Note : Les descriptions sont présentées dans la langue officielle dans laquelle elles ont été soumises.
CA 03139731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/IT2021/050055
- 1 -
CONTROL APPARATUS AND METHOD TO CONTROL A HIGH-POWER ELECTRIC MOTOR
* * * * *
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention concerns a control apparatus and method to control a
high-power electric motor, preferably in the order of megawatts (MW),
preferably, but not only, of a shredding or crushing plant, or able to be
associated
therewith. For example, the electric motor can be associated with a shredder
device, usable for example for shredding very bulky and heavy objects, such as
the bodies of vehicles, possibly already compacted, motors, mechanical
members, household appliances, or other, and which therefore require a very
high
crushing force, in order to obtain scrap, for example metal, ferrous and non-
ferrous, suitable to be then recycled, or recovered, for example to feed
melting
furnaces. The present invention can also be applied in the management of
electric
motors associated with other plants or equipment, for example for crushing and
shredding other materials in different processes, such as for example paper,
plastic, inert materials, wood, minerals, or other.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Especially in the steel industry, but not only, where there is the increasing
problem of procuring raw materials for the production of new products and the
associated need to recover as much as possible the materials coming from
objects
that are no longer used, for example ferrous materials from discarded objects,
for
example for the production of steel by melting furnaces, it is known to use
shredding plants provided with shredding, or crushing devices, also known as
shredders, to shred or crush even large and very heavy objects containing
iron,
such as for example the bodies of vehicles, household appliances, mechanical
members, motors and more, possibly already reduced in volume by compaction
in special presses.
Shredding plants first provide to crush and reduce the scrapped objects into
small pieces and then to separate the various scrap from the processing waste,
in
particular by separating the metal scrap, both ferrous and non-ferrous, from
the
other scrap, so that it can then be destined to a new use.
The material to be treated usually first undergoes a volumetric reduction and
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 2 -
then enters directly into the crushing chamber of the shredder device by means
of
a suitable conveyor belt.
The most common shredder devices normally comprise a rotating member,
called a mill, essentially consisting of a rotating drum with which a
plurality of
crushing members, called hammers, are associated and which are configured to
violently impact against the objects to be crushed.
Normally the rotation of the drum is advantageously commanded by a single
electric motor of high nominal power (P), for example up to over 10 MW (about
13,400 hp), which is made to rotate at different speeds (co), depending on the
torque (T) to be obtained for crushing the various objects to be crushed,
based on
the well-known formula P¨T=co. The working temperature of the motor (t) also
has direct repercussions on the torque delivered, in a directly proportional
manner.
Furthermore, since the productivity of the shredder device is directly
proportional to the speed of rotation (w) of the electric motor connected to
the
rotating drum, it is obvious that in order to obtain high productivity, there
is a
tendency to make the rotating drum and therefore the electric motor operate at
the
highest possible speed of rotation.
The rotating drum has a large mass, so that once it has been made to rotate by
the electric motor, it rotates by inertia, due to the flywheel effect, and the
motor
itself then only supplies it with the power input necessary to maintain the
speed
of rotation necessary to generate the kinetic energy required to crush, by
impact,
the objects or material to be crushed.
The crushed material exiting from the shredder device is collected on a second
conveyor belt where the separation of the light fractions is carried out, for
example by means of a flow of air, and subsequently passes into a section
equipped with magnetic devices to separate the ferrous metals from the non-
ferrous materials and from the inert and/or sterile materials. Each fraction
is then
collected in a specific container to be sent to other processes, or to
storage.
The electric power supply of the electric motor is normally managed
automatically by a control circuit in order to optimize the productivity of
the
plant.
However, said management is rather complex, especially in consideration of
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/IT2021/050055
- 3 -
the considerable forces involved, which are very variable during the shredding
process, as the type of materials to be treated can change a lot, as can their
density. This entails different hardnesses and sizes of the objects fed, which
create different resistances on the crushing hammers and therefore generate
variable loads, or resistances to rotation, to which the electric motor is
subjected,
with the consequent fluctuation of the power required by the process.
The variability of the load, linked to the variability of the material fed,
makes
the shredder device substantially unpredictable from the point of view of the
work cycle and therefore with regard to the electric power required by the
process, which can even exceed the nominal performance of the motor itself.
Therefore, during these high-power transients, the motor generates current
absorption peaks from the public or private electric network, with consequent
disturbances or damage, even considerable, to the network itself.
Fig. 1 shows schematically how the work power transmitted by the electric
motor to the rotating drum can be increased at most up to a value indicated by
Pmax, corresponding to the intrinsic limits related to the characteristics of
the
electric motor, beyond which the latter would break. In fig. 1 it can be noted
that
the speed of rotation co of the electric motor associated with the rotating
drum can
increase (co +) or decrease (co-) with respect to a median nominal value.
When the crushing hammers hit more voluminous materials, following the
greater resistance encountered by them, the number of revolutions of the
rotating
drum decreases.
If the torque is not increased, the available power decreases. This is
disadvantageous, since the crushing hammers may not have the energy required
to crush the material, resulting in a reduction in the productivity of the
shredder
device.
Therefore, to avoid a reduction in productivity, when the crushing hammers
encounter harder or more voluminous materials, an attempt is made to increase
the torque transmitted as well, causing the current absorption peaks as
described
above from the public network in the transients.
To try to transmit the maximum power supplied by the electric motor to keep
productivity high, however, both the motor itself and the kinematic chain are
heavily stressed, obliging installers to oversize these components, with a
89127488
- 4 -
consequent increase in costs.
In order to try to limit these effects, shredder devices of the known type
adopt
protection systems which, however, do not give very satisfactory results.
One known solution provides to use an oil joint to transfer power between the
electric motor and the mill, made in such a way as to protect the drive from
overload and damp torsional vibrations.
Another solution is also known to try to reduce the damage due to
uncontrolled overloads, which provides a liquid rheostat drive, of the type
known
as LRS (Liquid Resistance Starters), which consists of a power supply system
for
the electric motor in which the rotor of the latter is surrounded by a saline
solution, therefore conductive, in which electrodes are disposed; the level of
immersion in the liquid of the electrodes can be selectively adjusted to
increase
or decrease the conductivity between stator and rotor, so as to be able to
vary the
power that the mill requires from the electric motor. Adjustment is possible
by
using an amperometric transformer which detects the need for greater
absorption
and thus allows the variation in height of the electrodes inside the
conductive
saline solution.
This known system allows to partly damp the uncontrolled absorption peaks,
protecting the electric motor (with losses of 8-9% of the power in heat).
However, this intervention capacity is limited from the point of view of the
response speed over time (2-3 seconds) and in any case does not prevent a
waste
of energy, which causes the dissipation of power in the "Liquid Starter".
In any case, with this known solution, the phenomenon of power peaks is not
completely eliminated, and therefore it is still necessary to oversize the
electric
motor: for example, in order to work properly without excessive risks of being
ruined by high-power peaks, an electric motor with a nominal power of 3,700 kW
(about 5,000 hp) is obliged not to exceed 65-70% of the nominal power as
above,
and therefore it can work on average at about 2,500 kW (about 3,350 hp).
This solution is not very efficient, since it is not possible to fully exploit
the
power of the engine, nor, consequently, to transmit all the energy available
to the
hammers to crush the material, thus considerably limiting the performance of
the
plants and overall productivity.
Document US10476421 B 1 describes a control system for a switched
Date Recue/Date Received 2022-08-15
89127488
- 5 -
reluctance motor, which is able to select between a plurality of operating
modes
to control the current supplied by an inverter to the motor, based on: motor
speed,
transient speed, power of the motor, in which the operating modes comprise a
current regulation mode, a single pulse mode and a continuous conduction mode.
In particular, the solution described in US10476421 B1 provides to compare the
motor speed with a first threshold value to determine whether to control the
motor with the current regulation operating mode or with the single pulse
operating mode and, if the motor speed exceeds the nominal threshold value,
provides to keep the power constant by making the motor function in a de-
fluxing
zone, that is, by reducing the magnetic flux of the motor. This operating mode
allows to increase the speed considerably, but requires an increase in current
to
compensate for the reduction in flux, which can lead to unwanted power peaks.
This solution does not allow to maximize the use and efficiency of the motor.
Known solutions also have the disadvantage of being strictly dependent on the
network and electric current available, and therefore in territories or
countries
where the electric current is limited, it is necessary to reduce the nominal
power
of the motors.
One purpose of the present invention is to provide a control apparatus and an
associated method to control a high-power electric motor, preferably in the
order
of megawatts (MW), preferably, but not only, of a shredding or crushing plant,
or
able to be associated therewith, which is able to allow the electric motor to
transfer the maximum energy available to the motor in any situation.
In particular, one purpose is to provide a control apparatus and method that
allow the motor to be used at its nominal power without the risk of having
power
peaks, associated with variations in load, which could cause serious problems
and/or damage to the network that supplies the electric current to the motor.
Another purpose of the present invention is to provide a control apparatus and
associated method to control a high-power electric motor, which allows to
obtain
a high speed of rotation of the rotor of the electric motor, and therefore of
the
rotating member associated therewith, which provides a high productivity of
the
shredding plant in relation to the power delivered and the torque applied to
the
rotating member itself.
Yet another purpose of the present invention is to provide a control method
Date Recue/Date Received 2022-08-15
89127488
- 6 -
and apparatus that allow to maximize the torque applied.
Another purpose is to provide a control method and apparatus that can be
applied both in existing shredding plants, in order to improve their
performance
and increase overall efficiency, by fully exploiting the nominal power of the
motor, and also in newly constructed plants, allowing a correct sizing of the
motors themselves according to requirements, also correlated to the electric
energy available.
The Applicant has devised, tested and embodied the present invention to
overcome the shortcomings of the state of the art and to obtain these and
other
purposes and advantages.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In accordance with the above purposes, a control apparatus for controlling a
high power electric motor, preferably of the order of megawatts (MW),
preferably of, or associated with, a shredding plant, which is preferably
usable for
shredding very bulky and heavy objects and is provided with rotating shredding
means connected to the rotor of the electric motor, comprises electric power
supply means associated with the electric motor to selectively power it with a
voltage and a current so that the electric motor can operate at a selected
temperature, supply the power as above, rotate at a suitable rotation speed
and
apply to the rotating shredding means a determinate torque necessary for
shredding the objects, and a control circuit connected to the electric power
supply
means as above and configured to control the electric motor so that it
selectively
operates at the temperature as above, supplies the power as above, rotates at
the
rotation speed as above and applies the torque to the rotating shredding means
as
above.
According to a characteristic aspect of the present invention, the control
circuit
as above comprises selection means configured to select the supply of the
voltage
and current as above so that the electric motor can operate selectively in any
one
of the following three operating modes: a first operating mode, with a
constant
rotation speed, and with a power limited to a selected value; a second
operating
Date Recue/Date Received 2022-05-05
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 7 -
mode, with a constant power, and with a torque limited to a selected value
greater
than or equal to a nominal torque value; a third operating mode, with a
constant
torque, and at a temperature of the electric motor limited to a selected
value.
According to some embodiments, the control circuit is configured to select the
supply of the voltage and current as above in relation to the type of load of
the
shredding means, in order to return the electric motor to operate, or maintain
it
operating, in the second operating mode at constant power.
According to some embodiments, in the second operating mode the motor
operates with a nominal magnetic field flux value substantially equal to the
nominal flux value it has in the first operating mode. In other words, the
magnetic flux of the motor always remains around the nominal value and does
not reduce with increasing speed.
In accordance with some embodiments of the present invention, the selection
means comprise an inversion circuit, or inverter.
In accordance with other embodiments of the present invention, the inverter
can comprise a plurality of thyristors.
The possibility of adapting the functioning of the motor with the selection
means allows to increase and reduce the electric current in order to increase
and
reduce the speed and/or the torque of the hammers as a function of operational
requirements, in order to guarantee the transfer of the maximum available
energy
to the scrap. In fact, thanks to the inverter devices, it is possible to
obtain a
dynamic functioning process, which can adapt in real time to the type/quantity
of
load to be crushed and to the requirements of the electricity grid.
In accordance with some embodiments of the present invention, the electric
motor is electrically powered by medium voltage (MV) electric power supply
means, and between the latter and the electric motor there is interposed an
electric transformer configured to transform the electric voltage from medium
(MV) to medium-low (LV), and connected to the control circuit.
According to some embodiments, the electric motor is provided with one or
more detection devices suitable to detect one or more functioning parameters,
selected from rotation speed, torque, absorbed electric current, temperature.
In accordance with other embodiments of the present invention, the control
circuit also comprises a programmable electronic control unit, configured to
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 8 -
command the electric motor in one of the three operating modes, also on the
basis
of feedback signals that reach it from the detection devices of the electric
motor.
In accordance with some embodiments of the present invention, in the first
operating mode the power absorbed by the electric motor reaches a set maximum
power level, preferably comprised between 105 A and 115%, for example 110%,
of the nominal power of the electric motor.
In accordance with some embodiments of the present invention, in the third
operating mode the maximum torque, corresponding to the maximum operating
temperature of the electric motor, is set at a value preferably comprised
between
140% and 160%, for example at 150%, of the nominal value.
The present invention also concerns a control method to control a high power
electric motor, preferably of the order of megawatts (MW), preferably of or
associated with a shredding plant which is preferably usable for shredding
very
bulky and heavy objects and is provided with rotating shredding means
connected to the rotor of the electric motor, by means of a control apparatus
which comprises electric power supply means associated with the electric motor
in order to selectively power it with a voltage and a current so that the
electric
motor can operate at a selected temperature, supply the power, rotate at a
suitable
rotation speed and apply to the rotating shredding means a determinate torque
necessary for shredding the objects, and a control circuit connected to the
electric
power supply means and configured to control the electric motor so that it
selectively operates at the temperature as above, supplies the power as above,
rotates at the rotation speed as above and applies the torque to the rotating
shredding means as above.
The method according to the invention comprises at least a first step in which
the control circuit controls the electric motor so that it operates at least
in a first
operating mode, with a constant rotation speed, and with a power limited by a
set
maximum power value.
According to some embodiments, upon reaching the maximum power value, it
provides to select the supply of the voltage and of the current so that the
electric
motor can selectively operate in at least one of either a second operating
mode
with a control at constant power, and with a torque limited to a selected
value
greater than or equal to a nominal torque value, or a third operating mode,
with a
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/IT2021/050055
- 9 -
control at constant torque, and with a temperature of the electric motor
limited to
a selected value.
The three operating modes can be selected on each occasion as a function of
the type and quantity of scrap to be crushed, and/or the limits of electrical
energy
available in the power supply network, in order to modify the functioning
parameters of the motor in terms of power, speed and torque, so as to always
transfer the maximum available energy to the scrap.
In particular, it is possible to make the motor function at the nominal power
for most of the time, or even at a value higher than it, by setting it as a
constant
parameter, and adjust the speed and torque accordingly, in order to obtain
both an
increase in the efficiency of the plant, thanks to the fact that the entire
available
power of the engine is exploited, and also the transfer of the maximum
available
energy.
This solution allows to maximize, at every moment, the energy transferred to
the scrap to be shredded, efficiently exploiting the potential of the electric
motor,
at the limit of its thermal capacity, without compromising its correct
functioning.
According to some embodiments of the present invention, the method provides
to make the motor work substantially always with a constant magnetic field
flux
value substantially equal to the nominal flux value, in each operating mode.
According to some embodiments, the method provides to make the motor
function at variable load and at constant power, but in torque overload, that
is,
with a set maximum torque value higher than a nominal torque value, preferably
comprised between 140% and 160%, for example 150%, of the nominal value, at
least in the second and possibly in the third operating mode.
According to other embodiments, the method according to the invention
provides method
to regulate aeulateeotthdeinsg to he inventionuppltyvoltagean an provide d
courrenrtoovfte to hemkoetoerp theinsutcehmapweraaytuares
to keep it in, or return it to, the second operating mode.
The maximum torque value can be set as a function of a maximum
temperature that the motor can reach.
T
value of the motor continuously monitored, in order to suitably regulate the
voltage and current values supplied to the motor. Furthermore, this solution,
since it allows to control the functioning of the motor, in particular torque
and
89127488
- 10 -
speed, in real time, allows to work even in conditions of overload of the
scrap containing
chamber, so as to also exploit the energy transfer between the scrap itself.
The control apparatus and method, if applied to existing plants, allow to
considerably improve
the overall efficiency of the plant, while in the case of newly built plants
they allow to size the
motors on the basis of real needs, no longer having to compensate any power
peaks.
According to some aspects of the present invention, there is provided a
control apparatus for
controlling a high power (P) electric motor provided with rotating shredding
means connected to
the rotor of said electric motor, comprising electric power supply means
associated with said
electric motor to selectively power it with a voltage (V) and a current (I) so
that said electric
motor operates at a selected temperature (t ), supplies said power (P),
rotates at a selected
rotation speed (w) and applies to said rotating shredding means a determinate
torque (T)
necessary for shredding said objects, and a control circuit connected to said
electric supply
means and configured to control said electric motor so that it selectively
operates at said
temperature (t ), supplies said power (P), rotates at said rotation speed (w)
and applies said
torque (T) to said rotating shredding means, wherein said control circuit
comprises selection
means configured to select the supply of said voltage (V) and said current (I)
so that said electric
motor can operate selectively in any one of the following three operating
modes: a first operating
mode (A), which provides a control at a constant rotation speed (co), and with
a power (P) limited
to a selected value; a second operating mode (B), which provides a control at
a constant power
(P), and with a torque (T) limited to a selected value greater than or equal
to a nominal torque
value; a third operating mode (C), which provides a control at a constant
torque (T), and at a
temperature (t ) of said electric motor limited to a selected value.
According to some aspects of the present invention, there is provided a
control method to
control a high power (P) electric motor, provided with rotating shredding
means connected to the
rotor of said electric motor, by means of a control apparatus which comprises
electric power
supply means associated with said electric motor to selectively power it with
a voltage (V) and a
current (I) so that said electric motor operates at a selected temperature (t
), supplies said power
(P), rotates at a selected rotation speed (co) and applies to said rotating
shredding means a
determinate torque (T) necessary for shredding said objects, and a control
circuit connected to
said electric power supply means and configured to control said electric motor
so that it
selectively operates at said temperature (t ), supplies said power (P),
rotates at said rotation
speed (w) and applies said torque (T) to said rotating shredding means,
wherein it comprises at
Date Recue/Date Received 2022-05-05
89127488
- 10a -
least a first step in which said control circuit controls said electric motor
so that it operates at
least in a first operating mode (A), which provides a control at a constant
rotation speed (w), and
a power (P) limited by a set maximum power value (Pmax), and upon reaching
said maximum
power value (Pmax), it provides to select the supply of said voltage (V) and
said current (I) so
that said electric motor can selectively operate in at least one of either a
second operating mode
(B) which provides a control at constant power (P), and with a torque (T)
limited to a selected
value greater than or equal to a nominal torque value, or a third operating
mode (C), which
provides a control at constant torque (T), and with a temperature (t ) of said
electric motor
limited to a selected value.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
These and other aspects, characteristics and advantages of the present
invention will become
apparent from the following description of one embodiment, given as an
example, which does
not restrict the field and scope of protection, with reference to the attached
drawings wherein:
- fig. 1, as seen above, is a known graph that schematically shows the
relation between the
rotation speed (w) of the rotor of an electric motor and the power (P), torque
(T) and temperature
(t) parameters of the rotor;
- fig. 2 is a block diagram of a control circuit according to the present
invention associated with a
shredding plant;
- fig. 3 is a graph that briefly represents the trend of the rotation speed
(w) of the rotor of the
electric motor used in the shredding plant of fig. 2, in relation to the
corresponding power (P),
torque (T) and temperature (t ) parameters of the rotor according to the three
modes, A, B and C,
for controlling the electric motor according to the present invention,
respectively at a constant
rotation speed (w), at constant power (P) and constant torque (T);
- fig. 4 is a graph that briefly represents an example of the trend over
time (t) of the following
three parameters in the three operating modes, first A, second B and third C,
for controlling the
electric motor of fig. 3: rotation speed (w) (upper dashed curve), in
revolutions per minute (rpm);
power (P) (lower dash-dot curve), as a percentage of the nominal power of the
electric motor;
torque (T) (central continuous line curve), also as a percentage of the
nominal torque of the
electric motor;
- fig. 5 is a schematic representation of the control circuit of fig. 2;
- fig. 6 is a graph that represents the trend over time (t) of the power (P)
supplied by an electric
motor controlled by a control circuit of the present invention (lower
Date Recue/Date Received 2022-05-05
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/IT2021/050055
- 1 1 -
curve with solid black line), compared to that controlled according to the
previous state of the art (upper gray curve).
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF SOME EMBODIMENTS
We will now refer in detail to the possible embodiments of the present
invention, shown in the attached drawings. These examples are supplied by way
of illustration of the present invention and shall not be understood as a
limitation
thereof.
Before describing these embodiments, we must also clarify that the present
description is not limited in its application to details of the construction
and
disposition of the components as described in the following description using
the
attached drawings. The present description can provide other embodiments and
can be obtained or executed in various other ways. We must also clarify that
the
phraseology and terminology used here is for the purposes of description only,
and cannot be considered as limitative.
With reference to fig. 2, a control apparatus 10 according to the present
invention is shown associated with a shredding plant 11 of a known type,
having
an electric motor 12, the rotor of which is connected, for example by means of
an
extension, to a rotating drum, or mill, 13, provided with crushing hammers, of
a
known type and not shown in the drawings.
The rotating drum 13 is associated upstream with a device 14 for introducing
objects, or material, to be shredded and downstream with a device 15 for
collecting the shredded pieces.
The shredding plant 11 is connected to electric power supply means 16 of a
known type, consisting for example of a medium voltage (MV) electricity grid,
capable of supplying indicatively an electric voltage from 11 to 20 KY with a
power (P) of up to about 10-15MW.
Between the electric power supply means 16 and the electric motor 12 there is
interposed an MV/LV electric transformer 17, configured to transform the
electric voltage from medium (MV) to low (LV), indicatively, in the example
given here, to a value comprised between about 300 and 700 V, with a power of
about 3-3.5 MW.
The control apparatus 10 comprises a control circuit 20, connected to the
electric transformer 17 and provided with selection means 21 controlled by a
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 12 -
programmable electronic control unit 22, for example a PLC, also on the basis
of
suitable feedback signals coming from the electric motor 12 and indicative at
least of the torque T, the power P and the rotation speed co.
According to some embodiments, the programmable control unit 22 can
receive the feedback signals detected and/or monitored in real time by one or
more detection devices 25 associated with the electric motor 12. According to
some embodiments, the detection device/s 25 can comprise sensors suitable to
detect one or more of either torque, rotation speed, absorbed electric
current, or
motor temperature.
The detection devices 25 comprise in particular at least temperature sensors
suitable to detect the temperature of the electric motor 12 and send the
detected
values to the control circuit 20 and/or to the programmable electronic control
unit
22.
The selection means 21 comprise, for example, an inversion circuit, or
inverter, 23 which in turn preferably comprises a plurality of thyristors 24
(figs. 2
and 5).
The control circuit 20 is configured to actively manage the control parameters
of the electric motor 12 (power P, torque T, rotation speed co) thanks to the
inverter 23 and the programmable electronic control unit 22. All this in a
dynamic manner, taking full advantage of the potential of the electric motor
12 in
terms of percentage of the maximum torque that can be supplied in permanent
thermal regime.
In particular, the control circuit 20 is capable of separating the electric
motor
12 from the electric power supply means 16, that is, from the electricity
grid, so
as to be able to control the currents at exit from the inverter 23 and power
the
electric motor 12 in a controlled manner, preventing stresses on the kinematic
chain and disturbances on the electricity grid itself.
In particular, the control apparatus 10 allows to operate in three different
control operating modes.
A first operating mode A basically provides a control at constant rotation
speed co, with a limit on power P.
In this first operating mode A, the rotation speed co is the control parameter
and is kept constant. Therefore, its value is numerically fixed through
automation
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 13 -
and can be selectively set to try to achieve maximum productivity, since the
rotation speed w is directly proportional to the productivity of the shredding
plant
11.
For set values of high rotation speed co based on the formula P=T=co, the
torque
T and the power P also increase, up to a set power limit Pmax, which is the
limit
that cannot be passed in order to not damage the electric motor 12.
The power P absorbed by the electric motor 12 reaches the set maximum
power level Pmax, preferably comprised between 105% and 115%, for example
110% of the nominal power P of the electric motor 12, which corresponds to
point A in fig. 3. Beyond this limit, the electric motor 12 would be damaged.
In
fact, it would be possible to go over this limit only with an oversizing of
the
electric motor, as is done in the prior art. However, the present invention
does not
provide this oversizing but provides to pass, in an automatic and programmed
manner, to a subsequent second operating mode B.
The second operating mode B basically provides a control at constant power P,
with a limit on the torque T.
In this second operating mode B, the power P is the control parameter and is
kept constant, so that the torque T, which increases, and the rotation speed
ro,
which decreases to keep the power P constant, become variable.
In particular, in the second operating mode B the power P is substantially
kept
constant at the set maximum power value Pmax, or in any case at a value lower
than this.
The torque T is increased by increasing the current absorption. A higher
current leads to an increase in the specific energy passing through the
electric
motor 12, according to the formula 12t, where "I" is the effective value in
amperes of the short-circuit current and "t" is the duration of the current,
with a
consequent increase in the temperature t of the electric motor 12.
Therefore, advantageously, the temperature t of the electric motor 12 is
measured and its value is sent to the control circuit 20 in order to take full
advantage of the potential of the electric motor 12, at the limit of its
thermal
capacity so as not to compromise its correct functioning.
Therefore, by keeping the power P below, or at most equal to, the set
maximum value Pmax, it is possible to increase the torque transmitted by the
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 14 -
electric motor 12 to the rotating drum 13 as a function of the temperature t
of the
electric motor 12, up to at a maximum torque level T set to correspond to the
maximum temperature emax that can be reached by the electric motor 12
without it being damaged, according to the characteristics of its build.
In this second operating mode B at constant power (central zone of fig. 3),
the
following advantages are obtained:
- productivity increases by 25%-30%;
- no current absorption peaks occur on the side of the electric power supply
means 16;
- maximum energy is transferred on the side of the rotating drum 13;
- the electric motor 12 is not thermally stressed.
With the control circuit 20 and with the inverters 23, moreover, it is also
possible to control the switching on and off of the feeder rollers that feed
the
scrap to the crushing plant, as well as their speed, in such a way as to keep
the
engine power constant at the fixed value and transfer the maximum possible
energy to the scrap.
According to some embodiments, the second operating mode B with constant
power limit allows to adapt the functioning of the electric motor 12 also as a
function of the electric energy available. In fact, in the event a limit equal
to
120% of the nominal power cannot be set, but it is necessary to limit it to
80%, in
the second operating mode B it will still be possible to make the motor 12
work
with a torque T variable between 100% and 150% of the nominal torque,
regardless of the power.
The third operating mode C provides a control substantially at constant torque
T, with a limit on the temperature t of the electric motor 12.
When the maximum transmissible torque T is reached, which corresponds to
the maximum temperature t'max that can be safely reached by the electric motor
12, the torque T becomes the control parameter that is kept constant, allowing
the
possibility for the rotation speed a) and the power P to vary, in particular
to
decrease.
The amount of time during which the electric motor 12 can work in this
condition depends on the use percentage of the torque T with respect to the
nominal value, and on the previous functioning history of the electric motor
12
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 15 -
itself, which affects its temperature state.
When the torque T limit is reached and the control is performed as a function
of the temperature to, subsequently the control method provides to limit the
electric power supply to the electric motor 12.
According to some embodiments, it can be provided that after a certain time
interval during which operations are carried out in the third operating mode,
the
supply current supplied to the electric motor 12 is reduced in such a way as
to
bring the operating parameters of torque T, rotation speed co and power P back
within the values provided in the second operating mode B (see the graph in
fig.
3).
In particular, unlike what normally occurs in known solutions, the method
according to the invention provides to work initially with a speed control, so
as to
increase the power up to the maximum value Pmax, and subsequently pass to a
control at constant power set at the value Pmax by progressively increasing
the
torque T up to the set limit.
According to some embodiments, the voltage and current values supplied to
the motor can be regulated in such a way as to keep the electric motor 12 in
the
second operating mode.
The graph of fig. 4 shows a real recording, on a functioning shredding plant
11, of the three control parameters, namely power P, torque T and rotation
speed
co during a shredding process, with the three operating modes A, B and C.
In particular, the graph of fig. 4 shows at the top (upper dashed curve) the
trend of the rotation speed co in revolutions per minute (rpm), in the central
part,
with a continuous line, the torque T as a percentage and at the bottom, dashed-
dot
line, the power P also as a percentage with respect to the nominal power of
the
electric motor 12.
The functioning of the control apparatus 10 described heretofore, which also
corresponds to the control method according to the present invention, provides
a
first step in which the control circuit 20 controls the electric motor 12
according
to the first operating mode A, therefore the rotation speed co is set to
increase
until the maximum power threshold is reached (Pmax in fig. 3).
Upon reaching this threshold, the control circuit 20 passes to a second step
in
which the second operating mode B is adopted, therefore the power P remains at
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 16 -
a fixed value, for example the maximum power value Pmax, preferably
comprised between 105% and 115%, for example at 110%, of the nominal power
P.
The second operating mode B allows to take full advantage of the power of the
electric motor 12, so that, as can be seen in fig. 4, the lower dash-dot line
never
exceeds this threshold value of 110% and is kept substantially constant,
considerably raising the average value of the power used compared to known
solutions, until it almost reaches the nominal value.
As previously described, in the second operating mode B, as the torque T
transmitted increases, the temperature t of the electric motor 12 also
increases,
until the maximum torque T transmissible at the maximum working temperature
(Vmax in fig. 3) of the same electric motor 12 is reached.
According to some embodiments, in the second operating mode B the electric
motor 12 always works with a constant magnetic flux value, substantially equal
to the nominal flux value.
Upon reaching the maximum working temperature, the control circuit 20
passes to a third step in which the third operating mode C is adopted.
According to some embodiments, the torque value T in the second B and in
the third operating mode C is greater than or equal to a nominal torque value.
In the graph of fig. 4, the maximum torque T, corresponding to the maximum
operating temperature (emax) of the electric motor 12, is set to a value
preferably comprised between 140% and 160%, for example 150%, of the
nominal value.
When the type of material to be shredded, loaded into the rotating drum 13
(fig. 2) by means of the introduction device 14, is such that it allows to
drop
below the torque T limit set by the control circuit 20, there is a return to
the scope
of work of the second operating mode B, which is the ideal mode in which the
machine should be made to work, since it is the area in which the electric
motor
12 supplies the maximum power P without exerting effort, but in which it is
also
possible to obtain the highest productivity. This operating mode varies
between
point A which corresponds to the maximum rotation speed co of the electric
motor 12 and therefore of the rotating drum 13 and the lower torque T, and
point
C which corresponds to the maximum torque T and the minimum rotation speed
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 17 -
co at equal power P.
In order to switch from the third operating mode C to the second operating
mode B it is possible to act through the inverter 23 to reduce the electric
current
supplied.
According to some embodiments, the method according to the invention
provides to make the electric motor 12 work with a constant magnetic field
flux
value, substantially equal to the nominal flux value, in each of the operating
modes A, B, C.
The graph of fig. 6 represents the result of a comparative study between the
trend of the power P, limited to a maximum value of 4 MW and supplied in time
(t) by the electric motor 12 controlled by the control circuit 20 (lower solid
line
curve), in which there is no anomalous power peak, and that of the power P
supplied in time (t) by an electric motor according to the state of the art
(upper
dashed curve), in which it can be seen that in the latter case there are two
uncontrolled power peaks, the highest of which had a value of 7.2 MW.
As is evident from the graph of fig. 6, while in the case of the prior art it
is
necessary to provide an oversized electric motor, with a nominal power greater
than 7.2 MW, thanks to the present invention, with the same performance, it is
possible to use an electric motor with nominal power equal to, or even lower
than, 4 MW, with consequent cost savings in production and consumption.
Furthermore, with the control apparatus 10 according to the present invention,
the reaction of the control circuit 20 to the variations in the load to which
the
electric motor 12 is subjected is substantially immediate, of the order of a
few
milliseconds, compared to the time of a few seconds (from 2 to 3) of the prior
art,
for example with a known LRS.
It is clear that modifications and/or additions of parts or steps may be made
to
the control apparatus 10 and method as described heretofore, without departing
from the field and scope of the present invention as defined by the claims.
It is also clear that, although the present invention has been described with
reference to some specific examples, a person of skill in the art shall
certainly be
able to achieve many other equivalent forms of apparatus 10 and method for
controlling a high power electric motor, preferably of the order of megawatts
(MW), preferably of a shredding, or crushing, plant, having the
characteristics as
CA 03138731 2021-10-29
WO 2021/181435 PCT/1T2021/050055
- 18 -
set forth in the claims and hence all coming within the field of protection
defined
thereby.
In the following claims, the sole purpose of the references in brackets is to
facilitate reading: they must not be considered as restrictive factors with
regard to
the field of protection claimed in the specific claims.
