,
possible to select a system with two liquid phases,
wherein lignin and P0M are dissolved or suspended
principally in the first liquid phase (e.g. water) and
the second liquid phase offers a higher solubility for
degradation products of lignin (e.g. chloroform). It is
thus possible to remove the desired degradation
products of lignin from the reaction medium before they
react further in further reactions. It is consequently
possible, through suitable selection of two liquid
phases, to increase the yield of products compared to a
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 15 -
system with only one liquid phase.
A further embodiment thus envisages converting lignin
by means of POM in the presence of free-radical
scavengers and two liquid phases.
A further embodiment envisages using a metallic
catalyst in conjunction with one of the abovementioned
embodiments. Combinations of metallic catalysts,
usually palladium, with polyoxometalates have already
been studied in a series of oxidations and reductions.
An additional metallic catalyst enables the degradation
of lignin at lower temperatures and has a positive
effect on the selectivity with regard to the target
products. It is likewise the case that the yield of
desired products can be enhanced using an additional
metallic catalyst. It is possible to use a metallic
catalyst in combination with polyoxometalates for very
substantially complete oxidation of undesired degrada-
tion products of lignin in the course of the workup.
To implement the invention in a processing plant, it
is, for example, possible to perform the operations
described below. The following scheme serves merely to
illustrate possible operations and does not make any
claim to completeness.
= The conversion of lignin according to the above-
mentioned embodiments (reaction stage).
= Removal of the products from the reaction medium
(for example by extraction).
= Workup of the products (separation of the product
mixture).
= Removal of the free-radical scavenger (for example
by distillation).
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 16 -
= Recycling of the free-radical scavenger.
= Oxidation of lignin fragments which have not been
converted to target products by means of oxygen to
give carbon dioxide and water.
= Use of the lignin fragments or lignin which
has/have not been converted to target products to
generate energy (for example thermal energy from
oxidation).
= Reoxidation or regeneration of POMs (generally
simultaneous with oxidation of lignin fragments).
= Recycling of the POM to the reaction stage.
= Solids discharge at a sensible point (for example
by filtration).
= Addition of solvents at a sensible point.
= Discharge of solvents at a sensible point.
It is possible to perform the removal of the products
simultaneously to the conversion of lignin, for example
by extraction in one operation (reactive extraction).
In summary, the core of the invention thus consists,
inter alia, in providing a process for directly
preparing molecules with a minimum molecular weight of
78 g/mol by the degradation of lignin, lignin
derivatives, lignin fragments and/or lignin-containing
substances or mixtures in the presence of at least one
polyoxometalate in a liquid medium.
In this process, preference is given to using a free-
radical scavenger at least at times during the
degradation, said free-radical scavenger preferably
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 17 -
being a system or a mixture of systems which provides
free radicals, for example atomic hydrogen, and/or
which prevents or at least hinders the repolymerization
or combination reactions of lignin fragments, said
free-radical scavenger being usable in gaseous form,
liquid form and/or as a solid, and said free-radical
scavenger especially preferably being selected from:
molecular hydrogen, a peroxide, for example hydrogen
peroxide or dibenzoyl peroxide, an alcohol, for example
methanol and/or ethanol, a stabilized free radical, for
example a nitroxyl radical, an organic acid, for
example ascorbic acid, a phenol, for example
butylhydroxytoluene, an ether, for example dimethyl
ether, an ester, for example ethyl acetate, an
anhydride, for example acetic anhydride, or mixtures of
such systems.
A second, liquid phase can be added to the mixture,
said second liquid phase preferably having a
significantly different polarity than the first medium.
It is also additionally possible to use a metallic
catalyst, especially from the group of the transition
element-containing catalysts, preferably from the group
of those containing group VIIIB metals and/or group IB
metals, it being possible for said catalyst to be bound
on and/or in a preferably porous substrate.
The reaction can be performed under an inert gas, under
an oxygen-containing gas phase, under a hydrogen-
containing gas phase or under an ozone-containing gas
phase, in the pressure range of 0-300 bar, preferably
at more than 5 bar.
The polyoxometalate is preferably H3PMo12O90r the liquid
medium is water when an alcoholic free-radical scaven-
ger is used, preferably selected from methanol and/or
ethanol, the volume ratio of water to alcoholic free-
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 18 -
radical scavenger especially preferably being in the
range from 1:10 to 10:1, and the pressure preferably
being more than 2 bar.
It is generally advantageous when the liquid medium is
water, optionally in combination with an alcohol.
Between 2-200 g of polyoxometalates can be used per
100 ml of liquid medium, especially preferably between
8-12 g. Thus, preference is given to using concentra-
tions in the range from 0.01 mol/1 to 1 mol/l. Typi-
cally, the degradation of the lignin to the molecules
is followed by a removal of the molecules from the
reaction medium, especially preferably by extraction
and/or distillation.
Further preferred embodiments are described in the
dependent claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
The invention will be illustrated in detail hereinafter
with reference to working examples in combination with
the figure. Fig. 1 shows chemicals from the degradation
of lignin by means of POM and free-radical scavengers.
WAYS OF PERFORMING THE INVENTION
The inventive method for producing chemicals from
lignin by means of POM and free-radical scavengers is
illustrated hereinafter with reference to representa-
tive experiments.
More particularly, the effectiveness of the POMs and
free-radical scavengers is demonstrated.
Compared to a prior art method, the inventive method
can achieve a higher product yield.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 19 -
Experimental procedure:
Experiments 01-11 and blank sample (see table 1):
In a typical experiment, 9.13 g of the POM H3PMo12O40
were dissolved in 100 ml of water or a water/alcohol
mixture, which corresponds formally to a 0.05 molar
solution. This was then transferred into a 500 ml
autoclave (Premex Reactor AG, Lengnau, Switzerland).
Before the closure of the reactor, 1 g of pulverulent
lignin was added. The reaction mixture was then
contacted three times with 5 bar of oxygen or nitrogen
and vented, in order to displace the air initially
present. Finally, the reactor was filled with 5 bar of
oxygen or 10 bar of nitrogen. The reaction mixture was
heated to 170 C at a rate of 8 K/min at a stirrer speed
of 1200 rad/min. The mixture was kept at 170 C for 20
minutes. The liquid phase was removed after 20 minutes.
This was followed by the sampling through a water-
cooled cooling coil. The sample was filtered once and
then extracted three times with 10 ml of chloroform.
l of n-decane were added to the organic phase as an
internal standard for the GC-MS analysis (Fisons
instruments GC8000/MD800; column from Restek Rtx-5MS
25 30 m x 0.25 mm x 0.25 m).
In experiments 03, 04, 08, 09, 10 and 11, free-radical
scavengers (methanol, ethanol) were used.
30 In experiment 02, a second liquid phase in the form of
30 ml of chloroform was added before the closure of the
reactor.
In experiment 05, 9.45 g of the POM Na3PMo12O40 were
used. In the blank sample, no POM was used.
Experiment 12 and Wu et al. (G. X. Wu, M. Heitz,
E. Chornet, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 33, 718 (Mar, 1994))
r CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 20 -
(see table 1):
The experimental method in experiment 12 is kept analo-
gous to Wu et al. 10 g of lignin were dissolved in
100 ml of a 3 molar sodium hydroxide solution. The
solution was added to a 500 ml autoclave, and the
catalyst system consisting of 500 mg of copper sulfate
and 50 mg of iron chloride was added. The reactor was
closed and filled three times with oxygen at 10 bar and
emptied, in order to displace the air originally
present. Subsequently, the reaction vessel was placed
under pressure with 13.2 bar of oxygen. The reaction
mixture was heated to 170 C at a rate of 8 K/min at a
stirrer speed of 1200 rad/min. The mixture was kept at
170 C for 20 minutes. The liquid phase was withdrawn
after 20 minutes. The sampling was effected through a
water-cooled cooling coil.
In experiment 01, lignin was treated in a 0.05 molar
aqueous H3PMo12040 solution under inert gas. In the
course of this, the color of the solution changed from
yellowish to dark blue. This shows clearly that the
polymolybdate used was reduced. By means of GC-MS
analysis, 0.56 mg of lignin-based products (principally
vanillin) was quantified.
The yield of lignin-based products could be increased
by approx. 30% by in situ extraction (cf. experiment 01
with experiment 02). To this end, a second liquid phase
(chloroform) was added to the reaction mixture. This
has a higher solubility for the desired degradation
products and can therefore withdraw any products formed
from the actual reaction medium (aqueous POM solution)
before possible further reactions destroy the products
formed again.
The degradation of lignin with 0.05 molar H3PMo12O40
solution under oxygen (experiment 06) likewise
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 21 -
increased the yield compared to the degradation under
inert gas (experiment 01) . After the experiment under
oxygen, in contrast to the experiment under inert gas,
only slight discoloration of the solution to yellow-
greenish was detected, i.e. the polyoxomolybdate was
reduced only very slightly, if at all. This leads to
the suspicion that the POM is reoxidizable under the
conditions used and, in this case, oxygen is consumed
by the POM during the degradation of lignin.
Experiment 07 shows that various lignin types can be
used and that the yield of chemicals here is within the
same order of magnitude. According to the manufacturer,
the lignin from Aldrich (batch No. 09724CE) is a soft-
wood lignin (principally from spruce wood), which was
obtained in the Kraft process. The lignin from the
Granit process was, in contrast, obtained from plants
utilized in agriculture and therefore has a different
chemical structure.
In experiment 05, the POM used was the sodium salt
Na3PMo12Oq0 corresponding to H3PMo12040. The yield of
chemicals is noticeably higher in this experiment. It
is therefore found that changes in the POM system used
which are slight from a chemical point of view can
affect the yield of desired products. The use of a very
substantially optimal POM system is therefore of
crucial significance for the attainment of high yields.
The positive effect of the free-radical scavenger with
regard to the yield of chemicals was demonstrated in
experiments 03 and 04 compared to experiment 01 and the
blank sample. In experiments 03 and 04, ethanol and
methanol were used as free-radical scavengers. Using
the free-radical scavengers, the yield was enhanced
from 0.56 mg to 1.17 mg in the case of ethanol and to
2.38 mg in the case of methanol.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 22 -
In the case of the blank sample without POM, no lignin-
based products were detectable.
Figure 1 shows the corresponding GC-MS chromatograms
and illustrates that not only are the amounts of
vanillin and 4-hydroxyacetyl-2-methoxyphenol produced
greater when the free-radical scavengers are used, but
novel components are also prepared in amounts
comparable to vanillin.
The formation of vanillic acid methyl ester in experi-
ment 04 shows that methanol is incorporated into the
product (see equation 11).
Using ethanol as the free-radical scavenger, in
contrast, vanillic acid ethyl ester is formed (see
equation 12).
In addition, experiments were carried out to verify the
mechanism indicated in equations 11 and 12. With
deuterated methanol CD30D, it was possible to show
clearly that a methanol radical is incorporated into
the vanillic acid methyl ester product. The molecular
weight of vanillic acid methyl ester produced in
reactions of lignin in the presence of undeuterated
methanol was determined by means of GC-MS analysis to
be 182 g/mol. Using deuterated methanol, the molecular
weight was determined to be 185 g/mol. In addition, it
was checked whether the formation of the vanillic acid
methyl ester is also possible from vanillin, for
example via the reaction route of vanillin --> vanillic
acid -> vanillic acid methyl ester. The treatment of
vanillin in 0.05 molar H3PMo12O40 solution under nitrogen
in the presence of methanol gave no products
whatsoever. It can consequently be assumed that the
acyl radical shown in equations 11 and 12 results from
the scission of the Cu-C(3 bond in the lignin.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 23 -
The formation of the CH30= radical from methanol was
also considered in more detail. The homolytic scission
of the 0-H bond in methanol is thermodynamically impro-
bable owing to the high bond energy of 104 kcal/mol. It
was, however, found that methanol in aqueous H3PMo12040
solution under nitrogen is converted partly to dimethyl
ether. The homolytic scission of the C-0 bond in
dimethyl ether is possible owing to the relatively low
bond energy of 84 kcal/mol. It is consequently possible
that methanol can form free radicals via acid-catalyzed
ether formation and is thus considered to be a free-
radical scavenger in the context of this invention. The
direct addition of dimethyl ether as a free-radical
scavenger for conversion of lignin in aqueous H3PM012040
solution under nitrogen and in the absence of methanol
results in the production of a small amount of vanillic
acid methyl ester. It was thus shown that dimethyl
ether is directly active as a free-radical scavenger,
and the homolytic scission of dimethyl ether and the
associated formation of vanillic acid methyl ester is
possible.
CHa
1
0 'Zk:~C 0 0
+ CH, -, /
O CH3 O1-1 CHy
H H
{I1)
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 24 -
CH
o~C. 0
~CH,
+
-~ ~
o~ CH3 O= C4 H3
OH H (12)
In order to be able to compare the results of the
degradation of lignin by means of POM and free-radical
scavengers with the prior art, the method used by Wu et
al. (benchmark) was applied to the lignin from Aldrich
used in our examples.
A comparison of the results revealed that the yield of
lignin-based chemicals using the softwood lignin is
very much lower compared to Wu et al. (- one factor of
ten) . The reason for this may be the use of a very
different lignin type. The lignin from Sigma-Aldrich
used in our study is, according to the manufacturer, a
typical softwood lignin which was isolated from spruce
wood by means of the Kraft process. Wu et al. used, in
contrast, a self-produced lignin type produced from
hardwood by means of steam digestion. It is known that
hardwood lignin has a very much higher proportion of
syringyl units (- 500). The comparatively high
proportion of syringyl units is also reflected in the
results of Wu et al. in the considerable amount of
syringaldehyde produced (7.8% by weight). Softwood
lignin (from the spruce) possesses, in contrast, a very
great proportion of guaiacyl units (- 900). This
corresponds with our results, in which only traces of
syringaldehyde were formed. It is additionally known
that the degradation of hardwood lignin proceeds very
much more easily and rapidly than the degradation of
softwood lignin. In addition, the hardwood lignin
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 25 -
produced by Wu et al. was not characterized fully. The
composition of the acid-insoluble lignin is reported by
Wu et al. as: Klason lignin = 84.7%; acid-soluble
lignin = 3.0% and others (unknown) = 12.3%.
An economically viable process requires a reliable and
inexpensive lignin source. It therefore appears to be
advisable to use softwood lignin, which is obtainable
in large amounts, as a starting material for chemical
production. As already indicated, softwood lignin is
obtained as a waste product in papermaking (for example
in the Kraft or sulfite process) . The method of Wu et
al. is therefore applied below to the lignin available
to us as a benchmark.
A comparison of experiment 10 in which lignin was
converted under oxygen in the presence of POM and free-
radical scavenger with the prior art method (experi-
ment 12) shows that a higher product yield is achieved
with the inventive method. The chemicals produced are
principally vanillin (16.5 mg) and vanillic acid methyl
ester (13.5 mg).
In experiment 11, poplar lignin was used. The product
yield is likewise in the region of 3.5% by weight. The
main products here are, however, vanillin (5.0 mg),
vanillic acid methyl ester (6.2 mg), syringaldehyde
(8.2 mg) and syringic acid methyl ester (12.2 mg),
corresponding to the chemical structure of poplar
lignin with a relatively high proportion of syringyl
units.
It should be noted that the examples adduced in this
document represent the first test series. The achieve-
ment of the comparatively higher yields is therefore
particularly promising, since the inventive method has
not yet been optimized. In view of the numerous possi-
ble combinations of POM, free-radical scavengers and
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 26 -
ultimately also lignin types, there is still a very
large amount of room for improvement of the yields. In
addition, some reaction technology solutions, for
example in situ extraction, are still available. The
potential becomes clear in a comparison of experi-
ments 06 and 10, among others. Here, the yield of
chemicals was increased by a factor of 30 solely
through the use of an aqueous methanol solution. One
advantage of the invention presented here also lies in
the possibility of preparing different chemicals
depending on the free-radical scavenger. For instance,
vanillic acid methyl ester is formed in the case of use
of methanol, and vanillic acid ethyl ester in the case
of use of ethanol. It consequently appears possible,
through suitable combinations of POM and free-radical
scavenger, to be able to crucially influence not just
the yield but also the selectivity for a target
product.
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 27 -
Table 1: Results for production of chemicals from
lignin by means of POM and free-radical scavenger
compared to conventional methods.
Experi- Catalytic Medium Gas Lignin Products % by
ment system type [mg] wt.*1
GC-MS
01 H3PMo1zO40 H20 N2 Aldrich 0.56 0.06
(9.13 g) (100 ml) (10 (1 g)
bar)
02 H3PMo12O40 H20 N, Aldrich 0.74 0.08
(9.13 g) (100 ml) (10 (1 g)
CHC13 bar)
(30 ml)
03 H3PMo120qo H20 N2 Aldrich 1.17 0.13
(9.13 g) (60 ml) (10 (1 g)
C H50H bar)
(40 ml)
04 H3PM012040 H20 N2 Aldrich 2.38 0.26
(9.13 g) (60 ml) (10 (1 g)
CH3OH bar)
(40 ml)
05 Na3PM012040 H20 02 Aldrich 1.47 0.16
(9.45 g) (100 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
bar)
06 H3PMo1^O40 H,0 02 Aldrich 0.97 0.11
(9.13 g) (100 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
bar)
07 H3PMol2Oqo H20 02 Granit 0.59 0.06
(9.13 g) (100 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
bar)
08 H3PMo12040 H,0 02 Aldrich 9.5 1.04
(9.13 g) (60 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
CH3OH bar)
(40 ml)
CA 02679854 2009-09-02
- 28 -
09 H3PM012040 H20 02 Aldrich 25.63 2.79
(9.13 g) (40 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
CH3OH bar)
(60 ml)
H3PM012040 H20 02 Aldrich 32.73 3.57
(9.13 g) (20 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
CH3OH bar)
(80 ml)
11 H3PMo12040 H20 02 Poplar 34.22 3.64
(9.13 g) (20 ml) (5.1 (1 g)
CH3OH bar)
(80 ml)
12 CuSO4/FeCl3 H20 02 Aldrich 145 1.58
(0.5 g/ (100 ml) (13.2 (10 g)
0.05 g) NaOH bar)
(12 g)
Wu et CuSO4/FeC13 H20 02 Hardwood 12.9
al. (0.5 g/ (100 ml) (13.8 (10 g)
0.05 g) NaOH bar)
(14.7 g)
Blank none H20 N2 Aldrich 0 0
sample (60 ml) (10 (1 g)
CzH50H bar)
(40 ml)
~~ Based on dry lignin
